23 ms·
Tech journalism doesn’t know what to do with Mastodon
- birdyrooster 4y agoWhich means no one will end up using mastodon bc largely people do whatever the media tells them.
- jtode 4y agoI loved this line, cause I hadn't looked at it from this angle before: "For some reason, people who would never read an article in the Wall Street Journal about Procter and Gamble acquiring a new shampoo company will devour content about Microsoft acquiring a tech startup they’ve never heard of." This is so true. I've known people who get this instant passion for an area they know nothing about, if it brushes up against an area they do know something about, and want to start analyzing it like baseball card stats or something. But they're basically reading a card that's a square kilometre in size about a sport they have never played or watched for any amount of time longer than it takes to momentarily look at, and then flip past, a PBS cricket match (if you're North American and have no British relatives). edit: Only modification I would make to the article would be to emphasize that not only does Mastadon work in a way that is antithetical to contemporary understandings of how the internet works, it more importantly embodies the way that the Internet worked before capitalism showed up. I gave up on slogans as a means of social change decades ago, but I would love to see "Protocols Not Platforms" get more traction in the zeitgeist.
- Dalewyn 4y ago>it more importantly embodies the way that the Internet worked before capitalism showed up. Does it really? I miss the internet of the late 90s and early 2000s, but Mastadon feels like precisely none of that.
- ergonaught 4y agoFor me, "Mastodon" more closely resembles the BBS-with-Fidonet experience, which I suppose might be similar to UUCP/Usenet to a degree "before capitalism".
- Brian_K_White 4y agoThank you. I never had a Twitter account and so never migrated from Twitter to Mastodon, and hadn't checked it out otherwise either. But this comment is the first thing I've heard that makes me think I might love it. I loved the message subs on bbs networks. The fact that an ordinary user/commenter conveyed that useful essential impression that all those journalists never did in the years since it's been newsworthy, would seem to fit right in with the article's point. This article itself also finally presented some useful "what is the point? why might I want this?" points too about no algorithm manipulation. Mostly all I've seen are vague stuff that it's not Twitter and that it's federated kind of like email. But that really doesn't say anything useful. If it's like email, we already have email. How is email an alternative to Twitter and Facebook? They really have failed to write effectively about it.
- Waterluvian 4y agoIt feels kludgy and slow and unreliable to get what you want. That’s kind of like my 90s web experience.
- rsynnott 4y agoOn ‘slow’, this is very instance dependent; perhaps try another. My original one was pretty painful, but my current one is fast, certainly faster than Twitter of late.
- Waterluvian 4y agoYou’re right. But that’s a non-start for the majority of potential users. Recommending it to family and friends feels like I’m recommending Ubuntu. I really want it to succeed but the current landscape isn’t going to cut it.
- micromacrofoot 4y agoto be fair most of my family and friends without tech jobs didn’t really get twitter either
- kalleboo 4y agoA lot of people have forgotten just how long it took for Twitter to get the mainstream appeal it has, and for a long time just how confusing all @, # and RT stuff was, and how hard it was for people to find good people to follow etc. Twitter has been working hard on that for many years with all the onboard and the algorithmic stuff.
- birdyrooster 4y agoThe internet but with only privileged people, is it still the internet?
- wkat4242 4y agoIt's the "let's do this together" attitude. Whatever than the "how can we get rich quick" one that powers most of the internet now
- mepian 4y agoBy the late 90s capitalism was already there, even Microsoft was already dominating.
- WeylandYutani 4y agoThe dot com bubble was the very definition of capitalism. It's the MBAs (that HN hates) that turn "the internet" into a product that makes money- or that they can convince investors will make money some day.
- jtode 4y agoIt does really, and that's why it doesn't work as well in this current environment. Mastadon is a DIY app/platform, which constitutes one of any number of implementations of ActivityPub, which is the underlying protocol, and can speak to any of the other implementations without limitation, save those imposed by the protocol and self-imposed by the two implementations currently speaking to each other. There are multiple types of SMTP/POP/IMAP servers out there, but they all implement the same protocols, which means that my email client can reach your email client no matter what our clients, or the servers we connect to, look like. This is how the internet works; platforms will always be a limited subset of this fundamental reality. It's also how ActivityPub works, you can wrap whatever user interface you want around it, Mastadon or otherwise, but the protocol, not the platform, defines what is and is not an ActivityPub packet. Platforms, FB, Twitter, Tiktok, Insta, none of these work this way, they are closed platforms that you enter through secure gates and must play according to their rules, and they will always decide who gets amplification and who does not based on what makes them money, and good luck taking anything back out to the open internet with you, even if it's 100% your work. If you put it there, don't expect to get it back easily, and forget about control. It is a fundamentally hostile user relationship that cannot be improved without removing the profit motive. There have been other recent posts on HN about User Hostile software design. It's a thing and it's a bad thing. Mastadon is... tofu dogs. Mastadon is an attempt to feed healthy, protocol-based internet food to people who have been subsisting on bad, algorithmically-manipulated corporate internet food (the aforementioned user-hostile platforms) in a way that feels familiar to them while they get used to the idea of not consuming the internet equivalent of Twinkies and Pork Rinds and Liquor for the rest of their lives. It doesn't taste as good as Twitter, sure. Maybe that's not the most important thing.
- LarryMullins 4y ago> Mastadon is... tofu dogs. Mastadon is an attempt to feed healthy, protocol-based internet food to people who have been subsisting on bad, algorithmically-manipulated corporate internet food (the aforementioned user-hostile platforms) in a way that feels familiar to them while they get used to the idea of not consuming the internet equivalent of Twinkies and Pork Rinds and Liquor for the rest of their lives. Mastadon is hand-rolling cigarettes instead of buying them at the gas station. Brewing gin in your bathtub, instead of going to a liquor store.
- yosefk 4y agoProtocols Not Platforms - like Bitcoin which is mostly traded on a few exchanges, or email which is mostly handled by a few giant services? Mastodon will be no exception with high likelihood. Choose it over eg Twitter if you prefer where it's going _as a platform._ I actually prefer where Twitter seems to be going, but to each his own
- ido 4y agoWhere is Twitter going?
- 0x445442 4y agoToward a platform and away from a publisher.
- ceejayoz 4y agoWhat exactly is that supposed to mean? https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/12/publisher-or-platform-it-doesnt-matter https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/12/publisher-or-platform-...
- 0x445442 4y agoDid you read the Twitter files? Everything they were doing resembled the New York Times news room vetting a story?
- 2devnull 4y agoUsers will pay instead of the FBI. At least that’s one interpretation.
- ceejayoz 4y agoThe FBI paid legally required reimbursement for records requests. Twitter has kept this policy under Musk: https://help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-policies/twitter-law-enforcement-support#13.5 https://help.twitter.com/en/rules-and-policies/twitter-law-e... > Twitter may seek reimbursement for costs associated with information produced pursuant to legal process and as permitted by law (e.g., under 18 U.S.C. §2706). https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2706 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/18/2706 > a governmental entity obtaining the contents of communications, records, or other information under section 2702, 2703, or 2704 of this title shall pay to the person or entity assembling or providing such information a fee for reimbursement for such costs as are reasonably necessary and which have been directly incurred in searching for, assembling, reproducing, or otherwise providing such information $3M out of about $5,000M worth of annual revenue, and again, it’s reimbursement.
- hannofcart 4y agoWhat's a PBS Cricket match? Am an avid Cricket follower but haven't come across the term so far.
- geoduck14 4y agoPBS is an American TV channel - Public Broadcast Station. I'm guessing that is what OP ment
- mattkrause 4y agoCrucially, PBS member stations[0] run a lot of international—-often British—-shows, so it’s one of the few places you might possibly find cricket on American TV. Otherwise, your only bet might be one of the niche cable sports channels: not the main ESPN, but maybe ESPN2 or something. [0] PBS is more like a network (the S is for ‘service’) that provides member stations with a common identity and a shared pool of programmming. They’re usually non-profits, and so would not be able to afford a national news bureau (etc) on their own.
- jtode 4y agoAs Geoduck put it, PBS stands for Public Broadcasting Service, which is a publicly-funded and viewer-supported network of highbrow and foreign content that's been around for my whole life, not sure if or how much longer than that. It's also the primary way that North Americans have consumed British culture for my whole life, until the internet brought widespread, umm, "availability". So all through my Canadian youth I would flip through channels and periodically happen upon a Dr Who episode, or a British sport like Cricket, and wonder at the strangeness of my ancestral line (I'm extremely British, genetically speaking, and my family were both heavy socialists and also kind of cryptically proud of being part of the Empire. But they never admitted that, even to themselves I think...). It's no surprise that it was hard to key into why Dr Who - for one example of a show I came to love as an adult - is so cool. I would read about it in Starlog, here and there, and the doctor sounded like a real badass on paper, but when I came across Tom Baker for the first time, he was no Han Solo, shall we say. Which is great, cause there are aspects of Star Wars that I kinda hate now (mostly the fans), but maybe not so much when you're 8 years old and have been watching laser blasts and ships exploding and whatnot. Even godawful tripe like Jason Of Star Command was more captivating at the time.
- europeanguy 4y ago> "For some reason, people who would never read an article in the Wall Street Journal about Procter and Gamble acquiring a new shampoo company will devour content about Microsoft acquiring a tech startup they’ve never heard of." Good point, I'll grand you that, but I'm on the other side. I don't want to hear less about Microsoft acquiring tech startups, I want to hear more about Procter and Gamble acquiring shampoo companies. My guess is that journalists that write such articles exist, but possibly they publish in specialist journals / magazines...?
- jtode 4y agoYou seem like a prime candidate for a subscription to the WSJ, my good europeanguy.
- europeanguy 4y agoCan you go on the WSJ front page and point out to me one story that's like the "Procter and gamble acquire something obscure"? The WSJ send to be to be exactly like regular news, but themed to look like business, as opposed to what I'm looking for, actual business.
- dlgeek 4y agoAdmitedly it wasn't on the front page, but how about "Kroger-Albertsons Antitrust Review Likely to Focus on Local Store Overlap" (https://www.wsj.com/articles/kroger-albertsons-antitrust-review-likely-to-focus-on-local-store-overlap-11666344601 https://www.wsj.com/articles/kroger-albertsons-antitrust-rev...)
- europeanguy 4y agoFun, thank you!
- paulcole 4y ago> I've known people who get this instant passion for an area they know nothing about, if it brushes up against an area they do know something about See also every HN thread about nutrition, sleep, health, exercise.
- cjbgkagh 4y agoBefore capitalism? As in pre-AOL? The internet was the exclusive purview of the monied elite and the highly motivated tech nerds. The motivation was needed to spend so much money as everything was so expensive. The only way I could afford entry was by repairing old equipment. What ruined the culture for me was the Eternal September and I’ve been complaining about that ever since. The people yelling get off my lawn need to get off my lawn. Personally I’d like a BBS front end to Mastodon (does one exist? I haven’t checked) so my experience of the internet can go full circle and end up where it started.
- robswc 4y agoI find that comment funny too. Internet has only gotten more accessible. I do miss when it seemed almost everyone you talked to was a hacker in their own way but at the end of the day... you have everyone from kids on tablets to your grandma being able to use it now.
- pentachoron 4y agoMastodon (and potentially other ActivityPub-based Fediverse services) has Toot (https://toot.readthedocs.io/en/latest/index.html https://toot.readthedocs.io/en/latest/index.html) which is a CLI/TUI interface that probably looks like you want? (I know there's also at least one other project for Pleroma + forks specifically called Pleroma-CLI too...)
- cjbgkagh 4y agoInteresting, thanks. I did look it up after writing the comment and it appears that I’m not the only one getting BBS vibes. I do wonder how much the ability to post images changes the culture and if a text only for everyone social network could be an alternative.
- jtode 4y agoI feels ya buddy. I just said to someone yesterday that it's kind of a Law Of The Internet that it got ruined basically a short time after the subjective "you" onboarded, and the longer you're here, the more grumpy you get about it. This is true of me and anyone I know who thinks of this place as a figurative home. There are endless high-profile examples, such as the time that Stephen Fry, having just recently achieved some major follower milestone (million I think), got very upset about being called out on some faux pas or other - in retrospect, a minor offense and a failed attempt at cancellation, if it was even an attempt - and decided to leave the internet, with this long almost-crying essay about the internet he had gotten onto, which made it sound like some sort of Victorian fairy glade where the air was laden with cocaine and he got to make out with Oscar Wilde, vs the stinky plebian unsubtle and bestial place it had become. It was an overreaction worthy of Chris De Burgh, and one he obviously didn't follow through on in the long run. But even as I was loling at the tone of his rejection letter, I also recognized an emotional stream of my own in it. I have a somewhat different view of AOL than you. I was firmly middle class, neither monied elite nor genuine nerd, but my family could afford to buy me a C64 and as a young adult I bought myself a 386, strictly for the fun of it. I also started out on BBSes and was a sysop on both 8-bit and 32-bit systems, but I did have an uncle who logged me into the local U's mainframe as a kid, and I found my way to the early, command line internet before the WWW was born, though I mostly just hung out on irc, I was no leet hackz0r. But once the winsock era ramped up and that "invasion" of AOL kiddies happened, I have to say, I had a very good few years in alt.music.ween as well as some groups centred on my local community. a.m.ween had quite a few great contributors from AOL, actually, so for that group, it was a net benefit. The band also pioneered direct interaction by participating in the group, at one point doing an all-request livestream (this is maybe 2000 I'm talking about, very early, and it was awesome) which newsgroup members voted on. Deaner, the guitarist, was especially active in internet fan engagement, and would phone in from on tour using AOL as an easy onramp. Nothing salesy or memey, he'd just do your typical "tour diary" letters like any band of the time might have done for a fan club, which we more or less were. Perhaps places with too wide a net, such as rec.pets.cats, took the brunt of it in ways that niche bands or interests didn't have to. I recall a great war between them and alt.tasteless, many casualties. I was also put in a room once, this would be in the late 90s, to see if I could in any way help a woman who had complained some time previously to local media about porn on early usenet, and it ended with a newsgroup created by trolls called alt.sex.herlastname; mostly I had to reassure her, after looking at the content of the group, that there was no troll army keeping tabs on her movements, it was a totally dead group that someone probably created in a moment of f-you energy and never looked at again, but the internet never forgets. Not that I could have done more than that anyways, other than maybe send emails to every usenet admin I could find begging them to blacklist the group. But that incident, which I could definitely dig up some receipts about but I don't want to revive that part of her life for her, there are some undeniable resonances with Gamergate, are there not? The truth is, this place is exactly the same place it always was, just bigger and more dangerous, and that was inevitable when people came. That being said, I would say that there was definitely a pre-capitalist Internet, which had a certain culture and - say it with me - netiquette. I don't know, and could not begin to speculate, where the line is between the pre-capitalist internet and now. If I was going to put forward a candidate for when Capitalism "arrived" here, I think one good candidate would be, whatever day it was that Joshua Quittner handed over mcdonalds.com to the McDonalds corporation.
- dale_glass 4y agoI'd say that's because shampoo is a commodity and has next to zero side effects for most people. I'm sure there's people out there with very special needs who care about whether a given brand dies or goes multinational, but that's a very niche thing. But take say, Facebook buying Oculus. Oculus revived an effectively dead technology. Facebook gave them the ability to build much better tech, sell much more of it, and then coupled it with Facebook's love for sucking in private data. It absolutely had a huge effect on that part of the industry.
- barry-cotter 4y agoNo normal person cares about either of those things except insofar as it affects them. That’s the point. Facebook acquiring some startup is as relevant to the life of a heavy FB user as P&G acquiring a consumer goods company is to a heavy user of P&G products. Oh, it’s virtual reality. Who cares? If it ever becomes genuinely relevant it will show up in real life. If not reading about it is a waste of time. Remember, most people care about friends, family, work and things that come up relevant to those, and they mostly don’t care about work.
- dumpsterlid 4y agoTech Journalism absolutely knows what to do with Mastodon which is write the same lazy article over and over again about how Mastodon is dead. I personally love it because techbros read it and conclude it isnt worth checking out and the rest of us dont have to tolerate another techbro joining mastodon to jump into rando conversations and mansplain arch linux.
- college_physics 4y agoI think you can generalize the sentence to "xxx doesnt know what to do with Mastodon" where you can insert into xxx any of the major actors of modern life, including the public sector and its still a true statement The idea of empowering, democratic, relatively "low" tech that doesnt abuse its users has been expunged so effectively from the public consciousness (and tech journalism and others are so complicit) its not a mystery this new narrative doesnt fit But maybe its a blessing in disguise. As the fediverse is still rather immature, too much attention from ill-wishers might turn the baby into a stillborn
- dumpsterlid 4y ago"The idea of empowering, democratic, relatively "low" tech that doesnt abuse its users has been expunged so effectively from the public consciousness (and tech journalism and others are so complicit) its not a mystery this new narrative doesnt fit" It isnt just that, its also the fact that the media's conversation around moderation is childishly underdeveloped and nuanced. Moderation IS the hard problem of social networks, you cant automate moderation away, you cant not have moderation but any moderation policy you choose is going to have edgecases and problematic instances and the distortions those cause are going to threaten to overwhelm the spirit of the moderation (which is, dont be a dick). Also, people stuck at those edgecases (someone talking about their experience as a victim of an illegal crime for example) are going to get banned or silenced in extremely harmful ways. The reason Mastodon is the future is that it attempts to solve this moderation problem by having many different communities with different moderation policies that have unique wordings, red lines for behavior and different moderators enforcing the established policies. When different communities federate, they do so on the basis of similar philosophies about moderation. When more and more communities with similar value systems federate the edgecases of any one particular moderation policy begin to become less important as a vulnerability or exploitation point since any one particular community is small and the shared spirit of the moderation policies ("dont be a dick) becomes more important as a guiding principle in moderation disputes. Also the red line of unnaceptable behavior is different for each community which creates a fuzzy region of more and more unacceptable behavior that trolls cant exploit the way they can tip toe justtt around the edge of a singular red line. No moderation system is sustainable since it will by definition have edgecases which will cause problems or be exploited by trolls. No moderation isn't an option. Mastodon/the Fediverse is the third option nobody knew we had and really I have NO idea how corporate social networks with monolithic moderation policies projected across millions of people have any capability of adapting this innovation. It is the massive elephant in the room for corporate social media companies and yet tech journalism is still stuck on "should we have no moderation or a single moderation policy?" which Mastodon is FAR past at this point onto more interesting questions like how do instance admins negotiate moderation disputes? What does that look like and how can it be improved? There have been disputes between predominantly black communities and predominantly white queer communities on the fediverse and it gets absurdly complicated and nuanced fast but there is the capacity for that conversation to happen and different people to make their own choices and part paths (defederate) that makes Mastodon undeniably a far more advanced social technology than any other corporate social media platform where it just becomes person A is right or person B is right.
- api 4y agoInvestigate whether John Mastodon is in fact Satoshi Nakamoto?
- nottorp 4y agoAverage commenters on tech news sites dont know either. I went through an ars technica comment thread and 80% of the posters were assuming Mastodon is a for profit competitor to Twitter too.
- Kye 4y agoI still remember that tech journalist saying Mastodon would fail because he couldn't find William Shatner in 2017. To me, the lack of William Shatner is a feature.
- wkat4242 4y agoI think it's also that most of them write with investors in mind. In this case there's no investment angle.
- gumby 4y agoIt's a very good point. Linux was basically invisible until Red Hat showed up. RH wasn't even the first for profit business distributing Linux, but they were the first with a marketing department. And after some publicity, people who wanted to try Linux were no longer just the usual nerds who would download it or get a copy from a friend, but were folks used to paying for software so who were happy to pay someone to send them a disk with a distro on it.
- groestl 4y agoMastodon. It's bitcoin for your tweets. You're welcome ^^ (Edit: just for clarification, this is not meant to be serious, hence the ^^, but rather a play on bad analogies in newspapers trying to explain something the writer has not understood to people that probably never will)
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sph 4y agoI know how Mastodon and Bitcoin work, yet I have no idea what "bitcoin for your tweets" even means. That's a terrible analogy.
- dan-robertson 4y agoI think this breaks down because one assumes there’s some financial element (like other cryptocurrency projects) but that’s not really the case with mastodon.
- G3rn0ti 4y agoThe analogy has some merit as both Bitcoin and Mastodon are decentralized services that are not driven by a tech company with commercial interests in the background. Well, Bitcoin miners receive transaction fees and Mastodon instance operators donations but owners of Bitcoin or a Mastodon account have to create a meaning of these services by themselves. And I would argue that the article’s thesis is not far off as traditional media are confused by both projects due to this non-alignment of the services’ ownership and value they create. The typical crypto article focuses on advertising or scandalizing imploding crypto startups but fails to convey the benefit of international, distributed and programmable money. Similarly, the typical Mastodon article is about negative campaigning of Twitter and its new generally hated CEO but fails to explain the fundamental idea of a non-commercial distributed social network.
- rsynnott 4y agoThis confusion will get worse, not better, because non-mastodon activitypub things are about to become more of a thing. Tumblr is going to add activitypub support, apparently, and Flickr is muttering about it. I’m fascinated to see how they frame this to users.
- zainhoda 4y agoAgreed. I just posted a guide on how to do it in another thread and it’s actually not that hard. The only thing that won’t be familiar to all devs is HTTP signing. I expect that we’re going to have more HTTP middleware frameworks that support ActivityPub if Mastodon gains more traction.
- shortformblog 4y agoAs a journalist who often writes about tech and has found the transition to Mastodon pretty fulfilling, let me just say that I didn't realize how much of a problem this was until a fellow writer reached out to me about how to get set up over there, I offered to help, they posted twice, didn't appear to read any of my advice on where to start or who to follow, then ... completely dunked on the network. I am convinced that some journalists are using the wrong signals to decide whether a social network is good. It's not the onboarding, it's how the experience goes a month, or even a year, in. But tech companies are focused on building the userbase which means they're figuring out the infrastructure after the fact. Because the fediverse is open and has figured out this part, onboarding isn't as much a priority, when in reality it's the final coat of paint, the thing house flippers use to distract from the poor foundation. That has me convinced that there needs to be folks actually writing about this space in earnest as a phenomenon, because they're not getting it from their usual sources. I'm working on this now. If anyone here has thoughts on what that should look like, I'd love to hear.
- shortformblog 4y agoI can’t get over that I posted this comment emphasizing that there needed to be more direct coverage of this space and asking what people thought they wanted that to look like and literally everyone who responded minus, like, one person, seemed to focus only on a side comment I made about onboarding. It’s disappointing, if you ask me.
- newsclues 4y ago"It's not the onboarding, it's how the experience goes a month, or even a year, in." As a techie person, that makes sense, but as a normal user, if the onboarding isn't simple and easy enough, users won't make it to a month or year of using the service. If Mastadon is too complex to attract critical mass of users to achieve a competitive network effect, it will not replace Twitter.
- shortformblog 4y agoMy point is that Mastodon is being judged for not focusing on the easy part. And I'm convinced that Mastodon does not need to be a Twitter replacement to be a success. That is an important distinction that we should concede. It just needs to be a vibrant network that lots of people like using to succeed.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deltarholamda 4y agoThey don’t know what to do with Mastadon because they are not journalists. They are content creators. Most journalists fall into this category.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mark_l_watson 4y agoThings are now interesting with Mastodon! I joined 2 1/2 years ago but until a month or two ago, not terribly interesting. I only follow 181 people there (and just have 299 followers, a tiny number) but for me there is now a critical mass of people and interesting content. I have not given up on Twitter. I decided to pay for it and I am curious how a mostly paid for social media platform might evolve. People like Lex Fridman and Joe Rogan seem enthusiastic still about Twitter, but it is after all a large platform for them. Joe Rogan is interesting in part because of how much he advocates for other people, an example been his saying very complimentary things recently about Krystal and Saagar’s independent news channel (well, they are awesome).
- jrs72s 4y agoIt is an awkward platform to be honest. And can you trust the instance you are using??? The instance operator can see everything because there's no encryption.
- nishs 4y agoThere are many instances and instance operators to choose from. At least one of the choices may be sufficiently trustworthy for many users (e.g. an instance for their city run by someone in the neighborhood). You could also run your own instance. These options sound better than trusting a corporation. > The instance operator can see everything because there's no encryption. What additionally is an instance operator seeing that isn't already public? Are you referring to direct messages and privacy/blocklist settings? Regardless it's no different than having a corporation see (and mine, or sell) this data.
- dredmorbius 4y agoLikewise Twitter, Reddit, and Facebook. Hadn't stopped them.
- crazygringo 4y agoI'm sorry, but the idea that tech journalism doesn't know what to do with Mastodon because it's an open-source platform that doesn't fit into commercial startup narratives is... utter nonsense. Tech journalism does just fine with open standards/software/platforms like e-mail, domain names, torrenting, Linux, crypto. None of these fall into commercial startup narratives, yet journalists cover these things just as well as everything else. > The media seems to be regarding Mastodon as a bizarre curiosity, something that the general public couldn’t possibly grasp. Sure, the guys with a Linux server in their basement might geek out on it, but this thing isn’t for the masses. I mean, that's pretty accurate. It's easy to sign up for Twitter, it follows all of your expectations of how apps work. Not only is it hard to sign up for Mastodon, but it's hard to even figure out how to figure it out. Mastodon isn't for the masses in its current state. So as far as I can tell, the tech journalists are covering it quite appropriately.
- Dawnyhf2 4y agoTo my mind these websites are equally user hostile, twitter is extremely confusing to people who just signed up, too much influencer spam and it makes you login to find out that the stuff is just influencer spam. People who started Twitter earlier have a way better experience.
- robswc 4y agoI noticed this too. I made an account for a business and it was just odd. Maybe they’re targeting the younger generation? If not, that’s certainly what it felt like when signing up, lol.
- robswc 4y agoYep. It sounds silly but I learn more and more to just make things as frictionless as possible. Someone explained how to sign up and the first instance I found said it was shutting down soon and to migrate off. A few others I tried said they weren’t accepting new users and eventually I gave up. The funny thing is I swear I figured it out a few years back and don’t remember it being like that but maybe I just had more patience. Is there a reason you can’t just create your own identity, without an instance?
- dugite-code 4y agoI'm not sure I understand why there is any confusion regarding Mastodon. If you understand email you understand Mastodon instances... where is the confusion?
- s0sa 4y agoI’m not sure I understand how tech folks can’t contemplate the obvious confusion the average person would have around something like Mastodon. The vast majority of people don’t even understand what an “instance” is in this context without an explanation. Most people _don’t_ understand how email servers, SMTP, etc work.
- aezart 4y ago> Most people _don’t_ understand how email servers, SMTP, etc work. Yeah, I have explained to my dad many times that he can check the same email account from his tablet and his PC but he just doesn't get it. To him, his gmail is only on his tablet and his Comcast email is only on his PC and that's that.
- dugite-code 4y agoOn a simpler level everyone "gets" that their work email ends with @company.tld and their personal ends with @gmail.com. Heck we all say "at" for @ so it's easy to grasp that signing up for that involves going to these domains. Hell I explained this to my elderly mother and she got the idea straight away. So no I don't see how the confusion is obvious.
- aendruk 4y agoYep, from experience this is the way. No talk about federation and instances, just “your account is at somewhere” and choosing where is a social question not a technical one. And acknowledge that social questions are messy. “Which cafeteria table should I sit at?”
- tasuki 4y agoI for one am very confused about the excitement about Mastodon, and your comment made even me more so. Is comparing Mastodon to email a good comparison? Isn't email a protocol and isn't Mastodon a piece of software?
- i_am_toaster 4y agoArticle seems forced and comes to their conclusions based on poorly-informed opinions. For instance, this author seems to think that Mastodon is exempt from the bots and advertising because it is decentralized. However, I think the much more obvious reason is that it’s not popular; people don’t go there with their bots and advertisements. If it suddenly became popular, the bots/advertisements/“poor comment quality” would surely follow. (Just be clear, I don’t mean literal website ads, I mean posts that advertise products and businesses, whether it be obvious or not.)
- Proven 4y ago[dead]
- kleinsch 4y agoThe media will cover Mastadon when there’s an event to cover. It has existed for six years, so far there’s not a mass exodus from Twitter, so what’s the news the author is expecting? It seems like the author wants journalists to write promotion for a platform that won’t pay for coverage and where there’s no news to cover. That’s not how it works.
- Kye 4y agoYou must have missed the last month. https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=pastMonth&page=0&prefix=false&query=mastodon&sort=byPopularity&type=story https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=pastMonth&page=0&prefix=fa...
- LastTrain 4y agoOr maybe it’s just too much of a PITA to actually use.
- aaron695 4y ago[dead]
- asn1parse 4y agoThis article is poorly written and utter nonsense and just shows a clear confirmation bias with the author. lmao.
- dmix 4y agoIt’s oddly bitter. It’s normal for journalists to look for human narratives. He makes it sound like it’s some conspiracy that an OSS project lacks a good PR team to craft & communicate a good narrative. Journalists can still dig in to find the stories… even when the projects are hostile to it. Just look at the Dwarf Fortress: a small project that’s hacker made w/ an anti-gaming mainstream UI and not backed by monied elites but still has multiple fascinating journo friendly stories about it.
- insane_dreamer 4y ago> this thing isn’t for the masses it could be if signup and user discovery processes was much more frictionless; once you get past that, it's not any harder to use than other social networks. If there's anything the core devs should apply their efforts to resolving, it's that.
- Zpalmtree 4y agotech journalists hate crypto lol
- sircastor 4y ago>No one is trying to hack the attention of Mastodon users for profit, no one is bombarding us with ads. This is what happens when a new community springs up. It finds and audience, it grows because it’s a safe, interesting place, it gets critical mass, and then people become desperate to exploit it - because it’s where everyone is. It’s a newly discovered mine full of ore. It’s not that no one is trying to hack users attention, or advertise. They just haven’t figured out how to do it yet. Because of its nature, Mastodon might end up being a little more resilient, but who knows. The instance I’m on is fairly small and they’re already feeling the pinch of hosting expenses.
- boudin 4y agoI find that people being confused by federated network really telling on what it mistake it has been to let a few companies getting there hand on most of the content creation and distribution. I don't if it's the fact of having known the prime time of IRC, BBS, Usenet, and overall the web being a network of diverse communities, but I'm much more confortable with Mastodon than Twitter. Not having the possibility to host the service myself feels wrong. It's not that I want to, but I should be able to.
- dmix 4y ago> what it mistake it has been to let a few companies getting there hand on most of the content creation and distribution Centralized services drove massive adoption of consumer technology (see: Hotmail/Gmail for email). They paved the way… via marketing, customer support, design, infrastructure (even OSS services will probably run on AWS), etc. That all takes big investments that OSS typically can’t compete with. So it’s a good thing they paved the roads for which OSS can take over. All services and companies eventually stagnate or mess up, with rare exceptions. If OSS can eventually mature enough to legitimately compete in terms of UX/UI/features then there will always be opportunities in the various market to transition in that direction. People haven’t been trained or brainwashed to hate OSS, they just saw what was offered and aren’t willing the make the various sacrifices that typically come with most services like Mastodon. At least until the gap in offerings narrows.
- boudin 4y agoI'm not sure how much it actually helped. Customer support is really poor for a big chunk of those companies (I'm thinking Google, Facebook, not Apple or Amazon). People also got the concept of emails quite easily way before gmail existed or hotmail was popular. I don't think having a lot of providers was much of an issue. A lot of people still use providers which are not as big as google or hotmail, at least where I live. So I wonder if centralization was really something that helped people that much or it was more of a business strategy that was efficient for quick growth and that is the reason we are in this situation.
- tootie 4y agoBen Collins, Micah Loewinger, Taylor Lorenz. They're all MSM reporters and they are very much internet people. https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/otm/segments/mastodon-platform-taking-twitters-worn-on-the-media https://www.wnycstudios.org/podcasts/otm/segments/mastodon-p...
- anon223345 4y agoAs a software engineer, I found using Mastodon very confusing and nonintuitive. I want it to work and be successful, but trying to think of is anything but a curiosity until it’s more user-friendly for non-techies is a pretty fair argument…
- dmix 4y agoEven worse, users can signup on a random server then it can end up on one of the big server blacklists (or get shutdown) and they won’t be able to see or participate in major portions of the network. Try explaining to your mom why she needs to sign up again on a different URL, its no walk in the park (especially if you want to keep your old ‘tweets’ via backups): https://nerdschalk.com/how-to-switch-servers-on-mastodon-everything-you-need-to-know/ https://nerdschalk.com/how-to-switch-servers-on-mastodon-eve... If Mastodon grows bigger and blacklists grow, it could easily Balkanize, and it will be clear it’s more of a competitor or add-on to existing niche forums/communities. Something not really in the spirit of public social networks like Twitter. Which is totally fine, just different. …assuming they figure out the UX/UI issues to help it “cross the chasm” (which I’m skeptical will happen soon, that usually takes core leadership, good design is rarely tacked on afterwards). https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crossing_the_Chasm?wprov=sfti1 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Crossing_the_Chasm?wprov=sfti1
- sangnoir 4y ago> Try explaining to your mom why she needs to sign up again on a different URL, its no walk in the park How different is this from explaining switching from AOL to GMail?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- dmix 4y agoAOL doesn't blacklist Gmail users? And asking your mom to switch email addresses/providers and learn a whole new interface is probably not the example you want to use... People clung to Hotmail/AOL for YEARS, sometimes a decade.
- bell-cot 4y agoI noticed that every "standard tech journalism template" on his list was either tech Corporate Press Release stuff, or tech celebrity news stuff... ...vs., jumping over to Ars Technica (called out in these comments for having 80% of commenters assume that Mastodon is a for-profit Twitter competitor), and their "20 Most-read Stories of 2022" article - gosh, maybe three stories of their Top 12 fit any of those templates. Conclusion: Article author's mental image of "tech journalist" is actually "tech gossip columnist" - for people who want to sound cool & informed, but wouldn't actually want to know anything useful about tech.
- nottorp 4y agoFor the record I'm a paid subscribed to Ars. But the comments on the Mastodon article were... wow. But then the article was syndicated from somewhere and not at the normal Ars level either. Linky to article: https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/12/mastodon-is-hurtling-toward-a-tipping-point/ https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2022/12/mastodon-is-hurt...
- bell-cot 4y agoFrom a quick glance at wired.com - the syndicated Ars article's source - the original article's postulates look even more delusional.
- msla 4y agoLike this: > And administrators must comply with not only their local laws, but laws that exist anywhere their server is accessible. This is bullshit and they have to know it's bullshit. Why? Because their servers are accessible in Thailand, but nobody pretends they have to abide the lèse-majesté laws Thailand enforces. Ditto the various laws in force in other countries Ars doesn't care about. Plus, they don't look into why Twitter complies with the GDPR: Twitter has assets in Europe that the EU could seize. A local Mastodon instance operator doesn't, so they don't have to care. Vice-versa in the converse, of course: A small European Mastodon instance operator doesn't have to care about any laws in North or South America.
- notwokeno 4y ago
- beastcoast 4y agoTurns out Mastodon is “malware”? I can’t even read posts at work; it’s completely blocked…
- p0nce 4y agoSomething I appreciate a lot on Mastodon is simply its federated nature. It seems to me like a nice middle-ground between: 1. niche communities like Discord, and 2. "everyone at the same time" like Twitter.
- jasmer 4y agoYes, but, people care about 'stuff that works' 10x before they care about the tech press or supposed 'values' of some FSF moralisation. Mastodon is has a usability problem in the concept of Federation and many other things. It's complicated, they don't provide a clear path to usability or understanding. I mostly agree about the problem in journalism, but it's not a Mastodon problem, moreover, there are ways to fit Mastodon into basic narratives. I also don't think that WSJ articles matter that much with respect to influencing tech trends.
- 88j88 4y agoI think mastodon sucks. I think most people think it sucks, compared to twitter- which they likely already use. Is the friction of having a worse user experience worth moving from twitter, just because Elon is being a twit? I don't think most people care because- what is the value of twitter anyway? Most social media is- you get to hear what your friends think, and respond to them. With twitter it seems to democratize access to influencers. Would you switch to Mastodon if- none of the people you care about are there? I don't think so. And if most of those influencers don't move to other platforms, will those other platforms be covered by tech journalists? No.
- dredmorbius 4y agoJournalism does several things. One of those is to inform and report. But in doing so, it almost always tries to fit events into an existing narrative.[1] And the existing narrative of the past decade-and-a-half of online systems, with very few exceptions, has been privately-owned, for-profit, walled-garden, advertising-supported social networks. Mastodon is sufficiently disruptive that "John Mastodon" was invented out of whole cloth to match the terrain to the existing map: Then, the platform removed John Mastodon, the founder of a competing social media company named after himself, for posting a link to the jet tracker's Mastodon account. <https://boingboing.net/2022/12/18/mastodon-users-embrace-columnists-funny-error-about-a-fictitious-john-mastodon.html https://boingboing.net/2022/12/18/mastodon-users-embrace-col...> Note the mappings: - "John Mastodon" is created as a figurehead. - And as a "founder" ... - Of a "competing social media company" (itself three sub-mappings) I can understand how someone doing a sloppy hot-take could make those errors. But it also speaks to not having the narrative language to comprehend the reality. We don't understand what we don't have language for, "I'll see it when I believe it" also becomes "I'll see it when I understand it". That this afflicts those we rely on to tell the story is all the more problematic. (Camouflage works on a similar basis: <https://polination.files.wordpress.com/2012/12/animal-camo-leopard.jpg https://polination.files.wordpress.com/2012/12/animal-camo-l...>) I saw Newitz's comment and immediately replied (without checking the thread): By "impossible to use", what they of course mean is "impossible to use to monopolize, monetize, and commit massive fraud with". <https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/109560464904178130 https://toot.cat/@dredmorbius/109560464904178130> ... and quickly realised I was being anything but original on the thread. I've been in the tech orbit long enough to have seen multiple cycles of "tech is hard and can't be easily communicated", dating to the Apple II and Commodore Pet systems. By the mid-1980s, I was using uni campus Unix servers to write papers (formatted in nroff!!!) and communicate with my LDR grilf via email and talk(1) over a 56k leased-line network. I've seen mainframes, minis, PCs, the Internet, email, Usenet, FTP, the Web, Unix, Linux, mobile phones, smartphones, Twittr, and His Noodliness Knows What Else described as some esoteric geek-infused arcana up until the point it isn't. Two particular memories are of seeing a URL on a can of shaving creme ~1997, and of being in a bookstore (remember those) circa 1999 listing to a mother and young daughter talking about a new friend she'd met with her mother asking if they'd exchanged email addresses. Both were spillovers of my tech world into meatspace. Twitter ... has long been niche, relatively little-used, and fairly misunderstood itself. Searching phrases such as "I don't understand twitter" reveals many thousands of results. Facebook itself was largely niche until about 2010. Where both did become significantly adopted wasn't through argument, and probably benefitted relatively little from onboarding, but when they became where the conversation or interaction was, and people and organisations found that that's where they needed to be. Not necessarily everyone (I've avoided both), but a large and dominant fraction of online discourse. If Mastodon and the Fediverse become widely adopted, then it will be due to similar dynamics. And journalists will likely have found their narrative by that point. ________________________________ Notes: 1. A great book detailing this is Edward Jay Epstein's News from Nowhere. It discusses the production of television news circa 1974, though much of the journalistic element applies to other media as well (including voice and video over the Internet). <https://archive.org/details/newsfromnowheret00epst https://archive.org/details/newsfromnowheret00epst> <http://libgen.rs/book/index.php?md5=14C940300F3D0EA68652013E3046A701 http://libgen.rs/book/index.php?md5=14C940300F3D0EA68652013E...>
- SyzygistSix 4y agoMastodon doesn't even know what to do with Mastodon.
- philippejara 4y agoTech journalism most often then not doesn't know tech in the first place.Safe from a very small number, often in specialized outlets like techdirt, they're effectively "culture" journalists in regards to social media, so it isn't at all surprising that something more complex than just another twitter drama or nebulous AI VC project #234 goes way over their head.
- zeruch 4y agoTech journalism has for a long time been in the tech industry circle jerk olympics. This is a trend going back decades, and I remember when FOSS first got traction and the reporting was somewhere between factually vacant and ideologically psychotic. "Tech journalism" by and large exists to boost industry insiders or act as the journal of record for collective schadenfreude. Nothing has changed.
- tasuki 4y agoWhy is this about Mastodon? Isn't ActivityPub or Fediverse the real secret sauce and Mastodon just one of the many interoperable implementations? (These are genuine questions, I've not used Twitter, am not participating in Fediverse, and could be missing something)
- ciroduran 4y agoOr blogging in general! Or hand-made websites if we want to go further back (or right now if you use [zonelets](https://zonelets.net/ https://zonelets.net/) ) How would this article read if you replace any Mastodon mention with blogging? There have been ways to communicate and receive feedback from that communication for quite a while. They're not particularly cool, or sexy, or whatever you want to call them. And that's fine. The real value here is the people you connect with, the network effect as it's been named. It was blogging years ago, then centralised social media took over. Maybe it's time for the next thing. Re: Mastodon - ActivityPub is the protocol and maybe the secret sauce, but it looks to me that Mastodon is the case of an overnight success 5 years in the making. I remember opening a Mastodon account in 2017 and not giving it much importance, but now that conditions have changed, I see it with much more value than 5 years ago.
- int_19h 4y agoMostly because Mastodon is what the vast majority of users see as a frontend in this context.
- Night_Thastus 4y agoAs someone who hasn't used it yet - if this is "good" social media, for the love of all that is good - enjoy it while you can. If it gets big, it will be driven into the ground and become utter garbage. So enjoy it while it's small.
- xpe 4y agoWe need to design better. Why do we accept services that cannot, by definition, work well as they grow?
- Night_Thastus 4y agoIt has nothing to do with design. The problem is not a technical one. It has to do with economics. All social media have two options for their future, and it all comes down to control of their content: 1: Relatively laissez-faire. This is the more "free speech" oriented options. Inevitably, these sites gain reputation for bad behavior and poor conduct in some of their sub-communities. (Racism, sexism, antisemitism, some attempt at illegal activities like piracy, etc, etc) Radical individuals flock to these places. This lack of strong control over what appears on their site leads to wary advertisers and a lack of investors. A site with no advertisers and investors will not grow, period. Hardware costs money. Software costs money. Everything costs money. If lucky, some of these sites manage to stick around - but they are always very niche. Donations don't support a site with 100+ million users and lots of advanced features. 2: Strongly control content. This leads to a very "sanitized" site. Because it's a safe place to do so, investors and advertisers will flock to it if it hits a critical mass. More and more growth is desired, so the site needs to gain mass-market appeal. Over time, it becomes more and more accessible and generic, which erodes whatever original character the site had. Because of the nature of the "average" person when you have such a low gate of entry, the site quickly becomes just another facebook/twitter/reddit. The massive size also leads to enormous amounts of bots, spam, propaganda, etc. You cannot fight these - they are inevitable. Those are your two options. Social media that cannot grow and remains niche, and social media that's filled with generic, low effort garbage content, spam, bots, etc.
- _8j50 4y agoI tried to use it, you know why I can't? Email! Everyone wants email, sure I can register b.s. emails but I shouldn't have to on a communication platform and not in 2022/23. You would think they'd have learned from reddit instead of twitter. Plus, I have seen this "federated"/distributed type of services. I am cautiously observing how it turns out because I have been burned before. Account lockouts, bad moderation, hostile servers, reliability,etc... I hope they get it to work though but what scares me is lack of commercial motivation, can you pay for a mastodon account or host ads on mastodon? And is there a good/standardized way where I can find out who is running an instance to hold them accountable? Ok, most of you who are not very young probably remember the golden days of IRC right? Need I say more?
- doublepg23 4y agoAssuming you’re that concerned of decentralizing your identity I would suggest self hosting.
- _8j50 4y agoSee, I am not concerned about centralizing, I am more concerned of expectations like that where I should self host if I don't like how it is. Regular users can't do that so the adaption momentum now cannot be sustained long imo,but I hope I am wrong.
- eric4smith 4y ago“Open protocols” is all well and good. Onboarding is important. However what will cause Mastodon to remain as a niche network is that the networks you want are not over there. Ask yourself this… Which server are most of these people on? Are they scattered on multiple instances? How can you reach most of them without too much effort? That’s the reason I’ve not even been over there.
- bartimus 4y ago> no one is bombarding us with ads. is where journalism left the building. Not because of "ads". But because of "us". The article is subjective. What problem is he talking about? The problem of Mastodon not getting enough attention? Maybe Mastodon just isn't newsworthy (yet).