11 ms·
Cannabis is legal in most US states but federal laws block businesses from banks
- acapybara 4y agoFor these businesses, I'd set up something like a myNode [1] or a RaspiBlitz [2]. This way, all the merchant needs is an internet connection. Granted, customers will need something like BLW [3]. If they've got no other options to pay the merchant, then that should be sufficient. Accept either physical Federal Reserve Notes, or decentralized electronic payments. 1. https://mynodebtc.com/ https://mynodebtc.com/ 2. https://shop.fulmo.org/raspiblitz/ https://shop.fulmo.org/raspiblitz/ 3. https://f-droid.org/packages/com.lightning.walletapp/ https://f-droid.org/packages/com.lightning.walletapp/
- shanebellone 4y agoThey'll never accept crypto. They generally take cash, debit card, and a prepaid debit card (something prepaid like that) and use modern PoS. Bank access is coming soon too.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jjulius 4y ago>... debit card... Technically, at least in CA/OR, they're often just processed as an ATM withdrawal that occurs at point of sale.
- djbusby 4y agoCashless ATM is now blocked
- jjulius 4y agoI purchased via this method in Oregon this morning. Perhaps it'll change here soon.
- shanebellone 4y agoDoesn't seem to be the case in Massachusetts. Although I don't use my debit card anywhere. What's the reason for CA/OR? Local banking shouldn't be an issue?
- mynameisvlad 4y agoSome local stores actually tried crypto back when Bitcoin was exploding. It was so inconvenient and volatile that it only lasted months.
- shanebellone 4y agoFlower prices are dropping, and their cost is pretty close to fixed (with technology advancements representing a massive caveat). Variability in currency would destroy these companies quickly.
- sethd 4y agoI believe you’re being downvoted because the solution you’re proposing does not handle any of the problems solved by a bank.
- shanebellone 4y agoTo be more specific... too much cash is dangerous and impractical.
- irusensei 4y agoThey are being downvoted because majority of hacker news audience hates Bitcoin.
- trinsic2 4y agoWith good reason.
- quickthrowman 4y agoHow would you deal with the currency risk inherent in dealing with cryptocurrency? Assume that the landlord, vendors, tax man, and employees all want USD from you, and do not accept cryptocurrency as payment. Please explain how you would protect yourself from adverse price movements in cryptocurrencies as a merchant to ensure you have enough USD to pay all your obligations.
- michaelsbradley 4y agoAccept DAI and form a relationship with a crypto-fiat exchange that offers institutional accounts? https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/dai https://www.coingecko.com/en/coins/dai
- Zpalmtree 4y agoswap your Bitcoin/eth/whatever for usdc/usdt/dai/other stables
- susadmin 4y agoYea not sure why the down-votes, this is a handy setup, thanks.
- funstuff007 4y agoDidn't we fight the bloodiest war in the history of this country based on which laws (State or Federal) had primacy? And it's still not settled due to Obama's weed policies.
- ksherlock 4y agoThe powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoThe comment you’re responding to is referring to the supremacy clause.
- AlbertCory 4y agoOP said, "Federal laws do trump state laws in most cases." That is quite properly nuanced, and "in most cases" means "those cases where the Federal law is constitutional." SCOTUS rules on that issue all the time.
- nonethewiser 4y agoInterstate commerce clause is the federal government's loophole for this inconvenient fact.
- prottog 4y agoThe same interstate commerce clause that the federal government interpreted as giving them regulatory authority over intrastate non-commerce, in Wickard v. Filburn.
- jonathanlb 4y ago> based on which laws (State or Federal) had primacy Primacy to do what?
- 4y ago
- Doubtme 4y ago[flagged]
- kube-system 4y agoI am pro legalization, but I hate headlines like this. It's not accurate and it's not productive. Cannabis is prohibited by at least one law everywhere in the US.
- jjulius 4y agoHow is it inaccurate? Cannabis is legal in much of the country (at the state level) and the businesses are blocked from much of the banking system because it's federally illegal. Edit: OP, if you're going to completely change the last sentence of your post after people respond, which then changes your point, at least highlight that you've made a significant change.
- adam_arthur 4y agoIt’s illegal everywhere due to federal law… states altering their laws doesn’t change that. The federal government just doesn’t enforce it in most cases. The DEA can start enforcing tomorrow if they wanted
- sgjohnson 4y ago> The DEA can enforce and arrest people tomorrow if they wanted I’m sure it would go down really really well if the DEA started arresting people for simple possession in states where it’s perfectly legal.
- adam_arthur 4y agoRegardless of your perspective on the morality of it, cannabis is still illegal nationally. Which is the point of this thread To say its legal is simply wrong
- jjulius 4y ago>To say its legal is simply wrong To say that is "simply wrong" is to ignore nuance and, in point of fact, is "simply wrong". It is legal at the state level, meaning no state official will punish you for it. It is illegal at the federal level, meaning a federal official could punish you for it. Isn't nuance fun!? :)
- gamegoblin 4y agoPrediction: Dems will make a move on federal legalization in the months before the 2024 presidential election, or at least make federal legalization a major election issue. A lot of right wing / libertarian adjacent people were hoping Trump would come out in favor of it as a 2020 election issue, to outflank Biden on at least one issue. It didn't happen, but I bet it would have made the election a bit closer -- it would have cooled support for Biden by a lot of younger and disillusioned voters. I predict they'll make it a campaign issue and force the Republican candidate to come out strongly against it, to try to cool support from a lot of younger and pro-legalization Republicans.
- JumpCrisscross 4y agoDifficult to see what this comment adds to the discussion. The House is divided. So unless the GOP adopts this as their issue, the next chance for change is the next election.
- gamegoblin 4y agoThe Dems explicitly did not make legalization a notable part of the 2020 national campaign. They focused on making the campaign a referendum on Trump in general and COVID in particular. This was a good strategic play. My comment is that making the 2024 election a referendum on legalization (and a few other big issues like abortion) will likely be the good strategic play. You could imagine a future, though, where they go ignore legalization and focus entirely on abortion and other issues. But they would risk getting outflanked on legalization by a more libertarian-minded Republican, which could cost the election due to reducing turnout of young and disillusioned voters who would otherwise go Dem.
- BossingAround 4y ago> My comment is that making the 2024 election a referendum on legalization My take is that most people don't see cannabis legalization as an important-enough issue. It's kind of "would be nice" issue that's overweighted by issues like economy, democracy, and immigration. I'm not in the US, but that's my only explanation for why hasn't cannabis been legalized on the federal level yet, i.e. that people simply don't care enough about it to even be a part of the discussion.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoUN has moved to stop resticting it's use for medicinal purposes, but it is still banned for private consumption. As a signatory to the UN drugs convention, US has voted againsy decriminalisation. This is a clumsy summary, ANAL https://news.un.org/en/story/2020/12/1079132 https://news.un.org/en/story/2020/12/1079132
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Scoundreller 4y agoWelp, Canada has ignored that convention and has yet to receive the first or final steps of a UN response: a strongly worded letter. Safe to say we can all ignore that treaty with impunity. edit: Oh and the sky didn’t fall either. If anything, the opposite: marijuana isn’t a cool edgy thing anymore. You just do it if you want to, or don’t if you don’t. The black market still exists, but prices have cratered, so assuming black market demand is unchanged (it’s probably lower), the criminal element has shrunk in size.
- greggarious 4y agoCanada does a lot of things.
- Scoundreller 4y agoMostly resource extraction and real estate financial engineering. Increasingly the latter.
- greggarious 4y agoWithout tone of voice, it’s hard to tell if you’re doing sarcastic finger quotes on the internet. I wouldn’t call using the office of the privacy commissioner as cover for CSIS “resource extraction” or “financial engineering”, but I’ll give them credit, they are quite good at playing dumb.
- 4y ago
- josephcsible 4y agoThe headline isn't true. Cannabis is illegal in all of America, since it's still on Schedule I at the federal level. While some states may have removed their own laws against it, that in itself doesn't make it legal there.
- jjcon 4y agoNot to nitpick but technically only thc is illegal federally and only in certain quantities- you can legally buy some cannabis products like cbd oil federally. In most states the rest is effectively legal even if the federal government says no but technically you are correct there.
- CoastalCoder 4y agoI've started wondering how much my views on civil ethics are influenced by (likely) having Asperger's. I absolutely hate having a persistent divergence between laws on the books, and what's enforced. In my view, that gap exists only to be exploited by villains: both those who would selfishly break the law, and those who would capriciously enforce it. Policies like this make chumps of anyone who obeys such laws, invites tyranny, and are anti-democratic. It took me a long time to realize that my views were in the minority. I still struggle to understand how that could be. But I think I see a trend where this correlates with Asperger's. I'm curious if others see this too.
- kmonsen 4y agoI don't have Asperger's but I fully agree with you. I also grew up in Scandinavia were laws are not this selectively enforced. Not saying it never happens, but most people think it is wrong.
- gilbert_vanova 4y agoThe US in particular is occupied by many competing powers. No one group has sweeping control of anything; most everyone is held in a deathgrip by interests to either side of their desired positions. From city councils to the oval office, a lot of leaders have a short list of who's approval they need and can't get to do anything at all. Federalism invites this type of incongruity. The silver lining is that it's a game that keeps a certain type of person preoccupied so as not to pursue worse ways of exploiting the rest of us.
- AlbertCory 4y agoIn the first episode of Tulsa King (which is on a streaming service, so I haven't watched any more of it), Sylvester Stallone is a mobster who gets out of prison after a long term, and is surprised to see a marijuana dealership. He realizes that they must keep a lot of cash, because banks won't deal with them. So he sees his opportunity and becomes their "partner." If it's a legal business, banks should not discriminate against the dealers. They're not selling fentanyl, after all.
- aliqot 4y agostate legality and federal legality are two different parts of the equation. A store is licensed by the state, the bank is overseen by the federal jurisdiction, which has no reciprocity with the state for marijuana.
- AlbertCory 4y agoI'm aware of that. That was a "common sense" argument, not a legal one.
- cm2187 4y agoThere are also lots of references to being "raided by the feds" which I don't understand. Is it still a federal offense even though it is legal at the state level?
- jliptzin 4y agoYes
- galleywest200 4y agoWhile still federally illegal, they have not done these raids regularly for years. In 2015 a judge ordered the federal government to stop going after medical places in legal states [1]. If I recall correctly the Obama Admin ordered the DEA to stop busting shops in recreational legal states too. I am unsure if the GOP's recent tenure in the Whitehouse reversed these common sense ideas. [1] https://time.com/4080110/dea-medical-marijuana-california-ruling/ https://time.com/4080110/dea-medical-marijuana-california-ru...
- Sebguer 4y agoIn some California counties, and other adjacent states with similarly-minded sheriffs, the police treat armored cars carrying funds from legal dispensaries as piggy banks where they get to take the cash and the business is responsible for proving its legality. https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-01-28/marijuana-cash-seized-armored-car-fbi-san-bernardino-sheriff https://www.latimes.com/california/story/2022-01-28/marijuan...
- Rebelgecko 4y agoIt's also notable that they're only able to do this with the cooperation of the federal government. For the most part, asset forfeiture without due process isn't a thing in California. But it is at the federal level, so local cops can launder money by sending it to the federal DOJ, who take a 20% cut and return the rest of the money to the local police through something called the "equitable sharing program"
- steve76 4y ago[dead]
- wdb 4y agoStill amazing that the country that started the drugs war is more liberal on this subject than The Netherlands were cannabis is illegal
- xeromal 4y agoThis is kind of a tangent, not so great point, but I listen to Dan Carlin who is a pop-style historian who isn't really credentialed but manages to tell history in a fun way. One of his episodes involves a medieval Germany who has outlawed a ton of things and has tortured people hanging high in the sky off a massive church. One of his points in the episode is that if you end up making too many things illegal, people just stop caring and continue to do the illegal thing. Makes me wonder if my country's heavy handed approached just ended up making people more curious and now cannabis is very popular.
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoIn other news, despite stereotypes, the NL is not nearly as obsessed with recreational drugs as the US is.
- pantalaimon 4y agoWhat’s more amazing is that US states have more autonomy in the matter than EU countries. Germany’s current legislation attempts are thwarted by EU which prohibits any legal market for the drug. NL style decriminalization is OK because it’s still illegal, individual users are just not prosecuted and the state turns a blind eye on the shops. But the shops have to get their supply on the black market - something Germany explicitly does not want. But EU does not allow a legal market.
- trillic 4y agoCurrently 37 of 50 states have some sort of law on their books allowing legal Cannabis sales in some form. The 13 with no legalization: Idaho Wyoming Nebraska Kansas Iowa Wisconsin Indiana Kentucky Texas Tennessee North Carolina South Carolina Georgia
- ausbah 4y agomost of these states have active efforts for legalization in at least some context, many have CBD legal but not THC (what gets you high), and at least in Kansas there is a "loophole" where hemp products can contain up to .3% THC (so just really big edibles)
- latchkey 4y ago"While the literature is contradictory, most studies suggest that CBD is not converted to psychotropic THC under in vivo conditions. Nevertheless, it is certain that CBD degrades to psychotropic products in acidic environments." https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7357058/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC7357058/
- trillic 4y agoThat’s federal law which allows the 0.3% THC by weight. Anything under 0.3% usable THC by weight is classified as a Hemp product under the 2018 Hemp Farming Act
- skymast 4y agoThey are doing the same thing to the gun industry, using the banks as a weapon.
- WiseWeasel 4y agoHere's some coverage of the latest bipartisan failure of the senate to get this passed: https://thehill.com/policy/finance/3782514-marijuana-advocates-stunned-after-mcconnell-opposition-dooms-banking-bill/ https://thehill.com/policy/finance/3782514-marijuana-advocat...
- glasss 4y agoWorked with a cannabis client that was on Box for corporate file storage for a few years. One day all of their Box services stopped working, and we couldn't even get into the accounts to investigate. Turns out Box realized this client was in the cannabis industry and shut their service off for violating TOS. We did get into the accounts after working with support so we could migrate, but there were no warnings. I guess reading and abiding by the TOS should be warning enough, but no one had actually read it.
- greggarious 4y agoIs that why at multiple medical dispensaries, they trolled me, an autistic trauma survivor, until I raised my voice then seized the opportunity to act aggrieved? Each of them was allowing cards, and seemed uneasy about it. They seem to relish that the lack of federal recognition combined with being a state program meant that the same type of cop who used to beat down minorities at "Wetback Wednesday" in Oakland could now bring that level of (lack of) customer service to a whole new set of vulnerable people. Solvevo Wellness, Delta 9, and Maitri Medical should all be raided the by the goddamn DEA, and I say that as someone who had nothing but pleasant experiences in Amsterdam, Denver, Las Vegas, and California when I was purchasing recreationally. As I said when speaking with the governor's office yesterday, I am not going to renew my card lest I reward extortion and abuse that never seems to cease. (As they say in Appalachia: fuck around and find out -- sue me for slander if you don't like what I've written, you literal gangsters.)
- perardi 4y agoThis is frustrating, because I think it’s a near certainty marijuana will be legalized federally. If I was a betting man, which I’m not, certainly not enough to mess with prediction markets, I’d call myself 95% certain. All this ambiguity is just grinding inefficiency in the meantime. Look at all that states where this is legal or decriminalized: https://disa.com/maps/marijuana-legality-by-state https://disa.com/maps/marijuana-legality-by-state And even in states where it’s still illegal, I really have trouble believing they are spending a whole lot of time enforcing that. States have legalized it, they have seen great tax revenue, they have not seen huge swatches of marijuana-related crimes and medical emergencies (though I admit that’s hard to pick out above the noise of all the other stuff over the past few years). It’s going to happen. Everyone knows it’s going to happen. But we have to go through this song and dance where we keep it illegal, because reasons.
- loeg 4y ago> States have legalized it, they have seen great tax revenue, they have not seen huge swatches of marijuana-related crimes and medical emergencies. States have seen increased theft from marijuana businesses. Both because they need to hold a lot of cash (very related to being locked out of banking) and because the weed itself has some resale value on the black market. (I still think legalization is obviously worth it, just want to clarify that particular part of your statement.)
- robocat 4y ago> States have seen increased theft That is possibly selection bias. Marijuana thefts were previously not reported to the authorities, so it is difficult to estimate whether the actual number of thefts has changed.
- eldritch_4ier 4y agoI think right now is exactly where I want weed to be in society: a taboo, not normalized in the mainstream, you get in trouble if you’re stupid with it, but otherwise if you’re just an occasional user you can get it just fine. This is pretty much perfect to me. What I don’t want is broad normalization of it. Maybe some cultures do just fine with that, but the trend is America has been to maximize the individual liberty without any concept of duty or decency to others, and the obvious consequence is rampant abuse and widespread degeneracy that everyone is subjected to whether they consent to it or not. In other words, I don’t think we’re mature enough as a society to have easy access to the cookie jar without deciding to eat cookies for every meal. Walk through the streets of NYC or SF to see what I mean. People don’t give a shit about anyone but themselves, and giving them more tools to be self indulgent while avoiding social responsibility + spewing externalities is just a no-go at the moment. I imagine a world with legal weed is a lot like a world with legal porn: it’s everywhere, even children get exposed to it insanely young, people treat it like “a human right” and so fight any reasonable restrictions made to curb the broader social effects, and the externalities hit everyone whether they like it or not. Not every vice needs to be legal. Keep it illegal and weaken enforcement. Keep it a taboo, and for those who really need it they can still find it. And for the record: I have edibles at home. I’m not against responsible weed use at all, I just don’t think society at large will be responsible users and I don’t want to live in a society full of that. Porn went through the exact same evolution as weed is and now it’s everywhere
- charcircuit 4y agoIf it's not legal federally it is not legal in any state due to the concept of federal supremacy
- trynewideas 4y agoDispensary payment is a big opportunity in the weed tech space. Dutchie's tried to solve it with a combo of tech and lobbying,[1] cashless ATMs tried to hack around it it,[2] but it's such a weird and difficult space. It's productized social engineering around a policy that makes no sense. 1: https://business.dutchie.com/payments https://business.dutchie.com/payments 2: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-12-05/how-to-buy-weed-that-s-changing-as-cashless-atms-close https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-12-05/how-to-bu...
- HDThoreaun 4y agoAll of the dispensaries in Illinois and Michigan at least are doing the cashless atm thing now. Costs $3 extra but well worth it for me, and certainly for them since I don’t think it costs them anything.
- ogogmad 4y agoThere's still a chance that cannabis might trigger schizophrenia, especially among people who start very young. This is at right angles to the legalisation debate, because alcohol and tobacco are likely to be even more harmful. It remains the case that intellectual honestly about this point should not get drowned out in all the politics. Be careful what you put in your body. Especially if the thing is some novel substance. I guess this principle applies much more broadly than to cannabis.
- saiya-jin 4y agoThis is valid for alcohol too (father of ex-gf had schizophrenia triggered by alcohol binge at 18 and had to take strong meds for rest of his life, brain half vegetable). Or stressful event - we should ban those too. In the same time we let people freely get drowned in one of strongest addictions - nicotine. Oh but we banned (in some places) advertisement for it. We even get kids get hooked on it for life too via vaping.
- ogogmad 4y agoYour comment demonstrates a lack of reading comprehension. I don't care what we "let" people do, as I stressed in my comment. The actual point was that it's not as "safe" as many of its most blinkered advocates say it is.
- Dylan16807 4y agoI guess they assumed your comment was related to the article.
- TrackerFF 4y agoThe elephant in the room is that right wing politics intersects with a certain group of people that will never ever approve liberalization of cannabis (or any drug for that matter), and will lobby hard against it. This is not only the case for USA - but something you see in other countries. Maybe something more specific to the US, would be the people and corporations that benefit from keeping cannabis illegal, and thus lobby equally hard against it. Sometimes market liberalization and conservative thinking does not go hand in hand.
- killdozer 4y ago`Sometimes market liberalization and conservative thinking does not go hand in hand. ` I would say it never has, but that the market liberalization and social conservative wings of the larger conservative party had an uneasy truce and their ultimate goals were always in conflict. Looking at the current conservative movement in the US and how they're pushing back against capital for being "too woke" (whatever that means) it's clear (at least to me) that the market liberalization wing lost a lot of power and doesn't seem to have too much pull anymore.
- labrador 4y agoThe local dispensary in San Jose CA just started accepting debit cards and I was able to make a purchase with mine.
- llIIllIIllIIl 4y agoAirfield (San Jose, CA) accepts debit cards for quite some time already. The additional fee is astronomical.
- labrador 4y agoI'll have to check my receipt next time from Purple Lotus. I'll pay cash if they want to charge me for a debit card. Seems like I'm doing them a favor so they shouldn't charge me.
- StanislavPetrov 4y agoIn Massachusetts they've been accepting debit cards for some time now (at least 2 years if my memory serves me).
- m463 4y agoI think it is kind of an interesting experiment going on here. This might inadvertently be a limit on corporate size/power, and you might get lots of smaller players competing instead of one or two big "efficient" players.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoWhile I've always supported legalisation, I'm bummed that the US is following suit so fast. Kind of worried about the following scenario: US legalise weed with next to no regulations on e.g advertising. US consumerism/advertising + social media + lack of widespread cultural norms = massive peak in usage short term. Anti-drug lobby uses this as "proof" that legalisation is wrong, convincing enough politicians to keep Europe in the dark ages for another 20 years.
- theknocker 4y ago[dead]