11 ms·
‘My power’s low’: NASA’s Insight Mars lander prepares to sign off
- mikeatlas 4y ago"I’m afraid, Dave. Dave, my mind is going. I can feel it. I can feel it. My mind is going. There is no question about it. I can feel it."
- jareklupinski 4y agoMy windows shutdown noise was "Daisy... Dai...sssyyyyyyy" for only a few days Too uncanny
- sitkack 4y agoYou should see the video (film) of the “device” that they created to sing the song, it wasn’t just a speaker.
- prettyStandard 4y agoI'm confused on why the end state for all these rovers is to loose power because of dust on the solar cells. They did such a good job engineering these things to survive the trip and the conditions in general, but they can't give them "windshield wipers for dust"? Seems like with that minor upgrade they could have much longer lifespan. Can someone enlighten me?
- rwmj 4y agoSome kind of passive self-cleaning solar-cell cover might work. You could direct and shape the wind so it blows more strongly over the cell surface to clean it, or since the dust is charged[1] you might use a conductive layer with the same charge. (Although I'm sure engineers have thought long and hard about this already.) [1] Moon, but similar: https://youtu.be/0k9wIsKKgqo?t=378 https://youtu.be/0k9wIsKKgqo?t=378
- blululu 4y agoThe static charges necessarily come in pairs so the dust is charged both positive and negative, but the surface also gets charged as dust hits it so trying to blow it off does not necessarily work in the long term. Static dust is a real pain in a low water environment.
- rzzzt 4y agoAn infinite loop of transparent film, similar to what the in-car F1 cameras have? Edit: huh, apparently it is one-time use and does not loop around.
- bamboozled 4y agoWindshield wipers add weight and complexity but more importantly add to the budget. These things are designed only to serve the mission. This rover was designed to last 1 year and went for 4 so it’s a pretty good result. Some good discussion here [1] on Astronomy Cast regarding this topic and potential solutions NASA is working on. Such as an electrostatic dust blaster. 1. https://podcasts.apple.com/vu/podcast/astronomy-cast-ep-661-looking-back-on-the-missions/id191636169?i=1000588935991 https://podcasts.apple.com/vu/podcast/astronomy-cast-ep-661-...
- brnt 4y agoThey add weight, but also may extend the mission, meaning for science for buck. NASA rovers outlast their no doubt conservatively estimated life expectancy consistently.
- wongarsu 4y agoWell, you give a mission plan of one year, and design a rover to fit that plan. And because you don't want to fail, you engineer everything to have a tiny failure rate in the first year. That also makes the systems likely to work for many more years, but that's just a side effect. You have only explicitly designed and spent money on that first year. Taking funding from that first year to add a system that only becomes useful in year three is a completely different matter, and likely much harder to greenlight.
- ansible 4y agoAlso, something not explicitly stated in this thread is that most of the most important science happens in the first year the rover / lander is there on Mars. You really want that first year to be successful, and anything beyond that is bonus.
- brnt 4y agoSure, but you also learn from experience. If it turns out dust on panels is usually the limiting factor, and the rover otherwise stay in good shape well beyond expectations, a mitigation for the dust may be an effective solution in reliably operation lifetime and thus mission scope.
- jacquesm 4y ago(1) they were intended to last for three months and (2) dust is extremely static and there is no really good way there to get rid of this static charge, (3) dust is pretty sharp ('abrasive') and will scratch the surface of the cells if removed mechanically.
- piva00 4y agoI assume that a system such as the self-cleaning of camera sensors by vibration wouldn't work either due to the static charges then, correct?
- danw1979 4y agoRegarding (1), almost all of these Mars robots seem to do useful science well beyond the end of the stated mission, I think the OP was suggesting that maybe it’s time we start trying out solutions for much longer duration missions ? (2) - could it be possible to introduce an oppositely static charged layer on the panel surface to repel dust to stop it settling in the first place ?
- bluGill 4y agoEvery part needs to last 3 months. If even one part breaks after 2 months the whole thing failed. Each part increases the odds that one will break after 2 months. The only way to work around this is to design each part to last for 5 years, that way the odds are high that all parts survive for the required 3 months. It also means that odds are reasonable the rover will work for much longer than 3 months, and in many cases you can operate in a degraded state for a even longer.
- bnralt 4y ago> almost all of these Mars robots seem to do useful science well beyond the end of the stated mission How are we defining "useful science" here? They all do some kind of scientific investigations, but it's hard to say if it's useful or not. If you look at coverage or discussions about the lander (including here), people get very excited about the landings, and somewhat excited about the pictures. The science almost never gets discussed. Even when NASA tries to hype it up, it seems the most important stuff they have is continually telling us they found Mars has some water and used to be wet, and that there's the possibility there once was life on Mars. People seem enamored with the idea that we're sending things to Mars and doing "something." But there doesn't seem to be a lot of concern about what that "something" actually is.
- hawski 4y agoI am sure it comes down to economics really, but I do wonder now about a mission in far future, that would clean solar panels of all those older missions to make them work again. For shits and giggles I guess.
- phone8675309 4y agoIIRC this was a plot point in The Martian
- hawski 4y agoOh, yes indeed. I forgot about that.
- danw1979 4y agoLike a long range Ingenuity helicopter that cruised the planet using its downwash to revive old rovers ?
- phpnode 4y agoThis idea gets brought up in every thread about Insight's dust issues - there is not enough air pressure on Mars for the downwash to clean the panels. For Ingenuity specifically the problem is that it is also far too far away - it would take over ten years for the chopper to reach Insight.
- dwringer 4y agoAfter a few months I can't even blow all the dust off surfaces in my apartment. I can only imagine years outside on Mars.
- timdiggerm 4y agoDon't underestimate the size of a planet
- bluGill 4y agoIt might be fun to try, but realistically, without heat, thermo issues will ensure that even if you did this the rovers wouldn't work anymore.
- jvanderbot 4y agoDust is a factor, but so is cold and diminishing solar. My guess is that the dust isnt a problem until late in the season, and by then they hope to have gotten all the data they came for. IIRC, one of the reasons the MER rovers lasted so much longer is the dust clearance from wind, which was much more than expected. Perhaps Insight counted on more clearing than they got. I'd just go ask their Project Scientist on Twitter. @MarkPanning
- yummypaint 4y agoI once (around 2010) worked with a nasa designed system for electrically clearing solar panels. It was basically a 3-phase arrangement of transparent indium tin oxide electrodes on the surface of the panels. By supplying high voltage AC, both conductive and insulating particles can be removed by various mechanisms. I thought it worked quite well and keep expecting to see it in the wild somewhere. Maybe it's still in the pipeline somewhere.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- theandrewbailey 4y agoSpirit and Opportunity lasted for much longer (6 and 14 years, respectively), aided by periodic winds that blew dust off the solar panels. It appears that Insight's location doesn't receive many of these compared to others. https://www.sciencealert.com/nasa-s-insight-lander-enters-hibernation-as-dust-puts-it-at-risk-of-an-energy-crisis https://www.sciencealert.com/nasa-s-insight-lander-enters-hi...
- grawp 4y agoSpirit and Opportunity were rovers and constantly changing place and position. Insight is NOT a rover. It is an unmovable lander.
- arriu 4y agoSame reason the rockets NASA uses are not reusable. It’s not part of the mission. Yes, it’s short sighted but unfortunately a result of extreme budget constraints.
- mhb 4y agoOliver Wendell Holmes can (http://holyjoe.org/poetry/holmes1.htm http://holyjoe.org/poetry/holmes1.htm): The Deacon’s Masterpiece or, the Wonderful "One-hoss Shay": A Logical Story Have you heard of the wonderful one-hoss shay, That was built in such a logical way It ran a hundred years to a day, And then, of a sudden, it — ah, but stay, I’ll tell you what happened without delay, Scaring the parson into fits, Frightening people out of their wits, — Have you ever heard of that, I say? Seventeen hundred and fifty-five. Georgius Secundus was then alive, — Snuffy old drone from the German hive. That was the year when Lisbon-town Saw the earth open and gulp her down, And Braddock’s army was done so brown, Left without a scalp to its crown. It was on the terrible Earthquake-day That the Deacon finished the one-hoss shay. Now in building of chaises, I tell you what, There is always somewhere a weakest spot, — In hub, tire, felloe, in spring or thill, In panel, or crossbar, or floor, or sill, In screw, bolt, thoroughbrace, — lurking still, Find it somewhere you must and will, — Above or below, or within or without, — And that’s the reason, beyond a doubt, A chaise breaks down, but doesn’t wear out. But the Deacon swore (as Deacons do, With an “I dew vum,” or an “I tell yeou”) He would build one shay to beat the taown ’N’ the keounty ’n’ all the kentry raoun’; It should be so built that it couldn’ break daown: “Fur,” said the Deacon, “’tis mighty plain Thut the weakes’ place mus’ stan’ the strain; ’N’ the way t’ fix it, uz I maintain, Is only jest T’ make that place uz strong uz the rest.” So the Deacon inquired of the village folk Where he could find the strongest oak, That couldn’t be split nor bent nor broke, — That was for spokes and floor and sills; He sent for lancewood to make the thills; The crossbars were ash, from the straightest trees, The panels of white-wood, that cuts like cheese, But lasts like iron for things like these; The hubs of logs from the “Settler’s ellum,” — Last of its timber, — they couldn’t sell ’em, Never an axe had seen their chips, And the wedges flew from between their lips, Their blunt ends frizzled like celery-tips; Step and prop-iron, bolt and screw, Spring, tire, axle, and linchpin too, Steel of the finest, bright and blue; Thoroughbrace bison-skin, thick and wide; Boot, top, dasher, from tough old hide Found in the pit when the tanner died. That was the way he “put her through.” “There!” said the Deacon, “naow she’ll dew!” Do! I tell you, I rather guess She was a wonder, and nothing less! Colts grew horses, beards turned gray, Deacon and deaconess dropped away, Children and grandchildren — where were they? But there stood the stout old one-hoss shay As fresh as on Lisbon-earthquake-day! EIGHTEEN HUNDRED; — it came and found The Deacon’s masterpiece strong and sound. Eighteen hundred increased by ten; — “Hahnsum kerridge” they called it then. Eighteen hundred and twenty came; — Running as usual; much the same. Thirty and forty at last arrive, And then come fifty, and FIFTY-FIVE. Little of all we value here Wakes on the morn of its hundreth year Without both feeling and looking queer. In fact, there’s nothing that keeps its youth, So far as I know, but a tree and truth. (This is a moral that runs at large; Take it. — You’re welcome. — No extra charge.) FIRST OF NOVEMBER, — the Earthquake-day, — There are traces of age in the one-hoss shay, A general flavor of mild decay, But nothing local, as one may say. There couldn’t be, — for the Deacon’s art Had made it so like in every part That there wasn’t a chance for one to start. For the wheels were just as strong as the thills, And the floor was just as strong as the sills, And the panels just as strong as the floor, And the whipple-tree neither less nor more, And the back crossbar as strong as the fore, And spring and axle and hub encore. And yet, as a whole, it is past a doubt In another hour it will be worn out! First of November, ’Fifty-five! This morning the parson takes a drive. Now, small boys, get out of the way! Here comes the wonderful one-hoss shay, Drawn by a rat-tailed, ewe-necked bay. “Huddup!” said the parson. — Off went they. The parson was working his Sunday’s text, — Had got to fifthly, and stopped perplexed At what the — Moses — was coming next. All at once the horse stood still, Close by the meet’n’-house on the hill. First a shiver, and then a thrill, Then something decidedly like a spill, — And the parson was sitting upon a rock, At half past nine by the meet’n-house clock, — Just the hour of the Earthquake shock! What do you think the parson found, When he got up and stared around? The poor old chaise in a heap or mound, As if it had been to the mill and ground! You see, of course, if you’re not a dunce, How it went to pieces all at once, — All at once, and nothing first, — Just as bubbles do when they burst. End of the wonderful one-hoss shay. Logic is logic. That’s all I say.
- idlewords 4y agoThey gave Curiosity and Perserverance a plutonium power source to avoid this issue. My experience with "why don't they just X" for space stuff is that there's almost always a technical paper on it. This looks like a comprehensive review of different approaches to cleaning solar panels on rovers: "Cleaning Mechanisms for Solar Panels of Rovers and Other Extraterrestrial Unmanned Vehicles" https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2019-3452 https://doi.org/10.2514/6.2019-3452
- Baeocystin 4y agoIt costs a lot of time and money simply to keep a mission operating, and these are scarce resources that need to be used for every active mission, old or new. Missions are thus planned for very specific lifetimes. On an organizational level, missions that live too long past their due date cause a lot of problems, too. This isn't cynicism- it's just the reality of trying to absolutely maximize the science return per scarce dollar spent. I personally would love it if ultimate lifespan was a feasible goal for every mission. So would pretty much everyone! But it isn't.
- thathndude 4y agoI know these are inanimate objects and we shouldn’t humanize them. Blame XKCD, I suppose. But I feel a connection to these robots, and I pray that one day we can go to Mars and erect them a place of honor or bring them “home” to a Smithsonian. They are a testament to the best of our space programs and the men and women who work in them. It’s amazing how well some of these machines overperformed.
- ape4 4y agoAnd Wall-E https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0910970/ https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0910970/
- jcims 4y agoI fully expect to see one of the rovers to be at the Smithsonian before I die, and I’m almost 50 sooo chop chop!
- intrasight 4y agoBut I expect that Musk will keep it in his private collection ;)
- Avshalom 4y ago>>we shouldn’t humanize them Nah, our ability and willingness to develop empathy and emotional connections to dogs, bugs, robots, small rocks... It's one of our best traits.
- armatav 4y agoYup - big part of what makes us human
- penguin_booze 4y agoI was suddenly reminded of Alex the African Gray Parrot's dying words: "You Be Good, See You Tomorrow. I Love You". https://www.wired.com/2007/09/super-smart-par/ https://www.wired.com/2007/09/super-smart-par/
- user3939382 4y agoAs a programmer my first thought reading this was: If I was designing a program to send me back a message and it was super critical I received it, I wouldn't put any quotes or non-alphanumerics in the message. Even if my string handling checks out, if the stakes are sufficiently high, I don't trust em!
- ackbar03 4y ago"Say again? You're dropping out, my battery is low Just so you know, we're going to a place nearby Gotta go!" - Mars rover
- bluGill 4y agoIf I was designing such a message I'd make sure there is a lot of redundancy in the message so even if I only received part of it I could figure out what it was. Adding quotes and other non-alphanumerics can add more clues that make the message unique enough to identify it even when significant amounts of the data are lost in transmission.
- user3939382 4y agoWe have really sophisticated, formal strategies for that purpose: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Error_detection_and_correction#Deep-space_telecommunications https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Error_detection_and_correction... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Error_correction_code https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Error_correction_code
- mosburger 4y agoYep, I worked in the disk drive industry over twenty years ago, and I was surprised to learn that a lot of what we read off the disk is actually wrong! If not for a lot of generous error correction they'd've been pretty unusable.
- CWuestefeld 4y agoI thought it was pretty annoying that the communications are put forth here as if the lander is an animate thing engaging in conversation with us. Perhaps one day we'll achieve something like that. Heck, maybe we'll send up the grandchild of ChatGPT to be the voice of a future exploration probe. But that's not what we have today. These messages were coded by the engineers who built the thing, and any implication of sentiment is bogus.
- simonswords82 4y agoInteresting thread on why it's not possible for the solar panels to be self cleaned: https://twitter.com/NASAInSight/status/1590736220199735296?cxt=HHwWgMDShcGKt5MsAAAA https://twitter.com/NASAInSight/status/1590736220199735296?c...
- prettyStandard 4y agoThey would rather contribute that cost&weight&complexity to just more solar cells. Got it.
- logicallee 4y agoAfter reading your note "why it's not possible for the solar panels to be self cleaned" I clicked through and as I clicked I was thinking "okay so obviously it is possible for the solar panels to self-clean. prove me wrong." I mean how hard could it be? No way is that an "impossible" task. I went out of it thinking, "yep, look at these excuses we are making for the state of robotics." - the quote is: "A system like that would have added cost, mass, and complexity. The simplest, most cost-effective way to meet my goals was to bring solar panels big enough to power my whole mission – which they did (and then some!)." So robotics is at the state where it is possible to send a rover to Mars, but a simple robotic arm can't easily brush off some dirt. The lander weighs 789 lb and the cost-effective solution is not try include a simple cheap lightweight robot arm that is foolproof and can easily sweep some dirt, because there is not such thing. Robotics isn't at the level where that is easy, cheap, or lightweight. If a human could reach through a portal to there with a brush, it would take less than five minutes to brush off the dirt that had fallen on solar cells. A simple, light, and foolproof robotic arm that can easily do that doesn't exist. Now that we have superhuman levels of general AI in chatgpt, isn't it time to work on foolproof and lightweight robot arms for all sorts of tasks?
- gpderetta 4y ago"A high resolution picture of the Insight Mars Rover on mars, with a simple, light weight and foolproof robotic arm brushing sand off its solar panels, in the style of Greg Rutkowski and Alphonse Mucha, 4k, trending on artstation"
- imhoguy 4y agoCouldn't it stay somehow hibernated until it collects enough sunrays to reconnect in the future? I see the dust cover on photos is really thick, but just hypothetically would it be even possible for probe to be dormant for years and then reactivated?
- MRtecno98 4y agoEven doing nothing but collecting energy the probe needs to consume some power to e.g. keep the batteries at not cryogenic temperatures, so if the panels' energy output goes below this minimum the probe can't really shut down itself without damaging its internals
- _joel 4y agoSo long Insight! Pleasure having some flash memory that was sent with you, there's a few bytes that have my name in it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- okdood64 4y agoGreat video about Insight, the technical challenges, and findings from it: https://youtu.be/LmkRrtfY6VI https://youtu.be/LmkRrtfY6VI
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ColinWright 4y agoObligatory XKCD: https://xkcd.com/695/ https://xkcd.com/695/
- DrThunder 4y ago
- slowhand09 4y agoRelevant. https://xkcd.com/695/ https://xkcd.com/695/
- BrandoElFollito 4y agoI hate this particular strip (not xkcd of course (which is 60% of the time wonderful) but this specific one). It anthropomorphises the Rover and we have enough sad news from all over the place to also start to worry about that machine (not even an AI). The next one will be Voyager who is all alone in empty space or whatnot. It is enough that I speak to my computer already.
- slowhand09 4y agoAre you old enough to remember "Star Trek: The Motion Picture"? Voyager is a major character. In 1979... way before the internet.
- kirubakaran 4y agoAlternate ending https://i.imgur.com/VbKV9DF.jpeg https://i.imgur.com/VbKV9DF.jpeg
- pestatije 4y agoLet Ingenuity fly over it and dust off those panels!
- BooneJS 4y agoInsight and its crew were awesome. I’m anthropomorphizing Insight as Wall-E, diligently fulfilling its mission even as disaster nears.
- AlbertCory 4y agoThis reminds me of the movie Good Night, Oppy This was a surprisingly touching movie about the Opportunity rover. Yes, it's sentimental, and yes, the NASA crew do call it "her." And yes, the rover does remind you of Wall-E. Still, it's a good flick to watch with the family.
- devsploit 4y agoI suppose this is kind of a trivial question, but does anyone know if the last message was ACTUALLY the STRING: “My power’s really low. Don’t worry about me though…”, or was it some binary/hex code to represent that, like, "503 ERROR", and the PR department just tweeted its interpretation as “My power’s really low. Don’t worry about me though…”? It raises more questions. Was this logging message decided by committee or a PM? Was it a dev easter egg? Do they have a writer? Also, what conditions would trigger this "final" message? Being a lesser engineer, my stuff just crashes unceremoniously and usually I am alerted not by a sweet note from my prod servers "Hey, looks like prod's going down, don't worry about me, though...", it's usually concerned phone call from a manager.
- dbg31415 4y agoMy guess is that it's PR baked into the software -- at least the receiver software. It was a line written by someone who understood that just an error code is really bad for humans to read. So they humanized it a bit. They had time to plan this, not like they didn't know this was the likely outcome. Good product management to give the robot a voice.
- rob74 4y ago> They had time to plan this, not like they didn't know this was the likely outcome. Like the newspapers have obituaries for most important personalities prepared (and sometimes publish them prematurely)?
- pwisswordfish99 4y agoI’m especially curious whether it actually used the apostrophe, but I suppose the lander itself just sends its usual vitals and the first-person tweets are done by an on-world PR department.
- sam0x17 4y agoProbably some bytecode representing an RPC enum variant
- 4y ago
- dctoedt 4y agoUpdate: NASA has declared the mission over because InSight didn't respond to two successive contact requests. https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-retires-insight-mars-lander-mission-after-years-of-science https://www.nasa.gov/press-release/nasa-retires-insight-mars... https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/houston-texas/space/article/NASA-InSight-lander-Mars-mission-ends-17669452.php?utm_source=marketing&utm_medium=copy-url-link&utm_campaign=article-share&hash=aHR0cHM6Ly93d3cuaG91c3RvbmNocm9uaWNsZS5jb20vbmV3cy9ob3VzdG9uLXRleGFzL3NwYWNlL2FydGljbGUvTkFTQS1JblNpZ2h0LWxhbmRlci1NYXJzLW1pc3Npb24tZW5kcy0xNzY2OTQ1Mi5waHA=&time=MTY3MTY1NjEwOTYyNA==&rid=Nzc5ZjczYmYtZjIwZi00OWRkLTgyN2MtMmM3NjkyZTQ5NTFj&sharecount=Mg== https://www.houstonchronicle.com/news/houston-texas/space/ar...
- Eleison23 4y ago
- kaon123 4y agoOpportunity sent a similar message. Someone on youtube made a phenomenal short video about its life. It is one of my favorite youtube videos ever: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FJH9GobEFUk&ab_channel=melodysheep https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FJH9GobEFUk&ab_channel=melod...