11 ms·
I have really mixed feelings about this. From an open source and general fairness perspective, I would really like to have a true Firefox on iOS but I'm also co
by acdha 4y ago
I have really mixed feelings about this. From an open source and general fairness perspective, I would really like to have a true Firefox on iOS but I'm also cognizant of the fact that iOS' browser restriction is basically the only reason why “web” is not a synonym for “whatever the Google Chrome team chooses to ship”.
It feels like this would be best if paired with some regulatory pressure banning cross-promotion of Chrome on Google properties and requiring Google to actually do QA rather than accidentally breaking YouTube, Gmail, Google Cloud, etc. for users other browsers. For all of the “Safari is the new IE6” memes posted, I have far more frequently encountered cases where a Google web application is doing something which only works in Chrome but there is no technical why it could not work just as well in any other modern browser engine.
- smoldesu 4y agoWell, two wrongs didn't make this a right. If Chrome does use this as a power grab, then we should expect EU injunction again.
- acdha 4y ago> Well, two wrongs didn't make this a right. That was basically my point? > If Chrome does use this as a power grab, then we should expect EU injunction again. Since this is behaviour Google is already doing and has been doing for a decade, it seems like the EU could just skip to the part of actually doing something.
- smoldesu 4y ago> Since this is behaviour Google is already doing How so? There are a number of features Apple dragged their feet on (WebRTC, push notifications, WebM support, AV1, the list goes on), it could be argued that Apple was intentionally stifling the capabilities of the browser to enforce the profitability of the App Store. I understand your concern, but Apple's failure to compete with Google is not Google's fault. Apple had a chance to make a browser that Chrome users switched to, but they didn't. Chrome's market share destroys every Webkit-based browser combined. Regulators can't see into the future. Thus-far, Chrome's behavior might be frustrating but totally fair game relative to the way Apple plays. Once Safari is competing on it's own merits, we'll see how things go and respond accordingly. If it's anything like the App Store, it'll take us ~8 years to observe the abuse and respond effectively.
- Terretta 4y agoIncidentally, many of these "features" came about from Google trying to create moats or cut out competitors. Further, Chrome is a dog on Apple Macs, cuts battery life to a fraction, plus brings a host of invasive and compromising behaviors. In general Google has made no attempt for their browser to be competitive on feature dimensions that matter to many Apple hardware buyers; their share remains driven by residual tech influencer group-think still left over from the IE wars more than the value of, say, WebM over x265. (See also Duck Trumotion and Widevine for more of Google's motivation.) The profitability motive is false, see Steam charging the same 30% despite e.g. Gog or Microsoft store. This is inconvenient for those making the argument Apple's fee is out of line. > Chrome's market share destroys every Webkit-based browser combined. Clearly they need more help with this. Glad EU is looking out for them.
- smoldesu 4y agoSounds like it sucks, then. If things are as bad as you say, then we have nothing to worry about because everyone will want to use Apple's browser. I'll let all the Linux guys know, and I'm certain they'll switch to WebKit right away. > The profitability motive is false, see Steam charging the same 30% despite e.g. Gog or Microsoft store. No, it's pretty substantial. The App Store made 80 billion USD last year, which was one of their only businesses that approached hardware profitability. Ensuring that nobody can eschew Apple's software control is completely their directive. If Apple did become more like Steam (eg. had other software stores to compete with) things would be pretty fair I'd argue. > Clearly they need more help with this. Glad EU is looking out for them. Apparently Chrome is borderline-unusable on Apple products anyways, so Apple has nothing to worry about.
- yamtaddle 4y agoNormal users install the browser Google advertises at them constantly on all Google's websites, then complain that Apple sucks because their laptop's battery went from a reliably 12 hours of life to 7 hours and also the fans kick on all the time now, but they have no idea why that's happening unless they happen to bring this up with some computer nerd in their life and the nerd explains what's going on.
- flohofwoe 4y agoIt's not like the EU is turning a blind eye towards Google (e.g. https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-62888137 https://www.bbc.com/news/technology-62888137)
- nemothekid 4y ago>If Chrome does use this as a power grab, then we should expect EU injunction again. I'm not sure what the EU could do here; it's not like Chrome is coming pre-installed on iPhones or on Windows. Can the EU breakup Google?
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y ago> it's not like Chrome is coming pre-installed on iPhones or on Windows It comes pre-installed on Android; isn't that enough?
- smoldesu 4y agoIt would almost be an exploitative situation, if they didn't let you freely choose which browser engine you run.
- ThatPlayer 4y agoThat already got in trouble them for requiring Android phone manufacturers to include it: https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_18_4581 https://ec.europa.eu/commission/presscorner/detail/en/IP_18_... Nowadays I believe Samsung at least has their own Samsung Browser, so that's already a large chunk of Android phones that don't have Chrome default.
- bioemerl 4y agoSafari doesn't help the web be diverse, it just cripples the webs ability to compete with apps. When is the last time you said "I will choose to use safari" or seen apple pushing the bounds of what the web can do?
- dopidopHN 4y agoAt some point the battery usage on laptop was considerably better using safari. That’s a plus.
- threeseed 4y agoMany Mac users choose to use Safari because it is by far the most efficient browser.
- apaprocki 4y agoYes. I have used every way to consume the web since text-only was preferred in early lynx days and finding gopher resources was the norm. NSCA Mosaic, Netscape Navigator, all IE versions, Firefox, Chrome when it first appeared. I want nothing more to only use Safari / OS WebKit on all my devices. If this winds up going through, I will actively delete all applications that switch off WebKit. To each their own...
- bioemerl 4y agoI'm very skeptical this is due to safari and not Microsoft style monopolistic behavior by baking the browser into the OS so it's always loaded.
- threeseed 4y agoNo it's simply due to priorities. Apple has always placed privacy and efficiency over new features.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nicoburns 4y ago> I would really like to have a true Firefox on iOS but I'm also cognizant of the fact that iOS' browser restriction is basically the only reason why “web” is not a synonym for “whatever the Google Chrome team chooses to ship”. I feel like Firefox might actually regain marketshare if it can ship on iOS. Firefox on Android has a decent claim to be being better than Chrome at this point (largely because you can't run extensions on Chrome).
- yjftsjthsd-h 4y ago> I feel like Firefox might actually regain marketshare if it can ship on iOS. Firefox on Android has a decent claim to be being better than Chrome at this point (largely because you can't run extensions on Chrome). Firefox is better than Chrome on Android, but it doesn't have the market share to match.
- spijdar 4y agoI know this probably won't be a popular opinion, but I have to disagree with this. I use Firefox on all my "general purpose" computing devices, but I only use Firefox on Android for recalling the passwords I have saved on my Firefox/Mozilla account. For any day-to-day browsing, I use Brave with the cryptocurrency bits turned off. I used the "Fennec" version of Firefox for Android for years, since my first smartphone in college, but by the time the GeckoView-based rewrite was released, I just got tired of the poor performance and reduced battery life compared to Chromium. Only one anecdote, but Firefox felt more jittery and made my phone much hotter than Chromium did. After the UI overhaul, where (IMO) they tried to copy a Chromium-style interface, I ran out of any non-ideological reasons to use it over Chromium-with-an-ad-blocker-built-in.
- dutchCourage 4y agoUnfortunately I have a similar experience with FF on Android. A more jittery experience and a bigger batter drain than Chrome, even without any extensions installed. I'll plug my main mobile browser which is now Samsung's internet. I gave it a hesitant try after being disappointed by FF and I'm positively surprised. The UI customization options are even better than Firefox.
- VWWHFSfQ 4y agoSafari is pretty much the worst browser in existence. Basic technology like webrtc is absolutely riddled with bugs. It's so bad that most video chat services don't even support it.
- blowski 4y ago> It's [Safari] so bad that most video chat services don't even support it. Which ones? I've used Zoom, Meet, Teams, and Whereby in Safari with no problems. I've never encountered a video service _not_ work in it.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI was just on Teams and Webex video calls using Safari.
- kitsunesoba 4y agoGoogle Meet works fine in Safari too. Better even, since there it uses hardware accelerated video encoding unlike in Chrome.
- selykg 4y agoOn Mac, Safari is the only browser to respect battery drain and preserve power in any real meaningful way. I'll take some bugs for that win. I use Chrome or Firefox and my battery noticeably dies faster.
- acdha 4y ago> It's so bad that most video chat services don't even support it. All of the major services support it and the only one which I’ve ever had problems with is Google’s, which shockingly had issues with every browser other than Chrome. Do you have links to bug reports? I switched to Safari primarily a while back because it used the least battery and memory (Safari & Firefox were close, Chrome is a distant gluttonous third place). I’ve noticed very, very few cases where a compatibility issue forced me to switch browsers. As a web developer I use all three, of course, and using Chrome doesn’t feel notably better so halving my energy usage is an easy trade.
- kernal 4y agoSo it's okay for Apple to have a monopoly on their OS, but we need to knee cap anyone that tries to challenge them with competing apps.
- acdha 4y agoI hope you aren't trying to say that's what I wrote? My position is that if we're doing consumer choice, we should do it all the way: iOS is required to allow other browser engines (with any security requirements applied evenly); Google is not allowed to use unrelated business units to advertise Chrome in ways which Apple, Microsoft, or Mozilla cannot; and Google is required to test their applications in other browsers and promptly fix compatibility issues which are not due to a browser not implementing an approved W3C/WHATWG standard[1]. 1. I mention “approved” because of things like the way YouTube used to be faster in Chrome because they shipped a draft of the Shadow DOM API and then took a long time updating to use the standard version which other browsers implemented, during which time those other browsers were served a slow polyfill instead. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17606027 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=17606027
- Qahlel 4y agoSafari and Chrome have the exact same goals as they are maternal twins. They are both designed to monopolize their ecosystem and suppress the competition. Firefox is the odd one out.
- kevingadd 4y agoI think if Firefox had been allowed onto the iOS store much earlier (they had ports done and working at multiple points in history) it might have helped them fight off Chrome and slow the growth of the Chromium monopoly, but at this point it's not clear to me how you fix it. I'd still be happy to be able to use Firefox on an iPhone but Firefox's days as a usable browser are numbered in general, so at some point I'd be stuck going back to Safari on that device. I increasingly have to open up Edge to do basic stuff because people have stopped testing on anything other than Chrome and the set of Chrome-only APIs out there to use is constantly expanding.
- cal85 4y agoI agree that iOS Safari's popularity is the only thing currently keeping the web an open market. But I'm not too concerned that this move will break that situation. Most iPhone users just use the stock browser and don't know or care what rendering engine it is. Maybe Chrome for iOS gets a bit better due to this change, attracting a few more users, but I can't see it changing the numbers much.
- blibble 4y ago> Most iPhone users just use the stock browser and don't know or care what rendering engine it is. Google will likely turn on the popups with "BETTER ON CHROME! TRY CHROME NOW!" for ios users once it's possible
- acdha 4y agoHow'd that work for Microsoft Edge? Firefox usage tanked when Google started heavily promoting Chrome on search, Gmail, Youtube, Docs, etc. and I would be shocked if this went through and every Google app didn't start telling people that they should install Chrome or certain features were being held back for Chrome users.
- someNameIG 4y agoIirc on macOS Safari is still the most popular, with over 50% using it. It's no where near as dominant as Safari is on iOS but significantly more than Edge is on Windows. I like Safari too, so even with this change I'll keep using it on my Apple devices.
- cal85 4y agoI'm confused, how does this move affect Google's ability to promote their own iOS Chrome app to Safari iOS users? They already have that ability.
- acdha 4y agoChrome on iOS uses the same WebKit engine as Safari. Right now, if someone at Google wants to ship a web API they need to work with Apple and, to a lesser extent, Mozilla to implement it. If they could tell people to use Blink on iOS, they'd have the ability to ship the update and blow off attempts to change the code in the standardization process or even standardize at all because 95% of their users would be running code which they can arbitrarily update.
- ginko 4y agoCouldn't Apple just have had a "no Chrome" policy. No one cares about that browser but I'd really like to have Firefox.
- sangnoir 4y ago> I'm also cognizant of the fact that iOS' browser restriction is basically the only reason why “web” is not a synonym for “whatever the Google Chrome team chooses to ship”. May you explain this, because Google can't even ship their browser engine (Blink) on iOS and have to use WebKit. Why hasn't the world coalesced around WebKit?
- acdha 4y agoLook everywhere else: heavy promotion on some of the most popular web properties in the world (Google Search, Gmail, YouTube, etc.) has put Firefox into a death-spiral and Microsoft gave up on their own engine in favor of a Chrome derivative. There is little reason to believe that the same would not be true on iOS were it possible for Google to get users to switch. I think that matters because while Chrome has a number of great engineers, it's a single team at one company and the web should be bigger than that. We've seen many examples of a Google-proposed spec which became better with feedback from Mozilla or Apple engineers, and that makes the web healthier overall. One really interesting example here has been with tracking where every browser which Google does not control has a better privacy stance because none of those companies make their money by tracking people.
- dblohm7 4y ago> Why hasn't the world coalesced around WebKit? iOS is not the entire ecosystem. Blink dominates everywhere else.
- sangnoir 4y agoSo iOS' webkit-only restriction is not the reason why Chrome is dominant, right? I was trying to follow gp's logic and failing
- cpcallen 4y agoI have mixed feelings too, but for slightly different reasons: AFAICT Chrome is a power grab in the literal sense that (on macOS) it drains my battery a lot faster than Safari does, for equivalent use. Not great, but bearable on a laptop; on a phone, however, that's a critical issue. So at least in that respect it has been in the users' best interests to oblige developers to use the most power-efficient browser engine.
- trap_goes_hot 4y agoChrome is basically a keylogger for Google. There is an argument to be made that AV/Malware software should fingerprint it as such.
- acdha 4y agoNo. They’re slow to shut down ad tracking but that’s a very different thing and there’s no evidence even remotely supporting your claim.
- trap_goes_hot 4y agoChrome records everything you type in the address bar, everything you type in a textbox/form, every website you visit, everything you downloaded, button clicks, which ads you interact with, etc, etc. If any other software did that, it would be called a keylogger and malware. I wouldn't defend Google on privacy matters, but okay its your choice.