11 ms·
Why hasn’t technology disrupted higher education already?
- spicyusername 4y agoPretty much every industry that modern technology companies "disrupt" is made worse for it. Maybe we should start reconceptualizing technology's role in modern society.
- kennedywm 4y agoHard to replace traditional education's role as a class differentiator.
- zarkov99 4y agoThat is exactly right. In terms of knowledge acquisition the disruption has occurred. Any motivated young person can get a world class education free of charge, without ever stepping into an ivy. But it turns out the main purpose of college is to sort people not educate them and we are only now realizing that.
- 8f2ab37a-ed6c 4y agoExactly. This sort of post comes up on HN at least once a month. Higher ed is a positional good. You can watch MIT lectures, go to your local library, read blog posts, listen to podcasts, read open source. It's all free. But it won't give you that scarce resource of brand affiliation on your resume no matter how hard you try. Whatever you learn is only one of the many components of the total package.
- throw6383878 4y agoEnrollment is tanking! It did disrupted it, just not in very measurable way! Just the fact people are discussing and questioning value of higher education on social networks, means there is so e disruption! And YouTube is far better than bored and underpaid postdoc!
- kennedywm 4y agoMaybe, though I'd guess it has more to do with the realization that the debt isn't worth degree in many cases is starting to sink in.
- miguelazo 4y agoEnrollment is tanking because of the cost benefit analysis. States underfunded education for a generation so that Boomers could have lower income taxes, passed along the costs to students, and their incomes can’t possibly make up for the debt in a timely manner.
- DrStartup 4y agoCredentials
- hammock 4y agoThis. More specifically, if a school isn't accredited, you can't get government financial aid to go there
- aurelianito 4y agoI think that the parent says that while you can learn almost anything from youtube, it is imposible for other people to know that you know something you learned on youtube without a test.
- kennedywm 4y agoFunny enough, it's impossible for people to know what you've learned and retained at University without a test. They're more willing to assume that you have though.
- twobitshifter 4y agoCredentials can be tested for through examination & licensing.
- kamphey 4y agoTechnology could very well disrupt higher education, but not completely tear it down. Just like Airbnb disrupts hotels but Hotels still exist and are doing better now than ever. What the future of education looks like is a lot more fractured than we can see in the past. We might think of "higher education" as just a college/university, but in reality there are already alternative forms of higher education and those will continue to be added to. Sure MooC's seemed like scams, but some MooC's allow a huge scale of knowledge transfer. And some Cohort Based Courses as well, now. I like how Maven talks about courses as "transformational" and not just "knowledge transfer". I'm looking forward to more and more types of higher education in the near future. Retreats, Online-Only, Hybrid, etc.
- thwayunion 4y agoI don't think anyone ever thought they sounded like scams. At least, I didn't. They just weren't viable replacements for a traditional degree program. Which is fine, as long as you're not a VC losing your LP's money on something that anyone who has taught a few times know won't scale :)
- hammock 4y agoWe've already gone through an entire cycle of technology-driven higher education disruption... ever heard of an online degree? Many such online schools have made billions and lost it again by now. Separately, the accreditation scheme upholds a high barrier to entry for disruptors. Specifically, a school must be accredited (gatekept by the US Ed Dept) for matriculating students to be eligible for government financial aid.
- nradov 4y agoIs the accreditation scheme really a high barrier to entry? Several new institutions of higher education have gained accreditation in recent years. There is some paperwork and hassle involved, but we've got to have quality control to prevent scammers from taking advantage of students and taxpayers. Accreditation doesn't prevent schools from adopting disruptive technologies.
- Turing_Machine 4y ago> There is some paperwork and hassle involved There is a LOT of paperwork and hassle involved. Also years of time. It's enough of a hassle that some new institutions have found it worth their while to buy out a bankrupt school that already has accreditation rather than starting the process from scratch.
- clintonb 4y ago> There is some paperwork and hassle involved... Tell me you've never looked into tried to get a school accredited without telling me. /s Accreditation is a multi-year effort, and institutions do not necessarily receive accreditation on their first attempt. > Accreditation doesn't prevent schools from adopting disruptive technologies. Disruptive technologies don't matter if the market doesn't believe your degree is worth the paper it's printed on. If your school is not accredited, students may find it difficult to transfer credits or apply to graduate programs. Additionally, students cannot use federal aid—grants or loans—for non-accredited programs. > Is the accreditation scheme really a high barrier to entry? Yes. Yes, it is.
- rahimnathwani 4y ago
- seb1204 4y agoBecause governments make the rules about education and the curriculum. Give is slow and typ not at the tip of development. At the same time they need to get the trust and support of parents who all think they know better.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoPerhaps it demonstrates that very few people can learn abstract topics such as math, physics, etc., without some degree of hand-holding?
- d_sem 4y agoWe haven't quite cracked the nuance of programming human biological systems. Anecdotally, the stay-at-home learning during the pandemic was proof we have a long ways to go.
- randomdata 4y agoIt has. Decades ago. But this is kind of like asking why people still ride horses when we have cars.
- BMc2020 4y agoHas any country found a better way?
- miguelazo 4y agoI think most other countries don’t think there’s a problem. Because their college educations don’t cost several years of annual income, compounded at interest rates double what a car loan used to go for.
- giaour 4y agoEven in countries where college is free, students do typically give up several years worth of annual income in opportunity costs
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoYou're presenting an entirely new assumption, compared to what most people are discussing: that obtaining a bachelor's degree equivalent education can be done in significantly less than 4 years of full time study. In my experience, I don't believe that to be the case.
- giaour 4y agoYou're inferring that; I was referring to the income you can make in blue collar work. There are jobs that do not require a bachelor's degree equivalent education. Many young adults drop out of college (or never start) in order to take such a job.
- pcurve 4y agoThe article's title is a rhetorical question with answer that ends in: "Motivation and self-discipline are valuable commodities, and an in-person instructor can help provide them."
- miguelazo 4y agoAmong other things. Like being able to clarify things immediately and succinctly instead of having to open yet another tab that turns into a rabbit hole distraction.
- entropy2048 4y agoIn many cases, I'd agree. However, with anything that remotely smells like it's close to the technology field? Any clarification you might get, is probably 10 years out of date. At best.
- miguelazo 4y agoWhat's actually important to learn in the technology field wouldn't matter if it were 10 years behind. We're talking about higher education-- the fundamentals, not learning the syntax of some particular framework that will no longer be used in 10 years, if 5.
- jncraton 4y agoI believe clarifying things immediately and succinctly may be why the author mentioned LLMs. They have the potential to provide this sort of feedback. They are obviously imperfect, but for the sort of questions that many undergraduates get stuck on (code won't compile due to a missing semicolon, etc) they are already a great asset.
- etempleton 4y agoExactly. Graduating college proves a level of diligence more so than intelligence or knowledge. This is undervalued. Many of the smartest coworkers I have worked with were the worst colleagues. Intelligence and knowledge is only so valuable if hard work and interpersonal skills are absent.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- marmetio 4y agoI don't see how the in-person lecturer is the same as the personal trainer. The lecturer doesn't interact with you any more than a video (less, considering you can't rewind). Only the individual instruction pushes you.
- WheelsAtLarge 4y agoHigher education has as much to do with prestige as the education itself. Getting an online education is equivalent to saying you got a diploma through the mail. Maybe it's valid or maybe it's a diploma mill. You can't be sure. There's nothing equivalent to saying you graduated from an ivy school or such. Online education is making a dent. Some prestigious universities have an online curriculum and are awarding diplomas that can't be distinguished from a on-campus diplomas but they are the minority by far. The way I see it. Online education should be a game changer in 3rd world countries. Yet, it doesn't seem to be. It looks like it really does come down to motivation and your ability to push your way through the classes.
- unicornhose 4y agoMany parts of the elephant: no motivation to work on hard things without friends, professors, campus, well-paying jobs, and high-status contacts. Would be interesting to see MOOCs on daily stuff: cooking, gardening, cleaning & organizing, style, hospitality. Or MOOCs around hobbies: amateur radio, photography, sketching, watercolor, dance, music. Here there’s potential for the tech to meet users halfway.
- giaour 4y agoYou can absolutely find video tutorials on all the hobbies and daily stuff you list, and in most communities you can find groups that will teach you informally for free or in a slightly more structured way for a nominal fee. Where formal credentials exist, they tend to be based on observed skills (like a culinary arts degree or certification as a sommelier). I'm not sure the demand for MOOCs is there for most hobbies. There are some exceptions for hobbies with a well delimited body of knowledge (eg birdwatching)
- svnt 4y agoI agree with parent — there is no prestige issue and other contributing factors include a desire for specialized community that is absent in later years, plus reduced ability to/interest in relocating. While you can certainly get it for free, having a cohort and a badge that perhaps could serve as a prerequisite could benefit all students and all teachers/schools.
- readingnews 4y ago>> I am the opposite of a handy person, and I had no idea how to deal with this myself. But I Googled. And sure enough, there are multiple YouTubers operating in the home appliance repair space with sufficient specificity and dummy-friendliness that I was able to fix it. As an Engineer, I have had to explain this to countless people... a mechanic is not a mechanical engineer. An electrician, is not an electrical engineer, and so on and so on. His other anecdote of lecturer is a straw man also, as no one has done that for centuries. The idea of structured education (college) is to force you to learn ideas you would not normally learn, and have a guide to help you understand (the professor), and have those ideas organized in a pattern that aids the greater idea (e.g. taking maths: calculus, differential equations and linear algebra are not only necessary for much of engineering, but they help you to think in ways of solving problems that engineers come across often). This is one of the key problems with self-teaching, they end up not having the vast maths background to tackle complex mathematical problems, and then end up simplifying and making mistakes. In engineering, these mistakes can be deadly. In software, these mistakes can now be deadly).
- WalterBright 4y agoThe difference between a mechanic and a mechanical engineer is the latter knows the math behind it. The same for electrician and electrical engineer. I asked the electrician wiring my house to not put the phone wires through the same holes as the A/C wires. He asked why. I said because induction will put a 60 cycle hum in the phone wires. He had no idea what that was. I fired him and did the phone wires myself. When I had a house generator installed (long story) the electrician wanted to run the 12V battery charge line through the same conduit as the A/C. I said wouldn't inductive coupling put 120V on the battery charger? He had no idea what I was talking about. I was unable to explain it to him, and just worked with him to change the design. Electricians know the code, the rules, can figure out the right wire size from a chart, and how to do things without getting electrocuted. Step outside of that, and they have no idea.
- hgsgm 4y ago
- willjp 4y agoI'll bite. Haven't they? Is higher education about the material, or the order it is presented in, and the contacts that you make along the way? You're right, there are certain types of things that you can learn quite a lot about on the internet - this is especially true if there is no prerequisites. It's my favourite thing about the internet, and I'll never stop being grateful for it. I'm a self-taught hack, but I have a very intelligent/fortunate cousin that went to Berkeley (granted for business), and my interpretation is that it's a contacts/prestige thing. The information is mostly available elsewhere. I'm curious to see where this discussion goes.
- Hermitian909 4y agoI've worked in the ed-tech space for years and am good friends with many of the early pioneers. Most of the capturable value in education is signal of acquired knowledge and other factors. I'll address the knowledge signaling first. It has been possible for a century to self-study to the equivalent of a bachelor's degree using textbooks but it is very difficult to verify in a reasonable amount of time whether someone has done this. Thus, people use a degree as a first filter because people have a certain degree of trust that if you have a bachelor's degree, there's a minimum amount of knowledge you probably have. No one in ed-tech has built a tool that gives that confidence. Online universities have no pre-existing weight, and it is trivial to imagine hiring someone to do the work for you (this may now also be possible in university, but until that becomes a widespread notion it won't matter for this problem). There are then other signals that traditional universities provide. Graduating from Stanford not only implies knowledge, it implies that you are some combination of affluent, disciplined, hard working, and smart due to the exclusivity of the admissions process. Ed-tech cannot presently reproduce this without "climbing the ranks" so to speak, siphoning off students from the same people with a better value proposition (which it does not currently have).
- maegul 4y agoAbsolutely agree. And because of this, any fantasies from tech of easily disrupting education look rather naive … almost like they’re still in the mindset of the student trying to prove their intelligence. It seems then that the technical challenge is certification/assessment. Here, AI could play a role. If a machine can interactively and dynamically have a “conversation” with a person, that is randomised/unique and responsive to the student, all to assess how much they understand a topic, that’d probably do it. Combine it with a certain degree of oversight and random checking and provisions for review/appeal from “actual experts”, and you’d still have something that should scale pretty well beyond the university monopoly. An additional factor is the importance of cultural/mainstream perception. There’s a lot of “hacking” or gaming of the university assessment system, especially if you contrast the reality with the lofty and important goals of education and edification. I’d be interested to know how many, having gone through the system, really put that much faith in the quality of the “certificate”. I’ve certainly heard stories of some people/institutions wishing to also look at high school or secondary college results because they’re less likely to be “gamed” (though I have no idea how common at all this is).
- jackmott 4y ago
- oneplane 4y agoBecause technology was never the problem. All it did was morph some things in to different shapes with similar functions and features, and that doesn't actually change anything. Education in itself doesn't need disrupting. If anything, it needs stability.
- nickthegreek 4y agoIt just did. It’s called ChatGPT.
- wcarron 4y ago> And a sort of naive read on the situation would be to say that if we look at the people who are really strong, they show that inefficient, non-scalable personal training has been disrupted by whatever hobbyist forums or other internet resources they rely on. I think this absolutely misses the mark on the two most critical factors. Number 1: *exposure to and interaction with a community of peers engaged in personal improvement in the same manner* I can read Aristotle and Mills and Kant on my own in my living room; but this is not the same as being part of a book club (or a college course) reading these texts and discussing them. Finding positions, explaining them to your peers, perhaps defending those viewpoints, listening to others do the same, challenging them on their viewpoints, etc. These are examples of a secondary layer of context and understanding of a subject that is inherently not replicable in isolated learning. I have a friend who deadlifts over 750 lbs. Do you think he goes to Planet Fitness and hops on the elliptical for 20 minutes and then goes home? No. He goes to a gym filled with similarly powerful, driven lifters. He discusses training loads, regimens, diet, etc. with his peers. The knowledge transfer between skilled practitioners is critical to master of a craft past a certain point. Sure, almost anyone who lifts for 3 years with even moderate dedication can eventually break 3 plates. But 5 plates? 6? 7? 8?! No, that requires something more: a petri dish for cultivating improvement; a community of similarly motivated individuals. Number 2: A subject matter expert who can react and interact with you and your peers. Having a SME to highlight what is critical, to deprioritize what is 'cruft', to dispel or correct misunderstandings/misconceptions, to push the depth of the learning/training to a more advanced level; this is a massive advantage that in-person education has over impersonal, technologically-distributed courses. Sure, some things are easily teachabale over YouTube. One of my favorite examples: Simple mechanical work. I've used YouTube multiple times to supplement my existing knowledge & owner's manual. It's helped me flush brake lines, install oil coolers, replace a water pump, and align headlights. Work like this, that is to say, work that doesn't require a high level of expertise, is easily transferable via YouTube. This is akin to taking notes during a lecture. More complicated work, like... say, dropping an engine, replacing the crankshaft, and remounting the engine is a task that requires a higher skill/knowledge base to perform correctly. I would not trust someone to do that with purely internet-based instruction. Lastly, I would like to say that I believe scale necessarily diminishes the quality of what is being produced. You cannot teach 4000 students online as well as you can teach 400 in person; and likewise a 400 person lecture is necessarily a lower-quality educational product than a 40 person lecture & follow up socratic seminar.
- armchairhacker 4y agoFrom what I see technology has definitely disrupted higher education. Textbooks, worksheets, and report cards are being replaced by Khan Academy, MyLab, Canvas. Teachers are doing less teaching and delegating more tasks to these services: assigning online modules, quizzes, and resources to help students (and this isn't necessarily a bad thing, as some of these online modules are really good). I predict that very soon we will have AI tutors like ChatGPT, and then entire courses will be automated in technology. We already have "100% tech" online schools with one teacher per 100+ students or no teachers at all; but with AI tutors, I expect these schools will become much more effective, much more popular, and ultimately much more prevalent. I don't believe that the traditional school system will be replaced or that any public schools will become online-only: in-person learning is still necessary for many students, as are factors like free lunch and mandatory socialization, and AI will never solve those issues. But I do believe that fully-online learning, which is already rapidly growing, will start to grow even more rapidly. And this isn't necessarily a bad thing either. Frankly, many people's public education system sucks because of lack of resources, and I don't see any alternative way that it can improve, because of lack of resources. For the students, a good AI tutor can be much more helpful than a teacher (and much more patient). For the teachers, it may be harder to get a "traditional" general-elective teaching job, but maybe instead they can teach small focus groups in special classes, where the teaching is much more fun and interesting, but also harder to automate. The state of education in modern society is awful and this has serious consequences (see: recent elections); a low-cost, effective teaching solution would be a huge benefit to global society.
- sudomatic 4y agoIf AI tutors are not designed and implemented in a way that is inclusive and respectful of diverse learning styles and needs, they may perpetuate or even exacerbate existing inequalities and discrimination.
- annyeonghada 4y agoLearning styles are a pedagogical myth and there is no evidence that they exist or that catering learning to and individual learning style improves said learning.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sharadov 4y agoUniversities have been around for thousands of years. Good universities offer a unique combination of factors - people of the same age group, professors and a distinct atmosphere that encourages learning. How are you going to teach science and engineering courses where you need access to labs? And, university is where you get a chance to meet people from diverse fields and backgrounds, get exposure to challenging points of view and build life long bonds. It's another thing to work remotely as an adult, where there are competing demands on your time, but I would never wish online learning on a young adult!
- Turing_Machine 4y ago> people of the same age group Why is this an advantage?
- jcranmer 4y ago> Universities have been around for thousands of years. Actually, most historians tend to trace the oldest university back to the late 1100s (or maybe up to a hundred years older), with the University of Bologna being considered the first university. This is especially true if you consider university to be less "place of learning" and more an intentional community of students and their instructors.
- paxys 4y agoThe answer to "why hasn't technology disrupted [XYZ]" is always that the problems in XYZ weren't technology related in the first place. The education system, voting/politics, real estate, healthcare... the list goes on. You cannot automate away problems when there are humans and human emotions/motivations/conflicts in the way. Colleges and college degrees are first and foremost a social signal. There is no tech substitute to being part of an elite closed group and having a name-brand degree hanging on your wall. It's like asking why can't tech make Louis Vuitton bags more accessible to the masses. On the other hand technology has absolutely disrupted learning. Information and skills are more accessible today than any point in history. Fewer disciplines need formal structured education and credentials. Ultimately technology won't "fix" the higher education system, but simply make it less relevant in the practical world.
- RyanShook 4y agoIf cost is an indicator of value then the apparent value/relevance of higher education has only increased over the past 30 years. I think we are in the early phases of higher education disruption but it will be driven mainly by socioeconomic reasons. Is the current annual cost increase in higher education really sustainable over the next 10-20 years?
- TeMPOraL 4y ago> The answer to "why hasn't technology disrupted [XYZ]" is always that the problems in XYZ weren't technology related in the first place. I wonder why one would want to "disrupt* [XYZ] in general, and education in particular. Disruption seems to me to almost always being a net negative for everyone except the upstarts who displaced the incumbents by literally breaking their market - particularly, the customers end up holding the short end of the stick. > Ultimately technology won't "fix" the higher education system, but simply make it less relevant in the practical world. That is how technology works, which is why I don't like the whole "you can't fix a social problem with technology" line. You absolutely can. It's usually the only way you can fix it. And most of the time, the fix doesn't address the problem directly, just makes it go away by restructuring incentives that lead to it in the first place. Thus, my belief is that the answer to "why hasn't technology disrupted [XYZ]" is that the technology the asker has in mind barks up the wrong tree. The [XYZ] in question isn't a fixed artifact you can sculpt, but an equilibrium of economic and social incentives. It's dynamically maintained, so pushing directly against it means you'll be pushed back at. You can make a small dent somewhere, then you run out of money or will, and status quo resumes. EDIT: Or, if you have access to billions of dollars of VC money, you can try and do it the hard way, to detonate a metaphorical nuke in a valley to reshape it completely. Maybe you'll succeed, but more likely, you'll just starve every established company/institution to death, and then still run out of money, leaving just a completely broken [XYZ]. See my previous point about disruption not being all that positive. It's what's currently happening in food delivery and private transportation, as restaurants and taxi companies are being outcompeted by unsustainable corporations operating at a loss.
- RigelKentaurus 4y agoIf you use a different definition of higher education -- not as a college degree but truly incredible learning on a variety of topics, I think the disruption has already happened. Youtube has completely changed how I learn. The most amazing videos on philosophy, quantum mechanics, psychology -- it's all on Youtube.
- analog31 4y agoHow good are you at solving moderately difficult quantum mechanics problems? Maybe you're the exception, but when I meet people who've learned quantum mechanics from books, they've soaked up all the cool weird stuff, but can't write an equation. Disclosure: I don't know how I would have learned physics without classroom instruction. I was viscerally interested in it, and in math, but didn't have the self discipline to do the work without some guidance.
- bigger_cheese 4y agoI have a Materials Engineering degree. In my 4th and final year I decided to pick "Solid State Physics" as an elective, it was a 3rd year course taught by the physics faculty it had no prerequisites listed and sounded like it was an interesting subject. I was the only non physics student in the course and I remember sitting in the first lecture as the lecturer spoke a million miles an hour about Hamiltonians, Wave Functions and Fermi-Dirac Statistics. Almost everything he spoke about sounded like a completely different language to me and everyone else was nodding along to everything he was saying. I felt so lost. I somehow scraped a pass but in the process had to teach myself the prior assumed physics knowledge in order to do so. I would not recommend.
- jldugger 4y ago> why have the past 50 years of technological change had so little impact on schooling? A variety of fun reasons. First: it _has_ changed over time. I had recorded online lectures, grade books, course registration, etc. 20 years ago. The pandemic has sort of been a punctuated evolution for instructors, and IDK if we have any sense yet of how much will stick in post-pandemic education. Second: the cost of education is sort of a feature. Biologists and economists use the concept of "signals" -- actions you might take to indicate your fitness as a mate, or as an employee. Getting into a highly selective school is then very valuable, and the return on education relies in part on school selectivity. If thats the case, we shouldn't expect the price to go down much over time at the elite schools; they control access to a valuable commodity that only goes up as population grows. A technology that allows a school to teach 10x the students would be disastrous for signaling. Third: the cost of education at many (all?) state schools has been subsidized, and over the past 100y has been an a downward ratchet. Every time a recession devastates a state budget, the unis take another budget cut, but only rarely see subsequent increases. Often these cuts come at the same time the uni itself is showing record enrollments. Faced with a loss of funding and strong demand, school presidents take the action economists predict and raise prices. Which means, even as students are sent ever increasing tuition bills, the actual cost to deliver instruction is not so high, and in many cases going down. And since the return is so high on education, student take the offer they are given. Fourth: the opportunity cost of faculty delivered education is high. You want a Nobel laureate to teach you intro level physics? Well, every course they pick up is a grant they aren't applying for. Better make it worth the department's time -- every research dollar funds more grad students and PhDs on those important "similar schools" metrics.
- crote 4y agoI think this significantly misses the point of higher education. By far the most valuable parts are 1) peer interaction, and 2) lecturer-audience interaction. I learned way more from discussing the topic with my classmate during breaks than I ever did from the course material itself. Learning a fact is easy, deeply understanding it is not - and discussing it with your peers is the best way to discover each others' flaws in understanding. In addition to this, people asking questions is a crucial part of the lecture. Sometimes a question is because someone was asleep during the previous lecture, but most of the times it was because a concept was not explained clearly. And in a few rare but valuable cases someone asked a question, and the lecturer's eyes lit up as someone had rediscovered an open research problem - or made a critical link between two seemingly unrelated topics. Textbooks and videos can teach you a lot, but they do not allow for interaction. If you wish to simply get a basic understanding of a well-known topic, that might be enough. But if you want to truly master it and perhaps even contribute to advancing it yourself, it simply isn't enough.
- wrp 4y agoThis is why online teaching didn't take over college education the way administrators hoped it would 25 years ago. People like Hubert Dreyfus early on explained why it wasn't going to work (On the Internet, 2001).
- kmoser 4y ago45 years ago, when microcomputers were first starting to be introduced into the classroom, they were hailed as a panacea for educators. The thought was that computer-based training (CBT) was going to help alleviate the teacher-to-student ratio by letting kids sit in front of a computer and learn on their own. Guess how well that turned out?
- whimsicalism 4y agoHow do I work around this paywall? If not possible, is HN the right place to put it? Sites with paywalls that can't be bypassed are not okay on HN [0] cc @dang [0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10178989 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10178989
- wbillingsley 4y agoIf I recall, the overhead of running a university (the fraction taken by the central institution to run campus and facilities, versus the amount coming into the schools to pay academics) is around two thirds of the student revenue in Australia. Although that sounds large, it's not in corporate terms. Charging the customer 2.3 to 3 times an employee's salary seems about standard. And universities are notorious for casual using work to an underpaid "precariate". That suggests there isn't a whole lot of margin for technology to capture in the first place. After which, you find that degree-awarding is a regulated activity in most countries, offered by public institutions subsidised by government loan and contribution schemes. Tech has had a massive influence on higher education in the last ten years, but it seems to go via universities buying more systems and services rather than "University of the Unregulated Start Up" suddenly sweeping the public-controlled market for education.
- blinding-streak 4y agoCollege is not just about getting an education. An equally important part of a traditional college education is finding out who you are as a human being. Living with others full time, perhaps for the first time. The growth I experienced in those 4 years of college was unlike anything else in my lifetime.
- bottlepalm 4y agoPeople who don’t go to college also often live with others and don’t pay 30k for the privilege.
- annyeonghada 4y agoUniversity is, for about everyone who isn't in it for branding, about educatoon and getting a job. I don't need to live with others to know who I am: I can introspect in my room and maybe use the money saved in rent to pursue something that really makes me grow as a person, music for me. The only thing that I learbed living with others is that living alone is one of the greatest luxuries.
- pjmorris 4y agoFor me, this discussion brings up a question I've had: How well do the HN remote batches work compared to the in-person batches? My hunch (and it's only a hunch) is that there's something essential about in-person learning that technology, to date, hasn't captured... and that's why it hasn't disrupted higher ed.
- pbreit 4y agoEasy: higher ed is all about the credential.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- stephc_int13 4y agoKnowledge acquisition is, in practice, a problem that is not well understood. From empirical evidence it seems that 1:1 mentoring could be the best system ever found. With a tech close enough to AGI, it might be possible to have an even better 1:1 mentoring with infinite scale. There are clearly unknowns and probably unknowns unknowns on this path, but the potential positive effects are too important to pass.
- siliconc0w 4y agoAI tutoring and hiring will inevitably disrupt education. A degree is a really poor heuristic of someone's ability to do a job and AI will be able practice mastery learning with every pupil (only moving on to the next subject once the current one is mastered) and precisely identify and drill where they are struggling. On the hiring side I also can't see the status quo surviving, it costs so much employee time to interview and it's done so unevenly with such bias and even with multiple rounds and committees you still get poor signal. This is fundamentally a classification problem. The proctoring and suggested scoring will be done by AI with maybe human review at the end. Hopefully these are opensource and using open datasets so biases can be challenged but I can see this also devolving into proprietary models. Well regarded AIs might give out a (cryptographically) signed certificate that you are x percentile technically and even behaviorally or even going so far as to recommend a specific role and company where you'd fit in the most.
- throwawaaarrgh 4y ago"why hasn't technology disrupted plumbing already? click here for secret thoughtleader predictions" There should be a filter on HN to hide blog posts that are just technobabble musings with no actionable or definitive information. If I wanted my time wasted I'd troll op-eds in political rags. At least that crap is generic enough that I could have an argument in a bar about it. (or maybe I'm missing the point, and people in SF actually do talk about this shit in bars?)
- hardwaregeek 4y agoA school is simultaneously a community of young adults; a physical campus for them to live; a continuation[1] of a holistic, multi-subject education; a training program for a specialty; an economic, social, and political escape for many young adults[2]; a support system; a means to gaining a visa; and a way to find a partner and friends. Most people go for at least two or more of these reasons. Even if a school is not ideal in a lot of ways, there are no alternatives that provide even a fraction of these benefits. The only way that I could see higher education disrupted is by the government. If the government created a non-military service where young adults could work for the government, get trained in a career, while fraternizing with other young adults and getting paid a low but reasonable salary, perhaps that could divert people from university. Of course this would probably be mostly students who come from low-income backgrounds, as this service would not fulfill the requisite status and network building requirements that more privileged students seek. Which, now that I think about it, is also why a lot of low-income students attend college. So perhaps this would not work as well. [1]: Continuation is generous. Often it's a necessary supplement to a watered down, propagandist, taught-to-the-test high school education. [2]: Especially young adults who are queer, or who do not follow the political or religious beliefs of their parents.
- toldyouso2022 4y agoIf governments didn't regulate who can work based on papers acquired, we would be done with this clown system of university and public school. And beware it's not that we have discovered the better way yet, we have just discovered that our way is inefficient and brings many wrong conclusions in science, goverments forbid us from developing new systems do we can improve. Technology made us find we are wrong, but investigating how to fix it require resources and freedom and these are seized by goverments
- RunSet 4y agoI hoped that by "disrupted higher education" the author meant something at least as radical as what this decades-old essay proposes. https://citejournal.org/volume-2/issue-3-02/seminal-articles/should-the-computer-teach-the-student-or-vice-versa/ https://citejournal.org/volume-2/issue-3-02/seminal-articles... Alas, I came away disappointed. Instead of aiming for a quantum leap, the author only intends to automate the existing processes.
- will_wright 4y agoRight! I had a similar thought: the article appeared to be building to an interesting conclusion then ended abruptly... One follow-on paragraph could have easily explored autodidactic methods, through tools like youtube or open online courses, and how they have catalyzed an area of learning that previously didn't exist -- ie easy entry courseware is orthogonal learning model from the traditional education model. IMHO, the only thing that is going to disrupt higher education in the US is a change in the federal student loan system. Otherwise, the money is going to keep flowing and those institutions will have little motivation to adapt to survive edit: Good article! Thanks for sharing
- paulpauper 4y agoAs far as STEM is concerned, there is little that comes close to the rigor of in-person exams and problem sets. Certificates, MOOCS, bootcamps, online videos...just cannot match it.
- pdntspa 4y agoHow presumptuous to assume that education needs disruption, I think the disaster that is forced e-learning and all the extra bullshit associated with MOOCs and anti-cheat would be enough of a signal to stop breaking things
- yellow_lead 4y agoCollege works great if you can afford it. For everyone else, some disruption could be useful if the cost can be reduced through it.
- ChaitanyaSai 4y agoWhat is education? What is learning? These are surprisingly tricky to define because they are broad. My wife and I started a microschool (in Mumbai) because we couldn’t find any for our kids that were both good and did not require a multi-hour trek to get to daily. Taking up the responsibility of educating others’ kids meant we needed to articulate and clarify very foundational concepts. What exactly is a good school? What makes it so? As parents, we began our search with the “how”. We knew that traditional standardized age-segmented, test-driven schooling isn’t great. There is tons of literature on that. I also happen to have a PhD in neuroscience and have written a book about the mind, so I also know how little we know about how we learn. From whatever little we do, though, we know this current industrialized form of schooling is bad. And yet it’s been bureaucratized and dispensed with dogmatic confidence. It speaks to our resilience that we turn out okay despite its inanity. There are alternative methods that have been around for quite some time (Waldorf/Steiner schools celebrated their centenary recently). We’ve adopted one of the alternative methods. However, the practice of actually engaging with twenty kids for hours everyday quickly made us realize that it is not enough to change or ask the how. A set of telescoping questions quickly reveal themselves: How? What? Why? To ask how we must educate, we must ask what is education, and why is it required? Education is learning to play the game of life well. We must learn it because the game changes and we are not born with the tools and wisdom it takes to play it. We acquire them over our lifetime, learning about the game, about ourselves. We are learning even into our middle and late ages. It’s not just numeracy, literacy, or computational skills. It is mental wellbeing. It is understanding how we fit into the fabric of society and how we can navigate it successfully and profitably, and hopefully sustainably. Do you need school or college for that? No, but it helps to have a place where you can share notes and have experienced guides who are not merely transmitting information, but actively learning and exploring. That isn’t happening in most schools or colleges though. We are stuck with the unconscious definition of learning as information transmission and education as the institutional process within which this transmission happens in a measurable, testable, certifiable manner. Systems have been built around this idea and like all systems, these are tough to dismantle. I think Generative AI’s greatest potential lies in making the transmission of information so effortlessly easy and effective (by personalizing this transmission to suit each individual’s needs) that we’ll come to realize there is more to education, learning, and the game of life than devoting over twenty years of our lives to getting graded and branded within these transmission of information tests and systems that empower them.
- LarsDu88 4y agoI went to an Ivy League university. Was studying for Biochem one year to meet a requirement. Class had ~500 people in it and no classes. You just go to study sections once a week, and take the tests. The study sections were all run by OTHER undergrads and the entire thing was run by an adjunct. I ask one of the TAs (same year as me) - "Why the fuck are we paying so much for this education. My high school teachers put in 10x more effort." He says - "You have it all wrong - it's not about the education, it's about the credential and the networking that happens." 15 years later, and I finally realize he was ABSOLUTELY FRICKIN RIGHT.
- amazon_illegal 4y ago
- pcurve 4y agoJust curious, Cornell?
- LarsDu88 4y agoHow the heck did you... you're an alumnus too?
- UncleMeat 4y agoThere's only a handful of ivies. Not an especially unlikely coincidence to guess correctly here.
- pcurve 4y agoLucky guess ;-) Based on the followings I noticed: 1. Some alumni are reluctant to reveal where they went to school, instead opting to say things like, "I went to school up state NY" or "one of the ivies". We used to talk about why this was the case and concluded that it's because though Cornellians are proud, they still have inferiority complex against people who went to Yale, Harvard, and Columbia. And Stanford if you're from California ;-) 2. Your story about large biochem course and how it's run. I had a roommate who was a biochem major (though in the 90s) and lamented how Cornell had these 'weed-out' courses deliberately designed to winnow out the smartest. ('Orgo' i.e. organic chemistry being on of them) 3. Use of lingos like "biochem" or "TAs". I'm sure other ivies use these, but when I heard these two works, I had a flashback to my undergrad days. Btw, off topic, I recently visited and stayed at the Statler hotel, booked a room overlooking the Tower road and relived the old campus days. I'm not the one to regret much, but I spent too much time studying and didn't take advantage of the beautiful Ithaca while I was there. Better late than never ;-)
- Existenceblinks 4y agoIt's a social problem rather than technology. If something signals higher social status, it will keep going.
- est 4y agoIf we simply replace text books with iPads and instructors with non-interactive videos, then it won't happen. Here's how it will happen: digitalize knowlege, I mean really digital, like how LEAN math cover nearly all undergrad math subjects in mathlib. Make learning courses like MUD or multi-ending visual novels so learners can hae adaptive route of learning. The higher education won't be replaced until we hae complete single-source-of-truth in digital.
- mclightning 4y agoI think what they're really asking is; why tech hasn't disrupted higher education economically, with VCs, startups posing as universities etc. because in every other aspect tech disrupts culture and higher education continuously...
- darthrupert 4y agoBecause there is no tech solution to the most important parts of universities: prestige and networking.
- SergeAx 4y agoFirst of all, author confuses information and knowledge. Reading books (and listening to lectures, FWIW) gives you only former. Next goes knowledge and skill. I can cook a steak using YouTube video, and I can tell that I possess this knowledge, but it doesn't make me even decent cook, and there is an enormous gap between that and getting a position in a cafe on the corner.