15 ms·
Who invented the thumb drive?
- penguin_booze 4y agoIf someone in ieee publishing is reading this: please stop ambushing the reader with that popup.
- 2rsf 4y agoOh shit, another myth goes down the drain. As someone who grew up in Israel I was always proud of M Systems and Dov Moran as the inventors of the Thumb Drive and creating something nobody thought of before.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- samanator 4y agoThe myth lives on. According to Wikipedia: > Multiple individuals have staked a claim to being the inventor of the USB flash drive. On April 5, 1999, Amir Ban, Dov Moran, and Oron Ogdan of M-Systems, an Israeli company, filed a patent application entitled "Architecture for a Universal Serial Bus-Based PC Flash Disk".
- CrypticShift 4y ago> global sales of thumb drives from all manufacturers surpassed $7 billion, a number that is expected to rise to more than $10 billion by 2028. More than 20 years later, they are indeed dirty cheap. However, I often find them to be unreliable with slow/unsteady real speeds. Meanwhile, small NVMe-based devices in either this thumb-format or SD-format (5 years in the making [1]) are still not very popular, so the prices are high. Or is it the other way around? [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16474735 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=16474735
- mschuster91 4y ago> Meanwhile, small NVMe-based devices in either this thumb-format or SD-format (5 years in the making [1]) are still not very popular, so the prices are high. Or is it the other way around? Consumer devices don't need storage that fast and those prosumer/pro devices that do either use USB-C SSDs (e.g. Blackmagic's camera lineup [0]), outright SSDs (BlackMagic's fixed-studio equipment [1]) or CFexpress which actually is PCIe under the hood (Nikon, Sony and Panasonic all offer CFexpress support on their recent models of higher priced camera systems). Prices are very high, but that's justifiable IMO - unlike with SD cards or USB sticks where all the low-quality-binned flash chips go, CFexpress flash chips have to be the best of the best of the binning because they couldn't keep up with the performance and endurance that professional equipment demands. [0] https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/de/products/blackmagicursaminipro https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/de/products/blackmagicursam... [1] https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/de/products/blackmagicmultidock https://www.blackmagicdesign.com/de/products/blackmagicmulti...
- wongarsu 4y agoThere is more than a 10x price difference between slow run-of-the-mill sd cards and the high speed cards a photographer might go for. Why would it be any different for thumb drives? Higher speeds are more difficult to achieve and make up a small fraction of the total demand. And to make it worse people who need speed tend to be less price sensitive.
- epicide 4y agoI ran into this sort of issue with the Steam Deck, too. Initially ordered a slower-but-still-recommended cheaper SD card. Figured I could deal with the slower write speeds as that should just mean slower downloads. I loved the Steam Deck from the onset, but was always confused why nobody mentioned how slow and unresponsive the main menus were... Yeah, hindsight is 20/20. Games still ran fine off of the slower card, but every part of the experience saw a dramatic improvement after I switched to a higher-spec SD card.
- porkbeer 4y agoJust watch the video on disassembly and install a m.2. So much faster than an sd card. Its a 5/10 fiddly i hear. Ive yet to open mine but I bought the baller option. My steam controller was reasonably easy with a small plastic tool for prying, also available as automotive trim removers cheaply.
- CrypticShift 4y ago> 10x price difference ... Why would it be any different for thumb drives? I'm more concerned with the reliability (in my experience). The middle-priced ones are not necessarily better than the cheapest ones. > Higher speeds are more difficult to achieve I'm not asking for 1000 MB/s write speed. Why do I still sometimes get 10MB/s in 2023? Is it much to expect around 100 MB/s write (HDD-level speeds) in most "average" thumb-drive?
- bluGill 4y agoSome are much better than others. Where I work we have some embedded systems in lab that can only program from USB. We are constantly reprogramming them, so we go through a lot of USB drives. The cheap ones last maybe a week in the lab, we have found one that will last for months - they cost 5 times as much, but last at least 20 times longer.
- Arrath 4y agoMy office has a stash of staples thumb drives for people to use to schlep stuff around. They have the absolute worst, dog-slow controllers I've ever encountered. Or it could be an interaction with Sophos. Anyway, putting even a single file onto the drive takes a solid 45 seconds. Scanning something and saving it directly to USB at the MFC takes multiple minutes if its anything more than a few pages. The quality of these things has really gone down as they've gotten commoditized, it seems.
- josephcsible 4y agoI'd give it about a 1% chance that it's actually bad flash drives, and a 99% chance it's Sophos.
- Arrath 4y agoFair. It also loves to do full system scans at the worst time and send my fans to full throttle.
- Neil44 4y agoThe biggest deal for these taking off was that they just worked on Windows without any special drivers or messing around. It made them appear magic. People lost their minds over how much easier and better they were than all the other stuff - burning CD's, floppy drives, zip disks, LS120 etc. You couldn't email large files and WeTransfer didn't exist. We couldn't get them in fast enough for the users where I worked at the time.
- bheadmaster 4y agoObligatory xkcd: https://xkcd.com/949/ https://xkcd.com/949/
- egberts1 4y agoTo upgrade an old saying: Never underestimate the power of a Tesla Electric Truck carrying 4 tons of 32TB USB sticks barreling down the highway from San Francisco to Los Angeles. Still beats the fastest bandwidth of the latest satellite laser LAN.
- nso 4y agoNot necessarily the most practical if you include write/read time
- kevinmhickey 4y agoThumb drives in a truck offer great bandwidth but terrible latency.
- CobaltFire 4y agoNot everything needs to have Musks companies shoehorned in.
- porkbeer 4y agoTesla trucks are a bad application here, even though you were conspicously careful to keep your route quite short.
- 4y ago
- amelius 4y agoSomeone not smart enough to understand that most people want to write on it with a pen, so it should contain a large flat, bright-colored surface.
- porkbeer 4y agoEven with cassettes we used a sticker. The labelers know their craft.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoI guess manufacturers assumed people will first and foremost use them to move data around, not to backup/archive it, which makes sense as they were somewhat pricey initially, while the role of "write once, read many" was occupied by CD-R discs. Of course, at some point the prices dropped, and eventually some people ended up owning a dozen USB sticks of various sizes and shapes, some of which used for archiving, but none of them labeled.
- jaclaz 4y agoTo be fair, there were some USB sticks (that did not have much success) by PNY that had a (clever) open/close mechanism that made it into a rectangular shape with a paper label on one side where you could write (only 2 lines). The case/mechanism was similar to this: https://cdn11.bigcommerce.com/s-6bkt1ygjlf/images/stencil/608x608/products/478316/556001/P-FD16GBA3M1-BX-lg__88140.1537273996.jpg https://cdn11.bigcommerce.com/s-6bkt1ygjlf/images/stencil/60... but they were sold in boxes of 10 or 12, I cannot remember if they were 1 or 2 GB capacity. EDIT: found an actual picture of them: http://www.usbmemorysticks.net/wp-content/gallery/pny-third-generation-attache/pny-label-attache.jpg http://www.usbmemorysticks.net/wp-content/gallery/pny-third-... they were 2 and 4 GB.
- hakfoo 4y agoUnderrated point here. Floppies at least usually came with sticky labels so you could tell them apart. With flash drives, If you're lucky, you get a colour assortment in the box. I bought a packet of 5x16Gb drives, and I can't tell which ones are the "partitioned strange for use with a vintage machine" versus "my brother's backups".
- mk_stjames 4y agoI can tell I'm getting older by the number of articles I read that take time to describe 'history' of things that seem obvious since I lived through them, like the explanation of how 3.5" high density 'Floppy disks' held up to 1.44MB. Like... "I know... oh god some people don't know that."
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoI mean to add, the article says that thumb drives are still hot and the market will grow by billions a year more in a few years, but... I haven't used a thumb drive in years. The only time I actually went to look for one was to plug it into a shitty digital picture frame, and that one would also accept SD cards.
- brnt 4y agoNever underestimate the bandwidth of a man with a USB drive hurtling down the stairs.
- bayindirh 4y agoI still use the higher end ones (which have a USB SATA controller and a bona fide SSD) to carry photos and big files around when I'm on vacation. They look like bulky, yet ordinary USB flash drives.
- bombcar 4y agoYeah, online file sharing sites of various types (dropbox, box, google drive) have basically replaced the USB stick in most cases. It's simpler to upload and send someone a link than find the stick.
- narag 4y agoFunny, for me it helps replacing another device that I canned twenty years ago: the printer. Every time I need to print something to feed some troglodite's requirement, I put a pdf in a pincho and go down the street to the call shop. 20 cents is absurdly expensive, but much less than maintaining a printer for one paper sheet a month at most.
- rob74 4y agoI guess this was one of those "inventions" which are pretty obvious in hindsight, and I bet more than one party had already though of building a USB drive, it was just a question of the USB interface becoming widespread enough and of flash memory becoming affordable and reliable enough. Actually, flash memory cards with proprietary interfaces were available for some time before the year 2000 given in the article (Compact Flash since 1994, Sony's Memory Stick since 1998), so it was just the question of using USB instead of these interfaces.
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoThat reminds me, I don't remember if it was USB 1 or 2, but at some point I added a card to my PC that added two USB ports. I think that must've been USB 2.0 because the sockets were blue and I'm fairly sure I could hook up my keyboard and mouse through USB already.
- roperj 4y agoBlue is officially USB 3.0 - or possibly some knock off junk of course is always a possibility.
- russdill 4y agoYes, I think the use of the term "invented" as well as the idea that the invention was unfairly copied are a bit disingenuous. Credit where credit is due. Pulling together the different technologies and making them into a manufactural product is a great accomplishment. If there were inventions involved it would be the USB protocol, there mass storage specification, and of course flash memory. The thumb drive just brought those things together.
- mk_stjames 4y agoIt should also be noted that one of the reasons thumb drives took off when they did was not just due to USB.. as technically USB has been around for a few years and there were things like CF card readers coming on the market, and other flash storage readers a few years earlier.. so why did it take until later? Because Win 95 and Win 98 did not have plug and play drivers for USB mass storage devices, at all. I think it wasn't until Win98SE (edit: for true generic controllers it may have been Win2K even?) that there was a USB driver for generic thumb drives. But theoretically the tech was around and could have been implemented as early as 1996.
- jasode 4y ago>But theoretically the tech was around and could have been implemented as early as 1996. The USB physical form-factor and electrical signals were 1996 but the protocol for storage devices appears to be later in 1998: Universal Serial Bus Mass Storage Class Specification Overview V1.0 Revision October 22, 1998 : https://cscott.net/usb_dev/data/devclass/usbmassover_10.pdf https://cscott.net/usb_dev/data/devclass/usbmassover_10.pdf
- theandrewbailey 4y ago> Universal Serial Bus Mass Storage Class Specification Back in the day, some of my friends called thumbdrives MSDs, because when you plugged one in, Windows would show a popup telling you that it found a new USB Mass Storage Device. I don't recall that initialism catching on with anybody.
- jabbany 4y agoHmm, I remember still having to install individual drivers for USB thumb drives/sticks on our stock 98SE install. It was only until we "upgraded" to WinME that USB mass storage largely became plug-and-play. (Though, I think you could grab the winme usb drivers and plop them into a 98 install to get universal-ish usb mass storage, and later drives just ended up bundling a generic driver instead of a device specific one on the driver CD)
- 4y ago
- vkoskiv 4y agoI am the proud owner of an 8MB IBM branded DiskOnKey flash drive. Plugging it into my linux system, it throws a lot of errors, but I do have a ext2 filesystem on it. I can mount it and find the little 'hello world' text file I put in there last June :)
- PurpleRamen 4y ago8 MB..and here I'm sitting, filling a whopping 1 TB USB-storage with ISO-files for live-system, most probably bigger than a whole PC had available, at the time DiskOnKey was sold. That was just 20 Years ago. It's those little things which reminds me of how insanely fast technology moved in my lifetime. Who knows where we will be in 20 years...
- antod 4y agoI had a couple of those IBM 8MB drives - they were a lot larger (physical size) than anything since. I didn't even know USB storage was a thing until they included them in the box with some Thinkpads. Compared to floppies they were amazing in terms of speed, capacity and convenience.
- mkuan 4y agoNetac still holds patent globally until 2019. Other manufacturers paid Netac more than 2 billions over these years. Made in China has changed a lot of things. It doesn't matter who really invented thumb drives. I think the first mass production/sale of thumb drives happened in China. That's the reason the patent was granted to Netac.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoAm I the only one bothered that IEEE isn't GDPR compliant? They only give you the option to accept cookies and that's it.
- swores 4y agoMaybe they're not tracking any personal data? The ePrivacy Directive ("cookies law") is years older than GDPR and only requires notification not consent. Sites which choose to store zero PD (which includes e.g. not logging IP addresses) are GDPR compliant automatically, but still need to notify about cookies if using them. edit: though, having looked at their privacy policy it seems they do use PD... so yeah, not good (unless I'm misunderstanding their tracking policy which I don't think I am) https://www.ieee.org/security-privacy.html https://www.ieee.org/security-privacy.html
- bluedino 4y agoI have the same problem I did back when a 64MB drive was the hot thing - how do I know I'm buying a quality drive? Even between the same brand, one drive can be great, the other is slower than dirt (even with USB 3), is unreliable, etc.
- shagie 4y agoI've got an early generation portable USB drive that I've kept for some nostalgia. https://imgur.com/2XcXCPe https://imgur.com/2XcXCPe - its 128 MB. I purchased in '96 (or maybe '97). You'll note that it is orange which indicated solid state. There was also a black one which had a spinning disk in that same form factor and held 256 MB. I used it a few times in between 2010 and 2015 for transferring a file around sneaker net. You'll note that the USB plug is on a short cord - the places where I had to plug it in didn't always allow for easily inserting a short rectangular stick - they either stuck out too far for where the computer was or required moving other things out of the way. This one let me plug it in with minimal obstruction to other things in a cluttered USB port area.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- eric__cartman 4y agoThat thing must have been expensive back when it was new. The flash drive I carry in my keychain nowadays was like $8 new lol
- shagie 4y agoI want to say it was in the $100 to $200 range ($200 to $400 inflation adjusted)... though there may have also been an academic discount on that.
- TeMPOraL 4y agoI'm surprised that the market for this is hot. Who is still buying USB sticks or SD cards? I haven't in quite a while, because I don't know who to trust anymore: cheaper variants are likely to be those counterfeits with hacked metadata that advertise having 4-10x the capacity they have[0], and more expensive ones are a crapshoot wrt. performance. In recent years, for the occasional need to physically move some files, I've been using my phone as USB storage. Or, in the very rare case that isn't enough, a portable HDD or portable SSD drive. EDIT: As mentioned in a reply, I still have a bunch of USB sticks I bought bought some 8-12 years ago, before counterfeiting was that big of a deal. In a very rare case I need to make a bootable drive, I reach into the desk drawer and dust one off. ---- [0] - That's one of the nastiest form of fraud/counterfeiting I've ever experienced in the computing space. Less performant or even less functional hardware is one thing, but a 256 MB USB stick that pretends to be a 4 GB one will happily accept the first few files a typical user would put on it, lulling them into false sense of security, and then silently drop everything that's over 256 MB - a fact the user would only discover when trying to read back the data they "stored" on the USB stick, often days later, long after deleting the original files. I imagine it still beats ransomware on the metric of "priceless photos of loved ones forever lost, because some asshole thought they found a clever way to make money".
- brettermeier 4y agoHow do you install a fresh copy of Windows?
- TeMPOraL 4y agoIt's been years since I've done that. But I still keep a stack of USB sticks that I bought (or got as freebies from conferences) some 8-12 years ago, some of which have enough space for a Windows or Linux ISO to fit.
- 5e92cb50239222b 4y agoCreate a FAT32 partition on your SSD/HDD, unpack your .iso there, and you should be able to boot from it. You typically don't have to mark it as an ESP partition. It works on most motherboards, but not all.
- jk_i_am_a_robot 4y agoI assumed it was invented when a developer cut down an edge connector breadboard and shoved it directly into the USB port then et voilà it's a development board.
- rvba 4y agoIn 2022, can Windows (or Linux?) defend themselves against an USB drive that contains a virus? If you go to some service that offers prints and use your usb drive there, Im like 100% sure you will get multiple viruses. I dont understand why the operating systems dont seem to be able to defend themselves against it. Also in the past the drives had a "read only" mode, nowadays this is hard to find.
- paul7986 4y agoIn 2015 on a reality TV show about inventors (Americas Greatest Maker created by Intel and Mark Burnett) I pitched two phones sharing battery power (reverse wireless charging). In 2018 Huwaeii was the first to introduce into the market via their Mate 20 Pro. Samsung added it a year later in a Galaxy Phone calling it "Wireless PowerShare." Their been rumors Apple will add it too. I've always wondered if my pitch on that TV show to Mark Burnett(creator of the voice, survivor, shark tank, etc) & Intel was the spark for it all or they'd been working on it prior. I would hope Intel created some patents around it as overall it was just idea I pitched on recorded video for the show to Mark and folks at Intel. I'm not a mechanical or battery engineer rather a web developer. Would be cool to see if my idea (was at a tech event & phone died yet was surrounded by tons of powered up devices) was the first that sparked reverse wireless charging.
- ufmace 4y agoThe strange thing about the thumb drive world - I can remember getting my first one in the early 2000s, capacity of 4MB or so I think. The odd part is I have no clue what brand it was, where I got it from, or how I heard that they existed. I vaguely recall it being some no-name vaguely sketchy seeming thing. But it worked great.
- chirau 4y agoI know it is not Ajay Bhatt (he co-invented USB), but this reminded me of Intel's "Our rock stars are not your rock stars" campaign. https://youtu.be/0QYcgwjUlWo https://youtu.be/0QYcgwjUlWo
- somrand0 4y agounsung? not anymore. this article is singing for him
- bergie 4y agoThere are thumb drives, and then there are index finger drives https://bergie.iki.fi/blog/when_reality_meets_product_concepts/ https://bergie.iki.fi/blog/when_reality_meets_product_concep...
- steviedotboston 4y agoI remember buying my first thumb drive. I think it was in 2000 or so, and it cost $75 from Staples. It had a whopping 128mb of storage, which at the time felt massive. I used it for years until eventually it was lost.
- cptskippy 4y ago> The Iomega Zip Drive, called a “superfloppy” drive and introduced in 1994, could store up to 750 MB of data and was writable, but it never gained widespread popularity, partly due to competition from cheaper and higher-capacity hard drives. I've heard or read a few stories about the Zip Drive recently and they all seem to compress the 10ish years of existence and completely downplay it's impact or significance. In 1994 a 1 GB SCSI drive cost over $1000 the largest IDE drives were about 250 MB, new PCs were shipping with 130 MB drives and 486 CPUs. If you need more than 1.44 MB of removable storage you chose between a tape backup and the rarer more expensive Bernolli drives; both requiring a SCSI interface. Tape drives were relatively inexpensive, slow and didn't do random access; reading or wring everything serially and it took hours to restore files. Bernolli drives were expensive and unreliable; the fail state was a damaged drive head. I remember having an Irwin 40 MB tape drive that I used to backup games from my 100 MB Western Digital HDD. While tape was slow, it was still faster than installing Wing Commander or Papyrus Nascar Racing from 2 dozen floppy disks. It was also unattended unlike floppy. When the Zip Drive arrived in 1994 it offered 100 MB of external storage in similar capacities to comparably priced tape drives for similar prices. It was random access like a floppy disk and you could read off of it rather than having to copy the files to your HDD like with Tape. It was also much faster and the parallel port version could be hot swapped without rebooting. CD-Rs wouldn't be a thing for a couple years, they wouldn't be affordable for a couple more, and they wouldn't be reliable for a couple more. Initial drives didn't come with buffers and needed high performance machines, later buffered drives could still underflow if your PC couldn't keep the buffer filled. Burning disks was a ceremony where you carefully shutdown anything running and defragged your HDD to ensure nothing would interrupt the burning process. Everyone had a spindle of failed burns. Even when CD-Rs and CD-RWs finally arrived, they were slow. The ZIP drive was comparable to an 8x CD-ROM and those speeds for R/RW were still years away. For a 6 year period after the initial 100 MB drive launched, the Zip drive was a big deal. I don't know what their definition of "widespread popularity" was but Iomega was huge for a time and quietly died off in the early 2000s. When Iomega launched the Zip 250 in 1999, ZDNet wrote [0]: > "...Iomega is poised to expand its already massive share of the removable storage market." > "The biggest name in removable storage just got bigger thanks to the Zip drive's increased capacity--it now holds a generous 250MB of data." The 750 MB version wouldn't arrive until 2002 as a last dying gasp from Iomega in an attempt to compete with CD-R/RW. [0] https://web.archive.org/web/20001119014500/http://www8.zdnet.com/products/stories/reviews/0,4161,388070,00.html https://web.archive.org/web/20001119014500/http://www8.zdnet...
- dghughes 4y agoThe earliest I recall seeing a USB thumb drive was early 2000s maybe 2003. Staples then or a year later had 45MB thumb drives on sale I think $50). People went nuts over this deal. The cashier asked the elderly woman buying one if she wanted the protection plan for it. I probably still have the one I bought.
- Doorstep2077 4y agoOne interesting fact about thumb drives is that they have evolved significantly since they were first introduced. The first thumb drives were created in the late 1990s and were much larger and less reliable than the ones we use today. They were also much slower, with data transfer speeds of only a few megabytes per second. In comparison, modern thumb drives can transfer data at speeds of hundreds of megabytes per second and are small enough to fit on a keychain. This has made them an essential tool for many people, and they are now commonly used to store and transfer data for personal and professional use.
- aidenn0 4y ago> with data transfer speeds of only a few megabytes per second That sounds high to me; some of my more recent USB drives get single-digit MB/s. USB 1.1 had a theoretical limit of 1.2MB/s and I doubt many (any?) early thumb drives achieved that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]