8 ms·
The maddening mess of airport codes [video]
- ktkoffroth 4y agoNice to see this video here, I know CGP Grey is (or, atleast was) an avid HN lurker. If you're seeing this Grey, I'm a big fan, thanks for the videos and podcasts over the years :)
- woodruffw 4y agoThe entire world of airline coding (as in "encoding") is fascinating to me: there are all kinds of ancient semi-human-readable formats like ACARS[1] and IATA Teletype[2] that are still pushing data around. Not the mention standard meal codes[3], like BLML for "bland meal" and CLML for "celebration cake meal." [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACARS https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/ACARS [2]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airline_teletype_system https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Airline_teletype_system [3]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Air_Transport_Association_code#IATA_meal_codes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/International_Air_Transport_As...
- cratermoon 4y agoUMNR, INFT, CBBG, AVIH, ARNK. Just some off the top of my head.
- supernova87a 4y agoAdd to that (what I understand to be) extortionate data rates for ACARS/ARINC messages, that rival data sent to the Hubble / JWST (if you remember that story from a couple years ago).
- reaperducer 4y ago#3 has RFML - Refugee Meal. I wonder what that is.
- woodruffw 4y agoA lot of airlines have done refugee flights at one point or another, so I guess they needed a way to tell the ground crew to load whatever special foods were needed.
- bigDinosaur 4y agoWhat 'special foods' would be needed for refugees?
- woodruffw 4y agoIf they're famine refugees, something like Plumpy'nut[1] maybe. If they're religious refugees, something catering to their religious restrictions. MREs if the refugee operation is being assisted by a military or disaster aid organization. And so forth. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plumpy%27nut https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Plumpy%27nut
- nereye 4y agoTalking of MREs, some airlines do not allow them as carry on luggage, see https://www.tsa.gov/travel/security-screening/whatcanibring/items/mres https://www.tsa.gov/travel/security-screening/whatcanibring/....
- remarkEon 4y agoMREs contain a heating packet filled with magnesium pellets and a couple other things, which are used to heat the food when water is added. I'd imagine they don't want those in the cabin, given the gas that is emitted during the heating process.
- culi 4y agoThere's also TBML which is for Tech Bro Meals (soylent, mainly)
- AdamN 4y ago
- markdown 4y agoBig Mac Meal.
- SoftTalker 4y agoBread and water
- macintux 4y agoGiven that the only references I can find online appear to be copies of the Wikipedia entry, I’m a bit suspicious. Two entries were added by an anonymous contributor: CAKE and RFML. https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=International_Air_Transport_Association_code&diff=601576732&oldid=601447628 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=International_Air...
- doctor_eval 4y agoIt’s a euphemism for Soylent Green.
- aksss 4y agohumble pie
- PurpleRamen 4y agoRFML seems from United Airlines, and seems to mean: easy to digest. No egg, no dairy, probably no meat? Its for people from places where food isn't processed or where they had not eaten much for a longer time, so a change in diet content and quantity may be problematic for the passenger.
- macintux 4y agoIf you have a citation for that, you should add it to the article.
- gfaure 4y agoI've always wondered about the IATA meal code CAKE, and what it might have involved.
- SoftTalker 4y agoI've also wondered why cryptically abbrevated things like NOTAMS are still the way they are. It made sense in a teletype/telegraph world where brevity was worth time and money. From wikipedia, this is a typical NOTAM: A1234/06 NOTAMR A1212/06 Q)EGTT/QMXLC/IV/NBO/A/000/999/5129N00028W005 A)EGLL B)0609050500 C)0704300500 E)DUE WIP TWY B SOUTH CLSD BTN 'F' AND 'R'. TWY 'R' CLSD BTN 'A' AND 'B' AND DIVERTED VIA NEW GREEN CL AND BLUE EDGE LGT. CTN ADZ Likewise METARs (weather reports): METAR KTTN 051853Z 04011KT 1/2SM VCTS SN FZFG BKN003 OVC010 M02/M02 A3006 RMK AO2 TSB40 SLP176 P0002 T10171017= Pilots have to know how to read and understand this stuff. Only justification I can think of is that like mathematical notation, this shorthand, once learned, is unambiguous and conveys meaning better than prose. I don't know if that's really true though.
- 2143 4y ago> Pilots have to know how to read and understand this stuff. Only justification I can think of is that like mathematical notation, this shorthand, once learned, is unambiguous and conveys meaning better than prose. I don't know if that's really true though. You're correct. It's straightforward for pilots. They can quickly read a NOTAM and understand everything. Also, it's pretty standard and unambiguous worldwide. As for the specific example you provided, today is your lucky day! That exact example has been decoded on Wikipedia here: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/METAR#North_American_METAR_codes https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/METAR#North_American_METAR_c...
- PaulDavisThe1st 4y agoThis all seems quite reminiscent of when the US National Weather Service used to issue super-cryptic forecast background summaries, and then slowly non-meterologists started building systems to decode them.
- rob74 4y agoThat would be true in an ideal world, but pilots are also only human, so at least some of them will sometimes misread or ignore all that gibberish. To quote Wikipedia: > In July 2017, Air Canada Flight 759 nearly crashed into four other airliners as it attempted to land on a San Francisco taxiway misidentified as a runway: the adjacent runway was closed but the information was buried in the NOTAM. As a consequence, in September 2018, from the findings during its investigation, the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) stated NOTAMs were unintelligible and ignored, and recommended a more effective information presentation for better relevance. NTSB chairman Robert Sumwalt described NOTAMs as "a bunch of garbage that nobody pays any attention to". This led to an ICAO initiative to reform the NOTAM system.
- acwan93 4y agoCryptic codes and abbreviations are surprisingly prevalent in more places than you'd expect. Anyone working with EDI documents in medical or retailers has first hand knowledge.
- woodruffw 4y agoCertainly. Air transportation just holds particular interest for me, given that the codes and abbreviations reflect historical physical constraints: so-and-so many columns, so-and-so many inches of printable space on a ticket, etc. (This is also why I find US banking standards interesting[1].) [1]: https://blog.yossarian.net/2019/12/25/A-shallow-dive-into-the-American-banking-system https://blog.yossarian.net/2019/12/25/A-shallow-dive-into-th...
- culi 4y agoMost linters follow the 80 character limit because of the IBM punch card and Unicode and ASCII are also both full of these historical quirks. Many of us deal with these every day. I assume it's the same for people working in the aviation or medical industry
- culi 4y agoIf you visit an airline on WikiData, they have the FAA, IATA, and ICAO codes pretty well mapped out, but I hadn't ever come across an ACARS entry before. Might be worth mapping out. Example: https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q8731 https://www.wikidata.org/wiki/Q8731
- culi 4y agothe thing that bugs me the most about all this is all caps Numerous studies have shown by now that SHOUTING CASE is the slowest to read. Humans read words by their shapes not by individual letters. Capital letters lose the distinctive shapes that their lowercase counterparts often have and thereby also become more ambiguous and error prone
- dhosek 4y agoExcept that this isn’t really true. Some writing systems lack the ascenders and descenders of the Latin alphabet and reading still happens. Lowercase letters themselves are a late addition to the Latin alphabet. Most readability studies fail the replication test yet they get repeated as if they were scientific facts.
- aksss 4y agoIn a sea of lowercase prose, all caps stands out from the rest.
- tighter_wires 4y agoI have done work integrating real time systems with flight data in all of these encodings and telex for a large intl travel company that does contracts at an airport you have flown at. A lot of legacy systems are using very early web protocols like SOAP or old encodings e.g. Telex messages.
- pelagicAustral 4y agoAbsolutely hellish indeed. I had to write a parser for some kind of custom IATA PAXLST [0] (passenger list) that was coming from an ancient automated email system and I was dumbstruck by the weirdness of it all while reading the documentation. UNB+UNOA:4+SWAIR+NZCS+080708:0545+000000011' UNG+PAXLST+SWAIR+ NZCS+080708:0545+11+UN+D:05B' UNH+SWCA749+PAXLST:D:05B:UN:IATA' BGM+745' NAD+MS+++WILLIAMS:JANE ' COM+41 22 797 2025:TE+41 22 788 4689:FX' TDT+20+SW679' LOC+125+GVA' DTM+189:020322' LOC+87+BOS' DTM+232:020322’ DTM+189:020322' LOC+92+ATL' DTM+232:020322' DTM+189:020323' LOC+130+SFO’ DTM+232:020323' NAD+DDU+++WINDSOR:ELIZABETH:R' ATT+2++F' DTM+329:720623' LOC+178+NCE' LOC+22+ATL' LOC+179+MEX' LOC+174+FRA’ NAT+2+CHE' RFF+AVF:RXDWWH’ DOC+P+564SBB41' DTM+36+051215' LOC+91+FRA' DOC+V+VV258DD7' DTM+182+021212' DTM+36+0421201' LOC+91+:::MARSEILLES’ CNT+42:1' UNT+33+SWCA749' UNE+1+11' UNZ+1+000000011' [0] https://www.iata.org/contentassets/18a5fdb2dc144d619a8c10dc1472ae80/2010-api-guidelines-final-version-mig-release-date-25-11-2010.pdf https://www.iata.org/contentassets/18a5fdb2dc144d619a8c10dc1...
- rippercushions 4y agoYou think airport codes are bad, try airline codes. The IATA standard is still only two (2) letters, leading to insanity like recycling codes after one airline dies, meaning the meaning of the code is time-dependent, and, even worse, "controlled duplicates" where two airlines are intentionally assigned the same code at the same time, since they fly in different parts of the world and pinky-promise to never overlap. https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/35907/do-two-airlines-have-iata-code-n8 https://aviation.stackexchange.com/questions/35907/do-two-ai... Three-character ICAO airline codes are much better and used almost exclusively in actual flight ops, but for passengers it's still two-character codes all the way.
- cyphar 4y agoFunnily enough, CGP Grey also made a video about that[1]. [1]: https://youtu.be/jfOUVYQnuhw https://youtu.be/jfOUVYQnuhw
- macintux 4y agoThat’s the same video as the post, unless I’m missing something.
- javawizard 4y agoYou're not. GP, did you mean to link to a different video?
- slg 4y agoThis reminds me of a great stand-up bit about the process of coming up with the 2 letter abbreviations for the 50 states[1]. [1] - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dLECCmKnrys https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dLECCmKnrys
- iHateStylo 4y agoHow Dotty of you
- sieabahlpark 4y ago
- grishka 4y agoAlso interesting how old this system is and how everything is assigned once and never updated. Saint Petersburg airport is LED because the city was called Leningrad at the time the codes were assigned. Aeroflot, the largest Russian airline, has code SU, most probably because Soviet Union, and because it was the only Soviet airline.
- agurk 4y agoOne I always liked was Finnair's AY, as its original name was Aero oY. OY being Finnish for Limited Company, like AG in German, or AB in Swedish. As both Finish and Swedish are official languages in Finland that allows for the cleverly named lock company ABLOY. This stands for AB Låsfabriken Lukkotehdas OY, i.e. "Corp. Lock Factory Lock Factory Corp." in Swedish then Finnish.
- joelrunyon 4y agoIf you travel and liked wordle - you should try http://airportle.com http://airportle.com So much harder. Maddening.
- mathieuh 4y agoThat site doesn’t support https btw, you need to delete the `s` in the scheme to get it to load.
- joelrunyon 4y agoedited
- bigDinosaur 4y agoIt seems to work with HTTPS perfectly fine, with the HTTP version simply a 301 anyway.
- chrisbolt 4y agoThere's also https://airportcod.es/ https://airportcod.es/ which shows more detail behind each airport's code.
- Gigachad 4y agoWasn’t nearly as bad as I expected. If you think of the codes as meaningless IDs, there are no problems. The system is unambiguous which is the most important thing. MEL refers to one specific airport and you can know that for sure. All the problems in the video come from trying to use the letters to guess the areas they refer to. They might be related but they might also not. And that’s fine. Your booking site will let you type the full area name anyway.
- cocochanel 4y ago
- blamazon 4y agoRelative to the infinite recursion of metric paper, it is abject chaos. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pUF5esTscZI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pUF5esTscZI
- mananaysiempre 4y agoThe problem with metric paper is that A4 sucks for printing text—it’s too wide for a reasonable line length at 10 or 11pt, whence e.g. the sprawling margins of the standard LaTeX classes with the a4paper option; and A5 is definitely on the small side. (A single wide margin beside a long text column, like in the Berkeley physics course, Spivak’s Calculus, or Tufte’s books, is one possible way of taking advantage of wide paper, but it’s not used that often.) A period-2 infinite sequence with alternating 3:2 and 4:3 sheets, which in one form or another has been used for books since forever, would have been better, but apparently the committee(?) did not like it for some reason.
- thriftwy 4y agoNon-metric Letter is even wider and shorter, so it's worse by your description. I remember Firefox defaulting to Letter format when printing.
- Pxtl 4y agoI didn't realize that Canada's claiming of the Y space was deliberate in that way. I'd assumed we'd been late to the party and only the Ys were left.
- jll29 4y agoGreat video, thanks. So airport codes are no better than "standard" book numbers - ISBNs are not unique, contrary to what one may thing, and, yes, the mantra is "one book, two numbers" because there is "old" ISBN and the more recent "ISBN-13" with more digits. I started cataloging my home library using the barcodes on the books and pulling the meta-data from Amazon via ISBNs, but ever so often, the cover image pulled was for a completely different book, although the barcode contains a check sum and the Amazon data was not incorrect. The reason? ISBN re-use! (rolling eyes) This reminded me of the dude in one former company who proposed to reuse UUIDs...
- krick 4y agoMaddening mess? Come on, this is silly nitpicking. Airport codes are as clean an logical as it gets with century-old international standards. In fact, most of "maddening mess" in the video can be essentially ignored, which author basically admits by stating closer to the end that these are used by different organizations for different purposes. It is just that story is being told backwards and in a snarky voice for dramatic effect, otherwise it would become clear that IATA codes are pretty much the most natural and logical thing in the world, which would rob author of a passable video topic. There is no real pressure to use ICAO codes instead of IATA codes, and the switch would be quite complicated because of all the legacy in GDS systems, not to mention organizational effort. From the top of my head, I can come up with only one reasonably annoying thing about IATA airport codes, which is much less than most other legacy standards. While EWR can be used both as a city code and as an airport code, according to every airline in the world airport EWR belonged to the city NYC until this October (because it's "New York metropolitan area", despite being in a different state). This is no longer true, but there still are a couple of other peculiar cases like that in other countries. This is important, because airlines have different rules for fares, exchange rules and stuff for airports in the same city and different cities (like there will be different fares for round-trips and non-round-trips, and the definition of round-trip obviously depends on different airports being in the same city or not).
- fragmede 4y agoYou might (not) enjoy CGP Grey's video about runway numbering https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qD6bPNZRRbQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qD6bPNZRRbQ then, instead.
- raverbashing 4y agoRunway numbering in one HN comment: it's the magnetic heading of the runway, minus the last digit. If more than one with the same heading, add L or R (for left/right) accordingly. If more than one even with L/R markings, add 1 to the heading (or maybe take 1, not sure).
- Orthanc 4y ago>It is just that story is being told backwards and in a snarky voice for dramatic effect, otherwise it would become clear that IATA codes are pretty much the most natural and logical thing in the world, which would rob author of a passable video topic. I think most travelers, including myself until I started working on this project, have never heard of IATA and only know the ICAO codes -- which do seem like a real mess. It's weird to find out then when you look into them that a much better system exists, but it's not the one branded on the outside of all the airports!
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- gpvos 4y agoI'm not surprised that there is a connection with telegraph codes, but printing presses? Now I'm curious.
- kzrdude 4y agoStrange title for an otherwise interesting video. Why expect anything else than an organic growth with interesting quirks? It's more fon to appreciate it than deride it
- hef19898 4y agoBut deriding those things one basically knows nothing about makes you look so smart and funny. And it drives clicks and views. In reality, it is just uneducating, shallow and lazy.
- knotsofunny 4y agoThe title of the video is mostly to get views. The author mentions in a recent podcast episode he had a video in 2020 with a descriptive title that petered out around 700k views, then changed the title to clickbait "This abandoned shed may yet help end the world" earlier this year and got an additional 4 million views.
- miniwark 4y agoAnd the winner of all look like to be the Sembach Kaserne in Germany of course! Formerly 'Sembach Air Base' and 'SEmbach AnneX', and it's a military air base, so normally it would not need an IATA code... In fact this nice code seem to have disappear from the official list... to bad :-(
- hef19898 4y agoAh yeah, those nice codes! Back the day a place I worked at used four letter codes for warehouses, and they had a lot of those. Someone realized the implications once the alphabetic list hit ANA..., you guessed it. ANU.. was skipped then. Was kind sad, we had all kinds of fun imagining how we wouod comment on all the screw up of those places in the weekly meetings...
- SilverBirch 4y agoThis type of thing clearly just doesn't tweak me the way that it tweaks some people. I'm not convinced you could end up with a great way of assigning airport codes today, even if we completely started fresh and we assumed no new airports are ever created. In fact, in a lot of cases the weird corner cases are often situations where you can ask "Would it have been better to stringently apply the rule, or to bend the rule for ease of use?". Does it makes sense for London to have a LON code? Hell yeah! I live in London, I far prefer being able to go "Hey, let's just assume I can go from any London airport", because I know that LGW and LHR serve different destinations, I can get to either fairly easily. It's not maddening for anyone other than someone who wants simple consistent rules. But simple consistent rules isn't the aim, and even if it were the aim, you wouldn't achieve it without serious problems. Let's just What3Words all the airports shall we, that's consistent.
- raverbashing 4y agoPretty much this. As much as I like CGP calling it "maddening" is a bit clickbaity and ignoring a lot of history there This is like jargon, it exists for a reason, and while some choices could definitely have been better, it is what it is Oh but there is a better choice, the ICAO codes. But the "English please" crowd is never satisfied
- sigmoid10 4y agoThis is true for any area that constantly has to come up with new names for things. In physics for example, terms like "recombination," "technicolor" or just "virtual particle" have become profoundly confusing to new students, but naming everything after people or completely new invented words free of misleading context would probably be even worse. Even the term "black hole" was probably not the smartest choice in hindsight, but some people actually pushed back because they considered it obscene back then. This made people like John Wheeler only feel incited and they started publishing papers claiming "black holes have no hair" - which even Feynman thought was a bit too much. And yet today everyone acts like this is perfectly adequate terminology in physics and only people outside the field might get confused.
- 4y ago
- compsciphd 4y agopeople who complain about this remind me of Gary Gulman's comedy set on how the state's got their abbreviations. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dLECCmKnrys https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dLECCmKnrys
- skitter 4y agoInterestingly, on OpenBSD /usr/share/misc/airport lists IATA codes, but only adds airports where an OpenBSD developer has landed and confirmed it actually exists. Quoting the manpage: > There are also railway stations with IATA codes. These may not be listed, except if someone landed there by plane and survived to update the file.
- tiffanyh 4y ago“There are only two hard things in Computer Science: cache invalidation and naming things.” https://martinfowler.com/bliki/TwoHardThings.html https://martinfowler.com/bliki/TwoHardThings.html
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jmbwell 4y agoGreat! Now let’s name our data centers after airports and extend the problems into that space as well…
- BWStearns 4y agoAviation has all sorts of s/wonderful/terrible naming and encoding going on that's very historically dependent. What's the code for rain? RA of course, makes sense, English is the language of aviation after all. So mist is... wtf, mist is BR? Because brume is mist in French and the French took the lead in aviation for a bit early on because of a US patent battle. Or transponder codes. It's four digits, but not really, they only go up to 7. Why? Because the system is descendant from WWII IFF systems and 4 octals was good enough for the system design back then.
- jhbadger 4y agoBut that's like anything. Why is the symbol for hydrogen "H"? Well that's obvious. But then iron is "Fe", gold "Au" and lead "Pb", because those were named after the Latin for those elements: ferrum, aurum, and plumbum, that happen to differ wildly from English.
- BWStearns 4y agoCertainly, but we've been doing things with elements for a while now. Aviation is relatively new. It's interesting how quickly naming and process cruft accumulates.
- albrewer 4y agoThe most confusing ones that people might run into regularly are for sodium (Na) and potassium (K) since the medical conditions for having too much / too little of them are named after the Latin names - (hyper/hypo)natremia and (hyper/hypo)kalemia.
- dietsche 4y agoI enjoyed the complaining about q codes :) as a ham radio operator who does a lot of Morse code, I can tell you that they are far far from dead. QRL, QRZ, QSL and more are heard or sent over the air tens of thousands of times a day. Also the radio call signs of hams primarily start with either k, n, w, a in the USA. Airplanes have radios, so that’s why they treat those letters in a similar way along with fm/am radio stations
- wadkar 4y agoWe’re just looking at the manifestation of one of the hardest problems in software engineering - naming things. There’s no one good answer. Instead we must design our system to be “soft” i.e. malleable - able to evolve as the world evolves.
- ThePadawan 4y agoTo everyone saying "well it doesn't sound that bad", let me just point out: For a standard that supposedly started out as "we need a short code to refer to an airport", there is now a IATA code (QYG) that represents the concept of any railway station in Germany.