11 ms·
It might be a plausible argument for stuff sold 6 years ago when the future was uncertain. But in 2022 I'm not seeing how it's plausible as an excuse. Consideri
by MichaelZuo 4y ago
It might be a plausible argument for stuff sold 6 years ago when the future was uncertain. But in 2022 I'm not seeing how it's plausible as an excuse. Considering it's still being sold and marketed as 'Full self driving'.
Clearly even level 4 autonomy is far beyond what any near future technology is capable of. If at the very least due to the fact that a very commonly encountered condition, construction work, effectively requires an AGI to navigate.
Which would imply the best achievable self driving is around level 3 autonomy.
- jakelazaroff 4y agoPretend you don’t know anything about the different levels. You’re just a random person looking to buy a car. What does “full self driving” sound like to you?
- JustSomeNobody 4y agoGreat, so we're back to "unlimited data" doesn't really mean "unlimited" but, just a large amount, but not really a large amount, because... Words have meaning. Full self driving, to anyone who isn't a nerd who likes to pick shit apart, means the freaking car will drive all by itself as if a human were driving it, maybe even better.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoIt would sound like it could handle all commonly occurring road conditions. Such as rain, fog, snow, construction work, tunnels, bridges, downtown intersections, bike lanes, etc... I wouldn't expect it to handle rare phenomena such as hurricanes, hail storms, a collapsed bridge, etc...
- BoorishBears 4y agoTesla FSD can barely handle a balmy 70 degree day, so I think you'd be disappointed. I might biased because I work on actual self-driving efforts, but nothing at all about Tesla has ever indicated they were serious about solving self driving in any capacity. The day that Elon proclaimed they already had the sensor suite decided was the day that they openly admitted this was fraud.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoMy opinion doesn’t matter, but your last point resonates with me because this struck me as totally bizarre too. I don’t work in sensing let alone using AI with sensing data, but I’m around it a lot and my second-hand knowledge kind of set off some red flags. In remote sensing for landscape architecture, hydrography, and other similar fields (making sense of static things where no one is at risk of dying immediately, and humans review the data), the care and knowledge that goes into choosing sensor suites and processing the data properly is huge. Yet Tesla comes out saying “we’ve got some mediocre cameras and we’re gonna run with it!” Seriously? What? I get that it’s a lot of cameras but making sense of 3d space isn’t trivial at all. It’s so bizarre. Again, I know nothing, they know more than I do. The whole thing just doesn’t sit right.
- a1369209993 4y ago> Yet Tesla comes out saying “we’ve got some mediocre cameras and we’re gonna run with it!” To be fair, humans managed to solve self-driving with some mediocre cameras, some crappy microphones, and some unreliable force-feedback and chemical sensors, without (importantly) adding any new sensors to the hardware between start-of-project and successful full driving. So it's not a priori implausible that "use whatever sensors we have now, and just learn to compensate for any deficiencies in software", could work, since our only preexisting examples of full-self-driving (humans) essentially do that. It's just kind of stupid to hobble youself that way when you don't have to.
- user_named 4y agoHumans don't have cameras.
- a1369209993 4y agoSure they do. They're those two spherical mostly-white-with-colored-circles-on-the-front things embedded in the upper half of their face. (They usually tend to call them "eyes" for some reason.) They're closed-circuit and wired pretty directly into the brain, so it's not like webcams or recording cameras where you can semi-easily get the data off somewhere else, and obviouly they're kind of wet and squishy and not-easily-electronics-compatible like most human components, but in terms of actual functionality, they're cameras.
- secretsatan 4y agoWhy not? Do you expect legal immunity?
- amelius 4y agoDepends if you read the fine print.
- rootusrootus 4y agoThe only time I touch the controls on the car is to input the address I want to be driven to.
- jvm___ 4y agoAnd you can use it like a taxi service and send a non-driving human as a passenger. Or no passenger and just send it to an address to retrieve or deliver a package.
- ghaff 4y agoIt's probably reasonable to expect that there are some asterisks like paved roads only and can't drive in literally all weather conditions. But, yeah, no human supervision needed.
- a1369209993 4y ago> some asterisks like paved roads only Some asterisks like non-paved roads will cause poor and potentially dangerous performance, technically. If I tell it to drive into a volcano, and getting it to do so is significantly harder than five minutes of repeating various variations on "Yes, I know it's a volcano and will likely destroy the car and everything in it; do so anyway.", it's defective. (Preferably it also should not be significantly easier, of course, at least not to the point of being able to do so accidentally.)
- fbdab103 4y agoMy ultimate dream is to be able to more or less avoid flying. Hop in my car at 11pm, punch in address, pull out the lay-flat seat, go to sleep, wake-up 7-8 hours away. If I make it a day trip, I can do the entire thing in reverse never having had to pay for a hotel. Living on the coast, I would still have to resort to flying, but there are many places I would enjoy that are reachable in an eight hour drive.
- govg 4y agoYou can do this in practically every EU country, not to mention Asia (I don't know about other parts of the globe) via trains. I don't get why it has to be a car. It's just that the US has zero infrastructure for both inter city as well as intra city public transport outside of like 4 cities.
- derac 4y agoI don't necessarily disagree, but I offer a couple of counterarguments: A. Most people who bought this knew what it was, that it was unfinished, and they were funding the research (which is a public good to some extent) B. There should be some degree of burden on the customer to research what they are buying, especially with a claim as extraordinary as "Full Self-Driving"
- derac 4y agoCounterargument to myself: Elon sold it with a claim that it would skyrocket the value of the vehicles.
- rootusrootus 4y agoI never did understand how that passed the sniff test. Unleashing a fleet of self driving robotaxis wouldn't skryrocket the value of anything, it would be the fastest race to the bottom in memory.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThat particular aspect passes the sniff test for me. The race would only go so fast with a million cars produced per year, only some of which would be participating.
- rootusrootus 4y agoMaybe we should bring back patent medicines again? New, improved Radithor! If you're unhappy when your jaw falls off, it just means you should have read the fine print.
- CPLX 4y agoMaybe the burden should be on the seller to call it “unfinished and unreliable attempt at self driving” instead? The idea that we don’t let marketers make misleading product claims is very old. As a society our point of view is that no, actually the burden of proof should not be on the customer to figure out if a tube labeled “toothpaste” is actually wet gypsum or something.
- ProAm 4y agoSounds like fraud.
- CPLX 4y agoIt means a car that can drive in a reasonably broad range set if expected traffic conditions and has no failure mode that is unsafe at any point. It’s that second part that is the important one. If the car can’t drive in heavy snow or roadless areas or whatever that’s fine, as long as it’s able to recognize and avoid those situations in a graceful way, like refusing to engage with them and parking in a safe area, suggesting the trip be cancelled, that kind of thing. The current approach of it works, but when it doesn’t it will say “just kidding take over for me now” while going 70mph towards the side of a truck is definitely not that.
- hakre 4y ago> What does “full self driving” sound like to you? Well, that I would be fully self driving the car? ^^
- amelius 4y agoNo it means that you have to drive the car with your full self.
- ncr100 4y agoI feel our government should regulate this kind of speech more aggressively, to boost the safety of the public. The messaging by Tesla has been misleading, yes. There have been many other examples of couching date-slippage and over-promises with phrases like "no promises but Cybertruck|FSD|Model 3|Rockets|AI|Robotics|Neural-Link|End-Of-The-World should be here in two years." Announcing a capability, and importantly MUSK acting as a widely-recognized public figure like it's ready - shaming every other fledgling competitor, before it's ready, is amounting to GASLIGHTING. A speculate this is what we should expect from the company-owner's notable, controversial personality type. Immediately upon receiving "Full Self Driving Beta", in the 201x's, some Tesla drivers CRASHED because they turned ON the lane-keep-assist and then left the car to do the driving .. straight into the back of a stopped truck, or a split open lane-divider, and died. To reiterate, this mis-leadership has resulted in death. I suspect that CEO personality-type is a salient factor in whether a company should be allowed to operate. Should we stop this .. should we prevent actual Companies operating? Not just a group of hobbyists but tax-paying, licensed, employing companies. It is OUR government. We can stop this predictable travesty of gaslighting -> good-faith belief -> bad outcomes.
- strawhatguy 4y agoNo. I stopped at “the government should…” That never goes the way you think it will.
- ghaff 4y agoAdvertising claims are in fact regulated. There just isn't a lot of enforcement but, at normal companies, legal teams are very conservative about making claims in advertising and marketing materials. If I claim our product is better than Brand X, you'd better believe legal is going to want to see the evidence and probably qualify the statement.
- philippejara 4y agoIndeed false advertising is a thing and it's not legal(depending on where you live ? it is in most of the world that has teslas at least). The government reaching further than going for false advertising is where the slope gp mentioned would come in I assume, and on that I fully agree.
- slg 4y agoMusk is a charlatan, but why do people act like it is common to buy $40k+ cars like picking up some gum in the checkout aisle? What the features name sounds like is not the only factor here. People don’t buys cars with that lack of thought. What the salespeople say, what the marketing material says, what the manual says, what the CEO says in public, what the feature feels like during a test drive should all matter more. This isn’t a defense of Tesla. I think it still leaves an argument for fraud, but we really need a better argument than the same “the name sounds misleading when you first hear it” argument that has been repeated for years now. If that was all it took, we all would have sued cellphone companies for their “unlimited plans”.
- crote 4y agoThis isn't a "9 out of 10 dentists recommend using our product" situation, and cellphone companies have been sued for failing to deliver true unlimited plans. It is being marketed as "Full Self Driving", and the CEO is publicly saying it is "in beta", "coming next year", and "just waiting for regulatory approval". In reality it needs constant driver supervision, is still primitive enough that it is directly linked to multiple fatalities, has been coming "next year" for over 6 years, and is clearly not even remotely finished. Customers have paid thousands of dollars for a feature they are not able to use, half a decade down the line. They may never be able to use it as advertised at all. The product as delivered is substantially different from anything the company says. It's like saying your car can do 0 to 60 in less than ten seconds and then delivering a car without an engine - while putting a statement in the small writing that the car currently only reaches this in freefall from a mountain top, but pinky promise that they will install the engine in a few years.
- slg 4y agoYour comment helps prove my point because you didn’t stop at just the name. It takes more than “the name is a misleading” to be considered fraud. Tesla is guilty of more than just giving the feature a bad name. If you are arguing fraud, mention those other things. Because people don’t spend $40k+ based off a name of a feature. I can still go to Verizon’s website today and find “Unlimited” plans so the name clearly wasn’t the problem in whatever lawsuits they might have been involved in. And to reiterate, my point is not that Tesla is innocent. My point is that the most common argument used to point to their guilt is a stupid argument, especially considering there are better arguments available to argue the same underlying point.
- haliskerbas 4y agoWill not crash into stationary objects, bicyclists, pedestrians, or the cars in front of me. Will not randomly halt the car either.
- ncallaway 4y agoPretending I knew nothing about the levels “full self driving” sounds like it means I could safely nap in the back seat of the car while en route .
- mch82 4y agoTo me, “full self driving” has always meant the car has a built-in cab driver so I can work while the car drives to my parents for dinner 6 hours away, then sleep while the car drives me home. I’m not sure how the phrase “full self-driving” could mean anything other than that. Edit: When I pre-ordered a Model 3 Musk’s promise at that time was literally “press a button and your car will work as a taxi to earn money when you’re not using it”.
- jcranmer 4y ago> I’m not sure how the phrase “full self-driving” could mean anything other than that. There is some room to argue about the conditions under which the car can drive itself. If the car couldn't handle a high-grade, winding mountain road with an inch of snow on the ground and yet more coming down, I don't think too many people would be fussed is a "full self-driving" car said "uh, no" (especially as a good fraction of drivers couldn't handle that either). To my end, if the car can't handle any condition that doesn't make me go "I think I should stay home," that should disqualify it.
- newaccount74 4y agoHumans often drive in conditions were it's unsafe -- icy roads, dense fog, heavy rain, strong winds. We take the risk, and most times it's okay, except for the occasional pile-up on the highway. But I don't think a "full self-driving" car refusing to drive in those conditions would be a deal breaker. I'd prefer it if autonomous vehicles were more conservative and just refused to drive in unsafe conditions.
- sameerds 4y agoA lot like a git merge, then :)
- secretsatan 4y agoWell then, call it, self driving under perfect conditions but not as a star modifier
- 4y ago
- throw7 4y agoI know what I want. I want to tell my car to go the the shop and get serviced, come back, and take me home after work. After a flight, have it pick up my inlaws at the baggage claim exit. etc...
- wpietri 4y agoIt sounds a lot like something Musk promised in 2019: "Next year for sure, we will have over a million robotaxis on the road," "The fleet wakes up with an over-the-air update. That's all it takes." The most generous interpretation is that Musk is delusional and out of touch with his company and his technology. But I think it is more accurately described as bullshit ("speech intended to persuade without regard for truth") or a lie (making knowingly false statements). I think the interesting question is whether that legally ends up being fraud in the context of a civil suit. Whatever was going on in Musk's head (deluded, reckless, or lying) it seems like Tesla as an entity should have known that the cars were not actually self driving and that customers could reasonably think they were getting self driving.
- cwalv 4y ago> The most generous interpretation is that Musk is delusional and out of touch with his company and his technology. I'm not sure I'd describe that as a generous interpretation, but there is other evidence that he's just wildly optimistic/over-confident. E.g., he still pours significant investment/effort into his project to colonize Mars, even after describing falcon wing doors as "engineering hubris"
- wpietri 4y agoIt's not a particularly positive interpretation, but because it's the least bad, it's the most generous.
- secretsatan 4y agoBasically, steering wheel is optional, it wasn’t going to happen, it’s been clear for years
- 6510 4y agoGetting drunk every day.
- bagels 4y agoIt's pretty amazing how much money Musk's lies helped companies like Uber to waste on this stuff.
- mannykannot 4y agoI don't like how this whole thing has played out, but to be fair, I think fear of missing out over something that would, if successful, be an existential threat to Uber is probably a rational response.
- bagels 4y agoI don't completely disagree. They definitely have to be weighing the likelihood of that outcome, and Musk's statements probably made it seem more likely. That said, there are a lot of existential threats to companies that they should probably not be spending investor money on, such as asteroid defense.
- jleyank 4y agoWhat about non California weather? I imagine radar might handle fog, but driving rain as in Carolina or serious snow as in Canada?
- bsagdiyev 4y agoThe rain can be no joke here. I've had to stop driving and pull over for the first time in my life after moving to NC. The rain was too heavy to see more than 10 feet or so.
- Tempest1981 4y ago> The rain was too heavy to see more than 10 feet or so. Probably a hurricane. Did you see any cattle flying?
- bsagdiyev 4y agoNot hurricane season at the time. There's a clearly defined season for that weather. This is just a normal thunderstorm.
- ilyt 4y agoRain + city lights can make it hard to see even road markins in front. Technically self-driving car would theoretically have opportunity for advantage here (as it can just refer to maps) but practically it's super hard problem to solve.
- bsagdiyev 4y agoRain fade affects GPS does it not? Is the car relying on inertial navigation for a period? This rain is not something a camera and iffy GPS signal can keep you on the road. The intensity and amount of rain would definitely not let a camera see. Quick add: this was at 12PM (noon) on a countryish road. City lights had nothing to do here.
- kennend3 4y agoI've wondered the same thing about FSD in Canada. Often we Canadians drive on roads where we cant see the lines due to snow/ice. We sort of form our own "lanes" based on where we think the lines SHOULD be. How would a FSD Tesla handle a situation where everything is white? Even Humans who are use to these conditions still fail: https://ottawa.ctvnews.ca/opp-responds-to-numerous-crashes-on-hwy-401-in-eastern-ontario-as-heavy-snow-hits-area-1.6160551 https://ottawa.ctvnews.ca/opp-responds-to-numerous-crashes-o...
- cameldrv 4y agoWhat do you mean? Waymo and Cruise have already deployed level 4 vehicles.
- rurp 4y agoIf current Waymo counts as level 4 then we need sub-levels for them to have much meaning. They are a long way from supporting something like autonomous driving geofenced to all major US cities in all weather conditions. That big step up is still far behind true level 5, which can handle poorly maintained roads and all of the other weirdness one can encounter outside of major first world cities.
- MichaelZuo 4y agoCan you link to the source claiming that?
- ChadNauseam 4y agoWaymo offers a taxi service in SF where the cars have no driver. From https://spectrum.ieee.org/amp/full-autonomy-waymo-driver-2652903723 https://spectrum.ieee.org/amp/full-autonomy-waymo-driver-265... > The Waymo Driver operates at Level 4 autonomy, meaning, Waymo says, that “no human driver is needed in our defined operational conditions.” This, Waymo continues, represents “fully autonomous driving technology,” with the Waymo Driver being “fully independent from a human driver.”
- Shubham28 4y agohttps://spectrum.ieee.org/full-autonomy-waymo-driver#:~:text=The%20Waymo%20Driver%20operates%20at%20Level%204%20autonomy%2C%20meaning%2C%20Waymo%20says%2C%20that%20%E2%80%9Cno%20human%20driver%20is%20needed%20in%20our%20defined%20operational%20conditions.%E2%80%9D%20This%2C%20Waymo%20continues%2C%20represents%20%E2%80%9Cfully%20autonomous%20driving%20technology%2C%E2%80%9D%20with%20the%20Waymo%20Driver%20being%20%E2%80%9Cfully%20independent%20from%20a%20human%20driver.%E2%80%9D https://spectrum.ieee.org/full-autonomy-waymo-driver#:~:text...
- 4y ago
- sidibe 4y agoI think 2016 it was already widely known by the industry it was going to be very difficult compared to what Tesla was saying, especially without the handicaps they imposed on themselves. No one with knowledge took Tesla's timeline seriously > Clearly even level 4 autonomy is far beyond what any near future technology is capable of I've always been pessimistic about FSD but I think it'd pretty hard to reconcile that quote with actual L4 deployments by Waymo and Cruise
- School-Cotton 4y ago> actual L4 deployments In some of the cities with the easiest driving conditions in the world.
- Shubham28 4y agoApart from SF, they have also started testing in LA.
- kaczordon 4y agoI wouldn’t call San Francisco easy…
- sidibe 4y agoYes. And that's L4 and it exists
- Dylan16807 4y agoAn easy city is still a city. Only the low end of L4 is being reached right now, but that's massively better than "far beyond what any near future technology is capable of".
- kaczordon 4y agoThey also have remote operators standing by who jump in when the car gets confused tho…
- sangnoir 4y ago
- paulcole 4y ago> Considering it's still being sold and marketed as 'Full self driving'. The problem is that this isn’t what they do. They are extremely careful in their wording. Go back through the archive.org backups of tesla.com/autopilot and watch how their wording changes. Here’s what they say today: > Tesla cars come standard with advanced hardware capable of providing Autopilot features, and full self-driving capabilities—through software updates designed to improve functionality over time. Despite how you or any reasonable person reads it, Tesla can easily make the case that the cars (as sold today) do not have full-self driving available right now. The hardware in the cars does have the capability of allowing full self-driving at some nebulous point in the future (something that’s going to be very difficult to disprove). The other thing the do is use Autopilot (capital A) as a branded feature that doesn’t mean anything like what autopilot (lowercase a) means to a reasonable person.