39 ms·
Archaeologists ask Netflix to reclassify Graham Hancock’s docuseries as fiction
- epgui 4y agoNotice the usage of the word “cancel” in an attempt to play the victim and attract sympathy for what amounts, essentially, to intellectual dishonesty.
- pessimizer 4y agoWhen you impose a decision on someone they do not like, they do not have to play the victim, they are the victim. We can discuss whether they are a victim that you sympathize with or whether you think that they deserve their treatment, but accusing them of "playing the victim" is about as profound and distracting as accusing people of "playing the race card." edit: I need to add that it is also intellectually dishonest to dismiss arguments based on who you think the arguments have been designed to appeal to.
- flebron 4y agoThat seems a weird use of the word. By that notion, every convicted criminal is a victim, because the court imposed a sentence that they, presumably, do not like. This removes practically all meaning from the word "victim". In common parlance, well-understood consequences of one's own actions occurring does not make one a victim.
- pessimizer 4y ago> This removes practically all meaning from the word "victim". No, it removes the personal judgement from the word "victim," where we decide whether a particular victim deserves their punishment as a preliminary to discussing their situation. ----- edit: i.e. where sympathetic people who are killed are victims, and unsympathetic people are killed are being portrayed as victims. It's an attempt to distract from the material facts of a situation with arguments about language. edit 2: In the spirit of tripling down, I'm also giving this discussion more credit than it deserves. This is about someone saying that the word "cancel" implies the word "victim." So here's the implied argument afaict. 1) Using the word "cancel" to refer to an imposition on your work means that you're implying you're a "victim." 2) A "victim" is someone who is undeserving of what has happened to them. 3) This person is deserving of what has happened to them. 4) Therefore, they are dishonest.
- enkid 4y agoBut your original reply didn't say "he didn't call himself a victim," it tried to argue why he was a victim. The gp to this reply was pointing out how absurd your definition of victim is. It's not making an argument about whether or not he called himself a victim, it makes an argument about what you yourself defined as a victim.
- pessimizer 4y agoI've made that argument, and you can accept it or not. The larger point is that accusing people of playing victims is always a distraction from actual argument, and the entire thread is evidence of that. It started with irrelevance and ended nowhere.
- posterboy 4y ago> The larger point is that accusing people of playing victims is always a distraction from actual argume Yes, and when they are really playing they become the victim of their own ploy.
- bdowling 4y agoIf a court ignored the law and imposed a criminal sentence merely because it didn't like the defendant, then that would be an injustice and you would call the convicted person a victim.
- epgui 4y agoPoint of order: a non-domain-expert produced a thing he called a “documentary”, and then he was criticized for totally reasonable reasons by actual subject matter experts. Using the word “cancel” in this context is petty.
- moloch-hai 4y agoIt is petty if it specifically avoids mention of any of the evidence, and instead invents groundless personal accusations. Hancock is being proved right about his accusers.
- posterboy 4y agoIt's damning evidence enough that Netflix aren't having an expert on the show, isn't it?
- moloch-hai 4y agoMight depend on whether they were invited and declined. But inventing spurious ad hominem accusations instead of offering a plausible counter-narrative is not a good look.
- epgui 4y agoWhat exactly are you referring to when you say “ad hominem accusations”? I don’t follow.
- moloch-hai 4y agoCalling him racist.
- epgui 4y agoThey don't call him racist. Read the referenced material carefully.
- bl0rg 4y agoSome claim he's supporting racist conspiracy theories in their headlines. I'd say that's an attempt at canceling him. He's good at taking on the victim role though, I'll give you that.
- boppo1 4y agoHow is he helping a racist conspiracy theory?
- bl0rg 4y agoSomething about Atlanteans being white (I don't recall this ever being a point of Graham, and I don't think Plato mentioned it either) and bringing civilization to brown folk (who later brought it to white folk), implying that brown folk are lesser. Yeah, it's not their best work.
- 015a 4y agoTheir argument is: 28 years ago, Graham wrote a book about this theory (Fingerprints of the Gods) where he used the language "ancient white civilization". Why precisely he used this language may require deeper research, but it was at-least in part because Quetzalcoatl was described in Aztec literature as being white (to my knowledge this is not controversial), and Graham believes that the Quetzalcoatl story isn't a myth or legend, but rather a spoken-word memory of a visitor from this more-ancient civilization. Part of his theory (which is well explained in the show) is that there are a handful of ancient cultures like the Aztecs who have stories of an "enlightened visitor" like Quetzalcoatl, bringing the knowledge necessary to elevate their cultures into organized society. In other words: these ancient cultures, who are mostly non-white, were "saved" by an ancient white civilization. Having followed him loosely since then: he does not use this language anymore; certainly not in Ancient Apocalypse. If, upon reading that, your conclusion is "mainstream academia may actually be out to get him": you're beginning to understand why people like Dr. Hoopes [1] just need to shut up, go outside, and find more actual evidence to disprove him. Slinging insults like that only adds credence to his statement that mainstream academia is out to get him, which by proximity adds credence to the rest of his theories. But, what he would say is: mainstream archaeology is a lot better at insulting and talking than they are at digging; and independent of his theories, there's substantial evidence to conclude this to be true. [1] https://boingboing.net/2022/11/27/archaeologists-reveal-the-white-supremacist-nonsense-behind-netflixs-ancient-apocalypse.html https://boingboing.net/2022/11/27/archaeologists-reveal-the-...
- teej 4y agoYes, the show is clearly History channel schlock. But classify it as fiction? Give me a break. This is a waste of everyone’s time.
- globalreset 4y agoInstead of wasting time on petty stuff, how about a nice website with responses to his claims? Who, how and why built Göbekli Tepe so early? Let the facts speak for themselves.
- 1attice 4y agoBecause facts do not speak for themselves. Because what happens instead is that you repeat your interlocutor's claims, you validate the existence of a discourse at all -- and discourses necessarily have two sides. Consider the following imagined conversation: -- Alice: The Earth is hollow. Bob: The Earth isn't hollow; here are some facts about the Earth that speak against this claim. Carol: [to David, attempting neutrality] Disagreements about the hollowness of the planet continue David [to Bob]: Experts disagree on whether or not the Earth is hollow; why are you not taking Alice's concerns seriously? -- Generalizing, it's impossible to debunk an obviously false claim without subtly reinforcing the feeling that there must be some valid point being made. After all, would anyone be talking if there weren't facts on both sides? Because engaging with a batshit idea effectively helps promote it, the best thing to do with such an idea is to hustle the 'bat' out of the conversation as quickly as possible, before you find that the conversation is now entertaining angels, square circles, and multiple Atlantii. Yes, the need to downregulate dangerously absurd voices is in tension with free speech. Yes, it is still a necessary practice. Yet, ultimately, one must also make peace with entropy. Over the long term, no conversation can withstand batshit. Sooner or later, the convo will turn. Sooner or later, Alice will be celebrated.
- kodyo 4y agoWhat part was batshit? I mean, the evidence has only been moving toward Hancock’s theories over the last 30 years, not away from it.
- defrost 4y agoThey finally found a turd from Atlantis ??!! > “Why is there no evidence for this Ice Age civilization when we have plentiful evidence for hunter-gatherers all over the world at this time?” Dibble asked. “The truth is in the trash.” Every living being leaves something behind, but no refuse at all has turned up from Atlantis. “You’re going to clean up all your trash and vaporize it?”
- TeeMassive 4y agoI listed to their appearance on the JRE podcast. I didn't know much about them before that. The first half of the show they present their case relatively well (the flooding in particular kinda makes sense). But when they started talking about quantum physics and the multiverse my bullshit-o-meter went through the roof.
- api 4y agoHancock is one of those people who sounds reasonable at first. Then as you keep going it gets worse and worse. Someone told me he was going a little fash lately too. Don’t know if it’s true or not but it wouldn’t surprise me. That’s not to say absolutely none of his claims could possibly have merit. It’s just that he mixes reasonable heterodox ideas with schlock. Loads of other people on the fringe have the same problem.
- bl0rg 4y agoPeople think he's a racist because they think he implies non-whites are stupid because they got their knowledge of civilization from survivors from Atlantis. They don't really touch upon the fact that literally all civilizations would have spawned out of them, including "white" ones. I've never seen, read, or heard anything indicating that Graham is racist. Is there any substance to this, or it about as solid as his theories?
- moloch-hai 4y agoNo, the racist charge is just ham-handed ad hominem, and demonstrates his claim. Certainly the accusation was valid applied to numerous others, notably von Daniken. It probably is reflexive in this case, lumping him with them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Hikikomori 4y agoThat is the implications because the Atlantis myth has become white supremacy through deeply racist works from Helena Blavatsky and Ignatius Donnelly. Spoiler: the Nazis were really into this stuff. It boils down to that that all the non white peoples could not have done any of these things and needed help from a superior white race, robbing these peoples from their own ingenuity and heritage. Just because he isn't an outright racist doesn't mean that his theories imply that. I've not read his books but from what I've seen he likes to quote works built on the authors above that are just as racist.
- lethologica 4y agoTo preface, I have absolutely no idea about archeology or academia. I watched the first episode and I've been aware of Graham Hancock since his first appearance on the Joe Rogan podcast, but I had to stop watching this new show after the first episode. It felt like he was just purely on the defensive against 'big archeology' from the very get go, rather than presenting an interesting argument for why a civilisation like Atlantis might have existed. I may be misremembering, but I don't remember his style being so defensive when he first came into the public eye with these ideas. I think I'll still keep a distant eye on what he's saying though. His message definitely tickles a curiosity bone in my body, but I'll take it all with a massive pinch of salt.
- blindriver 4y agoI watched it with my kids (we have 2 more episodes to go). He definitely has a chip on his shoulder about being called out by archeologists, but it's a fun series and I learned a lot. He builds a pretty decent case, but it's not rock solid, but it's fun to hear. I tell my kids that the show is not proven facts, but that it's an alternate theory and the evidence he brings up sounds reasonable. But just keep it as another theory, and you consider strength of evidence as whether or not to believe it. So even if it's just a story, it's a fun story. Stuff like Gobeki Tepe, however, is pretty interesting and seems to shatter our understanding of how human civilization started. After watching the show, next year we intend to visit 2 of those sites he mentioned just for fun.
- evv555 4y ago>Stuff like Gobeki Tepe, however, is pretty interesting and seems to shatter our understanding of how human civilization started. He stacks alot of speculative but interesting claims on top of each other so it's not an all or nothing theory. I think a flooding/impact event pushing humanity into a dark age during that period is a very compelling idea. The idea that all megalithic structures come from a single lost civilization not so compelling.
- kodyo 4y ago
- nverno 4y agoHe starts off the series discussing his lack of scientific credentials, journalist background, etc., and presents the whole thing as his theory. How can that possible be construed as a 'deceptive cloak of veracity'? Let the man have his theories- I thought some of it was pretty interesting, although his raging against academia was exhausting enough to make it unwatchable after a point.
- colordrops 4y agoThey've been going after him pretty hard, calling him all kinds of names, so his defensiveness is somewhat understandable.
- nverno 4y agoI understand why he's defensive, but I found the excessive discussion of it in the series to be petty and negative- detracting from the exciting, mystical vibe of the rest of it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yongjik 4y agoHancock has been publishing since 1990s. If someone was publishing made-up theories in my professional field for thirty years (and becoming a globally known celebrity, sort of), then I'd also be pretty cranky about that.
- nradov 4y agoAll hypotheses are initially made up to an extent. Can you point out specific ways that Hancock's main hypotheses fail to match the available evidence? His claims are falsifiable, so people who care can go ahead and do the science to falsify them. Whether Hancock is a celebrity is neither here nor there. Proper science is supposed to be above personal attacks.
- kodyo 4y agoExperts are fragile.
- oh_my_goodness 4y agoHe doesn't even claim to be an expert, he says he's a journalist.
- kodyo 4y agoI'm talking about the establishment experts. They seem fantastically insecure and envious.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- oh_my_goodness 4y agoPossibly they're just annoyed that someone is spreading wild ideas that haven't been checked for accuracy. Perhaps if it was labeled "speculation" they might calm down.
- sleepybrett 4y agoHe's been churning out a never ending pile of bullshit in this vein since the 90s. At some point in 30 years one might expect he has gained some expertise perhaps reviewed some actual research. At some point he's not a journalist or an archeologist, he's just a crank.
- kodyo 4y agoAnd thirty years ago he was called a crank for suggesting what scientists acknowledge to be true now: That civilization is older than we thought.
- sleepybrett 4y ago... that is not what happened.
- marricks 4y agoWhen I was young(er) I remember the trope of old people complaining about how everything is getting worse and rolling my eyes, but as I get older... I distinctly remember growing up and watching educational dinosaur documentaries on the science channel and cool Roman history on the history channel. Couple decades later I check out those channels one is a hundred variants of "ancient aliens" and the other is... well I have no clue about the Science channel actual but the history channel definitely took a hard turn towards non-science based paranormal. I imagine the history channel was never a non-profit educational endeavor but it sure was at least somewhat educational back in the day?
- pessimizer 4y agoBravo used to show ballets and operas.
- api 4y agoSocial media has taken the same slide from helping people communicate and find information to being skinner boxes that serve streams of addictive filler. The pattern I keep seeing repeated is that things start out with positive intent but fine after a while discover that there is not only more money but more engagement and popularity to be had in making increasingly stupid and destructive material. We seem to consistently surprise ourselves with just how low our tastes actually are. Like if you took me from the late 1990s (college years) and showed me todays TikTok or YouTube I’d have laughed and thought there’s no way anyone would want to spend much time watching that schlock. It’s so low effort, dumb, boring… but human beings really do seem to just want our minds numbed. Same thing drives the opioid epidemic I assume.
- pessimizer 4y ago> there’s no way anyone would want to spend much time watching that schlock. It’s so low effort, dumb, boring… but human beings really do seem to just want our minds numbed. We've been trained into that by desperation. Social connections and celebrity have become so vital to any chance of having a middle-class income that you can't blame zoomers slaving at a repetitive drone job for long hours and token pay for carefully poring over the output of people who have been successful at gathering attention and converting it to rent.
- bhawks 4y agoPure Streisand effect that frankly feeds into Hancock's line that big archaeology is out to get him.
- dghughes 4y agoIt's so hard to find decent documentaries to watch especially my favourite subject ancient history. I tend to find that anything 15 to 20 years old seems mostly free of the stink of "ancient aliens". And I find that YouTube is the best place to find them since any current streaming services are infested with junk "documentaries". I can only speak of Canadian versions of streaming services which tend to carry slightly different libraries compared to US or international versions.
- defrost 4y agoI'd support the creation of "recent histories" that document the rise of the myth of the Atlanteans following the works of Ignatius L. Donnelly [1] [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignatius_L._Donnelly https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ignatius_L._Donnelly
- moloch-hai 4y agoIt is to Hancock's credit that he acknowledges everything was built by regular people constrained by regular physics. Accusations of racism are as reprehensible as they seem. That he is not exactly clear on regular physics is a result of his background. (E.g. confusing axial precession with solar system dynamics.) What is clear, and that justifies his complaints, is that inconvenient evidence is very systematically ignored. Would-be debunkers uniformly avoid mention of any of the inconvenient evidence motivating the speculation, or admitting the problem it presents. The word for all of them (miniminuteman perhaps excepted) is "disingenuous". Obviously journalist Graham Hancock is not going to discover the scientific truth the evidence points to. But his cohort are the only ones tackling the questions. He does have a talent for lighting on the right side of controversy, e.g. the now well-established Canada ice sheet comet strike 12,800 years ago. Which no one mentions anymore. (NB: whether the comet strike had any role in kicking off the Younger Dryas cold spell is a separate issue, of no import here.) That all of the most impressive megalithic stonework is also the oldest, and that no one knows how old it really is, should be occupying all archaeologists full-time. They could find out how old it all is, if they cared, via surface luminescence.
- stolenmerch 4y agoI'm a big fan of Hancock but also work with professional archeologists (though I am not one myself). I regularly read "kooky" topics as well as established science papers and monographs. To my eye, none of this should be this confounding -- yet it's festering into a culture war battle. Let's all chill out, not take ourselves too seriously, and just fine-tune the epistemic status of entertainment-level Netflix shows like this. Yes, Hancock is highly speculative and isn't doing archeology. He's also not a white supremacist either as many academics claim (the "canceling" part of his gripe). But let's not pretend that there is evidence for Atlantis either. For some reason this particular show is aggravating academics in a way the million Ancient Aliens and UFO shows didn't.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- screye 4y agoNote that a lot of professional-archeologist or professional-historian beliefs are also turning out to be false over the decades. Population-genomics is dispelling many commonly held beliefs of the field. Professionals hate people like him, because he uses the exact same techniques as these professionals to extrapolate towards obviously false conclusions. It puts the professionals in an awkward space, as they have to start with accepting that their own field is based on a lot of conjecture, and that it facilitates this kind of fictionalizing. This kind of fictionalizing was particularly true with non-western history of ancient civilizations where accounts were less dense, worse translated, had worse cultural context and dated back a few millennia. A lot of professional historians and archeologists have taken great liberty in interpreting the history of these regions, and the liberty taken by folks like Graham Hancock exposes some of these historians for the obvious 'fiction' that they stake their own careers on. In that sense, ancient History & Archeology is going through a similar moment as cooking did a while back. Popular FACTS such as 'Marination leads to flavor penetration' or 'searing traps the juices' have now been thoroughly debunked. Food Science exposed the 'old wives tale' aspect of cooking, and now Population Genomics is spearheading a similar disruption within academic history and archeology. The response to such an existential threat to the field is gatekeeping and defensiveness. And when a piece of work holds a mirror up to your field so brazenly, it receives the sharpest response.
- oh_my_goodness 4y agoAs you read the comments here, please remember the limitations of ChatGPT and try to be kind. EDIT: I've just had it pointed out to me that some comments here might have been created by human beings without use of a chat bot. If that's the case ... well, I'm mystified, but I apologize.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- blindriver 4y agoI have 2 more episodes to go and I've been watching it with my kids. I've truly enjoyed it, even though I don't quite believe it. To those that are interested, basically Hancock visits sites around the world that seem to show that humans had the technology to build megaliths much earlier than previously thought. Currently accepted archeology believes that human civilizations start around 6000 years ago, but some structures like Gobeki Tepe suggest that this actually happened much, much earlier, closer to 12,000 years ago. Hancock goes to various sites around the world and tries to build the case that if the technology to build these megalithic structures existed earlier than previously thought, then how is that possible? He then links ancient myths of great floods, and then links that to the Dryer Younger Impact theory, which is that around 12,000 years ago the Earth passed through a comet trail that cause catalysmic events and basically ended the Ice Age. He suggests that the civilizations that lived pre-cataclysm were able to pass technology onto human civilizations afterwards and then they died off or disappeared. I don't necessarily believe it, but it's a fun story to listen to, and after 3 years of COVID I'm desperate for stories that are intellectual, creative and new to my brain. However the article above is pretty poorly written. As far as I've seen, he has not once declared things as "fact". > Rather than presenting evidence of Atlantis from its existence, Hancock seeks to amend the legacies of existing ancient sites like the columns atop Gunung Padang in Indonesia, attributing them to advanced Atlanteans who survived their society’s purported destruction by comet. I never once heard him mention that Atlanteans built Gunung Padang, but rather that civilizations earlier than believed had the technology to build large structures like pyramids. > “Ancient Apocalypse,” however, crosses a line by claiming its hunches as fact. This has never happened, as far as I can tell from watching. He is always suggesting, and building a case, but he never declares things as facts unless they have been agreed upon. For example, Gobeki Tepi was measured as 12,000 years old by German archeologists, not by himself. I'm not an archeologist but everything he predicted the archeology community would do to him, they are trying to do. They are vilifying him for simply bringing up an alternative explanation. If they were better, they would just present their evidence but instead they attack him, try to ridicule his ideas, etc, and only make him look better. I don't understand why they have such a strong, predictable reaction to Hancock, but it definitely seems unwarranted. I would love to watch someone dispute the claims besides "This guy is stupid" or "Where is the evidence of this civilization?" I think he showed some pretty decent evidence to me, as an objective and open-minded viewer. I watched a Youtube Q&A between Hancock and Hawass, and Hawass was so rude and arrogant, it wasn't even close. He just extremely rudely dismissed the question about Gobeki Tepe from an audience member. I haven't seen anything else useful but would love to see a real honest debate. My guess is no one is confident enough they can debate Hancock though, because he builds a pretty good case for his theory.
- numeromancer 4y agoIt is not appropriate to classify this as fiction for the simple reason that Graham Hancock believes what he is saying. He may be faulting, but he is not feigning. There are likely already some documentaries which present Dr Dibble's conclusions. Netflix can and should show them.
- carapace 4y agoPlease and thank you. I got one of his books as entertainment, it's a guilty pleasure, I like "kooky" fringe stuff. So I was actually pretty stoked to see the series appear on Netflix, but then I watched the preview... It is presented as if it's not "Harry Potter"-grade silly nonsense, as if it's not fiction. Hancock might believe his own fiction, but that makes him a nutter, not a scientist nor a journalist. The problem is that this series, and say, the mushroom series about Stamets et. al., and Tyson's Cosmos are presented as if they are the same epistemologically, when they are clearly not the same. Cosmos is science. Paul Stamets is basically scientific with a gloss of pop and promotion. Graham Hancock is a kook. Normally I'm not one for the "won't somebody think of the idiots!?" folks, but I really find the presentation of the Netflix series problematical. But then the "History Channel" is full of ancient astronauts gunk, so what do I know? Tabloid trash sells.
- moloch-hai 4y agoHe is not a kook. He is just wrong about the implications of the facts. He gets attention because nobody whose job it actually is will even look at the facts. His "debunkers" carefully avoid so much as mentioning them.
- Hikikomori 4y agoWhich facts?
- carapace 4y agoMy friend, I'm sorry, he is a kook. (At best he's a kook, if he believes his own fiction he's merely a kook. He might just be trolling for the money. If so, he's a pernicious conman. But I think he's earnest. As I mentioned I'm a fan of his.) I've been reading fringe material since before the Internet was a thing, I've forgotten more weird theories than most people know exist. You can tell a kook from a journalist or a scientist w/o reference to the content, it's the form that their communication takes that gives it away. That's why this series is problematic: it conflates the three things: journalism, science, and kooky fringe "theories". (Whenever they say "ancient astronaut theorists" on those History Channel I giggle because what they really mean are "kooks". But it's fucking pathetic that that channel calls itself the "History" channel, eh? It's like a cooking channel that only showed programs about sewage treatment.)
- slashdev 4y agoGraham Hancock is a journalist, not a scientist. He doesn't pretend to be otherwise. He's likely wrong about most of his theories. But he's challenging accepted ideas in a field where accepted ideas are frequently overturned. That's useful. He stimulates the imagination and tells stories expertly, making it a joy to listen to him talk. There's value in thinking "What If" and being unafraid to think outside the box of the consensus. While being careful to understand probabilities enough to know it's likely wrong. I think Archaeologists need to be a little less uptight and remember why they go into the field in the first place. It's because their imaginations were captured by stories, told and untold, of history. Let's also not forget that every new idea in any science was once against the "consensus" view. I find it fascinating to think that civilization could have started earlier than we currently imagine. It doesn't seem that crazy to think that humans like to settle around river deltas and near the coast, and all the river deltas and coasts of 10,000 BCE are now under 400ft of ocean. What secrets lie buried under the ocean sediments? What will we discover? Graham may well be wrong about most of it, but I'd bet my life savings that there are fascinating discoveries yet to be made that will overturn what we currently think we know about human history.
- andsoitis 4y ago> river deltas and coasts of 10,000 BCE are now under 400ft of ocean. What secrets lie buried under the ocean sediments? What will we discover? With current technology isn’t there a way for us to scan all coastline to detect evidence of large settlements? If someone truly believes (and moreover fashions their entire career around) in advanced earth civilization before 10,000 BCE, wouldn’t they be figuring out a way to scan all coastline? This argument seems analogous to me to when someone tries to sell you an investment with unrealistic returns - why wouldn’t they just pocket the entire return instead of sharing?
- moloch-hai 4y agoYou expect a journalist to field tech to scan continental shelves? His role is to call attention to unaddressed questions provoked by evidence. It is historian's and archaeologists' job to answer them.
- braingenious 4y agoThis kind of makes sense depending on how you view the purpose of the show. He starts off, right off the bat, talking about how he is going against the establishment of “Big Archeology” and is subject to persecution by their shadowy machinations. It’s a very sensational idea, and my personal impression of the show was more about him trying to prove his DaVinci Code style narrative that centers himself than him trying to actually prove that Atlantis exists. His “archaeology” is tangential to (though in support of) his persecution narrative in that his thesis is about a shadowy conspiracy to hide Atlantis. For example, Behind The Curve was a _documentary_ about silly kooks that are trying to prove that the earth is flat. It was not an exploration as to whether or not the earth is flat. It would have been pure entertainment to take them at face value, like a Christopher Guest movie.
- User23 4y agoIt’s never sat well with me that anatomically modern humans are supposedly at least 300,000 years old but nobody got much past banging rocks together until around ten thousand years ago. I’m not an archeologist and I’m not claiming there were relatively advanced prehistoric civilizations, but I find the blanket claim that there can’t possibly have been ridiculous. With a glaciation or two along with various other weathering it sounds plausible to me that virtually all physical traces of, to give an example, the ancient civilizations the Vedas mention, could have been obliterated.
- nradov 4y agoNot just weathering, but also sea level rise. Settlements built on the coastline when sea levels were lower than today would leave little or no trace after millennia underwater. I'm not necessarily claiming that such settlements had any technology more advanced than stone tools, but it's difficult to conclusively prove that they didn't. Another possibility to consider is that while human skeletons might not have changed much in 300K years, it's also possible that some more recent mutations gave us the mental capacity to advance technology and build civilizations. Maybe our ancient ancestors just weren't very smart?
- Ar-Curunir 4y agoIf these societies were that advanced, would they not have figured out a fraction of the things that we have in modern times? The fact of the matter is that for a long time we simply did not have the population density to scale up to modern civilization standards
- 0thgen 4y agoThis is probably the best counter argument Ive heard thus far in the comments (not that the others were bad)
- User23 4y ago> The fact of the matter is that for a long time we simply did not have the population density to scale up to modern civilization standards That's true and I agree. But how would we know what the population density was of a conjectured civilization that would have been virtually totally destroyed over a hundred thousand years ago by catastrophic climate change?[1] I'm not positing some super society with flying cars and crystal skyscrapers or anything, but something more like the ancient Egyptian or Mesopotamian kingdoms that we do know about. There is a difference in kind and not degree between stating that it's absolutely impossible for any complex human civilization to have existed before 12,000 years ago and it's possible but we have little to no evidence for it. In the former world view any evidence to the contrary is immediately ignored as being impossible, whereas in the latter lines of inquiry remain open, despite being admittedly rather barren. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Last_Glacial_Period https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Last_Glacial_Period
- user3939382 4y agoThere does seem to be something going on with a lot of corners of academia where it’s not just about the science or evidence, which it should be, but also “playing the game” where you “pay your dues” by following roughly the same path as everyone else in the field and if you don’t, nothing you say or do will be taken seriously. That doesn’t mean everyone outside the mainstream is right, of course, but it means that when I see academics so up in arms I suspect motivations that aren’t as purely about evidence as they claim.
- rch 4y agoI live in Boulder, so I see more junk pseudoscience than usual, and I think it's out of control. It's worth noting that noted nonsense profiteer Gaia TV is based here, and I've had conversations with employees who make no apologies for what they're knowingly doing (and one who was uneasy about it, FWIW).
- fyrepuffs 4y agoThis is totally misinformed. When research is funded by corporations, we get ideas that are informed from the lunatic fringe that are based on nothing.
- adamsb6 4y agoSerious Academics are not much better in their use of conjecture and motivated reasoning. Consider this article in the New York Times in which a Real Archaeologist dismisses the idea that there was any violence involved in a large group of men suddenly meeting their genetic end: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/14/science/iberia-prehistory-dna.html https://www.nytimes.com/2019/03/14/science/iberia-prehistory... > But skeletal DNA from that period is striking and puzzling. Over all, Bronze Age Iberians traced 40 percent of their ancestry to the newcomers. > DNA from the men, however, all traced back to the steppes. The Y chromosomes from the male farmers disappeared from the gene pool. > To archaeologists, the shift is a puzzle. > “I cannot say what it is,” said Roberto Risch, an archaeologist at the Autonomous University of Barcelona, who was not involved in the new studies. But he ruled out wars or massacres as the cause. “It’s not a particularly violent time,” he said. > Instead, Dr. Risch suspects “a political process” is the explanation. In their archaeological digs, Dr. Risch and his colleagues have found that Iberian farmers originally lived in egalitarian societies, storing their wealth together and burying their dead in group graves.
- bulatb 4y agoWorld of Antiquity[0] on YouTube does a good job filling in the context around claims like this. He did one on the Netflix series[1] and has others about Hancock's take on flood myths[2], Plato's account[3], other Atlantis claims, and many other alt-archaeology topics in his Myths of Ancient History[4] playlist. He keeps it pretty civil, but he makes it clear when takes are bad or purposely misleading. [0] https://www.youtube.com/@WorldofAntiquity https://www.youtube.com/@WorldofAntiquity [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1dHNq8SURTU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1dHNq8SURTU [2] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R9PpokN1b58 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R9PpokN1b58 [3] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BqhMGVLUSB0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BqhMGVLUSB0 [4] https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLjhctHjnIbUgvin0ZlrsHg87l_k1RrKdf https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLjhctHjnIbUgvin0ZlrsH...
- moloch-hai 4y agoThe word that comes to mind watching any of those is "disingenuous". He very carefully avoids mentioning anything that might call into question what he wants to assure us he knows all about. Obviously Hancock is wrong. But he is right to be proposing answers that this smug seatwarmer is failing to even look for. His job is to present a strong case for something else, but he has none.
- bulatb 4y agoCould you give an example? It's been a bit since I watched them (except the last one) but nothing jumps to mind.
- moloch-hai 4y agoDoes he ever mention the helical groove in the tube-drilled core at the British Museum? Does he ever mention that the very oldest stonework is the most dumfounding? Or that nobody is bothering to get surface luminescence readings on any of it, since the few samples in Egypt came out 500 years too old? He picks the easiest topics, and never mentions that historians know vanishingly little of our 300,000-year past.
- archsurface 4y agoSounds like an opportunity for another series - taking the first one apart.
- geijoenr 4y agoThe problem with Graham Hancock is that he pretends to be scientific while disparaging the actual scientists. If he wants to write science fiction, great; is entertaining. But pretending to pass fantasy as science in the way he does is not Ok because some people cannot tell the difference. Is the opposite of education, with the aggravation that he is making money out of it.
- c3534l 4y agoTrue and non-fiction aren't the same thing. Conspiracy theories and crackpot ideas don't purport to be literary works. Nobody talks about papers about the luminiferous ether as works of fiction simply because they're wrong. Maybe a pendantic point, but if you're insisting on playing word games instead of boycotting purveyors of pseudoscience and crankery, then I'm going to point out that's not really what the word "fiction" means.
- StanislavPetrov 4y ago>Conspiracy theories and crackpot ideas don't purport to be literary works. The Pulitzer Prize committee begs to differ!
- dham 4y agoIt's just basic entertainment. It's cool to think about but I've watched shows like this on History channel since like 2000. Do they even play stuff like this anymore? I love this stuff. I don't know why it's such an issue now?
- StanislavPetrov 4y agoCredentialists in all corners of society feel threatened because the legitimacy and worth of credentials is (rightfully) coming under attack. This is especially true in the field of ancient archeology, where much if it boils down to, "my guess is more legitimate than your guess because I have some letters in front of my name!"
- GolfPopper 4y agoOne significant bit on information I don't see mentioned yet: "Hancock’s son, Sean Hancock, coincidentally works at Netflix as a senior manager of unscripted originals." https://www.whats-on-netflix.com/news/ancient-apocalypse-graham-hancock-to-present-netflix-original-docuseries/ https://www.whats-on-netflix.com/news/ancient-apocalypse-gra...
- anshumankmr 4y agoReverse nepotism?? that's a first
- unity1001 4y agoGraham's arguments have strong merit - the presence of the myth of 'civilizing HERO coming from the water with a BOAT, teaching agriculture, infrastructure, civilization' in regions that are not known to have had any contact until modern age points to one of the below: - There was a 'civilizing hero' or heroes that visited those totally disparate regions and this points to the presence of a localized, capable civilization that was able to travel the globe - Or, the majority of the cultures of the age were much more capable than what we previously thought, being able to travel large distances and have exchanges in between them and therefore this myth was shared. If the mythology was 'Divine being descending from the skies to teach things', that could be understandable. Because thats what many people could easily imagine, and what many cultures already had as a myth. But the myth of a 'civilizing, normal, human hero that visits here and there and teaches agriculture, infrastructure in the same manner' is too uniform and ordinary that it would be legitimate. This is without the commonality of those heroes having the habit of carrying a small bag in most of those myths. However, even more important is astroarchaeology or whatever they call it - in the absence of writing and lingua franca, sky is the only constant for all humans. And its normal for humans to try to record events and their dates using this only existing universal language - after all, there is no way that your wise men wouldnt know how to read the stars and their time-location analogies, right... Therefore if they recorded the date of a significant event using the position of the objects in the sky, surely not only your own tribe's wise men would know how to read it, but even the humans in the future. (they never thought we would invent something like writing and forget such traditions). Based on that, indeed, a lot of the prehistoric monuments point to a certain date at the end of younger dryas, which these prehistoric cultures described as catastrophic, cataclysmic in their monuments in different parts of the world. Which also explains the differing flood mythologies that exist in totally isolated cultures. Graham seems to be the pioneer here. And the conservatism of modern scientific establishment, which descends from its scholastic roots that shaped in the shadow of Christianity that always prefers to explain history in a linear, developing fashion, shows itself again. Note that humanity losing its accumulated knowledge is not an extraordinary thing. It happened many times before regionally, even continentally. Even today, our knowledge takes a LOT of effort to keep in the form of scientists, educators working everywhere, every day to catalogue and maintain it - it is a globe-wide effort. Yet we could still lose a huge swath of that knowledge if we end up having a nuclear war or another global catastrophe that will kill vast amounts of people and destroy large amount of infrastructure, therefore disrupting this extensive system of keeping knowledge. In the earlier ages, it would be much easier. Just remember the Library of Alexandria. And that, when writing existed and records of some knowledge at Alexandria was already duplicated and kept elsewhere. Imagine an era in which there wasnt writing but the wise-men relayed knowledge from generation to generation or inside their group/clique by teaching it through oral means. Just a small plague, a war, a major famine would cripple such knowledge-keeping systems. So it is possible that humanity may have had more advanced cultures or even what we would call civilizations (minus writing, maybe even that) that were lost because they were too localized and one major catastrophe crippled them...
- chris_wot 4y agoWhy did they never ask the History Channel to reclassify Ancient Aliens? Is there something they aren't telling us?
- motohagiography 4y agoShows like this could be a way to get real academic expedition funding though. Give up a bit of cred to let them tell their story, and you get a week on a research vessel paid for by television viewers to collect all the data you want. Personally, I would be pitching their show my exploration and field research proposals. Hell, do a real science television show and just bring one of these guys along to make it entertaining enough for everyone to watch, and use it to fund real science going on in the background instead of junk science.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoMy problem with this documentary was the editing style. Too stylized and sensationalized to be taken seriously. Hancock’s work does raise some important questions but this isn’t the way to present them.
- 8bitsrule 4y agoGraham is often reporting (presenting observations) of facts that are overlooked by the mainstream. He has spent a lot of time and money and travelled-widely gathering those observations. As with any hypothesis, people will disagree with the interpretation of the observations. That's how the game works, and how science advances one funeral at a time. (Plate tectonics for one fine old example. The YDIH for a much more recent other.) Sometimes evidence is ignored because it can't be right. (For example, no skeletons 7 or more feet tall have been found in North America ... 'those newspaper stories, all hokum'. Or, anyone who radio-dates bones at human sites in NA that are 24k or 130k or 200k years old has simply made a mistake. 'Incompetent. Take away their funding.' Or, it's our consensual opinion that it's most likely that the natives killed all the megafauna for food.) Graham (for one) has a real knack for looking at a lot of ignored evidence, pulling those pieces together and presenting hypotheses that often pass the Occam test. I've learned a lot reading of his discoveries. As to the 'truth' of it all, time will tell (or the coverups go on). Funny seeing the insiders getting all riled.
- Nursie 4y agoCan you tell me - if he was a hack pushing nonsense theories, rather than an outsider being suppressed by the orthodoxy, how would you expect things to look different?
- bearmode 4y agoI would say it's incredible how many people on here are actively supporting Hancock on this, or are at best pretending to not understand what the big deal is. But then I remembered that this site is full of the exact sort of people who lap this shit up.
- TillE 4y agoYeah people here were promoting all sorts of weird covid / vaccine conspiracy theories too. It's contrarian brain, I guess.