29 ms·
The War on General Purpose Computing (2015) [video]
- anigbrowl 4y ago(2011) And a bunch of these predictions never materialized. Subscription models are more widespread, but there's also more and better choices for opting out, and a much richer variety of development targets and ecosystems to mess around in.
- TeMPOraL 4y ago> Subscription models are more widespread I didn't think it before, but I think it now: this is what kills general-purpose computing - subscriptions, and everything-as-a-Service in general. They make the actually important part of the offering gated and completely outside of your control. You're left holding an interface to a remote thing that can refuse to operate for any reason, including you trying to use a general-purpose computer to access it. This is not a hypothetical anymore. > there's also more and better choices for opting out, and a much richer variety of development targets and ecosystems to mess around in. Mess around in, yes. Use in practice? Not quite. I think the most clear and worrying trend is remote/hardware attestation on mobile, in combination with subscription model / SaaS as mentioned above. The litmus test here is banking apps[0]. Banking is very much critical to life in the modern world, and banks are strongly pushing for having a mobile app as hard dependency[1] - and those apps make use of remote/hardware attestation. Ostensibly it's for your own safety, but as a side effect, you lose control over your own device. The use of those attestation APIs is accelerating[2]. In short: yes, you have a "much richer variety of development targets and ecosystems to mess around in", but if you don't sign the right contracts and the platforms aren't properly locked down, "mess around" is all you're going to be able to do with it. ---- [0] - Though I suppose the first real warning was gaming. DRM on media or games alone wasn't considered as worrying, because you could always find alternative source. But anti-cheat measures on multiplayer games are the first well-known DRM applied to an activity whose entire value sits in the network that's out of your control, and therefore not substitutable. You can't torrent a CoD or DotA multiplayer match. [1] - Even if you use the web interface for everything, which many banks don't provide, there's a push for using the app as the auth tool - if you do, then the app becomes a hard dependency for you anyway. [2] - The APIs are increasingly easy to use, increasingly promoted (at least in the Android world), and increasingly hard to hack - from what I read as an outsider, they've completely gutted the custom ROM scene for Android, as whatever cosmetics/QoL improvements you gain are not worth the functionality loss.
- shmerl 4y agoRelevant as ever. See also: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HUEvRyemKSg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HUEvRyemKSg Try to buy a 802.11ax WiFi router that allows running open OS. Good luck with that!
- user3939382 4y agoGCP is like (at least in the US) our right to free speech or privacy. It’s amazing but people either don’t want it, don’t care, or in any case aren’t willing to fight for it, while on the other side, world-dominating govts/megacorps benefit from it disappearing - so it will. Ultimately I’ve accepted that if the People aren’t willing to fight for these things, they don’t deserve them.
- amalcon 4y agoThe idea that free speech is disappearing in the US is patently absurd. Check out the Sedition Act of 1918 if you'd like to be informed on the progress we've made. The speech clause of the first amendment is stronger than it was for about 75% of the existence of our country. There's been a somewhat weird trend lately of the free speech of corporations being prioritized over that of individuals, but people care deeply about that on both the left (opposition to the Citizens United ruling) and the right (opposition to content-aware acceptable use policies). Take a slightly longer view and it seems insignificant, next to literal prosecutions for handing out pamphlets opposing the draft. Same with general purpose computing: it's more accessible than at any time in history. Most people who use only a computing-based appliance like a smartphone today, simply would not have had a computer twenty years ago. Meanwhile I can buy a new Raspberry Pi 4 (definitely a general purpose computer) for less than 25 hours' minimum wage -- try doing that in 2002. The problem is not availability, or that someone is trying to quash it. The problem is that most people just are not interested. Those who are interested have at least as much access as they ever have.
- smitty1e 4y ago> The idea that free speech is disappearing in the US is patently absurd. Lorie Smith's case[1] seems to argue otherwise. If the law can be used to compel speech, then the slippery slope to tryanny is well-greased. [1] https://restorationnewsmedia.com/articles/local-news/both-sides-see-high-stakes-in-web-designers-supreme-court-case/ https://restorationnewsmedia.com/articles/local-news/both-si...
- nerdponx 4y agoPeople don't understand what they are losing, and it's easy to look the other way when everything seems fine from your current perspective.
- nonrandomstring 4y agoWe need a civic cybersecurity bill. Nor for corporate interests but one written by the people to explicitly protect us from corporations and governments.
- generalizations 4y agoWe just need to sign an open letter that says what we, as developers, will and will not build, and what kinds of ostracism will result from not signing or not adhering.
- scottLobster 4y agoI hope this is sarcasm, otherwise it's rather naive. This may shock you, but lots of devs are not on reddit or HN, and do not participate in OSS development. They won't even know such a letter exists unless someone higher up the nerd tiers told them. For such a letter to have any teeth we'd need a nationwide developers union to enforce it, otherwise it would be just more impotent righteous noise on the internet
- jrm4 4y agoI so wish this would be a viable thing, but it's not, especially right now. In a way, you can blame "STEM", right? So many people in here, someone would likely sell out. Law/Policy/Liability and whatever other methods one can get skin in the game are the only answer. Harmful software has to be punished.
- yoyohello13 4y agoI hate to break it to you, but many, many devs out their (yes, even on HN) are more than happy to sell their soul for a salary bump.
- goosedragons 4y agoA digital rights bill. No, you can't label that button "buy" and then turn around 6 months later and delete it from my account. No, you can't go out of business and just turn off the DRM servers without removing the restrictions. No, you can't just add DRM to physical crap so you can get a monopoly, etc. Yes, users have the right to format shift your crap. If you want them to rebuy to use on X device add something worthwhile.
- jmclnx 4y agoI did not view the video, but I believe "General Purpose Computing" is coming to an end. With everyone moving to Cell Phones plus the boot lockdown (Secure Boot) and things like Intel ME, TPM, future is not looking too bright. And I heard Microsoft is requiring some new addition to Chips that Windows will need which seems to be a kind of backdoor (I forgot what it is called). I am sure many people here have seen this, looks to me this is the direction society is slowly heading towards: www.gnu.org/philosophy/right-to-read.en.html
- als0 4y ago> And I heard Microsoft is requiring some new addition to Chips that Windows will need which seems to be a kind of backdoor (I forgot what it is called). It's called Pluton, and (scarily) there is not much public technical information about it.
- cokeandpepsi 4y agoIntel should be figuring how to fix sleep on their chipset, the company is managed by idiots and we just injected them with billions of tax payer dollars so they can continue this b.s.
- taftster 4y agoJust some links for the lazy: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/security/information-protection/pluton/microsoft-pluton-security-processor https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/security/informati... https://www.howtogeek.com/779095/what-is-microsofts-pluton-security-processor/ https://www.howtogeek.com/779095/what-is-microsofts-pluton-s...
- wizzwizz4 4y agoNote that none of this is technical information; it's just broad descriptions of the sort that you could've written in 2005. It's not clear in your links, but I think Pluton updates work like microcode updates. There's a nice quotation from the end of the How-To Geek article: > As long as these measures don’t prevent us from running software we actually want to use, Pluton is a welcome development.
- WarOnPrivacy 4y agoFrom 2015, I believe. This could be a good point to assess Cory Doctorow's assertions.
- stingraycharles 4y ago2011 even, I found this talk from him on YouTube from then: https://youtu.be/HUEvRyemKSg https://youtu.be/HUEvRyemKSg
- Synaesthesia 4y agoI think we're continuing to march down that road in various ways, if you look at smartphones, iPads, even arguably MacBooks now, (I know enthusiasts have hacked their own Linux onto M1 but still ... Not open) Hardware is still totally not open, period. Try buying a PC with an open source BIOS or CPU, you can't!
- Retr0id 4y agoLinux on M1 wasn't a hack, apple allowed it to happen. There is certainly a lack of hardware docs (which is unfortunate), but apple did nothing to prevent users from being able to execute their own kernels, which I'm happy to see.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoGet back to me when they upstream their drivers.
- runjake 4y agoIn fact, Apple helped it along, somewhat. https://twitter.com/marcan42/status/1554395176025849856 https://twitter.com/marcan42/status/1554395176025849856
- est31 4y ago> Try buying a PC with an open source BIOS or CPU, you can't! https://support.system76.com/articles/open-firmware-systems/ https://support.system76.com/articles/open-firmware-systems/ The "open firmware" marketing term is a bit of a misnomer here as there is probably plenty of closed source firmware in those devices in various components, but at least the BIOS is open source.
- jmyeet 4y agoThere is no “war” on general purpose computing. There is a clear realization that the vast majority of people cannot securely run and maintain an open computer. Perhaps more importantly, they just don’t want to. People want appliances like smartphones. That’s it. The more computers there are the more dangerous bad actors becomes and the higher the cost of negligence. Botnets, DDOS attacks, etc. the only real way to combat these is at the source and that’s by taking away management of those devices from most users.
- postalrat 4y agoUsers like yourself. edit: I don't mean this as an insult. I wouldn't want people to read "most users" and assume they aren't in that group.
- rektide 4y agoYour assertion would be worth considering if any alternative had been given even 1/1000th the effort the prevailing corporate-run paradigm has been given. Confident assertions we are where we are because this is what people want, when no alternative has been presented or tried, is ridiculous. Then you go on to assert that authoritarian control is the only viable option. Here we have counter examples! Systems like Pop!_OS are parallel efforts to desktop systems like mac or windows, not designed for masterful smart supernerds but just to ne viable desktops for all, without fiddling, with safe-enough defaults. It didnt take suborning users under corporate whip to get here. Windows & Mac also show general purpose computing is in the broad possible- would that phones have at least this much freedom. But they dont.
- ryukafalz 4y agoRight - you can't make conclusions that people's choices are the result of some revealed preference when there aren't viable alternatives readily available. I'm reminded also of our car-dominated cities in the US. In our current built environment, cycling isn't considered as an option by most because it doesn't feel safe. But cities around the world have shown that if you change the infrastructure such that it does, people will start cycling. The high car usage isn't a revealed preference, it's the result of a lack of other options. So too with tech. The only options typically available for smartphones are Android with Play Services and iOS, and while it's possible to have Android without Play Services, you won't find phones sold that way unless you're technical enough to know what to look for, in which case you can probably install it yourself. (And things break in weird and wonderful ways without Play Services, because much of what we now consider core functionality for a phone has been moved into it.) Effectively, for the typical user, it's not an option. Likewise with Linux desktops; they're more available than the phones mentioned above, but they're still not likely to be found where people typically buy laptops and desktops. You have to specifically go seeking them out, meaning the typical shopper doesn't even see them as an option.
- datalopers 4y agoWhere’s the AI model to watch and summarize this talk into a couple of pages of written content?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Jenda_ 4y agoTranscript of a 2011 version: https://boingboing.net/2012/01/10/lockdown.html https://boingboing.net/2012/01/10/lockdown.html The version linked here seems to be more about collected examples of such war, DRM, right to repair etc.
- Garlef 4y agoAch. I don't know. I think that general purpose computing is simply changing. It's not going to be "A man and his Linux in a basement" anymore but rather "Let's run some code in a remote distributed serverless runtime". Cloud Excell for the masses. One part where we can already see this is how cloud environments like colab, hugging face, repl.it, etc remove some parts of maintaining a full installation of an OS. If you just want to write some python and run it on a GPU you don't have to buy a GPU, install drivers, etc anymore. We should be happy that we won't have to care about the bare metal (unless we want to).
- matlin 4y agoThe downside to this future is that it, being the shift from applications to services, means instead of your data living on your computer it is instead fragmented across a bunch of other random places. While most consumers don't really care and actually prefer the switch to everything being cloud-first, the stagnation it can cause for other developers is substantial. E.g. If I want to make a cool email client, I don't have to ask the user's permission to send and receive emails, I have to have Google's permission to access their machine and to make this compelling as Gmail, I have to then store all of my user's data on my own servers. This compared to me just writing a client-side application that has no server requirements is a huge bust IMO. My preferred future is where every user has their own server that can run general purpose applications. It would have all the benefits of the cloud (data available across all of your devices) and would grant developers more freedoms to create compelling experiences. The future, I want is that some high schooler could create the next Google Docs without having to compete with Google on large scale data infrastructure and security but instead on user experience.
- Garlef 4y ago> every user has their own server I think we're on the same page. The only difference is that I think that the OS/Server/Filesystem is a big hinderance for many applications. I just want an environment where I can to execute arbitrary code. My version would be *> Every user has their own remote code execution environment. One good candidate for the near future would be serverless WASM runtimes backed by serverless databases. (But you'll still have to store your codebase in a file system.)
- c7b 4y ago> ...UK's David Cameron, who've joined in with the NSA and GCHQ... What year is the article from? David Cameron resigned as British PM in June 2016 and as MP in September. He since seems to have held a number of positions on charity and corporation boards, I couldn't find anything that would tie him to current political decisions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- OJFord 4y ago2015, per the URL for the linked talk video.
- jrexilius 4y agoHe's absolutely right and it is a very bad place to end up, despite the supposed convenience for consumers. There are a number of problems that create a bit of rock-and-hard place. We (consumers) want to hold vendors accountable for policing "hate speech", kiddie porn, or terrorism, and various other centralized exercises of power that align with personal political whims. We want convenience and constant new features. We want things to work smoothly. We sorta care about security, as long as its not inconvenient. And we don't want to pay up front for any of it. Better still for it to be free with some ads. Governments are legitimately concerned with terrorism, nation-state influence campaigns, industrial espionage, and law enforcement. They have to solve these problems, with constrained resources, in a technology environment that moves far faster than they can. They will push the regulation tools they have, as hard as they can, to solve these problems, if we let them. There are almost zero short-term consumer/voter/elected-offical incentives for free, open, secure, interoperable systems. In fact consumer, political, and financial incentives are all aligned, currently, towards centralization of power and walled gardens. And the Silicon Valley model really is eating the world. This is why open source has become so incredibly important. Open source hardware and networks doubly so.
- dbspin 4y agoOne minor correction - no one 'wants' ads. People are reluctant / unable to pay for the hundreds of daily services they use, given the death by a thousand cuts nature of subscriptions, and the failure of microtransactions to ever become a reality. So we tolerate ads (to a point). But no one actively wants ads. This isn't a social contract that was agreed to. In fact, enormous numbers of people go out of their way to avoid them, online and off - using ad blockers, arriving late to the cinema, 'pirating' media they already have 'legal' add riddled access to. Completely agree with you in relation to the bad incentives at work, but adverts are not a desires outcome either.
- em3rgent0rdr 4y agoI want ads to a certain extent. Particularly when they are informing me of something that I likely want but wasn't aware of and which I wouldn't have stumbled upon without the ad.
- mjh2539 4y agoUnless someone waves their magic wand and makes it to where manufacturing microprocessors requires nothing but sand and electricity, things will go whichever way those with capital want them to go.
- tomxor 4y ago> Because it's the nervous system of the 21st century. We've got to stop treating it like a political football. Remember this, when anyone brings up mindless arguments against encryption or promotes other policies eroding the internet. The internet is invaluable to modern society, in the same way that the wheel is... politicians don't fuck with wheels, even though they are invaluable tools for criminals and terrorists, no one would be stupid enough to risk breaking wheels. Politicians need to wake up and realise that the internet is not a toy.
- pfoof 4y agoYou are expecting too much from undeveloped brains of politicians
- TeMPOraL 4y agoI'd say it's more like, they don't understand this thoroughly enough, as it's not their wheelhouse (sorry), so when someone will come to them and tell, "we can make wheels unusable for terrorists and child traffickers while not breaking them for law-abiding citizens, using the magic of our TECH", they will listen and believe it. And, of course, the TECH will be bullshit, but the laws will be changed to support it, and it'll make wheels less useful for people while not affecting terrorists at all, but hey, you should be happy your wheel subscription comes with so many colors this season! And have some patriotic pride, after all, our wheels-as-a-service companies account for a third of our GDP! Case in point: DRM.
- BryanA 4y agoHe gave an interesting follow-up talk as well: https://youtu.be/O_8J9rN1wug?t=477 https://youtu.be/O_8J9rN1wug?t=477
- college_physics 4y agothe outcome of that war depends, imho, largely on whether digital computing will continue evolving at breakneck speed or whether it will become commoditized, generic and (dare I say it), open source in the former case the current pattern of abusive oligopolies will persist as society continues being dazed and confused about the new toys and suspends critical judgement but we might be erroneously projecting the rapid developments of past decades (and the idiosyncratic events and actors that shaped them) into a future that is increasingly driven by other dynamics for one thing, the pace of innovation/adoption seems definitely to be slowing down facing a combination of technical and behavioral limits. a few more years without self-driving cars and regular space travel tourism and we might start having a second look at what has been the quid-pro-quo of all the tech hoopla. awareness of the dangers and pitfalls of surveillance capitalism (which is now the de-facto economic model through which computing is deployed) is diffusing, slowly but surely. finally, the ability of a tiny crowd of severely under-resourced hackers to maintain fully functional alternatives, whether that is the linux desktop, its huge collection of applications or the fediverse, shows to anybody that cares to look that there IS an alternative. Once/if the TINA spell is broken revisiting the role of computing in society may get us into completely different directions and the suffocating status-quo may forever be a thing of the past
- cratermoon 4y ago"the sunsetting of the consumer-welfare standard", as he writes, can't come soon enough.
- tannhaeuser 4y ago(2015)
- dang 4y agoI wish I'd seen this before spending 5 minutes tracking that down. Added above now. Thanks!
- dang 4y agoRelated threads. Others? Lockdown: The coming war on general-purpose computing (2012) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32224751 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32224751 - July 2022 (87 comments) We will win the war for general-purpose computing - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27859463 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=27859463 - July 2021 (178 comments) Taking a Stand in the War on General-Purpose Computing - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26242991 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26242991 - Feb 2021 (287 comments) The Coming Civil War over General Purpose Computing (2012) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24866279 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24866279 - Oct 2020 (210 comments) Lockdown: The coming war on general-purpose computing (2011) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19872364 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=19872364 - May 2019 (59 comments) Lockdown – The coming war on general-purpose computing (2012) - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14335261 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=14335261 - May 2017 (96 comments) The coming civil war over general purpose computing - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4436139 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4436139 - Aug 2012 (98 comments) Lockdown - The coming war on general-purpose computing - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3448754 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3448754 - Jan 2012 (46 comments)
- alwayslikethis 4y agoI've made it a personal rule that I would not pay to buy something I cannot own. Barring government regulations, if something does not give me full (theoretical) control of its functionality. Though, this is subject to some practical considerations, such as cost. If I can sufficiently limit the damage some unowned device can do (such as by not connecting to internet), and it is cheap enough second-hand, then I can still consider using it.
- mikewarot 4y agoSevere Minority opinion warning I believe there are some technical root causes that must be addressed, as well as those political and other issues. Unfortunately, the non-technical problems highly discourage proper technical solutions to these issues. I'll enumerate them here anyway. 1 -It's practically impossible to secure the hardware. Even CPUs have embedded control systems that form "management" layers hidden from everyone. Nothing built on top of this traitorous layer can ever be safe. It's possible to build something completely open and reasonably secure, but the market discourages it. 2 - RAM is unacceptably bad, most systems lack ECC as well. If we had properly tested and validated RAM, RowHammer wouldn't work, ever. 3 - The Operating systems themselves are usually modeled on Unix/Linux in some fashion, where there is no capability based security[1]. We're using a security model that was fine for the relatively low threat environment of small network of computers all serving one employer. It's entirely unfit for purpose in 2022. Note: If you assume I'm talking about "allow this app to access X", you really need to read the Wikipedia page. So, with the current Tower of Babel that is the software world, everyone blaming everything but these root technical causes, because there are fortunes to be made selling what are effectively band-aids in the field of CyberSecurity. I firmly believe it's possible to fix this, all the way up and down the stack, but I'm having doubts about my own ability to survive until that day happens. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capability-based_security https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Capability-based_security
- fsflover 4y agoIsn't security through compartmentalization a better security model? > I firmly believe it's possible to fix this, all the way up and down the stack, but I'm having doubts about my own ability to survive until that day happens. Did you consider Qubes OS, a security-oriented OS?
- mikewarot 4y agoWhile Qubes is close to virtualization, etc. in terms of separating environments, it doesn't provide capability based security. Nor does it address the underlying insecurity in hardware.