11 ms·
The best leaders are great individual contributors, not professional managers
- lakomen 4y agoThat is not true, an urban myth. Leaders who don't want to be leaders are bad leaders. I lead a guild once, because I wanted to decide how my time was spent and didn't want other people to decide for me. I didn't want to be a leader. I don't want to tell people what to do. I don't want to give orders everyone else has to follow. I like the team approach. But people are conditioned to follow. Except they aren't following... when you apply too much pressure. I set up a website to plan raids. Paid for a domain. Went through the hassle to configure it and a discord server and a bridge between those and all I wanted was that people fucking sign up or off from raids. I asked them when they're available and made a plan most people are comfortable with. Only 5 out of 30 people did even register on the site. They joined the guild because it was advertised as a raid guild with social spots but raid being the main theme. A RAID GUILD. After 2 months I was so stressed out that I simply abandoned the guild and left the game. I can't do everything alone. When I said that I never felt so stressed out in all my life 2 people offered to help with leading raids but at that point it was too late. Some players joined from other guilds, got spell upgrades for free, then left the guild. Some people joined from other guilds to cause drama and distress. This is of course not real life. But it's close. You don't pay your members money for work and can't expect they follow guidelines. But holy crap, can you at least expect some interest in the main theme of the guild and them to sign up on the site and sign on and off of raids? I never wanted to be leader. I feel well in the role of an advisor, someone who helps lead. But not the sole person responsible for everything. I'm not perfect. No one is. I was overwhelmed because every piece of the hierarchy in the end asked me what to do. And if I postponed answering things would get worse. In software development I can be agile and change things around, but people demand stability. They want a bed already made but are not willing to do the effort to build that bed. In retrospect I should've continued and "fired" 90% of the members even if that meant the end of independent raiding. But I was too stressed out and losing key people, because that game was designed around key roles being present in a raid. I didn't make the necessary decisions because I didn't want to lose anyone and not piss anyone of. But in the end key people left regardless. So lesson learned if you do something, focus on just doing that one thing and don't get ballast on board in the first place. It's better to have a small, dedicated group, seeing eye to eye, than a large group where the majority doesn't care about success. Anyhow, see I wasn't a good manager, despite me not wanting to be a manager.
- instance 4y agoI know an amazing IC at a software company I once worked at that I still keep in touch with. He has extremely deep technical knowledge, which you can simply deduct from basically everyone in the company (even from other teams) coming to him for advice. He's been at the company for >10 years. He has strong opinions on current processes and just getting things done. This post resonated deeply with me, since I've discussed before with him his role and how it could evolve. I know for a fact that he dislikes lots of meeting and really likes working on the core product, and so far hasn't really jumped on the opportunity to go into management - he doesn't really want to be manager. So he is kind of exactly the guy the post is describing. The company is growing though and he is very slowly getting pushed by the head of development into a more managerial role.. Let's see how it works out. I believe he is going to be a great manager though.
- phkahler 4y agoSome of the best I've seen are highly technical people who moved into management and then realized they can actually do more by leveraging their people. It's not the same hands-on, but they enjoy working with others to get things done.
- codexjourneys 4y agoAgree that great managers are sometimes individual contributors who take on the job because they believe doing so is the only way to ensure effectiveness. But it's important to filter for ego-as-motivation, which can make for a terrible manager.... There's another type of great manager, too, whose best quality is their ability to defend the team from b.s. and politics originating elsewhere in the organization. This is especially valuable in large, established companies.
- tartrate 4y agoReading the article, according to Steve Jobs, the best managers are the people who are so good that they realise that they must do it themselves, even if they don't want to. The title of the article thus has only a necessary but not sufficient condition according to what Steve originally meant. In other words: Clickbait.
- obblekk 4y agoThis is true but nuanced in my experience. Often the best managers look around, see other managers being incompetent and messing up people’s natural abilities, and want to fix the problem even if it requires them to become managers. Often the worst managers decide at a young age they’re good leaders, can lead people to do better than they would themselves, and decide they want to get into management. I make this distinction because even group 1 managers usually have to raise their hand and say something like “can we please stop messing this up. I can help.” Rarely is an awesome individual magically called upon to become a manager, particularly by poor managers who are already messing stuff up. In an environment where management is good, there’s a longer cycle of development, mentorship, and nudging of high potential people into management. But if you’re not in that environment, you probably need to ask to help make it better. It won’t happen magically.
- mdorazio 4y agoI’d say the worst managers are the ones who decide that management is the best path to money, competence and effort be damned.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>management is the best path to money, competence and effort be damned Basically every German company ever. ICs be dammed.
- formerly_proven 4y agoWhere management is literally the only career path in almost every company.
- thih9 4y agoAnd you get promoted until what you do changes so much that you’re not good at it anymore, so you can’t justify another promotion and you remain a middle manager.
- debacle 4y agoBeing a manager is like having kids. A lot of people don't want to have kids, because they see how other people's kids behave. You can do the right things and raise incredible children. A lot of people don't want to be a manager, because they see how other people behave as managers. You can do the right things and be an incredible manager.
- quelltext 4y agoUnfortunately, my impression is that there are more bad examples than good ones. I have some notion of what I'd want my managers (or I if I became one) not do, but I don't know what is necessary to be a good manager.
- TimPC 4y agoI think you have a very skewed view on why people aren’t having kids. Many people want kids but choose not to have them because they can’t afford enough space for them or don’t want to raise them while living with their parents. The number of people scared off by watching a few bad apples misbehave is a negligible fraction.
- gardenhedge 4y agoI think this is wrong and is an unhealthy way to look at management. Comparing workers to kids is.. not defensible.
- 988747 4y agoBut in many countries this view is even directly written into the law. In my country for example, employer must know at all times where the employee is, because they are responsible for any accidents that happen to them during the work hours. And to avoid those accidents you have to provide them with stupid things like instruction manuals for microwave, or electric kettle usage, because apparently employee cannot be trusted with operating those devices safely. You, the employer are also responsible for doing their taxes for them (i.e. paying monthly deductions), as well as sending them to the doctor every once in the while for routine check-ups. One of the reasons that I work as freelancer is to avoid such bullshit. On the plus side, your liability, as an employee, for any damages caused is limited to 3 monthly salaries, because, being just a kid, you cannot be held fully responsible for your own mistakes.
- Victerius 4y ago"And this, as I imagine, is the reason why the forwardness to take office, instead of waiting to be compelled, has been deemed dishonourable. Now the worst part of the punishment is that he who refuses to rule is liable to be ruled by one who is worse than himself. And the fear of this, as I conceive, induces the good to take office, not because they would, but because they cannot help --not under the idea that they are going to have any benefit or enjoyment themselves, but as a necessity, and because they are not able to commit the task of ruling to any one who is better than themselves, or indeed as good. For there is reason to think that if a city were composed entirely of good men, then to avoid office would be as much an object of contention as to obtain office is at present; then we should have plain proof that the true ruler is not meant by nature to regard his own interest, but that of his subjects; and every one who knew this would choose rather to receive a benefit from another than to have the trouble of conferring one." Plato, The Republic
- qwertyuiop_ 4y agoEmpirically speaking 90% of the managers out there became so because they were intentional in becoming managers. The reasons are myriad. Most want the power so they can hire or fire. Others with reaching the job safety inherently built into the role.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoA lot of IC historically become managers not because they particularly care about doing performance reviews but because they want more influence and to work at a larger scale. This leads to a situation of people managers who care less about managing people than managing delivery and technology strategy. The best of those also have a lot of empathy and inadvertently are good at people management. Another reason, often related in my experience, is a lot of companies careers plateau for ICs pretty early on. Your comp stops growing beyond COLA, titles exhaust, and despite being young you’re at a terminal career velocity. The only thing way to break up is to become management. This isn’t surprising - who controls promotion and comp other than managers, and why on earth wouldn’t they structure things to reward themselves and people like them? There are many companies that have recognized this and created IC paths parallel to management, at least up to the C level. However the relative difficulty in achieving them is disproportionately weighted against the IC vs manager. At Amazon there’s a crap ton of VP and Director managers. But it’s absurdly hard to get senior principal or distinguished engineer. The rationale is they want to keep the prestige of the level high for IC. But that’s weird - the prestige of the same level in management must therefore be low and why is the bar different for the same level if you’re managing vs building?
- leetrout 4y agoSpot on. I am so tired of the competitiveness in engineering to make the next pay band. You cant rely on a portion if teammates because they are jockeying for position and in other situations your opinion isnt valued because you are not high enough on the engineering ladder.
- bumby 4y ago
- the-printer 4y agoWe should all be leery of those who actively and openly declare and pursue positions of leadership.
- AstralStorm 4y agoLeadership is the art of getting people to do what they don't want to and keeping morale up. Way too many people end up in decision making who have no business being there - as strategists/tacticians - only thanks to their presence (mostly sales). That is a different technical skill.
- willnonya 4y agoI'm not sure Steve Jobs is someone you should be taking management advice from. The truth is that it boils down to the best person for the role to be filled rather than blanket statements based on anecdotes from a notoriously bad manager.
- dontbenebby 4y ago
- TimPC 4y agoBecause making a billion dollars in business means you are good at all the things regardless of any evidence to the contrary.
- waltbosz 4y agoI find the personal attacks in this comment to be unbecoming of HN standards.
- hsavit1 4y agoso following the cult like dogma of the late steve jobs is more inline with HN standards? probably yes
- waltbosz 4y agoNo I never said that. My intent was never to defend Steve Jobs. I just think the tone of way the comment was mean spirited and inappropriate. I think it's important to call out bad behavior in the HN community.
- dontbenebby 4y ago>I just think the tone of way the comment was mean spirited and inappropriate. Making a factual assertions about the behavior of a public figure is neither mean spirited nor inappropriate, especially if the intent is to avoid others coming into harm. You should discuss your feelings with a therapist rather than engage in what I like to term "emotional terrorism" -- silencing others if they stray from your preferred narrative. Or, if you like, you can take a look at my comment and tell me how you'd prefer it be phrased, if the core message of "Steve Jobs abused his family and his workers, why should we listen to his views on management?" (Maybe Steve Wozniak would be someone better suited to speak on management styles... I have never, in my life heard anyone say that Woz was rude to them on purpose... and I've heard a lot of stories about the early days at Apple in the hall at Defcon or whatever.)
- TimPC 4y agoA great IC with the right skill sets and inclinations to be a manager will be the best manager compared to a mediocre IC or someone out of field. Most ICs don’t have the right skill sets or inclinations for management and end up being a disaster of a manager.
- lambdatronics 4y agoAgreed. You can be a decent manager with mediocre tech skills provided you work really hard on the soft-skills part, but greatness only comes from excellence in both soft & 'hard' skills.
- zolland 4y agoPlato said this too--no great king desires the role, but when assigned it they will do what must be done for the good of the state.
- WalterBright 4y ago> no great king desires the role Great kings know it is effective to disguise their desire for the role.
- diego_moita 4y agoI wonder what kind of people are these Steve Jobs cultists... Most of the "wisdom" of all "Steve Jobs said..." is just subjective interpretation of vague and ambiguous statements. Truth, the guy had a lot of successes. But if you look at them most were just accidental and he only recognized them as success when they hit him in the face. * Apple didn't "invent" the Mac, all of it's technologies were copied straight out of Xerox's Palo Alto research center. He found them in a demo. * Jobs didn't "invent" Pixar. George Lucas and Ed Catmull did it. His project was to create an hardware company (the only thing he knew to do) and to sell it. But Pixar "accidentally" found success creating animated intros for commercials and television shows and Jobs did nothing to discover this early market. * Jobs didn't invent the iPhone. He was scared of dealing in an area where Apple didn't have expertise and tought it would be dangerous (a call to 911 failing because the phone could be stuck in a processing task). It took years of internal pressure by Apple engineers and management and a personal fiasco on a Nokia phone with iTunes for him to accept the iPhone. * Jobs didn't invent the AppStore. For the first 6 months the iPhone didn't had an AppStore because he tought it would relinquish control of the platform to others. He only accepted it because in these first 6 months the iPhone sales were a disaster. He accepted the AppStore because the customers were screamming for it. It was the AppStore that saved the iPhone. * Jobs didn't invent the Apple I, Wozniak did it. And the idea to turn the kit into a functional computer was not Jobs'. It was a precondition imposed by a RadioShack manager. * NEXT wasn't a commercial success. An expensive computer for college students with a black and white monitor was not selling enough to sustain the company. He was basically lucky that at the same time, Apple under Sculley, was a much bigger failure and the management board called him back. "Reality distortion field" and "stealing" other people's ideas were Jobs' greatest talents. But then, these are the talents of most cult founders from Jim Jones to Donald Trump.
- monsieurbanana 4y agoI'm predisposed to dislike Steve Jobs (I'm predisposed to dislike anyone who exploits other people tbh, so virtually all high-profile CEO). But there's already 5 pretty big successes in your list. At which point it stops being statically improbable he isn't exceptionally talented by some kind of metric?
- jimnotgym 4y agoI don't want any job at all. Does that make me a good manager
- mattbrewsbytes 4y agoFind a large multi-national company that isn’t in tech, get a job in IT or doing software of some kind and move up into management. You really want to be in a cost center and get into middle management, I still can’t fathom what those people did for the company, complete waste of space. So go do that, LOL. Or do the opposite of all that and feel connected to and enjoy your work by seeing that it has an impact on your customers.
- trentnix 4y agoAs a manager, I want to see myself in what he said because I really enjoy writing code and engineering solutions. But honestly , I don’t think the “want to” matters all that much when it comes to management. I do think many good managers are problem solvers. They are often hands-on, in the thick of ideation and problem-solving. They have the knowledge necessary to evaluate the competence and solutions submitted by the people being managed. And that knowledge and skill also helps them understand what their reports need to succeed.
- antipaul 4y agoI love the “manager as problem solver”. It’s a somewhat tricky balance between “micromanagement” and problem-solving, but then problem solving is a bit of a discipline after all.
- dimitar 4y agoI think the solution is to hire both, because there is also the Peter principle: "promoted to incompetence". The professional managers should be in a deputy position to the promoted ICs. This way they can bring their skills and expertise in management and empower the promoted ICs who understand the business or problems deeply. The professional managers can be pretty useful if they don't have people reporting to them and help with processes, compliance, planning, making presentations and excel tables and yet the capacity for damage will be limited as the promoted ICs will need approve anything. DEC apparently had "administration" instead of management, implying it didn't rule but rather assist, but I don't know the exact details.
- AstralStorm 4y agoThe person responsible for paperwork is called an accountant, a secretary or officer, not a manager. A person handling presentations is usually a salesperson. The person with deep knowledge about how a particular business runs and steps required to do so is called a business analyst. Many so-called professional managers are actually salespeople who have leveraged themselves - sold themselves as managers regardless of how good they are at actually managing. The closest equivalent is politicians. Sometimes an owner is actually forced to take on multiple such roles at the same time, especially in a small company or a startup. Then they tend to fail thanks to their shortcomings unless they get or hire help. For example Jobs was not particularly any good manager. He was a salesman and a designer. He hired good managers. When he managed directly he got abject failures, that only his skill in sales partly covered. The article described a case where someone hired a manager to actually do the job of a process quality engineer/quality officer.
- thewileyone 4y agoThis is actually a good idea because as a leader you should always hire to your weaknesses.
- cletus 4y agoThere are different flavors of not wanting to be a manager. The good kind Jobs refers to are people who see the necessity and that no one is doing it (or doing it well). They aren't the kind of people who don't understand people and fall into the trap of simply controlling and micro-managing people. Let me give you an example of the bad kind. Google's SWE ladder goes all the say from L3 (new grad) to L9 (ignoring exceptions like Google Fellow and execs). There is an expectation of growth from L3 to L5 (Senior SWE). There is a lot of reward if you can get promoted to L6 (Staff SWE) but it is incredibly difficult. It requires a lot of luck (eg being on the right project that doesn't get cancelled). Getting to L6 now is much harder than it was 10-15 years ago. One of the things Ruth Porat did when she came in was to control costs by reducing the promotion target percentage because it wasn't visible to people (there was a leaked memo). All promo candidates go to committee and effectively get stack ranked across committees. There is a quota ("target percentage") of who gets promoted. This creates a backlog and raises the bar for getting promoted. It gives more time for your impact to dissipate or your project to get cancelled (which was your promotion case). Compare this to getting promoted as a manager. Your manager level (M0 to M2, which is the same level as L5 to L7) is effectively a function of your head count with the added requirement that M2 requires you to have managers as reports. So if you're an M0 (which is rare), getting to M1 is typically as easy as getting to 10-15 reports (as long as you don't screw up so badly). So there is a breed of SWEs that bridge these worlds. They're half an IC and half an EM in the hopes that this gets them over the line. In my experience, these managers were generally the absolute worst. They had no interest in ever being a amanager and were just ticking a box for an L6 promotion case. Career development tended to be zero. Everything was seen through the lens of what helped them get promoted. If that means throwing someone under the bus, so be it. I think one of the best things Facebook did was they effectively didn't allow this. Having reports as an IC generally wasn't allowed. Being an L5 with reports was mostly not allowed. I mean there were some exceptions in some orgs and for some people but it was exceedingly rare. You'd see people ask "why can't I be a manager at L5?" and you heavily suspected the main motivator for this question was an inability to get promoted to L6 as a SWE.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoAnd the best politicians never want to be politicians.
- SV_BubbleTime 4y agoGive that power to people that don't want it.
- rcarr 4y agoBasically, be Aragorn (movie version).
- antipaul 4y agoMore details, from the people behind Apple’s internal leadership training: Ever since Steve Jobs implemented the functional organization, Apple’s managers at every level, from senior vice president on down, have been expected to possess three key leadership characteristics: 1. deep expertise that allows them to meaningfully engage in all the work being done within their individual functions 2. immersion in the details of those functions; 3. and a willingness to collaboratively debate other functions during collective decision-making. When managers have these attributes, decisions are made in a coordinated fashion by the people most qualified to make them. Article: https://hbr.org/2020/11/how-apple-is-organized-for-innovation https://hbr.org/2020/11/how-apple-is-organized-for-innovatio...
- lovehashbrowns 4y agoA special kind of disaster happens when a manager thinks they have deep expertise but they don’t. I have to be actively vigilant of what this manager is doing because one statement could lead to hours wasted. Just the other day they were about to launch a whole S3 tangent involving two teams because some report came back saying a few EBS volumes were not encrypted.
- shepherdjerred 4y agoInteractions with my managers at Amazon made me a much more cynical human being (at least when it comes to managers/corporate politics).
- rawgabbit 4y agoBut that runs counter to all the arguments professional scrum masters and agile evangelists make. "All you need to do know is agile/scrum/fad du jour". /s
- bitL 4y agoManager wannabes should be screened for narcissism and sociopathy and rejected if exhibiting these or similar traits. Unfortunately, recruiters are often already screening for these traits for the top management candidates and reject anyone who doesn't exhibit them.
- coffeefirst 4y agoIt's also really hard to parse that stuff out until you see people in action. Any self-aggrandizing jackass can talk a good game about servant leadership or supporting the team as a whole in an interview, and then go on to make himself the main character. Some of the worst of them are really, really good at telling you whatever you want to hear, and will gladly perform humility. I don't have an answer for this besides hope there's someone above them who will observe this behavior and nip it in the bud.
- newsclues 4y agoGood management is just leadership. Real leaders understand the burden of command and take it seriously and the stress is not sustainable for nearly anyone for the long term, so experienced leaders don’t want to do it unless it’s absolutely essential.
- sph 4y agoReminds me of my favourite quote by Kurt von Hammerstein-Equord: "I distinguish four types [of officers]. There are clever, hardworking, stupid, and lazy officers. Usually two characteristics are combined. Some are clever and hardworking; their place is the General Staff. The next ones are stupid and lazy; they make up 90 percent of every army and are suited to routine duties. Anyone who is both clever and lazy is qualified for the highest leadership duties, because he possesses the mental clarity and strength of nerve necessary for difficult decisions. One must beware of anyone who is both stupid and hardworking; he must not be entrusted with any responsibility because he will always only cause damage."
- etempleton 4y agoHardworking and stupid make great employees though. The problem is for doing such a great job as cogs in the machine they get promoted into positions of authority and then it is hard to fault them too much because at least they are hardworking.
- sph 4y agoThey would be terrible employees. Making mistakes and doubling down, too stupid to learn from them, and with the energy to follow any inane goose chase. Being stubborn is good only if you are right. But they would make fantastic career politicians. You need a certain type of person to work hard to get yourself voted by telling whatever stories your voters care about, but also capable of believing your own lies and fighting for them till the bitter end. I guess I'm too lazy to admire any of these personalities.
- nr2x 4y agoUgh, no way! Those people create messes that need to be cleaned up and don’t follow directions. The WORST
- AstralStorm 4y agoThen there is a special category of people being just smart enough to get themselves into a situation they cannot handle. They tend to be hardworking but average or below average talented, not outright stupid. These people tend to cause debt to accumulate, orders to get blocked or stonewalled, infinite delays, legal costs etc. A stupid person generally will fail early and obviously, an average person, especially in skill or experience, will get themselves beyond what they can handle before they recognize being insufficient.
- RustLove 4y agoI completely agree with this. The best leaders are those who have proven themselves to be great individual contributors before moving into a management role. This gives them a deep understanding and appreciation for the work that their team members do, which is crucial for effective leadership. Professional managers, on the other hand, may not have the same level of experience and can sometimes struggle to effectively support and lead their team.
- Patrol8394 4y agoYes, but, the problem with ic becoming managers is that they are too involved with eng work. Often dictating how things should be done. Also, they have hard time letting their beloved legacy code go. Best managers are IC who have the ability to trust their eng to do the work. Their main role should be “advice”, provide context and connections within the company.
- walnutclosefarm 4y agoI think the article, and many of the comments here, miss the point badly. No manager of a team doing technically complex and creative work can for very long remain capable of doing all the work themselves. Modern projects and processes simply require too much specialized knowledge to function for that to work. What managers need that (probably) comes from having been a strong individual contributor is sufficient knowledge of the fields involved in what they're managing to be able to understand the critical elements in the project or process in the context of the overall goal, and to be able to evaluate well the value of ideas for improvement or problem solution that come out of their team. But they also need leadership and management skills. The latter are not the same as, and are not developed by, stellar individual contributor skills. Furthermore, it's important to understand that management and leadership are not the same thing. My personal experience has been that I was a very able individual contributor, and that I was able to learn leadership skills (that is, how to inspire people; how to recognize their strengths and weaknesses and assign work that played to the former, and created opportunities to ameliorate the latter; how to point individuals and teams in fruitful directions without having (or often being able to) do all the hard work of pushing in that direction myself) by diligent study of people and myself. But I was never able to become more than a barely competent manager - I always had, by design, an "administrative partner" on my team who brought those abilities to the table - and I always paid attention to what they had to say. That combination (technical knowledge, leadership skills, and sub-contracted management skills) carried me from individual contributor to team lead, to product line lead, to CTO of highly successful $10B billion medical and technology organization in 20 years.
- fuzzfactor 4y ago>The best leaders are great individual contributors, not professional managers Duh. For a technical business to have the most unfair advantage (well above patents, etc.) there has got to be the most technical competence/productivity at the very top. There's still an unfair advantage if there's as much competence at the top, but when it's the most that's when it's really the most unfair. Jobs was an outstanding visionary, salesman, task-oriented and goal oriented manager, but without Woz at the top along with him Apple would have been greatly limited. Once things took off they could build some bigger teams, on paper it looked like they could afford anything. It was expected to require more than one engineer to design as salable a product as Woz could do single-handedly. By 1985 Jobs was reminiscing about being burned: >We're going to be a big company, we thought. So let's hire "professional managers." We went out and hired a bunch of professional management, and it didn't work at all. >They knew how to manage, but they didn't know how to do anything. As this took place it required more & more personnel, as well as these non-domain managers to go with them, in order to accomplish less than Woz and a small team. It was a no brainer. What a person can do single handedly turns out to be the best indication of how much more they can do with a proper high leadership position (if they are willing), especially when compared to "professional managers" without the domain expertise to hold their own when there's no technical team backing them up. Not how many people the impressive manager has managed before, even if there was legitimate positive financial outcome in their background. Once there was a competent all-technical team, if less wizardly than Woz himself, Jobs could sell that just as well, Woz was well set, and he was out of there with his shares in Apple wisely held. If Apple had not recognized this as early as they did, there would be no way Apple could have gotten as big as they are now. >I always had, by design, an "administrative partner" on my team who brought those abilities to the table - and I always paid attention to what they had to say. That combination (technical knowledge, leadership skills, and sub-contracted management skills) carried me Woz could legitimately say this about Jobs which is a true measure of whether there was adequate technical leadership at the very top during his time.
- zhte415 4y agoOnly one article cited,and it's about employee wellbeing which while an important topic is not the catch-all 'best leaders' headline. So, to play Devil's Advocate, a study [1] of a technology company, Microsoft, that finds that > technical skills are not the sign of greatness for an engineering manager. [1] What makes a great manager of software engineers? https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/8094304 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/abstract/document/8094304
- ebjaas_2022 4y agoDave Cutler is, seemingly, a good example of this. If you have not read it, I recommend the book Show Stopper! by G. Pascal Zachary, about the development of Microsoft Windows NT under his leadership.
- crsv 4y agoI’ve encountered significant evidence of the opposite being true in my experience
- refsab 4y agoI'm a counterpoint to this. Outstanding IC wanting to get into management for job security / ageism. Turned out to be a bad manager too focused on team and unable to effectively manage up and sideways. I'm now a consultant. Ageism is suddenly on my side in consulting. Coding until I die.
- joeyguerra 4y agoThis is true. And no more buts.
- throwawaaarrgh 4y agoThis is an editorial written by someone who is heavily biased and doesn't know how management or organizational improvement works. > In my case, I didn't need someone to manage what we already did. I needed someone frustrated by our current level of productivity. Someone irritated by our current level of quality. That's called Operations Management, buddy, and you don't hire an IC for that job. > Someone annoyed by the fact very few shopfloor employees were being promoted to higher-level roles. That is literally every manager's job. And, one could argue, a bad idea in general (see Peter Principle). > "If your boss could do your job, you're more likely to be happy at work." Why? Because the boss has empathy and compassion for her workers, and makes an effort to understand the work. That doesn't mean she has to do the work herself. She simply needs the context and understanding to be able to facilitate effectively and make her reports happy. Anybody who cares enough can do that. I have had IC bosses who were insufferable, and non-IC bosses who were insufferable, and good bosses of each too. The ability to do the work has both helped and hindered their management. Focus on efficiency is good, but often efficiency isn't technical at all. Managing is it's own skill, separate from being an IC. Simply promoting an IC who does not know how to manage will not always lead to good outcomes.
- 90d 4y agoI cannot wait to compare the LinkedIn comments this receives in comparison to the HN discussion. popcorn.gif
- iancmceachern 4y agoThis is exactly my experience, if you can't measure it you can't manage it, if you don't know how to do the tasks yourself, how can you grade others work?
- aristofun 4y agoThe core problem is that all people suddenly believe in the dichotomy ic/manager in the first place. This is an artificial separation.
- UweSchmidt 4y agoIt appears that outside our bubble software-work enjoys such a low status that management does not possess, or admits to possessing, any technical competence. This is in stark contrast to engineering or manufacturing companies, where engineers make up the highest levels of management and also adjacent areas like running the factories, and generally management prides itself with being hands-on, dropping knowledge and walking through the shop floor frequently. In an agile environment (the most common structure in software development) the professional class of scrum masters and analysts are often non-technical, and management is sparse and hands-off (teams are "self-organized"). Key technical decisions are relegated to senior individual contributors, allowing for CV driven development, cargo culting, and bad habits. Stories of a Microsoft VP who files a bug report and points out the line of code where the error occured could never have happened anywhere where I worked.
- farorm 4y agoI think modern software companies moves to remove roles like scrum masters, testers and analysts. My theory here is that e.g scrum masters wants to scrum, it’s their job. Much better to have the team take turn being the scrum master. They own the process and the pain.
- swagasaurus-rex 4y agoThe non technical scrum master fills a very important role for higher management: somebody to take blame and responsibility.
- jokethrowaway 4y agoI've never seen this, I've seen them be some kind of project manager role or just bubbly people who say some BS and convince company to pay them to waste employees time.
- civilized 4y agoIn my company, the project manager is essentially just there to report progress to management. Why is it necessary to report progress to management? I'm not sure; as far as I've seen, nothing is ever done with the information, except to propagate it further up the chain. I can only speculate that, without progress reporting, management would seem to have too little work to do to justify its headcount.
- __derek__ 4y agoThe article discusses senior-level management, but the comments here mostly focus on line-management. IMO, these are very different beasts. The former set overall strategy and need to be highly competent in their area of expertise. The latter focus on tactics and don't necessarily need to be competent in their team's area of focus as long as there are other mechanisms to provide their team with technical guidance, mentorship, etc.
- FlyingAvatar 4y agoWhat is the role of the manager, if they are not providing guidance and mentorship?
- lambdatronics 4y ago"Managers are hubs of communication, the better they communicate across these sphere boundaries, the more people they can communicate with, the more data they have, which, consequently leads to better decision making." "As a manager, your job is that of a bullshit umbrella. You need to decide what crap your team needs to deal with and what crap can be ignored." https://randsinrepose.com/archives/managementese/ https://randsinrepose.com/archives/managementese/ Leaders are shock-absorbers: https://www.edbatista.com/2022/10/leader-as-shock-absorber.html https://www.edbatista.com/2022/10/leader-as-shock-absorber.h... Leaders need to ensure alignment: "[Manager's] goals do not automatically become their employees' goals. On the contrary, much or most of a manager's job is to align these goals." http://yosefk.com/blog/people-can-read-their-managers-mind.html http://yosefk.com/blog/people-can-read-their-managers-mind.h...
- etempleton 4y agoNot always, but sometimes, the problem with people who want to manage is that they want to direct work. They like that power dynamic. I find the best managers kind of hate telling people want to do, but will if and when they have to.
- elgar1212 4y agoThe thing about the IC -> management path that bothers me (and makes me skeptical of people who take it) is that programming and getting PRs merged is so god damn satisfying Going from this to just having meetings, training people, looking at dashboards... I can't imagine anyone doing this who genuinely likes programming. Even if the pay is better The people who are the most inspiring (and also the best at getting shit done) are the ones who make it very far in the IC path and become team leads. Team leads are the best managers, the actual managers are just there to do boilerplate shit and politicking that team leads aren't interested in (disclaimer: not talking about all managers or all companies, just the ones I've personally experienced)
- rocketpastsix 4y agoyes its awesome to have my work merged, even though Im not supposed to be doing a lot of coding. But what is equally awesome is when the junior developer who I manage does the implementation work I laid out and gets her PR merged. Even better if it can get through with her defending all of the choices she made (even if we pair on it) versus coming to me to help in the comments.
- therealdrag0 4y agoI sympathize because even being a team lead has reduced my coding enough I sometimes code in my free time to make up for it cuz I enjoy it. But I think your mistake is saying only those who love coding are “most inspiring” and most “get shit done”. There’s definitely lots of people who love to get shit done who are indifferent about coding.
- pantojax45 4y agoI miss it so much. But there’s a different satisfaction with seeing a big team happy, motivated and successful (and hopefully the team taking all the credit rather than you!). I’m hoping I can go back and IC for a bit… It’s a different reward that’s more subtle than coding.
- msteffen 4y agoAs someone who went from IC to management, my perspective is that getting PRs merged is still that satisfying. I just don't have to be the author of the PR. More generally, I think some ICs do think that if managers and meetings went away, ICs could just write code distraction-free. But as anyone who's rushed to merge a PR before a colleague so that they have to deal with the merge conflict can tell you, engineers often don't get along, actually. Managers keep the company from getting stuck or thrashing when the engineers don't agree, and most of managing is brokering agreements of one kind or another.
- codegeek 4y agoMy take: Great IC skill is a necessary but not sufficient condition to be a great leader. Leadership requires various other skills and experiences.
- pleb_nz 4y agoThey're quite different roles and traits so I don't know people think this is the case. Not all managers are leaders and not not leaders are managers. The best leader I know owns and runs a fairly massive company and does no or at least, very little management. And the company uses the knowledge that leaders and managers are different to run a well oiled machine. They put managers in where managers are needed and use leaders where leaders are required. Of course there is crossover in places and they hire with the two traits in mind for those positions.
- seahawks78 4y agoIn the article that has been cited in the link the abstract says "Science says". I wonder if the writer even knows what Science is or means? No wonder our mass media today and public discourses are filled with utter quality garbage rhetoric and discussions that are not even worthy of two minutes of reading time.
- hrpnk 4y agoWorth mentioning that management vs. IC is not a decision for life. Charity Majors wrote about the opportunities and challenges when switching throughout one's career between management and individual contributor [1] and [2]. [1] https://charity.wtf/2017/05/11/the-engineer-manager-pendulum/ https://charity.wtf/2017/05/11/the-engineer-manager-pendulum... [2] https://charity.wtf/2022/03/24/twin-anxieties-of-the-engineer-manager-pendulum/ https://charity.wtf/2022/03/24/twin-anxieties-of-the-enginee...
- oldstrangers 4y agoI've gotten a lot of pushback (from two different companies) when I suggested openly that any PM should have an extensive if not intimate understanding of the projects they're managing. They should realistically be able to do the work they're delegating, because you routinely need that level of understanding if the ones you're managing expect to get useful information out of you. If the manager doesn't understand the project, it becomes a repetitive effort of "let me ask the client, I'll get back to you" and you end up wasting tremendous amounts of time.
- thenerdhead 4y agoI get the spirit of what you’re saying, but to realistically be able to do the work seems a bit far. This would be hard to apply to even Steve Jobs. Maybe another way to phrase it might be that they should intimately understand what the vision of the work entails rather than need to always ask for the next horizon.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- oldstrangers 4y agoThe entire spirit of the article and research though is that workers make better managers than pure managers. They don't need to actually DO the work, but understanding to that level is invaluable and why Steve emphasized it so much.
- thenerdhead 4y agoI feel like people interpret this wrong. Those who are great ICs and then assimilate into the traditional management role is not what Jobs was talking about. It is the spirit of an IC to push beyond the politics of the workplace and keep the philosophy of what makes a good IC alive. In other words, politicians cannot practice philosophy and vice versa. They are incompatible or fail quickly when attempted.
- Communitivity 4y agoManagement is a skill set, as is engineering, as is technical writing. Rare individuals have significant overlap of high skill in these areas, most don't. I have been a tech lead several times. In those roles I developed communication skills, mentoring skills, and planning skills far more than I had as an individual contributor. I also developed different subsets of those skills. The best leaders though are the ones that have that overlap, are great individual contributors but have gotten to the point where they focus on tough key problems and facilitate their team's contributions and growth. You can have good leaders that are strong in communication and planning, and ok on individual contributions. It is harder for them to plan effectively though, and they'll need to lean on their high skill contributors in the team.
- angry_octet 4y agoPeople who think being an IC is making a huge difference are usually self deluded. You are not Carmack. There are people higher in management who rely on mid career experts to guide technical decision making responsibly. There are junior people to guide and mentor. If you manage both tasks you have the beginnings of leadership. It seems people do conflate supervision and project tracking with leadership. Being a scrum master is another technical function, not leadership. Being a technical expert is some other facet is also not leadership. I've seen good leaders with both project management and engineering skill sets, but neither stands out as any more qualifying.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- elihu 4y agoI think this is true, but I wonder if there's also a problem with supply versus demand: we can't just replace all the professional managers (PMs) with great individual contributors (GICs) because there are a lot of the former and not enough of the latter to fill all the roles. So, the most desirable workplaces can maybe attract all the GICs to fill out middle management, whereas the less desirable workplaces have to stick with PMs because GICs won't work for them. In theory GICs could work their way into management organically in any organization, but it would require both that they be willing to take on a management role and that the organization is able to recognize who the GICs are. (There are also some GICs who just shouldn't be managers because they're unusually bad at dealing with people. They're probably the minority, but they exist.)
- plint 4y agoThere's some game theoryish ideas such as the Peter Principle which might explain why meritocratic promotion may not work out in the long run for organizations. See: https://arxiv.org/abs/0907.0455 https://arxiv.org/abs/0907.0455 which won the parody Ig Nobel prize, but I don't really understand why, as I thought it was at least as interesting as Robert Axelrod's simulation of successful strategies in the iterated prisoner's dilemma. In fact, I think it would be even warranted to do an extension of this model, considering possible assumptions such as Dilbert principle, negative selection, and alignment of agents with different goals and basic strategies. I am not understanding why such a model would be considered silly instead of insightful.
- AstralStorm 4y agoPeter Principle only applies to hierarchical organizations or ones where role changes are hard. Even if the depth of hierarchy is 2.
- plint 4y agoAren't most organizations operating in the market hierarchical, and role changes difficult? Why did you say even if the depth of hierarchy is 2? In fact, the difficulty of role change could also be a parameter in model, like how Nicky Case models stuff in some of their things, for example: https://ncase.me/polygons/ https://ncase.me/polygons/
- husamia 4y agoI managed several people for few years. I knew the ends and outs of everything. I can tell them what to do and how to do it. I preferred to let them do it on their own and be there to help them when they fail. No one ever came to me for help without getting the help they needed. My team told me I was the best manager in the world. But I wasn't happy being a manager. It was boring. I required me checking on them often. I loved my work, it bothered me to watch people struggling to work in job they didn't like. I wanted to do the work. No one could do it as good as me. I didn't want to get bogged down with administrative tasks. On top of that, I didn't have the authority to make decisions even as a manager. I was basically a baby sitter for people that didn't need baby sitter. So I let go of my manager position and I am happy. I knew some people could do better but I can't make them do it. I want them to do it without me asking. Just as I do.
- sacnoradhq 4y agoMBAs (from insert pedigree university) believe they're smarter, better, and more capable with zero knowledge, wisdom, and/or experience, which inexorably leads to Theranos-like hubris. People who are good generalists, able to switch contexts quickly, enthusiasm, interest in excellence, and have good social and customer service skills tend to be good managers. People who want to be managers and/or CEO by any means necessary typically shouldn't be allowed anywhere near non-IC work. Another solution to pyramid-building: flat orgs - make managers and all other roles equal to others in terms of respect and influence, and differentiate managers as have responsibility areas rather than god-like status. Empire building doesn't solve any real problems while it creates others.
- TrackerFF 4y agoA fundamental problem at most organizations is that if you want more pay, then sooner or later you _must_ be promoted to, or apply for a leadership position. If you want to keep on working in a 100% technical position, with little to no leadership duties, well, the options tend to be few...if any. So what can you do?
- AstralStorm 4y agoAgain conflating leadership with sales or strategy... MBAs caused a problem in this regard. One can be a leader without managing anyone, strategizing or selling, or making deals, or designing products. It only requires personal qualities and emotional skills, so-called human, personal touch. Ability to engender respect. Rare, I know. Sales sometimes involves that, but is usually more adversarial.
- the_jeremy 4y agoIn my contrary opinion, this should apply to tech leadership, not management. The best managers (for employees, not the company) are not necessarily great ICs. The best team leads / architects are great ICs. The problem is that "best" really depends on whether you are coming from the employer or employee's perspective. It's probably best for the company if they're great ICs: they can choose the right feature and deliver quickly and who cares about employee satisfaction at the margin.