8 ms·
Estimated cumulative excess deaths during Covid, World
- ggm 4y agoHow this varies by economy, and varies from declared covid mortality will be a fascinating story. As a disease which mainly caused fatalities in the older cohort it won't have quite the same long tail consequences Spanish flu did on childbirth and social structure, but it will have some. Of course an almost unquantifiable and continuing tragedy for families everywhere.
- decremental 4y ago6 million covid deaths?
- danuker 4y ago6.6 million confirmed COVID deaths, but excess mortality from all deaths compared to previous years is 16-28 million. Strangely, the two measures only diverged from July 2020. It could be that: - the initial strict lockdowns prevented deaths from more diseases - some later deaths were caused by COVID indirectly (without it being registered as the cause)
- mughinn 4y agoIt could also be that extended lockdowns caused a ton of deaths
- simplotek 4y ago> It could also be that extended lockdowns caused a ton of deaths Do you have any evidence at all that comes close to suggest this hypothesis, let alone substantiate it?
- danuker 4y agoI'd say the discrepancy is quite the elephant in the room to explain for medical professionals. Edit: found an article investigating it: https://bmchealthservres.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12913-021-07169-7 https://bmchealthservres.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/... > An early response to Covid-19, including borders’ controls and a strong test and trace capacity, could improve epidemiological surveillance and minimize excess mortality, with stringent and lengthy lockdowns not providing a significant benefit.
- ipsum2 4y agoNot the person you're responding to, but here's one example: https://news.un.org/en/story/2021/03/1087542 https://news.un.org/en/story/2021/03/1087542. tl;dr: closing schools causes children in South Asia to not be treated for malnutrition and immunizations and have increased teen pregnancies with inadequate medical attention. Estimated 230,000 excess deaths. Read the PDF report for more details.
- kadoban 4y agoYou appear to be blaming those estimated 230,000 excess deaths on lockdowns. The article blames the pandemic itself. That's not the same thing.
- mughinn 4y agoClosing the schools is a lockdown measure, the pandemic didn't close the schools
- kadoban 4y agoAlright, maybe I'm misreading it. Can you show me where it says that closing the schools caused 230,000 deaths? My reading was that those deaths are blamed on a combination of factors, few of which I'd think were due to voluntary lockdowns. The main ones appear to be a reduction in health services, with cause unstated. That's probably largely due to people being pulled into dealing with the pandemic itself and not enough resources to go around? And then it also raises "The region also suffered increased levels of unemployment, poverty and food insecurity due to the pandemic, further undermining public health, the report said"
- kadoban 4y agoThere are more options than that of course. One would be that government(s) started playing with their reporting stats or even just started being less able to confirm what the cause was.
- cies 4y agoHow many deaths world wide (estimated, as these numbers are always estimates) from the 2018 flu season?
- wellthatsawrap1 4y ago
- IAmGraydon 4y agoIt’s excess deaths. If you don’t know what that means, Google is your friend.
- simplotek 4y agoIt's also important to note that all the emergency public health measures put in place to curtail covid infections also contributed to lower the spread of the flu, thus it's expected that the number of flu cases behind excess deaths is significantly lower than the baseline.
- IAmGraydon 4y agoVery true. There's a lot of factors to consider, including the effect of decreased access to healthcare due to overloaded hospitals.
- doctor_eval 4y agoAll the figures include flu deaths. Including the pre Covid figures.
- ceejayoz 4y agoYes, that's the entire point of excess deaths. Cause of death doesn't matter; "a whole bunch more people died than is normal" gives us useful info. If you look at the chart at https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid19/excess_deaths.htm, you'll see a spike of excess deaths from the nasty 2017-2018 flu season on the far-left side, and you'll see the impact of the pandemic very clearly in the right-hand side.
- kadoban 4y agoIt does, but note that flu was _far_ lower than usual during at least some periods during this.
- flir 4y agoSome countries (UK, France, Denmark) show confirmed Covid deaths outstripping excess deaths. I wonder why that is.
- lapcat 4y agoCould be Covid-inspired change in behavior/lifestyle that resulted in fewer deaths from other causes.
- defrost 4y agoLockdowns and reduced movements limited both COVID spread and "regular deaths" (due to say, traffic accidents, work accidents, other respiratory diseases that were also suppresed by increased hygiene, etc). The end result; overall lower rate of death than usual, and a chunk of the deaths that did occur due to COVID.
- Thlom 4y agoYeah. My country had fewer deaths than usual in 2020 and 2021, and a bit more than usual so far in 2022.
- oxfordmale 4y agoThere a number of reasons, however, co-morbidity plays an important role. If you have stage 4 terminal cancer, any viral infection can push you over the edge. In normal years you wouldn't even get tested for this.
- Neil44 4y agoIn the UK at least a death where the person had tested +ve for covid within a certain (quite long) time period was recorded as a covid death. So you catch covid, recover, then get hit by a bus. Covid death. Meanwhile some countries report next to no deaths, also clearly not correct. The reported data is clearly close to worthless and yet it suits too many people's purposes to use it.
- exDM69 4y ago
- beardyw 4y agoYears ago I used to work in this area and you should not underestimate what a difficult thing "cause of death" is. At the time we mostly worked with the initial condition which led to death. But in-between that and death could be quite a few other conditions. There are relatively few ultimate conditions. Trying to apply more than one just confuses the stats/people. But our approach had one case of "flat feet" as a real cause of death! You can't win. That makes excess deaths valuable in the case of COVID.
- rtkwe 4y agoThat complexity was pretty ruthlessly exploited here in the US by groups that wanted to downplay the issue and end mitigation efforts. Endless takes on "well actually they didn't die of COVID they already had $co-morbidity-x or $co-morbidity-y and that's what REALLY killed them".
- bvhvhfcgxfdf 4y ago
- dustedcodes 4y agoUnbearably hard if you ask me. I don't want to socially distance myself from my parents, sister and close friends and it hurts in my heart to see them suffer alone at home and everyone getting visibly depressed over an issue that doesn't affect them directly. I'm all up for keeping others safe, but if it means I have to compromise the mental and physical health of my own family then I couldn't care less about the health of others. Family comes first, no matter what. If my mother who is alone doesn't have any co-morbidities and is in good health (which she is) then why make her unwell? No way.
- Retric 4y agoThat’s not how social distancing was supposed to work. The goal was to minimize the spread of disease not cause mental issues. A large party with 100 people is vastly different than a 1v1 meetings. What I think people missed is spending several days with a friend or family member is basically an identical risk as visiting for an afternoon. People could have spent the pandemic couchsurfing as long as the number of contacts over a week was minimized it wasn’t an issue.
- hirundo 4y agoOr about 1 in 400 people. This estimates that in the US about 1 in 4 of those deaths was from something other than Covid: https://brownstone.org/articles/deaths/ https://brownstone.org/articles/deaths/
- habibur 4y agoRough estimation from this chart. 10 people die every year per 1000. During this covid it had been 11 people per thousand per year.
- scanr 4y agoThe economist has a good breakdown https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/coronavirus-excess-deaths-tracker https://www.economist.com/graphic-detail/coronavirus-excess-...
- CGamesPlay 4y agoWhy is the 95% upper bound negative on March 9, 2020? Early COVID saved lives? Confirmed: 4009 • Upper bound, 95%: -22,912 • Central: -127,918 • Lower bound: -246,089
- thehappypm 4y agoAt that stage few people were dying (it took another couple weeks) but lockdowns were preventing car accidents and such
- refurb 4y agoWhat will be interesting is looking at data 5-10 years out. If most of the deaths were in the elderly, Covid simply accelerated their death by X years. You’d expect that you’d see a reduction in deaths over the next ~10 years (when those people would have died from other causes).
- lapcat 4y ago> If most of the deaths were in the elderly, Covid simply accelerated their death by X years. "simply"?
- badcppdev 4y agoI was trying to write a reply to call out the use of that word. People need to be more careful with their language.
- zaroth 4y agoAll causes of death “simply” accelerated another subsequent cause of death.
- conductr 4y agoIt’s difficult to talk about some subjects online when people are so keen to mince other people’s words like this. They obviously meant nothing by it and you’re letting pedantry invalidate the point they were making. I’d prefer if you’d lower your editorial expectations for casual internet discussions more than I’d prefer everyone edit their word choices so carefully (unrealistic expectation honestly). Not meant to pick on you, this is a common thing I see when certain topics are discussed but it does not benefit the discussion at all.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoMaybe the point was that they should have meant something by it. We're talking about death and misery on an immense scale, and certainly many of the people reading any comment here will have been affected, will be sitting alone reading this when they otherwise wouldn't. Is it so awful to ask people to consider that, to weigh their words carefully, given this context?
- eastbound 4y ago“Excess deaths” can mean undiagnosed Covids OR death from staying at home too much.
- voisin 4y agoBoth related to Covid, no?
- willcipriano 4y agoConsider the case of a 1800's patient who undergoes bloodletting, exsanguination is caused by their condition in the same manner that side effects of lock downs are caused by covid.
- smeej 4y agoSort of, but the opporunity to fix them would be different. There's not a whole lot you can do to alter the effect a virus has on a human body (at least not immediately after discovering it), but you might be able to learn a lot from the effects of various types of government intervention, what helped and what hurt, and make plans that reduce the negative effects the next time action is needed.
- harryf 4y agoThe real question that needs answering is what the cost of lockdowns was and for that we’d need to compare to suicide statistics for the same period.
- mannykannot 4y agoSome countries show estimated excess deaths less than the confirmed Covid deaths. I imagine this might be attributed to lifestyle changes reducing deaths from other causes. Of the countries that I have looked at, Sweden is perhaps the most interesting, as the figures tracked closely together until the beginning of 2021, and then diverged rapidly over the next few months.
- dkjaudyeqooe 4y agoDepending on the level or lockdowns, that can be due to things like less traffic and people staying home, thus less deaths associated with activities forgone.
- Zigurd 4y agoAs bad as the US is (and getting worse) many places in the world have really horrific traffic deaths, so reduced activity on roads can be a big factor.
- mdip 4y agoIt looks like there was minimal to no lockdown in Sweden: https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/sweden-covid-and-lockdown-a-look-at-the-data/ https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/sweden-covid-and-lockdow...
- _djo_ 4y agoIt's a misconception that life went on as normal in Sweden. Plenty of activities were reduced or curtailed and business and personal travel from surrounding countries was dramatically reduced. Even so, it saw much higher mortality rates than its neighbours.
- arcanemachiner 4y ago> Even so, it saw much higher mortality rates than its neighbours. Did they? https://twitter.com/JamesMelville/status/1596815870676041729 https://twitter.com/JamesMelville/status/1596815870676041729
- danuker 4y agoA study investigating the causes of the discrepancy: https://bmchealthservres.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12913-021-07169-7 https://bmchealthservres.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/... > An early response to Covid-19, including borders’ controls and a strong test and trace capacity, could improve epidemiological surveillance and minimize excess mortality, with stringent and lengthy lockdowns not providing a significant benefit.
- nradov 4y agoSome of those claims are a bit silly, at least for the USA, since we have never had secure border controls. And actually securing the border was never a realistic proposition during the early phase of the pandemic. And the part about a strong test and trace capability is obviously nonsense. That didn't work in any of the countries that tried, except previous perhaps in China where the government is able to exercise a level of totalitarian control worse than any virus. It's disappointing that this kind of unrealistic garbage makes it though peer review.
- xeyownt 4y agoThe paper doesn't investigate the causes of the discrepancy, but only the causes of the excess mortality, ie. why are there so many deaths due to Covid, not why there are so many more deaths than those actually reported. As for the cited part of the conclusion, this is silly in practice. Obviously not letting in any infectious case would be much better, but when that happens, which always does in practice, the stringent lockdowns are only solution left until you get everyone vaccinated. So it's like comparing apple to orange.
- wang_li 4y agoStringent lock downs are not the only solution. Sweden had an extremely light touch with very few restrictions, were heavily shit on for their “mishandling” of Covid, but as of now they have the lowest cumulative excess deaths percentage of all the OECD during the Covid era.
- 4y ago
- amelius 4y agoMissing: estimated Covid deaths without intervention (lockdowns, vaccination, etc.)
- jehb 4y agoMissing: estimated Covid deaths with adequate intervention (lockdowns were followed rigorously, everyone actually got vaccinated, etc.)
- seydor 4y agoMissing: Arguments that are deeper than tweets
- xeyownt 4y agoMissing: a reason why these fictive estimates would be of any interest.
- amelius 4y agoMissing: years of potential life lost https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Years_of_potential_life_lost https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Years_of_potential_life_lost Perhaps a more useful metric, since so many more older people died from Covid.
- smt88 4y agoThere are enormous numbers of papers trying to quantify this. If you haven't seen these estimates, you didn't read any Covid literature in 2020 or 2021.
- marcosdumay 4y agoOr, to be blunt, they tried to stick with non-fiction. People asking for estimates that fit their agenda is quite predictable, but those estimates aren't very useful. Anyway, your point stays, ignoring the huge amount of estimates produced, and asking for them later is quite a bad posture.
- 4y ago
- heydenberk 4y agoBy coincidence, the median estimate and world population are both fairly round numbers: 20M deaths on a planet with 8B people. Put another way: 1 in every 400 people on earth died from this disease. It's hard to process.
- kspacewalk2 4y ago>1 in every 400 people on earth died from this disease. 1 in 400 people are (estimated) excess deaths during the pandemic. This is not the same thing as claiming that all of them were in fact killed by the disease itself.
- Nurw 4y agoI agree, the disease itself might not have killed as many, but the effects of the pandemic most likely did. It was by far the largest deviation from the norm during the time and therefore carries by far the largest responsibility of excess deaths (as excess deaths are deaths outside of what would be ordinary).
- drewcon 4y agoYou’re going to have to bring citations. An incredibly novel infectious disease that kills older people at an intensely meaningful rate is clearly the driver here.
- omginternets 4y agoYou’re making a (possibly reasonable) leap of logic, but formally speaking, the parent post is 100% correct.
- sphinxster 4y agoAbout 1 in 10 die each year in the US as a result of medical malpractice. The oft-cited 2016 John Hopkins study has it at ~250k (of 2.7m all-cause). For 2016 that's 1 in 1300 people in the US, a first world nation with world class medical infrastructure. I wonder what's the worldwide figure? And what % of it overlaps with that 1 in 400?
- PaulKeeble 4y agoIts a real shame they don't have a related research on Long Covid which the WHO estimated at 144 million in October. To me it looks like we are running on about 1 direct death to 3 indirect deaths and about 21 disabled. All in most of the impact of Covid 19 so far seems to be 84% disabled, 12% excess dying and 4% directly dying from the acute infection. Most of the impact is after the acute infection has passed.
- giraffe_lady 4y ago
- ghaff 4y agoThe government in the US (and other western countries among others) are constrained by what their population is willing to accept. And it's pretty clear those populations as a whole (and it's certainly not just a US thing) have said screw it and are back to business as usual. Yes, some people are still wearing masks, but even many of them seem to be still fine with traveling and going to large events so long as they keep their masks on (when not eating/drinking). And there's also the question of what should "we" be doing. With all 5 shots, I attended an event that required masks in September and still caught COVID. So short of becoming a hermit--which of course isn't an option for all the people needed to keep society operating--I'm not sure what the options are.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoYes I have also been outside in the last 3 years. But the decisions people make are at least informed by guidance and policies of their governments, which so far in north america is that there are no meaningful long term consequences of having covid.
- taolegal 4y ago> half your workforce disabled This is such fantastic misinformation, and I'm surprised more people aren't called out on it. It's usually the most supposedly "sophisticated" that espouse it too.
- tlogan 4y agoIf I’m reading this correctly this means that 0.6% of world population died due to COVID. Is my calculation correct?
- pwinnski 4y agoMy rough math says: 20,000,000 / 8,000,000,000 = 0.0025, aka 0.25%
- ck2 4y agoNothing more can hurt the dead and politicians and people don't care if it wasn't their own friends/family. What we should be dealing with is the millions, maybe even a billion worldwide that will have long-covid for the rest of their miserable existence. They're alive but the quality of life is just gone, likely forever. We saw this with the original covid, SARS-COV-1 in 2003, many never recovered.
- dustedcodes 4y ago> millions, maybe even a billion worldwide that will have long-covid for the rest of their miserable existence. What? I don't think there is any data to suggest that 1/8 of the world population has long-COVID or that they have a miserable existence. That's quite judgmental to say about someone also. > They're alive but the quality of life is just gone, likely forever. Forever? How do we know? So many people recovered from long-COVID. Everyone is different, there is no data to suggest that people will have lasting symptoms forever.
- ck2 4y agoConvenient isn't it that they still don't have a test to detect and prove long-covid, forget treating it. Not going to get into a pointless argument here about it, there are already many studies showing at least 10% of people who get covid now have long-covid and it's decimated the workforce. https://www.brookings.edu/research/new-data-shows-long-covid-is-keeping-as-many-as-4-million-people-out-of-work/ https://www.brookings.edu/research/new-data-shows-long-covid... Long-Covid deniers might be the worst of all because the suffering is very real and they don't "get it" until it's their turn, and then it's too late.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoWe are going to eugenics them. You can already see the foundations of it in the "no one wants to work anymore" campaign, the immediate and intense denial of long covid as even a thing, the absolute refusal to consider or weigh long-term effects in covid policies, things like MAID in canada, the increasingly aggressive propaganda campaign against the homeless. For people with long covid we're going to deny it's real, deny healthcare, blame them for their financial consequences, give no support, then offer suicide.
- mcculley 4y agoI built some tooling around the CDC data. I am interested in input on how to better visualize it: https://mcculley.github.io/VisualizingObservedDeaths/ https://mcculley.github.io/VisualizingObservedDeaths/