7 ms·
sigh can we not have targeted-by-nationality bans and instead have .. rules? If Tiktok the app is performing surveillance, ban surveillance by apps. All of the
by pjc50 4y ago
sigh can we not have targeted-by-nationality bans and instead have .. rules?
If Tiktok the app is performing surveillance, ban surveillance by apps. All of them. Or make it technically impossible to escape its little sandbox, and let people have their entertainment.
- bheadmaster 4y agoBut what about national security? Surveillance by _our_ guys is necessary!
- dylkil 4y ago>ban surveillance by apps if only
- samatman 4y agoWe should have rules that include forbidding any Chinese company from selling SaaS or social media until CCP takes the Great Firewall down. They've made a pariah internet and they should stay there. Suit you? Suits me.
- pjc50 4y agoWhat about Russian social media (I think vk got sanctioned but not livejournal)? What about, given the other thread, Qatar? Should Orkut (Brazilian) have been allowed? My point is that the rules should target what it does rather than simply "China=Bad", since that offers a way back into compliance with the rules. However unlikely that actually is.
- cscurmudgeon 4y ago> Brazilian Nobody is calling for blanket bans of foreign apps. This is a straw man argument.
- vajrabum 4y agoOrkut by the way was created by a Stanford trained engineer at Google. It wasn't Brazilian. Rather it had a Brazilian community.
- unity1001 4y ago> What about What about that is that the US congress allocated $500 m for anti-China propaganda in its last budget and all the free, knowledgeable Americans who are littering this thread with their McCarthyist Cold War comments are just taken in with the 'latest thing' from their government propaganda. Nothing more different than how Saddam was the 'greatest threat to civilization' in 2003, or Gaddafi was in 2011 etc etc. And the 'civilization' they are stanning for is the one that kills its people if they cant pay for healthcare. Without even touching how poor are starting to choose euthanasia in Canada instead of being homeless. ... I see this as a way in which Angloamerican denizens direct their frustrations to external 'enemies' by taking their attention away from the problems at home, which they are powerless to fix. They vilify and demean chosen 'enemies', and direct all the criticism that should happen at home towards those enemies. This avoids both alienation from their own society and the pressure to address the problems at home. Long story short, they just avoid cognitive dissonance.
- yencabulator 4y ago> I see this as a way in which Angloamerican denizens direct their frustrations to external 'enemies' by taking their attention away from the problems at home, which they are powerless to fix. They vilify and demean chosen 'enemies', and direct all the criticism that should happen at home towards those enemies. This reminded me of the two-party system...
- unity1001 4y ago> This reminded me of the two-party system... Yes, well spotted - the two party system definitely employs the same mechanic: all the evils are projected out to the 'enemy', and all the wrongs in their own group are ignored. This provides group cohesion and allows them to avoid cognitive dissonance and taking responsibility for the results of their own choices. If there were more than two viable parties, or, god forbid 3-4 viable parties like in many European countries, this would be near impossible to make work. You cant vilify 2-3 other groups as the 'ultimate' evil at the same time...
- thesuitonym 4y agoSo your response to the Great Firewall being bad is to... implement one of our own?
- samatman 4y agoI see a sharp difference between preventing Chinese IP addresses from accessing whatever they would like, and allowing Chinese corporations to profit from the West's liberty while denying it to their subjects. So, no, that is not my response at all. There is no technology involved in kicking these corporations out of the civilized world, just political will.
- pessimizer 4y agoThat's because there is one. > preventing Chinese IP addresses from accessing whatever they would like is a technical thing that you can do with computers, and > allowing Chinese corporations to profit from the West's liberty while denying it to their subjects. is nationalistic nonsense that lacks any reference to anything material.
- unity1001 4y ago> out of the civilized world Which civilized world.
- samatman 4y agoThe.
- est 4y agoHow about block .edu access to China in exchange for GFW?
- krageon 4y agoWe can't have rules that aren't governed by nationality, because the US basically only sees nationality. TikTok is called "an issue" not because of what it does, why it does it or how it does it. It is called that because of who is doing it. As such, we can expect all this racism couched in careful political language to continue and keep continuing.
- sgu999 4y agoNot everything is rooted in racism... If Bytedance was a company from any of the Asian allies to the US, it would likely not be much of an issue.
- cscurmudgeon 4y agoWhy is this racism? Is this racism because China is mostly made up of one race? Then, we should ask why that is the case. (E.g. https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/06/30/chinese-communist-party-han-baby-boom-sterilization-ethnic-minorities/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/06/30/chinese-communist-party...) > because the US basically only sees nationality Is China more generous here? It is funny that any valid criticism of China is fought with claims of racism.
- LightHugger 4y agoThis is rather specifically not racism. You are allowed to have opinions about a country that has to do with it's government and the way it operates, without being racist. How do you or anyone else benefit from trying to connect this to racism?
- SuoDuanDao 4y agoI was with you till the r-bomb. Racism may be one consequence of US-China relations, but the proper r-word for the US celebrating Meta's data harvesting while condemning TikTok's is realpolitik.
- mc32 4y agoTargeting by nationality is how it works: Iran, Russia, N Korea, Venezuela, etc. Else it turns into whack-a-mole.
- darkteflon 4y agoWe can - and should - have robust privacy laws at home. We should also not roll over for our adversaries. China under Xi Jinping is, without a doubt, adversarial, and the risks are existential.
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoYou need to specify who "our" is there. USA's upper echelons, presumably? The risks are existential to ...? Again presumably you mean those who thrive under USA-centric capitalism? You think the CCP are planning a forced takeover of Western democracy?
- vorpalhex 4y agoI think the genocide of a people concerns us all.
- krolden 4y agoYou mean like the native Americans? Pretty sure that's still the largest scale, most drawn out genocide in the entire history of our species.
- hoolabooladoola 4y agoLakota checking in to tell you that a basic reading of history would confirm that you’re pretty wrong. Please don’t what-about the Uyghurs to Native American history because it’s disrespectful both ways, and minimizes their suffering. For all the conflict with Europeans, our historical experiences with them, painful as they may have been and remain, were much more nuanced and complicated than what is happening in China. I have also never met anyone native who thinks of our history as a genocide, and I’m involved in tribal politics. Honestly even calling our history a genocide is a dramatic simplification that removes our agency (all too common in non-native takes). We fought back and won some things, lost others. That’s not something you can say about victims of genocide.
- cscurmudgeon 4y ago> can we not have targeted-by-nationality bans and instead have .. rules? Let's have reciprocal rules. If country X bans US social media then why shouldn't the US do the same?
- sgu999 4y agoI've never understood either. This should be de facto for any market...
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoBecause USA supposedly values freedom of conscience and actions (within a framework) of its citizens, something it says distinguishes it from China. If they're distinguished in this way then them acting differently is expected.
- zip1234 4y agoThe rule is that if you arbitrarily block American companies then your country gets blocked too. It's called fair competition. If you open your country for American companies that are treated the same as your companies then we will do the same. Otherwise, no. The Chinese government and it's companies should not be treated as American citizens.
- cscurmudgeon 4y agoTo be tolerant, you have to be intolerant of intolerance.
- mhb 4y agoBecause, ceteris paribus, unilateral free trade benefits an entity regardless of whether its counterparty taxes or restricts its trade. Because comparative advantage. Because you don't jump off a bridge because Johnny jumped off a bridge.
- Eisenstein 4y ago> Because you don't jump off a bridge because Johnny jumped off a bridge. Why not? Is 'below the bridge' a place we need to get to, and do we have a parachute?
- solardev 4y agoChina isn't going to listen to your rules. Ban whatever you want, Chinese companies don't have to comply, and don't have to tell you when they're not complying... Unless you audit every foreign app's source code and sign its binaries, those laws are meaningless. And if you do that you're really just swapping foreign advertising for domestic wiretapping. shrug Lose-lose.
- jasonlotito 4y ago> China isn't going to listen to your rules And then they are banned. Not because they are China or TikTok, but because they break specific rules we hold everyone to.
- solardev 4y agoYou won't be able to tell when they're not following the rules.
- CyanBird 4y agoJust stop moving the goalposts while discussing and people might take you more seriously
- solardev 4y agoErr, pretty sure that was the entire premise of my post -- that you wouldn't be able to tell when they're not complying unless you audit and sign all their code before distribution.
- imbnwa 4y agoThis seems like an argument no Chinese software on American devices, what makes the difference?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- OJFord 4y agoOk, so what, you ban warrant-less data-sharing with governments? Warrant-from-certain-trusted-countries-less data-sharing with governments? Can't just ban data-sharing with governments, there's the infamous US 'CLOUD' act and surely similar/less-specific but essentially amounting to the same legislation all over the place.
- Xeoncross 4y agoGlobal rules for user privacy would be fantastic! But lets start by simply banning the most criminal organizations first. If the KGB, CCP, or any other group known for imprisoning and killing literally millions of people is running a social network we need to block it right away. Bytedance has forced CCP members on their board and you can bet the government uses the user data, behavior data and biometrics to help squash dissent. Then we can move on to blocking the networks sharing data with less dangerous groups.
- CyanBird 4y ago> But lets start by simply banning the most criminal organizations first NSA and cghq have tapped onto the global fiber optic systems on a global scale and see spying on every single person on the planet with dragnet systems alongside as you say biometrics, and that includes US citizen data. Where does that fall into?
- Xeoncross 4y agoWho is the priority here? Stopping the US who is spying on everyone or stopping the CCP who is murdering hundreds of thousands of it's own citizens. You climb a mountain one step at a time.
- computerfriend 4y agoLots of things can be bad at the same time. What NSA and GCHQ do is worth discussing, for sure. But it has nothing to do with this.
- shkkmo 4y agoThe NSA and GCHQ can literally and legally do the exact same things. In what possible what does it have "nothing to do with this"? If you are making a list of the worst actors in terms of global surveillance, they have to be at the top... The only reasons not to include them are purely nationalistic.
- 4y ago
- amelius 4y ago> ban surveillance by apps ==>> How??? <<==
- thesuitonym 4y agoLevy fines on app stores that allow surveillance apps.
- amelius 4y agoWhat if the phone/appstore is Chinese?
- thesuitonym 4y agoIf they do not operate in the US, then US laws don't apply. If the do operate in the US, they must comply with US laws.
- kube-system 4y agoHow would an App Store possibly know? Surveillance often happens out of band, and under foreign jurisdiction. The apps themselves may not even know or may be prohibited from disclosing it.
- jononor 4y agoThat is something the apps and App stores can solve in collaboration. And if they are required to in order to make money, they very likely will.
- pksebben 4y agothis is literally impossible in any case that uses a server to process unencrypted data.
- kube-system 4y ago
- trident5000 4y agoOne predatory thing TikTok does that app stores should have banned ages ago is they repeatedly ask you to show them your contacts. The point is for you to slip up that one time and accidently hit "yes" so they can collect all that info. This should not be allowed.
- AbrahamParangi 4y agoRules are great but rules are not always great. Sometimes the particularities of a situation are more important than the system of rules itself. There is a reason law becomes more like, a guideline in war.
- archagon 4y agoWe are not at war.
- ehnto 4y agoSurveillance isn't the issue I don't think, it's influence. It was easy to underestimate the affect of misinformation back in 2016, but I think by now, after a few political sojourns and a pandemic both riddled with division and information chaos, we should be taking it seriously. It's not that China would try to convert Americans to communism, but I think we should be worried that they could attempt to sway election results via TikTok. TikTok is the most efficient algorithmic feed based website to date, it's ability to take a human and just pour bite sized information into their lives is unmatched in my opinion. It makes you feel like you're part of a group that doesn't even exist, get enough talking heads talking about a topic and you get grass roots cultural movements as people imagine extreme ideas are widespread when they're not.
- rdevsrex 4y agoNot nationality, nation states that are known bad actors.
- animitronix 4y agoNope, we can't do that because we can't force TikTok to make code changes. Banning it is the only solution.
- SkyMarshal 4y agoWe really should have some sort of reciprocity with China by now. Frame it however you want, don't mention China specifically in the bill, etc. But they are no longer a developing nation, they are the largest or second largest economy and military power in the world, and are advancing a set of totalitarian values completely antithetical to what the US and our democratic allies have been fighting for (literally and figuratively) since WWII at least. If US social media, search, and other internet companies are banned in China, then similar Chinese companies should be banned in the US. If US companies can't operate in China except through a joint venture with a Chinese company, to which the US company must transfer its technology to, then same should apply to Chinese companies operating in the US. Etc. It should be clear at this point that negotiations with China won't change anything internally in China. The only option is for the US to do what is in its power to within the US (and perhaps with fellow democratic allies). Aka reciprocity. Reasons for banning Chinese social media particularly: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33657429 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33657429
- DiogenesKynikos 4y agoChina has uniform rules that any internet company operating in China has to follow, whether that company is Chinese or not. Some foreign companies follow the rules and are allowed to operate in China, while others are unwilling to follow the rules, either because they have ethical qualms about the rules (which involve censorship), or more cynically, because implementing those rules would be bad for PR back in the US. More broadly, American tech companies do a massive amount of business in China. Apple is the largest smartphone brand in China. China is the or one of the most important markets for Nvidia, Qualcomm, Texas Instruments, and many other American tech companies. > If US companies can't operate in China except through a joint venture with a Chinese company, to which the US company must transfer its technology to, then same should apply to Chinese companies operating in the US. Your understanding of how things work in China is out of date by about a decade. China has continuously reduced joint-venture requirements over time. There is a select list of industries that require joint ventures, and that list shrinks every year. For example, automobile manufacturing was removed from the list a few years ago, which is why Tesla was able to build its own plant in Shanghai. > It should be clear at this point that negotiations with China won't change anything internally in China. China is actually willing to negotiate over many aspects of how foreign companies operate in China, trade barriers, intellectual property, etc. If the conflict with the US were only about regulations on American companies in China, it would be relatively easy to solve. The Chinese government is very pragmatic about those sorts of issues. However, the conflict is about something much more fundamental: the US government believes that China will soon surpass the US in overall geopolitical power, and the US government desperately wants to prevent that from happening. The US views the high-tech sector as China's Achilles' heel, and believes that it can blunt China's economic development through sanctions (for example, on imports of high-end chips, or on companies like Huawei, SMIC and YMTC). There's no way for China to negotiate with the US over this issue, because China is never going to agree to not develop its economy.
- ZainRiz 4y agoIf you read the first paragraph of the article, the primary concern mentioned is not surveillance, it's influencing the American public in ways that benefits China and harms the US. Psy-ops effectively Here's a segment by 60 Minutes explaining how they show their own citizens educational, beneficial content inspiring them to be better citizens, while the rest of the world gets the degenerative content we usually associate with ticktok. And China could easily further adjust their ranking algorithm further to highlight the views it wants us to have. All social media has the power to do this, but China has both the most adversarial incentive and a demonstrated willingness to do so. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0j0xzuh-6rY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0j0xzuh-6rY
- SkyMarshal 4y agoDon't know why you're being downvoted without explanation, this is absolutely the case, among others. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33657429 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33657429
- spookie 4y agoThe bots be crazy, y'know? But in all honesty, I have noticed among fellow colleagues that this is the case. Even outside of the country, you can tell that people are afraid to speak about politics. I would be too.
- pjc50 4y agoAre "psyops" illegal, or are they free speech? How far beyond the Chinese government does this categorization extend?
- make3 4y agorules are a tradeoff. being restrictive has downsides on what you can and can't do, you may affect negatively something that had only good intentions, you don't know. when you know someone is a bad actor, it is normal to make rules more restrictive, as you know that you're not negatively affecting good uses.
- still_grokking 4y agoBut this would make Google, Apple, Microsoft, Facebook, and all the other big US tech business illegal… Nobody (in the US) wants this obviously. Btw, the EU isn't anything better in this regard: We would like to forbid other countries to spy on us, but the EU authorities "need to have" the possibility "because terrorism, child abuse, and other 'harmful content' & 'disinformation'". (Just see the fresh Digital Services & Digital Markets acts). Same surveillance everywhere. Only it's "OK" when done by "us", the "good ones", but not "the others", because they're the evil "bad ones"; of course.
- pessimizer 4y ago> sigh can we not have targeted-by-nationality bans and instead have .. rules? That won't work because China will just follow the rules. How would that hurt China?
- extrememacaroni 4y agoAh yes, rules. For China. Which now decides pretty much most of the content that the western world's children see. TikTok is part of it, them acquiring gaming companies is another, and there's likely even more ways in which China is gaining control of what we're consuming. I bet China's going to be like "guys we can't do this anymore, they just updated their terms of service with this brand new rule so we can't proceed with the head-in-toilet challenge operation". China is pretty smart, you trying to do the same thing in their country would be impossible. Guess why?
- hellfish 4y ago> If Tiktok the app is performing surveillance, ban surveillance by apps. All of them. No way in hell this will happen, just saying
- shapefrog 4y agoNahh US surveillance is the good kind /s