8 ms·
Tesla rival Rivian posts losses of $1.7B, with worse to come
- gigatexal 4y agoShame, Rivian won't get the DOE loans that helped Tesla stay afloat.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoTesla received $465 million in DOE loans, which it paid back. Rivian is going to need deeper pockets than that.
- HWR_14 4y ago> Tesla received $465 million in DOE loans, which it paid back. Why is "they paid the loan back" always a talking point?
- HorizonXP 4y agoWhy is needing the DOE loan always a talking point? It is not a sin to enlist the help of others to achieve your goals.
- lazide 4y agoA lot of people get angry when the money came from the gov’t (aka their taxes) without their permission to help someone who has more money than them.
- HorizonXP 4y agoI know it’s a lot to ask of the general populace, but self-reflection is key here. I’m smart and confident. But I know that I would be a terrible person to give a $465m loan to. Money is our economy’s way of rewarding those of us with outsized skills. It’s far from perfect, but it’s the best we’ve got. Is Tesla and Elon the best place to put that $465m? Maybe, maybe not. But it was the best we had at the time, and I certainly don’t see anyone better than him now.
- lazide 4y agoThat is indeed a lot to ask of the general populace. But I don’t think even a majority of the populace had an issue with it anyway - it’s always the fringe extremists that get most of the press, they tend to be a lot more quotable than the ‘meh, I guess that’s fine’ folks.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- megaman821 4y agoGM and Chrysler needed them to stay alive. Other companies (including some banks) just took them because why not, the future was uncertain. It turns out Tesla didn't actually need the loan so they paid it back early.
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoSee: PPP program, a near-trillion dollars of "Loans" that were not paid back. Why isn't the numerous instances of federal bailouts in thousands of other companies NOT a talking point if Tesla's is? Savings and Loans, Mortgage crisis, airlines, etc. If you don't think having a premier EV manufacturer in the US when the Chinese are otherwise poised for total domination of the sector isn't an economic national security issue, then I don't know what to tell you.
- HWR_14 4y agoThe PPP was multi-trillion, not near-trillion. And yes, there were a lot of issues with the PPP. That seems to have been fairly unique (thank goodness) The other federal bailouts aren't talked about often on HN, because they are not tech companies. And most of those conversations feature the talking point "they paid back the loan" as well. I have no idea why it's important. I'm fine with the government subsidizing EV manufacturing industries. That's not the question. The question is "why is it important they paid the loan back?"
- tomschlick 4y agoBecause at the time (2009 ish) auto companies were all getting bailout "loans" and many of them from the major auto corps were not paid back. Tesla got a fraction of what they did, and paid it back 9 years early and with interest.
- bonestamp2 4y ago> many of them from the major auto corps were not paid back Which ones were not paid back? GM and Chrysler paid their government loans back. Ford paid their private equity loan back.
- _ea1k 4y agoIts not so much that they paid them back, but that they paid them almost 10 years ago. That wasn't because they had tons of money, that was because the loan wasn't worth the problems it was causing.
- bryanlarsen 4y agoMost of the time that the DOE loan is brought up, the context is the implication that Tesla and SpaceX are parasites that only survive on taxpayer bailouts. So "they paid the loan back" is a pre-emptive counter-strike against that narrative. Probably unnecessary in this case.
- blitzar 4y agoSpot me $465 million for a couple of weeks and I will get it right back to you.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jacobkranz 4y agoExcept that the DOE loan was for 465m. If they lost 1.7m in the quarter then the DOE loan wouldn't even be 1 month of operations. Even with inflation, the loan they received wouldn't touch the losses rivian has been having. I do love their trucks and hope they succeed though
- delusional 4y agoTo anyone else confused while reading this. They lost 1.7 BILLION, the author of this comment mistakenly wrote 1.7 million. It's a simple typo.
- Sakos 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rivian#Public_company https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rivian#Public_company They've already received $11b in private funding and another 13b from the IPO. I don't think money is the problem here.
- adolph 4y agoAnother note about Rivian's later arrival to market is that it will have a harder time selling regulatory credits to other automakers. This profit center is decreasing over time but has averaged about 300M/Q. This is far from making up a 1.7B loss, but shows how Rivian doesn't have some of the first mover tailwinds. Additionally, while Rivian is a premium vehicle and may presumably attract a substantial number of cash buyers, increases in interest rates can't help sales. https://tesla-cdn.thron.com/static/WTULXQ_TSLA_Q3_2022_Update_KPK2Y7.pdf https://tesla-cdn.thron.com/static/WTULXQ_TSLA_Q3_2022_Updat... https://ir.tesla.com/#quarterly-disclosure https://ir.tesla.com/#quarterly-disclosure
- _ea1k 4y agoInstead, they've raised ~15B in capital. If Tesla had been able to do that, they wouldn't have needed a few hundred million in loans either.
- __derek__ 4y agoThe DOE loans helped seed the industry by getting first movers off the ground. That worked, so why would it make more loans?
- skhameneh 4y agoThey should have treated their reservation holders better. I put in a reservation before they signed a delivery van deal, then they played pricing games, then IPO games, and now I'm hearing the RWD versions are being cancelled. Maybe their partnerships will keep them afloat or maybe the quad motor offering will be enough. Either way, I've lost all interest in this company I supported early on and I know I'm the not only one.
- josefresco 4y agoWhat are you buying instead? F-150 Lightning?
- skhameneh 4y agoDecided I don't need a truck, buying a mid-size electric SUV. The Lightning Pro seems positioned really well for price; I did see a Platinum trim at a show which I liked a lot but it's way more cost and vehicle than I need.
- electriclove 4y agoWhat mid-size electric SUVs are out there?
- xeromal 4y agoI had an order for an R1T and a cybertruck but just got a 2003 LX 470 instead. At least the kinks have been worked out. lol
- dawnerd 4y agoI've been seeing a ton of Rivians around town recently so they are shipping cars. They just need to keep ramping up and hoping the higher interest rates are not causing too many cancellations. Their backlog is still 1yr+ though.
- sho_hn 4y agoI understand their non-commercial vehicles not selling, but I expected the deal with Amazon to provide more runway.
- 1123581321 4y agoThey’re selling retail as fast as they can produce them. Same for producing fleet vehicles. Their cash flow is all about their slow production and delivery right now.
- jandrese 4y agoThey've been missing their production targets by a fairly large margin. Ultimately if they can actually build the trucks they should be in a decent spot, but that is apparently difficult.
- jillesvangurp 4y agoYes, they are supply and production constrained; not demand constrained. Like most players in this industry in the current market they actually struggle to satisfy demand. That can only be fixed over time by investing in production capacity and supply chains. Luckily, they have plenty of cash in reserve to survive the next few years. So, if they start addressing those issues, their revenue situation should improve as their production volume stabilizes.
- _ea1k 4y agoIt baffles me that they didn't come up with a better plan for getting a second factory online. If anything kills them, it will be the time taken to get to their second generation, high volume products. Independent car companies don't survive without getting to hundreds of thousands of units a year. Tesla couldn't be profitable with less than 350k/year.
- echelon 4y agoI saw my first one several months ago and was so excited I wanted to take pictures. I've seen five of them in the past week because the headlights are so unmistakable. They draw your attention in a way few vehicle models do. I counted four pickup trucks, one SUV. This was in Georgia, which has a huge pickup market.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- TchoBeer 4y agoIt's very interesting how the EV industry models itself off the software industry, where companies deal more in hype and promises than actual products. This is expected from software, but it's surreal when it's a car company. The only EV company that started as an EV company and actually makes cars is Tesla, Rivian is a strong second and they have made like 2,000 cars.
- parkingrift 4y agoRivian has produced about 14,000 cards YTD and they seem to be on-pace for annualized production of 25,000 cars. That's not an overall impressive number, but getting a car company off the ground seems quite difficult and capital intensive. Rivian seems likely to survive. Some of the others... not so much.
- sergiosgc 4y agoIt's a capital-intensive industry with a long lead development cycle. You develop the product, then you develop the factories, then you actually build the factories. Software has a long lead development cycle but no capital investment in production facilities afterwards. I'd expect the auto industry to have longer times before profitability vs the software industry. It's expected, not surreal.
- mertd 4y ago> Rivian is a strong second BYD would like to have a word.
- ryzvonusef 4y agoRivian has tons of inefficiencies in their system sapping away precious capital Munro had a video [1] just for a single item, seats, and comparing the Ford F150L vs Rivian on a component-by-component basis, and even accounting for slightly higher luxury setting for Rivian, the over engineering and related cost and supply chain issues is astounding. Rivian needs to greatly simplify processes. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bV2e1gokYik https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bV2e1gokYik
- runnr_az 4y agoYeah... I mean, it turns out, the "old" car makers know how to make cars.
- ryzvonusef 4y agofor something like seats, yes, Ford has both its processes, and market understanding pat down (it knows just how luxurious it seats need to be for the segment it's targeting, which material or stitch features are not worth investing on, for example) and can have those seats made in the best possible way. Rivian is making more luxurious seats, so some costs to account for that is understood, but when you four differently sized plastic pieces for each end of the seat, when one same piece could do, (which means four different supply chains instead of one) it really does show the inexperience of new manufacturers. ---- But give a point for the EV side of things too, where old manufacturers are wasting material weight due to legacy frameworks etc (Munro has videos on that too)
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoIt is really funny when EV fans are slowly discovering Kaizen and lean production. Wait until they will figure out what is FMEA.
- antisthenes 4y agoYeah, I think seats are the least of my concerns when buying an EV. I don't want $5000 added to the price tag for fancy seats. Just give me more battery and power. I mean sure, if you make 500+ mile trips frequently, by all means, get yourself a custom car seat, but I just want a frictionless experience of getting from A to B (cheaply)
- thrill 4y agoAmazon took nearly a decade to become profitable, and seven years after its IPO, and that was during the crazy growth of the dotcom era. The article seems to try to make something of the company being around since 2009, ignoring that they were on a shoestring for multiple years until they had the idea and raised enough money to build their R1 prototypes which sparked significant interest. They're hardly hurting for orders with over 100,000 reservations still in their queue. The article seems to want to pain as negative a picture as it can, taking the position that the Mercedes partnership may be a negative because Rivian cautiously (and properly) caveated the investment as not factored into their operational capital flow, when ninety percent of the companies I've seen would be fundraising on that fundraise. without shame and without looking back. As for treating their initial reservation holders better, I don't think the CEO will ever be forgiven for the way he sprang the price increase on them, regardless of his quick about face on the matter. The company most assuredly could do better communicating actual useful information instead of warm and fuzzies with nothing actionable. And finally, they need to come-to-Jesus quit shipping at a rate that doesn't allow absolute quality of assembly and requiring multiple service center visits. Whomever convinced the CEO that shipping anything to be repaired later did the company absolutely no favors. I don't see many companies trying to build a multinational manufacturing operation from scratch these days, much less starting just before Covid kicked everyone's asses. Rivian will, eventually, be fine.
- runnerup 4y agoAmazon always seemed to claim they could have been profitable in the years after they IPO'd but simply chose to reinvest in growth and development. Investors believed in high future returns on this re-investment and preferred it over extracting it via dividends. I'm not sure Rivian is making similar claims or investors would believe them if they were. Most likely, investors in Rivian are anxious for them to become profitable now that they're finally producing and selling cars. The "hard/expensive" part should be over for Rivian now that their production lines are operational. These are very different companies operating in very different industries.
- bryanlarsen 4y ago
- __derek__ 4y agoIn what way is Rivian a Tesla rival? They don't compete directly.
- Delphiki 4y agoBecause articles with "Tesla" in the title get more clicks.
- __derek__ 4y agoTrue. I suppose it could be considered "context" for the headline, since readers are more likely to know Tesla than Rivian, although that's also true for Ford.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jedc 4y agoThey are both companies making EV-powered passenger cars? (And ONLY EV-powered vehicles).
- bradyd 4y agoHow don't compete directly?
- __derek__ 4y ago
- impulser_ 4y agoI don't see how this company or other smaller EV companies can compete at the scale a lot of investors think they will be at in the next few years. Tesla had first to market advantage as well as autopilot to put them at the front of the market, but these companies don't have any of those advantages. How are they going to compete in the market against Tesla, Ford, VW, GM, Daimler and other big auto companies who are going to be flooding the market with their EV over the next years and out scaling them do to having massive amount of cash, infrastructure, and supply chains already built. While Rivian will be stuck spending massive amount of cash to build infrastructure and supply chains all while playing catch up. Ford is already outselling Rivian trucks and SUV with their Lighting, and Mach-E models all while being a profitable company. Rivian is already valued at over half the value of Ford. Where do investors see the growth?
- echelon 4y agoWhile I agree that it will be difficult for smaller EV startups to compete against the whole market, this line always stands out to me: > Tesla had first to market advantage There is nothing that makes Tesla a monopoly. At the time the Ford Model T was itself in Tesla's shoes, it used to come in only one color. Competitors quickly filled in for unmet market demand and introduced lots of options. Just like Ford, Tesla will not be able to meet the demands of every consumer, irrespective of their current production capacity. Plenty of industrialized nations have a vested interest in their automotive industries and will do whatever it takes to help them along and grow to be competitive. Vehicle production is a national security interest. It supports factories and workers, keeping them fresh and knowledgeable. It provides great domestic jobs, domestic goods, and export potential. In times of war or other pressing need, these factories can be shifted to other types of production. Countries will ensure that their automotive industries survive. This will not be a single company market. This will not even be a 10 company market. You'll see fifty auto companies competing and producing EVs. Tesla may remain the market leader, but they will not dominate the market.
- _ea1k 4y ago> This will not be a single company market. Exactly! Not only that, but "second movers" like Rivian have some advantages too. They don't have to build out their own charge network to support coast to coast travel. They don't have to invent their own charge standard because the industry one was limited to 50KW. That also have lots of intangible benefits. In the early days of Tesla, reviews focused heavily on range and the lack of charging. Rivian reviews have been able to focus more on the vehicle, since people are more accustomed to EVs now. I see far fewer "oh noes, where will a customer charge" stories in the vehicle's reviews. The challenges that are similar are all around scaling the business. Launching a car company is hard. Rivian is exceptionally well capitalized, though.
- zaroth 4y agoThis is kind of a nasty article that just totally ignores the economics of scaling a complex manufacturing company. The same quarter last year Rivian earned a nominal $1mm. This quarter they produced actual product they sold for $536 million. I don’t know much about Rivian’s product, but I know people called Tesla “structurally unprofitable” for years. They were totally bankrupt, a fraud, etc… Fact is that it costs a tremendous amount of money to scale up a car company to the point where volume and margins will lead to profitability and positive free cash flow. What matters is that they are shipping real cars, and that people who own their cars are nearly fanatical in their love and support for them. If that is true, which I don’t know if it is, then burning money to scale up is the right move.
- api 4y agoThe oil and conventional ICE industries are still desperately hoping that EVs will fail and I'm sure they are sponsoring incredible amounts of astroturf to that effect. I got an EV a while back. It's a Nissan Leaf, not the "sexiest" EV by any stretch, but other than recharge time it outperforms a similar class gas car on every single metric: fuel cost, driving experience, acceleration, overall performance, TCO, reliability, and so on. Gas cars are inferior in every single way except recharge time and (depending on model) range and the gap is closing rapidly in those areas.
- TheLoafOfBread 4y agoIf BEVs won't go down with those prices, you can be sure they will fail in same way as biofuels did in EU - slowly forgotten.
- zaroth 4y agoI think this is just head in the sand thinking. BEVs are here to stay and are indisputably the future. EVs are already cheaper than comparable ICE vehicles in terms of TCO, and they can be made cheaper than comparable ICE vehicles even up-front. But more importantly, gasoline will only ever get more expensive. The expertise to maintain extremely complex and efficient gasoline engines will only get more expensive. The taxes on burning gasoline will only get more expensive. And as volume falls, gas stations have to spread their overhead across fewer gallons sold, only exacerbating the price increase at the pump. All the while electricity will only get less expensive. Many homeowners will choose to make a small upfront investment in panels and produce more energy onsite than they will ever consume, making their EVs even less expensive per mile. Real-world advances in battery tech and smart grid infrastructure will allow the car to play double-duty as a backup power source for the home, and even triple duty a profit-generating part of the electrical grid. The only limiting factor for BEVs is charging infrastructure. If you have a home you can charge at, and particularly if you have a roof you can put solar panels on, then your next car, or the car after that, will absolutely be an BEV. For those without home charging, we will either need incredible public charging infrastructure, or perhaps the ability for the car to go get itself a charge on its own in the middle of the day/night.
- samsepi0l 4y agoUnrelated really, but I think the design/spec of the Rivian trucks look great. Just cant imagine spending $100k+ on a truck.
- arcturus17 4y agoWell, are you the type of person or business who would make money off said truck?
- samsepi0l 4y agoNope. I'm just a regular human being who does not profit from the use of a truck
- rasz 4y agoAre you asking if he has a car dealership?
- arcturus17 4y agoNo, I'm asking whether the truck would be a money-making asset for them. Even a construction contractor or similar would fall into this category.
- rasz 4y agoTruck in a business doesnt make money, it is a depreciating fixed asset.
- arcturus17 4y agoSo is machinery in an industrial company. The notion that a depreciating asset does not make money is pedantic and better left to classroom settings.
- tzm 4y agoThey're ramping up production which will take time to see revenue. What I question most is whether the company culture has a sense of urgency needed compete compared to Tesla.
- diebir 4y agoWhat a strange idea to build an el camino (unibody pickup) for a flagman ev by a company... It is not a good pickup. It is not a good SUV. Why? Because Ford sells a lot of pickups? But Ford pickups are actually useful as pickups, Rivian is not.