17 ms·
Meta fires a software engineer two days after he relocated from India to Canada
- jbverschoor 4y agoSo he gets 4 months of pay, his signing bonus, and all if his shares vest immediately.
- zinckiwi 4y agoI’m not knowledgeable about Canadian work visas specifically, but many countries extend them only within the context of specific employment. In other words, he may need to take what he can get, in a rough economy, under immense stress (as someone who has lived in that situation before can attest to), lest he have to go all the way back.
- aww_dang 4y agoIf he wanted to live and work in Canada, wouldn't applying for jobs in Canada be easier than applying while living in India? As much as I dislike FB as a company, I'm not sure he is worse off?
- zinckiwi 4y agoCatch-22. You often can't legally search for a job as a tourist. Typically, like the US H1-B, a sponsoring company needs to "prove" that they tried and failed to source the employee onshore first, and therefore immigration is the interest of the domestic company. I'm separated from my family right now -- wife and kids -- while waiting on an immigration process that has taken far longer than we were expecting. I assure you that any immigration-related worry can seem outsized.
- sumitgt 4y ago> and all if his shares vest immediately I don't think so. I believe they only get the November 15, 2022 vesting.
- compsciphd 4y agowhich if there's a 1 year cliff, means he didn't have a vesting date then....
- charcircuit 4y agoMeta does not do cliffs.
- compsciphd 4y agook, didn't know that, though would he still have had a vest date then? ex. lets say meta vests one per month on the 15th, and he starts on the 14th, would he normally have vested right away, or would he have had to wait to Dec 15th? (and can apply to whatever schedule you want, just picked a monthly one for example sake).
- charcircuit 4y agoI don't know enough about Meta to answer that.
- rullelito 4y agoA (vesting) cliff doesn't mean you have to wait 1 year for the vesting, it means that your vesting significantly reduces after 1 year.
- stavros 4y agoI don't know how you've seen it, but I've seen it mean exactly that. A one-year cliff means that your whole year (usually your first) vests at once, in one day.
- kortilla 4y agoNo, that’s not what a cliff is. https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/cliffvesting.asp https://www.investopedia.com/terms/c/cliffvesting.asp What you’re talking about is front-loading or ballooning vesting schedules.
- jonathanhd 4y agoThe bigger issue is that he is likely now without a work visa and has to scramble to avoid deportation.
- bawolff 4y agoI dont think that's true in canada. IANAL but i was under the impression that if you are fired you are still allowed to stay until your work permit expires. Its only usa that has the problem you describe.
- culturestate 4y ago> Its only usa that has the problem you describe. The grace period can vary wildly by country and, often, by the type of visa or work permit you hold. Just in my own sphere of experience, for example: - Hong Kong GEP holders can stay for the length of their original permit, while people on domestic help visas get only 14 days - EU Blue Card and Japanese work visa holders get 90 days - US H-1B holders get 60 days - Singaporean EP and Chinese Z-visa holders get 30 days Of course there are ways to extend all of these (and some are much easier than others) but you can't legally work unless and until you find a new sponsor.
- Aeolun 4y ago> Japanese work visa holders get 90 days In basis. If you can still support yourself and you are still looking for a job Japan has no issues extending this.
- Broken_Hippo 4y agoIn Canada, one can stay until it expires but they aren't allowed to work for anyone else in that time. (some will let you look for work for varying times) It isn't the same doom, but doom nonetheless.
- Tao3300 4y agoCanada, so IANAB
- SXX 4y agoI wouldn't be so certain that his contract is as good as contract of US citizen working for Meta. Whole point of hiring and relocating people from abroad is that they have much weaker negotiation position so they usually being paid much less.
- weatherlite 4y agoIt remains to be seen whether relocating someone will still be a thing as much as it is now. I mean, we have remote tools and most big companies have branches everywhere in the world. Why bother with visas, lawyers and tragic cases like this. Sure for people who want to become a citizen somewhere in the West its great. For the companies I'm not that sure its better than the alternatives.
- SXX 4y agoRelocation to US / Canada is usually primary reason why people look for offers like that. No amount of remote tools an offices abroad will ever replace option to move countries. I am immigrant myself who want to get to EU / US at some point so I can understand reasons of other people really well.
- weatherlite 4y agoYou're saying there aren't enough good Indian engineers who will agree to work for Meta from India? I highly doubt that's accurate.
- SXX 4y agoI'm not from India so no idea how many good engineers are there. I am immigrant myself though and I have a lot of friends who changed countries so have some insight there. People who decide to move countries usually not just do it for reasons like career or more money. Most often it's because they dislike something in their home country or want better opportunities for their children. So no amount of shiny remote work tools or good local offices will make any difference for people who look for relocation. They'll just choose to work for company that does offer relocation.
- coffeeblack 4y agoSounds like a good deal. And plenty of time to find a new position if he wants to stay in Canada.
- slaw 4y agoOne person I know in Seattle worked for 2 months before layoff day and didn't get severance package. Probably 90 days is minimum working time.
- ramtatatam 4y agoI can't see the article to mention if he gets this package, remembering a few situations from my life I'd expect him not to get any package since he only worked for 2 days..
- throwaway1207 4y agonot true, everyone affected gets the package whether they joined 2 days ago or 2 years ago.
- ramtatatam 4y agoI don't know that, I don't work for Meta. Would be nice if you can share source to back your claim, if Meta is paying whole package to somebody who only worked for 2 days then that would be entirely different story for that guy.
- Aeolun 4y agoYou can skimp on the extras, but you cannot skimp on the basics. It’s their fault for hiring him after all. Not his fault for coming to the US and trusting them.
- ramtatatam 4y agoI agree, even if he gets the same benefits, he is still left in very bad place.
- Tao3300 4y agoCanada is not the US
- Aeolun 4y agoYes. Hence why I expect him to get at least the basics of the deal. Obviously he’s not getting any extra money for years worked.
- djmips 4y agoIt's still not worth it.
- jbverschoor 4y agoI'm not sure what Amazon was paying him in India as a SDE-2, but the range is somewhere between $35k and $50k So he probably got around 1.5 years of his previous yearly comp.
- kreetx 4y agoI mean, if it was just the title that happened, but actually the big layoffs coincided with the person moving from India to Canada, thus something like this was bound to happen. Do we really need to drum up animosity towards Meta that bad? (They already do it without needing to add a click bait twist on top..)
- senko 4y agoHe uprooted his life, moved across the globe, then got laid off and is likely facing a prospect of having to leave Canada (not familiar with work visa types there). This sucks, and the fact "it was bound to happen" (which is incorrect, it's not a law of nature) does not absolve Meta.
- anshumankmr 4y agoExactly what I was going to say.We need to have empathy every once in a while. 11K people being fired from Meta seems abstract but these are 11K families that have been at least temporarily disrupted.
- autotune 4y agoI have been laid off, or close to being laid off in that I had to leave, something like 3 different positions since the start of the pandemic and unemployed for around 6 months (doing amazing now in a recent role but that is besides the point). Was borderline close to being forced to move back in with my parents. I never got a story written up for me about that. I feel sympathy for many of those folks, but why should this guy, or anyone else at META, get so much press for themselves? These things have happened quietly in the background all the time in the industry in the past and nobody bats an eye until now because "META." It is kind of annoying.
- gwnywg 4y agoI'd say it's good we have so much press for this case, maybe he got attention you had not but in my opinion it's good for community if cases like this get highlighted, even if it's not my case...
- rayxi271828 4y agoMy sympathies for the gentleman -- but out of curiosity: for cases like this, what "time duration" would be "not surprising"? Even if he had stayed on for one more month, that would have been as shocking as well. Two months? Three? My suspicion is that there's no time duration within which this wouldn't be an upsetting experience. Perhaps unless we're talking about like a year, which no company would do anyway.
- theFco 4y agoBut there are degrees, also in two days this person has probably close to zero social safety network in Canada. No friends, no colleagues, no acquaintances at other companies. Even 2 or 3 months would have allowed them to start having some friends and do some networking.
- matkoniecz 4y agoAnd now they need to deal at the same time with relocation AND with being fired at the same time.
- andersonmvd 4y agoimho, 3 months at least, 4 would be nice and 6 great
- brigandish 4y agoRestating the Sorites paradox does not mean we're unable to see that being fired 2 days after relocation is worse than 2 years.
- WeylandYutani 4y agoThis happens a lot in my country. Eastern Europeans on temporary contracts and company housing (and we use the word house very liberally it is usually just a bed) end up on the streets when fired. They don't get help from the government because no passport. The socialist welfare state cannot be extended to foreigners or it would run out of € and the temp agencies take no responsibility.
- FeepingCreature 4y agoIf you pay for somebody to relocate to you, you should be legally required to pay for them to relocate back as well. This should have broad political appeal for the obvious reasons.
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoIt should be ideally, but I don't know a country where that is. Relocation between EU countries has no barriers and is relatively common but is expected to be on your own dime. Sure, for skilled professions in demand sometimes you get a relocation bonus to sweeten the deal and soften the financial blow, but there's always the risk that you get laid off during the probation period, which is something you need to take into consideration if you have to uproot your entire family to move to another country for a new job. Best way is to find a cheap place to rent and live below your means for a while until you feel comfortable and stable in your new country/job and not blow all your money on arrival. I've seen this happen a lot. Guy sells everything he has to move family to a new country for a new dream job, then spending big money on renting a nice new house for his family, buying a new car and tons of new stuff for the house and the kids, and a few weeks/months down the line he doesn't pass probation or the company changes course and lays him off, or he realizes the job or city is not what he thought and wishes to leave. And since he hasn't been contributing to the social services for long enough he's not entitled to any welfare/assistance from the state. It happens more often than you think. The good thing is that in EU your residence permit is not tied to an employer so if you get let go, you can still stay and find another job with relative ease, but no country or company that I'm aware of here pays for your relocation if things don't work out for you. That's why having some savings and living below your means for a while is of major importance when you move cities/countries.
- quickthrower2 4y agoImmigration policy is just as much to blame: good enough for meta = good enough for general working residency visa
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoimmigration policy does not address employee rights or notice. Its not wothing scope
- tibbydudeza 4y ago
- tjpnz 4y agoThis could happen to anyone working under an at will system. Nice generalisation of SMEs btw.
- tibbydudeza 4y agoI don't work in the US so "at will" is meaningless to me - unlike the US we have decent labor laws and unemployment. On the SME thing - working on a new database, a replacement for C++, come on really - why is this PO not being processed - it pays the bills and working on interesting stuff after hours :).
- tibbydudeza 4y agoWow - a lot of butthurt people here.
- mk89 4y agoI don't understand. That's unfortunately how it is, sadly enough. Should they have fired another person instead just because of location? I believe they should have not given the GO at all to the hiring manager, but hey... these CEOs nowadays like to take full responsibility accountability blabla-ility for their actions :) Some years ago I worked at a company that had to fire 3 people. They picked one of the guys that was still on probation time (like ~10 days before the end of probation). This person came from South America, and the worst part of it was that he decided to get his family here after a few months, because "you know, I came alone so that it's easier to find an apartment, to have bureaucratic things sorted out, etc.". Yeah. Then the family came and boom, fired. Why did they hire him in the first place? I believe that this is what many companies do wrong.
- ramtatatam 4y agoI'd say it's fair enough to expect not to hire when you plan to lay off... Especially when you make somebody to change their life upside-down...
- throwaway71271 4y agoIts not uncommon for people to turn the company upside-down (by leaving or other ways), why should the company care? The company is a subject to the categorical imperative, but it is also a subject to the seven deadly sins (metaphorically). It does what the law allows in order to preserve itself, and rarely more. In some companies I honestly think that all decisions are made with good intentions from each individual, and yet the emergent results are horrific. (playing devil's advocate)
- user_7832 4y ago> Its not uncommon for people to turn the company upside-down (by leaving or other ways), why should the company care? Just because a person might do something bad doesn't justify the company doing something bad to an innocent employee. And don't forget, Meta could easily sue someone if they for eg sabotaged something. An individual in this case getting fired is not likely to have the resources to sue a company the size of Meta.
- hooby 4y agoImho the real question here is, why is it that Meta keeps hiring right right until they do large layoff rounds? The kind of issue that requires large layoff rounds is not something that just materializes overnight, out of the blue. So why does their management - which should be able to read the writing on the wall, since that's part of their job - not issue a strict hiring freeze (in addition to other measures taken to try and avoid/reduce the impeding layoffs). Why do they go from hiring to firing in the blink of an eye?
- mschuster91 4y ago> So why does their management - which should be able to read the writing on the wall, since that's part of their job - not issue a strict hiring freeze (in addition to other measures taken to try and avoid/reduce the impeding layoffs). Hiring freezes are an internally visible sign (which may lead to critical people jumping ship at the wrong time or uncontrolled ship-on-fire quittings that end up larger than the original plans), but most importantly they are externally visible - and at that point they're market relevant, because early knowledge can be used to time the market as a serious headcount reduction will at least cause a significant volatility for the stock. Since there are specific disclosure requirements on potentially market relevant news, it makes sense to treat hiring freezes and layoffs by default as market relevant to keep the SEC and other market regulators away. And often enough, it's only highest level leadership that knows about plans, with not even HR being involved until the very last second, much less some middle manager with hiring authority. It absolutely sucks for everyone involved, particularly new hires, but I don't see a way around that for a publicly traded company. However, companies should be mandated to cover all costs of relocation and half a year severance for breach of contract in bad faith for such cases.
- hooby 4y agoSo, basically a Perverse Incentive [0] - a systemic problem. But the firings are externally visible as well - and it's also externally visible whether the firings occurred with or without a hiring freeze in place beforehand. And whether the number of people fired is larger - or smaller is visible as well (and after a hiring freeze and counter-measures it's always gonna be somewhat smaller). And one of those two options signals greater unpredictability and volatility then the other - which to investors means higher risk, right? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Perverse_incentive
- mduggles 4y agoI'm horrified by so many of the comments here that seem to lack even the most basic of human decency. Allow me to fill people in for those who have never uprooted your life and moved across the world for a job. It is a massive commitment on the part of the employee, where you sell the majority of your earthly possessions, property, cars, etc. Then you go through an immigration process which even if its handled by FAANG involves a ton of work. You get to the new country, find a place to live and start to adjust. So to do that to someone and then days later be like "we actually don't want you" is beyond shitty. This persons visa is dependent on their employment so now they get to go into a city they don't know and try desperately to find employment with an employer who is interested in sponsoring someone from abroad (which is a small fraction of the total employers). For all you budding Elons, here's a shorthand for it. If you ask someone to move across the world and don't need them anymore, give them three months on the books to find somewhere else that don't count against their visa. It will give them a chance to get settled and go on interviews. Or don't recruit internationally.
- hliyan 4y agoI'm inclined to agree. Giving a neutral, business sounding label to something like this, and normalising it doesn't make it right. As an interaction between two individuals, this would be immediately recognised as morally wrong, even if contractually right. Isn't morality supposed to scale?
- MonkeyClub 4y agoTheoretically it is; practically corporations are implicitly immoral - they’re not human, they have no feelings, it’s only left to whatever (HR in this case) procedures are in place to ensure a positive outcome. Such procedures tend to fail when you move fast and break things.
- feet 4y agoNo matter which way you try and slice it, there's always a human at the end of the decision. A human made the policies, a human made the layoff decision, a human decides to enforce policy.
- alkonaut 4y agoLayoffs are a fact of life in running a business. Treating people poorly is a choice.
- yreg 4y agoDo we have a reason to believe he was treated poorly?
- Ar-Curunir 4y agoDid you read the title?
- yreg 4y agoYes. It doesn't say anything about how they compensated him.
- alkonaut 4y agoIs there always a dollar figure when some treatment becomes acceptable?
- yreg 4y agoDepends on the treatment. If someone tortures me, then probably not. If someone hires me, I move to the other side of the world, they fire me in two days and pay me out a million dollars, then I would say it is very acceptable. Also, compensation might be more than money.
- mafuy 4y agoI don't think you appreciate how difficult it is to navigate in a foreign country with no help. You could well be given $100 million and end up on the street because you were unable to complete the move-in process on your own. It's not like you can wave with dollars bills to fix this.
- kepler1 4y agoI mean, setting aside the emotional aspect of the issue for a moment and just being analytical, can't we also acknowledge that there is a type of observation bias here? When you're talking about thousands of people getting hired a year, and a sudden event having to be done that affects 11,000 employees, you're bound to get a couple of very unusual and unfortunate cases. If we looked at different windows of time, we would get even more people who fall into sympathetic categories. How many people were just laid off after just 2 weeks of being on the job / moving countries? How about a month ago? 2 months? I wonder why the news story didn't look at an even larger window? But I guess they just are interested in (or heard about) the sensational case that draws your attention, huh? Or isn't the real story, "where's the person who got off his flight that morning and received an email that he was laid off?" When you deal with human processes, and have to draw a line somewhere, certain cases will pop up as falling into very odd or unfortunate cracks. Hopefully the compensation and severance is designed to make up for these cases.
- mkagenius 4y ago> When you deal with human processes, and have to draw a line somewhere, certain cases will pop up as falling into very odd or unfortunate cracks. So, how does it work - a snap like Thanos? or is there a process behind every name who is getting fired? this is ridiculous, it can't just be a chance that they fired him. They take multiple interviews to hire each individual, atleast half as much effort will go in firing an individual right?
- c_hackett 4y agoClearly the impact to a visa holders (especially new ones) is high. I would be curious if this something that can be insured against? Either as an employer to provide certainly in an uncertain jobs market, or as an employee about to relocate.
- haspok 4y agoI read a story on my LinkedIn feed about a lady who had it worse: she relocated to the US with her family a couple months ago on an L1 visa, before being fired from Meta. Because of this, she now has a few months to pack her belongings, because obviously the L1 is non-transferable, and even if she applies and wins on the H1-B lottery and finds a sponsor the earliest she could start working again is fall of next year. There is nothing she can do about it. Life is really unfair sometimes.
- sneak 4y agoI think that treating the adversarial and anti-business (and, dare I say, inhumane) US immigration policies as simple facts of life is a mistake. These are not stone tablets carved by a god; these are policies that people presently living dreamed up and implemented. They were made and they can be unmade. Life isn’t unfair nearly as often as US immigration policies are unfair.
- Aeolun 4y agoI think it’s more that this one lady cannot fight against the entire US judicial system. Especially with the SC as it is.
- irae 4y agoIf there is no provision on L1 for early termination, then the rules of this particular type of visa are entirely broken and needs fixing. I understand the reason L1 exists, I actually lived in the US under L1 myself, but there is no excuse for a country to accept a worker they deemed necessary and acceptable to migrate, and then impose such a harsh rule for edge cases. If the person needs to be let go because somehow their own fault, it is fine. But layoffs are an example where the company is at fault and the employee is the victim - in this case the minimum the government should do is to offer a fair amount of time for the person to find another job.
- pas 4y ago... but who gambles their whole family on these horrible visas? (Okay, obviously people who don't have better options. Still, very disturbing cautionary tales :/)
- ArcMex 4y agoVery sad indeed. Just a few days ago, I was thinking about what relocating could mean for me and my family and it frightened me to think about being a stranger in a strange land without a job. Wishing them best of luck.
- zelphirkalt 4y agoApparently Facebook (oh, wait, it is Meta now, how could I forget) cares about employees as human beings as little as it cares of its useds as human beings. Good to have these kind of things surface and brought to attention. Some counterweight against the rose-colored glasses, through which many people see Face...Meta. Working for FB/Meta is a questionable choice in itself, though.
- lnauta 4y agoGoing on on the whole fb/meta thing, I was wondering why people don't do the same for Alphabet. Everyone still calls it Google. But for facebook, the name was dropped almost immediately. Isn't that strange?
- zelphirkalt 4y agoMight be for historical reasons. Was Google first or Alphabet first there? Also because of time. In Internet terms it has been ages since Google became big. Little is heard about what Alphabet is actually doing, except being the parent company of Google. I couldn't name one thing.
- bumblebritches5 4y ago
- jasoneckert 4y agoWhile I've never experienced a similar situation myself, I've had several friends and acquaintances who have had similar issues with tech jobs that required relocation from Canada to the US - from having jobs rescinded last minute after selling their home in Canada, to being downsized due to company cutbacks within days or weeks of starting the new job (after all, new employees are more likely to be let go during those times). In short, there is always a risk associated with relocation for work, and the job or location must be worth that risk in order to upheave your life and move for it.
- snicky 4y agoDo immigrants do this often? I mean sell their houses, cars and other belongings before moving abroad? It's a sincere question from someone who also considered emigrating for work at some point. I could never imagine getting rid of all my stuff before I actually sit down in the office with my new bosses and co-workers for a couple of months and have a taste of what it is like. I won't be buying any house or a car in the new place right away anyway. I could just rent both before I decide I want to stay there for good. Or am I talking from some sort of a privileged position of a person who has some savings to deal with situations like this ... or maybe I'm too conservative and that's why I never left?
- Aeolun 4y agoGetting rid of excess possessions after you leave your original country is much harder.
- tobyhinloopen 4y agoAm I the only one who cannot scroll that page?
- nnoitra 4y ago
- genidoi 4y agoSo many commenters here (presumably US/CA citizens) don't realize that the gut-wrenching feeling of being laid off whilst your visa depends on uninterrupted employment is _nothing_ like the SHTF-but-all's-ok feeling of being laid off 'regularly'. In the USA, for most work visas, you are given a 60 day death clock pleasantly sugarcoated as a 'grace period' to find a new employer or leave the country. Cue trying weave in that baggage in between screening calls & technical interviews to explain to prospective employers how you have 47 days and 15 hours left to be hired or leave. The complication of dealing with USCIS and attaining a work visa (usually bound to your employer) is a marathon even with unlimited time, but in a puny 8 week window?... In my own experience this also happened in mid 2021 when Australia's borders were closed (to AU citizens as well...) so leaving back home wasn't even an option.
- rejectfinite 4y agoAnd so many people are okay coming into another country and wage dump because "its their right" to move halfway across the world to work in the USA or EU. See stuff like: https://www.thelocal.se/20070523/7387/ https://www.thelocal.se/20070523/7387/ You can't have it both ways. ---- I guess this is just CBS being racist :) https://www.cbsnews.com/news/how-h-1b-visas-have-been-abused https://www.cbsnews.com/news/how-h-1b-visas-have-been-abused... "But this week on 60 Minutes, correspondent Bill Whitaker reports that the H-1B visa program has since been seriously abused, allowing companies to fire American workers and to bring in cheap foreign labor." ---- No no, just downvote me more, don't reply, don't discuss, just hide what is uncomfortable.
- genidoi 4y agoFor the USA, you can't attain an H1-B / E-3 / <other work visa for SWE or other technical role> without your employer compensating you above the prevailing wage[0] (determined by the DoL) paid in the city you are being hired in in the field you are being hired in. [0] https://www.dol.gov/agencies/eta/foreign-labor/wages#:~:text=The%20prevailing%20wage%20rate%20is,the%20area%20of%20intended%20employment https://www.dol.gov/agencies/eta/foreign-labor/wages#:~:text....
- papito 4y agoI sympathize sincerely. A friend once worked at a startup that hired new people and made them relocate from all over the U.S. to NYC. The founders said noting about the runway ending. A few weeks later, the company closed. I imagine being from India, you have little leverage. Just getting sponsored is a feat. Personally, if I am ever in that situation, I will demand a reciprocal commitment - if you let me go right after I uproot my life, I want a healthy bundle of walk-away money.
- z9znz 4y agoThese scenarios don't just apply to being laid off. Another scenario which happens is that company ownership or control changes, and some key promises which were made to prospective employees get broken. I relocated to a big unpleasant city for a job early in my career, and the big promise from the hiring folks (all good people) was that "we hire at a low rate, but we give big raises fast". Their prime example was another young "star" like me who doubled his salar in less than two years. What the managers (and I) didn't know is that the recent acquisition of the company by a much bigger company meant that significant changes were coming. In my first six months, a lot of the developer perks (free lunch, but just normal food... nothing like a Google lunch) started to get scaled back or eliminated entirely. And then at my six month review, when my first raise should occur, my manager was honestly regretful to inform me that despite my excellent performance, he was only able to give an 8% raise because any higher increase had to be personally reviewed and signed off on by the CEO... and nobody was doing that. So not only did I burn 6 months at a place that was heading downhill, but it took another 6 months to be sure of this when the next review/raise period came (and disappointed). Meanwhile, I had other peers who had gone to some big accounting firms and were already enjoying nice perks, travel opportunities, and rapidly increasing pay. None of this was life shattering, but it is life days or months misspent. The feeling is that one has been cheated, even if there was no malintent on the part of the company. Aka, "bum deal".
- sbarre 4y agoI empathize with your story about being promised one thing and then not getting it.. But I think it's important to acknowledge that in most industries, you get a 2-5% raise maybe once a year, sometimes adjusted for cost of living if your employer is particularly good. Getting an 8% raise after 6 months is actually pretty good, relative to the rest of the working world, even though it's not what you were promised (so I acknowledge that maybe you accepted a lower starting salary with the assumption it would go up quickly - and so definitely a "bum deal"). Even with all the problems we face, we (the tech industry) have it pretty good, relative to the rest of the working world.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- incomingpain 4y agoMeta's loss, some other org in Canada's gain. Has anyone else noticed a great percentage of those being laid off are of asian descent?
- rejectfinite 4y agoNot a Meta problem, this is a USA workers right issue.
- nisegami 4y agoThis happened in Canada
- rejectfinite 4y agoAnd so many people are okay coming into another country and wage dump because "its their right" to move halfway across the world to work in the USA or EU. See stuff like: https://www.thelocal.se/20070523/7387/ https://www.thelocal.se/20070523/7387/ You can't have it both ways. ---- I guess this is just CBS being racist :) https://www.cbsnews.com/news/how-h-1b-visas-have-been-abused https://www.cbsnews.com/news/how-h-1b-visas-have-been-abused... "But this week on 60 Minutes, correspondent Bill Whitaker reports that the H-1B visa program has since been seriously abused, allowing companies to fire American workers and to bring in cheap foreign labor."
- jdright 4y agoYou have zero clue of what you're talking about, don't shame yourself this bad in public.
- rejectfinite 4y agoAnything substantial you want to add?
- jdright 4y agoI was dumb 20 years ago where I thought exactly like you. Also, this kind of thinking is generally coming from people with lack of self-confidence. I've been on both sides of this, and I saw in the last 20 years and continue to see how this works. Now, I'm on the hiring side for the last 7 years, and there is no way this push down wages, in fact it is exactly the opposite, this pushes wages up. I prefer pay more to bring someone very good, than pay half to have someone semi competent. If I restrict my hiring locally, I'll mostly get low quality workers, the market is satured of low quality which will push wages down, the very good ones are very difficult to hire.
- hnfong 4y agoFacebook pays prevailing "Silicon Valley FAANG" wages. There are firms that abuse the H1B process, but Facebook/Meta is not one of those.
- 4y ago
- MrDunham 4y agoSo, I have some inside knowledge on this one. There were many people who were axed as part of the layoffs days after start. But these layoffs were planned for months. The thinking was either 1) we can rescind job offers and give them nothing or 2) at least give a severance package to people who expected employment. Now, I'm not excusing that there are cases like this that fall through the cracks. It really really sucks. I'm not sure how to process it... when you're laying off 10k+ people there are bound to be "bugs"/misses and general failures. Should META have preemptively rescinded this employee's offer so they got nothing but at least didn't move? Maybe. Or give months of pay as an "I'm sorry our timing was awful (like they did)" in exchange for their own failure? Also a bad option given the move. I feel for this person. They got caught in get crossfire and that really blows. I'd be pretty pissed. In the other hand, the thought behind what happened was admirable - even though it created some awful edge cases. META has done a lot to draw ire. In this case I was impressed by management's decision not to rescind offers and save maximum money but to acknowledge that people would have quit jobs, moved, etc and give severances. A counterpoint could be "why give the job offer in the first place"? Given the level of secrecy and reality of a nearly 90k person company - it's highly doubtful that the people involved in the hiring process had any idea of the impending layoffs. Still - super super crappy for anyone who relocated due to the offer.
- madeofpalk 4y ago> Should META have preemptively rescinded this employee's offer so they got nothing but at least didn't move? Maybe. Yes, 100%. Relocating internationally is extremely taxing. Dealing with immigration stuff, even if another company "handles it" for you, it's still a huge toll on you mentally. I would pay $$$ to avoid a needless relocation.
- plgonzalezrx8 4y agoSadly, in the mind of these young white knights making these decisions, they thought they were doing these folks a favor by saving them from their poor country.
- kcplate 4y ago
- sebastianconcpt 4y agoOn the upside of such a shitty situation, being there will bring the guy a lot of other opportunities too to resolve that fast. Or result in something even better than originally thought.
- Invictus0 4y agoI sympathize but also people need to get a clue. This layoff didn't come out of nowhere like people are implying, it was strongly telegraphed in advance. On June 30 Zuckerberg said at an all hands "there are a lot of you that probably shouldn't be here". There were hiring freezes in place. The share price is down like 75% from peak. Stop being dumb sheep and learn to read the signs.
- achr2 4y agoI have watched this countless times in Canada. “Foreign worker visas” are tantamount to indentured servitude. Worse is that companies hire third parties making commissions on finding workers - whose very compensation depends on carefully neglecting to tell the recruits about local market conditions and the lack of safeguards. It is exploitation.
- eric4smith 4y agoImmigration related to work is generally shitty in almost any country worth working in. Even in countries not worth working in. In many countries, Once your employer fires you, then you have 7 days to leave the country. Period. The US/Canada/UK are relatively friendly about this and give a bit more leeway. Don’t get me started on Indian work permits. Yes it’s horrible all around. Working in another country is always a risk and on a whim you can get shafted by your employer. Always have, or start working on a plan B immediately (savings, side project, more money). And please don’t get started on “I’m not able to do anything else” - because that’s not true and if you think about it there is always unrelated things you csn do to get around this. As a person who worked in a few countries - I’m always aware or the fact that at any moment below permanent residency, everything could be pulled away. Please everyone reading about this guy’s fate, never leave your future in the hands of an employer or immigration authorities. Start working on a plan B and a way out - just in case. Anything otherwise is just putting your head in the sand.
- paulcole 4y ago> In many countries, Once your employer fires you, then you have 7 days to leave the country. Period. Just curious because I know nothing about this, but what are 10 countries where this is true?
- eric4smith 4y agoI’m not gonna google that for you. Don’t be lazy, spend the 15 minutes and do that research yourself.
- zhenghao1 4y agoJust one guy and there's all this fuss? I know of companies that layed off 100s of engineers that just relocated from another country. Sometimes it's really not up to the company. It is sad, but that's just the life we live in, in a post-COVID world. Too much uncertainty and things change in a snap.
- lashkhi 4y ago
- known 4y ago