14 ms·
GitHub stars won't pay your rent (2020)
- shrimp_emoji 4y agoClassic mistake. FOSS is not about making money. In fact, it's antithetical to making money. Value extraction is the province of closed source/user hostile software, by nature.
- nequo 4y agoA lot of people and companies are making money from Linux, including Linus Torvalds and many kernel hackers. Linux is GPL’d. I think it is hard to make the claim that making money is antithetical to FOSS.
- nextlevelwizard 4y agoA lot of people are also making money by simply running
- zaik 4y agoThis is quite the definition of an outlier.
- nequo 4y ago“Antithetical” is a normative, not a descriptive statement. The fact that a high-profile FOSS counterexample exists is in contradiction with it.
- rizky05 4y ago
- ilyt 4y agoI mean, if you look at amount of "paying users" vs "all users" it still checks out, just that at the economies of scale of Linux even 0.01% funding it is a ton of money. FOSS is great for doing "common good" code that everyone uses and many sides want to push forward, but not exactly easy to monetize if you're just a dev doing a thing.
- Havoc 4y agoI’d say “some” is more accurate than “ a lot” The first name that came to your mind was Torvalds - hardly a random.
- nequo 4y agoMany companies hire people to contribute to the kernel. Torvalds is the name we remember but there are many others. And that is the kernel. There are also companies like Red Hat and Canonical that make money through their work (more) in the userland. The people that they hire all make money from FOSS. Edit: For example, look at the “Most active 5.10 employers” list here: https://lwn.net/Articles/839772/ https://lwn.net/Articles/839772/
- thomasfromcdnjs 4y agoI've spent thousands of dollars on hosting/services around open source or non for profit work I've did in the last 15 years. buy-me-a-coffee™ Jokes aside, I've never minded paying for things, and never could be bothered doing the open source / paid version model that the author spoke of.
- spacepinball 4y agoMaking a living on FOSS is hard, as you discovered. I hope you succeed, of course. But since I have no good idea what your app is, except "a browser for developers" from the blog text, there is really no chance that I would ever search for this app, hear about it thru word of mouth, or eanything really that would make me end up testing your app. Here's some other ways you could have tried to approach the situation: - stop providing compiles, while selling access to the compiles on patreon or something. this way you can keep engagement from other developers and stay FOSS. - offer commercial services around your app
- democracy 4y agoAseprite is doing it. Compile for free or pay 20$ for the binary. I compiled once but the next time I just thought to hell with it and bought it on Steam )
- tech234a 4y agoNote: title should also include (2020).
- chmod775 4y ago> 7 to 10 thousand people were using the app every month. Given that, their income seems about right. Only a tiny fraction of (potential) users are typically willing to pay anything.
- chmod775 4y agoI have to correct myself. 93$ a month would have been about right, not 93$ in 2.5 years.
- TAForObvReasons 4y agoWhen talking about GitHub stars and money, it's important to understand the other side of the equation. A useful free and open source project garners GitHub stars and general recognition because it is useful, but also because it is free. The stars are the social compensation in this case. The free nature of the software is essential to that relationship.
- Emigre_ 4y agoThe ‘free’ part in ‘free and open source software’ refers to the freedom given to the user of the software to read, modify and distribute the software that is provided to them [1]. It refers to that freedom and is independently of the price that obtaining the software has. Free doesn’t mean it has no price, creators can profit from it. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_software https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Free_software
- ajgrover 4y agoIn the philosophical sense, sure. But given the context of this conversation, the fact that you don’t have to pay to use GitHub projects is absolutely relevant to their success.
- Emigre_ 4y agoI agree with you on that, sure. I think being gratis overlaps with being free… I think?… Having free access to the software means being able to use it and distribute it. I guess profit comes most of the times from support or distribution of the software, or the binaries. I have read this post [1] on the topic referenced in the Wikipedia article I mentioned, I thought it was interesting. [1] https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/libreplanet-discuss/2016-02/msg00228.html https://lists.gnu.org/archive/html/libreplanet-discuss/2016-...
- nnoitra 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- paulpauper 4y agoAnd then on the other extreme you have something like substack in, which writing political rants easily earns $50-100k/year in recurring donations even if you are not that famous. It's hard to get people to donate open source projects.
- therealdrag0 4y agoEasily? That’d be a eeally high ranking substack.
- paulpauper 4y agonot really. Even randos getting 100s of subs, not big names
- lawgimenez 4y agoAs moderator of Reddit, now I question myself why I am doing it for free.
- ausudhz 4y agoFor the glory
- rocketpastsix 4y agofor the lulz
- thrown_22 4y agoFor the ability to ban anyone who tells you you're wasting your life.
- xeromal 4y agoA mild bit of power
- notacop31337 4y agoWhilst mild, a much too vulgar display of power.
- howenterprisey 4y agobecause you value the continued existence/wellbeing of the community
- lawgimenez 4y agoI agree, but at least a little compensation will do. Like free Reddit premium or something.
- potency 4y agoCareful, if too many people start thinking like this reddit's entire business model built on free labor collapses.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- johnthuss 4y agoThis is a great encouragement for developers to not undervalue the usefulness of their apps. Most software is free (ad supported) that should be paid for directly instead.
- evgpbfhnr 4y agoWon't load for me -- kiss of death? webarchive link: https://web.archive.org/web/20221110001855/https://kitze.io/posts/github-stars-wont-pay-your-rent https://web.archive.org/web/20221110001855/https://kitze.io/...
- pie_flavor 4y agoI continue to think that the best model is the one adopted by Fody.NET[0]. It's open-source, on GitHub, under the MIT license, developed in the open, and with a voluntary OpenCollective. And if you open an issue or pull request and you're not on the OpenCollective, it's usually immediately closed, by policy. The result is a system that is paid enough to be excellent, excellent enough for most users not to need support, and non-bogged enough for paying users to get excellent support. The best part is when corporations get involved. A company will absolutely get something for free if it can, but if it has to pay, it'll pay a lot more than the absolute minimum, for PR reasons. [0]: https://github.com/Fody/Home/blob/master/pages/licensing-patron-faq.md https://github.com/Fody/Home/blob/master/pages/licensing-pat...
- nequo 4y ago> if you open an issue or pull request and you're not on the OpenCollective, it's usually immediately closed, by policy. Maybe I’m misunderstanding but does this mean that you cannot submit a bug report unless you donate to them?
- 8K832d7tNmiQ 4y agousers who use their product are probably assumed to be working on enterprise market already, hence a weird B2B model in an open community.
- layer8 4y agoYes. And this is answered in more detail on the linked page.
- _carbyau_ 4y agoMy reading of it on their page was that they are free to ignore your bug report unless you donate to them. You didn't pay? Well, that's just, like, your bug report, man... Essentially it boils down to: you cared enough to submit a bug report? Then you should also care enough to donate.
- 4y ago
- nnoitra 4y ago
- karaterobot 4y ago> it made 93$ in 2.5 years > When was the last time you chose a value above 1$ > you're a saint for choosing 2.5$ > OMFG THIS SHIRT IS 20$ For the record: the dollar sign comes before the number. I'll take the downvotes, I just can't stand it. I did read the article, and my heart goes out to the author.
- tomrod 4y agoThat convention is regional and, increasingly in the US, generational.
- karaterobot 4y agoWikipedia: > In the United States, Mexico, Australia, Argentina, New Zealand, Hong Kong, Pacific Island nations, and English-speaking Canada, the sign is written before the number ("$5"), even though the word is written or spoken after it ("five dollars", "cinco pesos"). In French-speaking Canada, exceptionally, the dollar symbol usually appears after the number, e.g., "5$". https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dollar_sign#Prefix_or_suffix https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dollar_sign#Prefix_or_suffix The linked article appears to be talking about U.S. dollars, and all evidence points to it being written in English, so I don't believe the regional usage is relevant. It's hard to argue what the accepted usage will be in future generations, but using the dollar sign as a suffix does not appear to have become accepted by any institutions I'm aware of at the moment. Distinguishing a simple mistake from a visionary act of linguistic prophecy is beyond my capabilities. If you can point me at a reference that makes a good case that the linked article is the accepted usage, I'd be obliged.
- ilyt 4y agoI'd imagine people using currencies with symbol after number just do the same for dollar out of habit. Hell I have to fight to remember that stupid symbol is for some obsolete reason before the number.
- tomrod 4y agoRegional: Canada can do both before or after number due to French influence--that was mentioned in your link, by the way[0] Regional: Philippines (personal experience) and many other countries write currency symbol following the number[1] Generational: starting to show up in texting culture[2] Having experience with languages evolving due to technology, including a few Filipino dialects, I've observed people adopting new conventions in spite of older generational mores is nothing new. Happens all the time. And as a person gets more experience with places that have different conventions, they typically let go of the provincial views that their learned way is the only way. The dollar sign is not the only chrrency. Does a US dollar sign after a number look right to me? No, because my grammar teacher taught me differently. But my native French boss flipped it all the time and nothing of communication value was lost. [0] https://linguaholic.com/linguablog/dollar-sign-before-or-after-number/ https://linguaholic.com/linguablog/dollar-sign-before-or-aft... [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euro_sign#Use https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Euro_sign#Use [2] texting and Text-to-Speech capture of written language.
- asicsp 4y agoI put up a donation link (before GitHub sponsors was introduced) on a repo that had 5k+ stars. Got just one recurring donation (about $1 a month). This wasn't a s/w tool though (tutorials for CLI text processing). Later, I switched to creating books out of such tutorials. I gave them away for free during launch weeks (but readers could still pay if they wish) and this model worked so well that selling programming ebooks is now my primary source of income.
- xwdv 4y agoIs the income more than what you would get in a normal software engineering job?
- asicsp 4y agoI used to work in a semiconductor industry before. My earnings this year is 25% of what I used to earn 8 years back (literally, not adjusted for inflation). However, this is still more than enough to pay my bills ;)
- e-_pusher 4y agoKeep it up, I am a fan of your ebooks. What were you doing in the semi industry, out of curiosity? ASIC design related ? (Looking at your username)
- asicsp 4y agoThanks for the feedback :) I was part of a team responsible for design and verification of DSP (digital signal processing) chips. ASIC part of the username refers to both "application-specific integrated circuit" and my college friend circle.
- nirui 4y agoIt sounded bad, but how much donations that you'll receive don't actually always link to star counts. Stars on GitHub is more like "how many people added this project to their bookmark" than anything else. That said, as how things goes, there are "high value" projects as well as "low value" ones. If you want to make money out of your open source project, target those "high value" use cases might help. Some fields just don't make a lot's of money even if you tried really hard.
- programmingpol 4y agoWell sh*t, there went that idea.
- xwdv 4y agoImagine for a moment though, if GitHub stars could pay your rent. Imagine a corporation spends money on an experiment where they purchase some luxury units of a fancy apartment building, and then rent was decided based on GitHub stars. You must collect a certain number of GitHub stars each month to satisfy rent or you get evicted. I wonder what kind of projects would come out of this.
- zaik 4y agoA method to artificially pump up the GitHub star count will be found, but little useful software will be made.
- tomrod 4y agoIt would perhaps be called "starhacking" or "repoCD"
- viraptor 4y agoAlso the distribution of stars is... weird. I've got a repo with 24k stars (which is still enough for top 500 on github) which took minimal effort and no maintenance - definitely lower than a lot of large software projects which deserve lots of money. Like, I'm next to pipenv and vagrant and making any money distribution based on that would be absurd.
- _wldu 4y agoThat idea sort of proves that Github has evolved into a popularity contest/social platform. It use to be a git hosting company.
- giantg2 4y ago"GitHub stars won't pay your rent" No. But they'll give me the satisfaction my day job never will.
- sd2022al 4y agoI agree. I recently starting contributing to an open source project, really enjoy the feeling of contributing and interacting with other passionate contributors and maintainers.
- giantg2 4y agoI don't really get to interact, except with a few users. For me, it's the idea that u actually built something useful, it's my own idea, and I have full ownership of it. At my day job, the expectation are vague, I have no real power, the people who do can't answer my questions intelligently, and at the end it's like I did some miniscule part of a system that works just OK, but not up to my standards.
- pjmlp 4y agoAssuming there is a day job as alternative.
- _wldu 4y agoI have been thinking about closing my Github account and moving all my code to gitweb on one of my personal domains. I'm tired of the social/popularity contest aspect of Github and just want to write and publish code that I find interesting. I also want more control and I don't want my code used for AI research like co pilot. I thought about trying source hut, or something similar, but I feel it will end-up just like github once it gets more users. Has anyone else setup a simple gitweb server on a personal domain? If so, how did it turn out?
- mylons 4y agohow does another platform help you evade copilot? wouldn’t a “lower” platform have to pursue legal routes that are very unpalatable for those lacking deep pockets and legal expertise?
- _wldu 4y agoAnyone may purchase a domain name from a registrar (such as 'example.com'). That is not a 'lower platform'. It's just a domain name. Sure, it's not as popular as 'github.com' but in every other way (in the DNS) it is equal. And unlike github.com, you have full control of that domain and its DNS records. There are no unique legal issues with regard to buying a domain name and writing and publishing source code on that domain. Using 'github.com' to host your source code does not give you more legal rights or protections. Copyright is copyright and a license is a license no matter where you publish it. You should not be afraid to buy a domain, write source code and publish it there. It's not illegal to do that and you are not at more risk (although these big central social platforms would like for you to believe that).
- xigoi 4y agoUsing another platformmeans that GitHub won't have more rights to your code than anyone else.
- Klonoar 4y agoThe unpleasant truth is that you won't "escape" copilot; if anything is going to be done about that, it's more or less a legal issue. That all said, the author of SourceHut seems really principled in regards to what they're building. If I was going to bet money on one person not ending up like GitHub (and one platform not ending up like GitHub), I'd probably bet on them. I kicked the wheels on it recently and was really impressed, though I'm unsure if I'll use it full time yet - for all it does well (kind of putting git back to what it should be), it does draw a line in the sand where I'm not sure I'd draw it. Something like Gitea might be another option since it can provide a familiar enough interface to drive-by contributors. In truth, I wish Gitea had support for git-send-email similar to SourceHut. Feels like it'd be the best of both worlds.
- MollyRealized 4y agoMay I ask: let's say I am Joe Schmoe, an individual, not a corporation. But I have a particular need for coding done in, say, AutoHotKey or as an Outlook macro. I wish to pay someone for this small coding project. What is the best forum to do this exchange? I'm assuming this question would be on-topic to this thread because it is essentially, "If someone DOES want to help you to pay your rent, or at least for a week's worth of coffee, where's the best place for that?"
- gajus 4y agoUnlike the other websites mentioned, Contra is commission free and does not limit your communication with the freelancer.
- rl1987 4y agoFiverr, but make sure to separate wheat from the chaff.
- blobbers 4y agoUpwork. Much better than fiverr. If you work there a lot, you'll need to learn to vet ppl.
- forgotmypw17 4y agoI'm not sure why I do it, but I regularly remove all the stars from my GitHub project.
- Aleksdev 4y agoYou are a complicated character.
- pabs3 4y agoIt is definitely not easy to pay your rent with open source and the money is likely not as good, but there are a lot of folks who do. Some resources for different ways to do that: https://github.com/fossjobs/fossjobs/wiki/resources https://github.com/fossjobs/fossjobs/wiki/resources
- democracy 4y agoGreat reading, thank you and best of luck!
- tanin 4y agoIt won't, but I feel pretty damn good about my repo getting almost 900 stars (https://github.com/tanin47/tip https://github.com/tanin47/tip). The github stars is quite useful to break into big tech as well. But the value of it probably stops there.
- tanin 4y agoIt has gone up to 901 stars. Thank you, kind strangers.
- destroy-2A 4y agoReally good read, love everything you said and did - I can relate a lot.
- mdswanson 4y agoMy first thought was: wait a minute...you can make money on GitHub!?
- asim 4y agoCan confirm. Have many GitHub stars. They can't pay your bills. Converting stars to money is an interesting process. And not asking for donations, that doesn't work except for the top 0.001% of projects. You have to find a large company that wants support and will pay you the equivalent of a salary as a consulting fee. That's a starting point. If you're more ambitious than that you can try sell the same deal to other companies, personal experience says it's really hard. If you're more ambitious than that you can build a product on top of the open source project or sell an open core version. Also very hard. Then there's the whole VC funded route, I did that. It's a whole other thing not worth discussing here. Open source sustainability is hard. I do think it comes down to the goals of the project lead and what level of financing it will require to sustain that. I have yet to see anything outside of company sponsorship or VC funding that makes it work. These individual donations don't scale. And even the odd $1k/month on patreon isn't enough. Let's face it, people working on open source are no less skilled than FANG employees, maybe even more so if producing code that's directly consumed. Open source should pay far better but I get the feeling it's still like free saas services on the internet. Each has a nuanced monetization path.
- senko 4y agoI've been harping for years to anyone who would listen, Open Source is not a business model [0]. If your motivation for doing open source is money, you're doing it wrong. You'll be much better off just getting a job (and GitHub stars can help with that!). We all know "build it and they will come" and "follow your passion and the money will follow" don't really work in the real world. You have to make something people want and convince those people it's in their best interest to pay you. Open source can be a part of a larger strategy to earn a living (consulting, customizations/open core, relicensing, books/talks/seminars, etc), but yeah, GitHub stars aren't money. [0] https://blog.senko.net/open-source-is-not-a-business-model https://blog.senko.net/open-source-is-not-a-business-model
- ushakov 4y agoAs someone, who has experience in building and selling open-source businesses, I cannot agree more Open-source can be a great selling point and a growth driver, but it won't replace all the other parts of running a business, such as marketing, sales and most importantly, a functioning, profitable business model If you need some advice, feel free to e-mail me I will take a look at your open-source project and tell you how it can be turned into a business
- TAForObvReasons 4y agoIt does work for the right sorts of projects [0] > whether an OSS project lends itself to monetization is a really interesting and subtle question. rule of thumb, be at least two of these: big, boring (roughly correlates with "infrastructural" as @patio11 puts it), and lacking obvious substitutes Many projects with high star counts fall into only one of those categories [0]: https://twitter.com/colinhacks/status/1422222156340072456 https://twitter.com/colinhacks/status/1422222156340072456
- nomel 4y agoI would claim, while biting my lip, that python meets those. It had two paid developers in 2019 [1]: https://discuss.python.org/t/official-list-of-core-developers/924 https://discuss.python.org/t/official-list-of-core-developer...
- ispo 4y agoI believe the macro landscape (I refer to the end of cheap money) is creating a change of Paradigm that is being reflected on multiple angles in our circles and professional sectors. What I'm curious about is where is the line between the software that really should not be open because of its competitive advantage and the software that you can make open?
- hardwaresofton 4y agoWe just haven’t found the right business model. I’m working on two things that will change that: nimbusws.com (this is the moonshot —- a managed service/hosting provider that gives back to F/OSS. Imagine what would happen if a company 1% as big as AWS gave 30% back to F/OSS projects) awsmfoss.com - A newsletter that features a new F/OSS project every day. 60%+ of recurring subscriptions are donated to F/OSS projects — only 2 paid subscribers right now but it’s a start. Things will get REALLY exciting once I build traffic and start donating ad revenue (probably via EthicalAds) If either of these sound interesting to you (criticism, encouragement, requests to invest, want to be the first hire) email me victor@(either domain above) and we’ll chat.
- hrbf 4y agoGitHub stars are a useless metric. It’s basically a bookmark count. If there was any correlation between them and donations, my combined projects of 35k+ stars should make me at least a couple of bucks each month. Instead, lifetime total of ~7 years is ~300 EUR, which includes donations to a NGO I forwarded, which account for most of it. Most people will not pay voluntarily for something they can get for free. That’s just how it is.
- ilyt 4y agowell, most of the project use tens if not hundreds other project's open source code and also do not donate to them
- hrbf 4y agoWhat about those self-contained ones like mine?
- Jorengarenar 4y agoUnless it's rigidly self-hosted compiler for your own language, I have a feeling it still depends on other projects a lot.
- hrbf 4y agoOne of it is, in fact, a static document, basically just a very large README.md file chock full of information. It could be a book.
- Jorengarenar 4y agoI don't think projects comparable to books can be at the same time comparable to software
- hrbf 4y agoI thought we were discussing GitHub stars' correlation (or lack thereof) to donations. I don't see how usefulness for many people should be limited to software only. Anyway, I've said what I wanted to say.
- applobabab 4y agoThe only way I've made any money from Github (3k stars) is by verifying my account on Brave Rewards. I made a grand total of 10 euros in about 3 years.
- dislikedtom2 4y agoAt least considering open source, I love the fact that not much money is involved because I feel that whenever money is involved, people start to serve money instead of users, meaning they might make decisions to maximize the money instead of the usability etc.
- leg100 4y agoNo mention of the role and benefit of contributors to your open source project? I would have thought that is the main benefit: many hands make light work. Cathedral and the bazaar etc. In the case of this chap sounds like it never got to that point, he was doing all the work. Seems like his impression of open source is a trade where you have a developer who displays his wares and offers them for free, and praise and donations roll in. Rather than a powerful operating model allowing software to develop that you could never hope to develop alone. Time/effort ratio is much reduced for everyone involved. Question its viability by all means. It's a progressive and generous idea. Sad that it's not even considered in the article.
- gauddasa 4y agoI still don't understand why some people want to make social work as a source of their income, while it should be the other way round. You may share some of your work which is source of your income with the society, or if that is not possible keep the two separated. I carefully avoid using proprietary software (like having not touched Mac/Windows for 15 years) and personally believe that all forms of IP should be in public domain by default. Each step by a man, however small or giant, should be a step for the mankind. Why should you continue contributing to open source projects: The amount of carbon footprint saved by opensource projects is tremendous. Think of how much resources are saved if the opensource solutions that we rely on today were closed and proprietary that the same software solutions had to be recreated from scratch at each instance of deployment rather than simply duplicated.
- debarshri 4y agoI have seen projects on github and not be an opensource but a source disclosed project. Certain customers expect your code to be source disclosed in order to mitigate risks. Project may not be free to use.
- ivanhoe 4y agoMy understanding of the article is that the author actually got quite a lot of benefits from having that OSS project and github stars. There's a huge difference if you're trying to promote a completely new software that no one ever heard of, and if you promote quite successful and popular OSS project like they do. Even being able to write this article as a way of pushing the new commercial version of the software is only possible thanks to that OSS project. So in the end github stars do payout, just not directly...
- rmanolis 4y agoOpen source libraries, sell binaries. That is my philosophy
- jenny89 4y agoBut where do you sell it? Somewhere like PrivJS or using individual contracts & Stripe etc?
- nnurmanov 4y agoI have been thinking about it and created openlist.dev, where you add banners into your Github profile page and make money when someone clicks the banner. I even emailed GitHub community manager and his answer was expected. They don't want ads on GitHub, their GitHub sponsors do not cover most developers. They should give more monetization opportunities.
- AnhTho_FR 4y agoThis post totally resonates, but wondering where the initial expectation came from : GH stars -> revenue ? Open source can be a part of a business model, but cannot be the only foundation of a business model. It would amount to say 'self-serve won't pay for your rent' if you assume 'self-serve' is just putting your product out there, without marketing, or growth loops. Some new OSS companies nailed the business model Plausible: https://plausible.io/blog/open-source-saas https://plausible.io/blog/open-source-saas (never raised funds) Posthog: https://posthog.com/blog/open-source-business-models https://posthog.com/blog/open-source-business-models
- wslh 4y agoWhen this subject arrives I always think about curl [1] and how a project reaching a market of billion of people and devices receives so few donations and little money [2]. I just discover the project added a link for commercial support [3]. [1] https://curl.se/ https://curl.se/ [2] https://www.google.com/search?q=curl+donations&oq=curl+donations&aqs=chrome..69i57j33i160.1735j0j4&sourceid=chrome&ie=UTF-8 https://www.google.com/search?q=curl+donations&oq=curl+donat... [3] https://curl.se/support.html https://curl.se/support.html
- submeta 4y agoDid I miss the part where he talks about how much money he is making now?
- lakomen 4y agoWell if you release something open source you don't do it for make money but to help people understand how to create something like that. If you want money don't release it open source. My sympathy for you is -100.
- EGreg 4y agoWho remembers this song? I always think of it when I think of earning stars on GitHub: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hT_nvWreIhg https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=hT_nvWreIhg
- kuharich 4y agoPast comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20683735 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20683735
- Der_Einzige 4y agoAfter 1K GitHub stars, you shouldn't need to leetcode anymore. People who did things like writing homebrew makes you orders of magnitude more valuable than another dime-a-dozen leetcode warrior. We have enough people who know how to do a damn BFS. We need people with good ideas and capabilities to execute with software. Lots of GitHub stars proves both
- einpoklum 4y ago1. People are less inclined to donate for something that's a day's worth of effort. 2. I wonder if web developers are more stingy than other developers... 3. "I obviously wanted to make a paid version of the app because the donations weren't exactly working out for me" <- Not obvious. The app should serve the public interest, as FOSS.
- 0x445442 4y agoThis struggle has been going on a long time and not just in the software development domain. 20 years ago there was a swell of ISVs a (Independent Software Vendors) in the blogosphere telling of their experiences of branching out on their own and selling their own software products. Some were successful but most were not. I think many in the software development industry become frustrated because the excitement and freedom of imagination that drew them into the field diminishes rather quickly in the “real world”.
- v3ss0n 4y agoWhat a load of garbage.. it's not problem of opensource, it's his problem of not understanding how to monetize things. OpenCore model destroying opensource world already, asking people to pay because they starred your repo is super weird. Think about this, how many opensource libs you have used in your project and are you going to pay for those all? Btw if you wanna make money with opensource, check how FastAPI doing it.
- gitgud 4y ago> Just imagine if you enter a clothing store and be like "OMFG THIS SHIRT IS 20$? ARE YOU CRAZY? I CAN GO TO THE STORE NEXT DOOR AND GET ONE FOR 7$. I CAN GET A SKIRT, CUT IT, AND WEAR IT AS A T-SHIRT. OR EVEN BETTER, I'M GONNA SEW MY OWN SHIRT!!!111!" This is a great analogy for open-source/commercial software in general. I still find myself naively thinking: "I could build this random project I just discovered!"