9 ms·
For its big comeback, Intel needs to spend money, and it's making less and less
- thrillgore 4y agoFour words: Too big to fail. Dark days ahead for Intel.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- uni_rule 4y agoThe dark times were 2012-17, only just recently in the past 3 years have they gotten off their ass in price to performance. They are now steadily improving.
- monocasa 4y agoThis is what I've been saying for a while would happen about when AMD ended up on TSMC 5nm if Intel was still sitting on Intel 7 (nee Intel 10nm++++++). They'd immediately lose that high margin data center money and no longer be able to keep the lights on for litho R&D exactly when they need it most to come back.
- brookst 4y agoIntel's in trouble, but they will have no difficulty sourcing the cash for any investments that promise to reverse the trend. The terms might be better or worse, but it's not like Gelsinger is going to have a great plan that just needs $20B and it just sits on a shelf because the investment can't be sourced.
- tenpies 4y agoAgree. One perspective that I'm amazed hasn't become obvious to mainstream yet is that there are a growing number of private companies where are functionally extensions of the US government. Everyone knows about the US military-industrial complex, but they haven't clued in that the complex has grown and companies like Intel fall under that umbrella now. The CHIPS Act should have been a huge clue to anyone paying attention. As long as the US government stands, regardless of who is in office and what letter is next to their name, Intel will not ever fail.
- reducesuffering 4y agoIntel may not ever fail, but that sure doesn't mean shareholders will reap any rewards. Boeing won't fail either, but has been losing huge chunks of money every quarter for 2 years now.
- user_named 4y agoWon't fail but their stock can and likely will continue to fall for quite some time.
- ethbr0 4y agoWhen its self-professed peer state adversaries are Russia and China, is it surprising the US is bending more towards national champions?
- LarsDu88 4y agoIt's the logical move from the national security perspective but I hope this doesn't turn into another Boeing aerospace monopoly fiasco where we saw the space program effectively stagnate for 30 years due to lack of competition. Disruptors in the chip manufacturing space are bascially gonna have to grow these things in petri dishes if we get locked into a government owned monopoly
- ethbr0 4y agoI look at it as internal / external competition. Even the heavyweight, plodding military-industrial companies were innovative when they were being driven by external, nation-state competitors.
- totalZero 4y agoThe CHIPS and Science Act is nowhere near a qualitative shift away from the investor-centric mentality of managing a public company. Many investors are short-term greedy and don't learn much about the real goings-on of the company. It makes a few things cheaper, but if you compare to TSMC and Samsung it's quite clear that Intel doesn't get anywhere near the amount of government money or political power that its competitors at the leading edge happen to have in their respective localities.
- UncleOxidant 4y agoIntel should probably think about reducing the dividend and focusing on plowing that money into investment in their business for a while.
- pavlov 4y agoThat would destroy the stock price, and executives get paid largely in stock.
- brookst 4y agoPrecisely this. As an executive, it is better to pay dividends and have the company borrow if needed.
- kypro 4y agoNot agreeing or disagreeing, but have you seen the stock recently? Surely at some point you have to ask if it makes stop prioritising the stock price and investors, and instead focus on the long-term sustainability of the company?
- pavlov 4y agoI’ve been watching both Intel and Meta stock with interest. They’re in a fairly similar situation. The reason why Intel trades at a P/E of 15 while Meta is hovering around 10 must be mostly the dividend. The market doesn’t trust Zuck but it still has some trust in Gelsinger to somehow balance the dividend with the massive fab investments. If Intel gives up on the dividend, they could be down another 30-40% to Meta-like P/E levels.
- parenthesis 4y agoBut Intel would presumably be investing the forgone dividends in something that looks better to investors than the metaverse moneypit.
- dnadler 4y agoIt would just be a question as to whether the reinvestment would be expected to yield a high enough return. Theoretically, at least, if the dividend is being repurposed for investment and the market believes that that reinvestment will drive enought growth, then the stock price could stay flat or even go up. Especially in the current environment where there aren't many good places to invest capital. I'd think that scenario is fairly unlikely though, and in any situation where the dividend goes away volatility will certainly go up.
- drowning-secs 4y ago
- hedora 4y agoIs there any market segment they are currently competitive in? I can't think of one. Even in their darkest days, AMD was winning the "$100-300 desktop with an integrated GPU" segment by a large price-performance margin (vs Atom processors).
- wmf 4y agoIntel is leading in lower-end desktop CPUs like the 12100, 12400, and 13600K.
- gloryjulio 4y agoNew intel cpu is competitive in gaming, but with the sacrifice of the power. And amd still has the counter play with 3d cache version which crushes intel on every metric. So yeah..
- PartiallyTyped 4y agoThey win absolute performance on Desktop CPUs but lose on perf-per-watt. An argument could be made for AMD's 5800x3d in gaming, but when paired with a 4090, the intel CPUs take the lead.
- fshbbdssbbgdd 4y ago> when paired with a 4090, the intel CPUs take the lead Crypto mining is out, but enterprising gamers can now defray their costs by operating a steam turbine with waste heat.
- Shared404 4y agoOr making an impromptu campfire!
- pishpash 4y ago> They win absolute performance on Desktop CPUs but lose on perf-per-watt. How is that possible? They have better thermal design or something?
- StillBored 4y agoYah, they should have been panicking four years ago. They can probably come back, but i'm betting in order to do it, they will have to temporary shift their higher margin devices to TSMC's more advanced process to keep up or just accept being second fiddle for a while. The question is whether all the cuts required to do that kill the company as they are forced to exist on the low margin devices they have been shunning for the past 15 years.
- bee_rider 4y agoWe better hope they come back. TSMC is a really impressive company, but we can't let one company be entirely responsible for a part that is require for an advanced economy.
- cma 4y agoASML is a bigger single point of failure, since they make the machine most critical to any modern fab from Intel, TSMC, or Samsung.
- bee_rider 4y agoSure. Intel and their competition sell directly to consumers, so any tech savvy person is at least vaguely aware of their relative positions in the market. I'm less familiar with ASML (other than the fact that, of course, they make that important part) -- haven't looked into setting up a fab! Do they have US competition that is "pretty close" in the same sense that Intel is to TSMC?
- v3ss0n 4y agoIt should , I remembered one intel developer posted here that intel manager writes tests in big word file.
- thriftwy 4y agoI remember two decades of Intel having unrivaled smallest fab process and AMD always having larger, hotter chips. To see Intel lagging behind is so unnatural.
- Ericson2314 4y agoThis is why it's crazy the Fed is trying to tank the economy the same time Congress is trying to do a CHIPS act. Crazy! If you are trying to do industrial policy you want to run the economy hot, more demand means less need to subsidize, and all the administrative and conflict-of-interest headaches that come with that.
- pertymcpert 4y agoSome things are more important than the CHIPS act.
- Ericson2314 4y agoThere is little evidence inflation below a huge 40% or whatever causes any serious problems.
- silisili 4y agoControlling persistent high inflation is way more important to the nation than homegrown chips right now.
- PaulHoule 4y agoHard to say. I am seeing the service economy wracked by a failure to invest in people, process and technology. Go to a restaurant, hair salon, pharmacy, or attempt to ride the bus (the one I ride in the morning has been canceled) and it is right in front of you. I know just enough process science to be dangerous, but something I see in all of these cases is very long queues which themselves become a source of disruption and chaos. People seem to think that being willing to wait in line is a sign of maturity, but it is reduced to practice people seem to almost universally not understand that your doctor can't see more patients by making them wait longer. I was at a Dunkin Donuts the other day and rather shocked that, because of a lack of hash browns, the kitchen was unable to serve any customers waiting in the drive through for almost 30 minutes. The anti-inflationist would say the problem is that people have money in their pockets to order hash browns that the restaurant can't serve and if we crashed the economy hard enough demand would collapse below supply. My fear is that, without the capital being there to invest in people, process and technology, supply will collapse and we'll be stuck with an economy where "nothing works" but the level of demand keeps dropping.
- cpach 4y agoThe innovator’s dilemma, right?
- wmf 4y agoNot really IMO. Intel's established product lines are plenty profitable... or they would be if Intel wasn't failing to deliver the basics.
- uri4 4y agoCome back to where? Are CPUs gold mine? It is saturated and highly competitive market. Maybe they achieve leadership again in performance or some other metrics, but how would that turn into profits?
- theturtletalks 4y agoMaybe they should go all in on RISC-V or another open-source instruction set and get ahead of what's going to be the future of chips in the long run.
- retskrad 4y agoAMD and Intel make gasoline cars. Their tech is outdated. I am honestly surprised that they have their current market cap. it should be much lower for both.
- aqfamnzc 4y agoAre you referrinng to their silicon processes, or their IP?
- mort96 4y agoAMD doesn't even have a process do they? So it's presumably about x86_64 and associated IP.
- wyldfire 4y agoAt the high end, Apple isn't in this market. ARM designs don't really compete well (yet). Graviton3 is great value but it does not unseat EPYC or even Xeon for raw performance.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- scarface74 4y agoMost servers don’t need raw performance from a single chip they can do their workloads by horizontally scaling.
- Night_Thastus 4y agoCompare to pre-pandemic/crypto bubble figures (a couple years back) and then maybe there's something worth talking about. All of tech was in a nonsense bubble because of the pandemic and crypto. Now that it's over(ish), things are going back to normal.
- Avlin67 4y agox86 is the way to go and will be the best at least for the 10 next years… intel needs some time but I dont worry
- UncleOxidant 4y agoNot sure how you can say 'x86 is the way to go' for the next 10 years given how much progress Apple has made with it's M* processors over the last few years. Sure, Apple keeps all of it's processors to itself, but if they were able to do this over a few years, others surely will be able to as well.
- xiphias2 4y agoI switched to M1 laptop from Windows when it came out and I'm not planning to go back. I'm waiting for the next TSMC process node for my next laptop purchase.
- lloydatkinson 4y agoDid you not try Windows on M1?
- xiphias2 4y agoNot really, it doesn't make sense, I liked Windows 7, but the newer ones not that much.
- hedgehog 4y agoTough situation to navigate out of. They lost the process lead, now TSMC in particular does so much more volume that Intel is at a significant scale disadvantage (makes it harder to catch up). The margins in the historically lucrative server business are under threat as Xeon has to compete with hyperscalers' in-house chips as well as credible alternatives from AMD. Moore's law is over so the big performance jumps that justified rapid PC refresh cycles are gone. They have trouble entering new markets themselves and their M&A track record is poor. It seems very possible that Intel will never return to the strong position they enjoyed ten years ago.
- ajross 4y agoI think that's largely true, but it's also worth pointing out that "Moore's law is over" means that they don't have much "catching up" to do. The truth is that all semiconductor vendors are heading for a future where they're selling an undifferentiated commodity product. Sure, Intel isn't going to be able to sell Xeons for $1k a pop in a future where anyone can go get their chips fabbed at TSMC. But neither is TSMC going to be able to command the margins they do right now if Apple and NVIDIA know they can trot right over to Intel to get a better deal. To me, the story here is much more "maturing industry is losing its margins" than it is a two-way horse race.
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y ago>The truth is that all semiconductor vendors are heading for a future where they're selling an undifferentiated commodity product. This is what I'm hoping for as well. But there are huge upfront costs (>20b). This will limit the number of potential players.
- hoseja 4y agoThe upfront cost may plummet if you don't need to redevelop and replace your entire tooling every five or so years.
- Vt71fcAqt7 4y ago
- prng2021 4y agoI don’t think the situation is that dire for Intel. AMD was in a much worse competitive position not that many years ago. An industry wide slowdown will affect all companies mentioned in the article. Intel has over $25B cash on hand and history has shown investors are willing to let companies (ie Uber) lose many billions every quarter for a long term return. AMD and Intel have been flip flopping on who creates the best cpus for decades. I’m sure that has been the result of a mix of great engineering talent as well as luck during R&D. I have no doubt this battle is going to continue for many more decades.
- hericium 4y agointel went down, back to their 2014 price with, what looked like, one corrupted board after another. The comment my "about" quotes resembles investors' emotions rather well. And markets are - at least currently - not very reasonable. Also: AMD and RISC-V.
- scarface74 4y agoAny public company can get money to fund investments. Netflix has been borrowing money for a decade until recently to fund content at junk bond rates. Intel could probably get much better deals
- RachelF 4y agoIntel has been doing the opposite - borrowing money and using profits to do $70B in share buybacks. The executives get better short term returns on this than by spending money on R&D.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- oc_elder 4y agoIf only there was a way for, let's say, the most powerful money printer in the world to grant / loan money to Intel so that they could onshore state-of-the art chip production in the interest of national security. A serious government would extract concessions for any grants (shares of profit), an seriousness one would just give the money over and be like "Trickle down baby".