9 ms·
OK, so far, not much. Musk is getting stretched rather thin. Space-X seems to be doing OK with Gwynne Shotwell running things. Tesla, which Musk apparently doe
by Animats 4y ago
OK, so far, not much.
Musk is getting stretched rather thin. Space-X seems to be doing OK with Gwynne Shotwell running things. Tesla, which Musk apparently does really run personally, is doing OK, but their side ventures are not. Self-driving is a mess. Solar panels (yes, Tesla has a solar panel business) are not doing well. The Cybertruck is years late. (Maybe next year.[1]) So is the Tesla Model 2, the low-end vehicle.
There's still no low-cost Tesla. The market for high-end cars is somewhat saturated. Tesla's order backlog is now 78 days, much less than usual for Tesla and about typical for the auto industry. Remember, Tesla has to become bigger than Toyota to justify the stock price. It is not possible to do that at Tesla's current price points. There are not enough buyers with that much money.
So Tesla has to compete on price with the Chevy Bolt, the Nissan Leaf, etc. Electric compact sedans are a crowded sector. Solving that problem is Musk's job.
Twitter is a distraction.
[1] https://www.edmunds.com/car-news/tesla-cybertruck-might-finally-become-reality.html https://www.edmunds.com/car-news/tesla-cybertruck-might-fina...
- danjoredd 4y agoThe problem with Musk's solar panel business is that it is more expensive and less effective than normal solar panels. They look nicer than normal panels, but to thrive off of solar you need as much efficiency as possible. Tesla panels don't provide that especially for the cost.
- foobarian 4y agoIs it though? I found that when combined with their battery offering, which triggers additional state incentives, their pricing is quite a bit below the competition. I just have cold feet because of rumors of bad/nonexistent customer service.
- thehappypm 4y agoIve found the service fine. It took a couple weeks to get someone out when I had an inverter issue, but they auto-scheduled the service
- libraryatnight 4y agoI live in Phoenix and a lot of people have been turned off on solar in general for their home because a lot of the companies are aggressive and shady. Seems like a missed opportunity for Tesla to have stepped in to be a "reliable" solar company simply by pricing competitively and not going out of business a year after installation.
- dexterdog 4y agoIf Tesla could have been reliable in comparison the other solar companies must be pretty bad.
- nathancahill 4y agoThey're aggressive and shady (pun intended?) because of government tax breaks that mess with the natural economics of the market. It's become a cash grab by installers to sign up as many people as they can to move money from state coffers to their bank accounts.
- _ea1k 4y agoTesla's solar business was started by purchasing one of the most aggressive and shady outfits in the business. SolarCity was a mess.
- caeril 4y agoThat's one reason I did my own build myself. It's a pretty trivial matter for the average high-IQ HNer to spec, design, and build. The "hardest" part is understanding and adhering to the construction codes, and dealing with inspection bullshit. Check out W&S in Flagstaff (https://www.solar-electric.com/ https://www.solar-electric.com/) (no affiliation) for components.
- wccrawford 4y agoThe problem I hear with their solar panel business is customer service. A friend of ours had their panels installed for months but couldn't get Tesla to actually turn them on. We went with a local company and it it took a couple weeks longer to install than estimated and they were turned on immediately after install. The power company has even changed out the meter now, so we're fully installed and done.
- c7b 4y agoHow do you turn solar panels on (or off)? I thought they just generate energy whenever light shines on them - if you don't take it out as electricity, they'll just heat up instead. Is that what you meant?
- dzhiurgis 4y ago> heat up instead Given ~20% efficiency I’d guess they heat up by ~20%
- barbacoa 4y ago>How do you turn solar panels on (or off)? They probably mean there is an issue with getting approval from city/utility company to connect them to the grid.
- wrycoder 4y agoOpen circuit, they merely generate a small voltage that blocks carrier drift, and thereby, useful current.
- wccrawford 4y agoThere are breakers and disconnects. The more complicated systems can even control what circuits are powered, and when.
- dawnerd 4y agoI sold my house and I still have the panels showing in my Tesla account as pending install ... except they installed them two years ago. Repeated emails to them and I still have access. Kinda tempted to try hitting the cancel install button to see what happens.
- stefan_ 4y agoThe problems with the solar panel business probably start with it not being Musks to begin with, rather it was his cousins failing business that he bailed out against Teslas better interests.
- WaxProlix 4y agoThe cars and panels aren't looking great, but Tesla battery business is good for now though, I think.
- megaman821 4y agoThe profit margin on cars looks good. If the 3 and Y cost around $35k and $40k to Tesla, they have a lot of room to respond to competitive pressures. I think Tesla's battery moves are spot on. Investing in extraction, processing, refining, and manufacturing is going to pay off big time in the future.
- dahfizz 4y agoI think this is the future for Tesla as a business, frankly. They should be a manufacturer of batteries and other EV components. Tesla is the king of battery manufacturing. Their EV drivetrains are the most efficient on the market today. But their cars kinda suck overall and they are not going to be competitive with the traditional auto makers in the long run. Better to sell batteries & motors to Toyota, and sell power walls & solar to consumers / resellers. That is their core competency.
- outworlder 4y ago> Tesla is the king of battery manufacturing Did you mean Panasonic?
- kjksf 4y ago> But their cars kinda suck overall Do explain how a kinda sucky car, Model Y, became best selling car in Europe in September and is tracking to be best selling car world wide in 2023. And yes, I do mean "car", not "electric car". Model Y is outselling Peugeot 208, a car half its price. https://electrek.co/2022/10/28/tesla-model-y-best-selling-car-europe/ https://electrek.co/2022/10/28/tesla-model-y-best-selling-ca... https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/teslas-model-y-tops-new-car-registrations-europe-september-report-2022-10-27/ https://www.reuters.com/business/autos-transportation/teslas...
- lupire 4y ago> Space-X seems to be doing OK with Gwynne Shotwell running things. Find Gwynne Chatwell for Twitter, and Bob's our uncle!
- disgruntledphd2 4y agoSheryl Sandberg?
- phpisthebest 4y agoHe should not bring in anyone from existing social media if he wants to change the direction of twitter like he claimed when he bought it. Bringing in a "Traditional" Social media Exec will just result in repeating the same policies all social media companies have, including the clear political bias all of these companies have
- raiyu 4y agoActually a pretty good idea. I think Sheryl Sandberg running Twitter would be a great idea. She definitely has a ton of experience, is used to dealing with complicated founders and executing on their vision, the only place that she could move up in her career is to be the CEO of not just a large corporation but something meaningful. In a way Twitter and Facebook are no longer as directly competitive as they were in the old days when it was just FB and Twitter.
- scythe 4y agoChristopher Poole.
- concinds 4y agoI expect Tesla will still be his "crown jewel". He's already announced he's searching for a Twitter CEO. I doubt it would take him much time out of his day to set a general vision for Twitter. Jeff Bezos for example owns the Washington Post, but doesn't run it (which will likely be the case with Musk and Twitter in a few months), and it doesn't seem to have detracted from anything while he was still CEO of Amazon. Finding the right CEO will be the challenge, and I surprisingly haven't heard any speculation on who could get the job.
- Gud 4y agoIs Tesla really his crown jewel though? I always thought that was SpaceX.
- concinds 4y agoDepends on what we mean by that; SpaceX might be what he takes the most pride in (due to the much longer-term vision, and more "grandiose" nature of space exploration). What I meant was that Tesla is his first priority, which he micromanages the most and spends the most time at.
- paul7986 4y agoTwitter I think will be his crown jewel! A kitchen sink app in which.. - Use Twitter to pay for parking (tired of downloading tons of apps in different cities to do this) - Musk should find other verticals where ppl have to download multiple apps to do the same thing.. just do it in Twitter - Make Twitter a public Internet identity system. You want to troll online use your fake account... you want to be serious, comment online using your verified Internet ID that Twitter has verified you in many ways - Free speech .. cesspool continues and worse via anonymous/fake Twitter accounts. Slightly less when one uses their verified account I think he could triple his investment with a kitchen sink app!
- jcranmer 4y ago> - Free speech .. cesspool continues and worse via anonymous/fake Twitter accounts. Slightly less when one uses their verified account From what I've seen, non-anonymity doesn't do much to reduce the vitriol of online discussion. What it probably has a larger impact on is on potentially persecuted minorities (say, trans people), where non-anonymity makes it easier to threaten them in real life.
- cinntaile 4y agoI think Starlink is a gamechanger, but I guess that's part of SpaceX?
- yumraj 4y agoBut what's the size of the market? TAM may be huge, but what's a realistic SOM? In other words, how many people with hard wired fiber/coax will change to Starlink or will be be useful only for the rural/remote segment. Yes, there's some international, marine, flight etc. market, but, again, how big is that. Serious question - is there any real data?
- dboreham 4y agoStarlink will never be competitive with wired connectivity. Source: Claude Shannon.
- yumraj 4y agoExactly my point. So, it will always be limited in market size and hence it may be a gamechanger for a subset of the use-cases, such as the ones I mentioned, but not from an financial standpoint.
- Dylan16807 4y agoDon't go too far with that. Fiber beats starlink by orders of magnitude. With coax it depends on how it's set up. Plenty of existing lines have worse upload speed than starlink because of frequency allocations that are expensive to change. Phone wires are very bad at carrying data and are usually much slower than starlink.
- kjksf 4y ago"42 million Americans don't have high-speed internet" That's just in U.S. Starlink is world-wide. Back of envelope calcs: $100/month == $1k a year. 1 million * $1k = $1 billion 10 million = $10 billion. Estimated cost to replace all Starlink satellites every 5 years: $10 billion. That's $2 billion a year. Cost: $2 billion/year. Revenue: $10 billion/year. Profit: $8 billion/year. Assuming only 25% of Americans currently without high-speed internet will opt for Starlink, not counting world-wide users, not counting commercial applications (boats, planes, gas stations), not counting using Starlink as internet backbone (i.e. alternative to under sea fiber). Most likely Starlink will be a cash cow (and finance Mars colonization). https://www.npr.org/2022/05/11/1098368187/42-million-americans-dont-have-high-speed-internet-local-providers-may-be-the-ke https://www.npr.org/2022/05/11/1098368187/42-million-america...
- _chap 4y agoThe Boring Company's latest test tunnel was about 1034 times slower than a snail (their current stated goal). https://www.reddit.com/r/BoringCompany/comments/xugxdl/comment/iqvxakg/ https://www.reddit.com/r/BoringCompany/comments/xugxdl/comme...
- Hamuko 4y agoHas the Boring Company really achieved anything that is not a flamethrower (not not a flamethrower?) and a slow EV taxi lane under Las Vegas?
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoIt's achieved distracting voters and politicians from proven mass transit technologies.
- DreadY2K 4y agoHow does this compare to other companies that dig tunnels?
- morelisp 4y agoPer Musk's original introduction of the snail, it's 14x faster than existing boring machines. So TBC did extremely poorly.
- grecy 4y agoWell , yes, that’s how development and improvement work. You have to start somewhere and Improve from there. Remember, the first SpaceX launch attempts didn’t make orbit. Did that make them quit because they ‘failed’? Improvement is the name of musks game
- HillRat 4y agoTwitter is also a risk, not just a distraction; now foreign governments can demand access and control in Twitter by holding Tesla revenue hostage (e.g., China's approval or disapproval of Tesla purchase tax exemptions), so he's basically paid a lot of cash to give bad actors additional levers to affect his other businesses.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoAlso physical assets like a production plant. Which I'm sure would never be threatened with a shut down over miscellaneous health and safety or permit violations.
- concinds 4y agoI don't buy that at all. Twitter has been able to withhold tweets from certain countries (e.g. EU) based on local laws, for many years. They can just keep doing that with China. You can't be held hostage if you just comply with the law and take a bunch of tweets down in China, which every company must do.
- Jalad 4y ago> if you just comply with the law and take a bunch of tweets down in China Note the last qualifier in your statement. "in China". I think the concern is that a potential adversary could influence Musk outside of their jurisdiction too. So "in China" becomes "everywhere". Which means that one day your might find that you're not able to criticize Putin or Xi Jingping or whoever else on Twitter because Musk has a large Tesla presence in that country
- concinds 4y agoFair, but I doubt that would be in China's interest. For example, we haven't seen China try to do that with Apple Podcasts, Apple News or (less significantly) Apple Music content that might be anti-China. I'm not seeing a track record here. China will do what it always did before with other companies: try to hack Twitter to get sensitive data, and try to place spies in high places to obtain trade secrets, IP, and technology.
- practice9 4y ago> Solar panels (yes, Tesla has a solar panel business) are not doing well. Source? Their last earnings show that energy business part has improved this quarter
- practice9 4y agoAnd while Cybertruck is definitely not releasing this year, Tesla Semi is going into production
- twblalock 4y agoI don’t think many people are cross-shopping Teslas with Bolts or Leafs. The difference in performance and technology is big enough to put them in a different vehicle class. Most of the people I know who are buying Teslas are coming from Audi and BMW, and never would have considered buying a Chevy.
- kadoban 4y agoThat's basically the point. Tesla can't sell to those people, because they have no product for them currently.
- speedgoose 4y agoBut they sell everything they produce with good margins. Cheaper vehicles can be introduced when needed, it’s not necessary to announce them too early and it could even reduce the sales of existing more expensive cars.
- twblalock 4y agoTesla sells every car they produce before they build them, and there are multi-month waiting lists. They don't need to go downmarket. If they build many more of the cars they already sell, they will make a lot more money.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoBut that's the point. Tesla's market cap is over $700bn. That's more than twice that of all of Porsche, VW (which owns Audi), Mercedes, BMW, Ferrari and Volvo put together. Without selling down into the mass-market and out-competing Chevy in that segment, that price premium cannot be justified.
- jliptzin 4y agoTesla’s margins are much higher and they also have no debt
- 4y ago
- quest88 4y agoDon’t forget the Roadster! Or whatever the really fast one is called.
- Hermitian909 4y agoDisclaimer: Previously worked in Toyota's EV R&D division, opinions my own. > Remember, Tesla has to become bigger than Toyota to justify the stock price. It is not possible to do that at Tesla's current price points. It is not possible to do that at Tesla's current price points. Long term Tesla has to create a balance sheet and a narrative that convince people that it's current valuation is justified. Based on my time in R&D I think Tesla might achieve that through lower cost vehicles - they were taking some very bold steps in manufacturing that might be hard for others to catch up to - but could also achieve it through other means. One thing I was very aware of at my time at Toyota was how many of the nascent supplies of Lithium and Cobalt Tesla was snatching up directly or indirectly. Even if other companies can deliver a lower cost of production it may not matter if they can't supply the batteries. 3-5 years from now those investments might pay off substantially in lower costs for Tesla's rather than other vehicles even if the bets in manufacturing don't work out.
- VBprogrammer 4y agoWhat I want to see is Tesla come up with a sequel which is another hit. I feel like their car styling was comfortably out there when electric cars first came on to the scene but now it's become incredibly safe. Other companies, now they are building specific EVs rather than throwing some batteries in the back of an existing car and calling it an EV, are really starting to play with the concept and are making some great looking cars. Cars like the Ionic 5 and the Honda-E for example are making the Tesla's look old hat.
- mft_ 4y agoWell , there’s the Cybertruck…
- VBprogrammer 4y agoNot a fan personally. Looks like someone tried to make a truck out of a table napkin.
- 4y ago
- guerrilla 4y agoYeah actually I think this is a very important point. A lot of people are either super worried or super excited about what Musk will do with Twitter, but both of those positions share the assumption that he'll be successful in whatever he's trying to do but I'm not so sure that's warranted. As you point out, he fails sometimes, and honestly the way he talks about Twitter doesn't really impress upon me the intuition that he'll be successful (this whole X thing sounds ill-conceived to me at this point.)
- ar_lan 4y agoWasn’t the Model 3 the “low cost” one? Is there supposed to be a cheaper one? Cars are so confusing these days - $40k USD just seems like the average price now. My neighborhood has so many Tesla roofs I was actually surprised by your comment - but that’s fascinating! I thought they would be doing much better.
- dexterdog 4y agoThe base model 3 starts at 48,490. They were supposed to have a $35K version. I think they sold one to a guy once at that price with bike tires and folding chairs as seats.
- hnburnsy 4y agoProud owner of the most inexpensive Tesla ever sold. Black 2019 Model 3, $36,500, less $3750 tax credit. Only took 3 years order to delivery.
- null4bl3 4y agoThat is almost the same delivery time as a free east German Lada
- flutas 4y ago> They were supposed to have a $35K version. They had a $35k version, it was just off menu as recently as early 2020[0]. But it was discontinued around November of 2020[1]. [0]: https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1127490_the-35k-tesla-model-3-still-exists-off-menu https://www.greencarreports.com/news/1127490_the-35k-tesla-m... [1]: https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/16/21569524/tesla-model-3-35000-price-stop-selling https://www.theverge.com/2020/11/16/21569524/tesla-model-3-3...
- emkoemko 4y agothe thing was the robotaxi would of payed of the car in a year so i bought it, now i will never touch Tesla
- hnburnsy 4y ago
- hnburnsy 4y agoBEVs sold by GM through 2022 Q3... 36 Lyriqs 782 Hummers 22,012 Bolts For comparison Tesla sold around 32,000 Model S in 2014
- enragedcacti 4y agothey have been supply constrained, just like very other manufacturer for almost every model, EV or otherwise. Further, the future market for affordable EVs is better represented by affordable ICE sales, as that is what they will be replacing.
- FpUser 4y ago>"Twitter is a distraction." Or it could be used as a huge influence platform. Guys like Elon might feel that they got to own it. Fishing out my old tinfoil hat ...
- emkoemko 4y agostill no golden goose the "robotaxi" he promised was coming out years ago and told people to buy the Tesla now since they would be updated with this feature... i got scammed, should of known a car making me 30,000$ a year was to good to be true.