20 ms·
Meta Earning Results Q3 2022 [pdf]
- spaceman_2020 4y agoRevenue down 4%, costs up 19%. Yikes!
- Aqua_Geek 4y agoStock is getting hammered after-hours. Down 11% currently.
- colinmhayes 4y agoHonestly I would be pretty unsurprised if Mark is fine with the stock getting hammered since it makes buybacks cheaper, he's certainly taken advantage of the discount this year. Tell everyone you're going to lose money for the next decade, wait for your stock to get hammered, buy it back for 50 cents on the dollar, and start making money again. Works for mark since he can't be fired.
- marvel_boy 4y agoNot a good sign, even they live on a mountain of cash the trend is no good.
- qbasic_forever 4y agoLegs will surely fix this situation.
- faitswulff 4y agoLegs are old news, certainly there must be other body parts that can generate revenue…?!
- qbasic_forever 4y agoMeta announces tails!
- philosopher1234 4y agoThere are... might make the board room a bit awkward though.
- svnt 4y agoFree cashflow at zero, down from $9.5B in the year-ago quarter. They can would’ve-could’ve all they want about currency exchange rates but there’s no escaping cashflow.
- threeseed 4y agoRevenue increased by 2% on a constant currency basis. And yes costs are up but they are having to do hardware R&D that they have never done before.
- loeg 4y ago> Revenue increased by 2% on a constant currency basis. Yeah, but flat isn't much better.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jstx1 4y ago> we expect headcount at the end of 2023 will be approximately in-line with third quarter 2022 levels. > We do anticipate that Reality Labs operating losses in 2023 will grow significantly year-over-year. Interesting.
- givemeethekeys 4y agoReducing Facebook / Whatsapp headcount to bet bigger on the Metaverse?
- urthor 4y agoNote almost the entirety of the lost revenue is from Europe, quarter on quarter year on year. Considering Meta's business is advertising. The fact advertising revenue is flat in the Americas & Asia is a strong signal companies are not cutting advertising. Ergo, no massive collapse in consumer confidence is predicted. It's just Europe that looks dire. Or at least that's what Meta wants you to think.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoRevenue is flat in the US - yet dollars are down ~8% - so adjusted for inflation - revenue is down considerably.
- acchow 4y agoDon't they report earnings in constant dollars?
- jsemrau 4y agoNot sure what "constant dollars" are, but I did Board Reporting for a Fortune 25 company and we used a 3 month average to limit the impact of sudden fluctuations.
- onlyrealcuzzo 4y agoNo.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoThat's not how anyone reports on this; you don't deflate your revenues for changes in the value of money.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoI wonder how much of this is the "spite spending" effect. We've barely had 6 months of normalcy. People are sitting on some savings. Many haven't left the house or traveled freely for 2 years. Maybe that's why they're okay spending more than they usually would - just a "f*ck it" after 2 years of isolation. Certainly was the case for me. I certainly overpaid for a lot of things recently. But we had our big festival here this week and now I'm tapped out. Next year will be a year of sobriety - at least for me.
- endisneigh 4y agoI’m shocked meta didn’t pivot more into “lifestyle”. I mean something like meetup, a superior marketplace for selling (no, not Facebook marketplace). There are a lot of cool things you could build on top of a verified identity. Even if VR and AR pan out I doubt apple would lose. They just have too much control over the entire stack. How Microsoft and Google, and Meta allowed Apple to slowly build over independent control of their entire ecosystem, from supply chain to software is baffling. They’re gonna get wrecked.
- spaceman_2020 4y agoI'm also surprised that they haven't focused more on giving businesses tools to communicate and sell to customers better through WhatsApp and Instagram. Whatsapp is the de-facto communication tool in India and LatAm from experience. Instagram is the de-facto discovery and social tool in India. Yet from a business' perspective, the experience is really poor. Most have to rely on third party tools to sell and chat with customers.
- spacemannoslen 4y agoI agree with all the above. Nothing to do with the username, either.
- homarp 4y agoisn't that a casualty of the US-centric/SF-centric view of the world?
- ninth_ant 4y agoMeta thinks about foreign market share constantly, it’s a primary reason why they purchased WhatsApp in the first place. The failure to capitalize on their userbase with accessory businesses probably has more to do with the VC/Silicon Valley obsession with the hot new thing and what they hope will be the next new hot thing. Commerce is boring, TikTok and VR platforms are much more exciting.
- dnissley 4y ago
- rr888 4y agoThat video of the life of a 23 year old Meta PM was really bad timing. Looks like they need some screws to tighten.
- endisneigh 4y agoI saw the video - didn’t see any problem. What did you think the problem was? Metas real problem is TikTok, Apple and the cultural zeitgeist
- rr888 4y ago> Metas real problem is TikTok Yeah it was particularly funny that it was posted on Tiktok not Instagram.
- amaks 4y agoMeta's real problem is Zuck.
- abeppu 4y agoI have no idea what she works on ... but surely at least some of Meta's product staff _ought_ to be regularly using TikTok both as consumers and creators, right? How could they attempt to compete without making an effort to understand why TikTok has been eating their lunch?
- lkramer 4y agoThere has to be a balance though. I remember hearing (probably a HN comment) that all the UI designers in the Windows team at MS use Macs, which blew my mind, but also explained so much. If you have people working on designing and improving a product who are ultimately not even willing to use it as a their daily driver, you get the kinda of disconnected mess that is that UI in Windows and the sometimes baffling decisions made.
- origin_path 4y agoUnderstanding it, doesn't mean obviously trying to become an influencer type on it. Did you really watch the video and see someone doing market research?
- jefftk 4y agoStock is down 12% after hours. If it sticks in the morning (and isn't just after hours being low-information) this is dramatic, given that the market had already priced in lower expectations after similar disappointing results from other companies.
- tester756 4y agoDamn, so many stocks recently on discount! Semicos, Google, Facebook, MSFT
- francisofascii 4y agoYeah, they took a beating this afternoon.
- kuwoze 4y agobuy the dip doesn't work if you are jumping from a plane
- bingohbangoh 4y agoNever try to catch a falling knife
- imnotreallynew 4y agoCan someone make an argument against buying at this price point? It was what, 378 a year ago? It’s even cheaper than the crash in 2020.
- Cwizard 4y agoAfter almost 20 years of doing business isn’t it about time that Facebook starts to position itself as a value company rather than a growth company? Realistically they had one big growth avenue and that was acquisitions but the regulatory (or rather political) environment doesn’t allow for it. I get that it is hard to let go of that growth mindset after 20 years of crazy growth but at some point the journey ends and you have to reorient the business (imo). I am not saying stop investing but scale it down a notch, set realistic budgets, pay a dividend or buyback stock. Maybe if they had shifted their mindset away from growth at all cost earlier they wouldn’t have gotten such a bad rep. I feel the same about Google. I wonder how much money their non-ad, non-cloud stuff made of its life time and if it has been profitable. In the end the goal of a company (whether you agree with it our not) is not to get as big as possible but to generate as much cash for its shareholders as possible. And I think Facebook over extended with going all in on Meta. But perhaps I am looking at this with too much hindsight.
- kccqzy 4y ago> I feel the same about Google. I wonder how much money their non-ad, non-cloud stuff made of its life time and if it has been profitable. That's like asking Apple how much money it made from sources other than hardware sales and online service sales.
- khuey 4y ago> In the end the goal of a company (whether you agree with it our not) is not to get as big as possible but to generate as much cash for its shareholders as possible. Facebook's goal is to do whatever Zuckerberg wants, since he still controls a majority of the votes. It's a fascinating test of the value of corporate governance rights.
- urthor 4y ago^^^ have to emphasize. 60-80% of the cost base in many F500s is bullshit (exceptions exist. FMCG, any industry where physical products make up their balance sheet. Not salaries). Any excuse to avoid returning money to shareholders. Everyone quietly acknowledges. If say, Visa, really tried, they could cut the cost base by 50% and achieve the same output. Carl Icahn style shareholder activists have a point. Forget tech companies. Most public companies are a conspiracy by VPs/C-suite/board. The difference with tech companies is Google feather-beds its EMPLOYEES with free food. From a pure capitalist standpoint. You could run Facebook's business on 20 billion USD in costs. Their cost base is enormous because Z has ZERO interest in cutting costs. He's in it for the ego/vanity. Same as every other F500 CEO/Chairman. Ego is the driver, not the balance sheet.
- loeg 4y agoNote Reality Labs revenue is down 50% YoY -- not a rosy picture for the Metaverse. $285M revenue on $4B in expenses and: > We do anticipate that Reality Labs operating losses in 2023 will grow significantly year-over-year. Yikes.
- threeseed 4y agoIt's a multi-decade R&D project that happens to occasionally ship products. Not sure why anybody is expecting it to be profitable at this stage in its lifecycle.
- stephc_int13 4y agoI don't think profitability is what matters here. They simply are burning way too much money for an R&D phase. Are they building giant factories or something?
- asadlionpk 4y agoYou have to agree the tech involved is complex.
- stephc_int13 4y agoSure. But to put things in perspective, the entire R&D budget for the first iPhone was $250M, and I don't think it was highly optimized for cost. 10B is 40x higher. And this is an average year, for an unfinished product that did not even start from scratch (they started with the Occulus Rift, a pretty advanced prototype)
- asadlionpk 4y agoin my mind, amazing R&D product is either = low budget + passionate people + toxic environment to work in longterm OR = high budget + leetcoders + cushy working environment
- 4y ago
- pavlov 4y agoMy Quest Pro arrived yesterday. It’s the coolest new computer I’ve used since the iPad. They’re getting close to nailing the mixed reality form factor. At the same time it feels like the Apple Lisa. Expensive hardware that’s clearly still not quite the end state, shipping with first-party software that’s barely past demo quality. There’s simply not very much to do on the Quest Pro so far, and the HoloLens trajectory suggests that real apps will be slow to arrive. Still, it’s an entirely new style of computing and Meta has subsidized it by tens of billions of dollars already. I’ll try to enjoy it while it lasts.
- umeshunni 4y ago> Expensive hardware that’s clearly still not quite the end state, shipping with first-party software that’s barely past demo quality. "Built for a Future That Still Isn't Here" is a headline I saw somewhere that resonates well with your comment.
- spaceman_2020 4y ago"Built for a future that no one even wants or asked for"
- colinmhayes 4y agoI want metaverse content. Still waiting for the matrix.
- bergenty 4y agoSpeak for yourself. I want solid VR and AR and everything past that. Why wouldn’t you?
- asdff 4y agoYou are going to have engineers using ten orders of magnitude more computational resources to open a text editor like they've been doing for 50 years. It's tech for the sake of tech until someone can come up with an actually novel use case that isn't just window dressing on stuff I can already do.
- Namahanna 4y agoTake a look at the net losses for Meta’s Reality Labs for the full years 2019 through 2022: 2019: Net loss of $4.5 billion on $501 million in revenue 2020: Net loss of $6.62 billion on $1.14 billion in revenue 2021: Net loss of $10.19 billion on $2.27 billion in revenue 2022: Net loss of $13.21 billion on $1.72 billion in revenue
- ethbr0 4y agoThey're obviously in it for the long game. At that rate, they'll have a $17.2 billion net loss on $2 billion in revenue for 2023... ... and then everything will be fine.
- zffr 4y agoI guess the hope is that revenue will eventually grow exponentially and outpace growing costs
- stephc_int13 4y agoSo, 34.5 Billions!? I was still on the 10B figure. At this rate they are going to reach 50B pretty soon. What is the limit? 100B? I understand why this is taking time, R&D and stuff, but I have some difficulties to understand how they manage to burn that much money.
- nicce 4y agoWhen you have too much money, you start forgetting how to optimise and control its use.
- skippyboxedhero 4y agoI wouldn't imagine they even have the capacity to do so. An ecomm company in the UK went bust today, Made.com. They had a decent business, they sold furniture online, but their main issue was cost. All obvious, they had hundreds of people working in single divisions, it made no sense at all. But they never attempted to cut cost until it was too late. I have seen this before, and it isn't "forgetting"...it is a physical capacity. You hired the 32-year old guy, he has only ever hired people, and you tell him he needs to fire 10% next week...he will start ducking you, what do you do? You can't fire him now, you need him to fire everyone else...most companies can't turn it around in time (Made was also run by people like the 32-year old, "entrepreneurs", everything will turn around soon).
- jmyeet 4y agoThere is a general principle that applies to markets and government policy: things are never as bad as they seem. Likewise they are never as good as they seem. Fear and greed. It's why markets and governments and even people tend to overreact. Rewind a few years and people were calling for antitrust actions against Facebook for their market dominance. Some still are. This never concerned me and I needed no better evidence than Instagram. Instagram popped up out of nowhere and was an existential threat to Facebook with 13 employees when Facebook bought them for $1 billion. If in the space of a few years something can appear and threaten your very existence then you aren't as dominant as people were making out. If it happened once, it will happen again. And it has: a lot of particularly younger people (a key demographic) use Snap. And you can't ignore Tiktok, which is rapidly eating Facebook's attention economy. The big problem for Facebook (sorry, "Meta") is they have no plan for the future. Oh, sorry, there's the Metaverse. That ain't it. There is absolutely no evidence that VR will ever be anything more than a niche. There's the argument that this will eventually lead to AR but once AR becomes viable (if it ever does) then Meta will be in the same competitive boat as many others because a VR headstart is no headstart at all. So how long can Meta milk the advertising teat before drastic change is company strategy is called for? I'd say that's coming sooner rather than later.
- labrador 4y agoI a fan of virtual reality, just not in the hands of Corporations and the Chinese Communist Party, whose interests seemed very aligned in regards to controlling and policing people. Both have thought police in HR departments and bureau of Party Functionaries. Mark Zuckerberg has a $10 billion plan to make it impossible for remote workers to hide from their bosses [1] China believes mass surveillance will help it engineer the perfect society [2] There's no sex in the Metaverse champagne room [1] https://fortune.com/2022/10/18/mark-zuckerberg-meta-avatars-video-chat-zoom-fatigue/ https://fortune.com/2022/10/18/mark-zuckerberg-meta-avatars-... (https://archive.ph/i5yJO https://archive.ph/i5yJO) [2] https://www.codastory.com/authoritarian-tech/china-surveillance-social-control/ https://www.codastory.com/authoritarian-tech/china-surveilla...
- intrasight 4y ago> There's no sex in the Metaverse champagne room LOL - love it ;) Sex sells but it doesn't pay the bills. i.e. you can't be coding Zuck's metaverse while having sex. I'm a fan of VR too. But the metaverse is either going to be the most amazing thing or the most dystopian thing that humankind has ever created.
- labrador 4y agoFacebook got caught doing A/B psychological manipulation and allowed Cambridge Analytical manipulate the 2016 election, so I'm leaning towards dystopian. Some other process will create the amazing virtual universe. I'm hoping for a grassroots open source virtual universe will arise in much the same process as the early internet.
- gavinray 4y agoHot diggity, I don't know anything about money, but if you look at "free cash flow" at the end: > FREE CASH FLOW > > 3MO 2022 3MO 2021 9MO 2022 9MO 2021 > > $ 173 $ 9,547 $ 13,151 $ 25,876 Does this mean they went from 13k * 1M to 173M in free cash in the last year?
- adam_arthur 4y agoFCF isn't a great metric for tech companies due to how many shares they issue through employee comp. FCF calculation typically doesn't include this cost. But yeah, it's down bigly. So is their net income.
- rahulgoel 4y agoYep, seems to be driven by 9.3B in purchases of property, plant and equipment in Q3 22 (up +116% from 4.3B in Q3 21). I think it's due to "investments in data centers, servers, and network infrastructure. An increase in AI capacity is driving substantially all of our capital expenditure growth in 2023."
- greenknight 4y agoQ2 report... June 30 was 4,450M Q1 was 8,528 and 9 months ago it was 13,151 Now its 173. Approximately 4,000 per quarter for the past 3 quarters..... Pretty crazy.
- MuffinFlavored 4y agowhere did all of their free cash flow go?
- oars 4y agoAre you sure that's how to interpret it? The way I see it is: - From Jul - Sep 2022, the net cash provided by operating activities minus their purchases left them with $173M. - From Jan - Sep 2022, the net cash provided by operating activities minus their purchases left them with $13,151M. So yes, this quarter wasn't great as they only had $173M cash leftover. But their previous two quarters were good enough to leave them with $13,151M - $173M = $12,978M free cash flow. It's just that in Q3 they only produced $173M free cash flow. They still have $13,151M free cash flow produced since Jan 2022.
- gigel82 4y ago> Headcount was 87,314 as of September 30, 2022, an increase of 28% year-over-year Oh wow, that was misguided. Other companies have been slowing down hiring significantly (especially after the war started in February). I don't see how they'd get out of this without layoffs (which is generally bad for the whole industry).
- jsnell 4y agoRemember that this is a year on year change. Most of that growth happened in Q4 2021 - Q2 2022. The change to Q2 was about 4.5%, so they already slowed down massively compared to the previous.
- pardesi 4y agoHow will zuckerberg make his employees work hard when the stock market keeps killing their motivation? Or those 70K+ are mercenaries of his madness? I think he should be replaced by a mature CEO who can balance growth & value (like other tech companies)
- loeg 4y agoEliminating dual class stock would see Zuck replaced tomorrow.
- tru3_power 4y agoI wonder this too. Even new hires hired a few months back are getting hit hard.
- johnwheeler 4y agoHe’s having his Steve Jobs Mac Lisa moment, but nobody’s going to fire him. I think there’s something to be said about founder-run multinationals.
- blinding-streak 4y agoBad comparison IMHO. Zuck universally creeps people out and is detested by a large % people, while Jobs was loved and had a huge cult following. Big difference. People trusted Jobs, unlike Zuck.
- johnwheeler 4y agoYou know, I'm starting to look at him in a different light. He takes a hell of a lot of flak and keeps focusing on his vision
- origin_path 4y agoNot at the time he was doing the Lisa they didn't. Remember that Jobs got fired and it was because he came across as a manipulative asshole - crying in meetings at odd times, things like that. Even towards the end of his life, Jobs was detested by a lot of people. Yes he had some loyal people who worked for him but even they tended to say they were loyal to him because he made them successful, not because they loved him as a person.
- mempko 4y agoEveryone here is upset that Zuckerberg has 'gone rogue' and is spending a ton of money on R&D to a problem that won't bring investors money in the next quarter. Literally every piece of technology you are using right now followed this model. Spend lots of money over many decades until the technology is developed enough to be valuable. Hell, VR is a technology that the federal government spent lots of money over multiple decades in research labs until they finally turned it over to the private sector. VR has been in development since the 1960s when Ivan Sutherland put his brilliant hands on it. Look up The Sword of Damocles. That's right folks, you are playing Beat Saber because the government spend 50 years developing the technology and components that scrapy startups were able to use to develop private VR headsets. Now Meta has enough cash to act like a small government because it has monopoly status. Kind of like how AT&T was expected to do heavy R&D for the privileged of being a monopoly. Where Bell Labs developed the transistor. Keep in mind, the transistor at the time was so expensive that the only customer was the government. So as long as Meta keeps being a monopoly, they will be expected to keep doing a lot of R&D.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- LeicaLatte 4y agoMark is doing worse than Ye, it looks like.
- forgetme2020 4y agoWho are the independent thinkers at Meta that might be able to convince Mark Zuckerberg to change course in case he is wrong about the size or timing of the Metaverse?
- nomel 4y ago> in case he is wrong about the size or timing of the Metaverse? I imagine there are an equal number of people that could convince him to continue, in case he is right. This appears to include Apple: https://9to5mac.com/2021/11/25/kuo-apple-plans-to-replace-the-iphone-with-ar-in-10-years/ https://9to5mac.com/2021/11/25/kuo-apple-plans-to-replace-th... I think the negative feelings towards all of this will flip, if Apple decides to release something.
- metaquestions 4y agoHe doesn't need convincing to continue. But yes Apple stepping in might help the PE ratio for the space
- dkrich 4y agoSomeone on cnbc made an interesting comment today. Not explicitly saying it but suggesting it might make a convenient situation whereby a company formerly villaified as being anticompetitive and dangerous now looks meek and on the verge of death so that they can again make acquisitions. I’ve thought for a couple years now Zoom would make an interesting target for them- a huge built-in enterprise audience, one of the last remaining independent video conferencing companies with (imo) best of breed engineering and product and now beaten down valuation and meetings are the main focus area for VR right now.
- waaveshine 4y agoIt's an interesting thought, but that seems like a huge gamble just to provide an opening to make moves that may or may not pay off. I would think things would have to be pretty bleak for a risk like that to make sense.
- etchalon 4y agoGiven its output, at this point I'm beginning to assume Meta Reality Labs is some weird form of tax evasion masquerading as a company producing niche hardware products.
- cbtacy 4y agoRevenue miss, and revised revenue guidance even worse. Revenues down 4% YoY yet costs up 19% YoY. Profits down 50% YoY. Users flat. Average ad price -18% YoY. Capex 2x+ YoY. Added 19k employees (+28% YoY). Costs expected to grow from ~$85bn '22 to $101bn in '23. I know there are external macro issues - but fundamentally you have to choose between two interpretations of this data. 1 - They've blown it badly over the last 7 year (strategically, but also at an execution level). And it's all been covered up by a bull market and cheap capital. 2 - But the metaverse!
- cheriot 4y agoZuck mentioned gaining share on time spent vs tictok and nobody in the financial press, twitter, or HN is talking about it. This is huge if true.
- mupuff1234 4y agoHow does Zuck even know how much time users spend on TikTok? It's probably some biased internal market research.
- cheriot 4y agoThere's a whole industry around tracking these things. I don't know what the methodology is.
- mupuff1234 4y agoDoesn't mean it's accurate.
- cheriot 4y agoAlso doesn't mean that it's not. We're both making assumptions
- mupuff1234 4y agoWell sure, but without any proof or data there's no reason to put any weight behind it. Execs and companies say lots of bs.
- cheriot 4y agoI doubt treating that as a non-statement will be the most profitable interpretation. Time spent is one of the most important variables in the value of an ad business.
- blinding-streak 4y ago
- andreygrehov 4y agoMeta stock after-hours is absolute madness: https://ibb.co/M7PtCYX https://ibb.co/M7PtCYX
- captainkrtek 4y agoDoes anyone aside from Meta even want a “Metaverse”? Metaverse just feels like it’s trying to be a “premium” version of reality, that comes at a premium. Seems like such a small target audience to spend so much money on, when across the spectrum of people I know, would rather meet up IRL, or go disconnect from technology.. Some of the tech is neat, and probably innovative, but think no one is as hyped about this as zuck. Also no one likes zuck.
- d4rkp4ttern 4y agoNice. 15 years ago when someone introduced me to FB I called it FarceBook.