9 ms·
Lessons learned since posting my salary history publicly
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- tchalla 4y ago> It wasn't until it was being actively discussed on the Tech Nottingham Slack that I realised it could have been illegal to talk about How can we move to a society where talking about compensation isn’t illegal?
- ok_dad 4y agoIt’s very specifically legal in the USA to talk about your own compensation.
- mrweasel 4y agoHe does say that it "could have been", but it turns out it's fine. It depends on where you're based, but I doubt that it's actually illegal in most countries. I know that I'm legally allow to tell people how much I make. It is kinda interesting when your open about your own salary, but your coworkers aren't. Apparently I made less that other in the same position at my previous job, I was just never told by how much.
- rippercushions 4y agoI'd be astonished if it was criminal-law illegal in any country. But in eg. India, it's pretty common to sign an NDA covering your own salary, meaning that sharing it externally could get you sued.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoI would prefer to keep my compensation private. I currently work for a smaller private company. It doesn't pay me as much as a large corporation in the industry. Were my compensation public, I would forfeit the option to increase it significantly again. I work here because I live next door, like the people and the work environment. It is worth it to me. Public registers would not reflect these choices. Otherwise I would need to keep up appearances and optimise my compensation. I like to keep these options. Not relevant in Norway because everyone earns a lot. Sweden seems to be a country with significant social pressure, not really a role model for me. That said, under no circumstances should it be illegal to talk about your compensation. Any company that forbids you to do so probably has some dark secrets here.
- cinntaile 4y agoIs your argument that if you get paid too little and this is public, then your next gig won't pay you more because they know this? If so, can you expand a little on why that would be the case?
- beambot 4y agoAnchoring: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anchoring_(cognitive_bias) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anchoring_(cognitive_bias)
- FrankyHollywood 4y agooh wow, it's a bit off-topic, but I'm on a desktop now and the mobile view of Wikipedia looks so much better, never realized!
- technion 4y agoThis is pretty consistent with communication most people get from recruiters: tell me your salary so we can know what you are worth. Back home I have a few screenshots of LinkedIn messages that opened conversations asking for screenshots of pay slips so they could verify. Not suggesting I agree with the practice of course.
- sgtnoodle 4y agoYou don't have to comply with their request. If it's for a company you're interested in, you can say no while also being polite, i.e. "Let's not worry about compensation until we're sure it's a good fit."
- raxxorraxor 4y agoTo be fair, the salary is relevant to recruiters for their compensation. For lower wages it often isn't worth it for them to recruit people. It isn't necessarily a judgement of you, although yes, overall your income is.
- TamDenholm 4y agoWhen they say illegal, they probably mean breach of contract, not illegal in terms of criminal law. Also just because something is in a contract, doesnt make it lawful or even actionable.
- avianlyric 4y agoIt isn’t illegal. The right to discuss your pay publicly, with anyone, is enshrined in British law. Any contract terms to the contrary are invalid, and actions taken against you for sharing are illegal, and UK employment tribunals take a very dim view of employer misbehaviour.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- thraxil 4y agoLikely not what's being discussed in the article here, but I used to be active on a developer mailing list where discussion of pricing/hourly rates/etc. was forbidden because there were a lot of contractors/freelancers working in relatively narrow spaces and some jurisdictions could consider it a form of price fixing. Essentially, imagine if all the experts on some particular niche technology sat down and said "we all are going to charge at least $X/hour". Doing that explicitly is illegal. And in a forum related to some profession, having conversations about "how much should I charge for X?" or "how much do you all charge for X?" can quickly run into legal grey areas. Discussing salary probably is safe (but IANAL) but you do have to be careful if it's a conversation about rates happening between competitors in a market.
- grepfru_it 4y agoDad took a photography consulting class and they instructed the whole class to charge market rates and to not cheapen the industry as a whole by starting a bidding war to the bottom. Felt wrong but my dad finally started charging competitively so I didn’t blink twice
- chrismcb 4y agoMove to America... Or at least bake free speech above being offended.
- pandaman 4y agoWe are already in such a society. Secrecy is an option in your employment negotiation. If you want to talk about your salary - go ahead and make it a part of your employment agreement. If others don't want to talk about their salary and instead negotiate for something else like a higher salary or more time off it's their prerogative too.
- markild 4y ago> One thing that I found out in my exit interview at Capital One is that the mistake I made while posting this was to call something a "counter offer" from Capital One. It was noted that this wasn't a counter offer, it was a "your salary is being updated anyway for competitiveness", but I'd misinterpreted the exact wording, as it sounded like a counter at the time. Sounds like a counter offer to me. I'd be very surprised if this "update for competitiveness" would have happened had it not been for a different offer.
- jamietanna 4y agoI'd originally written it on my salary page as a "counter offer", but the competitive increase was given to me regardless of the fact I was in my notice period :)
- barrkel 4y agoIt is absolutely a counter offer and they also don't want to give their employees the idea that they sometimes do counter offers. Counter offers are discretionary and usually you only get one chance at it - it burns a chunk of trust if you've demonstrated will to walk away. A counter offer is something a manager asked for, and if you do it again, they usually won't be as willing to go bat for you a second time. If there's been turnover in managers or you've switched teams in a large corp, then you may have more luck. On the other hand, larger corps treat engineers more fungibly, and if they're looking to trim headcount via a directive from on high, they'll just let you walk out.
- soco 4y agoBurning trust on which side? That you're actually more valuable to us but we wouldn't pay you more unless threatened?
- mitthrowaway2 4y agoAgreed. By making a counter offer a company demonstrates that they had not already been paying as much as they were willing to.
- onion2k 4y agoThe bit about the counter offer is interesting. It was noted that this wasn't a counter offer, it was a "your salary is being updated anyway for competitiveness", but I'd misinterpreted the exact wording, as it sounded like a counter at the time. For this to be true the author's salary would need to have increased regardless of whether they left. That would mean, if they chose to go, they'd earn a bit more during their notice period[1]. If the author's salary didn't increase during their notice period, or if the role didn't have the subsequent higher salary when it was advertised to find a replacement, then it was an offer designed to counter the author leaving, and I think it's very dubious to call that anything other than a counter-offer. [1] In the UK we to have 1, 3 or 6 month notice periods depending on seniority. None of this "2 weeks and I'm gone!" efficiency like the USA. Very high level (eg c-suite) roles sometimes have even more.
- jamietanna 4y agoI'd originally written it on my salary page as a "counter offer", but the competitive increase was given to me regardless of the fact I was in my notice period :)
- onion2k 4y agoFair play. That's actually quite impressive of Capital One then. Many companies wouldn't do that.
- varispeed 4y agoRegarding your point about notice periods in the UK, that's not really a given. More senior people typically work as consultants and it is not uncommon to have a zero day notice period. Which works great for both sides - senior people don't have issues with finding jobs and if the job turns out to be a chore they can do 'kthxbye' and be at a new one the next day. This is the same for workers doing work through an agency which gets increasingly more popular. Notice periods can also by asymmetrical - the employer can let go of the worker without notice period, but worker if they want to quit need to give 2-8+ weeks.
- switch007 4y agoSeems like doing a stint in the government is a good career booster (I’m not drawing conclusions just from this person’s salary history). His history should be a good kick up for the butt for those staying at One company for a while (me included!)
- jasekt 4y agoStupid question: is this yearly or monthly salary?
- isbvhodnvemrwvn 4y agoYearly.
- switch007 4y agoIn the UK it’s a safe assumption that it’s yearly, gross.
- blitzar 4y agoWeekly obviously /s Of course with a bajillion worth of stock options to go with it.
- wizwit999 4y agoIsn't this salary really low? For comparison, a new grad straight out of undergrad makes like $150k at Amazon (which is the low end of comparative companies).
- jstx1 4y agoYou should at least compare it to Amazon UK to get a better idea of the difference.
- emaro 4y agoComparative companies? Like GAFAM?
- rockbruno 4y agoHe lives in Europe. That's how it works here, we don't understand it either.
- noelwelsh 4y agoLower inequality means lower salaries at the top end.
- isaacremuant 4y agoIt's pretty easy. US has scarcity via VISA scarcity. US companies have a smaller hiring pool and more competiveness. US companies in Europe exploit workers from all around the world at the lowest price they can and call it "market salary" and "that's how things are". Then they'll rave about fighting inequality and "the wage gap" but no one will address that in the US you have double the salaries for usually less taxes. And no, what is done with those taxes is generally not good enough nor "way better than in the US" to justify the travesty in terms of high taxes. Housing crisis' abound and landlord classes and politicians are one, protecting their own interests.
- vbno 4y agoAs always, the desires of the shareholders come first and foremost, with the people spending their lives doing the actual work merely considered a resource to exploit the labor of.
- lynguist 4y agoI find it funny that in software engineering you become a senior with just 6 years of work experience. Doesn’t anyone else find that funny? So, at age 29, you’re basically a master of your craft?
- sgt 4y agoIt's just how the industry works. And by 50, you're an old donkey ready for recycling. /s
- soco 4y agoA senior donkey please.
- onion2k 4y agoNot really, because we've invented staff, principle, lead, and architect roles that are all above senior.
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoArchitect is becoming more adjacent akin to the manager path at some places. Lead is also more adjacent, given a junior can be a lead by proxy of leading others. Haven't heard much of 'staff' and principle seems reserved for Fortune N types.
- saagarjha 4y ago"Senior" doesn't mean "master". It just means you're capable of leading projects on your own of reasonable size. The terms we use for people who have truly mastered their field are things like "technical fellow" or "distinguished engineer". (And, FWIW, people can reach "senior" far earlier than 6 years of work experience.)
- zimpenfish 4y ago> It just means you're capable of leading projects on your own of reasonable size. That's a "team lead" which is a particular skill of its own - I'm definitely a senior (age, experience, skills, breadth of knowledge, etc.) but absolutely not a "team lead" (or any kind of management) because that is a skill that eludes my brain.
- pertl 4y agoThis guy is just showing off, isn't he? I bet if his pay was closer to the UK minimum wage he wouldn't be publishing any salary history.
- zimpenfish 4y ago> This guy is just showing off, isn't he? He might be but it doesn't mean that everyone doing it would be - I'm contemplating publishing mine (assuming I can remember that far back) and trust me, there's no bragging rights there at all.
- DrNosferatu 4y agoIndeed - I'll be polite: I just cannot falsify the "showing off" thesis. What value to the community does it add posting this single data point under his own name? Aggregates like Glassdoor are much more valuable. Is Glassdoor skewed/misleading? Then make that the post (and quantify). PS: And always be very careful with individual anecdotes! There were whistles blown - from multiple sources - about extreme abuse at a famous science institute in Germany [1], and the single review on Glassdoor about it at the time was one guy singing it praises. [1] https://www-sueddeutsche-de.translate.goog/wissen/belaestigung-mobbing-vorwuerfe-erschuettern-garchinger-vorzeige-institut-1.4049657?_x_tr_sl=de&_x_tr_tl=en&_x_tr_hl=en&_x_tr_pto=wapp https://www-sueddeutsche-de.translate.goog/wissen/belaestigu...
- jstx1 4y ago> What value to the community does it add posting this single data point under his own name? People get an idea of what's possible. If you're making £50k and you see an anecdotal report of a £90k salary in the same market, that tells you something about the progress that you can make. Comparing yourself to an average isn't always helpful. > Is Glassdoor skewed/misleading? For a well known company that I worked for the Glassdoor average was lower than the company's actual graduate salaries.
- mmarq 4y agoIf this shows anything is how low salaries are in the UK compared to the cost of living. 90K in London make you a working poor by Western and Southern European standards (I mean, try to send 2 children to nursery and rent a 3 bed flat on that salary)
- onion2k 4y agoI mean, try to send 2 children to nursery and rent a 3 bed flat on that salary. You can't fix the problem of things being insanely expensive by increasing wages. That just makes prices go up.
- blitzar 4y agoI sure as shit can fix my problem of things I need being insanely expensive by increasing my wages.
- onion2k 4y agoYou can't if everyone is using the same tactic, and if everyone is using it more successfully than you then you'll be a lot worse off. A different approach would be preferable.
- bearmode 4y agoPrices go up regardless of increasing wages. This is just an excuse capitalists use to keep wages down.
- onion2k 4y agoI don't think that's true for house prices.
- bearmode 4y agoYou don't think house prices go up without wages going up? House prices have near enough doubled in the UK over the last 10 years. Average house price at the start of 2020 was 240k, now it's bordering 300k. Do you honestly think that wages have seen growth even close to that?
- personjerry 4y agoIf you're looking for more salary numbers, I've usually used levels.fyi for salary comparison (primarily for silicon valley companies) https://www.levels.fyi/ https://www.levels.fyi/
- eurasiantiger 4y agoThe justified monospaced text is really awful to read.
- thenerdhead 4y agoSalary transparency is especially helpful for knowing if you got a bad or good deal in comparison to your peers. I had a peer who was doing the same work as me early in my career and I found out they were paid 2x less, so I helped coach them to ask for a market adjustment and they easily got it. Not only was it demoralizing for them hearing how much I was paid when we shared, but seeing how happy they were after they got what they asked for is something I’ll never forget. What ruins it for everyone is when people go to LinkedIn to be “radically transparent”(aka brag online) about their 500k USD total comp package in SV. Not only is it fairly rare, you also have to gamify your career to get there.
- catiopatio 4y agoThese companies are increasingly hiring in non-SV offices, but I take (particular) umbrage with “gamify your career to get there”; that’s not remotely true.
- draw_down 4y ago
- smcl 4y ago> the damage had been done Does anyone know what this damage was? I didn't read the original post, but I thought it'd at least be alluded to somewhere on this page. All I could see was that someone suggested checking the legality of disclosing their salary, but that turned out OK in the end.
- tothrowaway 4y agoDo any UK people here know what the typical employer taxes are on payroll? US companies pay around 10% of the employee's salary in taxes (~8% for social security and some change for workers compensation, unemployment and whatever else the state demands). So if your salary is 100k, your actual value to the company is closer to 111k (plus whatever benefits they are paying like health insurance). 90k seems low compared to American salaries, but if the employer has to pay 50k in UK taxes to hire you, well, that (partially) explains it.
- switch007 4y ago13% on £90k https://listentotaxman.com/?year=2022&taxregion=uk&age=0&time=1&ingr=90000 https://listentotaxman.com/?year=2022&taxregion=uk&age=0&tim... Edit: Also we brits /know/ our salaries are low compared to the US. Also the majority of us get very confused when someone claims that they’re on £200k plus bonuses as a devops in London and we’re left utterly confused as those salaries are like from another planet for us
- blitzar 4y ago15.05%
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- petesergeant 4y agoSalary of £90k will cost the employer £103,496 a year, including NI and mandatory pension contributions. The employee will get net £58,524. All of this from https://www.stafftax.co.uk/gross-to-total-salary-calculator https://www.stafftax.co.uk/gross-to-total-salary-calculator > £90k seems low compared to American salaries It is. But you do get unlimited health-care for you and your dependents. Also note until recently it was worth $115k-ish USD and now it's worth $99k-ish. Finally note that his £90k is actually £110k with stock, which is a strong London developer salary outside of banking.
- jstx1 4y ago> But you do get unlimited health-care for you and your dependents Healthcare in the UK is not a solved problem at all - long waiting times and lots of stuff that should be covered in theory but in practice can't be accessed by many people (mental health, dental treatments). I'm paying a lot in taxes and NI, I have private health insurance through my employer and in many cases I still need to pay out of pocket for treatments.
- thr0wawwy54 4y agoTheres giant, 8 years old thread on polish programming forum where people do post their compensations, edu, stack, exp, location, etc. https://4programmers.net/Forum/Kariera/233131-ile_zarabiacie https://4programmers.net/Forum/Kariera/233131-ile_zarabiacie Arond 3600posts
- throwaway45643 4y agoAre the salaries per month or per year?
- tennisflyi 4y agoWhere does one get a salary of £90,000/month?
- dusted 4y ago> it could have been illegal to talk about Wut? In Denmark we have a law specifically stating that not only are employees free to talk about their salary, it is also particularly illegal to fire them for doing so. A contractual clause disallowing this would in itself be illegal.
- annie_muss 4y agoI understand the ideas behind publicly talking about salary, but I don't think I could ever mention my salary publicly. I know my friends earn a lot more than me and I'm ashamed of my salary. I'd much rather have them thinking that maybe we were possibly on level footing. When talking about money, it's not just money that matters. Social rules and emotions are in there too.
- RestlessMind 4y ago90K GBP salary, 9K GBP bonus and 21K Stock for an L5 at Deliveroo in London? If you are in that position, I am 99% certain that Silicon Valley is a better[1] choice. Any L5 at a Fintech or a Social media or a Gig-economy based company will earn 350K-400K, if not more, even in this economy[2]. That's a 3x difference, or 2.5X if GBP recovers. Comparing London vs SV on other aspects: you get great health insurance at these companies, better than NHS; housing prices are the same level of crazy; SV tech co's will give you at least 3 weeks of vacation + 10 holidays; SV has far worse dating scene but SF is not bad; taxes should be comparable; [1] strictly in a monetary sense. Please stay in London if you have an awesome social network there or love English culture or prefer English weather or have trouble getting a US visa. [2] Source: I am hiring L5s and I have comp data for the US.
- malshe 4y agoOn a related note, in the US all state government employee salaries are public. As a state university professor, my salary has been pubic for years. I like it this way because our salary negotiations with the college dean can be more informed.