14 ms·
Carmack Unscripted
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sneak 4y agoLoginwall - anyone have a summary?
- jandrese 4y agoSeems to be about VR tech so far. It's mostly about social media stuff thus far, with complaints about slow login times and how the Horizon Worlds doesn't integrate with the rest of the system and has interface issues. John wants more screen sharing for people in VR chat like environments. John is obsessive about eliminating lag everywhere. Ironic that his facial animations are slightly lagging the audio track.
- mtlmtlmtlmtl 4y agoAlso, the facial animations are so limited in expressiveness it makes it look like he's suffering from blunted affect.
- jandrese 4y agoThey probably calibrated them on Mark Zuckerburg.
- radiojasper 4y agoTune in to Carmack Unscripted at Meta Connect to hear John Carmack’s unscripted take on the future of technology.
- mmastrac 4y agoI clicked through and it's a livestream of Carmack's VR avatar somewhat out-of-sync with his voice. I think it's live now and hopefully there'll be a transcript later.
- drexlspivey 4y agoAlso streaming in youtube https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ouq5yyzSiAw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ouq5yyzSiAw
- captainthrow 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cm2187 4y agoAm I the only one being put off by the talking avatar thing? It's in the way. I don't think it works.
- savanaly 4y agoIt's sort of pointless if you have to just watch it in a video like I assume we all are. I think it would be better if you were in there in the room with John (using a VR headset). Personally I'm listening to it in the background from another tab.
- ncallaway 4y agoYea, I actually found the avatar in the video was worse than just audio. It was just enough motion to distract my eye, while being pretty valueless in terms of communicating anything. I ended up listening in the background, but opened up a new blank tab to hide the motion.
- p1necone 4y agoIt looks like a wii avatar from 15 years ago and the motion tracking is all jittery, FB is trying to win the VR market with this garbage?
- yrgulation 4y agoThis is doing a disservice to the vr market as people will think this the best it has to offer.
- solardev 4y agoIt's like the Wii avatar playing a VR version of itself and thinking "wtf I don't look like that, this is terrifying"
- tomcam 4y agoHighly distracted. First time I’ve listened to John Carmack without being able to concentrate easily.
- 4y ago
- cheschire 4y agoProbably a condensed version of his 5 hour Lex Fridman interview. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I845O57ZSy4 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I845O57ZSy4
- savanaly 4y agoThat interview is great but I don't think there's any overlap. This is focused on VR, something that was only touched on in the Lex interview.
- dagmx 4y agoNot at all. Carmack does these each year at Connect, and they're always fairly bespoke to the things that Meta are working on and just announced
- waffle_ss 4y agoHe seems to do an annual "update" video from wherever he's at, about minutiae of whatever he's working on at the time. It used to be QuakeCon keynotes[1] when he was at id. [1]: https://archive.org/details/john-carmack-quakecon-keynotes https://archive.org/details/john-carmack-quakecon-keynotes
- stusmall 4y agoI'm sure some PM somewhere in Meta is proud it's using that horrid avatar instead of an actual video. But ooft, it looks so goofy on what seems to be a serious conversation. Their whole metaverse bet seems weirder and weirder by the day.
- Geee 4y agoThis level of quality is fine for low-end headsets like Quest. All game engines should be able to increase rendering quality on high-end systems. It's a mystery why they don't do this.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- SXX 4y agoMeta just need to partner with Microsoft to integrate it with Linkedin. Then it's will turn into the one true cringe generator.
- kwertyoowiyop 4y ago“I am so proud and honored and humbled to announce that my avatar now has three glowing rings over its head!” “Please help me celebrate my Metaversary…” “Nobody truly appreciates how hard us weebles work to get our Zuckabadges. Next time you see a weeble, give it a ‘/clap’!” Oh sweet lord this will be horrific.
- aaaaaaaaaaab 4y agoFunny, but work anniversaries at FB are literally called “Metaversary” after the Meta rebranding. Also, your colleagues are your “Metamates”. I’m not even kidding.
- kwertyoowiyop 4y agoIt's sad when reality exceeds satire. "Veep" seems like a mild documentary now.
- LoveMortuus 4y agoI hope a video of the event will be uploaded to YouTube, for some reason it didn't want to play on my MS Edge Android... Only works on Chrome when on Desktop mode, but that's really not usable...
- lwneal 4y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ouq5yyzSiAw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ouq5yyzSiAw
- TheAceOfHearts 4y agoIs it just me or is the audio balance set a bit too far to the right? It makes it uncomfortable to listen to this with headphones.
- wskinner 4y agoI noticed this as well.
- tomcam 4y agoWhy… why is he bottomless? (He’s represented by a Wii-like avatar. When camera angles change from close up to medium shot he’s just a floating torso in a living room set)
- paulryanrogers 4y agoMy guess is because of height variance, crouching, misaligned floors, difficulty doing IK in a lifelike way given all those.
- kwertyoowiyop 4y agoThey could maybe hire some engineers and, I don’t know, have them work on that? Every other game in the world seems to have figured out a solution.
- paulryanrogers 4y ago"Every other game in the world"? Few other games are VR with human avatars and involving so much variation in real time.
- ioseph 4y agoVR Chat seemed to do a far better job 8 years ago
- nomel 4y agoThey did. They announced and demoed the new avatars in the Keynote, and explained why the current avatars are legless. But as with all things new, everyone is just too busy shitting on their own misunderstandings, rather than actually paying attention. :P
- kwertyoowiyop 4y agoFair enough.
- 4y ago
- dzdt 4y agoI'm convinced that as long as "metaverse" is a thing that involves putting on a nerdy pair of goggles to participate the whole concept is going precisely nowhere with the general population. Its like 3d TV: no one has any interest in putting special hardware on their face to participate in things like that.
- p1necone 4y agoThe thing that bewilders me is that this has already been done with stuff like VRChat, but FB seems to think they can come along with a weird sanitized corporate version of the same thing that doesn't do anything at all new and actually attract users?
- tblflpr 4y agoYou mean like how FB made a weird sanitized collegiate version of MySpace that didn’t do anything at all new? Edit: My mistake — Zuck added a poke button.
- p1necone 4y agoI don't know why we should assume that a company will be successful in one area just because they've been successful in a totally different area - I wouldn't expect a text/photo based social media company to succeed at creating... whatever this is any more than I would expect Toyota to win the fast food market (although VW does make sausages...). My prediction: the successful "metaverses" will either be created by totally new companies/indie devs, or by an established game developer (I know this stuff has some overlap with the social media wheelhouse, but no more than say World of Warcraft does). Ideally someone creates some common open protocol for 3d/VR/AR social spaces that catches on, but I won't hold my breath. (I know there's a few projects like this around already)
- celdon25 4y agoHaven't they already been successful with the VR hardware? They've also had a games platform for many years now. "Totally different area" is a bit of a stretch.
- runjake 4y agoThis is embarrassing for Carmack and I'm surprised he agreed to this.
- ffhhj 4y agoHe just entered the Desert of the Real. Leave all that has a meaning behind.
- kwertyoowiyop 4y agoHe’s Audi 5000 to work on AGI, right?
- dbish 4y agoNot 100% true. He stated on Lex’s podcast that he is part time (1 day/week AR/VR) with the rest of his time on his new AI startup
- barbazoo 4y agoI'm wondering how this is any better than video. Sure, if you have a hammer, everything looks like a nail but still.
- rvz 4y agoSo we have the Carmack fans rushing in to hear his masters voice as a floating virtual avatar in the metaverse. But I thought they weren't interested in the whole thing because of the 'Meta is dying' narrative? [0] So far it looks like despite the so-called 'chaos' reported by the media about Meta, he is still bullish on both AR and VR at the company. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33087535 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33087535
- parker_mountain 4y agoAR is where the future is. VR is a major stepping stone. He is being paid obscene amounts of money to work on things he finds is cool. So of course he's not going to trash talk it. > But I thought they weren't interested in the whole thing because of the 'Meta is dying' narrative? [0] I am happy to listen to a smart person who is very clever talk about things I'm interested in, even if I disagree with them on key points.
- jstanley 4y ago> AR is where the future is. VR is a major stepping stone. I think this is totally wrong. VR is going to be where almost everyone spends almost all their time, and it's not even that many years away. There was a time when humans lived in the wild, and nobody knew any different, and any talk about living in cities would have been met with derision. Right now humans live in "reality", but in the not-too-distant future (maybe a couple of generations), people will primarily live in totally virtual worlds. There are many advantages: - you can have as much land as you like, and you don't have to pay for it - you can get whatever furniture or whatever home decoration you like, and you don't have to pay for it (at least the physical materials - you would probably have to pay a talented artist if you wanted to motivate them to create something bespoke; but you could probably settle for Stable Diffusion anyway) - you can travel to visit friends instantly, no matter where they are in the world, and you don't have to deal with passports, visas, airport security, etc. A really good VR world solves basically every pain point of the physical world. I think people push back on this idea because they think I'm talking about VR as it appears today. I'm not. I'm talking about a version of VR where it literally feels real. Where there is no tangible difference in experience between the many versions of "reality" you can experience inside (for sake of argument...) your headset, and the singular "reality" that you experience outside your front door. There's also the point that although HN readers may have nice large houses and comfortable lives, the average person in the world doesn't have as much space as they'd like, doesn't have as nice furniture as they'd like, has more noise from neighbours than they'd like, and so on. A really good VR solves all of these problems, and saves money at the same time. People would be crazy not to adopt it. We'll still rely on the physical world for nutrition, of course. The same way we still rely on nature to provide our food even though we live in cities and work in offices instead of living in the wild and foraging for berries. But the proportion of human activity that will be focused on "reality" will drop from near 100% today to maybe 1% not too far in the future, the same way the proportion of activity that was focused on "nature" has dropped from near 100% 10,000 years ago to maybe 1% now.
- SXX 4y agoWhile this "metaverse" thing is worse than some "crypto NFT AR" scams I do appreciate that Facebook invest into VR R&D heavily and hopefully at some point in future some other company will benefit off their investment. I guess it's great they give funding to people like John Carmack instead of spending these money on lobbying another anti-consumer garbage.
- hwers 4y agoI’m seeing a lot of R&D solely focused on giving them the chance to extract rent through future silly things like buying artificially scarce houses in fbs metaverse. I’m barely seeing any “giving back” type research like AT&T created with their research in the internet.
- camdat 4y ago> I’m seeing a lot of R&D solely focused on giving them the chance to extract rent through future silly things like buying artificially scarce houses in fbs metaverse An example from FB please?
- SXX 4y agoTheir end-game is very much obvious, but honestly they are so bad at it... I doubt they will manage to actually build anything successful to extract any value out of it. The reason why Facebook Metaverse is so cringey is because they have no clue how to make games or anything like it. The "real metaverse" already exist in Roblox, Fortnite and few other popular games that every teenager socialize in. At the same time thanks to Facebook any average Joe can easily get consumer-ready VR hardware for around $400. We just really dont have many companies behind VR except for Valve and they're simply dont have enough manpower to create mass-market hardware. My point is that we must appreciate those engineers who persuaded Zuck to spend money on VR hardware and research. Yeah their attempt at "metaverse" is laughtable, but investment into hardware is priceless.
- neuronexmachina 4y agoIt looks like their AR/VR publication list is here: https://research.facebook.com/publications/research-areas/augmented-reality-virtual-reality/ https://research.facebook.com/publications/research-areas/au... For publications in general: https://research.facebook.com/publications/ https://research.facebook.com/publications/
- coding123 4y agoI don't know what metaverse is, but I feel a lot more comfortable just playing a game like ESO and hanging out with people dancing and sitting in chairs near me. /sitchair
- barelysapient 4y agoWhy even have the video? The lips aren't in sync, the movement stutters. Its horrible to watch.
- msa_ds 4y agoI can't even see how long the video in my firefox, and no jumping around. I would personally fire the people responsible for this right now, bad idea and bad implementation. But seems Zuckerberg is obsessed over this failure...
- actionfromafar 4y agoI think it was because it was a live transmission.
- nomel 4y agoIn person, there's very low latency thanks to all the engineering effort, as he mentioned. I don't understand why the capture was so incredibly terrible.
- loud_groan 4y agoThese devices weren't designed to stream video, end of story.
- cma 4y agoHe actually mentioned there is still too much voice latency in person and he wants to fix it at the firmware level. Sad part is he's said the same thing about audio latency on Android for the past 5 or 6 Connect events going back to GearVR. The company must be completely dysfunctional. They hired a whole custom OS team and abandoned the project rather than fixing low-hanging fruit.
- nomel 4y agoThe in person experience shows “still too much”, which is nothing like in the video, and very usable. These are separate things.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- karmasimida 4y agoI mean I really don't want to shit on Meta but ... is this parody? The quality of this is really really bad, almost ps2 level bad Using this for presentation is really unwise.
- kwertyoowiyop 4y agoHoly cow and he said this was a CUSTOM BUILD to maintain frame rate! So it can’t even push this level of graphics normally. For what it showed I’d expect about 600 FPS. And the arms are jittering..Wtf?
- ZephyrBlu 4y agoThis VR world is running on a headset (Basically a phone), not a beefy computer: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32505204 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32505204.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- abledon 4y agoI wonder if the majority of people designing/pushing these huge systems of weird cartoon avatar interaction systems... are a tad bit on the spectrum (Which gives them superpowers in understanding tech/algorithms....) but a side effect is the uncanny valley of these weird avatars being pushed by these teams at Meta/FB. It feels more 'creepy' to me talking to a cartoon 'uncanny-valley' representation of a person rather than just seeing their actual photo/video feed. reading this post on "Avatars, Anthropomorphism, and Autism Spectrum Disorder"... > A 2016 study looked measured the neural responses of children with ASD and neurotypical children when shown unfamiliar human and robot faces. The test showed that the targeted responses were present for both for neurotypical children, but only for the robot faces for the kids with ASD. “Together, these studies provide some evidence that individuals with ASD may typically process anthropomorphic rather than human faces https://codebaby.com/avatars-anthropomorphism-and-autism-spe https://codebaby.com/avatars-anthropomorphism-and-autism-spe...
- beezlebroxxxxxx 4y agoIt looks like they're trying make corporate Memphis art meets DreamWorks movie character design into just the standard avatar. Insanely goofy.
- loud_groan 4y agoThe biggest games are Orcs, Humans and a Lot of Brown (the Riot and most of the Blizzard portfolios). Or Toon With a Lot Of Purple (Overwatch, Fortnite, many Playstation titles). Or Brown (Modern Warfare, PUBG, CS:GO, R6). Or anime. Or photoreal (Unreal engine titles excluding Valorant & Fortnite, RDR, Cyberpunk...) When you reach 100m users, the ideas get limited. C'est la vie.
- benreesman 4y agoI’m more than a touch aspy myself which makes this faux-biting rebuke that sounds cool in only my head a bit meta: but nerds figured out how to sell tech stuff to normies quite some time ago.
- 4y ago
- nharada 4y agoIs there any good way for me to try this out without buying a $1500 piece of hardware? My instinct is that Oculus' VR vision doesn't make any sense, but I want to try it out before being confident that my instinct is correct.
- SXX 4y agoThanks to FB you can buy $400 "Meta Quest 2" and experience like 95% of good VR content. Yeah it somewhat worse than Valve Index for VR enthusiasts, but it also much cheaper.
- Nextgrid 4y agoI recently got the HP Reverb G2 to explore VR. It's not that much more than the Quest and has the benefit of being Zuckerberg- and spyware-free.
- yrgulation 4y agoIf you do get a vr headset tether it to a pc and try some actual quality content.
- nomel 4y agoOr, if you have a Quest, forget the tether and go full wireless PCVR, like the rest of us.
- yrgulation 4y agoWireless works surprisingly well, you are right.
- ab-dm 4y agoThis is the way. Currently playing through the HL2 VR Mod using wireless PCVR. It's amazing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- JieJie 4y agoThe developer of Doom is building the corporate Metaverse. You guys are pulling my leg, right?
- msa_ds 4y agoEvery single one of my childhood heroes has committed suicide before my eyes by doing stuff like this. I always considered them having some solid morals and being wealthy enough would make this improbable but boy I was wrong. Oh well, they can't kill the old memories, yet.
- SXX 4y agoTo be honest Carmack have a good reasons to work on it even if it means work for TheEvilCorp: first of all if you listen to him he is truly interested in advancing VR tech. So he doesn't do it just for the money. Also I guess he run out of money when Armadillo Aerospace has failed and at least before he talked like he want to make second attempt in space industry and this will require a lot of money.
- slavik81 4y agoCarmack shut down Armadillo Aerospace before it got to that point. I don't recall where he spoke about it, but he has talked about this in the past.
- SXX 4y agoGood for him then, but AFAIK he is still very much into space and I hope he'll have another chance even if it's gonna be funded by money Facebook gave him. PS: Might be something changed by now, but I hope not. I really need to check latest podcasts / interviews with him.
- Bluecobra 4y agoIn the Metaverse, no one can pull your leg because they forgot to code it. :D
- 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nsxwolf 4y agoCarmack never stops talking for even a moment. Never repeats himself and clearly expresses his thoughts in real time. It's some sort of autism I presume.
- Version467 4y agoI find it very inspiring to be able to express your thoughts in such a clear and concise manner. Most people are usually either very charismatic/good presenters, or highly technical. But Carmack does both while still sounding friendly and just in general excited about tech.
- wvenable 4y agoCarmack used to be pretty bad at giving talks but he kept doing them, and because of that, has gotten a lot better at it. Practice makes perfect.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- goertzen 4y agoSeems like they could of made this a lot better with a basic lighting setup … but nothing was as a bad as the comments suggest.
- sebringj 4y agoThe bit about the logs was funny. I have noticed my oculus 2 be pretty responsive and zippy to now being frustrating to the point I put it down. I would guess its getting bloated.
- swellguy 4y agoHas John Carmack ever been scripted? Kind of a weird catchphrase. "Gun that shoots bullets."
- actionfromafar 4y agoTrue. Why point that out? I get paranoid. :) Was he scripted this time? The avatar video was to hide reading from the prompt?
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThey are working with low bandwidth graphics, I wonder if that is part of their global strategy…
- Ninjinka 4y agoMy company's Slack was dying laughing at how negative his event was within the first 10 minutes. And then towards the end he says "and now I'm gonna be grumpy" and we were sent reeling. Favorite quote was "one of my internal posts was reported and taken down for not being sensitive enough."
- tristor 4y agoWow... thanks to the person that posted the YouTube link, because I have Facebook blocked. Carmack was good to listen to, but the pan in when they turned it over to him /felt/ laggy, like you could see frame rate jitter, and the entire thing was out of sync. I'm generally pretty bullish on VR for entertainment and collaboration long-term, but this honestly felt like going back 20 years ago. I've had more realistic and smoother experiences in MMOs with voice chat.
- nomel 4y agoThe frame rate is fine in person, with these avatars. I think the delay/low FPS was on the 2d capture side. But sheesh, that should have been worked out.
- FrostKiwi 4y agoSame experience with the Quests about 2D capture. If you allow video capture to kick in, rendering resolution is lowered, the devices struggle to maintain proper frame rate, Asynchronous reprojection kicks into high-gear. It's really a hardware limitation of those mobile SOCs, but pretty embarrassing none-the less.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lofaszvanitt 4y agoWorld is bonkers... can someone elaborate what is happening @ FB and other Silicon Valley companies where people seemingly went crazy? There are a handful of contenders in the video game entertainment industry who are really capable of creating a metaverse like thing with stunning detail, but this?
- yrgulation 4y agoI suspect micro-dosing is showing its effects. Cant find any other rational explanation.
- lofaszvanitt 4y agoNah, this is more like I'm pretending to be an idiot... and this pattern appears at even more and more outlets.
- DethNinja 4y agoI can explain it, but you won’t like it: * Entire economy is right now controlled by FED and mega funds like Blackrock. What Engineers or public think is at the moment is unimportant, entire shift to Metaverse is directed by these mega funds / mega investors. * So, people that control the economy desperately want Metaverse to happen. * The reason is that they believe Metaverse will give much needed bread circuses to citizens and keep them happy during the incoming calamities like climate change. * Moreover, they can easily forcefully strap low income workers to VR/AR glasses and control them more effectively during the work. * Though there are couple of major problem with this plan. * Most of the companies working in this area is just interested in suckering the investments. This is very similar to blockchain startups. * Public won’t be very interested in AR tech, and forcing AR top down will actually create genuine social issues.
- lofaszvanitt 4y agoHell, it's hard to believe/digest. Anyway, it seems forced, that's for sure. The 3D glasses/TV madness had similar traits back then. If this turns out to be true, then I'm wondering what will the company who succeeds creating a compelling Metaverse will get in return. :O
- yrgulation 4y agoAs someone who’s always looked up to carmack, unless he’s forced to do this against his will, i find it disappointing he would promote this failing meta product.
- droopyEyelids 4y agoHe's not just drinking the kool-aid, he's an exec in the kool-aid company hoping to build kool-aid factories and put a pipeline to a spigot next to the water faucet in every home
- jandrese 4y agoHis job is basically to make it work. A lot of his points are about the current deficiencies and how he thinks he can make something compelling with more work. Everything from lag to loading times to poor integration between the two virtual environments to features he thinks would make the experience compelling.
- yrgulation 4y agoHe’s working at meta one day a week i believe, i dont see how he can improve things. Also how much room for improvement is there for a mobile phone with a builtin vr goggle? Basically thats what the oculus is. Even carmack said there is only this much you can achieve on such a platform. Now if somehow they’d squeeze in more hardware then that could work. Or a dedicated console and stream content via wifi (wireless pc vr works quite well on oculus, albeit the headset isnt that great).
- FrostKiwi 4y agoI recommend watching last year's speech by Carmack. It gives a little perspective as to why this was targeted to be a virtual session. He is not a fan of how Meta pushes the Metaverse, "Money is flowing and enormous wheels in the company apparatus are turning" and he wants to salvage that financial energy to push technology in some meaningful way. (Pushing down audio latency on the Quest 2 was such a talking point). This shows what Meta's tech is capable of, mask off, no per-rendered CG advert and I think that's a good thing. Besides that, afaik he is largely detached from that project now and only does once a week consulting, with the main focus being his pursuit of AGI. Doesn't change of course how embarrassingly bad Meta's money invested vs results achieved are. edit: Fount the spot I referenced. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BnSUk0je6oo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BnSUk0je6oo at 15:10 onward
- KVFinn 4y agoIn all the past years Carmack did a couple extra hours of talks/questions in random online VR rooms. These were just as info-dense as the main talks, and Carmack was even a little looser in them, but it was so hard to find. I just have to hope a random person in the room will be recording their VR session!
- mberning 4y agoThese people are not interested in creating a better world and a better life for everyone. They are interested in making the vast majority of people their personal slaves and digital sharecroppers. It’s horrible.
- DonHopkins 4y agoNo closed captions or sign language interpreter?
- Comevius 4y agoWell it needs to run on the Quest 2, so it looks uncanny, janky and all that, but it's running on smartphone hardware from 2020. Meta really wants to have it's own hardware platform, otherwise they are at a mercy of Apple, Google and Microsoft when it comes to collecting data. They are very brave for coming out with something this uncomfortably useless though. I'm pretty sure Apple will end up winning this one with their more sensible AR approach.
- RoyTyrell 4y agoReminds me a little bit of this... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xg29TuWo0Yo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xg29TuWo0Yo
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- RobLach 4y agoI have enjoyed so many Carmack talks but this presentation is so jarring it makes me uncomfortable.
- jallen_dot_dev 4y agoI'm listening to this in a separate tab, not watching the video, and I feel like I'm missing absolutely nothing for not watching a floating Carmack Cartoon torso that occasionally blinks.
- HanyouHottie 4y agoAre they serious? VRChat is already better than this in every way. Graphics quality, frame rate, full body tracking, face tracking, legs... Not to mention being able to make your own maps and avatars. I get that this for mobile platforms but VRChat also has Quest support that is better than this.
- numpad0 4y agoI can't think of reasons that this exist other than they might have fundamental, architectural, philosophical disagreement with VRChat that neither parties cannot tolerate but Facebook/Meta is on the losing side, like over real-name-real-face policy vs having none of it.
- onepointsixC 4y agoYou don't think that there is room in the market for more players? Even as the player base review bombs VRC for invasive anti cheat/tampering?
- RockRobotRock 4y agoVRChat is an amazing experience but it really does require a high-end gaming PC to run well. VRChat on Quest is a joke. Going with a very conservative graphical quality seems like it gives a lot of advantages as well.
- ZephyrBlu 4y agoI'm surprised people are shitting on this so hard. The facial animations are quite impressive and everything else isn't that bad. It's not amazing, but it's not unwatchable either. I can imagine this becoming a good alternative (Not replacement!) to in-person events.
- iandanforth 4y agoAnyone have a link to a recording that has speed control?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- cheeselip420 4y agoI feel like this whole thing could be a webcam and some snapchat filters. I must be getting old, because I just don't get it...
- Salgat 4y agoThe feel and vibe is so bizarrely similar to DigitalSpace Traveler (which existed 25 years ago). https://www.digitalspace.com/traveler/ https://www.digitalspace.com/traveler/
- sanderjd 4y agoI don't understand what I'm supposed to find at this link. It seems like just a Facebook events page? I'm confused...
- hettygreen 4y agoImagine if all of this money and brain power went to designing pleasant civic spaces where we could meet each other face to face. The idea of a future where everyone is at home with screens strapped on their face, talking to their bubble-friends in a simulated tree-lined park while the outside world turns increasingly hostile is pretty sad. Serious question: Has anybody else noticed that it's gotten very hard to talk to other people face-to-face lately? I feel like I'm expected to be an anonymous and obedient dopamine dispensing machine for the other person. Even worse, I've also noticed myself doing the same; getting home and then realizing I spent the whole conversation bragging or ranting while barely letting the other person speak. It's like the odds of having an even back-and-forth interaction is <20% post covid.
- cma 4y ago> in a simulated tree-lined park while the outside world turns increasingly hostile is pretty sad. To the extent it ends up saving on jet travel and commuting it could make the outside world less hostile (delaying the onset of global warming). I don't think it is there yet in this iteration obviously.
- Animats 4y agoIs there a transcript of this? An hour of Facebook promoters speaking is too much.
- SkyMarshal 4y agoCreating the metaverse as merely a skeumorphic copy of the real world seems like such a boring imaginative failure and wasted opportunity. You can form this digital medium in any way you can envision. Why limit it to bars, houses, offices, avatars, and other humdrum aspects of normal life. Instead let's push our creativity to the limit. I'd like to see something completely unreal and unlike anything possible to experience irl, and yet interactive, explorable, and as a result something we can build intuitions about how it works. Imagine if Brett Victor, Shigeru Miyamoto, Steve Jobs, Pablo Picasso, and Stanley Kubrick all went on an acid trip together, and collectively envisioned a virtual reality unbound by any of the forms of the real world, yet with a set of consistent rules learnable via interaction and exploration. I imagine something like that could be enlightening and mind-expanding, and far more interesting and compelling than what Zuck has envisioned thus far. That's the metaverse I'm holding out for.
- Karrot_Kream 4y agoIt's not limited to this stuff at all. Horizon Worlds is pretty lacking in this front but has some games. Open up VRChat though, and you'll see some amazing stuff. You'll ride in buses that drive through beautiful, vaporwave sunsets. You'll sit at the edge of a waterfall. You'll play games on high speed rails jumping against walls (and yeah it's as crazy as it sounds in VR.) And that's ignoring the games for VR out there.
- lumost 4y agoSeriously, who wants these VR systems? Have we evolved to the point where giant tech companies no longer require customers? Even the high end-VR games I've played in the mall aren't as convincing as a standard PC/Console game. From what I've seen a mere 260k VR units were sold in 2022. Smartphones were already selling 47 million units in 2010. Where are the lines around the corner? where are the reports of sold out VR headsets? I haven't been able to buy a GPU for years, but I'm willing to bet I'll find a discounted quest if I go looking.
- oxff 4y agoI would love an answer to this. They look like bad mobile games because it has to run on mobile hardware. Interactions, latency etc. are all worse than on some average PC game. You could just log into, I don't know, ARMA III server as a department and host your meeting there instead of this torture.
- solardev 4y agoEven on the PC-connected headsets (Index, Vive, etc.) where the graphics are infinitely better, the games are still really meh. It feels like a solution in search of a problem. Once the novelty of "ooh, 3D and position tracking" wears off, the games themselves feel like tech demos... even the best VR games pale in comparison to your typical "very positive" rando indie game on Steam, of which there are hundreds. You know how Nintendo sold a bazillion Wiis and Switches even though their hardware is pretty subpar? They had solid, fun games with charisma and charm. The VR world, meanwhile, has... uh... disembodied techbros floating in a shrink's office with you? I really respect Carmack, but... what the hell, man?!? Any of his old indie or id software games were SOOOO much better than this Meta crap. The whole thing feels like a sunken cost fallacy where some True Believers keep making new headsets, but they're not fundamentally getting better... still stuck in dorky-gimmick land.
- wcarss 4y ago> Smartphones were already selling 47 million units in 2010. The bet isn't that the Quest or any extant VR headset _is_ the iPhone, the bet is that some successor of the Oculus could be the iPhone. Facebook is hoping they can either capitalize on it directly or hold the patents to skim the cream off of whomever does. The current headsets are more like PalmOS -- pretty cool, but not yet cool enough. They're for geeks and enthusiasts. If my silly analogy holds, we're currently waiting for Nokia and Blackberry to show up and miss (but make a lot of progress along the way), and then we'll get an iPhone around ~2028, and the bet might pay off.
- barbariangrunge 4y agoFor those of us without Facebook accounts, what is this?
- wink 4y agoFrom reading the comments I would have expected something far worse, like that image with the Eiffel tower. Actually doesn't look too bad (I guess my expectations are very low), but what's the missing leg thing? That's just "alpha of a game" level weird.
- H12 4y agoCan anyone with experience having social interactions in VR speak to the value-add of the concept? Having played VR games, I find the experience novel at first in a way that's pretty impossible to adequately describe to others, but gradually lost interest in it over time. Curious if there's anything about social VR that you kinda have to experience first-hand to really "get". In concept, for something special and rare like a conference, I could see VR being an improvement over zoom but nowhere near a replacement for the in-person experience. For stuff like daily meetings, I feel like the fatigue would set in very quickly similar to how it did with VR gaming for me.