6 ms·
> I really can't shake my personal feeling that chess as a sport is just simply dead, especially as an online e-sport. Especially in combination with the possib
by lmm 4y ago
> I really can't shake my personal feeling that chess as a sport is just simply dead, especially as an online e-sport. Especially in combination with the possibility that there's plenty more cheating that they're not catching/detecting.
Online chess is bigger than ever, and some kind of botting/cheating is possible for virtually every e-sport (indeed I'd say many are easier than chess). This is a major scandal that should have serious consequences, but there's no reason for it to be the end of online chess.
- maegul 4y agoTotally fair ... and it would make a lot of sense that this event brings about some sort of cultural cleansing or realignment. I guess I really just meant "dead to me." That being said, if it turns out that online chess continues to do well, but there's still plenty of cheating going on, I don't think it'd be accurate to say online chess is alive because it wouldn't be chess but something different, for better or worse. And whether such an outcome occurs might be what's really at stake here.
- pedrosorio 4y agoJust look at Magnus Carlsen's performance in the most recent online chess event. https://chess24.com/tour/standings/ https://chess24.com/tour/standings/ (Prelim standings / Knockout Bracket). Online chess is alive and well. The whole "so many top players caught cheating" is a bit much. None of the very best are cheating.
- hndamien 4y agoWell, none are getting caught cheating.
- patmcc 4y ago>>Online chess is bigger than ever, and some kind of botting/cheating is possible for virtually every e-sport (indeed I'd say many are easier than chess). I think it's the other way, chess is about as easy to cheat as it gets. With chess you can have a perfectly usable cheating system that isn't on the same computer at all - computer A is clean, and is where you actually play on chess.com, computer B is where you enter the moves into the chess engine. That doesn't work for something like CS:GO or League of Legends or whatever, cheating or botting needs to be in real-time and on the same computer.
- kadoban 4y agoFor shooters, bots or assists that only use vision and normal input (special mouse/keyboard) aren't hard to imagine and I'm positive already exist. I know specifically I read a while back about mice that do recoil correction to improve aim, and things like "click when something that looks like a head is in the crosshairs" would be a weekend project at most for a bored college student. Strategy games may be harder, but still not going to take too long before those exist.
- Semaphor 4y agoThose have been common for decades and are pretty much the lowest bar for detection.
- socialismisok 4y agoUsing computer vision on the video stream (eg via a capture card) and then sending valid mouse and keyboard inputs most definitely has not been around for decades. It's a mechanism to cheat that has zero binaries running on the host computer.
- eru 4y agoYou could do statistical analysis on the mouse and keyboard inputs to try and detect this. (Very similar to how you might detect chess cheaters, actually.)
- erwincoumans 4y agoYou can use (the data of) statistical analysis to train a deep neural network to avoid detection. That may also help avoiding chess detection cheaters, so the moves are not perfect anymore.
- eru 4y agoYes. You can't make cheating impossible, but you can make it harder to pull off.
- vkou 4y agoCheating is common in e-sports, but it is rare in high-level competitive e-sports. Sure, you may be a 'gaming chair enthusiast', using a cheat when in your online Apex or Forntite pub games, but you can't bring it with you to a tournament. Starcraft is about the only e-sport where I can see tournament cheating providing a very large advantage for a single bit of information - a player who can be notified that he is being all-inned would have a huge advantage in tournament play.
- b4je7d7wb 4y agoDota2 could have a similar situation. Enemy is doing Roshan. Obviously not as significant as your example since teams play around the control of that area and have very good gamesenses. But sometimes that few extra seconds or confidence to initiate would make a gamechanging difference. It would also be a lot harder to detect since just having a hunch is a perfectly valid reason to jump into the fog.
- mrguyorama 4y agoCSGO has had multiple instances of players bringing cheats with them to huge tournaments.
- amelius 4y agoCan't we just consider cheating part of the sport? If you or your team is capable of making a tiny chess computer that fits under your skin and can go undetectable, then congratulations to you. So basically a bit like Formula-1.
- Bakary 4y agoI'm sensing a market in dedicated hardware here. For players who spend upwards of 1000 hours on a single game it could be worth it to have a locked down machine for certain contexts where you have to prove your bona fides.