14 ms·
230K Chinese “persuaded to return” from abroad to establish Extraterritoriality
- o0-0o 4y ago[flagged]
- walterbell 4y agoNon-China cities with Chinese police stations include: > Amsterdam, Athens, Belgrade, Buenos Aires, Barcelona, Budapest, Dublin, Florence, Frankfurt, Glasgow, Lisbon, London, Madeira, Madrid, Milan, New York City, Paris, Porto, Prague, Quito, Rio de Janeiro, Rome, Sao Paulo, Slovakia, Stockholm, Rotterdam, Toronto, Tokyo, Valencia, Viña del Mar, Vienna. https://jamestown.org/program/future-global-policeman-the-growing-extraterritorial-reach-of-prc-law-enforcement/ https://jamestown.org/program/future-global-policeman-the-gr... > some countries where fugitives may have fled have either avoided signing extradition agreements with the PRC or have rescinded them following the introduction of the National Security Law to Hong Kong in 2020. These include Australia, Canada, Germany, Finland, Ireland, the Netherlands, the UK, and the United States. > ..PRC authorities ..use alternative means to apprehend fugitives. “Persuasion” has become a common tactic, which human rights groups have called “involuntary returns.” Such returns are achieved by threats against family members in the PRC, directly approaching and intimidating the fugitive overseas, or outright kidnapping ..Involuntary returns ..comprise a mix of genuine criminal fugitives, officials who have fallen out of favor with the CCP leadership, and others pursued for their religious or political beliefs. Earlier thread: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33049729 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33049729
- Amfy 4y agoAlso, one could imagine, these “Persuasion” tactics, might be more successful than, the Western approach of where extradition treaties exist. Putting social (family?) pressure on someone probably more likely leads to a person giving in, than just being exposed to legal pressure that possibly can't reach them.
- walterbell 4y agoWestphalian nation states were established to supercede private armies of mercenaries. If societies now accept extra-legal methods of influence, as vividly illustrated on TV shows like The Sopranos, there will be many organized non-state actors lining up to join the party. If citizens want a new legal category for extra-territorial operations, beyond extradition, this can be negotiated in a formal international treaty.
- im3w1l 4y agoWhat would "not-accepting" these methods of influence even look like?
- walterbell 4y agoStep 1: picket/protest and close the overt "police stations". Any would-be kidnappers can run a covert operation like countries have done since time immemorial, at the risk of unscheduled encounters with local city, state and federal authorities. Or they can work through the legal extradition system. If this is allowed to stand after global public disclosure, it can be taken as implicit "consent" having been granted by citizens and their elected representatives, which means the next phase of extra-territorial activity (e.g. new laws on 1st December 2022) will push boundaries even further. If some countries want to sell their territorial integrity and citizen safety down the proverbial river, at least they can negotiate a good price, e.g. bounty per head, prisoner exchange, or reciprocal global kidnapping by <foreign-country> of <host-country> targets. Good luck recruiting nomadic tech talent after opening such Dantean doors.
- dendriti 4y agoThe fact that you think a "formal international treaty" means anything, tells us that you're not ready. States will do whatever states CAN do. Treaties mean nothing by themselves, especially in this context. (side note: nearly all treaties are both formal and international by default)
- 4y ago
- Amfy 4y agoI am surprised they are even allowed to "operate" in all these cities... especially the USA/Europe.
- curiousgal 4y agoSaudi Arabia funded 9/11, Israel shot an American citizen, the U.S. continues to operate as usual with those countries. My point is that, politics is never about the people/victims.
- rat9988 4y ago> Saudi Arabia funded 9/11 Well, some conspiracy theories are considered facts now.
- nyokodo 4y ago> some conspiracy theories are considered facts now. There are mainstream sources detailing evidence of Saudi funding for Al Quaeda. [1] Whether they approved of/sanctioned 9/11 is another matter. 1. https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/projects/documents/evidence-of-financial-links-between-saudi-royal-family-and-al-qaeda https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/projects/documents/evide...
- imglorp 4y agoA civil court agrees too. https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-saudi-sept11/saudi-arabia-must-face-u-s-lawsuits-over-sept-11-attacks-idUSKBN1H43A1 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-saudi-sept11/saudi-ar...
- zaphirplane 4y agoNo dog in this race First of all this is a civil case of liability which ranges from indirect responsibility to facilitated thru incompetence/ambivalence Second this article is about dismissal of the case over jurisdiction for parts of the claim Third “The judge also dismissed claims … lack … jurisdiction” Maybe the case is over with a ruling, maybe there is an article proving a link, maybe maybe but this article doesn’t make that Proof
- threeseed 4y agoNote that in Australia I know first hand of Chinese university students having their families back home threatened due to them participating in protests. I have no doubt that this is not just about criminal activity but any activity that the PRC does not approve of.
- fennecfoxy 4y agoAdditionally there was the video of that protest in Australia over China related stuff where Chinese people stepped in to assault the protestors.
- Kognito 4y agoThere was a similar situation during the pandemic in the UK, I know of individuals whose parents in the PRC were contacted by the authorities to “encourage” their kids studying abroad to stay abroad, lest they risk bringing covid back home.
- bigcat12345678 4y agoThis seems a normal reaction
- phpisthebest 4y agoI would say it was a common reaction, but it should not be considered "normal"
- anony999 4y agoTraveling during a pandemic is not normal so I find the advice not to travel back home during a pandemic is totally normal. Doing otherwise puts everyone at risk (the traveler, people who he/she interacts with during the journey and the host/home country)
- phpisthebest 4y ago
- VectorLock 4y ago>threats against family members in the PRC, directly approaching and intimidating the fugitive overseas, or outright kidnapping Wow. Actual gangster tactics.
- Phlarp 4y agoWhen we do it: Realpolitik When they do it: Gangsters
- nyokodo 4y ago> When we do it: Realpolitik I haven’t encountered a monolithic opinion in the United States on rendition, mostly disgust and self loathing except amongst the most terminally committed to the “war on terror.” I’ve found many friends in considering it a criminal activity.
- seanmcdirmid 4y agoThe people who think china doing this is bad are generally the same people who think the USA doing the same thing is bad also.
- collegeburner 4y agoyet again unjustifiably both-sidesing the actions of America and china. i don't like when America does it but it isn't relevant and i'm a lot less worried about her expanding power than china. spoiler: most of us actually don't like the bullshit war on terror/war on drugs tactics. and is there evidence we've threatened American citizens at home to get to expats?
- jollybean 4y agoThe US does not threaten to kill or arbitrarily imprison family members of those they wish to extradite, and does not clandestinely do even remotely such things with US citizens unless there are huge issues of national security, aka a US Passport Holder running a terrorist camp in some place, plotting to blow up buildings. The moral equivalence argument with China is tiring, and it's actually part of their horrible communications strategy. The equivalent would be: 'nobody' US citizen 'Joe Smith', living in Paris, mocks Joe Biden on Facebook. As a result, FBI in USA threatens family with prison for arbitrary reasons with fabricated evidence, and clandestinely threatens US citizen in Paris to come home and 'face justice'. So please.
- Scoundreller 4y agoThe Toronto one… seems like the CCP operatives absconded with the funding! > All were in areas with large Chinese populations, but no one The Globe spoke to was aware of a police service station or had heard of the Fuzhou Public Security Bureau. One address in Markham was a private home, while the other was a mall full of small Chinese businesses and restaurants. The third property, in a business park near a highway, is owned by the Canada Toronto FuQing Business Association, a federally incorporated non-profit. https://www.theglobeandmail.com/world/article-china-police-stations-citizen-crackdown/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/world/article-china-police-s...
- GauntletWizard 4y agoAlmost equally likey are that one or all of those businesses are fronts or covers; it's not like the CCP wants to advertise the existence of these extraterritorial police stations to nosy journalists.
- graderjs 4y agoDon't suggest Chinese police overseas are doing covert action. It's silly, those stations are there for helping Chinese tourists, because there are so many in those places. If Chinese want to do covert action overseas they don't send police to do it I think... It would not be covert. This mushing together is like a racist smear fear mongering. It's bad.
- oivey 4y agoThat’s what consulates are. An actual police station is way different.
- graderjs 4y agoNo you're getting confused, and have it backwards. These Chinese police patrol around tourist areas with local police. You don't go to a consulate when you lose your mobile phone or someone steals your wallet. These are police who operate in concert with local police. The whole point is to help Chinese tourists I think. It's not for anything nefarious...It's too racist to be smearing everything Chinese under the banner of the current Western-'China-bogeyman'-hysteria
- kelnos 4y agoIs this sort of thing common? Do other countries place police forces in other sovereign nations with the intent to help their home country's tourists get around in a foreign land? If not, then I think we need to look at this as an aberration, with scrutiny, and assume the worst until proven otherwise. I personally think it is outrageous that the US government (or state or local governments) allows China to station police officers on US soil, and gives them the right to act in a police capacity. I am not ok with that at all, even if what you suggest as their purpose is correct. Why would this even be necessary, if they're here for the purpose you suggest? Local police can handle these sorts of cases, and cities where tourists tend to travel certainly have translators on staff. Hell, cities in the US have translators to help with residents whose English skills are poor. Also: it's not "racist" to dislike this sort of thing if the foreign government in question is not aligned values-wise with your own. I don't think it's remotely appropriate for an authoritarian anti-democratic country to have law enforcement influence on our soil. I wouldn't have the same reaction if, say, a tight US ally (South Korea or Japan, to pick examples from the same part of the world) were to have an informal police presence in the US. But even then, I would expect them to be working with the FBI (or similar) on higher-level international crime matters (sorta like an Interpol type thing), not working on local crime. Foreign police forces should not have any kind of jurisdiction in "local" crimes.
- jccalhoun 4y agoI"m not sure if this is directly related to this particular "initiative" by China or another one: https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/five-individuals-charged-variously-stalking-harassing-and-spying-us-residents-behalf-prc-0 https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/five-individuals-charged-vari...
- NonNefarious 4y agoAt a time when traditional American values are more desperately needed than ever around the world, they are dying right here in the USA.
- Bakary 4y agoThis is a confusion of cause and effect. The current crisis you are seeing is in part caused by this very same baked-in self-congratulatory mindset that permeates many American institutions and demographics
- kelnos 4y agoThat's... a bit of a weird thing to say. For one thing, this idea that our "American values" are so superior to everything else is an insult to a large part of the rest of the world that also has values that we'd consider positive and good. They didn't come by those values "because America" (ok, maybe a few did here and there, but that's far from universal). For another thing, what "traditional" American values are you referring to, in particular? Slavery? Racism? Institutionalized oppression? Police brutality? The military-industrial complex? The prison-industrial complex -- the fact that we have such a high percentage of our population incarcerated? Our legally-enshrined puritanical fear of victimless "crimes" like smoking a plant? The disenfranchisement of the poor? Income and wealth inequality? The continued weakening of labor movements? A small but loud and influential contingent of religious nuts who seem to believe that their god should be calling the shots in our legal system (hypocritically many of the same people who have wrung their hands over "Sharia law")? Sure, I'm focusing on the negative here, and as much as I'm a bit cynical these days, there is plenty of good to come out of our country, even today. But this whole "wave the flag", "everyone should be more like us" stuff is pretty gross and short-sighted. The better values "dying" of late bit may be true (or not, I don't know anymore), but also overlooks a lot of bad stuff that has been in our national DNA for centuries.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- NonNefarious 4y ago
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- timeon 4y ago> ... Sao Paulo, Slovakia, Stockholm, ... Is Bratislava too small?
- walterbell 4y agoOops, I missed Bratislava, it's indeed listed in the table on p. 13, https://safeguarddefenders.com/sites/default/files/pdf/110%20Overseas%20%282%29.pdf https://safeguarddefenders.com/sites/default/files/pdf/110%2...
- Nowado 4y agoIsn't Slovakia too much of a country?
- yreg 4y agoSo how does this work? Police stations are bases of operation for policemen. And policemen are people who need to have a lawful authority for what they do. These folks roleplaying as policemen have no such authority. So what do they do? I can't imagine they are detaining people, giving out fines, etc. So what makes them police? Shouldn't we call them spies instead?
- worewood 4y agoYeah, agree completely. Shouldn't be called police station, more like a spy operations office.
- netsharc 4y agoMakes me think of this[1]. I guess a bit like in the spy movies where American spies were free to roam everywhere, the superpower status (i.e. money and market access) of China means they get to swing their police truncheon around and most countries just stay quiet about it. And they were even watching Xinjiang activists outside of China (Source [2]): > [...] one of the officers shoved a photo under my nose. It was my daughter Gulhumar. She was posing in front of the Place du Trocadéro in Paris, bundled up in her black coat, the one I’d given her. In the photo, she was smiling, a miniature East Turkestan flag in her hand, a flag the Chinese government had banned. To Uighurs, that flag symbolises the region’s independence movement. The occasion was one of the demonstrations organised by the French branch of the World Uighur Congress, which represents Uighurs in exile and speaks out against Chinese repression in Xinjiang. The drily-written post only talks about telecommunications fraud. Is that a big deal in China, are they doing something like Nigerian 419 scams? I suppose they'd be targeting mostly Chinese citizens, using e.g. WeChat, although that's probably a bad idea because how much do you want to bet WeChat can report home the user's GPS coordinates or even just their IP would be enough for country geo-locating. [1] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/dec/09/secret-deal-reveals-chinese-spies-free-rein-switzerland https://www.theguardian.com/world/2020/dec/09/secret-deal-re... [2] https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jan/12/uighur-xinjiang-re-education-camp-china-gulbahar-haitiwaji https://www.theguardian.com/world/2021/jan/12/uighur-xinjian...
- miohtama 4y agoWould China call any freedom of information and uncensored messages telecommunication fraud?
- cyber_kinetist 4y agoIt's interesting how the authorities of the US and China have a different view of how to control its populace through information. China is all about the controlling the logistics of the flow of information, where the authorities need to crack down dissent that can impede the structural stability of the CCP. (Not all social criticism is censored, but the ones that directly criticize the party are.) Therefore they have done many things to shut down access to foreign sites, and created one of the biggest bureaucracies in the history of the world to search through the deluge of information on the domestic net to pick out which users and posts are deemed censorable. And it kinda works, but also kinda doesn't (If you have seen the memes and lexicon circulating in the Chinese nets, you'll understand what I mean instantly.) Whereas the US authorities plays a much more smarter game: is all about tactics. Instead of controlling the flow of information in a top-down way, it lets them free, and then actively participates in it. While China focuses on removing the opponent's pieces on the chessboard, US focuses on adding their own: through its numerous media conglomerates and NGOs (which if you ultimately trace back its funding, all leads to one of the alphabet-named agencies or neoliberal thinktanks like the Ford Foundation or the RAND Institute). When you search a dissident figure in the Chinese net, all traces will be erased and you will find nothing. When you search a dissident figure on Google, you will be spammed with all the numerous media sites that try to mislead you in some way. (And yes, this also kinda works, but also kinda doesn't. But I see this as a more sophisticated strategy than what China is doing.)
- csa 4y agoIt would not surprise me if a large part of this is not driven by an attempt to control the drug trade (e.g., opium) that flows through the golden triangle and southwest China. Note that this trade is huge and is a problem in China. I don’t want to sound like an apologist (not a fan of this line of action for a number of reasons), but the focus on the nine forbidden countries (mostly in Southeast Asia) and the number of folks repatriated from those countries makes me think that this is not a small part of the motivation behind these actions.
- walterbell 4y agoIn that scenario, a public transparency report on involuntary returnee legal cases would be a good start.
- csa 4y ago> In that scenario, a public transparency report on involuntary returnee legal cases would be a good start. Why would they do that? I’m pretty sure that the powers that be in China don’t really care about the opinions of advocates of human rights, government transparency, etc. They probably are also not keen on airing their dirty laundry with regards to the drug trade. Chinese leaders pretty much double dog dare any country not to trade with them based on any set of principles, knowing that the other country will be the one that suffers the most. The US is maybe the only country that could stand up to China, but the US and China are in super weird but oddly balanced symbiotic relationship that would become mutually destructive if one side decides to force its will on the other.
- walterbell 4y ago> Why would they do that? The history of human civilization has countless examples. Those who willfully ignore history can enjoy speedrunning it instead.
- nyokodo 4y ago> the powers that be in China don’t really care about the opinions of advocates of human rights Perhaps, although the recent Chinese adoption of wolf warrior diplomacy [1] makes it appear like they care and are trying to cover it up with bluster. China “doth protest too much, methinks.” 1. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolf_warrior_diplomacy https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wolf_warrior_diplomacy
- jopsen 4y agoUsing "persuasion" in quotation marks is perhaps too nice. It's coercion, if not worse. Not that there is much we can do about it. Though limiting ability of Chinese authorities to operate outside china is fair. After all we don't permit organized crime either.
- motohagiography 4y agoAn example of mainland presence from one of the cities mentioned: https://nextshark.com/hong-kong-chinese-nationalists-supercars/ https://nextshark.com/hong-kong-chinese-nationalists-superca... Imo, the laurentians area (ottawa/quebec) political class basically hates the rest of the country because we represent their parochial origins, and so they figure they can just import new constituents who can be more easily bribed or with special protections for their money, as a way to keep themselves in power, without having to listen to the constituents they imagine themselves as having transcended and left-behind. Something similar is likely true in other countries with these bases as well. I can't believe that I can say without an ounce of hyperbole that our representatitives made a deal with the devil, and now they have communist party secret police bases in their cities.
- jeromegv 4y agoCanada made no special deal with “the devil” and the article you showed in no way demonstrates that. All those secret polices offices in canada were visited by journalists and nobody was there. If China is sending spy, it’s definitely not under the agreement or through a special deal with the Canadian government. You are imagining a lot of things.
- glouwbug 4y agoThe amount of astroturfing on this site is incredible
- visiblink 4y ago
- harpiaharpyja 4y agoOh, the whataboutism. Forget about what humanity is doing today, we gotta be outraged about the past.
- kergonath 4y agoOnly the past that’s convenient to make a point, though. The rest, that could prove the opposite, can stay unmentioned. Fuck nationalism, as well as whataboutism.
- pessimizer 4y agoThis entire NGO seems extremely suspicious. Here's the Swedish guy who runs it being interviewed by a friendly outlet: https://hongkongfp.com/2017/01/08/peter-dahlin-qa-the-swedish-ngo-worker-who-confessed-to-endangering-chinas-national-security/ https://hongkongfp.com/2017/01/08/peter-dahlin-qa-the-swedis...
- justusw 4y agoCan you explain what’s suspicious?
- cyber_kinetist 4y agoNot too sure about this one though... But the organization is too well aligned with American espionage goals to dismiss it as just a well-intentioned grassroots organization. Do you have any good pointers about how the org is being funded? (Usually the blatantly obvious ones have funding traces back to places like various alphabet-named agencies and other places like the Ford Foundation or the RAND institute.)
- mannerheim 4y agoChinese agents have also been arrested in the US for this. https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2022/03/16/chinese-spying-arrests-new-york/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/national-security/2022/03/16/...
- sva_ 4y ago> Since the end of November 2021, many notices have been issued to warn the Chinese public not to travel to nine countries with serious telecom and web crimes: Cambodia, the UAE, the Philippines, Thailand, Myanmar, Laos, Malaysia, Turkey and Indonesia. People who have no "strict necessity" or "emergency reason" to travel to or stay in those countries are required to return to China as soon as possible.
- yogenpro 4y agoAs the report says: > a seemingly recent campaign to counter transnational telecom and online fraud (according to the official provincial statements) The increase in telecom scamming activity is a real thing in China, with scammers operating from southeastern Asia countries. And operators are often Chinese citizens hired for what they originally thought would be "oversea job with good pay". The "persuaded to return" strategy might be targeted primarily at them. Those scams are particularly bad -- maybe even worse than the telecom scams happening in the US and other wealthy English-speaking countries -- because taking personal loans is way too easy in China. A few clicks on a lender's app and you get cash transferred to your account instantly. And there are hundreds of such apps. Scammers can talk victims into maxing out their credit lines and wire the loaned cash away. And the fact that there isn't "personal bankruptcy" laws in China also makes it worse. Such loans are rarely forgiven and victims often had to pay them off with their future income for years out of the fear that loan defaults can affect their credit score for life. So I guess this is Chinese police's way of "do something about it". Of course they don't have jurisdiction overseas and should have gone with Interpol and/or local police first, except that hasn't been very effective. My 2 cents on the reasons behind this is: 1. Local police might be paid off; 2. No incentive for local police to prioritize their resource for cases like this -- there were no victims in their own countries; 3. There are just too many scammers; Surely once this set up is in place it's possible to extend its coverage to harass/"persuade" political dissidents but CCP has already be doing it for years without it. If this oversea police "persuasion" program is getting local law enforcement's attention to the point that they can arrest both them and the scammers, I would see it as an absolute win.
- anovikov 4y agoTime and again we see how every dictatorship eventually becomes a snake eating it's own tail, and succumbs to self-inflicted wounds... How can they probably hope to build an advanced society treating their people like that? It will only push Chinese emigres abroad to break every tie with their home country, including relatives that stayed behind, reducing any positive impact on homeland of those people learning things and making money abroad.
- DisjointedHunt 4y agoPeople in the West rarely get to encounter situations such as these that make me thankful every day for the imperfect heaven we live in. This is a daily experience for the families of those 230k. Imagine the horrors the families in places like Xinjiang are going through. Even if a small portion of these reports is factual, we're talking rape, torture, organ harvesting, despicable acts against human life everywhere. What we have in the west isn't perfect, but God am i thankful to not have my family denied education or other social essentials because i decide to speak my mind.
- walterbell 4y ago> thankful to not have my family denied education or other social essentials because i decide to speak my mind Ongoing vigilance is essential to preserve these freedoms, as evidenced in the recent US DOJ prosecution of eBay executives for intimidation of a journalist, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33049853 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33049853 > A former eBay Inc. executive was sentenced on Thursday to almost five years in prison for leading a scheme to terrorize the creators of an online newsletter that included sending live spiders, cockroaches, a funeral wreath and other disturbing deliveries to their home.
- throwamon 4y agoAlmost five years? Wow, I'm sure he'll come out of it a better, de-psychopathized man. Your example only shows what a joke the system we live under is and what ridiculous lengths we go to justify it.
- walterbell 4y agoAre you aware of another such case which was even prosecuted, much less obtaining a conviction with prison sentence?
- rmbyrro 4y agoI've heard of a LOT of people in the West who lived during the 1940's and wouldn't agree so much with your perspective.
- flerovium 4y agoIs this actually true? It says there is a chinese police station in NYC. Where? I looked at the NGO's pdf and didn't see an address. It's unclear exactly what having a "police station" means. Has the NGO reported the CCP taking actions in foreign countries against Chinese nationals? The stories are all about getting at them by threatening family in China.