43 ms·
Why are nuclear power construction costs so high? Part III – the nuclear navy
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoI am stunned by the "Navy has operated 5,000 years of reactors". But, I come back to my basic thesis on nuclear power. It's the A+ game or bust Yes the US fricking Navy can do it well, but the minute the Soviet's ran out of cash they just let it all rust. If we lean on nuclear in the carbon energy transition then when we run out of money, can we afford to let them rust.
- Spivak 4y agoSo why don’t we have the US fricking navy actually run and manage the reactors? It’s not as if they only exist at sea. And if the reactors are actually wholly military operated we might get the added benefit of being able to use the Navy’s 20ish year lead on civilian nuclear. Amazing what you can learn when you have a navy nuclear engineer a few beers in and trying to impress you.
- epistasis 4y agoIs our ultimate goal to get nuclear at any cost? Then sure. But nuclear at any cost is not a reasonable goal. The only reason we want nuclear is for its carbon-free energy. At which point it must be evaluated on its merits, not as an end goal of its own
- donmaq 4y agoAnd how can we just ignore the waste problem? [1] In many cases, containment pools are full to the brim with spent rods [2], which is both environmentally hazardous, & a target for terrorists (dirty bombs) 1: https://www.ucsusa.org/resources/nuclear-waste https://www.ucsusa.org/resources/nuclear-waste 2: https://ips-dc.org/spent_nuclear_fuel_pools_in_the_us_reducing_the_deadly_risks_of_storage/ https://ips-dc.org/spent_nuclear_fuel_pools_in_the_us_reduci...
- pfdietz 4y agoWe can ignore the waste problem because nuclear fails even if we do so.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoThe waste problem is real, and if the nuclear shills can demonstrate that there can exist a nuclear reactor that can compete with solar+storage in winter at 45 degrees north economically then we can bother talking about it. Until then we dismiss them along with every other technology that does not meaningfully exist.
- ok_dad 4y agoThat only solves part of the problem, the civilian reactors are still too expensive to build. Nuclear is great, I went through the Naval Nuclear Power Program several decades ago myself, but it's not financially viable. Let me say that again to those engineers who weren't listening: Nuclear (fission) power is not, and will never be, financially viable for civilian powerplants. I'll eat a roll of toilet paper covered in hot sauce if someday nuclear fission is financially viable enough to produce power for civilians at a decent scale.
- kinghajj 4y agoEven assuming that's the case, isn't the counterargument "Fine, then governments need to subsidize investment into nuclear power plants, just as we do with other green technologies."
- orangecat 4y agoRight. It's fascinating how this is the one area where so-called environmentalists suddenly become very concerned about fiscal responsibility.
- epistasis 4y agoEnvironmentalists have pretty much zero impact on the ability of nuclear plants to be started and demonstrate feasibility. In the US, Georgia and South Carolina started building with nary a peep. France started building again without any environmental objections. Yet these builds are all catastrophic failures, to the point that any other financial backer is scared away from even touching nuclear. The decision makers are those with the dollars to invest, not the environmentalists.
- andbberger 4y ago"environmentalists" in california have succesfully prevented at least 6GW from coming online, and were directly responsible for plans that shutter california's last operating reactor. They lobbied PG&E with a study they paid for that, under the insane assumption that california's energy use would _decrease_ in the future, concluded renewables would be cheaper. Meanwhile CAISO issued increasingly urgent press releases warning of the catastrophic consequences to grid stability were diablo canyon to close. A disaster which was narrowly avoided a few weeks ago by newsom. don't underestimate the negative influence of "environmentalists"
- dickholesalad 4y agoI’m an ex navy nuke (I did the whole thing, school through startups, sea trials, refuel, operations, maintenance, was nuke mechanic). I think some of the main impediments to adoption of navy-style training, operations, and maintenance in the civilian world are that the work is challenging and high stress. The school is very mentally and spiritually challenging to most people. When you get to the fleet the work is very challenging both mentally and physically. You are taking weekly technical short answer tests, operating the thing in 100F degrees doing legit physical work, responding to emergency stuff at 2 am before a 6 am shift. It’s nuts. The navy selects smart people through asvab test requirements. Most students are still challenged by the coursework. When you stay in by reenlisting it gets a little easier because you have less physical work to do but you still have to maintain excellence and train the junior people to the required competency level. Combine this with the fact that the pay is shitty compared to other jobs in industry available and the incentives just aren’t there. Where do we find these highly motivated, fit, young, intelligent people to work like dogs? They don’t exist in sufficient quantity to do this. The navy doesn’t have superior technology; most of the ships are old and maintained. The secret sauce is the personnel and their desperation. You aren’t going to contract people in the civillian world to do this stuff. I really don’t think it’s feasible.
- dqpb 4y ago> Combine this with the fact that the pay is shitty compared to other jobs in industry available and the incentives just aren’t there. > Where do we find these highly motivated, fit, young, intelligent people to work like dogs? We increase the pay. It's that simple.
- nradov 4y agoThus killing the economics of nuclear power relative to competing sources. The Navy uses nuclear power on a few dozen carriers and submarines because that's the only practical way to accomplish the mission. But after building a handful of nuclear powered surface combatants they abandoned that approach, and returned to conventional engines largely for cost reasons. Civilian power plants have to find a way to operate at a profit.
- 4y ago
- jjoonathan 4y agoHuman nature is inherently a bit of a crapshoot and progress on that front is slippery, but "make a reactor robust to neglect and abuse" is an engineering problem and progress on that front is sticky. We've gotten much better at this particular engineering problem. For instance, Fukushima was designed in 1967, but if it had been designed in 1972 it would not have had its fatal flaw.
- andbberger 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TRIGA https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/TRIGA
- hunterb123 4y agoFukushima was neglect. As you said we had known those types of tsunamis were possible since 1972, but no additional safety measures were put into place over the decades. There were multiple studies and suggestions ignored a decade before the incident: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_nuclear_disaster#2000_and_2008:_Tsunami_studies_ignored https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fukushima_nuclear_disaster#200... It wasn't that there was a fundamental flaw with the design, just the sea walls needed to be higher.
- SECProto 4y ago> I am stunned by the "Navy has operated 5,000 years of reactors". When they've been building them for 70 years and have over 200 nuclear powered vessels, it shouldn't be that surprising. For comparison, Ontario Power Generation has operated 787 years of nuclear reactors (343 combined at Pickering, 120 at Darlington, 324 at Bruce), each of which is at least 3.5 times larger than the biggest navy nuclear reactor. France has dramatically more than that.
- acidburnNSA 4y agoI wrote a similar take here on the topic: https://whatisnuclear.com/economics.html https://whatisnuclear.com/economics.html
- godelski 4y agoTo give context to who acidburn is, he's been a long time HN user, has a PhD in nuclear engineering, has worked in fission and fusion for over a decade, and has blogged about it for years. The take here is the take of an expert and not just a nuclear bro.
- implements 4y ago(“Acid Burn” was also Angelina Jolie’s handle in Hackers - if it was ringing anyone else’s bell).
- acidburnNSA 4y agoYeah I made my HN username on a whim years ago after watching that movie and didn't realize it was a dumb choice. I wanted it to be 'hackery' and anon. Oops.
- nmfisher 4y agoI think you misspelled “awesome choice”.
- poorlyknit 4y agoI don't know acidburn but I'd argue that having a PhD in nuclear engineering and having worked in the field is likely to increase your bias towards nuclear (being a "nuclear bro") rather than equalize it. PLT PhDs will tell you Haskell is the best programming language and environmental science PhDs will tell you solar is the best energy source.
- godelski 4y ago
- jmyeet 4y agoThis is a well-written series (Parts 1 and 2 are linked in this article). This last part makes comparisons to the reactors designed and used by the US Navy. If you read through all of this the message I got was that size is the enemy. In one part it notes that a 100MWe core meltdown could likely be contained by the vessel but a 1000MWe reactor meltdown likely wouldn't. This concern is part of why there are ever stricter requirements on civilian reactors. So you have opposing forces: bigger reactors produce more power and scale better. Smaller reactors are safer and easier and cheaper to build. Smaller reactors probably means more of them, each requiring separate planning permission, design approval and so on. It also probably means people living closer to the reactor, which many would and do oppose. This series makes a good case for regulation being a significant cost component but it doesn't really make the case (nor does it try to) that said regulation is overly onerous or otherwise unnecessary. A lot of regulation came about because of our experience with nuclear reactors, accidents and near-accidents and the bigger failur emodes of the larger reactors power supplies would likely want to build.
- jjk166 4y ago> Smaller reactors probably means more of them, each requiring separate planning permission, design approval and so on. It also probably means people living closer to the reactor, which many would and do oppose. The major selling point for smaller reactors is that you can make a mass produced design that doesn't need separate planning, permission, and design approval every time. You can still have large power plants to get the benefits of scale, you just put more of these small units together at the same site. In fact you get some bonuses as you can shut down some reactors for maintenance while still producing power. Indeed most nuclear power plants already have multiple cores for exactly this reason, but typically its 2-6 rather than 20-60 and thus they are still pretty big.
- brutusborn 4y agoI think the point is more that the past cost overrund are due to _changing_ regulation, not necessarily the regulation themselves. It's like a software client changes requirements a year into a 2 year project and suddenly you need to rearchitect the whole thing, essentially starting again. Following regulations is costly, but following changing regulations throughout a project lifecycle is _very expensive_.
- tomComb 4y agoYes, cost is the issue. Everyone assumes that anyone hesitant about Nuclear power is focussed on the environmental or safety concerns, but that is wrong. The costs (and cost overruns) of the construction and maintenance of Nuclear reactors have been enough reason on their own to be bearish on Nuclear. I'm hopeful that new technologies, such as small nuclear reactions that can be built in a factory, will address this.
- virissimo 4y agoOur nations were far less wealthy when the existing stock of nuclear power plants were built, the technology available for building them have improved since then, and the raw resources needed as their inputs aren't a constraint, so why have costs risen so much relative to what we are willing to spend on it? Environmental and safety regulations are supposed to be explanations for this rise in cost, not rival explanations to "cost is the issue" (since they take that as given).
- KptMarchewa 4y ago>the technology available for building them have improved since then Broadly, construction is the singular industry where productivity hasn't improved with modern technology. https://constructionphysics.substack.com/p/sketch-of-a-theory-of-construction https://constructionphysics.substack.com/p/sketch-of-a-theor...
- MichaelZuo 4y agoIn fact, the opposite, there’s been a noticeable productivity decline in the US in most of the construction industry.
- towaway15463 4y agoConcrete infrastructure projects in particular seem to have gotten more expensive and time consuming.
- 4y ago
- whearyou 4y agoUntil fail-safe fission technology is ready (unlike fail deadly technology which all current and planned systems currently are) nuclear power seems to me a sophisticated example of cutting off your nose to spite your face
- dickholesalad 4y agoIf by fail safe you mean that powering off the reactor makes it cool down then the Navy uses fail safe reactors. Water is used as the moderator to absorb radiation. When water is heated its density decreases (edit), thereby making it a less good moderator of radiation. This effect lowers reactor reactivity and heat output. This effect is combined with various devices to produce what is called an inherently safe design. Losing power will not make the reactor have a fuel element failure or melt down.
- whearyou 4y agoFail safe means that in a catastrophic failure of the reactor’s regulatory systems it stops functioning rather than overloads. Entropy trends it to not working rather than working too much - for example a gas furnace will stop burning if the systems running the furnace stop working and are unable to provide more gas to the burn chamber. Is that how Navy reactors work?
- dickholesalad 4y agoChernobyl used a neutron moderator with a positive temperature coefficient of reactivity (liquid sodium), while U.S. Navy reactors use water, which has a negative coefficient of reactivity. The more energy you put into the water surrounding the reactor, the less reactive it allows the reactor to be. This has a stabilizing effect on the system. U.S. Navy reactors are inherently stable and inherently safe. To answer your question directly, yes entropy will trend toward making the reactor produce less heat with no intervention.
- pfdietz 4y ago
- daniel-cussen 4y ago
- poorlyknit 4y agoOut of curiosity, how is this relevant to the posted article? I don't really see the connection but I'd be delighted to hear your train of thought.
- daniel-cussen 4y ago[flagged]
- fffobar 4y agoIs this neural-network generated? The bio makes me think that it is, in fact, written by a machine: > Perhaps you'll think my comments are unthinkable. My only response to that is that they were legibly written, not by a machine, but by a writer with a soul.
- yrgulation 4y agoI’ve seen quite a few machine like comments as of lately. They should nail auto complete and support chatbots first then try to fool people around here.
- z7 4y agoI don't think this was a machine. The Simpsons observations, the Zola reference, the epiphoric sentence rhythms... doesn't feel like it. He just seems to ignore Grice's third conversational maxim.
- BMc2020 4y agoHere's my response from 10 days ago to this same story. 0 points by BMc2020 10 days ago | parent | context | prev | next [–] | on: Why are nuclear power construction costs so high? ... I opened all three of these, but did not read any of them I did a Ctrl-F for "subsid" (to find subsidy or subsidies) 0 hits I did a Ctrl-F for "decomm" (to find decommission or decommissioning) 0 hits Having read many of these types of articles before, I've learned some shortcuts on how not to waste time.
- kragen 4y agoYou can in theory decommission naval nuclear reactors by letting them sink to the bottom of the ocean in a terrible, sad accident from which fortunately all the sailors were safely rescued. I don't know that anybody has done this; often the sailors all died. But it seems that even without taking decommissioning into account, naval nuclear reactors are not cost-competitive with other power sources. Looking for "subsidies" when we're talking about a military project doesn't make sense; the project is 100% taxpayer-funded unless some supplier is selling parts to the government at a loss. Far more likely, lamentably, is the opposite, the proverbial thousand-dollar toilet seats. Maybe it's relevant to the cost question that the Navy can buy diesel engines from half a dozen naval diesel engine vendors but has to commission custom nuclear power plants.
- BMc2020 4y agoYou didn't read parts 1 and 2? You've had many chances since this propoganda is re-posted so frequently: Why are nuclear power construction costs so high? Part III – the nuclear navy (constructionphysics.substack.com) 104 points by gmays 5 hours ago | flag | past | 100 comments Why did we wait so long for wind power? Part I (constructionphysics.substack.com) 26 points by jseliger 9 days ago | flag | past | 4 comments Why are nuclear power construction costs so high? Part III – the nuclear navy (constructionphysics.substack.com) 4 points by bilsbie 10 days ago | flag | past | 1 comment Why did we wait so long for wind power? (constructionphysics.substack.com) 2 points by gok 10 days ago | flag | past | discuss Why aren't there economies of scale in building size? (constructionphysics.substack.com) 2 points by rwmj 21 days ago | past Where do economies of scale come from? Part II (constructionphysics.substack.com) 66 points by jseliger 23 days ago | past | 4 comments Where Economies of Scale Come From (constructionphysics.substack.com) 10 points by vwoolf 28 days ago | past How the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) Works (constructionphysics.substack.com) 44 points by jseliger 34 days ago | past | 15 comments Why are there so few economies of scale in construction? Part I (constructionphysics.substack.com) 95 points by danboarder 34 days ago | past | 84 comments Why are there so few economies of scale in construction? (constructionphysics.substack.com) 5 points by h2odragon 35 days ago | past | 2 comments How NEPA Works (constructionphysics.substack.com) 3 points by burlesona 41 days ago | past | 1 comment How the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) Works (constructionphysics.substack.com) 2 points by jseliger 42 days ago | past The Rise and Fall of the Manufactured Home – Part I (constructionphysics.substack.com) 158 points by samclemens 76 days ago | past | 174 comments The Rise and Fall of the Manufactured Home – Part I (constructionphysics.substack.com) 3 points by jseliger 77 days ago | past Nuclear reactor costs – US Navy Edition (constructionphysics.substack.com) 4 points by uncertainrhymes 88 days ago | past Why are nuclear power construction costs so high? Part III – the nuclear navy (constructionphysics.substack.com) 3 points by jseliger 3 months ago | past Why are nuclear power construction costs so high? Part II (constructionphysics.substack.com) 34 points by jseliger 3 months ago | past | 14 comments Why are nuclear power construction costs so high? Part II (constructionphysics.substack.com) 3 points by jseliger 3 months ago | past | 1 comment
- lowbloodsugar 4y ago>Following the Three Mile Island accident, Naval Reactors was asked to prepare a statement on what civilian reactors could learn from the navy’s long history of safe reactor operation. Of the 111 pages prepared, 88 were devoted to training.
- credit_guy 4y agoWhenever we talk about nuclear power on HN, people are split in two groups: those who'd love to see nuclear power succeeding, and those who are against it and who support solar and wind. I am pro both nuclear and renewables. Solar and wind have been on an absolute tear lately. At least in the US (where I live) new solar and wind construction has been growing at a breathtaking pace during the last decade. Take a look at the latest data from the EIA [1]. For the last month available, July 2022, solar and wind generated together 45 Terawatts hour of electricity. Coal generated 86 TWh. But 3 months prior, solar/wind produced 60 TWh, while coal only 55. To get an appreciation for how much solar and wind have grown over the last 2 decades, here's their July production every 5 years since 2002 (in TWh): 2002: 1 2007: 2 2012: 7 2017: 22 2022: 45 Somewhere up there Moore is smiling. Guys who are pro-solar and pro-wind: rejoice, you have won. Solar and wind have achieved escape velocity. If they keep it like that, we won't have any problems fully decarbonizing by 2050. We'll actually get there sooner. Without any help from nuclear. We won't even need batteries or hydrogen. Few people know, but we could keep all the current natural gas plant and still achieve net zero (actually net negative). How is that possible, you ask? Right now the forests absorb about 13% of the total emissions in the US [2]. Electricity generation contributes by 25% to the total emissions, and natural gas generates less than half of those. So overall, land and forestry absorb more greenhouse gases than those produced by the natural gas power plants. If we increase solar and power, at some point we will need natural gas to only cover the intermittency. That means, even if we keep all the current natural gas plants, their usage will go down, and their emissions. If we cut all other sources of greenhouse gases (apart from aviation, which depends on energy dense fuels, and contributes quite little to the total emission), we will have no problems to achieve net zero by 2050, and very likely much sooner. On the nuclear side, things are looking quite good too. Just head to the DoE infographic [3] and see how many cool ideas are in the works. My favorite ones are the fast reactors. But they are just vaporware, you say. In that case, head to the NRC webpage [4], and click on some links over there, and see that all of those ventures (and some more) have already started the licensing process. Of course, none is as advanced as NuScale. But my point is that NuScale is not our only hope. Lots of other startups are hot on their tails. My prediction is that 15 years from now, more than 1 of all these startups will have delivered reactors that will be selling electricity at a profit, without subsidies. [1] https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/browser/ https://www.eia.gov/electricity/data/browser/ [2] https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emissions https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/sources-greenhouse-gas-emis... [3] https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/infographic-advanced-reactor-development https://www.energy.gov/ne/articles/infographic-advanced-reac... [4] https://www.nrc.gov/reactors/new-reactors/advanced/licensing-activities/pre-application-activities.html https://www.nrc.gov/reactors/new-reactors/advanced/licensing...
- grej 4y agoJust remember that a huge part of the current excess cost is in part: (a) because nuclear power is the only energy technology for which the full lifecycle costs have to be fully accounted for upfront. No one is accounting for the disposal costs of solar panels in their initial capital expenditure, for example. (b) The build costs in terms of energy of wind and solar are comparably high. They are raw material and energy hungry and have a much lower energy return on investment and require a much larger geographic footprint. Plus their use without adequate baseload generation will necessitate a large additional requirement for raw materials to create energy storage. Much if not all of wind and solar’s cost advantages will likely evaporate in an environment where they are no longer subsidized by very cheap fossil fuels.
- croes 4y agoMaybe (a) is because solar panels are less dangerous than nuclear waste.
- ryoshu 4y agowe need to account for the danger of disposal/long term storage of the dead batteries for solar as well. But I'm not sure what the calculation for that is vs. nuclear waste.
- adrianN 4y agoBatteries can be recycled. They contain expensive metals in high concentrations, recycling makes financial sense.
- dieselgate 4y agoThey can be recycled but it doesn’t appear we’ve had to deal with this much on an industrial scale - yet. Electric car batteries may be better off being “reused” for less demanding tasks after they’ve hit their usable limit for vehicle use. Of course they’ll need to be recycled eventually. This isn’t my domain so I’m very open to new information. In regards to recycling lead acid batteries the work seems horrendous, for more information check out the lead poisoning cases from Florida workers at Gopher Resource in Tampa.
- Gud 4y agoIn the end, no one is arguing that nuclear power in the West is not expensive. As the first part of this article series notes, South Korea does not seem to have such extensive costs. Instead of looking into why South Korea can build nuclear power plants at reasonable costs, it hand waves it away implying that the South Koreans are faking the numbers. South Korean companies also built the Barakah nuclear power plant in the United Arab Emirates, which is hugely successful. https://www.enec.gov.ae/news/latest-news/start-up-of-unit-3-of-barakah-nuclear-energy-plant-accelerates-achievement-of-uae-net-zero-2050/ https://www.enec.gov.ae/news/latest-news/start-up-of-unit-3-...