18 ms·
Why are sex workers forced to wear a financial scarlet letter?
- a-user-you-like 4y ago
- SnowHill9902 4y agoThat’s not the question it’s trying to answer. And why is it bad, if you want to answer?
- BlargMcLarg 4y agoRegardless of your stance, yes, this is a serious article and has been actively debated for several decades now. And it has also lead to a huge amount of cognitive dissonance.
- classified 4y agoAmerica seems to be more backwards on anything sex-related than Victorian England.
- a-user-you-like 4y ago“Backwards” I suppose if all your daughters wanted to be whores you’d be a good chap and send them on their way with a box of biscuits.
- Der_Einzige 4y agoGo read Foucault's "A history of sexuality". He spends the whole world debunking the idea that the victorian's were especially sexually prudes. He spends the majority of the work trying to figure out why modern people are still convinced that the victorian's were uniquely prudish. He thinks this belief is deeply connected to many other strange sexual beliefs. I think Foucault is frequently overrated but at least volume 1 of a history of sexuality is pretty neat.
- matthewmacleod 4y agoIf you have something to say, it would be more effective to just say it, rather than pose vague, unanswerable rhetorical questions that rely on us being able to read your mind.
- a-user-you-like 4y agoTo say that whoring is immoral? Are you advocating for more whoring in society?
- roenxi 4y agoCrypto is an option here. Seems like a pretty good fit for what the sex workers need.
- LinuxBender 4y agoAn immutable record of who paid what sex workers sounds like it has the potential for machine learning to map who did what and with whom. Could this information be abused?
- takoid 4y agoThere are cryptocurrencies besides Bitcoin. Monero seems like an appropriate choice for this use case.
- ethotool 4y agoCrypto has been such a proven failure yet people still say these things on the regular.
- x86x87 4y agoHere is one thing you can do with crypto that you cannot do with a credit card: use your money how you would like. There is no payment processor to decide that you are not allowed to send or receive money.
- mrguyorama 4y agoMeanwhile walmart still won't let me buy snacks with bitcoin
- x86x87 4y agoEveryone believes that's an edge case/oddity until they or a business they care about gets banned by the payment processor gods.
- ceejayoz 4y agoSure, unless you need a mortgage, a car loan, or any number of other financial products.
- dtx1 4y ago
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoAgain with the denigrating of sex work. It's a pervasive and ancient part of human society, but it should not be studied, because? We study bookmaking and banking and families and art, but not this because, it's naughty? it's taboo? it makes some uncomfortable? All that is a clear sign to me, that we need more such scholars.
- dtx1 4y ago
- kingkawn 4y agoWhat is the purpose of the academy other than to organize knowledge about significant cultural, social, and financial aspects of our society? I think you just enjoy taking what you think will be cheap shots.
- ChefboyOG 4y agoCan you expand on why pornography is an unsuitable focus for a scholar?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Bakary 4y agoIf we frame the idea a bit more precisely: 1) Pornography studies can be an aspect of sociology, and it's not uncommon for sociologists to specialize in a narrow area. 2) The study of pornography isn't all that narrow to begin with. It's something that has driven technology to a great extent, in particular media and web functionalities. It's something with thousands of years of history and with literally billions of people involved as producers or consumers. There are probably very few people reading this thread who have never viewed a form of it. 3) A job can have a poor financial outlook even if its subject matter is worthwhile.
- faitswulff 4y agoThis is what I thought that “Censor-Resistant Payment Processing” post from a week ago was going to be about.
- pessimizer 4y agoI would hope it would be. Pornographers use the courts to enforce their copyrights and other business arrangements. A good test for an anti-censorship payment processor would be handling payments for legal sex work.
- fareesh 4y agoEric Weinstein sat down with Ashley Mathews (Riley Reid) and discussed this a few years ago on his Portal podcast. https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/21-ashley-mathews-aka-riley-reid-the-mogul-and/id1469999563?i=1000464283583 https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/21-ashley-mathews-aka-... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uHNBCVGH34c&themeRefresh=1 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uHNBCVGH34c&themeRefresh=1
- mvdwoord 4y agoInteresting (perhaps), tangentially related, column by Cherie DeVille on the influence of payment processors on the porn industry. https://www.thedailybeast.com/inside-porns-silliest-new-trend-women-stuck-in-things https://www.thedailybeast.com/inside-porns-silliest-new-tren...
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoAll this time, and technology hasn't solved this issue? Wasn't bitcoin supposed to be applicable here - anonymous transactions? Wasn't the internet supposed to enable humans to interact at will without censorship?
- fknorangesite 4y ago> Wasn't bitcoin supposed to be applicable here Accepting bitcoin is all well and good, but it doesn't help you much if your customers aren't able/willing to pay with it.
- manuelabeledo 4y agoYou can do the same with just cash.
- JoeAltmaier 4y agoIt won't go in the floppy slot somehow...
- Overtonwindow 4y agoBut then cash becomes a storage issue. The same way marijuana shops are blocked from depositing their cash into banks, cash with sex workers becomes a problem. How to get it into the banking system without drawing the attention of the police? Even worse, try paying bills with cash. If you'll pardon me, I think cash deposite below $1,000 should be none of the government's business without a valid, specific warrant. If someone wants to sell drugs, sex, or graphics cards on the side for cash, it's none of the government's business.
- CaptainZapp 4y ago> The same way marijuana shops are blocked from depositing their cash into banks, cash with sex workers becomes a problem. Only if sex work is illegal. Which it isn't in significant parts of the developed world. Prostitutes (male or female) here around are taxed like everybody else. In addition they need to be health checked to perform their work. Paying them in cash is really no problem neither for the client nor for the provider.
- LatteLazy 4y agoWe're really seeing a counterrevolution around sex and sexuality. From Row vs Wade to crackdowns on pornography to this, America is getting back to its puritanical roots...
- colpabar 4y agoThis theory goes out the window as soon as you turn on a television and see the programming and commercials people watch.
- jrm4 4y agoNope. This confirms it. "Sex" as fine as long as it's not too explicit and mostly not actually about sex, but about keeping you insecure to buy stuff.
- pcthrowaway 4y agoEverything in the world is ultimately about sex. Except sex. Sex is about power. - Oscar Wilde
- nicwolff 4y ago- Robert Michels [0][1] [0] https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/a/24106 https://skeptics.stackexchange.com/a/24106 [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Michels https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Robert_Michels
- jrm4 4y agoReal talk. As someone who was raised Catholic, I just sort of assumed that sexual repression was a by-product of strong religious beliefs, and now I'm both fascinated and dismayed to discover that religion is in no way a requirement for this. America has managed to reinstate sexual repression, and it's odd how there's no clear "source" for it beyond "habitual capitalism" or something like that.
- 4y ago
- sh4un 4y ago
- horsestaple 4y ago
- Workaccount2 4y agoConstruction is the male equivalent but nobody seems to even notice.
- socialismisok 4y agoAlso, there are plenty of male sex workers...
- j_m_b 4y ago>We also know that the vast majority of people who work in the "industry" are either coerced by others or forced into it by life circumstances. Citation needed. Porn stars are coerced into it? Are cam models forced into it? The fact that the oldest profession is illegal leads to exploitation. "You think I sell my body, I merely sell my time" -NOFX
- potatototoo99 4y agoPorn STARS probably not. Cam "models" yes absolutely are the majority forced into it.
- marginalia_nu 4y ago> I would argue that renting out your body in the most intimate way is very different from most jobs You seem to only imply these arguments. What are they, specifically?
- NoraCodes 4y ago> We also know that the vast majority of people who work in the "industry" are either coerced by others or forced into it by life circumstances. Most people are forced into work by life circumstances. That's how society operates: work or starve. Sex trafficking is a genuine issue, but it's not at all the majority of the industry. I don't see what makes consensual sex work uniquely coercive or evil when compared to other physically or emotionally intensive labor.
- giantg2 4y ago"It also establishes a precedent, allowing private companies to set opaque, moralizing, and arbitrary censorship terms without oversight." Yes, this is done with other things as well. On one hand, I think that the free market would create payment processors willing to work with the groups rejected by others. On the other hand, it seems that many financial things are set by international organizations, which the processors would still need to follow to be included in the central systems, such as the coding (does adult content have its own code, or is it under entertainment?).
- izacus 4y agoCorporate consolidation made sure that a lot of important markets aren't free anymore. Vertical integration between corporations made that even worse - e.g. if Visa won't process your payments, people with Apple phones won't be able to pay either. These kind of things - there's too little competition across many markets so big players just itegrate with themselves and newcomers simply can't compete due to integration and network effects.
- dbingham 4y agoIt's important to point out that this is a natural consequence of a market system, and it's exacerbated by allowing capital to rule those markets. Until we recognize that, we're not going to be able to fix it. One can't just declare that "If only the market were truly free, it wouldn't be like this." We've seen this play out on the freest market that has ever existed (the early internet) and we ended up in the exact same place - with a few massive players buying up all their competitors and completely dominating their verticals. There was as little regulation or government interference in the early internet as there has ever been in just about any market. And we still got there. Corporate consolidation is a consequence of free markets, not a corruption of them.
- edmcnulty101 4y agoIt's late stage capitalism. It's how all 'free markets' end up eventually. The biggest players gobbling up all of the competition and essentially having a monopoly. All you have to do is drive through middle america to see the Ruby Tuesday/Strip Mall-ification effect on most of the United States. I love capitalism when it's functioning it's the greatest system ever invented. When it's just a market full of monopolies it's akin to dysfunctional communism from a consumer choice perspective. I don't know what the solution is.
- AmericanChopper 4y agoThe only thing special about sex workers in this situation is the politicized nature of their work. The industry they work in, and they way they conduct their business, simply doesn’t align very well with the risk management strategies of conventional financial institutions. Any form of non-conventional work is going to run into exactly the same problems. I know this because the same thing happens to me. Nearly all my income comes from InfoSec-related contract work, and most of my customers are overseas. This is a very non-conventional working arrangement, so when conventional financial institutions apply their routine risk assessment processes to my situation, it produces a lot of “computer says no” outcomes. For instance I was recently told that I would need to provide 90% collateral in order to get a car loan, despite being able to prove having a very high income over the past 12 months. Clearly a stupid situation, but with a perfectly rational explanation. The problem here is a tiny niche of customers not being catered to by large institutions. The reason for this is because tiny niches of customers are typically not worth the effort to large institutions. But that conclusion is unlikely to attract much outrage traffic…
- Bakary 4y agoThis is a great theory, and I am inclined to agree, but how does it explain large, stable adult websites encountering such roadblocks?
- AmericanChopper 4y agoThe risk factors are the same. The only thing that scales with the size of the operation is the dollar value of the risk.
- mrguyorama 4y agoThe above poster has completely ignored the large religious morality groups that have made it their mission to remove porn from the internet entirely. They are the ones that took pornhub to court saying all their content was child porn and got pornhub to remove 90% of its inventory
- 4y ago
- mkl95 4y ago> Excessive chargebacks plague many industries: auctions, online gaming, event ticket sales, multilevel marketing, and more. But when your business is regarded as a reputational liability—as porn is—payment processors are quick to blacklist. It sounds like a combination of tangible and intangible stuff. There are cultural aspects behind it but also legit financial concerns.
- hackeraccount 4y agoThere's a libertarian ethos that says anything between two consenting adults is the their business. I'm more and more skeptical not just of that principle but the self awareness of the people who purport to support it. I know that the choices I think are correct may not be - either for myself, for everyone or for any particular person. For that reason I don't think that anyone should run my life or that I should be trying to run other people's; excepting crossing the bright line of consent. I'm beginning to wonder though if there isn't some space short of stopping a person from doing something - even if just to stand up and say - "What you're doing is crazy. Why would you do that to yourself? Why would you let someone do that to you? Why would you do that to another person?" If you talk to people who would ask those questions though the issue is that anyone who's willing to say something is also unable to accept that that's all they can do. They'll push whatever isn't right for them to the other side of the bright line.
- confidantlake 4y agoI think that is friends/family/social pressure is for. We don't forbid it, but people will look at you sideways if you drink beer at 9 am on a weekday.
- slfnflctd 4y agoThere are countless situations where that sort of pressure simply doesn't exist, and likely won't in the future. I also don't think the example you provided is a very good one. Perhaps a better example might be extreme cosmetic surgery (&/or body modification) addicts. Or maybe I should say 'enthusiasts'.
- confidantlake 4y agoYup good point, it wasn't a very good example.
- SpicyLemonZest 4y agoSocial pressure seems sufficient to produce most if not all of the problems described in the source article. Why are chargeback rates so high? Because the customer's spouse found out about the purchase and now they have to pretend it wasn't them. Why won't VCs invest in Onlyfans? Because it would be extremely embarrassing for a partner to attend a board meeting about all the great porn the company's producing.
- Kiro 4y agoAmong Swedish feminists and the left, sex work is completely unacceptable and prostitution is pretty much equated with rape. Is this not true for other countries?
- Kye 4y agoSwedish feminists probably have as wide a range of opinions on any given topic as any other kind of feminist. Also: "the left," a fraught and increasingly fluid concept.
- Kiro 4y agoThe narrative is extremely one-sided in Sweden and there's no debate. Celebrities get unanimously cancelled for getting caught buying sex. Here are some quotes (Google Translated) from the biggest feminist organisation (Feministiskt Initiativ): "Prostitution and human trafficking for sexual purposes is a form of violence and a violation of human rights." "Sexualization and objectification work against the principle of the human being as an independent subject and can limit women's ability to protect their bodily integrity." "Equality cannot be achieved as long as it is possible to buy other people's bodies through prostitution, strip or sex clubs." "Working against pornography and objectifying representations is thus an important part of violence prevention work."
- zppln 4y agoYes, generalizations can never be made and truth does not exist.
- socialismisok 4y agoIn the far left in the States it's considered work, and something that should be well regulated and safe. The center left/centrist (Democrats) position is more split. Some folks think it's a bodily autonomy issue and others think it's degrading. Feminist opinion is likewise split. But most feminists I know tend to fall in the, "if it's consensual, it should be protected and regulated work. You shouldn't fear going to jail because you had sex." So, it's a mix of opinions out here.
- Mockapapella 4y agoKind of related to the financial aspects of this article: why is the housing market treated as the basis/most important part of the US economy and not, specifically, energy or finance? The article talks about financial institutions' ability to hinder or even halt growth altogether, and we saw similar actions being taken in Canada last year with the truckers. With regards to energy, I've heard that the cheaper energy is to produce in a nation, the wealthier it tends to be.
- bombcar 4y agoAt least in the US it's because of deliberate policy decisions after WWII around home ownership. Massive government agencies are explicitly tasked with getting the percentage of Americans owning homes as high as possible. Energy and finance are important, but don't directly involve individuals as much, and people are VERY emotionally tied into their home and it's value. If all houses suddenly lost 50% overnight, and mortgages were slashed simultaneously to compensate, it wouldn't be that big of a deal but everyone would freak the hell out. It's much easier to inflate the currency than it is to allow home prices to drop.
- josephcsible 4y agoWhy doesn't the argument "private companies can do whatever they want, so if you don't like being arbitrarily banned by the incumbents, then start your own bank and payment processor" apply here?
- RunSet 4y agoBy way of answer, a cautionary tale: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberty_dollar_(private_currency)#Federal_Government_response https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liberty_dollar_(private_curren...
- josephcsible 4y agoMy question was about a new bank that would deal in existing US dollars, not creating another new currency.
- giantg2 4y agoThe only thing I can think of is that most of the centralized systems are highly regulated at the national and international level. Without those systems, a company would not be competitive. Even entire countries have tried to create their own systems with limited success (look at Russia trying to replace Swift recently).
- pjc50 4y agoObviously it depends on whether people like the activity being banned or not?
- josephcsible 4y agoThis is basically what I was thinking. The argument is never actually sound, but people only acknowledge that when it's something they like that gets banned, instead pretending that it is a good argument when something they don't like gets banned.
- giraffe_lady 4y ago
- JTbane 4y agoContent creators are also self-censoring to avoid automatic moderation (YouTube demonetization and TikTok shadowbanning). Things like "sex" and "death" are euphemized or not said (see things like "unalive" instead of "dead", "heckmet" instead of "helmet".
- rippercushions 4y agoWhat's wrong with "helmet"?
- Mindwipe 4y agoIt's a euphemism for penis.
- detaro 4y agoit has "hell" in it.
- aluminum96 4y agoBut it... does not. It only has one L.
- detaro 4y agothe thing people try to avoid is crappy speech recognition software, with a dose of cargo-culting because of course the platforms don't tell people what exactly they don't like, so people try to find patterns in what gets demonetized.
- rglover 4y agoBest guess: the AI interprets it as "war," "penis" and "clitoris" and pushes it into a moderation/flag queue.
- mellosouls 4y agoIn other words, a world in which payment processors and content platforms rule unchallenged is a problem not just for porn creators and consumers. It also establishes a precedent, allowing private companies to set opaque, moralizing, and arbitrary censorship terms without oversight They've only just noticed this after years of WrongThinkers being deplatformed?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rendall 4y agoNo. Maggie MacDonald among others have been talking about this for years.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- marcus_holmes 4y agoI investigated this a few years ago in Australia. Sex work is legal in Australia, kinda. It is legal to exchange sexual services for money, but supporting and assisting such a transaction is illegal. So a landlord who rents a property to a sex worker is breaking the law. A payment processor who processes the card transaction is breaking the law, and so on. There are some clauses around managing establishments that basically make brothels just, barely, within the law. It's a ridiculous position in that it almost forces sex workers onto the street or into brothels (which often take a huge chunk of each transaction). There was no way of getting my client (I was freelancing for a sex worker to try and solve some of their tech issues) any reasonable ability to process credit cards. Or do a wide range of things that we'd consider normal for a small business (like set up a Stripe account, or even a business bank account, or rent an office). This needs to change.
- wallscratch 4y agoI’m confused — why can’t the sex workers just claim to be independent masseuses or something else innocuous like that?
- chki 4y agoWhy can't drug dealers claim to sell recreational tea products?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- some_random 4y agoWhy can't hitmen claim to be bespoke pest exterminators?
- RajT88 4y agoOK, so I don't know about the hitmen thing, but there's been plenty of news stories about "independent masseuses" and "incense", "bath salts", etc. People do stuff like this. I too wonder how they get away with it for as long as they do.
- bergenty 4y agoIt’s a little too easy to be nude on the internet and make money off it compared to being a prostitute irl. There needs to be some moral policing in my opinion so online pornography doesn’t become normalized. I’m all for completely legalized prostitution, but the balance is it still needs to be on the margins to have an upstanding society.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- x86x87 4y agoToo easy to be nude? Wtf are you talking about? A lot of tech we have today may not have existed or flourished if not for porn. There needs to be moral policing? No. There is no need for this. Let the market decide. If people want porn give em porn (you need a reality check btw. Most internet traffic is porn. Even today). Also, puritan moralistic misguided people need to get with the program. You don't like it? Don't do it. You don't hold the absolute truth (in fact you are just recycling garbage that was created out of thin air millenniums ago and does not apply) and you don't get to decide how everyone lives their lives. Upstanding society my ass. An upstanding society is one where you are free to do whatever you want to do and you are polite and tolerant of other people that don't fit your ideas. That's upstanding!
- bergenty 4y agoI don’t agree with that. I think the puritans were onto something and I want a partial return to those ideals.
- charles_f 4y ago> Despite a user base of over 130 million, OnlyFans has failed to attract venture capital I don't get why that's a problem? They already built their platform, it works, they're the gold standard and they have a massive paying userbase! Why do they need VC money? Why would you want to dilute your stock rather than just build with your already existing, sizeable revenue stream?
- nine_k 4y agoUsually it makes sense to take investor money if you want to grow faster than your revenue stream allows. It lets you potentially capture the market before your competition. But I don't think that there's much direct competition to OnlyFans, or that there is a market which is easy to capture by copycatting them. Hence, they can afford to not take any investment. This is similar to how GitHub operated and grew for the first few years.
- kreco 4y agoEspecially because it also means that potential OnlyFans competitor will come across the same fate. So there is no need to worry about them (unless the owners intended to get massive cash asap).
- rtkwe 4y agoIt would have been useful early to pay for hosting. OF may not exist today if not for the great de-porning of Tumblr that happened about a year after they started as a business.
- lostgame 4y agoThe Tumblr de-porning was the single most SMH business moment I may have heard of since Yahoo’s previous worst business move ever of not buying Google. I mean - my God… Yahoo may very well be the single dumbest major tech company in history. Just…blunder after blunder after shitty decision. Watching its history is almost the definition of seeing a slow motion train wreck. It’s almost impressive. With regards to Tumblr - I can’t imagine what potential business decision could’ve been worth what they had to know was suicide. Why make the acquisition and then kill your user base? It’s not like they didn’t know. That’s probably one of the single biggest wastes of $1b I’ve seen. Why buy it to knowingly, fully intentionally, throw it down the toilet? So baffling.
- ethotool 4y agoReading about E-Pimps changed my whole perspective on OnlyFans. History tells us where this is going and it’s very likely things are not going to get any better unfortunately.
- P0l83q4p1Hw3Ul 4y agoWhat did you learn about E-pimps? What does history tell us?
- 0xbadcafebee 4y agoStupid question: why isn't there a credit card company that simply does not support chargebacks? Or only take debit? Or something?
- mrguyorama 4y agoBecause the chargebacks aren't the actual problem, but merely an excuse. Anyone who offers services of any kind to sex workers, especially internet based ones, gets attacked by very specific religious based groups who have taken it upon themselves to get porn off the internet. These groups have taken visa to court multiple times, and were the reason that pornhub was forced to remove basically 90% of it's inventory last year.
- _ktx2 4y agoThe most troubling thing, that is somewhat observable in today's threads, is that ostracizing sex work is almost entirely normalized. People favor legal structures analogous to Don't Ask Don't Tell. This tees up a system of cascading effects: - Sex workers must now navigate a very fluid monetary system. Sex workers must be paid in cash, Bitcoin, etc. Then they have to somehow represent this money to the federal government to pay their taxes. - Everyone around sex workers are considered criminals. Unknowingly rent a property to a sex worker? You're a criminal. Date a sex worker? Suspected to be a criminal. Lend money to a sex worker? Criminal. Use sex work services? Definitely a criminal. This system shoves sex workers into an intentional class system that prohibits them from owning property, prohibits their use of public services, prohibits their utilization of our monetary system. All of these things, when used, don't just benefit the sex workers - they benefit you. One of the uncomfortable conversations that many people don't want to have is that sex work is heavily used by society and yet neglected constantly, thereby making it dangerous for both sex workers and the users, even making it more dangerous at times.
- npteljes 4y ago>ostracizing sex work is almost entirely normalized 100%. One of the universal curses people throw at each other is implying that someone's mother is a prostitute, or that they are a product of extramarital sex, implying the promiscuity of the mother. This all is hand-in-hand with the implied comtempt towards women of course.
- tablespoon 4y ago> 100%. One of the universal curses people throw at each other is implying that someone's mother is a prostitute, or that they are a product of extramarital sex, implying the promiscuity of the mother. This all is hand-in-hand with the implied comtempt towards women of course. How so? Not all women are prostitutes.
- staticassertion 4y agoBecause no one's throwing around "your father is a prostitute" as an insult.
- entwife 4y agoWith regard to the charge back problem, it seems that this could be addressed by using cash or maybe Bitcoin. Something that cannot be charged back, and maybe can't be traced.
- JustLurking2022 4y agoWhile many people on here are glorifying the workers in certain 1st world countries, I doubt it's representative of most sex workers worldwide. There's a ton of coercion and exploitation, and most countries don't have the sort of social safety net that ensures it's actually a real choice. I would imagine that's why banks at large have generally steered away from the industry - if 90% of the business is super shady and exposes them to excess risk, it's not worth it to sort out the 10% that's not. If there were a processor targeting the industry, the fees would probably be through the roof to account for this. That's just the markets at work.
- eric4smith 4y agoOstracizing sex work has always been the case for thousands of years in every successful culture and religion. In fact, cultures that allowed widespread open sex work have always failed. (No, Amsterdam’s red light district is not “widespread”). Just because it’s 2022 does not mean things should automatically change. Even Onlyfans performers, strippers and pr0n stars are openly shunned or relegated to non “wifely” roles. This is because there are super deep lizard brain biological reasons why cultures have always done this. And it will still take a few more generations before no one bats an eye (25+ years). Yes, it would be better if it were safe and legal. Would probably be better for it’s consumers and providers. But in the end the biological imperative to “be fruitful and multiply”, which is deeper than many of us would like to admit - is going to always fight back. Railing against this ostracism is like railing against the sky being blue.
- OkayPhysicist 4y agoAll cultures, of any kind, have failed. That is the nature of time. Culture is constantly dying and being reformed. So an argument that "All cultures that allowed X have failed" is a really tepid argument. The vast majority of cultures that normalized eating have failed, simply because the vast majority of cultures have failed, period. What differentiates Amsterdam's red light district from OnlyFans' red light district's, or Las Vegas's, cultures from any others? The real answer, of course, is that excluding all the examples of something you can think of makes for an easy way of framing your statements as an absolute truth, but that's certainly more than a little underhanded.
- eric4smith 4y agoMmmmm…. You’re very literal here. It’s clear I mean fail more quickly and easily. Of course everything eventually ends.
- reilly3000 4y agoThis is about financial institutions protecting themselves from regulators. Higher risk clients get higher rates or excluded- some just aren’t worth the risk. Different banks have different risk tolerance, and certainly that varies per locale as well. Rules that are locale-specific are hard to accommodate. Crypto is a solution if you believe that crypto is regulator-proof. I’m inclined to not think it is. Sure, Monero, etc. As soon as “Terrorists” are using it, regulators will find a way to monitor, control, outlaw, or even break it. By any means necessary. I see 3 approaches: - find a way to make locale-specific compliance easier for enterprises. Locale is hard with anon web traffic, and maybe other systems as well. - make a national law for sex worker payment rights. Banks are good at complying with national laws. Our current political climate may not permit this. - weaken the power and scope of US financial regulators. Certainly those affected by SWIFT sanctions would love to see it, I’m sure. Our current administration is very committed to keeping and enhancing its resources and reach.
- fiat_fandango 4y agoI don't personally, but society (even liberal society) still has structural reasons to disincentivize this kind of behavior. Even as someone who doesn't think the government should tell you how to live, you can't pretend to be blind to the fact of why the government doesn't want to promulgate this kind of promiscuity / lack of family structure. It's ironic, given they think it's completely okay to explicitly target firearms companies who make devices and implements protected by the constitution - however cry wolf when acts that may cause far more psychological or societal harm are also given a scarlet letter. To be clear, even as someone far-left leaning I'd acknowledge pornography, more specifically sexually driven parasocial relationships (onlyfans) as far more integral to incels and anti-social males than firearms. Sex work is commonly targeting at arms-length as "sex trafficking" - many sex workers commonly complain of this law enforcement "trope". However, the bright line of what is/isn't sexually predatory or supporting aspects of pedophillia are becoming more gray with sites like onlyfans. For instance, do we really want young women to only see immediate value in exposing their bodies on the internet for $5 a mo? (Ironically, less money than you'd donate to a charity to feed a child in africa) Just my 2c.
- wnoise 4y ago> Even as someone who doesn't think the government should tell you how to live, you can't pretend to be blind to the fact of why the government doesn't want to promulgate this kind of promiscuity I can. Make the argument, rather than saying "it's obvious -- you know. Come on, you know. It's obvious." Until the argument is actually made, it can't be engaged with. This just terminates discussion.
- seydor 4y agoThe chargebacks thing must be an urban myth. I would like to see the data, broken down by country
- jeffrallen 4y agoBecause sex sells, except for the upside down world of politics, where anti-sex sells.
- throwaway22032 4y agoMost people (not only the religious) wouldn't want their wife, husband, child, mother, close friends etc to be a prostitute or pornographic artist, in a very emotional sense that goes far beyond e.g. having a low status job. It's completely unsurprising that it's frowned upon.