17 ms·
Florida to Supreme Court: Let us regulate social networks as common carriers
- eddof13 4y ago100% agree with florida here, would be huge for me
- ceejayoz 4y agoWhy would this be huge for you?
- brink 4y agoProbably because his ideas and opinions are actively censored. It's no secret that social media has a heavy bias.
- fallenasleep 4y agoboth sides think "social media" is biased against them; I honestly could not guess which way you think the bias goes
- pessimizer 4y agoThey're biased against something, because they delete legal content.
- nrb 4y agoWho cares that it’s legal though? You’re on their property, committed to abiding by their terms of service even. If you’re hosting a garden party and one of the guests has become disruptive to everyone else, are you not allowed to demand they cease their behavior or leave your property just because their angry ranting is not illegal speech? You’re totally within your right to say “I’m out, this party sucks anyway, you guys don’t want to have honest debate” but it’s a little absurd to force the property owner to allow you to stick around when you are no longer welcome.
- pessimizer 4y agoDo you feel the same way about telephones? How about electricity? Is it out of the realm of possibility that a conscientious electrical supplier might not want to power a racist's computer?
- nrb 4y agoElectricity is analogous to the the road that you traveled on to the way to the party. > Is it out of the realm of possibility that a conscientious electrical supplier might not want to power a racist's computer? Isn’t this the case that these same people are making for why ISPs should NOT be neutral, even though they’re much more like electricity and roads than private garden parties?
- honkler 4y ago
- cowtools 4y agoIf you don't like it, just build your own state. smh.
- epakai 4y agoThis is a first amendment violation. It should be obvious how the state differs from corporate entities or persons.
- ladyattis 4y agoActually, Florida doesn't own the property of the private citizens whether its the network fiber, routers, or buildings which contain these items. If you can't justify such a capricious law then maybe your intention is malicious?
- luckylion 4y agoAnd both Ukraine and Russia say they are being attacked. I think there is real bias (and in the West it's more biased against conservatives and some minority groups while it's different elsewhere, depends mostly on the dominant ideology) and there's faux discrimination to get victim points to trade in for control.
- eddof13 4y agoit aligns with my values on free speech and I think social media platforms should be common carriers and be forced to allow all free speech (aside from fire in a crowded theater)
- triceratops 4y agoEnjoy the deluge of spam
- kelseyfrog 4y agoAs a post-social media accelerationalist, the utter chaos that would result in social media platforms' inability to combat spam would devolve into the inability to exist at all and should be welcomed. Social media's negative externality is our individual mental health. One of the greatest things we could do for our mental health would be a complete and utter implosion of uncensorable social media. It cannot come soon enough.
- cowtools 4y agoI didn't read this whole thing but I agree it would be pretty funny if social media was legally forced to host spam
- triceratops 4y agoI mostly hate social media. But we'd also lose useful things. Such as the discussion board we're currently on. Or the treasure trove of educational and funny content on YouTube. Watching puppy videos is amazing for my mental health. It would be a shame for it to be drowned in spam.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoIt would honestly be better for me if social media categorically ceased to exist. Before anyone responds with, "You could choose not to participate," what I mean is that if they ceased to exist it would increase the supply of the attention and time of others. When I'm competing in time and attention for others with the likes FB/IG/TT I'm simply at the loosing end. I don't have a team of PhDs whose goal it is to increase people's engagement with me - they do. If I have to compete at all, I'd much rather compete with other people - not against professionals.
- acomjean 4y agoI guess you’d support no more downvoting or flagging post here either.
- eddof13 4y agofine with downvoting, just no banning or censoring for unpopular opinions
- acomjean 4y agoI’m not sure how that would work. Isn’t enough downvotes the same a censoring as the site isn’t letting your opinion be heard. Dang won’t be able to step in and maintain order. Spam couldn’t be disallowed.
- sixstringtheory 4y agoPeople don't usually get banned for their opinions. They get banned for being jerks. Try enabling showdead. There are some accounts marked as [dead] that I don't get, but the vast, vast majority of flagkilled posts and banned accounts I've seen don't deserve the product of someone else's labor to propagate their speech.
- smaryjerry 4y agoThis is idealistic thinking however there are countless cases where a ban was done by a bad actor or bad algorithm, with the only recourse being a user taking their ban to another platform to complain, and if they gain enough traction on another platform then they get the ban reversed. Unfortunately that only works for large creators while small creators have zero recourse for unjust bans.
- ladyattis 4y agoSo you believe that a website should be regulated in how it manages user access? So if I have a forum for betta fish owners and I don't want spammers or trolls then I must justify my bans to some bureaucrat in DC or the state capital? Seriously, this is why I don't buy there's any good faith behind these laws.
- pfisch 4y agoIf you want to post on 4chan, go post on 4chan. Don't turn the rest of the internet into 4chan so you can force gross ideas and content onto everyone else.
- eddof13 4y agowe should put speed limiters on cars so they can't go faster than 5 mph and endanger someone else
- pfisch 4y agoAre you describing speed limits on roads?
- triceratops 4y agoCars run on public roads. On the other hand if you said that only speed-limited cars are allowed on your property, you would be entirely in the right.
- sixstringtheory 4y agoHyperbole aside, I've ridden in supercars that are equipped with speed limiters in order to be able to drive on public roads legally in the US.
- silisili 4y agoWhat law prevents fast cars in the US? The Tesla roadster claims 250MPH, and there are others street legal up to 300 afaik.
- sixstringtheory 4y agoI must have misremembered, it looks like the cars came from the factory with speed limiters installed. Sorry for the mixup but this actually is a good point to consider, this is a platform moderating as it sees fit, according to their observations on when handling becomes less capable at speed. What Florida wants to do is the equivalent of telling carmakers they cannot put speed limiters on their cars, putting more people in danger. If I want my children to have speed limiters in the cars they drive, well, guess I’d be out of luck! It goes the other way too: it could also be used to force all carmakers to install speed limiters, and never let people even race at a track. As the original commenter I replied to tried to use as a point against the idea. The problem with the way they framed it is they tried to make it seem like allowing platforms to moderate as they see fit removes everyone’s choice, which is the opposite of the outcome.
- protomyth 4y agoWelcome to the natural consequence of social networks becoming important to just do daily business. The phone companies, and other utilities, operate under strict rules. I do wonder how many and type of companies will become internet utilities?
- NovemberWhiskey 4y ago99.5% of Americans could never log into Facebook, Twitter or anything ever again with no substantial impact on their daily lives. The remaining 0.5% have careers centered around social media and should probably find a real job. Honest to goodness, the hyperventilation about how "important" social media is just amazes me.
- smaryjerry 4y agoAnd 100% of people could live without phone companies with no impact to their daily lives, we’ve got internet right? Of course I would be the one defining impact here. You may consider impact to daily lives not substantial, but others see the substantial impact of not being able to reach their family, friends, and customers and the disadvantage that comes with others having that access but you not. It’s not like Facebook actually is making the “social media” you see in your feed, it is 100% carrying social media from users, the same way a phone company aren’t the one making calls.
- scarface74 4y agoAre you really comparing the level of effort of setting a phone company to creating a social media platform or a website to get your ideas out there?
- smaryjerry 4y agoExactly. There is much lower hanging fruit but if you ask someone what is more valuable to their business, phone service or social media, many would choose social media.
- ProAm 4y agoThis would be a terrible precedent. These are private companies, who is the government to tell them how to operate without funding them. If you don't like what you read, or if you read things that are not true that is on you as an individual to make appropriate choices. The government shouldnt meddle with social networks. They are just that, social and voluntary.
- protomyth 4y agoPrivate companies are regulated all the time. Look up the rules for any utility or communications company. They banned politicians, so that's going to get laws passed.
- ProAm 4y agoThey are given massive subsidies from the government to do so. Social networks have nothing to do with infrastructure where as utilities and communications do.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> Social networks have nothing to do with infrastructure where as utilities and communications do Social network and communications have nothing to do with each-other? are you reading what you are writing? How is Facebook messenger call different from a phonecall of the 21st century?
- triceratops 4y agoI only have one or 2 choices of phone carriers with a high cost to switch. I have a multitude of alternatives to FB Messenger (which I don't even use) with very low cost to switch.
- Const-me 4y agoYou can use any phone carrier you want, one of these two real ones, or one of the hundreds of VoIP providers. Regardless on your choice, you can still call the people you want, regardless on their carrier. The only difference is cost per minute, which is typically low cost to switch. It's impossible to use an alternative messenger to communicate with people who use FB messenger. Unlike e-mail providers or phone operators, these newer web services don't have any interoperability, they're closed systems. To switch from Facebook, a person gonna need to convince all people they communicate with to switch as well - to the same alternative messenger. That's very high cost to switch, borderline impossible to do for many people.
- Ekaros 4y agoEntirely reasonable either they are publishers and thus have free speech and carry full penalties for all the content they allow. Or they are carriers and thus should have no say, but also no risks of content.
- nonethewiser 4y agoThey are obviously publishers at this point.
- pessimizer 4y agoNot sure what you mean. Publishers are held responsible for bad content, and they are not. So we're deciding whether we want to make them publishers, make them common carriers, or keep the status quo. ----- edit: my guess as to what they are now is online services who republish submitted third-party content or however section 230 defines them. ----- edit2: An interactive computer service that retransmits material provided by an information content provider. > No provider or user of an interactive computer service shall be treated as the publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider. So they are explicitly and definitively not publishers.
- ceejayoz 4y agohttps://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/12/publisher-or-platform-it-doesnt-matter https://www.eff.org/deeplinks/2020/12/publisher-or-platform-... > We’ll say it plainly here: there is no legal significance to labeling an online service a “platform” as opposed to a “publisher.” Yes. That’s right. There is no legal significance to labeling an online service a “platform.” Nor does the law treat online services differently based on their ideological “neutrality” or lack thereof.
- boardwaalk 4y agoIt’s a little (a lot) frustrating that people are so sloppy with their thoughts (and by relation speech) on this subject. It wouldn’t take that long for people to read up on what section 230 actually is before saying “publisher” like that means anything (is related to anything the law talks about). Laws of course need interpretation, but if people think, “Oh, they’re a ‘publisher’” (whatever that means; they probably couldn’t tell you) “they must be subject to different rules,” they’re frankly just kind of dumb.
- Kerbonut 4y agoI agree and we should classify the underlying Internet service providers, that social media providers depends on, as common carriers as well!
- layer8 4y agoAlso services like Cloudflare, and email providers like GMail.
- case0x00 4y agoI agree, unless the alternative is to break apart the monopolies which I think is better.
- elil17 4y agoIt's unclear to me that email and CDNs are the kinds of natural monopolies that need to be regulated as common carriers
- layer8 4y agoLook what happened to Kiwi Farms, and what happens to people who try to host their own outgoing SMTP server.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoWhat happened to Kiwi Farms was that no-one wanted to do business with them from a risk-management and just general good-moral-fiber basis.
- cowtools 4y agoThe problem is that there are only a handful companies to do business with in the first place. I think what you would expect in a sane market is that they are forced to negotiate a more expensive deal with the remaining service providers due to the supply/demand imbalance. As there are so few service providers here, there's only a few levels of risk-tolerance/good-moral-fiber that you can negotiate on. Activists only need to push a site above the highest risk-tolerance level (which is unnaturally low due to this quantization)
- brk 4y agoThis seems to be centered on politics/candidates, which IMO is the wrong motivation. Politicians really should not have special exemptions or privileges when it comes to free speech issues. Eg: they have exceptions to use robo-calls, text spam, etc. Realistically, we probably need to define when an organization is a media influencer vs. a niche communications platform. I do think Facebook/Twitter/Etc. need to be held to a different level of accountability on things like this than say Tomshardware, or HN.
- nonethewiser 4y agoThe law applies to social media sights with > 100,000 monthly active users.
- pessimizer 4y ago> This seems to be centered on politics/candidates, which IMO is the wrong motivation. Because political censorship is the worst censorship (you might argue that all censorship is political.) It's like how political prisoners are the easiest sign a place is a dictatorship. If the powerful are censoring the political process, there are no means to make any of the powerful less powerful. It becomes self-perpetuating.
- marcosdumay 4y agoPolitical speech is not "speech made by politicians".
- pessimizer 4y agoWho are you quoting, and why aren't you replying to them?
- brk 4y agoBut at the same time, politicians using social media to continuously publish blatant lies is also not a mechanism for stable government. In the past, this was regulated to a large degree by traditional media outlets being a filter of sorts and not just printing any random direct statement made by a politician. I think there is a balance between "social media must not interfere with blatantly false statements from politicians" and "social media can ban their political detractors without consequence". The ideal reality would be the public actually holding politicians responsible for being deceptive or treasonous, but that does not appear to be on the horizon either.
- vdnkh 4y ago[flagged]
- Mattasher 4y agoAt this point we need to recognize that these "private companies" are now de facto state actors. They take censorship advice from government agencies (like the CDC), ban certain people in response to political pressures, and hand over user's private data without a warrant. That doesn't mean regulating them like common carries is good or workable, but we need to start by recognizing that there are first amendment claims on both sides now.
- fallenasleep 4y agothe big ones are also global companies who operate in many countries (and cooperate with many countries' law enforcement). For me, the better metaphor is to think of them as virtual governments of virtual territories
- Mattasher 4y agoThis seems like a better analogy than "private companies", but then where does that lead you in terms of how they should be treated? No snark here, genuine question.
- aNoob7000 4y agoThe problem is finding the right balance between free speech and censorship. I look forward to see how cases that go to the Supreme Court are going to be handled. I personally believe that a private business like Facebook has the right to control content on their app/website.
- HotGarbage 4y ago
- buildbot 4y agoI’ll ask the same question I asked on the other threads to all those cheering this - do you think HN will be the same without moderation? Or just another 4chan? Will r/conservative stop banning users who dare suggest trump was maybe not such a good person, even if they are otherwise extremely conservative?
- klyrs 4y agoIf HN and other forums are doomed to become 4chan, it would probably be a net positive in my life. I waste too much time here.
- brobinson 4y agoWhy do people associate 4chan with not having moderation? It's always had moderators ("jannies"), and they are a common target of disdain. /g/ is far more entertaining than HN.
- buildbot 4y agoI would say it is less moderated, but to be frank I really don’t have any data and I don’t spend time there.
- honkdaddy 4y ago4chan is as or more heavily moderated than most of reddit, I'm not sure where you get the idea it's not. 4chan culture is the way it is largely because of the demographic of its users, it doesn't really much to do with its moderation policies.
- klyrs 4y agoMeanwhile, Florida is purging libraries of unpopular political opinions. This is not about a principled approach to free speech. It's about protecting the right to enforce religious-inspired bigotry, tearing down the separation of church and state even as that bigotry becomes "unpopular."
- case0x00 4y agoTo what are you referring?
- klyrs 4y agoThere is a "satire[1]" meme floating with some disinformation about book bans in Florida. However, the state is second, only behind Texas, in actual book bans[2]. Relatedly, the vague "don't say gay" law has a significant impact on LGBTQ teachers right to free expression -- straight teachers are totally free to talk about their spouses, for example, but gay teachers are not. Quite reminiscent of the "don't ask don't tell" policy. [1] https://www.poynter.org/fact-checking/2022/a-viral-list-of-banned-books-in-florida-is-satire/ https://www.poynter.org/fact-checking/2022/a-viral-list-of-b... [2] https://floridapolitics.com/archives/557111-florida-second-only-to-texas-in-banning-school-books-as-number-of-bans-rises-report-finds/ https://floridapolitics.com/archives/557111-florida-second-o...
- zdragnar 4y agoWhat's struck me as weird about this is that I don't recall a single teacher ever mentioning their spouse, or their personal weekend plans. The idea that a teacher wants to talk to their students about their personal lives is utterly foreign to me. Maybe it's just a sign of times changing? Edit: this thought came to me in the context of a quote I saw from a teacher upset he couldn't talk about going surfing with his husband. There was a wide enough income gap in our school that teachers talking about vacations was frowned upon, since you never really knew which kids didn't actually ever get to go on vacations, etc.
- 4y ago
- sanp 4y agoIsn’t it up to Congress to legislate this? Or, is the hope that the current SC will make law?
- chrismcb 4y agoThe supreme court can't make laws.
- bell-cot 4y agoIANAL, and have not read Florida's law, but it sounds ripe for abuse by trolls: 1 - Become a political candidate (even if a write-in for some bottom-end office in a tiny municipality) 2 - Register with social networks as a Florida-protected candidate 3 - Spend all your time spewing hate at people you don't like. Maybe automate that, to get both far more spewing and far more free time.
- danaris 4y ago...and this is where the difference between law and code kicks in, as the social networks ban you, and when you sue under this law, the courts say, "but everyone knows they only meant real political candidates; you know, from one of the two parties that can actually win elections".
- bell-cot 4y agoYou might want to look into how easy it can be to become a real "major party" candidate, for a minor office, in a small municipality. Especially if "your" major party is the "no hope" party in a dyed-in-wool municipality, or you're just a primary candidate. Or the party understands that you'll mostly be spewing hate at people they hate. And if the social networks are forced to follow this Florida law, and Mr. A. Troll De Vile was spewing hate at the politicians behind the law...might some social networks feel "deepest frustration" that they were, alas, legally barred from banning Mr. De Vile?
- pwinnski 4y agoHi from Texas, where real-life candidates belonging to one of the two major political parties spew open hate and then win office.
- starik36 4y agoAs long as the speech is protected under the 1st amendment, it is irrelevant what they are "spewing".
- 8note 4y agoOr 3. Spend all your time advertising for whichever business pays you the most
- fzeroracer 4y agoIt should be incredibly obvious to just about anyone that this sort of law is untenable and would just lead to social media companies either completely banning anyone from Florida from posting on their platform or putting them into their own special space completely separated from the rest of the world. Someone in Florida will issue a terrorism threat that goes afoul of European laws or something and social media platforms will sooner side with the rest of the world than Florida. And how is Florida going to have any standing to try and sue a company in compliance that does not operate in or offer service to Florida? It's the same as what's going down in Texas. Never mind that as another commentator mentioned these same state governments are also busy burning books and censoring other individuals so it's not a matter of equal freedom. They want the ability to threaten minorities.
- paxys 4y agoWhen a state is against net neutrality, pro super PACs, pro hobby lobby/religious tests in employment, pro book banning in libraries, but wants to regulate social networks because "political freedom", their motivations are a bit suspect.
- munk-a 4y agoAt the same time - this one move might make Florida accidentally the most progressive state in America.
- scarface74 4y agoThe same Florida that passed a law specifically to punish Disney because they spoke out against the “Don’t Say Gay” law and passed the “Stop Woke” act?
- munk-a 4y agoI suppose I should've added some more overt humor markers on the above statement.
- pyuser583 4y agoLack of humor markers is a downside of text communication.
- anon291 4y agoThey punished Disney by not granting them self governing status. In my world, corporations being subject to the government is the Hallmark of progressivism. But no one's actually paying attention to the actual actions, just their own view of the motivation
- sircastor 4y agoThe Disney properties were already self-governing. The Florida legislature revoked that in political retaliation, and passed the cost on to nearby counties.
- Jemm 4y agoFunny how they care now when they feel oppressed.
- duxup 4y agoProtection only provided to politicians … I guess some are more equal than others…
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- jedberg 4y agoThere are several types of common carriers. One are transportation companies (including companies that transport electronic communication). The key differentiator between those and social media are that the content is private. So while they have to carry anything, the content of what they are carrying is from one party to another, and the carrier may not even know what it is. So that model shouldn't apply to social media. The other type are broadcasters, like TV and Radio. But the way those are regulated, they don't have to show anyone's content all the time. They get to choose what content is shown, but also be liable for the content being shown. But then there are cable companies. Which carry multiple broadcast channels. And they are not liable for the content on the channels they carry, nor do they have to carry all channels. What they do have to do however is set aside some of their capacity for public access. This is how social media should be regulated. They can choose what channels (broadcasters) they want to carry, and the broadcaster is liable for content. Funny enough, this is already how social media works! The only change would be every social media being forced to add a section that is unmoderated for "public access" in which they would not be liable for the content. I imagine that would go about as well as you'd expect. It would be filled with child porn, hate messages, and the occasional unpopular political opinion.
- webmobdev 4y agoYour analogy about tech platforms being similar to cable companies which broadcast multiple channel is not correct as the tech platforms also host these "channels" / content and it is the internet which enables their distribution. So if they host these content, and want to decide what content should be disseminated, they are actually acting like TV / Radio media platforms. In which case, they need to accept the liability for the content they disseminate, just like any TV or radio business have to. But obviously tech companies do not want to bear this burden. Online platforms are both communication platforms for private communication and public broadcast platforms like TV and Radio. Just apply the existing laws and regulations to both these aspects. If they don't want any liability, then they should be treated as common carriers who have to be neutral to the content that flows on their platform - let the content producer be liable. Ofcourse, this means anonymous content cannot be allowed.
- Buttons840 4y agoThey're doing it at the wrong layer. Make the internet a common carrier and maybe regulate AWS (etc) to ensure everyone can host their own websites somewhere. How can social media be a common carrier when it cannot be accessed through a common carrier? It feels like we're fighting to have our one sentence displayed among the ads, while giving up the ability to create our own webpages and platforms.
- krapp 4y ago>Make the internet a common carrier and maybe regulate AWS (etc) to ensure everyone can host their own websites somewhere Everyone already can host their own websites somewhere, AWS isn't even required.
- andrew_ 4y agoThat's a great angle, hasn't thought about it like that. I'm not sure it solves the "stack" problem that alternatives would face. Would that go so far as to regulate payment processors that are accepting and handling payments via internet?
- bergenty 4y agoWhile actively campaigning against any form of net neutrality which is the layer on which this argument should be made. The GOP are transparent, politically pukeworthy cretins at this point. Just thinking about them makes me want to spit.
- favflam 4y agoI think the Chinese have something to teach us. Basically, once a social network surpasses say, 20M users, it becomes a defacto political entity, with the power to move elections. Given this immense power, the government should regulate accordingly. Instead of passing detailed regulations though, I am of the opinion that if a company passes 200B USD in enterprise value, that Congress should get the right to appoint 50% of the board of directors. This way, the company's responsibilities match its defacto political power to sway elections. Basically, make Facebook into an Amtrak or USPS. If Facebook does not like this idea, then they can split the company into pieces. Additional benefit: this functions also as anti-trust regulation. Amazon would be subject to this as well.
- kweingar 4y agoWhy stop at the board? Why not have the government actually buy half of the company? Then the government can profit as well, like a sovereign wealth fund
- favflam 4y agoMy suggestions and implication of the suggestion is that companies will split themselves before they reach this level. Anti trust if you will. If no anti trust, then become a federal agency.
- caf 4y agoSo your solution to the worry that large social networks have the power to move elections, is to put that power in the hands of the people with the most incentive to move elections?
- favflam 4y agoBetter Congress that operates under the US constitutions and bi-annual elections than shareholders, no? I don’t want to put words in your mouth, so correct me if I am wrong. You are saying that shareholders ought to hold this immense power that say Facebook has to move elections?
- jupp0r 4y agoSo do I get my daily Wall Street Journal Op-Ed slot now or can they still choose who they let publish on their platform and who not?
- jmull 4y agoIt would be pretty funny, in a terrible way, if the First Amendment was gutted in the name of free speech. I'm somewhat amazed at how poorly the people in favor of this understand what appeal these social networks was to let them grow large in the first place. Isn't it obvious that it wasn't by letting everyone post anything? We've had that all along. No need to force social networks to do what has already always been an option (go ahead and start that personal blog and post all your thoughts on it). But of course, that's not what the politicians mean. They use the words "common carrier" to make it sound like they aren't doing what they are actually doing: attempting to force social media companies to be megaphones for the political messages of the politicians. De facto state media. The very opposite of free speech and the first amendment. It would be laughable if the Supreme Court was principled.
- Helmut10001 4y agoI would say it is not possible to change social networks at this stage, they need to be replaced with something new. What this could be? Maybe the Matrix protocol [1], already connecting 40 Million users worldwide. There are various tools that use the Protocol already in a web-context, e.g. Cactus Comments [2] or the Matrix cerulean test [3]. Maybe something else. [1]: https://spec.matrix.org/latest/ https://spec.matrix.org/latest/ [2]: https://gitlab.com/cactus-comments https://gitlab.com/cactus-comments [3]: https://matrix.org/blog/2020/12/18/introducing-cerulean https://matrix.org/blog/2020/12/18/introducing-cerulean
- anon291 4y agoAs much as I dislike facebook. Florida is going about this the wrong way. States should simply ban social media, especially for children. It should simply be illegal or highly restricted. Sounds harsh, but the world would be a better place. Also, government agencies and political candidates should be banned from interacting on social media that is not federated. That is it. Unfortunately, politicians don't understand the meaning of federated. This should be done as an anti-trust action, and facebook should be broken up. Twitter should also be broken up, but it is an utterly useless product, so probably just liquidated. Social media should be for trashy pursuits, not serious discourse. Those should be done on open fora. Hacker news as well ought to be federated.
- tinus_hn 4y agoOf course the HackerNews hive mind can’t stand for this! But when someone pops up to complain about his essential social network account being banned on some flimsy pretext everyone agrees that that shouldn’t be legally possible!
- ladyattis 4y agoThese laws just make no sense to me. First, a website is a website is a website. Whether it's Google, Facebook, or your granny's knitting blog. You can't just say because one website has X features of interaction and Y number of unique users that it must be handled differently than others as it makes the delineation arbitrary and flimsy. There has to be a basis to say Facebook must be given extra supervision by the state that makes it clear that Facebook is not alone in its own functionality. If Facebook were made the special case then it leads to making convoluted laws that are hard to decide on. Second, as some have already said, this is the wrong level of the Internet to manage such a concept of common carrier. Facebook isn't in the business of actually routing data between two points on the internet. Facebook handles internal data on its own internal networks that connect up to the core of the internet which then that core connects to all the edge networks (consumer facing ISPs). This approach is better as it means there's no arbitrary singling out of one provider over another (Comcast vs some random rural co-op) due to political climate. Everyone gets the same process, everyone has the same burden or benefit. Third, this is all political theater in an age that frankly doesn't really make sense to me. How is this exactly going to get the core voters of Republicans out to the ballot box? I just see this as over the top nonsense.