20 ms·
YouTube’s ‘dislike’ barely works according to new study on recommendations
- dredmorbius 4y agoThis article is a discussion of a study Mozilla published ... without a dateline, though the Wayback Machine suggests it probably appeared 20 Sept. 2022 (today): <https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/youtube/user-controls/ https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/youtube/user-controls/> That was previously submitted to HN though there seems to be no activity presently: <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32910321 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32910321>
- operator-name 4y agoThe linked report [0] is dated today and uses data from the RegretsReporter extension [1] and additional surveys from December 2021, which is basically when youtube removed the dislike counter [2]. It's both suprising and not that suprising to see quantitatively how little disliking or telling youtube to not reccomend channels or content has an impact on the algorithm. They also rightfully point out how much of a pain it is to try to provide negative feedback to youtube's reccomendation system. It's always been a chore to remove the hot new trending clickbait from the reccomendations. I sadly doubt that this report will change much, but it's good to finally have some statistical validation of what I've frustrating subjectively experienced. [0]: https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/research/library/user-controls/report/ https://foundation.mozilla.org/en/research/library/user-cont... [1]: https://addons.mozilla.org/en-GB/firefox/addon/regretsreporter/ https://addons.mozilla.org/en-GB/firefox/addon/regretsreport... [2]: https://blog.youtube/news-and-events/update-to-youtube/ https://blog.youtube/news-and-events/update-to-youtube/
- dredmorbius 4y agoThanks for the date confirmation, I'd not dug that far through Mozilla's links. I'd encourage them to make that information more apparent earlier in the link-train. And yeah, agreed on YouTube's algo-feedback uselessness, and the value of solid data substantiating general impressions (mine as well).
- PaulHoule 4y agoIt’s been a while since I’ve logged into YouTube but my impression is that the experience including recommendations is worse if you are logged in.
- eimrine 4y agoBest YT experience is to clear cookies then open a lot of YT links from HN, but when our human nature drives us watching a stupid video or two from YT recommendation then after that session do clearing cookies and open YT links from HN again.
- hombre_fatal 4y agoYou can delete individual videos from your watch history in the history tab to remove them from recommendation basis. Unlike the “Don’t show me videos like this” button, it works well.
- dredmorbius 4y agoUsing YT via Incognito or Firefox containers, with frequently-cleared cookies, and using search as a primary discovery method ... works OK... It's not great, but it's not terrible. The recency bias means that whatever terms you're searching become prevalent for that session. It's not possible to dismiss items or channels (idiotic on YT's part IMO), but you can at least create a short-lived preference instance unpolluted by any previous explorations.
- HeckFeck 4y agoJust don't try the YouTube search and scroll down by more than six results, it will make you scream inside.
- dr-detroit 4y ago
- dredmorbius 4y agoThat was my experience years ago when I last did so. Logging in offered no visible upsides and multiple downs. I learned not to log in and use search wherever possible. Now I use Invidious (with JS disabled and/or uMatrix blocking YouTube functionality in the browser as an additional nudge), or youtube-dl / ytdl / mpv to play video directly. Usually audio-only for talkpieces. I'll also disable recommendations and comments portions of the website, for additional bonus (via Stylus).
- HardwareLust 4y agoYouTube doesn't seem to understand my preferences, at all. It's far, far too biased toward what you recently watched. It basically doesn't work and certainly doesn't "learn" anything.
- beart 4y agoI feel like every recommendation service works this way - YouTube, Amazon, Spotify, etc. Whatever the last thing you looked at becomes your entire life's mission according to these systems. When I think about all the buzz words around machine learning, ai, and so on, it's completely incompatible with the reality I see. What exactly are all these engineering teams doing just to end up with this result? Amazon might be the worst example though. Buy something like a bike rack for your vehicle and Amazon will recommend nothing but other bike racks... as though I need dozens of them for one car.
- Arrath 4y agoAmazon really, really likes to recommend me a wide variety of shower curtains after buying one, 4 years ago. Give it a rest already.
- HeckFeck 4y ago> Buy something like a bike rack for your vehicle and Amazon will recommend nothing but other bike racks... as though I need dozens Perhaps they beta tested only with Jeff Bezos who had this exact quandary.
- tus666 4y agoBut at least the "not interested" option works well, at least for me.
- amatecha 4y agoThis reminds me of how games (coughLeagueOfLegendscough) match me up with a player that I literally just reported for harassment, griefing etc. in the previous match. Like, there weren't any other possible players to match me with out of the many thousands? I don't mind waiting a few more seconds to match up with someone else! I'm getting a lot of responses as if I expect the player to be totally blocked from matching with me, but that's not really what I mean. Even a basic "temporary match score reduction" would work. I would also expect a cooldown system where the reduction caused by reporting no longer applies. Arguing against the idea "because it creates a prisoner's island" misses the subtlety of a well-thought-out implementation where reporting simply lowers the matchup "rank" for a while, and serial-false-reporters have their reports basically nullified/ignored.
- lupire 4y agoDid you Block or just report?
- dannyw 4y agoIt shouldn't matter.
- judge2020 4y agoDota 2 added a (paid) “avoid player” option, where the matchmaker will not match them with you no matter what. It's definitely possible. https://win.gg/news/dota-2-avoid-player-feature-improved-as-long-as-fans-pay-up/ https://win.gg/news/dota-2-avoid-player-feature-improved-as-...
- account42 4y agoGreat, another incentive for developers to make the game less fun until you pay up.
- proteal 4y agoOverwatch had a feature where you could avoid players, but a top sniper was avoided by enough top players that he could never find a match. The matchmaking system could never find him a match because almost all potential matches had at least one player on each team that had him avoided. The devs eventually reworked that feature so that he could play the game. Sometimes seemingly innocuous features have weird edge cases! Even for an average player, adding an avoid player feature would ultimately make matchmaking take longer. It necessarily reduces the number of valid matchings of players, so the system will only be slower. My guess is that average queue time is an important metric that management does not want to increase. It’s an especially tough sell because if you really wanted fresh players in your game, you could always not queue for a few minutes and you will almost certainly get all-new teammates.
- makosdv 4y agoI'm not surprised by this. I gave up on the YouTube Home page, etc. years ago and I only look at the Subscriptions page. I've just found new channels to subscribe to through word of mouth over the years and I have more than enough content to choose from.
- kache_ 4y agoWhich is actually quite a good way to find youtube channels! I find them through twitter, 4ch, and friends.
- jdmdmdmdmd 4y ago>twitter, 4ch, and friends I was under the impression that these three are mutually exclusive to each other
- dchftcs 4y agoMaybe that's the point..
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- laweijfmvo 4y agoSame, but deep down I know that the chronological subscriptions page will be taken away soon, and that’s when I’ll stop using youtube except for direct links to videos.
- TheAceOfHearts 4y agoThe trick to improving YouTube recommendations is to regularly prune uninteresting videos and channels. Eventually this should start surfacing videos you're more likely to find interesting. I've actually hit the end of my recommendation stream on the mobile app after marking dozens of videos with Not Interested. Once this happens it starts recommending videos you've already watched or older videos from creators you've been watching lately. Personally, I'd love it if you could curate the recommendation system a bit more. I'm never interested in rewatching stuff I've already seen. And the recency bias for recommendations means you're always getting more if what you've recently consumed. I'd like it if more older interests were mixed in. Finally, I'd love to be able to blacklist certain topics and games entirely. There's so much missed potential with YouTube recommendations. Some might say that you can still use search, but that has been crippled to include unrelated recommendations after one page of results. Not only that, I want YouTube to help me discover new content. When the recommendation system works and it shows me new kinds of interesting stuff, it's superb. TikTok is eating YouTube's lunch in this regard. Edit: forgot to mention this. On mobile if you do a recommendation refresh it'll show a New to You filter which you can use to explore more diverse recommendations. I don't know why it's hidden in this manner.
- zoltar 4y agoI've done this aggressively in the past. The effect is so poor it's absolutely not worth the effort. I honestly couldn't imagine writing a system worse than their current recommendations. Straight up random would be a better system in some situations.
- svnpenn 4y ago> I'm never interested in rewatching stuff I've already seen. thats a weird position. The whole point of YouTube (used to be anyway) was long form content. YouTube is not new anymore. You really have no interest in watching some good 10 minute video you saw 9 years ago?
- teh_klev 4y agoI also don't want to be recommended videos I've already watched. If it's something I might want to see again then I save it in a playlist, I don't need YouTube pestering me to re-watch old stuff.
- behaveEc0n00 4y agoThe zeitgeist of our culture; of course you didn’t MEAN to be negative, here try again. No, no; I most certainly did mean to suggest you should stop showing me this persons channel. Not because I hate the person but because I don’t want a shit “AI” that’s feeding me what Google makes the best margins on.
- ehsankia 4y agoWhat I find interesting is the duality of YouTube criticism. On the one hand, YouTube should respect people's like and dislikes to a letter, but also at the same time YouTube pushes people into dark echo chamber rabbit holes by only giving them what they want. On the the one hand they need to stop accidentally taking down innocent videos, but also need to take down bad videos faster. People don't realize that all these issues are two sides of the same coin. They complain on each side separately and don't understand why optimizing for one messes up the other.
- stemlord 4y ago> feeding me what Google makes the best margins on. Lol exactly, Google and I disagree on a fundamental level, they cannot be the ones to do the work to find what I like, which is why I've disappeared the entire right-hand column on yt altogether with in extension
- JohnFen 4y agoYouTube's recommendation system is pretty terrible anyway, so that's not surprising.
- mrkramer 4y agoIn practice it doesn't work in the short term but it should work in the long term because Google processes so much data with billions of data points so their algorithms need some time to catch up. Sad but true. The same situation is with search ranks; they update their ranking index every few months or so according to billions of data points they gather with the final word of ranking algorithms. Basically every big internet service runs on algorithms. You name it: Ebay, Amazon, Google, Facebook, TikTok, Netflix, Spotify etc.
- JohnFen 4y ago> In practice it doesn't work in the short term but it should work in the long term In practice, it doesn't work in the long term either. I've been using YouTube regularly for many years.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nostromo 4y agoYouTube likes and dislikes are now pretty similar to Facebook likes. It's not there to help you, the user. It's there to make the content creator feel popular. That's why YouTube removed dislike numbers and Facebook never had it to begin with. It's mostly window dressing.
- umeshunni 4y agoNot driving my car today has no effect on global warming a to my house. Temperatures today were barely changed from yesterday, according to researchers at Mozilla.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- SkyMarshal 4y agoI never use dislike, just "Not interested" or "Don't recommend channel". Those seem to work as advertised.
- mod 4y agoI do the same, and I agree, they seem to work. What pisses me off, though, is that if I get a video recommended, I can ignore it for days, sometimes over a week, and it stays in the recommendations unless I "Not Interested" it. After I've chosen...lots of other videos, maybe it's time to stop recommending that one. Often it's a video I've already seen, and enjoyed. I hate doing "not interested" to those. I also hate doing the work of it all. I would blame the algo or whatever, but I actually think the algo is working exactly how Google wants it to.
- throwawayallday 4y agoI wish they kept the dislike count visible. It was a useful signal that's saved me hours of my life.
- sophacles 4y agoHuh, so google can't figure out what people like? In possibly related news, google is shutting down surveys.
- washywashy 4y agoI attended a conference a few years back where a lead ML/data scientist at a big company you’ve heard of and probably use said the dislike button was ignored in favor of this: did you watch and engage with the content.
- hiimshort 4y agoThis lines up with my experience and continued frustration with YouTube. I use the service a lot whether it be for background noise, research, and so on. The recommendations have been awful (doubly so in Shorts) regardless of how many videos I dislike or categories of channels I choose to stop recommendations of. My only question then is: how do I know if I dislike a video if I haven't watched it? Sometimes I can leave a video early, but others I will have to watch for a bit before realizing it is a waste of time. This is more pronounced with Shorts due to the duration of videos. I will end up watching something that is 20 seconds long to see what it was about (you never know when you will find a gem), but then dislike it once it is finished. YouTube just keeps recommending low quality garbage until I get fed up with it and spam "Do not recommend channel" the moment a video shows up.
- Sophistifunk 4y agoWhy is everybody pretending the recommendation system is designed to show you what you want to see, rather than to maximise ad revenue?
- bricemo 4y agoAgree. This study is assuming the intent of the feature is to remove those types of videos. In reality the intent is to use it as one of many signals to make better ML recommendations. Oftentimes, there are also differences in revealed and stated preferences.
- kilroy123 4y agoI assume this because I pay and don't see ads.
- harry8 4y agoYou are in a minority. Why do you think they built their recommendation system with you in mind at all? You've already paid, you no longer impact the fit of the short term revenue maximization objective function.
- maroonblazer 4y agoI suspect daily/weekly/monthly active users and minutes viewed are a metric they're interested in maximizing. That would be incentive to optimize the recommendation system for paid users too.
- Kbelicius 4y agoI think that, concerning paid users, what they would be interested in would just be daily/weekly/monthly paying users. As for minutes watched they'd be incentivized to reduce it as far as it is possible while still retaining a paying user. After all, they don't show more ads if a paying user watches more minutes of video. At least not yet.
- 4y ago
- londons_explore 4y agoLong ago, tech giant CEO's realised that recommendation systems are very powerful. They can trick hundreds of millions of users into spending double digit percentages of their life watching memes. From that point on, focus was reduced on working on recommenders. Instead the goal was not to trick users into spending their whole life on the platform, but to maximize ad revenue from those users in the limited time they did spend on the platform. The one party that wasn't part of this was tiktok. And that's why they have stolen so much user share.
- dmix 4y agoI find both TikTok's and Youtube's algorithms show me highly relevant and interesting content. The idea that it only shows you memes seems to come from people who a) dont actually use these services more deeply than surface level interactions or b) they are actually watching low-quality memes (meaning finishing more than 75% of the videos) so Youtube/TikTok is simply showing them what they previously indicated they are interested in. When I bought Youtube premium I started using it much more seriously (meaning curating subscriptions, marking things as "Not Interested", and actually following up on my notification feed when new videos get released) and I've been amazed at the level of quality it delivers. It learns exactly what you like and dislike. And no it doesnt force feed me politics or ragebait like Reddit and Twitter - both of which do in spite of my efforts to curate them. TikTok took a bit of time investment at first but now it shows me HN-style tech stuff, highly local restaurant recommendations, nerdy film stuff, etc. I never see dancing teenagers and I don't think I ever saw them after the first day I used TikTok.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lunarmony 4y agoWhat makes you believe TikTok's goal is not to trick users into spending their whole lives on the platform?
- flenserboy 4y agoImproved recommendations would be nice, but the ability to exclude specific channels from ever appearing in recommendations or search results would be fantastic. The amount of litter on YT is extraordinary.
- mikrl 4y agoI didn’t like when they removed the dislike counts, and I still don’t like it. When I look for videos of folks working on Subarus, I don’t want to have to manually scrub through the video to gauge the quality. Before I’d just look at the ratio and if I was feeling generous I’d preview the frames to see if they had what I wanted. Now it takes me at least 2 mins longer to get to the same judgement which begs the question of why I’m watching a video when I have a book on my lap and a car waiting outside.
- mdcds 4y agoI've been using Return Youtube Dislike addon for Firefox. Idk how accurate it is, but you can gauge the sentiment (mostly positive, mixed, mostly negative)
- donio 4y agoI believe that uses a separate database that was seeded from scraped youtube data but now it's only updated by those who use the addon. So it would have a much smaller sample size for recent activity.
- jobigoud 4y agoI'm not sure about this because when going through Youtube shorts I regularly see videos with +100K dislikes, and any "viral" video has dozens of thousands of dislikes. I don't think this many users installed an extension to bring back dislikes and happened to dislike these particular videos.
- Doxin 4y agoThe extension estimates the "true" dislike count based on the like/dislikes it has in its database. E.g. if the database contains 100 dislikes and 900 likes, but the video has a million views, it'll estimate 1000 dislikes. I'm sure there's some cleverness in there for videos where it doesn't have a tonne of information yet.
- 4y ago
- micromacrofoot 4y agoI often wonder if the people who work at youtube actually use youtube.
- tomphoolery 4y agoYouTube: (removes the ability to see dislikes) Also YouTube: "dislike barely works!"
- dvhh 4y agoTo be fair, it is mozilla saying to youtube that "dislike barely works"
- tonfreed 4y agoEvery other day YouTube seems to want to give me another American local news channel, despite the fact I'm in Australia. I've marked them as "don't recommend" as I've seen them, but I'm still getting a lot of results for Fox Local Clapistan 7 all the time which just aren't relevant to me at all.
- robswc 4y agoHonestly, I feel like YouTube recommendation is the _only_ good thing YouTube has lol. I often see a ton of complaints about the recommendations but I've honestly never had an issue. I know that yes, you click on one video and now all the sudden you get 100s of that type... but it sorta works for me since it seems like that "effect" wears off just as fast as it starts. For example, I have a friend that's into cars. I watched a few car videos and then 50% of my recommendations were car videos. It works for me though, because usually those videos are genuinely interesting. I haven't watched one in weeks tho, so going to my home I see 0 car related videos. I will 100% believe everyone though when they say it just doesn't work for them. Just wanted to share my experience.
- crazygringo 4y agoYup, works fantastically for me as well. I almost never go to my subscriptions because every new video I want to see is right there on the home page. I super love the categories at the top too. If I want all cooking videos instead of just 2, it's a single click. It's really neat to see it use machine learning to tell me what my ~15 top topics are. And it's entirely correct.
- nitwit005 4y agoThere is some incentive to want you to watch car videos in that situation, as someone with a recent automotive interest is an ideal person to show car ads to.
- robswc 4y agoTrue. I do have premium though (hopefully that doesn't make a difference) + adblocker so I never get traditional ads. Another example though... I just watched a few videos about fake self help gurus and influencers. I now have 3/10 recommended videos about that. 2/10 a random meme (which do look funny, tbf) and then the rest are subs.
- donio 4y agoNot sure what we are doing differently but for me it's pretty much random and useless. It seems to be a mix of mostly old videos from channels I follow anyway and random junk I am not interested in. I am sure I could find something new and interesting in there if I looked long enough but the signal/noise ratio is very low. Old account with thousands of views and likes/dislikes.
- vxNsr 4y agoAnyone else find it odd that we’re doing 3rd party studies on a programmed algorithm?
- Bakary 4y agoI think it's alarming in the sense that it highlights the Google monopoly. But what do you find odd about it?
- dredmorbius 4y agoHow else would you suggest this be done? Self-reporting is strongly subject to bias. YouTube/Google have long been non-credible in reporting on their own activities. I've had some experience with this myself, as a third-party researcher: <https://ello.co/dredmorbius/post/naya9wqdemiovuvwvoyquq https://ello.co/dredmorbius/post/naya9wqdemiovuvwvoyquq>
- not1ofU 4y agoI noticed that when youtube implemented the auto-play feature on the homepage, whereby you hover the mouse over a vid, it expands slightly and starts to autoplay the vids, that it actually puts the vids in to your watch history, even if you only watched a few (2-3) seconds. After this i noticed that my recommendations got crappier almost instantly. Basically, I would see something with a 'nice' tumbnail and hover it. Since then, everytime I open youtube, i need to go into the preferences and disable that shit, so not to pollute my history, and thus pollute my recommendations. I clear cookies when browser closes and this setting doesnt get saved, for some reason, google isnt smart enough to save these settings / preferences to my account like all the other setting, oh no, its controlled by a cookie. This may have already been scailed back abit since I first noticed it, so maybe not 100% accuarate anymore, still pisses me off.
- jiggawatts 4y agoWhat a lot of people are missing is that when watching YouTube, they're the product, not the consumer. I know this has been said many times before, but ignoring this reality is like trying to understand life without considering evolution, or understanding chemistry while ignoring the periodic table. Google's incentives are to tailor customers to advertisers, not customers to content! They don't care if you see what you want to see, they care if you see what they want you to see. In that light, it all makes sense.
- vineyardmike 4y agoHow does that at all relate to YouTube videos though? YouTube wants you to see ads. Ads are put in front of YouTube videos. Therefore youtube wants you to watch videos. YouTube, logically, should want you to watch more videos, for longer. If they serve you bad videos, you stop. Therefore, Googles incentives are to tailor good recommendations of content for customers. QED. I think all this “you’re not the customer you’re the product” signaling - which is true to an extent- needs an additional corollary of “products aren’t free to acquire or produce” or “businesses can’t exhaust their supply of products to sell”. Because if YouTube truly doesn’t care about serving you relevant videos -as you conjecture-, why not recommend the same 100 videos to everyone? It’s make caching way cheaper.
- ax0ar 4y agoThey are sort of recommending 100 videos to everyone. In my circle, a lot of people I know have very different interests than me. Yet, whenever I recommend a video to a friend, they often say it was already in their recommendations. They might be pushing videos or topics that advertisers are more willing to pay for.
- vineyardmike 4y ago> a lot of people I know have very different interests than me. Yet, whenever I recommend a video to a friend, they often say it was already in their recommendations. Is it possible that Youtube knows your friend's video interests just like you do? > They might be pushing videos or topics that advertisers are more willing to pay for. This, however, does seem very possible.
- Razengan 4y agoIt was never about what you want to see. It’s about what they want you to see. We will just end up back full circle at TV, with the only thing our control being the ability to flip between channels. Seriously, fuck everyone who implements that “Relevant” sorting in searches on every platform, which is usually everything but what you are actually searching for.
- cptnapalm 4y agoI just find channels or playlists I'm interested in, copy-paste the urls into my TubeArchivist and let it handle getting them for me.
- KaoruAoiShiho 4y agoI run https://fiction.live https://fiction.live which has a similar recommendations function as youtube. The key insight here is that dislikes are not the same thing as uninterested. People will dislike stories that they're interested in but think are poorly written or do not have the ending that they want it to have. If you use dislike to mean uninterested you are ruining the recommendations. Rather you need to have a separate button that says do not recommend other content like this. That's what we do and it works out well.
- aantix 4y agoI wrote an app called SmartKid that attempts to curate your YouTube recommendations via disliking videos that match a set of keywords (e.g. Minecraft, mrbeast, reaction). https://smartk.id/ https://smartk.id/ Working on getting my Youtube api quota extended.
- Double_a_92 4y agoInteresting site. But the "Sign up for FREE" button is very sus to the point where it stops me from even trying it. Either it's really free so it should just say "Sign up" or it's not free so there should be a "Pricing" section that I can see before I sign up.
- aantix 4y agoGreat points. I’ll make the changes.
- JetAlone 4y agoJudging by the ads I have been getting lately, Youtube must somehow think I'm a Japanese person who moved to middle America, because I'm getting ads for local businesses I couldn't use if I wasn't living there, like pet grooming centers. Unless of course, there's some malcompetence at play, and youtube is deliberately allowing for the waste of advertising budgets of middle American businesses on people like me, to sabotage them.
- chillfox 4y agoMy recommendations have been filled with crazy conspiracy stuff for months just because I watched some caving/diving disaster videos styled like camp fire stories. I have tried marking videos as not interesting and blocking channels, but there appears to be an endless supply of that stuff. To make it worse it looks like accidentally letting the preview play a few seconds of a video marks the subject as something you are interested in and it can sometimes be near impossible to select a video in the middle of the page without having one of the surrounding videos start a preview. I want good youtubers to be able to make a living and I pay for the YouTube subscription, but this crap is driving me towards setting up Invidious rapidly.
- tgtweak 4y agoDidn't they remove the dislike button? Amusingly, TikTok just implemented a dislike button very recently.
- SicSemperUranus 4y agoThere's still a dislike button, it just doesn't show the like to dislike ratio, so it's barely worth pressing. The outcry at the time seemed to indicate that this is explicitly to appease bigger media companies, who put out crap and don't care what anyone thinks (but do care about what people think other people think).
- Imnimo 4y agoI'd be curious to know how many additional "wanted" recommendations the system is able to serve by not treating a dislike as a strong negative signal. It seems like there's a tradeoff here, where YouTube figures that if it interpreted a dislike with a heavy hand, it would also knock a bunch of videos you do want (or at least they think you want). Presumably from YouTube's perspective, it's more important that your recommendations pane contain at least one video that you want to watch than it is that it contains zero videos you don't want to see. The user's desires are a probably a little more balanced - seeing videos on topics you dislike is annoying even if you don't watch them, and even if there is a single good video mixed in.
- JohnFen 4y agoExcept that when the recommendations are 90% garbage, I'm not going to sift through them to find the occasional gem. That's just burning time for little reward.
- Legion 4y agoThe only way to make YouTube even remotely tolerable is with liberal use of the "Not Interested" and "Don't Recommend Channel" functions. I also set up separate YouTube viewing accounts by interest, so that I can clobber away everything not related to a specific interest in that particular account (eg. anything not sports related gets "Don't Recommend Channel"'d in my Sports YT account). YouTube pretty much fights you tooth and nail the whole way, but eventually your blocking of irrelevant and garbage recommendations leaves them no choice but recommending things related to that interest.
- cortesoft 4y agoI use YouTube, but only direct links or searches. I never use YouTube itself to find my next video
- RockingGoodNite 4y agoI'm almost at this point as well. Using the Not Interested and other tips helps but it's not long before the stuff rolls in not remotely matching my interests.
- fastball 4y agoI just use this Chrome extension[1] (though actually with Brave for the ad-blocking) and don't worry about recs at all. When I want to watch a YouTube video I go on YouTube and am given a list of recent uploads by my subscribed channels. I pick one, watch it, then usually close the tab because there are no recs on the screen to lead me on an endless rabbit hole. [1] https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/unhook-remove-youtube-rec/khncfooichmfjbepaaaebmommgaepoid https://chrome.google.com/webstore/detail/unhook-remove-yout...
- popcalc 4y agoI was wondering recently if a thing like this existed. This is exactly what I was wishing for!
- imiric 4y ago
- benknight87 4y agoI wish I could set YouTube to open my subscriptions feed instead of "the algorithm" by default.
- ax0ar 4y agoCopy the url for the subscription page and add it as a new search engine with a shortcut like "y" if you are using Chrome or a Chrome based browser. Then you can just go to the address bar and type y + enter. A fast way of getting to the address bar is CTRL + L (CMD + L on mac).
- ax0ar 4y agoI hope we will get a good alternative to YouTube. The amount of negative feedback from its audience has been increasing at a very fast pace, and Google doesn't seem to care at all. At this point, I'm thinking they are very deliberately choosing to take this path. For what reason? I don't know. But it seems like Google really don't want people to discover any good content and force users to watch a very select collection of videos. My circle and friends are basically all watching similar content to what I'm watching, and I have almost no common interests with some of them..
- subtract-smiles 4y agoI've found that the algorithm can be extremely volatile for some things and barely react to others. I watch half of one video by a 'pop' youtuber like MrBeast or LazarBeam and that's the only recommendations I get for a week. Likewise, I can spend hours and hours listening to more passive content like music or long-form documentary style videos and I barely see any bump in that kind of content recommended for me. The most effective tweaking methods to the algorithm I've found is just subscribing to people who cover a genre I want to see more of and then watching videos from their videos recommended section. I'm perpetually confused by YouTubes weights for choosing recommended videos.
- happytiger 4y agoThis concentration of videos around recent topics and YouTube’s circling of that content seems to be one of the reasons so much disinformation and misinformation gets pushed on the platform. It’s not just an inconvenience. If I watch a video from one or the other side of the political spectrum, or watch something more fringe just because I want to learn about the subject, I get nonstop recommendations for more videos and more videos and more and more and more of the same, nonstop forever. I can’t escape the subject without wiping the account, and while there does seem to be an effect from block channel dislike seems to do little. I feel like I’m staring into a bathtub full of water in the middle of the ocean. YouTube needs to fix their discovery tools because I think it’s causing someone who goes down a rabbit hole to keep going down that rabbit hole with ease, and that’s not really that cool with radicalizing content. Just my 2c from recent experience. Love the platform (except for the increase in ads to cable levels recently) otherwise.
- Bakary 4y agoIf we expand the argument a bit, we might say that we're okay with some bathtubs but not others. If there is a slight chill or the water is ice cold, we feel trapped, but if we like the temperature we're fine not plunging into the ocean. It's true that we can't avoid having our thoughts affected by our environment but it feels weird to know that so much of our mental landscape is determined by alogrithms or persons that are not connected to the actual material or social fabric of our lives.
- izzydata 4y agoDoes anyone else just not use youtube anymore? It's not even worth fighting its annoying systems. There might be some content I want to see on there, but it's going to go unseen by me. Sorry video creators. It's probably time for a new site.
- yedpodtrzitko 4y agoI dont see it mentioned BlockTube extension [0] anywhere in the comments yet. It automatically blocks videos/channels based on your defined keywords and it works perfectly. For some period of time my main YT page was filled with a variation of videos about "walking in Tokyo". I'm not interested in walking in cities nor Japan, so I have no idea where that came from. No matter how many of these videos I marked as "not interested", more of them kept coming for days. Blocktube just automatically purged them for me. Sometime I saw just a blank page (because all the videos were blocked automatically), so I had to reload page to see at least something. It took some time to get rid off the "noise", but my YT experience is now way better. [0] https://github.com/amitbl/blocktube https://github.com/amitbl/blocktube
- boastful_inaba 4y agoI second the BlockTube recommendation. It's great for spoiler avoidance too! Put in keywords like: "ending explained" "top 10" "death scene" "betrayal scene" "all bosses" "all endings" as well as series names that you don't want to be spoiled on, and suddenly your Youtube experience will be much better.
- Bakary 4y agoThere's a certain type of Westerner that really likes Japan so perhaps it mistakenly identified you as this based on your other interests.
- ipv6ipv4 4y agoWhy be logged in and subject yourself to recommendations in the first place?
- Double_a_92 4y agoWithout it's even worse... Full of Music videos or Clickbait.
- wodenokoto 4y agoAnn Reardon (not Reed, as I wrote originally), from "How to cook that" did a video on it. Basically Youtube rewards interactions, and a dislike is an interaction. Her main evidence was a video by pewdiepie where he asks everyone who views it to dislike it. It is one of his most viewed videos, at least around that time, and by far the most disliked. Sadly Ann Reardon names her videos after what she cooks or debunks, and not her critiques on the algorithm (she has quite a few really good one) I'd appreciate if someone knows the link.
- Tommah 4y agoThis one? https://youtu.be/KqAEC4jLFqA?t=905 https://youtu.be/KqAEC4jLFqA?t=905 BTW, her name is Ann Reardon.
- wodenokoto 4y agoThank you for the link and the correction!
- pwdisswordfish9 4y agohttps://thezvi.wordpress.com/2017/12/02/more-dakka/ https://thezvi.wordpress.com/2017/12/02/more-dakka/
- dredmorbius 4y agoRelevance?
- Barrin92 4y agoDoesn't seem popular because it's autonomous and scary and all but youtube should just move towards the tiktok system of algorithmic recommendation purely based on what people watch. How people vote with their feet will always be the strongest genuine indicator of what they actually want. Likes and Dislikes have countless of disadvantages. They're subject to review bombing, heavily skew towards power users because normal people don't even care to hit any buttons and it's a purely binary choice.
- adolph 4y agoSeems like someone has rediscovered the: Placebo Button is a push-button or other control that appears to have functionality but has no physical effect when pressed. Such buttons can appear to work, by lighting up or otherwise reacting, which rewards the user by giving them an illusion of control. They are commonly placed in situations where it would have once been useful to have such a button but the system now operates automatically, such as a manual thermostat in a temperature-regulated office. Were the control removed entirely, some users would feel frustrated at the awareness they were not in control. Examples include: * Office thermostats * Walk buttons at pedestrian crossings * London Underground train door buttons * Elevator door close buttons * FCC do not call lists https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Placebo_button https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Placebo_button
- Bakary 4y agoThe ballot box as well. Only half joking here.
- adolph 4y agoThe flag link for election misinformation....joking
- Bakary 4y agoI wasn't making a reference to American election fraud, but rather the notion that even in nominally democratic countries you are often voting for different sides of the same political structure with little fundamental change
- mkl95 4y agoThe problem with Youtube's recommendations is that they are not organic. Producing ad revenue is its main goal. This makes YT fundamentally different than a decade ago, when the algorithm just wanted to show you some genuinely interesting stuff. Making Youtube better from Google's point of view inevitably makes it worse from a user's point of view. It would take a really bad quarter to tune the algorithm and make it more user centric. And that's not going to happen any time soon.
- tomcam 4y agoPeople seem to think we can train the YouTube algorithm. That's backwards. As I see it, the algorithm is there to train us.
- jawadch93 4y ago
- tjpnz 4y agoThe report button doesn't work either. I regularly get crypto scams in my recommendations. I report them but they're still running hours later.
- thomasahle 4y agoOve been thinking about this problem with Facebook's recommendations: While previous "dislikes" are taken into account when predicting of a user will interact with a post, the system is still fundementally trying to predict "click through rate" not whether the user enjoys a post or not. It might even be that disliking something is positively correlated with clicking it, since they may have watched the video before deciding it is no good.
- macrolime 4y agoI get mainly good recommendations in YouTube, while in Spotify I frequently get recommended playlists where I don't even really like a single song. Does other people have the same or opposite experience?
- shultays 4y agoI am pretty sure it is working as intended. And the intention is not for you to customize your feed, it is for youtube to customize it for better retention in average. In dislike's case, you are marking the video as controversial which is a good metric for the video and youtube pushes it more
- shultays 4y agoAlso after a while, it tends to forget about "don't recommend this channel" queries you do. I guess it gives the channel another chance for you?
- user_7832 4y agoI'm a bit surprised at everyone in the comments going "YouTube isn't great with their suggestions/thumbs down prediction etc" Why do you expect Google (or any trillion dollar company) to care how good or bad the thumbs down or similar actions work? Google only cares about revenue and profits, for which it doesn't matter if the video is an educational one, a game being streamed or content designed to outrage people or spread hate. Did you watch the ad? Good. Google is happy. And google doesn't care. "But I don't watch those clickbaity videos! Google's losing revenue on me!" Yeah well apparently not on 95 or 99% of the viewers apparently for them to continue acting like this :shrug: Unless the incentives of Google and the viewers align (or regulation/competition forces Google), don't expect the thumbs down button to be more than a "Please Sir, I want some less" button-equivalent.
- TheCapeGreek 4y agoPersonally, I found the homepage recommendations too sticky after pruning. I have other things to do than watch videos, but find it difficult to stop. I've cut back to discovering content only via other sources (HN, other communities, friends) by blocking the homepage and sidebar recommendations entirely. Plug this into your uBlock "My Filters" and YT should become far less addictive. It blocks both direct homepage access and SPA routing (on the latter the homepage will just be blank): ||youtube.com^|$doc youtube.com##ytd-browse[page-subtype="home"] ! 2022-02-07 https://www.youtube.com www.youtube.com##ytd-item-section-renderer.ytd-watch-next-secondary-results-renderer.style-scope
- _def 4y agoI recently watched a craft video of a guy that was a pretty egocentric douche, at one point he even mentioned how people get offended by him and dislike his videos (not only via the dislike button, but also that) and he mentioned that it doesn't matter. Apparently he was right.
- doener 4y agoLink to the original paper: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32909873 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32909873
- cerved 4y agoYouTube is the new Facebook
- vonwoodson 4y agoThey left out the block channel button. Very effective. Seriously, as an avid YouTube consumer (and not a creator) training my algorithm is such a huge part of what my entertainment life is. Definitely have used private mode, on a VPN, with a different browser to watch videos I didn’t want polluting my algorithm. Now that my kid knows how to use YouTube and I let him use my account, my years of work are totally shot… maybe. It’s nice to be able to see and block channels, guide the algorithm away from YTP, and be sure to keep plenty of math and science options on the recommendations. I’ve also noticed that it varies by time of day. I wouldn’t mind more control, but as it is, I learn the system and do have control that I need. I don’t always know what I want, and do like surprises. Like, who knew I’d be into cow hoof trimming? YouTube did.
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoThe “Block channel” does nothing as a viewer. It just means that actual YouTuber can’t comment on your videos.
- blamestross 4y ago"repulsion" in a hyperbolic space (especially a higher dimension one) has basically no power to guide selection. That's what a "dislike" is, a repulsion in a space where there is a lot more room to slide around in than most folks intuition allows for.
- fortym2 4y agoThat is why for the last couple of years I have been only using Invidious/Piped (on desktop) and NewPipe (on Android). I have my subscriptions there and only new videos of the channels I'm interested into appear. No distraction, no trending low quality videos in my feed anymore. I only get what I'm interested into. When I want to look for something new, I head over the popular/trending sections and maybe navigate a bit on vanilla YouTube to look for new things. No regrets.
- kevincox 4y agoMy main problem with YouTube recommendations is that the majority of my feed is videos I've already watched. I generally get quickly tired of waiting for the algorithm to recommend something interesting. Although occasionally on the mobile site it inhects a "want to see something new?" into the feed which is a godsend. That list of recommendations is beautiful and interesting. However it doesn't seem to have any repeatable way to access it. Although the poor recommendations may be partly because I manage my subscriptions via RSS so most of my watching is direct-to-video links then leaving the site. But that doesn't seem to excuse recommending things that I have already watched.
- Garvi 4y agoAbout 6 months ago I ran my own little unscientific experiment with Youtube, after I noticed them promoting a certain channel that I've never watched. Nothing political or anything like that. Just a run of the mill youtuber, currently very popular with the kids. The first week or two I was pushing the "not interested" and "don't recommend channel" every time one of the videos would show up in my feed (mind you I've never actually clicked on one and watched it and I'm a firefox+ubo user). Those two buttons had no effect at all. So I tried flagging the videos for "unwanted content". No effect either. The videos would keep on appearing in my suggestions at various places for a whole month straight. The theory being that the channel was being actively promoted by Youtube and was thus impossible to hide. Ties in with the removal of the 'dislike' button as I believe it had the same reasoning behind it: raising the value of their advertising service.
- kavenkanum 4y agoYeah, flagging stuff or just clicking dislikes sometimes does not work at all. I feel this is due to popularity being more important than these dislike acts. Additionally Youtube algorithm also treats user `dislikes` like an engagement, so it may work against your common sense. What I did find very useful some time ago was to actually `Block` whole YouTube channels (you do it from Channel's Info page by clicking on the Flag button). This is an ultimate way of getting rid of some content on your feed. I blocked pretty much all these 5-Minute Crafts, Blossoms, Bright Side and other crap-generating trolls. Best decision ever!
- thelittleone 4y agoRecently I saw a video on my youtube feed claiming to be a "Live" crypto discussion with 4 people including "Elon Musk". It looked pretty legitimate so I checked it out. It was obviously pre-recorded and re-streamed and a scam. So I flagged the video and 4-5 hrs later got a notification that it has been removed. The next day the same video appeared. I flagged it again and it was removed 4-5hrs later (note there was 50k+ viewing the live stream). The next day it appeared again. I stopped bothering to report it. Does youtube not have a responsibility to protect viewers from fraud? Surely they can detect the same video being posted again? I wonder how many people are losing money to these scams.
- xani_ 4y agoYou're supposed to click in video in recommendedation in the three dot menu and click either "not interested" or "do not recommend channel"... for some fucking idiotic reason. Other fact about downvotes is that they count as engagement so downvoting a video promotes it more than not clicking anything at all, that is why many youtubers go "if you don't like it click the downvote and write about that in the comment"... because both of those actions drive "engagement" so video is promoted more
- mattgreenrocks 4y agoI wish I could dislike entire genres of things, specifically reaction videos. Laziest “content” ever and they completely takeover results anytime I search for music.
- JohnFen 4y agoFor me, it's those damned "shorts". I really wish I could just make those completely invisible.
- dncornholio 4y agoA thing that I noticed is that Youtube recommends me completely different video's when I'm at work (mostly music) then when at my desktop at home (complete mix of interests). And different video's when i'm on my phone (documentaries). It seems the system is coupled with your device and time of day. Funny thing is, I never get recommended music on my desktop and at work I never get documentaries recommended. The system works well enough for me.
- roody15 4y agoFacebook, YouTube and many others are user hostile. They make money by controlling the information you see. Your attention is a commodity they sell. Both of these services... give you what you want from time to time just to keep you on the service.. then they maximize trying to divert your attention to what they want (or are paid to show you). From one angle its quite dystopian to watch people endlessly scroll or just go from video to video on youtube.... essentially an algorithm is influencing your behavior.. perhaps programming you to an extent. Super creepy to see people everywhere just sit and stare at the device while this happens. Its like there is an illusion of user control.
- Izkata 4y agoAm I the only one that never thought the like/dislike buttons were tied to recommendations? That it has any effect at all surprises me. They used to be star ratings and were always meant to indicate to the video creator and other users the quality of the video.
- hsavit1 4y agoYoutube does almost absolutely nothing to get its users to curate the content that is presented to them. That's part of their business model
- charles_f 4y agoEspecially with their new vertical and short format, I feel like downvoting does nothing. I get hooked in by something that looks interesting, and then get served reaction videos that I hate, people stealing content from others and assembling it into "5 hacks you didn't know", beginner mountain bikers going slow on a flat run, and for whatever reason garage workers complaining that people tell them they don't know their jobs but yeah they know their jobs. I'm scared to watch these things because they last 10s each so by the time I realize what it is and downvote/switch I'm already halfway through and I assume youtube considers this as a success and reinforces my stream with that garbage. PITP is that I still get the same content despite downvoting
- Oliviai 4y agoWhen you browse for content in a certain field, it will often refer you to content in the same field, which makes me feel trapped in a small circle and not exposed to other diverse elements.