20 ms·
What I’ve learned from users
- VinLucero 4y agoI think best when walking. Does anyone know if these essays are available in Audiobook format? I can obviously do text to speech per URL, but would be awesome if Paul, or someone else, just hosted them on Spotify or elsewhere!
- JL-Akrasia 4y agoCaveat - The best type of mentors for founders are other founders. VCs, Incubators, are not optimal mentors, rather those are key folks to have in your pocket. My suggestion for all founders - find a mentor who is a founder & builder.
- whiddershins 4y agoThe article makes this point as well.
- jeffshek 4y agoIn defense of YC, many of them are previously founders of startups.
- jedberg 4y agoPretty much every YC partner is a founder and builder.
- halfjoking 4y agoLet's say you're one of the hundreds of thousands of solo devs/founders making some money - but less than $1000/month on your SaaS startup. You don't want VC, you just want growth and the ability to do your startup full-time. Why would someone mentor you in that case? What's the benefit to them?
- ghufran_syed 4y ago"paying it forward"? Getting personal satisfaction from helping others? E.g https://www.indiehackers.com/ https://www.indiehackers.com/ ? I haven't spent a lot of time there but it seems to be a community of exactly the kind of founders you describe trying to help each other out.
- tomjakubowski 4y agoLots of people simply enjoy helping others when they can.
- dustedcodes 4y agoI thought this article was about what PG learned from users but he just wrote about how good he is at identifying startup problems because they are all the same but actually not so same when it comes to replacing his job with an automated FAQ.
- soneca 4y agoYeah, it was odd. The learnings: 1. The number of companies of a batch affect how YC should work 2. Bad founders don’t understand what problems they have (or miscalculate its relevance) 3. Founders don’t listen None of those come from listening to founders. Number 1 not even came from founders, it was an internal realization that didn’t affect founders. It was kind of interesting to read, just odd due to its title and hook.
- n4r9 4y agoI had the same impression. After item 3, there is then a tangential (ironic, even?) ramble about focus. I wonder if Paul decided on the title before or after writing the content!
- mrhektor 4y agoI think he's referring to startups as his "users". In that context, I guess he's saying he's learnt the common patterns of why startups fail.
- blast 4y agoFTA: What have I learned from YC's users, the startups we've funded?
- ekidd 4y ago> how good he is at identifying startup problems because they are all the same I have never been an investor, but I have been a consultant who focused on short-term, strategically important projects for startups. So I got to see a lot of companies, both successful and unsuccessful. After a while, patterns really do become obvious. When you've seen some winners, and some doomed companies, and some that will just muddle along forever, you start to notice things. One thing is that when your customer base is truly energized, they'll practically crawl over your desk to write checks. With other companies, you'll need a sales team to push things uphill. But those companies can still win, if the sales department is humming. Other companies have poured their heart into their product, but they've never figured out how to sell it, or even how to talk to customers. (I can fix product problems, but I can't fix teams that don't talk to their customers.) Sometimes all it takes is a 5 minute phone call with a founder, and you can tell which is which. I've turned down pretty generously funded projects because it was clear that no amount of software would help a particular company connect with its market. Now, a successful investor has seen far more companies than I ever saw. I imagine the best investors can filter quickly and surprisingly well.
- KennyFromIT 4y agoOff-topic, but I wonder how much traffic is lost on PG's site due to not having a valid TLS certificate for his domain.
- ajkjk 4y agoprobably.. like.. 5 readers. Maybe 10.
- skellyclock 4y agoi've got an ultrawide screen god i wish he'd centre texts
- cercatrova 4y agoI use Stylus which let's me inject custom CSS. I used it on his site to center the content.
- deepnet 4y agoHow ? https://stylus-lang.com/ https://stylus-lang.com/
- cercatrova 4y agoStylus the Chrome / Firefox extension
- marssaxman 4y agoI wonder why reader mode doesn't work here.
- m_t 4y agoMaybe because everything is in tables?
- dilap 4y agoused to be bothered by the same thing but have since adopted one of those "quickly position window" utilities -- so e.g. you can quickly move the whole window to a reasonable column-width in the middle of the screen i use "rectangle" for the mac, but there are lots of alternatives on lots of platforms. very nice QOL improvement.
- fbanon 4y agoThis guy is very smart!
- vaylian 4y ago> YC founders aren't just inspired by one another. They also help one another. That's the happiest thing I've learned about startup founders: how generous they can be in helping one another. Synergy is a powerful thing.
- gaul_praham 4y ago
- NhanH 4y agoI adore pg’s essay. But this time something is tripping my spider sense, so I had to take a closer look (at my spider sense, and a bit on the essay too). This is the first time an essay feels like a sale pitch. Specifically, a sale pitch for YC. I’ve read pg’s essay about YC for about 15 years, and this is the first one I have that feeling. This one is a bit too abstract. I’m getting the idea that YC can help founders tremendously, that their knowledge is specialized and hard to get elsewhere. But I’m eagerly waiting for one concrete example, and none are to be found. Normally I’d expect a real set of examples from startups, instead of the analogy in horror movies. I still remember the essay where pg described how he came up with Jessica the idea of YC, while walking somewhere, explaining very concretely what he thought at the time. For any other writer or organization, I’d just guess they are trying to “keep their secret recipe”. That is neither pg or YC’s MO. So yeah, this feels strange.
- ignoramous 4y ago> But I'm eagerly waiting for one concrete example, and none are to be found. Well not in essay, but there are plenty examples in the real world, surely? "Paul Graham gave us a series of advice that changed our business forever." -Brian Chesky, https://archive.is/xvx31 https://archive.is/xvx31 "One big thing that YC did for me is it was an ambition multiplier. Pre-YC I thought it'd be cool to make software that could just pay my bills. A year post-batch and I find my default state is much more ambitious than before." -u/CoffeePython (YC S21), https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32556060 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32556060 "I have to say though - while the success rate of these YC-only funds is likely good enough to make them quite profitable, none of them come even close to what I observed with PG's ability to pick the winners (which makes sense, since a lot of other people have tried to build accelerators and none of them come even close to YC)." -u/aerosimle (YC), https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25381893 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=25381893 ...
- NhanH 4y agoThat is exactly why I single out this essay as being unusual.
- 4y ago
- kiddz 4y agoFunny, we're literally launching a new project today that allows for distributed focus groups. We haven't changed over the DNS -- here's the Heroku link (https://opinion-graphs-website.herokuapp.com https://opinion-graphs-website.herokuapp.com) How we got here: for a while we had been struggling with breaking through on another project that user voice input to measure sentiment for office space. Last week, we took a step back and thought that having a tool that could allow start-ups to ask opened ended questions where people could just "talk" and what they said is analyzed for sentiment would be valuable. So that's what we're building with OpinionGraphs. IMHO this is directly in the vein of PG's points about learning from users. With whatever you're building, if you're interested in trying a new way to connect to users or targeted customers along the lines of PG's advice, please dm me or just leave a comment here and I'll reach out.
- avg_dev 4y agoI’ve read a few of pg’s articles over the years. I believe it was one about nerdy kids and their relationships and worldviews that first brought me to this site. At some point, I read the article “Hackers and Painters” and I felt like pg’s essays didn’t resonate with me anymore. I even read a response called “Dabblers and Blowhards” that I resonated strongly with. I thought to myself, pg is distanced from reality, and that perhaps I was or had been as well. Over the past year or so I’ve been trying to make sure that my opinions are mindfully and consciously held. I’ve worked on debugging them: I test and evaluate my beliefs when the opportunity arises. I try to make sure I still feel what I think I feel and that I understand what is going on in my head and my heart, and that they act congruently. For instance, I know now that I dislike many, many things that Amazon has done and how it treats its workers. But I think that the people who worked on my Kindle Oasis have the utmost respect for their users. It makes me somewhat comfortable with the ambivalence that for me goes along with using it. For I surely love my Kindle and I surely am happy to purchase books on the Kindle store while I simultaneously am disgusted by the treatment of factory workers, delivery drivers, software developers, and other real human beings who work for Amazon. I could say the same about my iPhone. Sometimes I think hard about the slave labor that went into the manufacturing of the device that I am typing this message into. Should I stop using it? Maybe so. Maybe not. At the moment, I consciously choose to continue using it. It is quite possible that history will judge me quite harshly for this. But I believe that there is empathy and soul (and blood and inhumanity) in these things. This morning I had a feeling of revulsion when I saw that pg had written another article and that it was on the front page of one of my favorite websites. I readily see the hypocrisy in this. But as I mentioned at the outset, I wanted to determine if I felt the way I most recently felt about reading his essays. So I read it with as close to an open mind as I could. I believe that on this subject, pg knows more than I likely ever will. His users are early stage startups and he has clearly identified wide classes of issues and the ability to suss them out in the course of a brief conversation. He is able to envision founder habits changing, and recidivism of said changes. He is able to approach each situation with the mindfulness and presence that it deserves by understanding that as much as these issues fall into buckets, the circumstances surrounding them are unique, and the people involved are individuals. He is able to relate these and understand them in the context of one of the most near and dear things to my heart: cutting edge software development. He is able to see when a founder is incorrectly assessing their own situation, and he is able to guide them to a course correction. He is able to ask the founders key questions that they themselves can evaluate to understand their predicament. He is able to understand their humanity. And he has built a whole team of partners with this ability. Going against the grain of my prejudices and my expectations, I thought this was a fine article. I have considerably more respect for YC and pg than I did before I read it. I am more comfortable browsing this site as a result.
- debacle 4y agoPaul, if you're reading, this the color on your footnotes is very light on my screen and they're very easy to miss.
- avg_dev 4y agoI could be wrong but I got the feeling that was by design. They are meant as supplements and not to distract or detract from the core message.
- marcosdumay 4y agoThat's why you make something a footnote. But that's not a reason for making the mark invisible.
- jefftk 4y ago> At first I was puzzled. How could things be fine at 60 startups and broken at 80? It was only a third more. Then I realized what had happened. We were using an O(n2) algorithm. So of course it blew up. This is neat, but isn't actually right. Each partner has to know each startup, which is, yes, O(n2) relationships. But there's no one who needs to do work proportional to the number of partner-startup relationships: each partner only has O(n) startups to keep track of. So probably the reason it blew up was just ordinary linear growth outstripping capacity: 60 startups was an amount most partners could keep track of, and 80 wasn't.
- jkaptur 4y agoYeah, the tech-nerd chestnut to bring out here is Dunbar's number. Not that that's necessarily the mechanism, but it's the thing to mention.
- travisjungroth 4y agoAppealing to Dunbar's number for org sizes is a strong signal for me I should de-weight whatever the person is saying. They're just parroting pop-science with reasoning that doesn't hold up to a second of critical thinking. If humans evolved to hold about 150 relationships in our minds, to say that an org has a tipping point of 150 people assumes the members of the organization know 0 people outside of the organization. Maybe this is approximately true for Amish communities. It is not close to true for startups doubling in size every year. The available "relationship slots" for your company is probably more like 10-25. If you want to say "things get weird at about 150+", sure, maybe that's true. But no need to bring up theories that extrapolate primate cranial capacity.
- bjelkeman-again 4y agoMy experience is that one can have multiple 100-150 person contexts and keep track of the people in them, i.e company, football community, friends etc. But it is harder when they get bigger.
- chalst 4y ago
- thenerdhead 4y ago> Speed defines startups. Focus enables speed. YC improves focus. Couldn't you substitute YC for mentorship, coaching, advisement, etc? Or even peers trying to accomplish shared goals/vision? Surprisingly this article has little to even say about users, but more about YC users (i.e. founders in the program). I was hoping to read something applicable to how little companies actually talk to users and how practicing zero-distance between them will make you successful regardless of how much money you raise. Instead, this read like an ad for YC.
- hinkley 4y agoIsn't that kind of the point of YC? Consultants are everywhere. Some are bad, some are just a bad fit. But the checks flow in one direction the entire time. YC's schtick seems to be that the checks flow in the other direction at first, when the listening often matters the most. Basically YC has found a way to profit off of consulting as a value add.
- thenerdhead 4y agoI just thought the title was misleading. It read to me that of the value add of YC to its users. Not to the value add that YC companies bring to their users.
- dsr_ 4y ago"[2] When I say the summer 2012 batch was broken, I mean it felt to the partners that something was wrong. Things weren't yet so broken that the startups had a worse experience. In fact that batch did unusually well." When something unusual happens (every partner needs to keep track of more startups) and the result is unexpectedly more success instead of less, doesn't that suggest that the partners were counterintuitively wrong about feeling wrong? An experiment might be in order.
- 0xbadcafebee 4y agoCame here to point this out too. Maybe try to break it again?
- yashap 4y agoThis was a surprisingly bad essay (and I generally enjoy PG’s essays). It claims to be about “what PG has learned from YC users (startup founders)”, but basically just says “founders are wrong, YC is amazing,” then descends into a YC elevator pitch. There’s really nothing concrete about what he’s learned from users, other than “they have similar problems” (with zero information about what those problems are) and “they’re wrong about what’s important for their businesses” (again with zero details). If anything, this reads like an essay of someone who aggressively DOESN’T listen to his users.
- zigman1 4y agoGlad I'm not the only one.
- brk 4y agoI don't entirely disagree, but I think the takeaway is that the right path is not always intuitive, experience matters, and that it is hard for founders to trust advisors at times. This one probably could have been 50% shorter, which would make it 200% more effective in communicating the message. PG needs an editor :)
- PaulHoule 4y agoMy take was the opposite. Here he is talking about something he knows something about which isn't always the case.
- metadat 4y agoLife is a journey. I remember when I first encountered and read one of Paul's essays circa 2012. They were like a breath of fresh air! The clever, apparently data-driven analysis and freely imparted wisdom, wow. His writing came across as so intelligent and I concluded he must be a nice and decent person - just like me, maybe even a better version. For a twenty-something who'd already worked at a slew of startups, the essays contained some useful advice for life. Then over the years, over time, something changed. What used to read and be interpreted in a way I deemed "correct" now comes across as arrogant, elitist, dismissive, and overly broad. I no longer find the essays informative. It's kind of like the Polar Express holiday story; the bell no longer rings for me. https://polarexpress.fandom.com/wiki/Silver_bell https://polarexpress.fandom.com/wiki/Silver_bell Paul, thank you for inspiring me, your writing helped me in my twenties. Sometimes things were right for a certain period of time and then inevitably become dated as new wisdom and revelations unfold and the landscape changes.
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoThe thing that leaps out is "fund lots of small startups, the lessons are repeatable". I occasionally bang on about "Million Startups". Some back of the envelope maths and I reckon one could finance a literal million startups with what SoftBank might call a bad year (around 30 billion). When YC started they funded people with 5k per founder. I am not saying fund the next fusion machine, but put momentum into cities and groups across the globe. And if what pg says is true (there are few new problems) then guiding those startups must be more feasible then "million" sounds. Yes 60 to 80 is a big leap but 80 to a million is only slightly bigger :-) Anyway - saying more startups on HN is very much preaching to the choir so Inwill stop now.
- ianmcgowan 4y agoMaybe rebrand UBI as the government funding a few million startups? That and universal healthcare probably would free up enough people to start their passion project. Enough to cover the ones that want to be artists, caregivers, or just go surfing/play video games.
- Hallucinaut 4y agoMy favourite brainwave on UBI was to brand it a negative income tax. Would stymie a lot of the more traditional fiscal conservative arguments (albeit not going to counter the drive for regressive rates).
- lifeisstillgood 4y agoThe thing that fascinates me about UBI (apart from the right wing capitalists promoting socialist utopias) is the effect it (presumably) will have on salaries and companies. I mean HN is populated by people who mostly enjoy their STEM related work, but even so if we did not have to pay mortgages tomorrow I suspect 75% would hand in their notice and go something else - still working but working on their own start ups or the like. I cannot see a way to bring it in without collapsing the economy basically.
- mdorazio 4y ago
- kytazo 4y agoThis is something I've been speculating about long and something that I dread a lot. To be honest I have a pretty bad feeling about big CDNs like cloudflare. I think they will play a critical role in upcoming outages from alleged cyberattacks or even worse further down the road denial of service based on social status akin to social credit systems in the east.
- lisper 4y agoThis essay is getting a surprising amount of hate, and I must confess that my first impression on reading it was that it sounded an awful lot like a Robert Kiyosaki book [1]. But then I followed the two links in the essay [2] [3] and that put it into perspective: the thing that Paul learned from his users is that they are looking for The Answer, the formula, the procedure for how to succeed, and there is no such formula. It's like Goedel's incompleteness theorem, except that it's not a theorem. People come to YC and buy Robert Kiyosaki's books hoping to find an Answer that simply doesn't exist. The difference between Paul and Robert is that Paul is up-front about this while Robert is cagey and deceptive and makes his money by stringing people along thinking that The Answer can be found by buying one more of his books. But I think a lot of the hate here is driven by disappointment that Paul is honest, and that his answer is that there is no Answer. It can be frustrating to hear that (which is also something that Paul explicitly points out). --- [1] https://www.amazon.com/Rich-Dad-Poor-Teach-Middle/dp/1612680194 https://www.amazon.com/Rich-Dad-Poor-Teach-Middle/dp/1612680... [2] http://paulgraham.com/lesson.html http://paulgraham.com/lesson.html [3] http://paulgraham.com/before.html http://paulgraham.com/before.html
- iamwil 4y agoYeah, I think it's a combination of some of this stuff is common knowledge now, rather than surprising, and people were looking for concrete examples of mistakes startups made (so they can avoid it themselves) Rather, this is an essay about what was surprising to him about startups in YC. And I think it's fair to say that these were all surprising, and I wouldn't have inferred them if someone told me about YC as an idea back in 2005. Or put in another way, if someone came to you and told you about the idea for creating YC back in 2005, when the only model of investing in startups was how large institutional VCs and angels invested in startups, would you have been able to tell them the following insights about how it would work and what the value add of the advice is? Remember, when YC started, lots of people thought 7% for $15k (I know they give more now) was a joke. - Most startup problems are the same, but in different forms. It makes advising tractable for a single person to do. - Advising a lot of startups in batches has the advantage of learning about all these problems faster. - And yet, startup advising has to stay individualized (presumably to keep things concrete), so in order to scale, they had to shard. Limit was somewhere between 60 and 80 per individual advisor. - Identifying problems and ranking their severity are two different skills. You'd think they're the same, but they're not. As an advisor, if you can help startups do only these two things, it'd go a long way. Lots of advisors try to help with other things, but these are the two most important, because if a startup died, all other problems are moot. - Despite this, founders don't listen to advice about how not to die. And they don't listen because the advice is counterintuitive. It's like how there are more skiing instructors than running instructors. Skiing is more counterintuitive. - A big headwinds to advising startups on how not to die is that due to the educational system, founders have all learned how to hack the system. The skills that got them to where they are stops working when trying to build a company. - Beyond helping startups not die, advisors likely know less about the product/strategy in any domain, but they can increase focus, which increases speed of iteration, which indirectly helps startups with their product/strategy through iterative greedy algorithm. - A follow-on value-add of YC is the alumni network. Like clusters of painters in Paris during the impressionist period or musicians in Vienna, and Xerox Parc, lots of great work is done when great people do it in clusters along side each other. At the time, people thought the price of independence of is loneliness, but turns out it's not true.
- deepsun 4y agoNo HTTPS, in 2022?
- karlzt 4y agopg is outdated :(
- breck 4y agoAmazing essay. The only weak spot I could find was "It took me a long time to figure out why founders don't listen." I think sometimes their advice is packaged in a data backed, falsifiable way. For example, JL's: "I don't know of a single case of a startup that felt they spent too much time talking to users". But sometimes it's just "Because I said so". In the latter case it would be better if they showed their CSV backing their advice, or took the time to reformulate into a testable, falsifiable piece of wisdom.
- fairity 4y agoMore of a meta discussion, but it's interesting that pretty much all HN threads on PG's recent essays have a strong, negative sentiment. My guess is that this is explained by 3 factors: 1) The quantity and quality of new ideas in PG's essays is declining. 2) Readers' expectations of quality in PG's essays is increasing. 3) The pool of disenfranchised readers is growing. The quantity and quality of new ideas is decreasing because PG naturally wrote down his best ideas a long time ago. Readers' expectations increases because YC's power and influence grows. And, the pool of disenfranchised readers grows as more people try to join YC's ranks unsuccessfully. I feel badly about this because anyone who has interacted with PG irl knows he's as kind-hearted as people come. But, then again, I get the sense this doesn't bother him too much .
- sbdncuvh 4y agoOr the IT industry is just full of participation trophies and the new grey beards just cbf participating in a toxic community that can't handle a single opinion outside their own narrative.
- nvr219 4y agoI was gonna upvote this comment but then I realized it's not clear who you're saying is the toxic community that can't handle the opinion.
- barrysteve 4y agoThat's the genius of it.
- nvr219 4y agoBrilliant.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- avgcorrection 4y ago
- vecter 4y ago> We learned that the hard way, in the notorious "batch that broke YC" in the summer of 2012. Up till that point we treated the partners as a pool. When a startup requested office hours, they got the next available slot posted by any partner. That meant every partner had to know every startup. This worked fine up to 60 startups, but when the batch grew to 80, everything broke. The founders probably didn't realize anything was wrong, but the partners were confused and unhappy because halfway through the batch they still didn't know all the companies yet. I was part of the S12 batch. I certainly knew it was broken a few weeks in. Every week when we had office hours, it was always with a new partner and we spent the entire time getting them up-to-speed on just our background and context. Still loved the experience and would do YC again.
- ahmadss 4y agoI was curious to see what companies were part of the S12 batch, and who were the most notable. Among the 80 or so in that group, big winners were Coinbase, Instacart, and Zapier. https://techcrunch.com/2012/08/21/yc-demo-day-s12/ https://techcrunch.com/2012/08/21/yc-demo-day-s12/
- TigeriusKirk 4y agoWith Coinbase ipo'ed and Instacart about to ipo, that's not a bad batch from a purely investment perspective.
- killerdhmo 4y agoCoinbase? they're down 80% since their IPO (I am a shareholder); I suppose if the checkbox is "they IPOd" then sure.
- platelminto 4y agoI mean, that’s a pretty big checkbox regardless.
- kojeovo 4y ago
- contingencies 4y agoYC founders aren't just inspired by one another. They also help one another. That's the happiest thing I've learned about startup founders: how generous they can be in helping one another. This goes both ways. A few years ago a group reached out to me from HN who wanted to start up in the same sector we're working in. They were a small group of guys from a famous US university who arranged to call me and pick my brains, which I was happy to do for over an hour. I was all like "welcome to the space" and gave them some strategic pointers. I had done online YC and met some of the YC partners and felt these people being from a decent university and engaged with HN should have been, err, of reasonable ethical stature. Later on these people totally blanked me, are presenting my insights freely shared as their own, and have since secured YC funding. I am not worried in the slightest - in fact I can see them struggling and their mistakes are clear to me from afar, but I just wanted to note clearly that there is no code of honour that will not be broken, and this place is not immune.
- phpthrowaway99 4y agoOne of the goto success stories of our generation, Facebook, is based on a university student acting extremely immorally as he stole the idea from people he agreed to build said idea for.
- jseliger 4y agoAnother related surprise is how bad founders can be at realizing what their problems are. Founders will sometimes come in to talk about some problem, and we'll discover another much bigger one in the course of the conversation This is also true of undergrads, who often come in to office hours thinking they have one problem, but they in fact have another, or several others. I suspect that mentorship is useful: https://jseliger.wordpress.com/2010/10/02/how-to-get-your-professors%E2%80%99-attention-or-how-to-get-the-coaching-and-mentorship-you-need/ https://jseliger.wordpress.com/2010/10/02/how-to-get-your-pr... because good mentors often see the non-apparent problems.
- thorncorona 4y agoThis is a very well written essay. I like your writing style.
- t3estabc 4y agoOh cool a new essay from Paul.
- jollyllama 4y agoGood article, there are still startups out there (some in late stages) choosing mistaken strategies that don't allow them to get or incorporate user feedback.
- barrysteve 4y agoPG is great. What would we do without him? We want a PG in the arena at all times. This article doesn't hit the mark. Startup people don't listen, because they're trying to create something new, that nobody else understands (or people who understand are a 'parallel thought threat' like Newton and Liebniz). Counter-intuitivity is in the ballpark, but not quite "it". Really what an inventor/entrepreneur does is to specialize in a direction or idea no-one else gets or no-one else will understand the way to make it, until it's in MVP or prototype stage. How can that person slam the breaks on the train and start doing rational, sensible things that could extinguish the light of discovery/creation? Not saying that's a good thing, it's what it is. There's a weird trend online to keep blaming school for poor thinking. It's a cool rhetorical device. Doesn't work for me though. I went to a good school that challenged me to open my mind and is also the basis for faith and way of thinking that gets me to discovery. The patterns I see that others don't, is partially because I hold a tiny candle flame for an older way of thinking that is sorely needed in some spaces. There's also a quiet truth that there's now two truths. One truth for the established and comfortable, another truth for the man battling for his soul's light. They point mostly in different directions and they don't understand each other so much. It's physically painful to try and synthesize those two truths into one. More transparency in communication is the way to go. Everyone needs to admit only the old wisdom and knowledge is firm and stable. The more we can admit we don't know what's going on as we go forward, the more we can relate... my probably-wrong 0.02c
- hinkley 4y agoIt's a chicken and egg problem though. Is the idea new because I am a novel, intelligent person gifted with foresight, or is the idea new because I'm a contrarian and am more concerned with changing the world than having a really compelling reason to do so? We talk about people 'losing their way' as Reality chips away at their original idea. And while I'm sure this really does happen to some people, how often is it just a pretty story the person tells themselves that makes them feel good, helps them get through the day, helps them sleep at night? It's much easier to compromise on something you didn't hold that dearly to begin with. Anything else that helps you sleep at night (like not worrying about payroll) makes a fine substitute, especially if you don't look at it too closely.
- flavmartins 4y agoPG has reached a status where it's difficult to publish thoughts/blog posts that don't have every minute detail scrutinized. It's also HackerNews so it's a higher level audience too.
- O__________O 4y agoOddest part of this post to me is that the author founded HN, but largely abandoned it because dealing with the users was a huge mental sinkhole for them; not able to find the quote, but clearly recall him saying this, though might be wrong. As it relates to HN, PG what have you learned from the users? If HN was a startup, would it make it into YC?
- stingraycharles 4y agoTotally depends on the ambition; perhaps it was never PG’s ambition to completely understand and “own” the target audience of HN, but rather wanted to delegate that responsibility, to focus on YC’s core users instead. It may be precisely because of a tendency to understand and improve, that it is a mental sinkhole.
- O__________O 4y agoFound the PG quote I mentioned: ____________________ >> Here's a little known fact about the history of Y Combinator. The single biggest source of stress, for me at least, was not picking startups or advising them or Demo Day or even fighting with people on the startups' behalf. It was running HN. >> Don't start a forum. ____________________ Above was posted to Twitter Jul 11, 2020 — please see link below for additional context: - https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1282052801347100675 https://twitter.com/paulg/status/1282052801347100675
- robocat 4y ago> PG what have you learned from the users? To me it appears that the users of HN and the users of YC have slowly become a disjoint set. I felt it used to be more of an internal message board where founders interacted, and outsiders were welcome. It is now more of a publishing media outlet, with few founder cross-interactions. You might as well ask about other groups of users PG is — or was — associated with. HN turned out to be a side-track, and PG hasn’t posted here for two years https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=pg https://news.ycombinator.com/threads?id=pg — the last time he really interacted was when he posted about his hobby project, bel. > If HN was a startup, would it make it into YC? It would lose it’s HNness, become more social media. It could monetise by political influence, rather than advertising dollars. Disclaimer: my own opinions. No idea what PG thinks.
- hinkley 4y ago> Not that founders listen. That was another big surprise: how often founders don't listen to us. A couple weeks ago I talked to a partner who had been working for YC for a couple batches and was starting to see the pattern. "They come back a year later," she said, "and say 'We wish we'd listened to you.'" I have a theory I've shared a few times that one of our main problems is Exceptionalism, and stuff like this go into the evidence pile. My first thought on reading this paragraph was, "Someone needs to watch more Gordon Ramsay shows." PG's observation is practically the thesis of GR's Kitchen Nightmares. Owners think their business is in trouble, not that they are in trouble, and so any advice that touches their identity is abruptly and sometimes aggressively dismissed. One guy was so invested in the fact that he'd bought some fancy french stove that Ramsay had to bully him into selling it. Even used the price versus a stove more appropriate for the business was enough cash to keep the owner afloat for an extra 3-6 months. It seemed like Ramsay thought that if he hadn't bought it in the first place, the restaurant wouldn't have gotten on his show at all. Most of the computing problems in software were solved in the 70's and 80's. The new solutions trickle in just fast enough to keep things from getting tedious. Most of what we spend time on are 'process' or 'style' issues that are really people problems, ranging from cognition to group dynamics. But we don't want to face that because, as someone once put it, some of us were drawn to computers because we thought we could avoid interpersonal dynamics, and instead what happened is that we spent years looking at computers while our peers were practicing interpersonal skills, putting us several years more behind, and then we find out the job is substantially about interpersonal skills. We don't want to look at it because it both breaks the illusion and suggests that we made a mistake, and we can't make those, can we. Everybody has these problems to some degree or another. You can learn how to deal with them by watching other people do it. On TV, doing hobbies (with or without social groups), volunteering, heck even exercise comes down to getting the emotional part of your brain to allow the objective part to low-grade torture you so that you feel better the rest of the time.
- FerociousTimes 4y agoPrompted by the negative feedback that this essay received, ranging from being a sales pitch in disguise, to being a word salad going in all directions without answering the central question posed by the author right in the opening paragraphs, I had to go and re-examine the piece and see if these concerns are valid or not, and unexpectedly the second reading reaffirmed my initial positive reaction that this is actually a good piece, maybe not the best, but still good. In spirit of open discussion and intellectual curiosity here, I share my insights in the following order matching that of the post: 1) PG opens with the best advice that he could dispense to prospective applicants which is "what you've learned from users". 2) He proceeds to ask himself the same question. 3) He then informs readers that his users; startup founders, usually face the same set of problems across the board. 4) Since these problems are the same, he thought of automating the solution to scale his business (dogfooding in some sense). 5) That blew up in his face spectacularly that he had to rework the plan and concede that his solution won't scale. 6) But these same problems are not recognized uniformly by founders as they sometimes face difficulties identifying them in the first place, that's where the YC partners' role come to fill this unmet need. 7) Even when people are good at identifying problems, some are bad at determining the severity or urgency that these problems pose, cue again the YC partners' role. 8) Even when they're good at risk assessment, some are bad at risk mitigation, and won't listen to the advice given by the partners but it is not made clear what he means exactly by "not listening", dismissing/not acting on solutions proposed by YC staff, or not acknowledging that there's a problem to begin with? 9) Getting down to business to solve these problems warrants focus, and how this focus is tied into speed, and how YC can help with that. 10) Startup colleagues are more important than YC partners when it comes to realizing success with their feedback, guidance and even practical help, and how YC is the best in class in this regard. Even though the marketing language, esp the value propositions in the piece is a bit stronger for my taste, but I can't say with honesty that it overpowered the core message of the essay nor was it incoherent or disjointed in anyway that made following or understanding impossible as some have claimed here. Verdict: 8/10
- jstummbillig 4y ago> without answering the central question posed by the author right in the opening paragraphs I love that it doesn't and how it doesn't. I also find it hilarious that we have been so trained by SEO and modern day marketing gurus to expect The Answer (either roughly 90% down the page or alternatively within a list of 10 short, bulleted paragraphs) that an open question makes people uncomfortable.
- phpthrowaway99 4y agoPGs take on why early stage VCs gain so much experience reminds me of my opinions on why car sales is the best sales experience. I sold cars for almost a decade and was pretty good at it averaging 30 cars a month. That means every year I helped people sign for $16 million of products. In the end I probably sold 3000 cars for over $100 million. (Note, I stayed in it way too long. I think most of these benefits would come from 2 years) I made close to 50,000 phone calls, leaving probably 20,000 voicemails. I closed atleast 1000 deals purely on the phone. I've heard excuses, stalls, lies, promises and objections over 10,000 times. I've seen thousands of married couples discuss if they should go ahead with spending $30-100k. I've seen how they interact while waiting. (Nothing pains me more than couples, or moreso one party, playing games on their phones ignoring each other). While there is a lot more to modern tech sales than just closing incoming leads, I think car sales is an accelerator course for interacting with, reading, and closing people.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoThis is interesting because as a car buyer, the only experience I want is car sellers quoting me prices until I get the lowest one. All via email.
- arecurrence 4y agoBought a car via carwoo back when it was in business. The service let you message dealership salespeople and get quotes back. I met the guy that sold me my car for about 15 seconds total in the entire process. By far the swiftest and best large product purchasing experience I ever had. I was sad to see them close.
- Scoundreller 4y agoI think Costco used to have a service like this, but it’s on hiatus because it doesn’t really work with the supply chain issues.
- phpthrowaway99 4y agoI would get many of these type leads. The better you are, the more of these you can close. They're not anyone's favorite, but if I have a car we can't sell because it's an ugly color, or weird options configuration, or in general we need to move some cars, I'd play along. I'm just kidding a bit. In reality, even very desirable cars can have this game played on them. I once sold a car $25k over MSRP, and the customer was thrilled because that was the lowest markup he could find. When it comes to used cars, finding the lowest price is usually a terrible plan I could go into for longer than a PG blog post.
- bullen 4y agoIt's important to get the right users. Focus on repelling bad users; stay poor, stay happy. Success is way harder than failure!
- andrewmcwatters 4y agoGod, even as an open source maintainer, all of these insights SCREAM incredibly relevant. In fact, what is worse is that you don't realize your focus is totally wrong because you're not losing revenue. You might be losing eyeballs or growth and adoption, but that's easier to gloss over considering it's a factor of advertising. I constantly ask myself when looking at some of the de facto solutions in open source spaces what the hell the maintainers are doing, because what they are focused on is completely irrelevant. The same could be said about large companies who have so much revenue that can continue to make mistakes until someone challenges them.
- clairity 4y agothis is why fair competition is so important in markets (not "free"). it's literally what makes markets efficient, not omnicient capitalists, as they'd love for you to believe. the market works because mistakes become directly apparent in the catchall metric that is price (and its derivatives, revenue and profit).
- kevstev 4y agoWith open source, the incentives from a maintainers view might look a lot different than what you would think. A friend of mine has a very popular JS framework out there, gets about 500k downloads a week off of NPM. There are lots of user requests that he just outright ignores. He doesn't even care about his stats, or trying to "compete" with another more popular framework- to him its just more headaches. He built what he wanted, pushed it out for the world to use, and plenty of people did, enough that even 10x'ing that number is unlikely to really burnish the resume any further. He even tried to make it a full time job, but he found the Patreon model just way too much begging and inconsistent. Offering a support contract, a few people bit, but not enough that he could really hire people so he could offer 24/7/365 support that that implies. So he refactors, adds features he wants, and tells everyone to go Fork themselves if they whine about their pet feature not getting implemented. Of course PRs are welcome, and its actually more of a community based project now, but he has retained BDFL status for the core of it.
- andrewmcwatters 4y ago
- gnicholas 4y agoIs this what VCs want when they ask what you have learned from your users? It sounds like most of the learnings are about what his users do wrong, and why. There's surprisingly little in the way of "our users told us X and we realized we need to do Y". I assumed that when people ask what you've learned from your users, they're not asking you to list how lousy your users are at doing various things, and why they just need to listen to you more. I would actually be interested to read a post about what a VC has learned from his/her users, in a constructive sense.
- inglor 4y agoIt's a literary device. What he's telling you is that he learned: - That founders don't believe YC-partners often because their advice is counterintuitive. The underlying message is that it's important to not only give advice (sell your service) but also understand if it's being taken (your service is being actually used). - That founders (sers) come with presumptions and those affect how they apply your advice (use your product). In his "hack the test" example he emphasizes how important it is to persist in your advice (educate your users) so they unlearn old habits. etc.. He skips directly spelling out the conclusions to encourage you to read more than headlines which makes the reading (IMO) more interesting.
- gnicholas 4y agoI guess that's one way to put it. But skipping the conclusions means that we don't know what, if anything, they are doing differently to solve these issues. Just telling someone "trust us, you'll regret it if you don't follow our advice" isn't exactly a compelling argument. I'ma also not sure PG is trying to use a literary device, as you suggest. His normal writing style is very candid, so it would be surprising if he were all of a sudden burying (omitting?) the lede here.
- tlb 4y agoWhat YC's users want most of all is for their startups not to fail, so the essay talks about learning what makes startups fail and how to help founders avoid it. Founders ask for other stuff from YC too: a hangout lounge in SF, comfier seating, shared office space. But helping their startups succeed is 100x more important than all those frills, as any founder who has succeeded or failed will confirm. Markets where customers only care about one thing are rare, so people aren't very familiar with them. They're unlike commodity services like dentists, where you care about convenience & frills, and more like heart surgeons where you want the one that will give you the best chance of not dying. I suspect that not providing the frills helps YC attract better founders, because the best founders care only about their startup succeeding, while the scenesters care more about the frills. Also, it sets a good example of focusing on the most important thing, as startups should. Most importantly, by not spending much time on other stuff, YC can focus its energy on helping startups succeed.
- jrm4 4y agoI think I very much understand the hate this article is getting, and perhaps it's a thing endemic to the entire concept of "investment." People around here like "solving problems," and I'd go further to say that this is perhaps the most fulfilling thing one can do. VC doesn't do that. VC is "just greed." This is not to say that VC's can't invest in companies that solve things. If they do, great. But what's perhaps irksome is, here we are watching money try to chase more money, and whether or not a problem is solved is irrelevant. For those of us who have actually solved problems by means of a business -- watching this particular flavor of a mistake by wealthy (or wanna-be-wealth) people e.g. "oh, I wouldn't buy the product myself" is just annoying. To those of us that solve problems -- we're now hearing about obviously just a complete f**ing idiot chasing money -- and worse, a space that still might give to him despite this. I understand that this it just how it is sometimes, but I'm not surprised that this catches backlash.
- maverickJ 4y ago“Focus is doubly important for early stage startups, because not only do they have a hundred different problems, they don't have anyone to work on them except the founders. If the founders focus on things that don't matter, there's no one focusing on the things that do.” Paul hits the nail on the head with this. I like to think of this as the idea of everything is not for you. It’s very important to know what the goal is and ignore every other thing that does not align with it. The article below helps provide a framework of focus and the idea that everything is not for you. https://leveragethoughts.substack.com/p/everything-is-not-for-you https://leveragethoughts.substack.com/p/everything-is-not-fo...
- jollybean 4y agoIs anyone bothered by the consistent lack of YC/PG's ability to coherently articulate all of these lessons pedagogically? Almost all of their advice, even Siebel, is in the negative: 'don't do this' etc. Siebel does give specific advice, and it's great, but a bit ad-hoc. Even if startups are counter-intuitive, there should be a way to write this book, with 'How To' lessons, even if it's very 'case based'. There are enough examples of YC companies that they could grab 10 examples for each specific foray, to demonstrate what works, what does not and why. There's enough experience and data that someone should be able to write the high level rules, and then discuss a ton of field-level tactics that work for things like brand, direct sales, communications, marketing etc. etc..
- mwcampbell 4y ago> The educational system in most countries trains you to win by hacking the test How can we raise a generation of kids that, as a rule, don't hack the test?
- gerdesj 4y ago"The first thing that came to mind was that most startups have the same problems. No two have exactly the same problems, but it's surprising how much the problems remain the same" I'm out.
- kjkisielewicz 4y agoPG the goat
- personjerry 4y agoA bit surprising that pg hasn't upgraded to https yet
- hendry 4y agoWhat pains me is how difficult it is to give feedback or complain about a service with startups half the time. All I wanted is an email address. Twitter can be hit and miss. This morning I went down a rabbit hole to try submit a bug report to OpenAI. Had to go through a Kafka-esque Discord registration process. Astonishing how hard it is to get a service provider to listen.
- ano88888 4y agoI like PG and his essays. And I followed him on twitter also. While I really admire him but no one is perfect including PG. What I notice is that he always stubbornly believe he is right on all things he believe and look down on others who have a different opinion. I think PG should reflect on himself, if he believes he is right on all things all the time, then it is probably objectively not true. This is the smart people trap. They are right a lot of the times and that make them too errogant.
- skhameneh 4y ago> Indeed, very ambitious people probably need colleagues more than anyone else, because they're so starved for them in everyday life. This stood out for me, likely for reasons different than intended. I've tried to reflect more on ambition and focus, realizing that others cannot read ones mind. In many ways we're limited by how we express ourselves and how we're perceived. Everyone has their own scale of ambition and beliefs; a good colleague will be able to understand your level of ambition irrespective of their own.
- langsoul-com 4y agoReminds me of the quote "every happy family is the same, but every unhappy family is unhappy in their own way". Also, kitchen nightmares, they can only get in the show if their restaurant is nearly going under. At the start, they'd listen to his advice and go with the changes. But after the show ends, they'd change back and then go under.
- sbt 4y agoThis essay is uncharacteristically incoherent. The title is "What I've learned from users", yet after reading it I have no answer to this question.
- Jenny_Wengerd 4y ago
- drekipus 4y ago
- notaccept 4y ago
- egberts1 4y agowhen I buy a car, I expect the least amount of infrastructure of entanglement. That means none of the followings: - an internet “KILL ENGINE” server - an advertiser stream - a collection server of receivers of dubious trustworthiness - a tracker that reports to strange entities Looking at you, Tesla.