25 ms·
Apple’s iPhone 14 Redesign for Repair
- incanus77 4y ago> Forget satellite SOS and the larger camera, the headline is this: Apple has completely redesigned the internals of the iPhone 14 to make it easier to repair. HN: <crickets>
- smlckz 4y agoExtra hilarious as I can actually hear the sound of crickets.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mcguirep 4y agoThis doesn't make any sense to me, considering it's being commented upon literally as you wrote that comment within days of the phones release.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- incanus77 4y agoThis post was on the HN front page and made it all the way there without comment, mine being the first.
- Uehreka 4y agoYeah but you posted that comment like, 20 minutes after the post even went up, probably less than 10 minutes after it hit the front page. For a post to not have any/many comments at that point is pretty normal.
- dang 4y agoBreaking the silence by posting something unsubstantive is the worst thing you can do. Threads are sensitive to initial conditions. Please don't do that again. It's quite normal for a thread to get upvoted but not get comments for quite a while. If that means people are reading and digesting the article, that's great. We want reflective comments, not reflexive ones (https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sort=byDate&type=comment&query=reflective%20reflex%20by:dang https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&sor...) and those take time.
- elteto 4y agoThere’s another comment already moving the goalposts: “sure it’s more repairable now but what about the closed software????”.
- aaaaaaaaaaab 4y ago
- dang 4y agoIf you keep posting unsubstantive comments we are going to have to ban you. We've already asked you multiple times, and you've unfortunately continued to do it a lot. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- notriddle 4y agoSwift is great. Apple should use it more.
- webmobdev 4y agoIt's good to see Apple behaving and recognising the momentum the Rights to Repair movement has got globally in the last few years (especially in the large market of EU, and now picking up in Asia). But I think iFixit has been too generous in giving the iPhone 14 a repairability score of 7 out of 10 when Apple still places additional unwanted hurdles and control through software: > We are hearing reports that Apple is continuing their hostile path of pairing parts to the phone, requiring activation of the back glass after installation. You really shouldn’t need Apple’s permission to install a sheet of glass on a phone that you already own. Using software to prevent the use of aftermarket parts gets a big thumbs down from us. These locks are frustrating and ultimately futile—Apple simply can’t control all the repairs that happen with their products, no matter how hard they try.
- grumpycamel 4y agoIf Apple allows super easy salvage of another device for parts, I wonder if phones will start to be stolen again. Easy salvage might create an unacceptably wide-spread life-safety risk to ALL smartphone owners. Tradeoffs, unintended consequences.
- reisse 4y agoLife-safety? Seriously? It's gun control and law enforcement problem, not the one of easy salvaging. Y'know, it's hard to imagine that someone in Europe or most of the Asia would be robbing at gunpoint for the smartphone. Risk/reward just does not match - it'll be most likely few years or even probation for simple robbery with good ol' bats, and tens of years for robbing at gunpoint, a good part of it from illegal firearms possession. Not to mention that actual murder for smartphone will move it much closer to life sentence.
- spideymans 4y ago>Life-safety? Seriously? It's gun control and law enforcement problem, not the one of easy salvaging. Y'know, it's hard to imagine that someone in Europe or most of the Asia would be robbing at gunpoint for the smartphone. Yeah, instead you’d be robbed at knifepoint. And if not at knifepoint, then by using any serious of improvised weapons.
- mmazing 4y agohttps://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2022/09/18133349/iPhone14_21_edit-squashed.jpg https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2022/09/18133349/iPhon... Uh, look at that wonky Qualcomm SDR735 chip. Actually looking at it a bit closer it seems like the board was destroyed during disassembly?
- zeroflow 4y agoYeah. If you look at the complete board shots, those chips are inside the sandwich of PCBs. So yeah, it was probably disassembled in an reflow oven without much care for the components. 1. https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/iPhone+14+Pro+Max+Chip+ID/153224 https://www.ifixit.com/Guide/iPhone+14+Pro+Max+Chip+ID/15322...
- fodmap 4y agoNot only that, in the previous picture you can see some smd components have been blown away as well. https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2022/09/18133340/iPhone14_20_Edit-squashed.jpg https://valkyrie.cdn.ifixit.com/media/2022/09/18133340/iPhon...
- spookthesunset 4y agoI noticed that too. They might have been poking and prodding around with the different chips or something to see what is inside. That or it is the result of aggressively removing all the shielding. Sure threw me for a loop though.
- radicaldreamer 4y agoTaking all the shielding off those chips is probably what destroyed the board. Without doing that though, these images would just have all the chips covered by shielding metals/alloys.
- everyone 4y agoThis has gotta be cus of pressure from EU? Like if they didnt make them more repairable it might be illegal to sell them here soon.
- edhelas 4y agoNaaahhhh it's only because they wanted to. Took a few years and a few hundred millions difficult to repair devices to get there.
- kmeisthax 4y agoThe EU pressure would be in the domains of software distribution (Apple thinks third-party app stores are just malware) and charger compatibility (Apple still holds onto Lightning). They've yet to talk about either of these at all, and I wouldn't be surprised if at least one of these requirements is either geolocked or exclusive to EU models.
- tomxor 4y ago> Apple thinks third-party app stores are just malware Apple is greedy not stupid. They don't want third party app stores because it would cause competition and interfere with their almost entirely vertically integrated consumer milking machine... they don't care about malware, they care about control, controlling the user, to make sure they spend as much money as possible with Apple. Notice that they have been increasingly swapping out as much third party as possible so they can take all of the profit, they "produce" film and tv shows and sell those tv shows on a device they make with a payment processing method they own... lots of layers of profit, it goes well beyond monopoly, they are destroying the concept of a free market. They do similar things with hardware and tech, buying out or forcing businesses into positions where they have to sell to Apple out or get pushed out.
- spideymans 4y agoI can assure you there are plenty of people within the Apple organization that genuinely care about security and privacy. And if Apple happens to profit due to those efforts, all the better. Not everything is some evil nefarious ploy.
- gcau 4y agoOnly the base model, and it's gone from bad to less bad? I can forgive that designing a phone to be easily repairable can be very hard, just as long as you don't purposely make it harder to repair, or unnecessarily expensive.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- MBCook 4y agoThey’re still doing the pros so they may have improved as well.
- SayMyName 4y agoOdd article considering everything is still software locked to the phone. Sure it's easier to repair, but if you get your parts from anywhere else than apple's program directly, a lot of features will stop working. Hugh Jeffreys made a video interchanging parts on two brand new iphone's and it disabled a lot of things including auto-brightness. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K2WhU77ihw8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=K2WhU77ihw8
- thepasswordis 4y agoAh, so there is a way to disable auto brightness! Are there any aftermarket upgrades which will also permanently disable "live photos"?
- incanus77 4y agoSettings > Camera > Preserve Settings > Live Photo
- lostlogin 4y agoOP wants an aftermarket method.
- kube-system 4y agoShip me the phone and I will click the button for you for only 3 easy payments of $19.95.
- thepasswordis 4y agoYeah I've done this. It somehow keeps getting turned back on wether it gets grazed by my finger, an update happens and resets the setting, or whatever else. I'm saying i want a way that disables it and then prevents it from ever being re-enabled. Also: it's a joke.
- pb7 4y agoJokes are supposed to be funny.
- jitl 4y agoApple started offering home repair kits for iPhone this year, but they’re super difficult to use: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/25/technology/personaltech/apple-repair-program-iphone.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/05/25/technology/personaltech/a... There’s speculation that offering the kits is an attempt to head off right-to-repair legislation. But seeing this redesign, I wonder to what degree the repair program is incentivizing repairability within apple’s corporate structure. Now that “profit/loss per self service repair” is tracked in a spreadsheet - does repairability matter more? Anyways - it’s great to see some improvement here, for whatever motivation.
- dijit 4y ago> but they’re super difficult to use I can't read the link as it's paywalled: but my understanding of the Apple tools is that they're hilariously over-engineered; not that they're hard to use.
- Bud 4y ago"hilariously over-engineered" read: "not crap"
- cududa 4y agoI mean I can take pictures underwater with a freakin phone. I guess you could call that "over engineering" but I also understand that means maintaining that type of device integrity would require some heavy lifting to service the device after it's been sealed up.
- spookthesunset 4y ago> I also understand that means maintaining that type of device integrity would require some heavy lifting to service the device after it's been sealed up. Wel;l... it did require heavy lifting but according to this article that is no longer the case! Sure you'll still need a bunch of specialized tools for handling super small components but it is miles ahead of what it once was. It took me a while to come around to the idea of "right to repair" because I had the same concerns many people here have. To make it repairable would mean to sacrifice a bunch of stuff like waterproofing and weight. But I guess with this new iphone it's "game on" for repairability. Which is awesome.
- dmitrygr 4y ago> We are hearing reports that Apple is continuing their hostile path of pairing parts to the phone, requiring activation of the back glass after installation. On the other hand, this makes stealing an iPhone more and more pointless, as more and more parts cannot be parted out and sold. After activation lock was added, thieves started parting out screens and batteries to sell them and get at least some value out of an otherwise useless stolen iPhone. Want to see how useless an activation locked iPhone is? Check eBay. I assume that for iP14+ it'll be even less. I welcome this move. (all opinions my own)
- formerly_proven 4y agoThere’s no expectation of getting an open platform with iDevices so anything that disincentives stealing them is a plus.
- Swenrekcah 4y agoThat goal could presumably also be accomplished by enabling the owner to check a "stolen" box in their iCloud and after that all serialized parts of that phone go on a blacklist. An iPhone checks every day or something if any of it's parts are blacklisted and refuses to work if true. To prevent a massive attack on Apple by corrupting the blacklist, the phones would only perform this check if any of the factory parts have been replaced.
- dmitrygr 4y agoYour plan has serious a flaw. Imagine this timeline: 1. steal iphone A 2. split it into parts 3. install parts into iPhone B 4. parts not yet marked stolen, they work, check passes 5. Iphone A marked stolen ...
- Swenrekcah 4y agoI did actually think of that but decided it would be a net good. People would learn to buy from trusted sources (which would probably work in Apple's favour) and also it would out the thieves in a rather unfortunate way for them, so they'd probably get the reputation they deserve rather quickly.
- rTX5CMRXIfFG 4y agoI’m not sure I care much about repairability. For me, makers should have the freedom to design products as they wish. I don’t think that phones and laptops would be as light and portable as iPhones and Macs are if Apple was inhibited by the Right to Repair movement from arranging internal components in such a jampacked way. I also think that makers should have the freedom to design computers whose software tightly integrate with the hardware. Repairing a broken part with a third-party is exactly the opposite of tight integration. If people didn’t want tight integration, then products that are built specifically for tight integration are just not the right tool for the job that they want to do, and I don’t understand why they can’t simply choose not to buy the product. It’s not like the phone and computer markets are monopolies either. Androids and PCs of all form factors and OSes exist. It would make more sense to me to call for regulation against pricing abuse for the repairs of tightly integrated products. The Right to Repair movement as it stands just doesn’t resonate much with me, nor do I agree with it, because integrated products that come with everything you need make for great user experiences.
- blacksmith_tb 4y agoEven if that was entirely true, I am fine with regulation leaning on manufacturers to make products that aren't full of soldered ram and storage, glued shut so even their own techs have trouble repairing them, because of the implications for generating mountains of avoidable e-waste. The ability to fix to fix your own gear is just a nice plus of that arrangement, I agree it won't be of use to most people, but it's still a plus.
- minimaul 4y agoSoldered RAM isn’t just to be difficult. It has genuine performance & power consumption advantages for DDR4/DDR5/LPDDR4/LPDDR5. Storage though, I agree with :)
- kube-system 4y agoYeah, LPDDR sockets don’t even exist. Machines that use this type of RAM have to solder it, there’s no other choice.
- postalrat 4y agoNow just put a usb-c port on the phone and allow me to use any web browser.
- Spivak 4y agoWeb browsers, like communism, is a red herring. There would be absolutely no point to using alternative browser engines on an iPhone unless they got super special second party access. Not being able to run any downloaded code, no JIT, or extensions would make them useless, and allowing those things effectively breaks the iOS security model. Most obviously with screen time, and parental control, but Apple also disables their JIT in lockdown mode. I think the sanest compromise would be adopting Firefox, Chrome, and/or Edge as second party browsers. I guess we will see what happens in 2024 because I doubt it will be opening the floodgates.
- moffkalast 4y agoI don't understand how it's not possible to just sandbox all of that in iOS, like you would on desktop.
- randomdata 4y agoWeb browsers could be given super special access or some other suitable sandbox. We know how to do it, even if it comes with some tradeoffs. Communism is a thought experiment about how people might organize if we ever achieved post-scarcity. We haven't yet figured out how to achieve post-scarcity. We have absolutely no idea how to do it, if it is possible at all. Quite different.
- postalrat 4y agoApples own browser downloads code that can download more code that itself can download even more code before finally executing the last bit of code. The technology to secure it surely already exists or ios devices are already insecure.
- Spivak 4y agoApple's own code also implements all the security of the device. The mechanism Apple has to run arbitrary untrusted code on the device is their JavaScript engine. Whatever you want to replace JSC with, like V8, isn't the thing that's constrained by the sandbox, it's the thing that implements the sandbox. Everyone who's like "just sandbox it" -- yeah that's exactly what JSC is for.
- oneplane 4y agoThis has got to be one extremely expensive toolchain and supply chain redesign to do, but since they have done it a few times before (instead of incremental changes) I suppose the money department has worked out when it is feasible to do that kind of thing while keeping the people in charge happy. I'm curious to see if this is a 'test' to see if this doesn't have too many downsides, I imagine ingress area increasing this much might be a point of worry (well, there are flexible seals for that now), and instead of having a one-way stack you now have a two-way stack so tooling and workstations around that (even if we just think in terms of assembly and rework) are going to be a PITA to convert or completely replace. Either this will be a success and allow for the architectural change to be applied to other products, or it's a medium-success in which this only works for specific parts/antenna/power envelope configurations and we won't see this design in other form factors. What does itch a little is iFixit whining about the parts needing be a signed set to work together. Nobody has come up with a better integrity protection method, and no-protection isn't an option either for the ecosystem. Besides, instead of having a 'safe' and 'unsafe' option for which practically no user will ever be able to make an informed decision, you can simply choose not to buy it if this is a feature you seriously despise.
- londons_explore 4y agoI disagree that integrity protection is necessary across many components of the phone. There should be integrity protection on the SoC, and then all other components should be untrusted. Sure, that means someone can proxy the fingerprint sensor or put on a fake screen that shows a fake consent dialogue. But I think that is an acceptable risk - after all, you can never protect against someone making an entirely new device that just happens to look like an iPhone.
- oneplane 4y ago> But I think that is an acceptable risk And I think it is unacceptable. That doesn't mean that you also have to think the same thing, but I would rather not have that option taken away from me. I also don't think that you have made a case for any similar-security implementation for integrity protection. I think distributed trust is the only way to make trustworthy components, and the only known-good way to do that is using PKI, and the only proven way to do that is to have a CA. > [..] after all, you can never protect against [..] That's the kind of thinking that gets you stuck in "we have already lost so we should stop trying". If you can make sure that your finger print never leaves the secure enclave, and you can make sure that the Secure Enclave cannot be replaced, you can trust the device a whole lot more than a fake security measure that can be circumvented at every stage. What is the point of an insecure security control? You don't send your passwords plain-text over the internet, do you? Just because TLS is imperfect, and your CA store can be compromised, and your screen might be recorded using a camera and a telescope doesn't mean that therefore we should stop improving TLS...
- pigtailgirl 4y ago-- guessing - three things - 1) better margins on repair kits than hiring folks to replace screens all day - 2) difficult to assess if a screen/part is apple genuine or not at the store when dealing with trade-in/warranty returns - 3) apple genuinely cares about their environmental impact --
- MBCook 4y ago#3 seems true, but remember all this bites Apple as well. The redesign also makes it cheaper/easier for them to repair things. So even if this is 100% selfish it would still be good overall.
- anonymouse008 4y agoApple Care + is going to become an insane profit center and an absolute no brainer when purchasing a new Apple device. This puts Apple’s recent “no limit to accidental repairs” policy update in perspective. When I saw that I said, “well I guess this is how they are going to use their cash reserves, because no way will this be net profitable” To boot, I always wondered why it was so cheap - $200 for AC+ then $29 per screen or back replacement. When considering the employee time and equipment, that’s absolutely a loss. As someone that just wants good things in the world, this makes my heart flutter. It’s wonderfully aligned with customers and does good for the bottom line. Sorry to all my fellow repair brethren still slogging it out there. Accuse me of being a fanboy - but this is amazing. [Edit]: This may potentially eat into the phone case market as well. The feel of a bare iPhone is that much better and you can put the cost of the case toward AC+.
- spiderfarmer 4y agoCommercial repairmen are already pretty quick with repairs, if this make repairs easier, they will make more money as well.
- layer8 4y agoSo far, not buying AC+ has had better amortized cost for me.
- dkonofalski 4y agoUntil it doesn't. I also gamble with this because I've never damaged my phone ever and I've had an iPhone since the OG. I'm not under any delusion, though, that this streak will last forever. I think I would currently need to damage/replace my phone twice to come out in the negative but that's still a possibility. I've been extremely careful and/or lucky.
- layer8 4y agoI damage my phone every couple of years. So it happens, but not frequently enough to warrant AC+.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>Apple has completely redesigned the internals of the iPhone 14 to make it easier to repair HN: <crickets> Easier for who? Quote from the video: "We're hearing reports of Apple continuing on the hostile path of pairing parts to the phone, requiring activation of the back glass after installation. Why in the world would you need permission to install a sheet of glass?! Using software to prevent the replacement of components with aftermarket parts gets a big thumbs-dwon from us." Let's call it like it is. Apple is not doing you a favor for easier repairability, they're doing their bottom line a favor. If they actually cared, they wouldn't be so hostile to software lock you out of replacing a bloody glass panel. The internal design is still greatly thought out though. I've been asking myself for years: why can't phone makers make phones with a mid frame that allow both sides to be easily swapped out, instead of one or another. Seems like Apple has cracked it. I hope other phone makers copy this minus the SW locks.
- selykg 4y agoSort of. You can still buy replacement parts from Apple as part of the repair program. This would, in theory, make repairing the iPhone 14 a lot easier than it has been in the past. No, this still doesn't mean you can go get the cheapest replacement option you can on Alibaba but the repair is STILL easier, even if you still have to buy from Apple. For certain replacement parts I can see this being important, like anything involved in Face ID or Touch ID. Credit where credit is due, let's hope it continues in the right direction.
- ChuckNorris89 4y ago>For certain replacement parts I can see this being important, like anything involved in Face ID or Touch ID. Those are secure elements. The back glass is not a secure element. That's just vendor lock-in malice for the sake of profiteering. Edit: Since I can reply to your comments below, your argument fails flat because: 1) SW lock-outs also apply to genuine apple parts, not just aftermarket ones 2) If the user's ability to verify the originality of the parts installed in their phone was the real reason, they Apple could just have a prompt for the user that the new part is not genuine instead of completely locking it out.
- kiririn 4y agoThis brings back memories of the Xperia Z1 Compact (+ several later generations) that used this same design of gluing the screen and back glass independently to a mid frame. Unfortunately they are not good memories. The slightest, barely visible bend or sub-par repair and the back glass would peel up in one corner and coat the underside of the camera in dust and condensation I’m not sure I would risk buying a phone with this design again. Apple will have to have worked some serious magic to make it strong and robust
- crisdux 4y agoTotally speculating here. I wonder if this is preparing for a future where Apple encounters supply issues or pricing pressure caused by environmental and political turmoil. I could see the average lifespan of devices continuing to increase and more people using repair services. It also makes it easier to refurb devices for second hand use.
- hedgehog 4y agoThis design isn't more resilient vs supply chain problems in any obvious way but my guess is the next iPhone SE will be a derivative of the iPhone 14. Lowering repair costs paves the way to Apple offering leased phones and is directly aligned with a shift towards services revenue.
- Gigachad 4y agoNow is probably a good time because it seems like there is less pressure for new features. Apple is so far ahead of the rest right now that they can afford to release almost exactly the same phone a second time and it wont hurt.
- Sugimot0 4y agoFar ahead in what exactly?
- tpmx 4y agoThe article text is kind of incomprehensible on its own, IMO. If you're not already knowledgeable about modern smartphone repair you have to watch the video to make sense of it.
- dev_tty01 4y agoLooking at the board photo, something bad happened during disassembly of the 14 Pro Max. At least 9 components were heated and moved off their pads on the main CPU board in the lower left corner. Some of the chips on the other side are also shifted. Will take some work to get that running again...
- boywitharupee 4y agoWhere's the display engine located?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lawgimenez 4y ago> It’s an upgrade so seamless that the best tech reviewers in the world didn’t notice. I think it’s bad taste on how he keeps on knocking tech reviewers. Of course they won’t notice because they don’t open phones for a living.
- pwthornton 4y agoCorrect. Tech reviewers don't open phones for a living, and the vast, vast majority of cell phone buyers literally could not care less.
- ohadron 4y agoI think he meant that though the redesign is comprehensive an it's basically a different phone from the inside, reviewers still considered it an exact same design externally.
- xpe 4y agoMaybe it is an oblique criticism or maybe it isn't. It also implies this question: Best reviewers? Or most popular?
- thathndude 4y agoReally happy to see this write up. I’m probably in the tank, but I genuinely believe that Apple strives to do right by its customers, and to be a good company. it’s not a nonprofit, and I don’t expect them to act like one. Sometimes I feel like people enjoy piling on because they are the big dog. Again, please don’t mistake this comment for a blindness to some of its operations. But it’s nice to see them get credit for the good stuff.
- mildmotive 4y ago> Apple strives to do right by its customers, and to be a good company Meanwhile, millions of people accidentally turn on iCloud without understanding the consequences, due to Apple’s UI decisions. Apple need to do way more than this to show that they really strive to be good.
- dylan604 4y agoSo after however many years since iCloud was offered, I finally broke down and decided to subscribe. It's way more than just a switch that can be accidentally flipped. I had to agree to terms (yes, not a show stopper), and I had to authorize payment. Are people as cavalier with authorizing payments as they are to accepting ToS?
- gene91 4y agoI think you’re confusing iCloud and iCloud+. The former doesn’t require payment.
- newtritious 4y agoYou haven’t said what these evil consequences are.
- spogbiper 4y agoThey are one of the most profitable companies in the world.. basically the opposite of a non-profit, and they do generally act like it. It's not unexpected, but it isn't good for me as a consumer.
- hot_gril 4y ago> Forget satellite SOS and the larger camera, the headline is this: Apple has completely redesigned the internals of the iPhone 14 to make it easier to repair. This made me chuckle. I'm willing to bet that the overwhelming majority of users care far more about the camera than the repairability. The latter is hardly even something they consider. It will probably help them in unseen ways, like improving resale value.
- majani 4y agoIt would matter if it was highlighted. People care about repairability of expensive items. Admittedly, it is a secondary concern, but I would say it is probably the top secondary concern
- dylan604 4y agoIs it? Most people that might be concerned just pay for Apple Care, and then let Apple repair it. Only the 1% of people that are techy/nerdy enough to even try this are even bothered by this.
- fomine3 4y agoPerhaps it's true for richer people in the developed world. 3rd party repair shop is a thing in worldwide.
- lukas099 4y agoThis is about speed, not cost of repair. The selling point of Apple Care is that it takes the stress out of your phone breaking. When my sister's iPhone's screen broke, she took it to the Apple Store at the mall to use her Apple Care benefits. When they gave her some enormous time estimate, she marched to the iFixUrPhone stand and they did it in an hour. I believe Apple knows that this is a problem and is taking some preliminary steps to fix it. That's what this play is about.
- dylan604 4y agoYeah, you kind of need to make an appointment through their app. When you do that, you walk in, they find you a person, then it takes about the same hour. I'm honestly surprised they even accepted you as a walk-in
- mrtksn 4y ago> Forget satellite SOS and the larger camera, the headline is this: Apple has completely redesigned the internals of the iPhone 14 to make it easier to repair. I find this line hilarious because it's an example of law of the instrument[0]. iFixit and other activist repair shops treat these devices as if their(the iPhones) purpose is getting a repair and all this talk over they years about iPhone repairability was from that standpoint. I'm happy that Apple is making the new iPhones easier to repair but I never in my life purchased a brand new device with intention or plan to repair it. Why would anyone try to sell me a device by talking about how easy it is to repair it? What I expect is that it would never need a repair and if it needs a repair the vendor will handle it. Also, iPhones were always the easiest phones to repair because specialists who repair iPhones could be found on every corner. Every repair shop repairs iPhones, so repairing an iPhone was never a real issue but something that repair nerds like to speculate on. It's almost as if the happiest they could have been if Apple shipped the iPhones broken but easy to repair using some cheap generic part. I had my iPhones replaced, repaired or self services by buying the parts online through the years. It's no accident that iPhones always were best at retaining second hand value. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_the_instrument https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Law_of_the_instrument
- jorvi 4y ago> Why would anyone try to sell me a device by talking about how easy it is to repair it? I guess Framework laptops must have a hidden compartment full of gold, because they keep selling like hotcakes.
- mrtksn 4y agoHow many millions of laptops they have sold so far? Are they selling over 10 million a year thanks to the superb repairability? I like Framework, it's nice concept and if I had a few thousand dollars expandable money I would definitely buy one to fiddle with.
- mechanical_bear 4y agoNot yet, but they are still scaling. Is that your measure of success? 10 million units?
- alana314 4y agoDoes the 14 Plus have the redesigned midframe as well?
- greyhair 4y agoFrom the text of the article: "Every Android phone opens from the back." I have replaced screens an a couple different models of Motorola phones, and the screens popped off the front. Just looking at my Pixel 5a, the screen clearly pops off the front. This wouldn't bother me as much, except it is on the ifixit web site, which posts videos on screens repairs, that clearly show any number of Android phones being opened from the front. Disappointing mistake, coming from ifixit.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ornornor 4y agoI don’t know. They call it a victory for repair ability but the parts are as paired as they’ve ever been… Even replacing the rear glass triggers a warning and requires activation… That’s hardly repairable if the software is crippled as a result.
- outworlder 4y ago> Why isn’t Tim Cook bragging about repairability? This is Apple, they totally would have. If the flagship was also similarly repairable. As it is, this is making the 14 more appealing to me than the 14 Pro.
- cromka 4y ago> Why isn’t Tim Cook bragging about repairability? We had no idea this was coming, because Apple didn’t mention it—at all. But they should have. I wonder how the team behind that redesign must have felt when they watched the keynote. Probably like this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zZCszIUcyVM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zZCszIUcyVM
- zzzbra 4y agoincreasingly happy that I held out since iPhone 7+ for this one
- georgehm 4y agoDoes the iPhone 14 still have the battery glued to the back? Couldn't figure it out from reading the article. I recently replaced the battery on my old iPhone 6s using the ifixit repair kit. Of all the steps I found removing the tape attached to the battery was the flakiest/hardest operation. After many attempts I did remove it but I also ended up cracking the battery a bit :sigh:. Any changes that make the removal of the battery easier would be a great win for repairability.
- _V_ 4y agoThey are still gluing it however they use "pull tab" strips. Although they are somethimes PITA to remove, they are not the worst thing. If you tear one off you can usually use a little bit of IPA to loosen it.
- 127 4y agoSo... it's easy to change a new battery in?
- beckman466 4y agowhy don't we just open source everything and use peer-to-peer software for a new type of digital networked resource accounting to replace money and privately-owned resource planning (ERP) software that is used today to produce imperialism.
- joshfraser 4y agoNow if they would just get rid of those hideous camera bumps. Why not make the phone a millimeter thicker and fill the extra space with battery?
- EduardoBautista 4y agoI find my iPhone 13 Pro to be heavy as it is, I don't want the phones to become heavier.
- atestu 4y agoI’m with you except making the battery bigger would make it heavier and I think my 13 Pro is pretty heavy already…
- dcre 4y agoMore like 3-5mm, or half the thickness of the phone. Which answers the question. (They're a lot bigger on the 14 than on my 12.)
- joshfraser 4y agoYeah, I guess it depends on the model. I'm still on the 12 myself. iPhone 12: 1.5mm, iPhone 12 Pro: 1.7mm, iPhone 13: 2.51mm, iPhone 13 Pro : 3.65mm
- fckgw 4y agoIt would be like 50% thicker, it's not an insignificant size difference.
- _V_ 4y agoI dunno, this article reads... strange. I mean yeah, it is nice to be able to open it from front and rear. But what good does it make when they pair every single component to the motherboard? Yeah, technically parts are more accessible (physically) but thats only the beginning of the repair process. And unless you can buy genuine parts without hassle and put them in, you are still SOL. To me it is like cheering that murderer did not also litter I mean I guess it is kinda nice of him, but...
- wmeredith 4y agoI think this is a big deal because far and away, the most common repairs made to iPhones are replacing the front or back.
- _V_ 4y agoExactly and this is why Apple pairs the front part (and various other parts) to the motherboard. To make it easier or something. Got it
- kaba0 4y agoI’m fairly sure that you have to plug in your monitor to your desktop PC, otherwise it is kind of hard to.. you know, use it.
- _V_ 4y agoYeah. And I'd like to get to the same state with iPhones :-) So they let me connect another monitor to my phone without hardwiring it together. Honestly, if they cared about "best user experience", they would have done digital signature of the LCD/cable and if OEM was detected, they could display something like "Hey, someone tampered with your phone and changed the screen using OEM parts". If not, they coud say "Hey, someone tampered with your phone and replaced screen with an unoriginal one. You might see some degradation in quality because of that".
- varenc 4y ago
- ahaucnx 4y agoOn our product (air quality monitor[1]) we made the concious decision to design it for long life and repairability by e.g.: - using no glue or snaps - all components on one PCB, no thin cables that can break - standard philips/torx screws - four screws to open the enclosure, four screws to take out the pcb - expensive sensor modules on pin sockets for easy reaplacement - only using components that are certified for longe lifetime -even if they cost a few dollars more (e.g. DC to DC converter) - not using plastic for packaging and we ask our supplier to not use plastic when sending us the parts (e.g. no bag around the USB cable etc) We wrote about this [2] and often do presentations for customers and have a slide about this and it gets a great response and I believe gives us an advantage compared to competing products on the market. As the market more and more appreciates this, Apple probably also realized that this can be a competitive advantage and give them positive press. [1] https://www.airgradient.com/airgradient-one/ https://www.airgradient.com/airgradient-one/ [2] https://www.airgradient.com/about/ https://www.airgradient.com/about/
- philistine 4y agoYour scrutiny stopped at the hardware. Your first link showed a white page for 31 seconds while it was running javascript and using up to 50% of my M1 Mac's power. All that, for a page 2 MB page.
- jpgvm 4y agoThey are hardware guys, they probably wrote some good firmware but their expertise falls short of cutting edge web stuff. I would cut them some slack and hope they are successful enough they can pay someone else to do web stuff at some stage. :)
- intrasight 4y agoLooks promising and I'm in the market for a few. Too bad I can't buy them.
- ahaucnx 4y agoSee my comment above about pricing. We also have pre-soldered open source kits available that are "hacker friendly". More information on this page: https://www.airgradient.com/open-airgradient/kits/ https://www.airgradient.com/open-airgradient/kits/
- bogwog 4y ago> We are hearing reports that Apple is continuing their hostile path of pairing parts to the phone, requiring activation of the back glass after installation. Hopefully that's not the case. Why go through the effort of a redesign like this if you're just going to continue handicapping repairs that way? Clearly it wasn't a marketing gimmick since they haven't mentioned it at all. Reading through this article made me really start to consider buying a new iPhone. I've had my mind set on switching to Android for the past year, but a pro-repair pro-planet move like this needs to be rewarded in the marketplace, and I'll be telling everyone I know to get a 14. ...that is, unless they're still locking parts down with serial number checks.
- jquery 4y ago> Why isn’t Tim Cook bragging about repairability? We had no idea this was coming, because Apple didn’t mention it—at all. But they should have. Didn’t they upgrade AppleCare to include unlimited repairs and brag about that? I think this might be related, and a better way of marketing the feature.
- asimpletune 4y agoWow seeing it opened up like that... it's so beautiful
- fennecfoxy 4y agoAhaha. Apple only changes stuff when they can jump on a bandwagon to make money. First privacy/security, which they didn't give a crap about until they realised it was marketable. Now right to repair, which they also didn't give a crap about and often went out of their way to prevent. Suddenly public awareness has increased and it's not become a marketable feature. So not surprising that Apple has jumped on it.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]