22 ms·
Weird Al had 100 gigs of RAM
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zmachinaz 4y agoProblem is, there is a big divide in user base: For a normal user, 8 GB is mostly sufficient. If you have a lot of chrome tabs open, 16 GB makes your day. But, if you are any sort of a creator, you can not have enough ... my 256GB is barely enough.
- macrolime 4y ago8 gigabytes is not enough to run Windows. It ok for an iPad, but any Windows computer with 8GB ram essentially unusable and will crawl to a halt the second you open a web browser. What normal users don't use browsers?
- icedchai 4y agoI'm on 8 gig Windows laptop running Firefox right now. There's over 3 gigs RAM free. It's bad, but not that bad.
- anthk 4y agoWe use Ublock Origin and try to compress the RAM as a virtual swap everywhere. Chrom* based browsers have optimized switches for low end machines, starting with --light, that's it, append that parameter to your desktop shortcut and things will speed up a bit. Using the web today without UBo today it's suicidal.
- dagw 4y agoI have 8 GB on my old Surface Pro running Windows 10, and it works perfectly fine for browsing, office work and most lighter programming tasks.
- alfiedotwtf 4y ago"What kind of chip you got in there, a Dorito?"
- Eleison23 4y agoOkay, let's stipulate that "Weird Al" knew exactly what he was talking about, so why did he claim "100 gigabytes" which is an impossible number to achieve in one device? (Other than meter scanning) It should have been 128, yes?
- vantablacksheep 4y ago192G RAM (64G x 3) + 8G on the video card.
- TheDong 4y ago"Weird Al" was, in fact, making a song, not a rigorous piece of technical journalism. "I got me a hundred gigabytes of ram" flows better lyrically in the song than "I got me a hundred-twenty-eight gigabytes of ram". Whether he knew the details of typical memory module sizes or not, it's such a minor inaccuracy that the lyrical flow matters far more. Anyway, I bet you could achieve it if you really wanted to try. Get a dell poweredge server with 24 DIMMs, install 12x8GB (96) + 4x1GB (4) for your total of 100, and with 8 DIMMs leftover.
- ollien 4y ago> The general public isn’t asking for a hundred gigs, but I’d love to see the baseline rise up a bit. It doesn’t feel like we’ve budged meaningfully here for years. Or is that just me? While the baseline of 8GB hasn't risen, I do think the floor of what we'd consider "unnecessary" has risen. I remember in 2018 I was building a new desktop and I spent a pretty penny on 32GB of RAM; folks on r/buildapc said that was a waste. Now and days I feel like I've seen a lot of higher end builds that feature 32GB or even 64GB. Just my 2c; I don't have stats to back this up or anything...
- RajT88 4y ago32gb is totally worthwhile. I don't know if I need 32gb exactly, but I desperately needed more than 16gb.
- waynesonfire 4y agoat least on linux, any unused ram is going to be used for your buffer cache. get as much memory as you can afford.
- erulabs 4y agoMy primary workstation has 128GB and it is for sure unnecessary. Even with multiple projects running each of which spins up a dozen containers in k3s, and a background game of Rimworld as well as all the electron apps that life requires these days, I rarely ever breach 64GB much less 100GB. The only real use is writing horrifying malloc experiments and having a couple extra seconds to kill them before OOMing.
- gambiting 4y agoI work in video games development and all our workstations have 128GB of ram - I consider that the bare minimum nowadays.
- inciampati 4y agoI routinely use this much RAM for work. And it's not malloc experiments lol. I need 200ag to 500G for my research work. Most of our systems have 384G and this is just enough. If I could only have a laptop with that much...
- obblekk 4y agoInteresting point that RAM has basically not moved up in consumer computers in 10+ years... wonder why. The article answers its own question by pointing out SSDs allow better swapping, bus is wider and RAM is more and more integrated into processor, etc. But I think this misses the point. Did these solutions make it uneconomic to increase RAM density, or did scaling challenges in RAM density lead to a bunch of other nearby things getting better to compensate? I'd guess the problem is in scaling RAM density itself because performance is just not very good on 8gb macbooks, compared to 16gb. If "unified memory" was really that great, I'd expect there to be largely no difference in perceived quality. Does anyone have expertise in RAM manufacturing challenge?
- Syonyk 4y agoI don't think SSDs allowing rapid swapping is as big a deal as SSDs being really fast at serving files. On a typical system, pre-SSD, you wanted gobs of RAM to make it fast - not only for your actual application use, but also for the page cache. You wanted that glacial spinning rust to be touched once for any page you'd be using frequently because the access times were so awful. Now, with SSDs, it's a lot cheaper and faster to read disk, and especially with NVMe, you don't have to read things sequentially. You just "throw the spaghetti at the wall" with regards to all the blocks you want, and it services them. So you don't need nearly as much page cache to have "teh snappy" in your responsiveness. We've also added compressed RAM to all major OSes (Windows has it, MacOS has it, and Linux at least normally ships with zswap built as a module, though not enabled). So that further improves RAM efficiency - part of the reason I can use 64-bit 4GB ARM boxes is that zswap does a very good job of keeping swap off the disk. We're using RAM more efficiently than we used to be, and that's helped keep "usable amounts" somewhat stable. Don't worry, though. Electron apps have heard the complaint and are coming for all the RAM you have! It's shocking just how much less RAM something like ncspot (curses/terminal client for Spotify) uses than the official app...
- bombcar 4y agoAlso people forget that the jump from 8 bit to 16 bit doubled address size, and 16 to 32 did it again, and 32 to 64, again. But each time the percentage of "active memory" that was used by addresses dropped. And I feel the operating systems have gotten better at paging out large portions of these stupid electron apps, but that may just be wishful thinking.
- thanatos519 4y agoHe also got a flat screen monitor 40 inches wide! (I believe that your says "Etch-A-Sketch" on the side) ... and the typical monitor seems to be 27" these days.
- timbit42 4y ago> 40 inches wide What would that be diagonally?
- iancmceachern 4y agoI have a 40" monitor
- jbellis 4y agoI tried using a 40" 4k tv as a monitor a few years ago. It was big enough that I had to move my head to see different parts of the screen. I didn't like that and now I'm back on around 30".
- ak217 4y agoLG makes a 43" 4K IPS monitor. It's the centerpiece to my most productive setup, with a 27" in portrait mode serving as a sidecar. My only complaint is that it's not 8K. There's no such thing as too many pixels.
- bombcar 4y agoAnd "Slackers" would have a whole new meaning these days.
- madmoose 4y ago
- dotdi 4y agoFrom a professional perspective, I completely agree. I used to run into "not enough RAM" situations frequently and convinced my company to splurge 4K EUR on a Macbook Pro with 64 GBs of RAM. I'm very happy with it. I also had to block several planned purchases where somebody unrelated to the work my team does decided to order MacBooks with 8GBs of RAM for new team members. It's 2022 my dude, the 2000s called and they want their 4*2GB RAM kits back. From a consumer perspective on the other hand, I feel that current machines with 8GB of RAM run typical software (browsers and whatnot) well enough.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- vonseel 4y agoIf they are unrelated to the work your team does, how can you be sure they really need more than 8Gb of unified memory? I'm on an 8Gb M1 Macbook Air and really don't notice it swapping often, unless I'm running something heavy in addition to browser + terminal + IntelliJ IDEA.
- entropie 4y agoImage or video editing?
- Miraste 4y agoThe M1 is absurdly better than Intel Macs about swapping, I think because of the giant caches. I never have memory issues on my 8gb M1 Mac Mini, but my work 16gb Intel Macbook runs into memory slowdowns as soon as it launches Slack, a browser, and an IDE at the same time.
- Sakos 4y agoI have a 16GB M1 MBP. I can easily get it to slow to a crawl if I'm not careful. This is with Intellij Idea and other tools I use regularly. It's the worst thing about Macbooks, limited RAM.
- faeriechangling 4y ago
- Veedrac 4y ago> But memory has felt like an exception to Moore’s Law for a while, at least in practice. That's because it is. Memory is failing to scale. That's why there's so much investment in alternative memory technologies, including why Intel sunk so much money into 3D XPoint despite the losses. But the market is brutally optimized, hence the difficulty cracking it.
- EmuAGR 4y agoSRAM cells need 6 transistors. DRAM cells need a transistor and a capacitor. 6 transistors aren't dense, so are capacitors in integrated circuits. Comparatively with NAND, it only needs one (floating gate) transistor. Samsung is working on 3D-stacked DRAM cells: https://www.i-micronews.com/samsung-electronics-gearing-up-to-develop-worlds-first-3d-dram/ https://www.i-micronews.com/samsung-electronics-gearing-up-t...
- fudged71 4y agoAnyone else get stuck parsing the title whether it's Weird AI or Weird Al?
- DOsinga 4y agoYep I did. I thought this was about some new network architecture that needed loads of RAM but also produced, I guess, weird results
- bo1024 4y agoMy font (Firefox) was actually very helpful for this. A tiny serif at the base of the l.
- sien 4y agoWeird AI would be a great name for an ML system that made up lyrics for popular songs.
- bombcar 4y agohttps://www.businessinsider.com/weird-ai-yancovic-algorithm-parody-song-fair-use-2020-7 https://www.businessinsider.com/weird-ai-yancovic-algorithm-... Searching Google for “weird ai” just returns “weird Al” results heh
- mnd999 4y agoI actually do have 100gb of ram in my desktop, mainly because I got a bit carried away on eBay and bought an epyc, and you kinda have to fill all the slots to get the performance.
- thegagne 4y agoI think a big piece that is ignored is how much normal compute/memory usage has been shifted to the Cloud. I no longer need to have local resources to do amazing things. I don't need an 10GB+ GPU in my phone to be able to hit some website and use AI to generate images. I have fast web/email search capabilities that don't require me to have a local index of all of it. I can spin up a remote compute cluster with as much RAM as I need if I want some heavy lifting done, and then throw it all away when I'm finished. "Back in the day" we would try to build for all that we could perceive we would do in the next 5 years, and maybe upgrade memory half way through that cycle if things changed. We ran a lot of things locally, and would close apps if we needed to open something needy. I think also systems have gotten a lot better at sharing and doing memory swapping (see comments about SSD helping here). Back in the old days, if you ran out of memory, the app would just not open at all, or crash.
- z0r 4y agoI need >16GB of RAM to reasonably run Chrome on a personal computer.
- BoorishBears 4y agoI somewhat jokingly built out my gaming PC with 64 GBs of RAM with Chrome as my justification... unfortunately well before it reaches even 16 GBs of RAM usage it becomes fairly unstable before eventually reporting that it's out of memory despite less than 50% memory utilization.
- brundolf 4y agoI just did a test, checking RAM usage before/after closing Chrome (which has 8 tabs open, three of which are Google apps and three of which are Jira, so pretty heavyweight). It's using 2.8GB
- dijit 4y agoAlways reserve about 2G for macOS/Windows and about 1G for a desktop variant of linux. For example "WindowServer" on my Mac is using 1.22G at the moment by itself. For Chrome tabs: 95MB static cost per tab; some sites load a lot of data: console.cloud.google.com takes 1GiB of ram for me; LinkedIn takes about 700MiB Jira, Confluence, Google Cloud Console, Slack and Gmail on my machine consume 4GiB when running simultaneously. That's before I have things like teams, onedrive/dropbox, docker or an IDE. I don't think 16G is too little, but I could see how there's a potential there to run out quite easily.
- FreeFull 4y agoI wonder if another thing that's been holding larger amounts of RAM back is the lack of error correction. Maybe DDR5 will mitigate that problem, although it's still suboptimal that consumer-targetted CPUs don't support ECC.
- robocat 4y agoDDR5 supports on-die ECC eg. https://v6m6x4a4.rocketcdn.me/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/SK_hynix_DDR5_Advantages1.png https://v6m6x4a4.rocketcdn.me/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/SK_... Not sure if it is a compulsory part of the spec, and irrelevant for most laptops since laptops generally wouldn’t use DDR5, but use low-power DDR instead.
- toast0 4y agoOn-die ECC should help with data integrity, but on-die ECC doesn't protect integrity all the way to the memory controller, and lack of reporting means I don't think you'll even know when there's an uncorrectable error. Which means you've still got the same basic issue --- memory is not stable, although the error rate is likely reduced.
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoNo, what's "holding larger amounts back" is that it's not needed by consumers. For most people, 8 GB has been plenty for 10 years now. For gaming, I'd recommend 16 GB, 32 GB if you play a heavily modded Cities: Skylines.
- bombcar 4y agoI’ve been pleased with Skylines even heavily modded in 16 GB, but that’s with all the “save memory” mods running.
- smiley1437 4y ago8GB isn't quite enough anymore, even typical office employees are starting to need 16GB now because of many browser tabs Damn middle click is too convenient and no one wants to close tabs because they might not find that one critical page again
- kitsunesoba 4y ago> no one wants to close tabs because they might not find that one critical page again And most of the things in the tabs don't meet the threshold for bookmarking them, because the overhead of maintaining bookmarks makes one want to only bookmark things that are used often.
- bombcar 4y agoI’d pay for a local program that would fully text index every page I visit forever so I can search for them again quickly.
- lanstin 4y agoGoogle's lack of search quality affects hardware specs. Better at answering general questions and less good at finding a specific thing, especially from a few months ago.
- stereolambda 4y agoSo basically bookmarks and history devolved into tabs for people? I do notice the difference between my Firefox installation (with 'live downloaded' search suggestions disabled), where I mostly can pull anything I want from the past, and the times when I have to use Chrome, which at least by default makes it difficult to recall a page visited even a moment ago. (Yes, technically you have history hidden in menus.) I would dread living that in normal browsing.
- mwcampbell 4y ago> The general public isn’t asking for a hundred gigs, but I’d love to see the baseline rise up a bit. Please no. The pressure on us software developers to keep our bloat under control, particularly when better options than Electron become available, has to come from somewhere. There will always be people who can't afford to upgrade to the new baseline, and we shouldn't leave them behind if we can help it.
- ChadNauseam 4y agoWhat better options than electron can we hope for? Writing UIs in TypeScript with React is amazingly productive. A huge amount of effort has been invested into making that entire stack fast and it’s still a lot slower than I‘d want it to be. I’ve written some websites in Yew (react-like rust library), but either Rust or Yew seems to really suck for UI stuff. I feel like we’re missing some kind of nice middle-of-the-road language that’s both reasonably productive and results in reasonably performant apps. OCaml is the only language I know of that’s in that sweet spot, but there’s no UI libraries for it unless you go the ReasonML/react route, but then you’re just compiling to JS again.
- anthk 4y agoQt5/6.
- staticassertion 4y agoIf that pressure doesn't exist than why does it have to come from somewhere? I also run exactly 0 electron apps but definitely would like to have more ram - 64GB would give me some breathing room, 128GB would probably be optimal.
- mwcampbell 4y agoYou're right, real pressure to keep software bloat under control mostly doesn't exist, but it should, for the sake of our users.
- 4y ago
- MBCook 4y agoHasn’t memory sped up dramatically in the last 20 years? Maybe that, combined with ever faster SSDs, means most people just don’t need too much more. It used to incredibly painful to run out of ram. You’d have to hit swap or page a file in from disk that was tossed and wait hundreds of milliseconds. That was incredibly noticeable. But now we can get things into memory so much faster having to load something off permanent storage takes a few tens of milliseconds. It’s not so objectionable. At the same time most people are doing similar things to 20 years ago, needs haven’t scaled. Sure needs have gone up as images have gotten sharper but text is still text. Audio is still only a meg or two a minute. Unless you’re doing high end photo editing, video editing, or neural net stuff (which is mostly GPU memory?) do most people really need much more than 8/16GB?
- distantsounds 4y agoYeah, this. we are still running our desktops at sub-5ghz speeds, but we've gotten far more efficient at it. there are more things to take in account.
- MBCook 4y agoI remember when the first MacBook Air came out someone, I think it was Jeff Atwood, posted about compile speeds. The Air had no cooling and an underpowered little CPU so low power Apple had Intel make it just for them. But you could pay a crazy amount of money for a teeny-tiny SSD instead of a tiny hard drive. The SSD was so much faster than standard hard drives that machine could compile code faster than the normal MacBook Pros of the day, even though they could hold more ram and had better CPUs. Gettin go things off disk to the CPU matters a lot. It’s OK if you don’t have enough memory if that pipeline is extremely fast. The situation may have happened again with the M1 Macs. Not only were they faster than the Intel chips at most things but the on-package memory screams and the storage controller is fantastic. People have reported those machines at 16GB anecdotally feeling amazing despite having half the ram of other existing machines.
- jimt1234 4y agoI wonder if Bill Gates still does Weird Al's tech support.
- dimensionc132 4y agoWeird" Al Yankovic - Amish Paradise is a better song about technology https://yewtu.be/watch?v=lOfZLb33uCg https://yewtu.be/watch?v=lOfZLb33uCg
- w-m 4y agoCommercialization of large machine learning models might push the RAM game for the end user up in the not-too-far future. For unified memory machines like the current Apple chips that is, and otherwise the memory on consumer GPUs for the enthusiasts. Last week, several posts made it to the HN front page of stable diffusion forks that reduce the memory usage, to make it possible to generate 512x512 images with < 10 GB GPU memory, but with a tradeoff in computing speed. Trying to go beyond HD resolution (far from phone photo resolution) will still blow out your top-of-the-line Nvidia consumer GPU. When approaches like these will be hitting your favorite image editing tool, you'll want to get that 256 GB RAM iPad for your mom. Otherwise, you'll have to deal with her having to wait minutes to give your family cat a festive hat in last year's Christmas picture.
- nocman 4y agoOf course, the other plausible explanation is that (at least at the time) Weird Al didn't know the difference between RAM and hard drive space (especially likely, because he's talking about defragging a hard drive). In fact, I'd be surprised if that wasn't what he meant. I will, however, leave room for him knowing the difference, but intentionally being absurd (it is Weird Al, after all). That problem (referring to things that are not conventional fast, volatile random access memory as RAM) seems to have only gotten worse in the last twenty years - exacerbated, I believe by the increased use of flash technology (SSDs, etc - which have, admittedly blurred the lines some). It also doesn't help that smart phone and tablet manufacturers/advertisers have long insisted on referring to the device's long-term storage (also flash tech) as "memory". I doubt that will ever stop bugging me, but I've learned to live with it, albeit curmudgeonly. Whippersnappers! :-D
- function_seven 4y agoSee also "Wi-Fi" meaning any Internet access now. Or "screen saver" meaning the desktop wallpaper.
- treeman79 4y agoInternet is down! Umm no it’s fine. Shows me Facebook not working. Umm that’s just Facebook down. So the internet is down! After a few rounds sure. The entire Internet is down. I’m going to go play an online game.
- netsharc 4y agoA pet peeve I've had to grow out of is the missing word "connection" when people say "The Internet is down".
- fijiaarone 4y agoSo you don’t believe in technological solipsism?
- 4y ago
- goatcode 4y ago>MiB That 'i' is silly. As is the one in "GiB."
- m2fkxy 4y agowhy? how else do you designate binary prefixes?
- icedchai 4y agoIf you've been in computing since, say, the 90's, you don't. It was always based on context. Memory = binary, bandwidth = decimal, disk/SSD storage = decimal (maybe!)
- Kwpolska 4y agoWindows (and most of the world) doesn’t bother, 1 KB = 1024 B. https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20090611-00/?p=17933 https://devblogs.microsoft.com/oldnewthing/20090611-00/?p=17...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- kelnos 4y agoThey're binary prefixes[0]. If we go by the traditional meaning of the SI prefixes, "M" means "10^6", so 1MB is 1,000,000 bytes. 1MiB, by contrast, is 1,048,576 bytes (1024*1024, or 2^20), which would be more correct for something like RAM. Yes, in the past the SI prefixes were "abused" for power-of-two quantities, but nowadays it's best to be more precise, as many computer-related things actually do come in power-of-ten quantities, not just power-of-two quantities. For example, my NVMe drive's capacity is actually 2TB, not 2TiB[1]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Binary_prefix https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Binary_prefix [1] Ok, ok, it's actually showing up in `parted` as 2,000,398,934,016 bytes, which is a little bit more (~380MiB) than 2TB, but considerably less (~185GiB) than 2TiB.
- pessimizer 4y ago> many computer-related things actually do come in power-of-ten quantities They don't have to do this, they do it because it confuses people.
- jabbany 4y agoIDK, anecdotally at least I broke the 100G RAM barrier earlier this year by upgrading to a Ryzen 5900X with 4 x 32G sticks. RAM has largely become quite affordable with a 32G stick of DDR4 going for around ~$100 (and you can occasionally see discounts down to ~$80). It has been great being able to spin up VMs as needed, or keep hundreds of tabs open on Chrome and not have to worry about things getting bogged down. The only annoyance is that this also results in gigantic memory dumps if the system crashes... (FWIW, I'm usually hovering around 20G just with browser tabs alone and no VMs running. Admittedly, I do use tabs as a way to organize work so having hundreds is common.)
- kevin_thibedeau 4y agoWithout ECC you've exploded your vulnerability to bit flips.
- jabbany 4y agoNot a hardware person but it seems it wouldn't be that much of a difference? Assuming bit flips happen at a fixed rate (cosmic rays whatnot), then wouldn't the likelihood only depend on the actual amount of memory used rather than the total capacity? Like, if a bit flips in unused RAM does it really matter... And used memory is used one way or the other so the flip would have happened anyways. I think the bigger issue is outright RAM failures/errors are harder to diagnose. Like if I had a bad chip on one of the sticks, it would be harder to notice since the chance of hitting that error and crashing is much lower, so the system would seem to run fine most of the time. Doing memtest is rather annoyingly slow so I've only done it once after building the system to make sure none of the sticks were DOA. On another note, for my NAS I do run ECC (4 x 8G DDR3) on a server board and over the course of about 7 years, I've had 1 stick fail in the form of consistently getting stuck bits (which are then corrected and reported) and have had about 3 or 4 spurious flips in total on the other sticks.
- antidaily 4y agoLost my virginity to that song.
- slg 4y agoIsn't this just the same as processors? We used to primarily care about GHz and GBs, but there were diminishing returns for continuing to grow those. As a result, processors started shifting to multiple cores, but still usually hovering in the same GHz range. Meanwhile RAM total size might be the same in your current machine as it was a decade ago, but bandwidth and clock rates have drastically increased since Weird Al wrote that song. A similar thing happens with digital cameras and megapixels. It wasn't that things stopped improving, it is that the old measure of improvement has been de-emphasized in favor of other factors that have proved to be more important for normal use.
- LeoPanthera 4y agoMoores law held for RAM until about 2016. If you start in 1980 with 32K and then double it every two years, you get a reasonable approximation of the RAM of a desktop-class computer all the way until then. You hit 8GB in 2016 and then the rule goes out of the window.
- Kerrick 4y agoGoing from 2016 to today (2022) is three more doublings, which would be 64GB of RAM -- and that is an available configuration in laptops such as the XPS 17 or the MacBook Pro. That's not even considering desktops (which can handle 128GB) or workstations (which can reach terabytes).
- bombcar 4y ago8GB in ‘16 would be a nice amount - 64GB seems a bit high for me today. And 8GB in 16 was common but I feel 64GB today is relatively rare.
- tanjtanjtanj 4y agoI purchased a 32GB kit of fast-for-the-time RAM for around $150 in 2016. There was a 64GB kit available for a little more than I wanted to pay as well. In years after that the price of RAM went WAY up due to a mixture of natural disasters, RAM cartels, and a change of priorities for manufacturers. In 2019 I was offered $320 for those same sticks of used RAM. Looking at current motherboards of the same type, they also top out at 64GB (I know there are higher limits but I'm in the Mini-ITX ecosystem). So I agree with your point just disagree a bit on the 8GB number as I had a fairly middle of the road laptop in 2012 with 16GB of RAM as well.
- sturob 4y agoIt could be interpreted as him owning 100 gigs of RAM across all his devices. I'd estimate I'm around 50-60, so I'm sure plenty of HNers are over 100 total?
- kelnos 4y agoIf most people here use laptops (which is my -- perhaps flawed -- perception), then maybe not. I just put together a new Framework laptop with 64GiB, and that was a huge jump from my Dell XPS 13 with 16GiB. All of the other 13" laptops I looked at max out at either 16GiB or 32GiB. Even 15"/16" laptops probably usually only have 16GiB or 32GiB, on average, though I'm sure there are some with 64GiB. And then phones, even the high end ones max out at around 8GiB, right? I think mine has 6GiB, though it's a few years old now. Even someone with a desktop machine (for gaming, perhaps) probably "only" has 64GiB. So the total (64GiB desktop + 16GiB laptop + 8GiB phone = 88GiB) is still under 100GiB. I guess if we include the dedicated VRAM on a the discrete GPU that might be in the desktop? Not sure I'd count that, though. I do have a few Raspberry Pis (of various vintage) and an old Mac Mini that are doing various things around the house, so I guess that's another 4+4+1+0.5+16 = 25.5GiB. So my grand total (including my phone and laptop; I don't have a desktop) comes to 97.5GiB -- so close! I wouldn't count these, but my router has 2GiB, and I have two APs with 128MiB each, so that'd bring me to 99.75GiB. Can't believe I'm only 256MiB short!
- bombcar 4y agoOne stupid old VM server from eBay throws me past the mark, and that doesn’t even count the other space heater that’s just off.
- SECProto 4y ago> Weird Al had 100 gigs of RAM And he needed it because of his 2000" TV! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbDostWXpcU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gbDostWXpcU
- ehayes 4y agoOld enough to remember upgrading the RAM in our home PC so we could play Doom —quadrupled it to 4 megabytes.
- bombcar 4y agoSo many upgrades to meet “minimum” specs back then - I recall scrounging around to find a video card with just enough RAM to run SimCity 2000. Now almost all upgrades are to make it better, not make it work at all.
- JuanPosadas 4y agoI remember a friend having a 64MB computer and struggling to play Diablo II. It would always lag. I upgraded him to 512MB using some old RAM sticks. The game never lagged again.
- wyldfire 4y agoBattery life. Many of us using memory are using it on portable devices. And even if we're using servers, the power consumed there matters too. Refreshing that RAM costs power and more RAM means more energy -- even if the memory is unused.
- monksy 4y agoDefragmentation isn't as big of an issue on SSDs, but trimming is an issue.
- throwaway0asd 4y agoImagine the revolution when UltraRAM becomes common and inexpensive. Then everybody can have terabytes of storage as cheap as hard disks and faster than today's RAM. Benefits: * Fast. 2.5x faster (at least) than RAM when running at the same bandwidth because it does not need to be refreshed. This was proven by Intel's insanely expensive persistent Optanium memory. RAM requires an electronic refresh at least every 65ms or it loses its contents. * Archival. Contents could last, with integrity, past a 1000 years. * Massive. The goal isn't to replace RAM, but to replace hard disks. Since UltraRAM will be faster than RAM functional obsolescence immediately applies. Storage and memory become a single volume. When UltraRAM does become available technologies dependent upon memory optimization and current storage innovation also achieve functional obsolescence for the first time in computer history, which includes database applications. Databases will essentially become a high level storage mechanism on top of faster lower level storage mechanisms like file systems.
- naniwaduni 4y agoSo are we expecting UltraRAM to become commercially viable before or after the Mill architecture?
- zamadatix 4y agoI'll take cheaper flash any day but when you start talking about making RAM obsolete the metric will be latency not bandwidth. I can already stick e.g. 4x PCIe 4 NVMe drives into a x16 slot or a 32 into an AMD server and beat whatever the RAM bandwidth and cost/GB will be it's just not very useful to do so so nobody really does it as a RAM replacement.
- Dwedit 4y agoOn a related note, the computer from Mega Man X has 8192TB of "real mem", 32768TB of "avail mem", and laughably small cache sizes of 512KB, 768KB, and 32768KB.
- jl6 4y agoIt took Weird Al a further 7 years to perfect the tech diss track: https://genius.com/Weird-al-yankovic-white-and-nerdy-lyrics https://genius.com/Weird-al-yankovic-white-and-nerdy-lyrics
- mgaunard 4y agoI don't understand how defragmentation isn't an issue on SSDs. It's mostly a filesystem problem, not a hardware problem.
- antod 4y agoThere's a difference between something still existing and something still being a problem. The reason it was a problem on spinning disks, was that the delay in getting the next bit of data highly depended on where it was relative to the previous bit. With SSDs (as I understand it) looking up any bit of data is (just about?) independent of where it is located. So, it's still a thing - but the cure (involving lots of wear) is a lot worse than the disease now.
- mgaunard 4y agoIf you read data to an arbitrary position in a file, you first need to figure out in which block(s) that data is located. If the file is fragmented, this may require more reads than if it's contiguous and uses an extent. Exact scheme is filesystem-specific.
- antod 4y agoYeah, that was one of the reasons I said "just about". But minuscule compared to millisecond seek latencies on a spinning disk. So the problem getting orders of magnitude smaller while the costs of the cure increasing a lot swung the equation away from defragging being a good thing overall.
- paulkrush 4y agoI encourage you to google this.
- BizarroLand 4y agoSpinny hard drives have a master record file that tells the seek heads where all the parts of the data lie on the magnetic material. It takes time for the read arms to move back and forth to literally read the data on the sector indicated by the master record file, and defragmenting the drive helped minimize that by moving the files around to be a linearly arranged as physically possible given the sophistication of the given system. SSDs also have a similar master record file, indicating where all of the bits of the files are located on the flash memory in the hard drive, but since it makes at most the most atomically minute difference in seek times for the controller to read the data from those sectors (since there is no seek arm that has to physically move to the physical location nor any delay waiting for the spin of the disk to reach the correct location for the data read to begin) then file "fragmentation" has the most negligibly minuscule impact on file read speeds or drive performance, and given the dramatic increase in destructive writes that a file defragmentation would cause on an SSD, it should be avoided under any regular usage.
- zitterbewegung 4y agoMy MacBook Pro M1 Max has 64 and an M2 Max will probably top out at 96 if they use Samsungs new 12 GB LPDDR5. An entry Level laptop now comes with 16 GB. Scaling is just not as fast because with RAM either has sweet spots and swapping is much faster with SSDs. To be quite honest if you interpret his lyrics the people with lots of ram are Prosumers or professionals which can get 100gb of ram or more it’s not just about the SOCs
- andyjohnson0 4y ago"Case took the pink handset from its cradle and punched a Hongkong number from memory. He let it ring five times, then hung up. His buyer for the three megabytes of hot RAM in the Hitachi wasn't taking calls." - Neuromancer, by William Gibson, 1984
- NovaVeles 4y agoYeah, that would do it. :D My work PC is currently using 8.4GB with outlook, Excel and note pad open!
- cybrexalpha 4y ago'Workstation-class' computers absolutely can have 128 GB of memory, or even more. Even Apple does this (not just on the Mac Pro, you can configure the Mac Studio for it too). On the PC side all AMD Threadrippers can support at least that much, as can the Intel i9. These aren't server-class CPUs that require ECC memory or anything exotic like that either. Normal consumer hardware.
- sleepytimetea 4y agoI regularly work on servers with 768 GB of ECC RAM. These aren't very common but they do exist. I am trying to upgrade to a terabyte of ECC RAM. On Amazon, they sell a 32x32GB package of ECC RAM for about $10k. https://www.amazon.com/Adamanta-32x32GB-Upgrade-PC4-17000-Registered/dp/B01M1IMRQG https://www.amazon.com/Adamanta-32x32GB-Upgrade-PC4-17000-Re...
- anthk 4y agoWith that amount of RAM you could bind an entire VM storage on it by using /dev/shm or some other TMPFS directory. Amazing.
- buildbot 4y agoIt was probably possible with ultra-high end servers/mainframe like systems even in 1999: https://shrubbery.net/~heas/sun-feh-2_1/Systems/E10000/spec.html https://shrubbery.net/~heas/sun-feh-2_1/Systems/E10000/spec....
- bombcar 4y agoYeah you had to go to Unix systems or similar because PAE x86 couldn’t get past 64GB.
- sxates 4y agoIf anyone want's to one-up Weird Al, you can configure an Apple Mac Studio with 128GB of RAM for a mere $4800. https://www.apple.com/shop/buy-mac/mac-studio/20-core-cpu-48-core-gpu-32-core-neural-engine-64gb-memory-1tb https://www.apple.com/shop/buy-mac/mac-studio/20-core-cpu-48...
- userbinator 4y agoIt's also worth noting that 64-bit x86 processors only appeared a few years after the song, with all 32-bit systems until then being limited to a theoretical maximum of 64GB (with PAE). The general public isn’t asking for a hundred gigs, but I’d love to see the baseline rise up a bit. I'm still comfortable with 4GB (and currently using ~1GB of it), because I stay away from the bloated web stuff. Outside of certain applications, I think there really isn't a need for huge amounts of RAM; unlike e.g. storage, which even I have several TBs of, simply because of accumulating media.
- VerminOctopus1 4y agoI can’t imagine how esoteric your setup must be to be fine with 4GB. Modern software eats that up with no problem.
- mod 4y agoNot GP, but about 75% of the time, I'm not using any GUI software besides browser & terminal. In the terminal I'm running a tmux/vim based development environment. Of the half dozen non-technical users whose habits I know, I think all of them use their PC exclusively for a browser. They could sub in a chromebook, I guess.
- userbinator 4y agoI mainly do native (Win32) development. Like I said, staying far away from anything "modern web" related seems to make the biggest difference.
- ozaark 4y agoI have a 2008 Mac Pro with 64GB ram installed ¯\_(ツ)_/¯
- bearbearbear 4y ago
- whoisterencelee 4y agoIt's about deminishing returns, the more ram you have the more likely you need to move bytes around. For applications that are moving more bytes from drives to memory, this means we need to wait for the transfer and we end up preferring to delegate these applications to the cloud instead of running on our own machine, because servers are where the ram is increasing and abundant. So basically we are doing a lot more big ram computation elsewhere and doing small ram computation on our desktop
- IIAOPSW 4y agoI at first read "Weird AI" rather than "Weird Al" and it took way too long to figure out my mistake.
- brunorsini 4y agoGetting a 64 gb 2021 MacBook Pro really changed the game for me. The computer now works on my rhythm, not its own. No need to suspend tabs or do any other shenanigans. Sometimes it's just not productive to stop everything to clean up tabs and/or open apps. Some rabbit holes are actually quite worth digging into, and they are often RAM-hungry! Going from 16 to 64 gb on my personal laptop meant I got to choose when to deal with my own mess... on my own terms. I much prefer to do this cleaning exercise on weekends, versus "whenever the computer starts choking up". So yeah, highly agree with the author here. Wish Apple laptops were RAM upgradable, but I doubt that will be coming anytime soon.
- dusted 4y agoIt's kind of terrible that people are still stuck on 16 and even 8 gib of memory, and we're suffering for it.. Firefox recently introduced the most retarded feature ever.. Unloading tabs, that breaks javascript applications and gives an unreasonably bad experience.. I disabled it, but it keeps changing back to being enabled.. I have 128 gib of memory in this machine.. I don't care if firefox uses 10 or 20 of them.. It's 2022, it's sort of ridiculous that we still even have memory tiers.. I want my on-die 16 TiB nonvolatile RAM, and I want it two years ago!
- habosa 4y agoAny computer targeted at business users really needs to start at 16GB minimum. I can't understand why 8GB is still the default base configuration on almost every computer. My company made the mistake of ordering 8GB M1 MacBook Pros for everyone. After all ... they say "Pro", right? Truly the worst computer I've ever used, all because of memory management (and M1s unique memory-sharing architecture). Even simple tasks like opening a new tab or switching windows showed serious lag. I could not run my local dev server and listen to music at the same time. We eventually just said "screw it" and bought all new 16GB MacBook Airs. 1000x better.
- 5e92cb50239222b 4y agoIn other words, you still decided to support a manufacturer that makes it impossible to simply insert another stick of RAM (like we've been doing for decades) and requires you to throw a whole computer away. Or sell it, whatever, you've said that it's pretty much unusable already in spite of being new. Seeing that from one of the poorer countries, you guys really do have too much money.
- ehutch79 4y agothe 13" pro and air are basically the same machine :-/ I'm pretty sure they're keeping that pro because it's a physical drop in replacement for previous models, just for business that want that continuity. That 8gb though. I had to switch to one when my last macbook died. I could develop on it fine, but chrome and teams killed me. Especially teams where it's just now getting a native release. There's no reason a lot of apps are using as much memory as they do. 8gb _should_ be more than fine for any office worker. I'm growing on the idea that developers shouldn't be getting massive amounts of memory in their machines, so they can feel any pain their users will.
- HereIGoAgain 4y agoOK.... This is certainly a topic.. fun to read at least. lol
- zecg 4y agoRAM uses power, 8GB of DDR3 was something like 3W and once you have 16GB in a personal computer, you simply don't need more for everyday use.
- foobarbecue 4y agoI've often wondered this -- why isn't it normal for consumer systems to support more RAM? I built a PC with 256GB DDR4 in 2016 for working with large pointclouds, but most motherboards I looked at only supported 64GB max, and the situation doesn't seem to have changed in the last 6 years. I guess it's because the emphasis with RAM has been on improving speed rather than volume.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- magicalhippo 4y agoWere you thinking about adding more RAM slots, or why the sticks aren't larger? The reason the sticks aren't larger seems to be because they had trouble scaling down the DRAM memory cells[1] since about 2016. DRAM works, as you might know, by letting a capacitor hold a charge (or not). This ability is a function of the geometry of the capacitor: the area of the anode and cathode, as well as the distance between them. Leakage current discharges the capacitor, hence why DRAM needs to be periodically refreshed, the industry settled on 64ms retention time per cell[2]. Leakage current tends to go up when the features shrink, due to there being less insulation between the conductors. As mentioned in [1] it seems things are about to change, so perhaps we'll see much larger sticks in the near future. If you were thinking of slots, I think that's more economics and feasibility. The Threadripper motherboards had 8 slots[3], since the CPU supported it, but they were quite expensive compared to regular Ryzen motherboards. It also requires a lot more power, so forget having that in laptops. And the slots take up space, so was only for the full ATX size[4]. [1]: https://www.allaboutcircuits.com/news/micron-unveils-1a-dram-process-node-highest-density-dram-to-date/ https://www.allaboutcircuits.com/news/micron-unveils-1a-dram... [2]: https://www.csl.cornell.edu/~martinez/doc/isca13-mukundan.pdf https://www.csl.cornell.edu/~martinez/doc/isca13-mukundan.pd... [3]: https://www.asrock.com/MB/AMD/X399%20Taichi/index.asp https://www.asrock.com/MB/AMD/X399%20Taichi/index.asp [4]: https://www.asrock.com/mb/AMD/X399M%20Taichi/index.asp https://www.asrock.com/mb/AMD/X399M%20Taichi/index.asp
- dr-detroit 4y ago
- donatj 4y agoI bought a Mac Studio recently with 64gb of RAM. I adore it, but I am kind of missing the portability of a laptop. I’ve been watching Facebook Marketplace recently for a cheap Mac Laptop, and I was surprised to find the place is absolutely flooded with near-new MacBook Pros with 8gb of RAM. It doesn’t make any sense, it’s the worst place to cheap out - it’s not upgradable and makes a huge performance difference. I suspect it might be self-selecting. The reason there are so many on Facebook Marketplace is because the owners can feel they need an upgrade. Do they know the reason for it’s lackluster performance being the lack of RAM? Maybe not, they just know the machine runs poorly and are going to upgrade to a newer one with 8gb of RAM. To contrast my 11 year old iMac I was upgrading from has 24gb of RAM and still held up fine as my daily driver. The lack of software upgrades being the thing that pushed me to upgrade.
- stockerta 4y agoSame, I have a 2nd generation intel i5 desktop at home. since I have upgraded to an SSD and the RAM from 8 to 24gb it gained years of new life. Perfectly capable daily driver.
- FractalHQ 4y agoI bought a MacBook with 64gb ram in 2019 and it’s a beast. So much so that I haven’t felt the need to upgrade to Apple silicon yet.
- DanHulton 4y agoHuh, that's interesting! I had a 2019 MBP with only 16gb of RAM - an amount I've been comfortable with on other computers prior to that - and it was UNUSABLE. Just MISERABLY slow. Upgraded to Apple Silicon with the same amount of RAM and it feels unstoppable, just always running at 150% of expected speed. (I would have gotten more RAM in the 2019 laptop, but it was during that brief window where new laptop shipping times were measured in months, and I was happy to have ANY work laptop and not have to be using my old personal one, an old Air.)
- cesaref 4y agoLast time I worked in finance, the typical 2U machines that we ordered were configured by IT with 256Gb by default unless we said otherwise. The typical workload was data analytics, and when you've got lots of cores, you get through RAM pretty quick for those sorts of workloads (and any spare caches data which is also useful). Home machines are typically consuming rather than producing stuff, so it seems reasonable that the RAM hasn't leapt ahead, since typical workloads aren't memory bound.
- dzdt 4y agoWeird Al's song released in 1999 [1]. I don't think it was possible to buy a desktop/workstation/server machine in 1999 with 100gb of addressable RAM. So the lyric is absurd (possibly intentionally so). The first 64 bit Pentium system went to market in 2004. With 32 bit systems the maximum memory addressable per process is 4gb; this could be stretched to 64gb with PAE [2]. It might have been possible to get a 64gb RAM pentium-based server in 1999. But 100GB is simply impossible. There were 64 bit processors from other families available in 1999. DEC, SGI, and Sun all had workstations using 64 bit processors. The earliest I can find supporting 128gb of RAM though is the SGI Origin 3800, shipping in 2001. [3] [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Running_with_Scissors_(%22Weird_Al%22_Yankovic_album) https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Running_with_Scissors_(%22We... [2] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physical_Address_Extension https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Physical_Address_Extension [3] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SGI_Origin_3000_and_Onyx_3000#Onyx_3000 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/SGI_Origin_3000_and_Onyx_300...
- ACV001 4y ago100G back then was more of a satire, something unimaginable. However, it is true that installed RAM hasn't increased a lot.. Actually it is not very true, in the mid 2000 4 GB was standard and now 16GB is more or less standard. But, RAM has increased in price A LOT around 2011 when there was a RAM production crisis. "After the 2011 earthquake in Japan, there was a severe chip shortage of NAND memory and displays." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chip_shortage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chip_shortage
- gmiller123456 4y agomid 2000 4 GB was standard I don't think so. From [1], in 2006 a Dell XPS M1710 costs $2,845 and had 1Gb of RAM. Inflation adjusted, that's $3,550, so a pretty high end system for the time. Today, you can get a 16Gb laptop for well under $1000. That's a 16x capacity increase in about as many years for 1/4th the price. [1] https://247wallst.com/special-report/2019/06/07/cost-of-a-computer-the-year-you-were-born/9/ https://247wallst.com/special-report/2019/06/07/cost-of-a-co...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- quickthrower2 4y agoIt is ridiculous that to get more than 16gb laptop PC it has to be a heavy gaming laptop, super expensive with high power consumption. At least here in australia. And the 16gb ones can’t be upgraded further.
- iconosynclast 4y agoI'm amazed by the number of people here that think 16 or even 8 gigs are "enough" for everyday use. Sure you CAN live like that but it's noticably painful with even the most pedestrian of usage. open a browser and a handful of tabs, there goes 4 gigs, open some messengers and you got another couple gigs gone. maybe that's fine as long as browser and messengers are literally all you do but the machine becoming painfully slow to use as soon as you go from background level usage to any sort of productivity is not "good enough" by a long shot IMO
- ehutch79 4y agoIs the problem actually the lack of ram though? We used to browse the web just fine on megabytes of ram... Now I expect modern sites to take my resources, but 1000x more?
- iconosynclast 4y agoarguably the problem is the excessive use of the resource but that's kinda just the reality of it. I'm not saying it's impossible to deal with it but it's no where near the point where I never have to think about it which is what I would consider truly "enough"
- Ancapistani 4y agoMy primary "personal" system is an M1 MBP with 8GB of RAM. I edit 6K video on it all the time. While it could certainly use more RAM, I don't feel like I need it bad enough to justify spending the money right now. My gaming desktop only has 16GB of RAM. It's the fastest DDR4 that my motherboard will support, granted, but all of the games I play on it are CPU or GPU bound. Additional RAM isn't going to significantly help anything.
- iconosynclast 4y agoIt's acceptable and can do a lot for sure but I was getting the vibe a lot of people consider more basically pointless which it IMO isn't. I think with a little bit of multitasking most users would experience a noticable improvement
- gthrone 4y agoThis just made my day. He's randomly touring right now as well
- leephillips 4y agoThe mere existence of this article about this particular song and this discussion about amount to a high level of (mostly) unintended meta-hilarity. “The first, and most obvious reason, was that the song was supposed to be a bit silly!” +5 insightful.
- _yb2s 4y agoYou guys must also think 50 cent always carries guns as big as an adult human, Ice Cube has literally shot bullets into the sun, and Ludacris never drives under 100mph. Al is satirizing hyperbole in rap music. The stream of implausible claims is why the song is funny- 100gb of hard drive space wouldn't have fit with the song at all. Also, plenty of people were actually using computers with 100gb of ram in the late 90s. ASCI Red at Sandia had 1,212gb of ram in 1997. Blue Gene/L, which they were building when this song came out had 16,000gb of ram and was designed to be upgradeable to as much as 128,000gb - even much more if the node quantity were maxed as well.