12 ms·
Interest in heat pumps has increased dramatically in recent years
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- belter 4y agoWhen reading many of these articles always miss a condensed explanation of what a Heat Pump really is. In some countries they are common, while in others, seems they are very rare. "Heating and Cooling With a Heat Pump" - https://www.nrcan.gc.ca/energy-efficiency/energy-star-canada/about/energy-star-announcements/publications/heating-and-cooling-heat-pump/6817 https://www.nrcan.gc.ca/energy-efficiency/energy-star-canada... "Heat pump" - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_pump https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_pump
- ChuckNorris89 4y agoRegardless of implementation, a heat pump is basically a reverse air conditioner: taking heat energy form outside and brining it in your house. The main components are also the same as an AC: heat exchangers, a compressor, refrigerant fluid and piping. Where exactly outside you tap in for that heat energy and how the outdoor heat exchangers look like varies depending on implementation, but the principle is the same.
- whoooooo123 4y agoIs there any meaningful difference between a heat pump and an air conditioner, other than the direction the heat is pumped in? Wouldn't it be more accurate to say that an air conditioner is a type of heat pump?
- jasode 4y ago>Is there any meaningful difference between a heat pump and an air conditioner, other than the direction the heat is pumped in? In terms of basic science, they are the same principle so "air conditioner" is a type of "heat pump". But in terms of semantics that is understood by the general public for purposes of differentiating various HVAC equipment one can buy, a heat pump has an extra reversing valve to change the flow of refrigerant. A standard air conditioner doesn't have that extra feature. When folks casually say "heat pumps", they're talking about a HVAC equipment category and not general science principles.
- otikik 4y agoUS people call them heat pumps because they have been calling the non-reversible cold-only kind “air conditioner” so they needed a new term. In Europe most units are reversible cold/heat unit so “air conditioning” means making air both colder and hotter. We would call the ACs the Americans have “air coolers”, if we needed to make the difference.
- contravariant 4y agoAlthough to be more exact it's a reverse engine, where an engine is a device for turning a temperature gradient into work, and a heat pump is a device for turning work into a temperature gradient. In this view air conditioners are a kind of heat pump.
- ornornor 4y agoTechnology connections on YT has a fantastic video on heat pumps, how they work, their energy efficiency… highly recommended
- sokoloff 4y agoThat video: https://youtu.be/7J52mDjZzto https://youtu.be/7J52mDjZzto
- magic_hamster 4y agoTC have a wonderful presentation, but like all YouTube channels, should be taken with a grain of salt. TC made a fair share of errorenous claims, some of which they addressed in follow up videos (definitely not all). One example they never addressed was in their dishwasher video where they explained how a dishwasher worked (which was good) and then pushed to stop using capsules in favor of soap powder. Using powder requires more maintenance because you'll have to buy special salt and run your dishwasher with it but this was never mentioned in the video. The capsules have this so you don't have to add anything else. If you followed their advice blindly, you could damage your dishwasher. Ask technicians what to use and they'll all say the capsules are better for your appliance. Always trust professionals over YouTube videos.
- codewench 4y agoThe salts issue was actually mentioned in a follow up video [0], with the note that only homes with specific water types (excessively hard water if I remember correctly) will require them. [0] https://youtu.be/Ll6-eGDpimU?t=2099 https://youtu.be/Ll6-eGDpimU?t=2099
- styfle 4y agoIt seems odd to account for hard water in one appliance but not another. I’ve lived in places with hard water and most people have a water softener right next to their water heater so that all water to all appliances in the house is softened.
- ssizn 4y agoIt sounds like something fancy but it’s common where I live. It’s usually hot all year round so it made sense to buy an air conditioner with a heat pump built in. Although it’s been a few years since we last turned it in because it’s never cold enough to justify the electricity usage given the always high prices here in Europe. So perhaps it doesn’t even work anymore :P
- ricardobayes 4y agoThe key as to why is probably lies with the price of gas vs electricity. Countries where natural gas is cheap, you won't find heatpumps.
- foepys 4y agoEverybody already has a small heat pump at home. It's the part that makes the refrigerator cold.
- RandomWorker 4y agoIt’s basically a reversed refrigerator. In the box heat get pumped out from a power temperature to a hotter one the room. Open your fridge door to the outside and the radiator into the home it’s done.
- oezi 4y agoI haven't understood why they are called heat pumps now when it is essentially the same as a AC.
- toast0 4y agoAn heatpump is either an Air Conditioner (which is really jusf a refrigerator) running in reverse, or an A/C with a reversing valve so it can move (pump) heat in either direction, depending on the application. Heat pump driers and water heaters never cool the clothes or the water, but home heat pumps are almost always setup for heating or cooling.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoThanks for the links! The Canadian one is great!
- LatteLazy 4y agoFor heat pumps to work, you need well insulated houses. This means you're more likely to get them in colder environments (Canada) than more temperate ones (here in the UK)
- hedora 4y agoNot true. You can just buy a bigger heat pump if you don't want to spring for insulation. There is a question around time to pay off though. If you run it one day a year, you may as well buy the cheapest possible thing.
- 2Gkashmiri 4y agoI am in the market for a heat pump. A bit of back story. When we built our home in 2003, we had plumbing for central heating put in with the idea that we would get a boiler, a lot of kerosene and get heating. Sadly, but the time the home was finished, kerosene started to reach unreasonable levels which continues to this day. Never had any boiler or even the radiators put in. Over the past year or so , I found how people are using heatpumps to heat the water at 40-55°C, that water can be used to warm the house. Tried to talk to some installers including the one who set up the plumbing, they are not convinced. One said " the life of a heat pump is like 10 years. If you buy one, you will use it only for 10 seasons and the cost of that is quite a lot so the math does not check out. To note, we don't have at whole house heating right now. Tried to find YouTube but there isn't a lot of material on using heat pumps with central heating.
- ricardobayes 4y ago40 to 55C is good for underfloor heating. Which in most cases unfortunately is way too costly to install, in an existing structure as you'd need to rip out all your floors and the ground beneath it, to allow for 8 cm of tubing in a cement structure.
- rjsw 4y agoThere is a big push in Europe to replace gas central heating boilers with heat pumps, from before there were any problems with the supply of gas, I think the information available on them will improve quite quickly. My brother has installed one for his house but I have not done yet.
- BonoboIO 4y agoHeatpumps at least in Austria are the preferred heating method for like 10 years if you build new or renovate. They just work and it’s interesting to see that they are the new sh*t in the US.
- kleiba 4y agoThat's right. My sister's family built their house 11 years ago in Germany, and they have a heat pump too. I think it's pretty standard for new residential builds.
- contravariant 4y agoDo heat pumps still have a high enough efficiency at temperatures of over 150 degrees to justify the investment? I suppose the theoretical efficiency is still around 300% but I'm not sure how close heat pumps can get to the theoretical limits.
- adgjlsfhk1 4y agothey should. in general, the main time they drop significantly below theoretical efficiency is when the cold end gets iced up which wouldn't be a problem here.
- sokoloff 4y agoPage 79 has a bit of info on COP (efficiency) vs LLT (leaving liquid temp). With intelligent management of LLT, your install will spend a lot of the year at 120°F or lower, where the efficiency is fairly high. If you end up with 2-3 days of COP under 2.0, that’s not catastrophic if you spend 40-50x as much of the season at COP of 3.5+. You can probably find the outdoor temperature histogram for your area and figure out what your overall heating profile looks like. But, if you need 150°F water a lot, AWHPs are probably not a good fit.
- contravariant 4y agoOh were the temperatures mentioned in Fahrenheit? Then that makes things a bit easier, I thought they needed 150°C.
- sokoloff 4y agoIn that article (for industrial process heating), it could be in °C. For home heating, 150°C would be far too dangerous to circulate.
- nkurz 4y agoNo, the temperatures are in Celsius. From the white paper linked from the main article: "This paper makes a distinction between low temperature (<200°C) and high temperature (>200°C) process heat". https://www.sintef.no/globalassets/sintef-energi/industrial-heat-pump-whitepaper/2020-07-10-whitepaper-ihp-a4.pdf https://www.sintef.no/globalassets/sintef-energi/industrial-...
- Waterluvian 4y agoIn addition to a heat pump, I wish my HVAC had a filtered vent from the outside and would be intelligent enough to sometimes just pump in cooler or warmer air from the outside when viable. I don’t like having to shut off my furnace and manually manage windows. But I also don’t want automatic windows. I just want it to be like, “you’re asking for 21C and we can get there by pumping in outside air rather than using an AC to transfer heat from the inside air to the outside air.”
- bombcar 4y agoThere are machines that do just that. They’re descended from commercial units, and you have to match humidity, but they can be done. It’s just not been worth the cost, usually.
- bofh23 4y agoThis “Smart Window Fan” is a window-mounted economizer. If it’s cooler and dryer outside, like at night, it opens its louvers and pulls in cool air and exhausts warm air. It also has a HEPA filter. I assume it has humidity sensors too to avoid running when it’s humid outside. I am wary of a product sold by only one vendor. Economizers tend to be added to large central ducted commercial HVAC systems and this is the only window unit I’m aware of. EcoBreeze 2.2 - Nature's Cooling Solutions® https://naturescoolingsolutions.com/ecobreeeze-2/ https://naturescoolingsolutions.com/ecobreeeze-2/
- Dig1t 4y agoYou must have a well insulated house.. as soon as I turn off my AC or heater my house very quickly becomes the same temperature as outside..
- ghaff 4y agoReally? I live in a mostly not very well-insulated 200 year old wood construction farm house and I find that there can easily be a 10 degree F delta between indoors and outdoors. I have heat for the winter given northern climate but otherwise mostly just do regulation by opening or closing windows.
- jwie 4y agoHeat pumps are air conditioning systems. They work on the refrigeration cycle. Rural homes in the US tend not to have connections to natural gas utilities. If winter isn’t severe enough to justify a storage tank, the home typically has an HVAC heat pump/AC unit, and really high electric bills for a month or two. Heat pumps have gotten better, but they’re never a first choice for heating for good reasons. Like most “emissions saving” initiatives the crux of it is where the electricity comes from. Burning something for heat is always more effective, cheaper, and produces fewer emissions compared to an electric heater. Heat pumps need to power a compressor, while there’s some phase change and pressure hacks to move the heat around, systematically it’s trading electricity for heat. If you’re getting electric heat from coal fired steam that’s always worse than burning the coal locally to heat something, and this is true for all emission-producing power sources.
- ctur 4y agoWhat? No, this is incredibly short-sighted. It overlooks the fact that much grid energy is renewable already and will become more so in the future. Go with electric sources for cooking and heating (home and water), then let the grid handle being renewable. Heat pumps are amazing technology and moving heat, vs generating it, is incredibly efficient and clean. Do not burn fissile fuels in your home.
- sokoloff 4y ago> Do not burn fissile fuels in your home. Completely agree; that would be incredibly dangerous and polluting (and probably illegal)!
- tialaramex 4y agoBuffy had it right, "Fire bad, tree pretty".
- tialaramex 4y agoYou seem to have only half understood? The heat pump is only moving the heat. Burning coal doesn't move heat, it makes heat by destroying coal. Because the heat pump isn't making the heat it is able to move the same amount of heat from somewhere else (say, the outside air) into your home, using less energy than you'd need to make that heat inside your home. Because you can't destroy heat (thermodynamics) for refrigerators we have no choice, we must use heat pumps. But once you get good at this technology, it's just better regardless of whether you want to move the heat away (Air conditioning, refrigerator) or towards you (heating a home). This is how heat pumps claim seriously > 100% efficiency in many cases, they're comparing the efficiency of moving heat against making it.
- knolan 4y agoYour refrigerator is a heat pump. If you put something warm in there its heat is drawn out to the environment heating your kitchen. A refrigerant is used to achieve this. When it’s pressure is reduced it will evaporate absorbing thermal energy from its surroundings to change phase. When pumped around it’s circuit and compressed and accordingly condenses releasing all that energy to its surroundings. The electrical energy required pumps the fluid and drives the compressor. Of course there will be some heating due to heating of the mechanical components. A lot of homes here in Ireland (and I presume elsewhere in Europe) must be built to an ‘A level’ build energy rating. This typically means installing PV Solar or heat pumps. Rarely both. My modest solar installation on my three year old house only provides about 40% of my electricity needs (typical daily import is 8 kWh and generation is 5 kWh). Winter is a different story. Most heat pumps here are air to water systems. Homes don’t require AC here but you can get air to air systems that can heat or cool your home as needed. The benefit of a heat pump is it’s coefficient of performance (CoP). This is the amount of thermal energy you get out for electrical energy put in. A typical system can sustain a CoP of between 3 and 4. However this drops off as the outside temperature drops and you push up the heating demanded. They should be as reliable and performant as your fridge or AC unit. So you many need to replace the pump or refill the refrigerant. Another interesting technology is a so called solid state heat pump or thermoelectric module. These have an awful CoP usually much less than unity. They are interesting for thermal management due to their size however. You can aggressively cook a small high-flux component and then deal with the thermal load form the hot side of the TEC with a big cooler. You can even stack them. Their efficiency increases as the temperature difference goes to zero so a stack with a small temperature jump between layers can be better. They also work in reverse and can therefore be used to scavenge electrical power when you have hot and cold reservoirs. For example put one on the exhaust of your car and you can harvest enough energy to charge your phone.
- Nextgrid 4y agoWhat’s the advantage of an air-to-water heat pump as opposed to an air-to-air system? Why are they used for new buildings, instead of a standard A/C indoor unit which can also offer cooling?
- 4y ago
- intrasight 4y agoI have made a successful offer on a house. When I had initially walked through with realtor, I looked at the furnace and thought something was amiss. Then during inspection, the inspector told me that it was a heat pump, and it's only about two years old. My first reaction was "on no - electric heat". But later I Googled and found a page that has a cost calculator. https://www.columbiagaspa.com/services/add-or-convert-to-gas/calculate-your-savings https://www.columbiagaspa.com/services/add-or-convert-to-gas... It looks like it will be ~20% less to have a heat pump. Also natural gas prices are forecast to continue up and make the heat pump even more cost effective. I still do wish there was gas service to the house. But I doubt that I want it enough to pay for the installation.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIf the house has no gas connection at all then, depending on local regulations, they may have been able to insulate to a higher standard, and so you save even more money. Because of combustion you need extra ventilation designed in. That and the connection cost make it an easy choice for newly built homes.
- nkurz 4y ago> depending on local regulations, they may have been able to insulate to a higher standard Are you implying that some places have maximum amounts of insulation that are allowed for new construction? This seems backwards.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoNo, but they'll insist on minimum ventilation if you burn stuff, which usually involves letting heated/cooled air out with the toxins.
- Scoundreller 4y agoDrove me bonkers that “over-the-range” microwaves are unavailable in europe. Probably because they assume everyone uses gas and would set them on fire, or that it’s impossible for them to vent fast enough.
- ctur 4y agoIt feels obligatory to reference Technology Connection in a thread about heat pumps. TC is a super fun YouTube channel that digs j to everyday technology and has had a number of episodes on heat pumps and modern thermodynamic management challenges and technologies. https://youtu.be/7J52mDjZzto https://youtu.be/7J52mDjZzto
- bcjordan 4y agoCame here to post this :D The TC channel is definitely a hacker's eye view in to all the technologies that we take for granted every day. Tons of fascinating tech history covered, too. Other fun ones: - a defense of the simple drip coffee maker https://youtu.be/Sp9H0MO-qS8 https://youtu.be/Sp9H0MO-qS8 - why do the turn signals not sync up when you're at a stop light? https://youtu.be/2z5A-COlDPk https://youtu.be/2z5A-COlDPk - how humidifiers work and ehy the simple swamp cooler style are pretty ideal https://youtu.be/oHeehYYgl28 https://youtu.be/oHeehYYgl28 - why dishwasher detergent packs are stupid (use powder/liquid) and why you should use the pre-wash slot and not bother pre rinsing your plates https://youtu.be/_rBO8neWw04 https://youtu.be/_rBO8neWw04 - why do light switches click? https://youtu.be/jrMiqEkSk48 https://youtu.be/jrMiqEkSk48
- oezi 4y ago> - why dishwasher detergent packs are stupid (use powder/liquid) ? I thought that powder and liquid for dishwashers have come out worse on any consumer reports test (at least here in Germany).
- mschild 4y agoDetergent packs in the US seem to be mostly gel packs. In Germany, most tabs are simply hard pressed powder. Gel packs did fail in their cleaning function and the recommendation generally goes for either tabs or powder, where powder can save you money because you set the dosage according to how full your dishwasher is.
- lupire 4y ago
- stormdennis 4y agoThe focus today is also on insulation ie preventing heat loss. That means making houses less draughty. But draughty houses are also healthy houses. More fresh air and less mould. I think it would be better if people accepted that in Winter it's going to be colder indoors so wear thermal underwear etc.
- tialaramex 4y agoIt is possible to considerably improve the heat insulation of a building while still allowing turnover of fresh air. We don't specifically want to throw away the heat, we just want to change the air, and you can arrange to do that. The laws of thermodynamics forbid us from arranging to keep all the hotter molecules and lose the cool ones, but they allow us to insist on a roughly fair swap, hot air going out gets cooler, cold air coming in gets warmer. This will be more expensive than just sealing everything up and hoping, but that's the sort of reason why you want somebody figuring out how to do it properly and only subsidising work that we know insulates homes without destroying ventilation so that they're horrible to live in. Modern homes here have much better heat insulation than when I was a kid, yet there isn't the damp problem I saw in cheaply retro-fitted rental places where I lived.
- simooooo 4y agoYa lost me half way, but sounds like you’re describing HRV
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoIts called heat recovery ventillation, its the cheapest and most cost efficient improvement you can make to your life, house and energy bill. You will have fresh air, control humidity and use 95% of the heat in your house air to heat incoming air from outside. It solves problems with mould and humidty. You can seal your house from the elments A 'box' that does everything costs just 1 grand, just install ducting and you are done.
- Jill_the_Pill 4y agoDo you know: is this tech useful for hot water radiator/boiler systems or is it just for air?
- kkfx 4y agoThere are two issue in heating a home with a heat-pump: - one is for new homes, well insulated that do not demand much energy and have a p.v. system, so they need ways to minimize all costs, one way is if space is not an issue, to heat large quantity of water and store them to grab heat at night. For instance if you need 40kWh to heat the home for a night having something able to push 1000l of water let's say from 20 to 60℃ quickly enough to run on winter Sun from p.v. means free heat for the night [1]; - one is for those with old homes, who simply need MUCH thermal energy. They do not have much choices, so they need powerful heat-pumps and in that case low temp heating it's not much an option, they need high temperature water. This is interesting for another consideration: most "efficient" electrical devices are built to consume less overall, but their load profile is TERRIBLE for a p.v. inverter. Witch means that a modern tumbler with a heat-pump not only costs more and last less than a classic ones but if you have p.v. it means LESS self-consumption. Similarly for ovens who try "pushing the heat" instead of give large amount of energy: they tend to have pulse loads that are terrible for a p.v. inverter. That's a thing their OEMs must consider in the present and future models. [1] if some are curious thermal kWh = 4.2 kJ/kg·℃ * (initial_temp-final_temp) * volume_in_liters * 1/3600 h/s witch means in the above example 4.2(60-20)1000*(1/3600) = 46.67kWh
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIf you have a hot water store its relatively cheap to dump excess electricity as heat when you have nothing better to do with it. Not as magically efficient as heat pumps but possibly still worth it overall abd there's already products that meet this need on the market.
- kkfx 4y agoI do that already, but just for home sanitary water (sorry, do not know the name in English, water for shower etc) with the secondary resistive heating of an "old" (not on sale anymore) Daikin/Rotex M2O EKHHP 300l v3 but I can't do the same for heating: too much water is needed. Actually I'm looking to expand the system with just a set of insulated tanks (found some on sale 500l/~1kWh/day of dispersion at 60℃ inside, 5℃ outside) and a bigger external heat pump + wood stove (for emergency) to heat the water. It's just an idea because: - nothing pre-built seems to exists, apparently nobody is interested enough in try this way to save energy bills; - it not really cheap and DIY style there are many things who can break making the project more an expensive toy than an effective solution. IF I found something that seems good enough next spring I plan to expand, but it's still a relevant and generally interested issue the fact that nearly nobody talk about the dichotomy between p.v.-powered device needs to maximize self-consumption vs non-p.v. powered homes needs to reduce the total consumed energy: with a p.v. system anything should be designed to run all together at full power as much as possible, so automation to power on and off things quickly and things made to march at very different speed depending on the available power. It's far better for instance in that sense a classic resistive boiler who heat water less efficiently than a heat-pump BUT with a constant load and perhaps not a single resistance but few, to being able to "sum or reduce" the power depending on how much you can get from Sun. While if you do not have a p.v. it's far better to save as much energy as possible... Some patterns might be common, like running appliance at a dynamic point in time, one depending on the Sun, the other depending on current grid load (and so price). But many others are different. A stupid example my washing machine, with it's eco-mode actually consume less kWh, but consume MORE from the grid because it have spike loads my p.v. inverter can't satisfy quickly enough from p.v. so they goes on the grid. On contrary running an "expensive" high temp washing program my self-consumption is normally 99.99999% Surely, so far most homes do NOT have p.v. so the biggest market for any appliance is the one who do not count p.v. but is not really expensive counting it. Also it's absolutely not expensive ad ModBUS controls on anything who consume more than 1kW. It does not really change the price. It's absurd not offer such option in most appliance with a significant overprice (let's say 40€ for something that to the OEM cost just 1€).
- donny2018 4y agoIs there a heat pump technology that I can just swap my gas furnace to? With no additional insulation requirements and no other strings attached?
- SuperQue 4y agoYes. But it depends a bit on the climate where you live. What you're looking for is an air-to-air heat pump. Basically it replaces the outside unit of your traditional air conditioner. But it can heat or cool. For example: https://www.trane.com/residential/en/products/heat-pumps/ https://www.trane.com/residential/en/products/heat-pumps/
- toast0 4y agoIf they only have a gas furnace, then they may not have an outside unit currently. Piping a refrigerant line and signalling from where the furnace is to a suitable location for the outside unit may be easy or hard depending on their home. Of course, if they have a furnace and an air conditioner, it's a lot easier to change to a heat pump and that's it (or more likely, a heat pump and just in case resistive heating)
- falcolas 4y agoJust did this myself, but I augmented our gas furnace, instead of replacing it. The two technologies can work in tandem, if it gets too cold for the heat pump to work efficiently. You do need more room for the heat exchanger. But you can also get “mini split” units which are basically single room units.
- sharpercoder 4y agoIn my country, I can't install a groundwater heat pump until summer 2023. That's almost a year. Many installation companies do not even take new customers any more.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoIt feels like modern air source tech is displacing ground/water source to some degree, I'm not sure exactly when ground source makes sense but it feels like the crossover point has been moving in air sources direction. Might be worth looking into as the easier install is of course the key benefit.
- simonebrunozzi 4y agoWhich country is it?
- seniorsassycat 4y agoWould it be feasible to create a 'heat bus' to pump heat between a network of devices in a house? E.g in winter allow the fridge to dump heat into the kitchen, in the summer pipe it outside, or into the bathroom floors, or into the water heater. Install one outdoor unit in the sun or attic where it's hot and another in the cooler shade...
- grigri907 4y agoThis is pretty common in commercial buildings, though not for the heat reclaim that you're describing. It's particularly useful when you have simultaneous heating and cooling loads that can effectively serve each other.
- presentation 4y agoMarket penetration for home heat pumps here in Japan is very high, I’ve never seen an apartment that doesn’t have one in the last several years. As an American I was pretty surprised that the heating mode on my AC’s worked! https://heatpumpingtechnologies.org/market-report-japan/ https://heatpumpingtechnologies.org/market-report-japan/
- benrbray 4y agoMeanwhile houses here have no insulation or double-paned windows so it's still not cool enough and my electric bill is through the roof!
- presentation 4y agoYeah that part is a real bummer
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoI notice the title has been changed. I think some people have misunderstood the original title, which was talking about a new category of industrial heat pump, since the site is Norwegian and assumes audience familiarity with 'standard' heat pumps. Most of the conversation here is about standard heat pumps so the new title suits the conversation better, just thought it worth noting.