11 ms·
Science is political, and that's a bad thing
- cable2600 4y agoWhen Al Gore said in 1998 that California would be under water by 2005, he was exaggerating for politics. A lot of climate change data was cherry picked and exaggerated to scare people into taking action. Climate change is used as a bat to hit poor people in the head politically. The politics come from the left.
- cammikebrown 4y agoAl Gore literally never said that
- vorpalhex 4y agoHis prediction was that Manhattan would be under water, before the year 2026. > When co-anchor Katie Couric asked Al Gore on the May 24, 2006 Today show “What do you see happening in 15 to 20 years if nothing changes?…Even Manhattan would be in deep water”, he replied: “Yes, in fact the World Trade Center Memorial site would be underwater.”
- defrost 4y ago> Weekend flooding left cars submerged in New York ... ( 19 July 2022 ) > New York City is highly vulnerable to flooding from coastal storms due to its intensively used waterfront and its extensive coastal geography. Floods have the potential to destroy homes and businesses, impair infrastructure, and threaten human safety. With climate change and sea level rise, these risks are expected to increase in the future, but will most adversely affect low-lying neighborhoods. - https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/planning/download/pdf/plans-studies/climate-resiliency/flood-risk-nyc-info-brief.pdf https://www1.nyc.gov/assets/planning/download/pdf/plans-stud... Looks like he was correct about the increased risks from storm surges et al as a result of climate change.
- 77pt77 4y agoThat's in no way what he said. You are being dishonest.
- defrost 4y agoHe's a US politician .. hardly a climate expert. He was relaying his understanding of the general predictions he'd been told and took things a little too literally on an accelerated time scale. Increasingly underwater increasingly frequently as storm surges increase and mean water levels increase leading to greater extremes is a complicated sound bite. "New York will be underwater" is simpler and turned out to be true in a literal sense. I literally have zero knowledge of what he has said, I'm not in the US, I didn't watch his film, and I wouldn't watch a US political figure for an explaination of anything technical when there are better and more primary sources.
- vorpalhex 4y agoAl Gore received a nobel peace prize for his climate work.
- jjcon 4y agoI mean New York has had big storms multiple times in its history - that is nothing new and I certainly don't interpret that as being what he intended: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1893_New_York_hurricane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1893_New_York_hurricane https://www.weather.gov/okx/1938HurricaneHome https://www.weather.gov/okx/1938HurricaneHome https://www.nytimes.com/1976/08/10/archives/hurricane-donna-in-60-was-the-last-bad-one.html https://www.nytimes.com/1976/08/10/archives/hurricane-donna-... etc etc etc If we are that generous in interpreting him everything he says then becomes non-falsifiable.
- refurb 4y agoAnd people wonder why there are climate deniers. Trying to talk your way out an prediction that was clearly false just makes it look even worse.
- macinjosh 4y agoHe did claim that the peak Mt. Kilimanjaro would be permanently snow-free by like 2016 and yet it is still plenty snowy on top 6 years later still. He is a liar and also a sexual predator, but he some how escaped #MeToo. https://slate.com/human-interest/2010/07/why-the-masseuse-s-story-about-al-gore-rings-true.html https://slate.com/human-interest/2010/07/why-the-masseuse-s-...
- defrost 4y ago"Plenty of snow" is subjective, in truth there is less and less and less as time goes on. https://tunza.eco-generation.org/file/kilimanjaro-melting.jpg https://tunza.eco-generation.org/file/kilimanjaro-melting.jp...
- autoexec 4y agoEven if he had, Al Gore isn't a scientist. X person said Y is a distraction because people can say anything. There are countless people and organizations that twist statistics or misrepresent science to suit their political ends, but it doesn't necessarily make the science flawed. Sometimes it's just misinterpreted, or cherry picked, or outright invented to support a political opinion, but that's not a problem with science as much as it is a problem with politics. It's a lot more worrisome when you have scientists taking money to falsify data or faking results to push their own political agenda. We expect politicians to lie to us, but when science does it that risks setting back our collective understanding of the world we live in and can keep us from the truth for a very long time.
- threeseed 4y ago> Climate change is used as a bat to hit poor people in the head politically I am sure the poor people who are suffering through the droughts in Europe, floods in Pakistan, increased erosion in Senegal and the hottest ever temperatures in Death Valley would disagree. Climate change is happening and the science has been ignored for far too long.
- thrown_22 4y agoYes, we could have solved it with nuclear power in the 1960s. We still can, but we could have too.
- threeseed 4y agoPeople can push nuclear as much as they like. But right now cost wise it's massively uncompetitive with solar/wind + storage.
- thrown_22 4y ago>solar/wind + storage. Then why are energy prices rising in every grid the more renewables it uses?
- threeseed 4y agoIt's not unless you have evidence to the contrary. https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-07-14/renewable-energy-provides-relief-from-rising-power-prices https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2022-07-14/renewable...
- elihu 4y agoElectricity is a fungible resource and most of it is generated from fossil fuels. The price of natural gas is way up, so electricity prices generally are up. Not to mention, hydroelectric production is down in some places (Hoover dam for instance), some nuclear plants are running below capacity because rivers are too low and/or too warm (France) and there's a major land war in Europe right now. It's also possible that some investments in renewables will take time to pay off, like any investment in new infrastructure. I'd expect the same thing if some area built a brand new coal plant. (Ideally these costs are buffered out by some kind of financial instrument so rate-payers don't get hit by it all at once.) Solar power is actually quite cheap. Storage can be cheap or expensive depending on whether it's done with pumped hydro (where geography allows) or chemical batteries.
- neonsunset 4y agoThis is a cheap attempt to co-opt an argument "Climate Change" that is factual and not political, into political direction "Person X said Z" and "Fact X was stated by political side S". Climate change has nothing to do with right or left, or any other way people use to paint things black and white.
- nigrioid 4y agoExactly. There is objective proof of collusion to falsify climate data. Look no further than the 2008 Hadley CRU "climategate" leak. Edit: The leak actually happened in November 2009. The file you're looking for is "FOI2009.zip".
- autoexec 4y agoClimategate was not the smoking gun people claimed it was Further reading: https://www.newsweek.com/factcheck-climategate-doesnt-refute-global-warming-75749 https://www.newsweek.com/factcheck-climategate-doesnt-refute... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climatic_Research_Unit_email_controversy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Climatic_Research_Unit_email_c... https://science.slashdot.org/story/10/07/02/1433246/climategates-final-days https://science.slashdot.org/story/10/07/02/1433246/climateg... https://www.factcheck.org/2010/04/some-climategate-conclusions/ https://www.factcheck.org/2010/04/some-climategate-conclusio... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_E._Mann#Controversy_over_hockey_stick_graph https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Michael_E._Mann#Controversy_ov... https://skepticalscience.com/Kevin-Trenberth-travesty-cant-account-for-the-lack-of-warming.htm https://skepticalscience.com/Kevin-Trenberth-travesty-cant-a...
- refurb 4y agoReading the Wikipedia article is not very confidence inspiring considering the criticisms of “lack of transparency”, “lack of sharing code and raw data”, “heavy reliance on statistics but no inclusion of trained statistician”. The only encouraging finding was “no outright scientific fraud”.
- autoexec 4y agoI thought "Eight committees investigated the allegations and published reports, finding no evidence of fraud or scientific misconduct.[17] The scientific consensus that global warming is occurring as a result of human activity remained unchanged throughout the investigations.[18]" to be encouraging. I haven't read all the reports yet, but it was good to see all of them ended up at that same conclusion. I'm sure there are people who would complain about the amount of time, money, and effort that went into investigating, but I'm glad there was so much scrutiny from so many different eyes.
- howinteresting 4y agoI wish it would have worked and people had been scared into taking action. Now we're looking at serious ecological devastation and hundreds of millions of climate refugees (look at the recent heat wave in India and flooding in Pakistan).
- autoexec 4y agoPlenty of people were scared into taking action, but sadly the people with the power to make meaningful change were taking bribes from industry to continue ignoring the issue. The rest of us spent our energy taking shorter showers, separating our trash, buying things advertised as "green", and all the other largely pointless rituals they gave us to keep us calm and make us feel better while they continued to make money hand over fist destroying the future for our children.
- blooalien 4y agoAnd then there were those of us who weren't even scared, and just took all those actions simply because it was the right thing to do. Now of course, we're just as screwed as everyone, all because more money for a few that already have too much of it is far more important than "doing the right thing" or "human life" (or any life, apparently). More money for the already filthy rich is by far the most important thing in the entire Universe.
- hackerlight 4y agoAl Gore was directionally correct, which is better than the climate change deniers on the right that point in the opposite direction to reality. Moreover, Al Gore was a political actor, not a climatologist. Let's face it, both the left and the right politicize science. The left sometimes does it when it comes to biological sex (conflating gender and sex), intelligence testing (saying they're next to useless), genetic determinism (saying all outcomes are environmental), GMOs, nuclear energy safety, sociology (denying impact of culture on outcomes). The right can do it when it comes to gender identity, GMOs, climate change, stem cells, intelligence testing (race realism), sociology (thinking it's all culture and not racism), creationism, anti-vax and public health. Nobody has a monopoly on politicization of science. The problem is that the right's politicization is, in the current moment, more dangerous. Covid denial and social acceptance of vaccine hesitancy has killed hundreds of thousands. Climate change denial threatens the entire world.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- userbinator 4y agoRelated recent article: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32595083 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32595083
- beebmam 4y agoIt seems to me that science has been political since it first came into existence, even before we had a well-defined scientific method. Science is political because the organizations and institutions that fund/support science decide which scientific studies get funded/supported, and the outcome of the scientific process often affects the legitimacy of those organizations' and instutitions'.
- ifsothen 4y agoI see this response a lot. It's a cop out and deflection. Sure, it's always been political. But there are times when the politics of science has hued much more closely to the pursuit of truth than it currently does. It's not hard to see why when modern, powerful political movements say that "objectivity is a tool of white supremacy" or of the "patriarchy." Such positions would have been laughed out of the room in 1980 but now they are widely held within the academy.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoMethinks you need to read more papers from the 1980s. I keep Susan Bordo's The Cartesian Masculinization of Thought in my back pocket when people try this argument. It was published in 1986. Try again.
- ifsothen 4y agoYeah, the work stuff really took off during that decade. Probably a function of the 60s and 70s student terrorists/protestors becoming a significant portion of tenured professors finally.
- kelseyfrog 4y agoSo it both wouldn't fly in the 1980s and then also really took off in the 1980s? I guess we're just sorta freewheeling with whatever we want to say then? Cool.
- 4y ago
- rayiner 4y agoMovements and institutions need to jealously guard their own interests, and not spend their political capital on unrelated movements. When they don’t do that, they undermine their own supposed priorities. When public health officials made an exception to their Covid position to support protests in 2020, they revealed that they’re willing to put their personal political views ahead of “the science.” And when you do that, that shreds your credibility. It’s a really dangerous thing for scientific institutions to signal to people that they have an agenda beyond their specific field.
- thrown_22 4y agoThis puts into very simple words my opposition to orgs like Mozilla making outreach for women, minorities and whatever else the flavour of the month is in California a part of their goals. Doubly so since they have been loosing market share every quarter for 10 years. Stick to doing the one thing you're meant to be doing. We don't need a dozen organizations to be chasing whatever is popular right now - poorly - we need organizations that follow the course regardless of what happens.
- autoexec 4y ago> This puts into very simple words my opposition to orgs like Mozilla making outreach for women, minorities and whatever else the flavour of the month is I don't think this is really a problem as long as they aren't being hypocritical. If a web browser company wants to make "outreach for women" (whatever that means) something they strive for that's perfectly fine unless it undermines their other goals. Telling people in the middle of a pandemic to gather in large groups for chanting and screaming is a bad look for an origination whose purpose is to promote people's health. If Mozilla went around looking for ways to encourage women to take an interest in open source browser development that could easily support their interests.
- thrown_22 4y ago>I don't think this is really a problem as long as they aren't being hypocritical. There isn't a problem if the violence to women orgs start spending half their budget on building a good open source browser. Otherwise there is very much a problem.
- wikitopian 4y ago
- wikitopian 4y ago
- muglug 4y ago99% of science being published today has no political motivations. The public perception of science, though, is not dictated by scholarly journals. It's what's discussed on the nightly news or seen in the Facebook news feed, and that often comes with a helping of politics. We're also seeing a recent uptick in criticism (and also suspicion) of "elites", and academics are generally lumped into that bucket. And then COVID happened, making everybody an armchair epidemilogist overnight. You could see this play out on Twitter, where accounts with large followings with no previous professed statistical experience started sharing non-peer-reviewed study after study, often drawing inaccurate conclusions. Scientists continue on, but there's absolutely no putting the genie back in the bottle. Science is political, and we need (a hopefully small number of) scientists to get some decent media training and start explaining their work to the general public.
- rufus_foreman 4y ago
- reikonomusha 4y agoDo you have examples of reputable journals publishing politically motivated results? Or even just some significant examples from the arxiv?
- futuretaint 4y agoHere's the Nature article from last week which was surprising to many inc Hacker News https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-022-01443-2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41562-022-01443-2 re: hard sciences, the scientific community's refusal to accept the covid lab leak hypothesis stands out IMHO. School shutdowns/mask mandates for pre-k and public schools is another politicalized issue.
- futuretaint 4y agohere's the HN comment chain from last week: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32595083 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32595083
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ckemere 4y agoAs a scientist, I think this piece completely misses the point. "Science is political" because most scientists aspire to answer questions that will have value for society. If you read the cited articles, the point is to remind scientists to consider how their poorly posed questions (limited as always by fundamental limits in how confounding factors can be controlled and/or resource limits on things like group sizes) will be interpreted by non-scientists in formulating policy (or attempting to, in the cases of crazies). Said another way, while it is possible for science to be less political, it explicitly requires that the questions being posed are as far removed from policy decisions as possible (i.e., useless). I would challenge the author to articulate an alternative in which [(a) scientists desire to have a positive impact on society (beyond simply increasing knowledge) and (b) they recognize the limitations of their capabilities] but do not need to think carefully about how the results of a resource or technical limitation of their work might lead it to be misapplied to bad policy. Saying "remember science is political" is no different than saying "remember that if you decide to always check PSA levels you'll mess up more people's urinogenital loves with unnecessary tests than you'll save from cancer. Note: many scientists (like me!) gravitate to "basic" science so they won't have to worry. But I don't think that makes us better.
- UIUC_06 4y ago> scientists desire to have a positive impact on society (beyond simply increasing knowledge) That's where you're off into Error Land. Increasing knowledge is the only legitimate goal of science. If you wanted to benefit society, you should have gone into a different line of work.
- polygamous_bat 4y ago> Increasing knowledge is the only legitimate goal of science. If you wanted to benefit society, you should have gone into a different line of work. And who are you, so wise in the ways of science, to decide what the only legitimate goal of science can be? Science, technology, none of these exists in a vacuum. People, even academics, have a life outside of their work. What affects that life affects what they work on as well. It's only natural.
- 4y ago
- foxes 4y agoI stopped after reading the use of a nebulous “they” scare quote which lets the reader fill in whoever “they” are, and which is basically a right wing dogwhistle. Consider for example a recent analysis of a certain right wing talk show. I think substack should be banned completely from HN.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- js4ever 4y agoWhat? So you want to read only left wing things? Personally I prefer to continue seeing both sides because there is no good side.
- foxes 4y agoYes. But that’s because the right has become synonymous with, or at least tacitly supports, insane racists, fascists, bigots and more unpleasant adjectives. You can be pedantic about our wording and try and slide the issue but the data is there. There are plenty of issues where you can have multiple sides or perspectives and want to allow debate. But that is not what is happening.
- Dove 4y ago> Hmm. I’m not much of a speech-writer, and that felt a little bit embarrassing. Wow. You're really not. Let me give it a go. Bias can never be eliminated, but it can be overcome by a greater commitment: the commitment to truth. We commit to pursue the evidence wherever it leads, because we believe that the truth is of such great and ultimate benefit and significance that this overwhelms any personal or political inconvenience. We will be the first ones to say what no one in our generation wants to hear, but what the next generation will be glad we uncovered, as has been the role of so many of our forefathers, heroes in the past. Though my peers abandon me and seek to bury the inconvenient out of fear of the consequences or desire to manipulate, I will tell the truth because I trust my fellow man to always make the best decisions with the benefit of full and accurate knowledge. We will not blink, and we will not lie, and we will not allow professional ambition, personal benefit, or cherished beliefs to overpower our sacred trust as humanity's best line of defense against ignorance and lies.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- smeagull 4y agoEverything is political. There's no getting away from it. You can be safely working in woman's health, and suddenly - it becomes political. No change in what you're doing, others have decided that it's a political issue, and so it is. There's no science that is safe.
- eyelidlessness 4y ago> conflicts are a bad thing What the hell? The literal process of science is conflict. It’s not a bad thing. It’s the sorting out of which ideas are most accurate and most useful for answering questions. Edit: gob help me I’ll just say “dialectic”. I’ll take whatever is incoming for saying it.
- physicsguy 4y agoHe means “conflicts of interest”
- aj7 4y agoA lot of you may not be aware of the deep, seething hatred a large number of Americans have for the educated elite. Not only are they perceived as having money and power now, they are blamed for the developments that take away people's jobs in the future. This hatred is so widespread that it was no trouble to convince people, used to flu shots and polio vaccines, that the COVID vaccines were dangerous or a hoax. You usually don't run into these attitudes in Silicon Valley, in college towns, in academia, and in the "better sections" of large cities, so many successful technologists are unaware of how deep-seated and widespread this attitude is. So politicizing climate change, COVID, etc. was very easy, there was a built-in audience.
- thesis 4y agoThis is an interesting take. A fairly elitist take at that. You do realize that generally the people who live in the non-“better sections” (as you put it) of large cities generally vote in line with how the super highly educated elite people that live in Silicon Valley vote.
- aj7 4y agoYou are right. I was focused on the bubble that persons with good tech careers live in— they almost never come across the resentful 33% in their lives. By the way, those “resentful 33%,” in their own way, are not wrong. I saw a YouTube of what a young woman did when home from college. She sat in a cramped enclosed office, 20 feet off the ground with a narrow 18” (450mm) shelf with three crappy looking PC’s. She was plowing about 100 acres of farmland, riding in this combine. If farming can be automated to this degree, of course manufacturing can.
- hackerlight 4y agoI'd say it's more because of the anti-white anti-male anti-Christian virtue signalling competition that the social elite do, which seeps into all cultural products including entertainment and media. It makes low status traditional white men feel alienated from all of society except for Fox News and Donald Trump. The feeling of societal alienation leads to fascist sentiments as Hannah Arendt figured out. That's the explanation for the phenomenon, but it doesn't mean I have sympathy for these people. They are perpetuating white supremacy and domination without realizing it. I simply wish our culture didn't create such a hostile climate for white men for purely pragmatic downstream reasons (i.e. I don't want fascism), as well as for egalitarian realism (i.e. race essentialism is wrong, even when directed at white people). Regarding trade: such people aren't entitled to my trade or business. If I want to buy something from a Chinese person, that is my right, and they have no right to interfere with that.
- Barrin92 4y agoOne thing that's interesting is that the author doesn't really disagree about the political nature of science but rather looks for degrees of objectivity within what he acknowledges to be an already political field. This sets up a pretty big strawman because everyone agrees that, to pick his example, Lysenkoism is hogwash but that does little to address the contentious and serious political issues we grapple with, or the larger question of the proper nature of science. I'd rather take up the second point, namely that the author almost takes it as a given that politicized science is bad. He puts forward this idea that science ought to be bureaucratic, ideally all scientists ought to be disinterested, universalist, apolitical monks who try to improve reproducibility, and so on. To chain science to objectivity or to any kind of formulaic process may help everyone to agree on results, but it impedes the evolution of the scientific process (or better, processes) itself. There's nothing wrong with methods that in different places drift into different directions, because overall this makes for a more competitive field of methodologies. in fact something even as stupid as Lysenkoism serves a purpose, it's in itself part of the scientific map of ideas that need to be discovered before they could be disregarded. So if you want to do insular corporate science, and someone wants to do militaristic science, and someone else wants to do cooperative 'objective science', all of this is valid and in fact useful, not despite, but because it creates conflict. To do ideological science is simply to run an experiment on the scientific method itself, it's what Feyerabend called 'epistemic anarchism' which he identified as the only thing that avoids limiting the potential of science.
- Cupertino95014 4y ago> To chain science to objectivity or to any kind of formulaic process ... Sorry, there, but "objectivity" is not up for debate. Unless you subscribe to the woo-woo "different ways of knowing" crap. The scientific method is not up for debate. > To do ideological science is simply to run an experiment on the scientific method itself, it's what Feyerabend called 'epistemic anarchism' which he identified as the only thing that avoids limiting the potential of science. "the potential of science": Berkeley nonsense. It's too bad he didn't just stick with Popper, who'll be around long after he's forgotten.
- 4y ago
- acidburnNSA 4y agoSounds a lot like what Weinberg was saying in '72 with the whole idea of trans-science. https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.177.4045.211 https://www.science.org/doi/10.1126/science.177.4045.211
- VikingCoder 4y agoPolitics should be informed by science. How should we govern ourselves? By understanding the world. Forming theories and testing them. Developing models that can predict the future. Peer review. Following the data where it leads us. Controlling for variables. And on and on and on. Said another way - there are people who are actively fighting a scientific understanding of the world, in declaring how we should govern ourselves. Please, be careful to not sound like you're on their side. Because they're so painfully wrong.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- autoexec 4y agoExactly. The twisting of the truth by polluting bodies of research is extremely dangerous. The consequences of falsifying scientific data, either for money or ideological reasons should be harsh. As a child I thought that no scientist would ever do that because it would ruin their reputation and they'd never work in their field again. Instead industries are happy to keep scientists in their back pockets and nobody seems to have problems with 'science by press conference' or with taking industry funding for research knowing the results will never see the light of day if they are unfavorable to that industries profits. Science has the ability to self-correct and get to the truth, but that takes time and money and the ones with the most money are more interested in pushing whatever lies are needed to preserve their power.
- jjcon 4y ago> Politics should be informed by science. Informed by science, absolutely. I think the point here though is that science is inherently amoral (meaning without judgement). For a mundane non-political example, Science may say: If we ban skiing the outcome will be fewer people dying in accidents. It takes a politician to assess the effects of making that decision in the context of societal values (freedom, privacy etc). Science should not be prescriptive, only descriptive. It cannot weigh its descriptions against the values of a society or people.
- VikingCoder 4y ago
- wzwy 4y ago> After a decade of discussion about the replication crisis, open science, and all the ways we could reform the way we do research, we’re more aware than ever of how biases can distort things - but also how we can improve the system. So throwing up our hands and saying “science is always political! There’s nothing we can do!” is the very last thing we want to be telling aspiring scientists, who should be using and developing all these new techniques to improve their objectivity. Not only is the argument from inevitability mistaken. Not only is it black-and-white thinking. It’s also cheems. Even if we can’t be perfect, it’s possible to be better - and that’s the kind of progressive message that all new scientists need to hear. A layman’s perspective: While not necessarily because of politics, the replication crisis had made some, if not many, people very skeptical of psychology research and maybe the whole scientific enterprise as whole. Whenever someone brought up anything about science, they’ll link to some news about the replication crisis or some other flaws of the science, followed by preaching about how much of a sham science can be. It’s not that skeptics don’t think there’s value in science. They might believe in science as a theory but not in its application. Evaluating the application of science can be very difficult and time-consuming especially for a layman. If the application of science is as flawless as its theory, we can just read the abstract and be done with it. But that’s not the reality, and people are expected to have a bevy of skills to read scientific papers. When they don’t have the skills and try to share their interpretation of the papers, you can expect someone criticising them (normally with a very adversarial tone) because of their incompetence, ignorance, blindness, biasses, etc. Because of the difficulty and intellectual battleground surrounding scientific paper discussions, some people would rather take the default route of not caring about or even denigrate science; the replication crisis is the best they could’ve hoped for to justify and bolster their positions. The progressiveness espoused by the author shouldn’t be limited to scientists. Anyone interacting with science should try to read scientific papers even if they’re not some hotshot supposedly unbiased scientists. Similar to the scientists, non-scientists should also try to improve their objectivity, and not think that they should be supremely objective before they can read anything.
- sunjester 4y agoThis isn't a negative comment towards the man himself. I would say take a look at his other posts (https://substack.com/profile/1881468-stuart-ritchie https://substack.com/profile/1881468-stuart-ritchie) before you take this article as serious as you should. There is an article about "racist dog names" so I would think, take this article with some salt. It's opinion not fact guys. Again, I'm sure he's a cool dude and let's drink some beers and all but I wouldn't take this guys stance on science and politics as something that is that serious. SEO ftw?
- greaterthan3 4y agoCalling this[1] "an article about racist dog names" is a complete misrepresentation. It's a critique of a study published in Social Psychology Quarterly, which is an official journal of the American Sociological Association. [1] - https://stuartritchie.substack.com/p/dog-name-racism https://stuartritchie.substack.com/p/dog-name-racism
- origin_path 4y agoThe guy is an academic scientist (well, psychologist) and has written a successful book on bias and fraud in science. He isn't just some random guy at the bar.
- mk81 4y ago
- wizofaus 4y agoMaybe I didn't read the whole article as carefully as I could have (3 G&Ts will do that to you) but I think it made a valid point. The scientific method should definitely be above politics and the moment that scientists make significant changes in how they report their results based on political inclinations then we should absolutely be concerned. But I still believe that the scientific process (falsifiable hypotheses, peer review etc. etc.) is the best method we have of determining truth about reality regardless of personal political inclinations.
- refurb 4y agoScience itself isn’t political, but what the science means for society is political. And because of that, science is political. Or at least, how we talk about science is. But science itself (in its aspirational form) isn’t political. Back when I was in the lab, one of the most accomplished things you could do is prove an existing theory wrong - that was the very definition of scientific progress.
- llanowarelves 4y agoIt's unfortunate that there can be a tendency (probably in any sentient creature), even among scientists, to double-down to defend prior investment. It got Semmelweis put into an insane asylum by his fellow academics and beat to death. And everyone remembering Pasteur instead of him. That was his reward for being correct and saving mothers and their babies -- with his unhinged conspiratorial idea of "washing yor hands is good".
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThis is a recurring conversation. People who are part of the dominant group (often rich, white, WASP, male in American history) do stuff that is biased. People try to remove that bias. The first group attacks that as "political" because when they do it, they don't consider it political. "Political correctness" is what the other side does, not hounding the Dixie Chicks for speaking out against war. "Identity politics" is something only minorities do, not the KKK etc. Now, political science is bad when they do it, we don't do political science, please ignore the several hundred years of history behind the curtain. This whole argument is the "red team" strategy that the Trump admin was pushing for climate change, and previously "teach the controversy" in evolution. It's just stalling from people who have lost the argument presented as balance.
- stillkicking 4y ago- Make vague generalizations about white people, men - Blur the distinction between non-credible fringe groups and some of the most credentialed institutions around so you can play the underdog - Ascribe all actions taken in name of minorities as the express wishes of those minorities, even if they are ineffective or destructive - Frame it as redress for hundred years of "history" (read: the specific grievances of North American colonialism) - Wrap it all up in a blue=good red=bad American apple pie with a Trump bow while simultaneously deriding others for being too set in their ways There are colleges that are demanding _diversity and inclusion loyalty pledges_ with adherence to a _specific socio-political agenda_, and you think "science is political" is just stalling from people who have lost perspective? The American left is insane and delusional.
- IYasha 4y agoCan somewhat confirm. But what's even worse, many scientific works and publications are commissioned and highly biased. I mean, they sole existence can be justification of some private/corporate interests. I've seen this in communication and medical areas, but this is just everywhere, even archeology.
- germandiago 4y agoScience should not be political. Science is about intellectual honesty. The results can have 1000 interpretations but at least it should be consistent with your models, as transparent as possible and without trying to force conclusions from your hypothesis beforehand. Anyything that does not try to its best to be like that would be something else to me, honestly. So no, science is not political, it would be more tied to politics philosophy itself. But it looks it could be convenient for some to promote people to believe that. This article seems to push in that direction.
- jscipione 4y agoScience, like all institutions of the West, has been turned against its own population and is working to destroy them and all of Western Civilization because that's what the people who are paying for science want.