14 ms·
Is the psychedelic therapy bubble about to burst?
- febeling 4y agoLet's not forget, the bubble being about getting these substances back from being banned and considered to dangerous for society to research and otherwise deal with responsibly. Fits the theory that this is a paid hit piece, obviously without evidential support. Remind me, could there be an industry financially interested to get psychedelics back into the box?
- eternalban 4y ago> The findings were somewhat lackluster: it found that the psychedelic was only marginally better than traditional treatments at relieving depression. Not a peep about the side-effects of "traditional treatments", which presumably include the designer drugs.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yung_steezy 4y agoI'm not sure this is necessarily a hit piece. There have been a few high profile cases of psychedelic therapists in countries like Canada being investigated for questionable practice. At the moment we're in a bit of a wild west where the actual procedures surrounding the use of these drugs as treatment are not standardised.
- BobbyJo 4y agoThat feel less like a bubble bursting and more like a cage breaking.
- Lacerda69 4y agoYour comment sparked some interest in me and I found this article to be very detailed and nuanced: https://www.madinamerica.com/2021/09/ending-silence-psychedelic-therapy-abuse/ https://www.madinamerica.com/2021/09/ending-silence-psychede... If you know other sources on your comment, I would love to check them out as well!
- NoToP 4y agoWhat industry conspiracy are you trying to insinuate? Is it big pharma? Doubt it. Guess who would ultimately own the labs, run the clinical trials, and be first to market with a safe and precise FDA approved antidepressant based on a psychedelic active ingredient. Let's not forget LSD started as a research chemical in a drug r&d lab in Switzerland. Industry never wanted it criminalized. It's not a good look to rationalise away all bad news as "paid hit piece".
- mandmandam 4y agoIt's not a rare or unheard of thing for an industry to attack solutions that are significantly better than their own (very profitable) solution. Psychedelics _can_ permanently fix problems - anxiety, alcoholism, depression - that otherwise would make pharma companies huge amounts of money. LSD is incredibly cheap to manufacture. There's no patent on it. Same with mushrooms and many others. Now look at how much money those pharma companies made with Lexapro, with Prozac, with Risperdal. Even when they were caught marketing those drugs for unapproved uses, to children; and caught buying academics opinions, they made billions off the stuff. Compare the list of side effects on their drugs to mushrooms or LSD. Compare the effectiveness. These companies aren't maintaining huge divisions of PR goons for the fun of it; they absolutely are out there on the internet, lobbying, and on traditional media, convincing people to form opinions like yours.
- dr_dshiv 4y ago> It's not a rare or unheard of thing for an industry to attack solutions that are significantly better than their own (very profitable) solution See Juul, attacked by both the smoking industry and anti-smoking lobby. Ecigs don’t have brand loyalty like “Marlboro”—and cigarettes cost only 6 cents a pack to manufacture. So, buy Juul, kill it, preserve the massive profit flow.
- mandmandam 4y agoYep. That's a pretty clear example, and it sucks to see people falling for it. Vaping is immediately and obviously far less bad than smoking, but they can't say that. The fear-porn around the issue is wild, and I'm certain legislators and media types are getting brown envelopes to demonize vaping. Cannabis / hemp would be another. Alcohol giants, cotton, painkillers, and many more have a lot to lose to an alternative that's superior in many ways. Fossil fuel companies spend huge amounts putting doubt into people's mind about nuclear and renewables, lobbying for themselves, systematically buying academics and news stories. With the above examples, there are people dying thanks to the PR FUD. Microsoft did similar stuff, buying and squashing competitors by any means necessary. Even the DoJ had to step in when they tried to own the internet. Some people think MS Office is still around because it's better than the competitors, lol. Banks lobby to make business as awkward as possible for credit unions. Bitcoin maxis smear superior tech with the most laughable arguments. Etc.
- benevol 4y agoNo, it hasn't even started, and it's not a bubble. There is so much potential in this and so much catching up to do. Many who are familiar with the relevant substances know this. Our various corrupt systems (political, financial, "health" care, media, etc.) have deliberately prevented this type of therapy from exploding for a very, very long time. It will massively reduce the pharma industry's revenues, among other things.
- zozbot234 4y ago> There is so much potential in this and so much catching up to do. And a whole lot of new risks to go with the potential. As the saying goes: it's important to keep an open mind, but not so much that your brains fall out.
- derac 4y agoKeeping relatively safe substances criminally illegal is probably not the best solution.
- matt89 4y agoProper and wider research is important. Let's hope that these substances become more popular and available to be researched and tested, so that hopefully in 5-10 years we would know their risks and advantages. Then people could make educated decisions whether or not to try and use them.
- spaetzleesser 4y ago"And a whole lot of new risks to go with the potential" As long as alcohol is legal and easily available we shouldn't worry about psychedelics. I know plenty of people who have taken all kinds of psychedelics and seem OK. Psychedelics just don't seem very addictive for most people. I also know quite a few people who have been hurt by alcohol. They either hurt themselves or they hurt others while drunk.
- WastingMyTime89 4y agoPsychedelics are mostly illegal because Nixon didn’t like the hippies and federal agencies were looking for new budgets. It’s not as shameful as weed being illegal because the cops hired to enforce the prohibition needed new jobs and it mostly impacted poor communities and African American but it’s close.
- HighlandSpring 4y agoOnly tangentially related but quite interesting: https://mobile.twitter.com/GraduatedBen/status/1565041582671290376 https://mobile.twitter.com/GraduatedBen/status/1565041582671... Sometimes I wonder if SSRIs are one of those things that the industry overinvested in and now that there's plenty of momentum (and budget) to support the narrative that they are the cure it's hard to suggest that there may be simpler alternatives
- krona 4y agoThe SSRI narrative seems to be unwinding, very quickly. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41380-022-01661-0 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41380-022-01661-0
- p_j_w 4y agoIt's not been very quick, the serotonin hypothesis has had huge question marks around it for as long as I've been reading about it, which is 10 years.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pessimizer 4y agoI'm worried that the industry is stampeding into lionizing and monetizing another thing that ultimately statistics say may not be working better than placebo and has harmful side effects, but 20-50% of the population is on and is also responsible for a large percentage of health care spending. SSRIs are that. Opiates are almost that (for long term pain management.) Statins are suspicious (and also held up as miracles by paid experts suggesting that we might add both them and lithium to the water supply like fluoride.) I see a future of bare clinic rooms filled with beds, and on each bed someone who is being intravenously fed psychedelics (that are still illegal to grow, or take without a doctor's signoff and a nurse's supervision.) Each of them paying a $10 copay, while the facility bills the government and insurance $500/hr. It'll be like the methadone clinic model, where we decided that to get people off heroin, we would addict them to a drug far harder to quit than heroin. edit: I wish we would simply decriminalize psychedelics, and not do this thing again where something gets captured by a couple of oligarchs and sends their worth into the stratosphere, while every media outlet is fanning the flames. Really fucking dreading seeing the psychedelic (completely industry-funded) patients' rights organizations representatives getting interviewed while crying on tv about how party/politician X doesn't take depression seriously and is trying to genocide them by not letting five year olds trip.
- devonallie 4y agoIs this not the opposite of a bubble? It seems like public opinion and public policy are actually making significant shifts into making psychedelic treatments more mainstream. From which I expect a large industry to emerge.
- hcks 4y agoYou are literally stating what makes it a bubble: the narrative according to which psychedelics are now being rehabilitated into treatments due to very promising results. But this narrative is getting old now, and the promising results in question are actually quite slim, in a field which is historically riddled with treatments that have a low effectiveness (when they work at all)
- devonallie 4y agoThis is true. I should have said that it seems to be a slowly but sustainably growing market. When I think of bubble, I think of a rapid boon followed by a bust. I don’t think this industry will have either.
- ad404b8a372f2b9 4y agoI don't think that makes it a bubble. A bubble is when my mom starts talking about it. Who has access to these psychedelics outside of research? They are not mainstream at all. If I wanted some I couldn't get any.
- mistermann 4y ago> the promising results in question are actually quite slim Promising results that occur outside of formal scientific settings still occur, although consciousness (possibly amplified by various pre-existing beliefs) can make it appear as if they do not. As luck would have it, psychedelics can be very helpful in sorting out one's thinking on such things.
- MAGZine 4y agoSo by your definition, fusion energy is also a bubble?
- myshpa 4y agoPersonal anecdote: 2 years of "research", 2 trips on psilocybe (one month apart), proper set & setting & guide & a lot of talking about it later with a trusted person ... decades-long cripling neurosis/anxiety disorder gone, addictions gone, depression receding, worldview changed, rated as one of the most influential experiences. Depression is (imho) not to be healed with "here, swallow a pill", structural changes to one's life are necessary. Psychedelics can help to show the way, not to solve it.
- konfusinomicon 4y agoI wonder if the same effects can be attained by someone who has used psychedelics recreationionally their entire life, from say 16 onward. is it the external guidance during the experience that really makes the difference? or is a life of experiences responsible for one not having anxiety or depression on those levels
- Ayesh 4y agoPsychedelics, LSD in particular, see their major use being a party drug. Coming from a personal experience, many people decide the "trip" they want to go on way before the trip starts. I am pretty sure there are non-zero amount of people who regularly take psychedelics, but have never been on that kind of "trips" that instead of going deep into your own mind, they just enjoy EDM, a party, perhaps a hike, paint something, watch a movie, play some sports outside, play video games, etc.
- recyclelater 4y agoEdit: I wanted to amend this to say I don’t think people should use psychedelics regularly, which I think my original comment below might imply. Lots of downsides to regular use, occasional (every couple years) seems to have little risk and some benefits in my experience. Original text below is unedited. I dunno, if you regularly use lsd or mushrooms, you probably have had a “wow that was more than I wanted” experience, that means you had complete ego loss, had the veil of reality completely pulled back so you could “see” the arbitrariness of society and human interactions. Your embarrassing actions you have been deluding yourself about come crashing down around you. You sober up and you rationalize some of it away but there’s a big nagging thing in the back of your mind screaming “maybe you should stop doing ____”. At least this has happened to me on a couple of occasions and has led to me apologizing to people, changing my default behaviors, etc. I am not a super introspective person so the kick in the head that psychedelics occasionally provide has allowed for some personality changes that were necessary and good. As an adult I now recognize that these experiences could be beneficial as therapy with the right person to guide you through it, that most people probably don’t get the full benefit these occasional experiences provide by themselves. I didn’t think this while young and just partying (though did have a bit of woo woo collective consciousness mind expansion mindset). Anything other than the recreation aspects of it were me trying to justify why it was ok, and getting high a lot is generally not ok. I actually sobered up for rest of my life after a strong mushroom trip left me thinking I was wasting my life and going down the wrong path. In short, there’s meat here, but of course with all these things there will be people riding a fad and making a buck, but bad usually tags along with the good in some amount.
- bambam3000 4y agoI happened to watch the 'Ecstacy' documentary on Prime last night. I was surprised to see the guy who brought MDMA to the world was sad that it had become a party drug as he believes it's primary purpose could have been to help people psychologically. Definitely worth a watch.
- mmsnberbar66 4y agoMDMA is underrated. I gained a lot of healing from it in the past. If done responsibly and intelligently it can be very powerful.
- yboris 4y agoPeople just don't know that MDMA has been shown in careful research studies to cure PTSD in severe treatment-resistant cases.
- kristofferR 4y agoThere's no mismatch between being a party drug and helping people psychologically [1]. The only people who think so are the same kind of sad, dull people who were upset at the Finnish prime minister dancing - and since MDMA turned out to be an awesome party drug they had to ban it and punish the ones who had fun. [1] For me, for example, I didn't have any major traumas before I tried MDMA (so therapy would have been pointless), but I were really shy. MDMA at a party setting helped me realize deeply that there's no reason for being scared of talking and connecting with people.
- deadbeeves 4y agoNo fun allowed.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y ago> create a “psychedelic utopia.” To those of us "of a certain age," this sounds ... familiar.
- mistermann 4y agoLet's hope we screw it up less badly this time, and maybe eventually get it to stick.
- derbOac 4y agoTimothy Leary is probably rolling in his grave.
- saint_yossarian 4y agoRolling... on MDMA?
- Mordisquitos 4y agoWhether the potential of psychedelic therapy has been overstated or not, I think the bubble cannot be "about to burst" for the simple reason it hasn't had the timeframe nor the scale to even be called "a bubble", let alone for it to finish on such an intense note as "bursting". «Is the psychedelic therapy spark about to fizzle out?» might have been a more apt analogy. (I have no reason to opine either way regarding the answer)
- flybrand 4y agoI agree, this isn’t yet big enough - or fake enough - to be labeled as a bubble.
- mountainriver 4y agoIt hasn’t even remotely reached its potential
- Cthulhu_ 4y agoIt hasn't even had nearly enough scientific research done on it either, since it's classed as drugs in most areas.
- alecbz 4y agoI’ve dealt with depression for the better half of my life. I tried SSRIs for a decade with moderate results — they definitely helped, but more so in a way where the depression felt manageable than feeling really happy. I went off them at the beginning of the year to experiment with managing the depression other ways: therapy, meditation, exercise. One day I got to work and noticed that for the first time in a while, I was feeling really happy. In a way where I realized that other times I thought I was happy, I was really just not-too-sad. This was what actual happiness felt like. I was kind of surprised, but thought “wow, I guess the meditation and exercise are finally paying off? It must be that… nothing else has been different recently…” And then I remembered that I’d tried shrooms for the first time the day before. So far, trips seem to pretty reliably have this effect for maybe 1-2 weeks. I suspect I’m also seeing some more durable benefits beyond that, but a little harder to be sure.
- mattgreenrocks 4y agoI don’t take psychedelics. But I’m convinced meditation and exercise can re-wire your brain. Meditation trains the mind to learn to see when it is falling into maladaptive grooves. It doesn’t prevent it, just a raises awareness. Exercise for me seems to shift the baseline mood forward a bit. Kind of feels like my hormones are in the right place after 25 years.
- kekebo 4y agoI agree, learning to direct focus can shine valuable light onto (often unreflected) self-narrative processing. Exercise never yielded the benefits I sometimes saw in studies for me but every time I manage to motivate myself to do the healthy/sane/right thing against inner resistance, it leads to a small boost in self-respect that accumulates over time.
- elevaet 4y agoAs someone who's taken plenty of psychedelics, done lots of meditation, and gets tons of exercise, I'd agree that they can all re-wire your brain. Psychedelics are very different from the other two tho, just like exercise is very different from meditation. They are all very worthwhile and can help you grow. Meditation and exercise are best practiced regularly. Psychedelics are best used for singular cathartic events, saved for special occasions. Psychedelics can change your outlook overnight, while meditation is a more gradual process. Excercise won't really change your outlook palpably, it will just keep you in a better head and body space. They all can be difficult and rewarding. Its possible to harm yourself with any of them, but generally you come out well ahead if you do them responsibly. They can all make you a better person.
- jp0d 4y agoHow is this a bubble if it's actually helping people with mental health issues. A lot of universities have begun studying this. These should never have been illegal in the first place.
- Kalanos 4y agoright, "only slightly better than existing drugs."
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jasonhansel 4y agoA lot of people here are claiming that Big Pharma is suppressing the truth about psychedelics so that they can make money from SSRIs. But remember: Big Pharma isn't making much money on SSRIs anymore, now that they've gone generic. If anything, it's the movement against SSRIs and in favor of new treatments that may be motivated by profit.
- eluketronic 4y agoPsilocybin is still something that can be grown/synthesized outside of a lab. Sure, major pharmaceutical companies could synthesize pure psilocybin and sell that as a new treatment in some kind of ideal form but it seem that from a lot of anecdotes posted here as well as many other stories I’ve heard, “normal”, non-lab-produced psilocybe mushrooms can have a profiundly positive effect. This might be what big pharma is seeing as a potential opportunity loss and therefore funding studies that skew results in a less positive way.
- jasonhansel 4y agoThe issue is that your doctor can't write a prescription for the mushrooms themselves, so those aren't likely to become a mainstream treatment. The more likely outcome is that the industry will create a synthetic analogue of psilocybin, conduct the trials needed to get it FDA-approved as a depression treatment, and then market it widely, making it more readily available and widely known than psilocybin itself. This isn't necessarily a bad thing: such an analogue might (say) have fewer side effects or work more reliably. But it will result in the pharmaceutical industry getting the bulk of the profits.
- smt88 4y agoBig Pharma has more money to make from psychedelics than from suppressing them. They're already selling ketamine and ketamine-adjacent drugs for depression.
- gnz11 4y agoA drug becoming available as a generic doesn’t mean end of shady practices to maximize profits. https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/pharmaceutical-companies-pay-over-400-million-resolve-alleged-false-claims-act-liability https://www.justice.gov/opa/pr/pharmaceutical-companies-pay-...
- 34679 4y agoThe headline presupposes that a bubble exists. I would argue it doesn't. A psychedelic therapy bubble would have many commercial products that do basically the same thing, all competing for the same dollars. Begging the question: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Begging_the_question https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Begging_the_question
- tony_cannistra 4y agoI was totally struck by the sexual abuse perpetrated by therapists within research studies that this article talks about. It belies a need for much more careful scrutiny of the whole research enterprise, if you ask me. I can't believe someone who wants to help someone else (and, by the way, try to demonstrate the power of psychedelics that they no-doubt believe in) would jeopardize the whole enterprise that way. Why has nobody in this thread commented on that?
- AndrewVos 4y agoProbably because sexual abuse is a bad thing that happens, but not something that invalidates taking drugs to cure depression?
- tony_cannistra 4y agoForgive me, but have you driven a car? Surely you wouldn't suggest that research into the efficacy of automobile safety technology should continue unchanged were it determined that humans were being irreversibly harmed by said research.
- ravenstine 4y agoIs the pop science journalism bubble about to burst? Unfortunately, Bettridge's Law applies here.
- ghostpepper 4y agoThe core complaint here seems to be that therapists abuse patients undergoing pyschedelic therapy - but I don't see any claims of evidence that abuse is more prevalent than abuse in any other therapeutic setting.
- throwpsychosis 4y agoIf anyone with mental health issues is considering psychedelics on their own, outside a clinical setting: please be careful and do your research beforehand. They nearly completely ruined my life. Definitely do not do them if you are on an SSRI. I am bipolar but was diagnosed incorrectly with depression and OCD, taking an SSRI. I was a regular marijuana smoker and took DMT which resulted in acute psychosis that lasted months. I'd had what I now recognized as hypomanic episodes before, but nothing this bad. I will not get into details for privacy reasons but had to take months off of work or school. I alternately thought I was famous, being followed, could control cameras that were following me at all times - the works. I had visual and auditory hallucinations days after the DMT experience, auditory weeks to months later. I told friends strange things about my mental health history that were misperceived. It is a bit of a blur. About a week after taking DMT, I was involuntarily hospitalized and only sent home with family supervision. They put me on strong antipsychotics with nasty side effects. They didn't help at all. I only got better months later, after I got off of all psychiatric drugs, and realized when talking with a friend that I was not famous. I then entered into a nearly year long depression and perceived that I had lost almost all my friends, although I now think that was not the case. Now, I've been stable for almost 10 years, and am married with a great career. We have a dog, a house, and are looking to have kids soon. I'm incredibly happy and only recovered with the support of family, friends, and great doctors. I've been taking lamotrigine daily for bipolar. For me, it is a wonder drug. Bipolar is incredibly hard for psychiatrists to diagnose. It took them years to identify it. Another friend of mine had acute psychosis due to another psychedelic drug and had a similar experience to mine with a hospitalization. If you have any family history of schizophrenia or bipolar or are on psychiatric drugs, please really carefully consider the possible consequences of using psychedelics.
- kirel33 4y agoLamotrigine has been a wonder drug for me, I'm still early days on my treatment but can already notice the massive improvements! just adding my comment so people see that getting help is perfectly fine (if you get the right treatment/diagnosis, it's a life changer for the best!) - mental health is still a bit taboo in some circles and I remember reading about the good experiences of people online made me finally jump into treatment :)
- jamal-kumar 4y agoI made friends with a woman who does something called integration therapy. She deals mostly with people who have gone and dosed themselves in the hope of finding themselves or whatever and just end up needing professional help because that's a very hard thing to do to yourself if you're already messed up. The way I've always seen it is this - Learning your lesson with these things is kind of like learning your lesson because you just got your ass handed to you in a fist fight, except with psychedelics it's like getting cosmically beaten into a pulp by having your consciousness put into a cannon and fired across the universe and back. Some people are really attuned to this kind of thing and can just shake it off while laughing the entire time. Others, who have no idea what they're getting into, with stuff like pre-existing anxiety conditions? If anyone really thinks them going solo on these kind of journeys is going to make them better then they might as well send them down some rapids with no boating or swimming experience for a 'therapeutic' prank show. The key thing this article and the researchers touch on is that it's the integration part of the therapy that works, the drug is something like a catalyst, and any hype around treatments which work without that component is likely to turn out to be a dangerous disappointment. I don't disagree with this at all.
- braindead_in 4y ago> Afterward, participants received aftercare, known as “integration,” in which they process everything that happened during the trip. Integration is definitely the key step. Without integration, the trip is no different than recreational use for fun. Integration requires sustained effort and guidance. If you don't have professional help, then meditation is the best DIY method. It usually leads to Spirituality. Pyschedlics tend to go very well with Buddhist and Vedantic spiritual practices. I think it best complements with Neo-Advaita. If Advaita is the theory, then psychedelics are the practicals.
- Ambolia 4y agoNever cared about psychedelics, but if it's only "marginally better" than antidepresants, and has less side effects, that sounds like a huge win.
- pessimizer 4y agoThe first bloom of the rose being marginally better than current antidepressants is a bad sign, seeing as right now it's going to be getting the most biased and cherry picked selections of studies it's ever going to get. SSRIs started off as miracles before they became possibly no more effective than placebo. Psychedelics are starting as marginally better than possibly no more effective than placebo.
- michaelwww 4y ago1) This is nothing compared to when Prozac® was introduced in the 90's. The idea that Prozac was going to cure Western mental health ills was quite popular and viral. It was a dawn of a new age according to some. Now SSRI's are still used when appropriate, but no one thinks they are a cure all for depression. 2) There's a distortion at work here. Many people, including myself, thing that natural growing mushrooms or other plants containing hallucinogens should not be illegal. The problem is that it appears the only way to legalize at the current time is to force them into a doctor/patient therapeutic relationship. This is causing people to twist themselves into a knots trying to explain why this small step towards legalization should be allowed. Many exaggerations and false claims are being made. And who wants to always have to do their trip with a doctor sitting by their side? My hometown of Santa Cruz California is on the right track. Decriminalize for personal use and move on to more important issues. Santa Cruz decriminalizes magic mushrooms and other natural psychedelics, making it the third US city to take such a step https://www.cnn.com/2020/01/30/us/santa-cruz-mushrooms-psychedelics-trnd/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2020/01/30/us/santa-cruz-mushrooms-psych...
- yboris 4y agoOther cities have followed, for example Ann Arbor in Michigan - making mushrooms the lowest priority for police (effectively decriminalizing them). One thing stands out: Oregon decriminalized all drugs in 2020 - it feels like a not well-known fact. Another side-note: because mushroom spores do not contain the psychoactive ingredient, they are not illegal to ship across state lines, so it's entirely legal to purchase spores on the internet ("for microscopy use only"), and then use "Uncle Ben Tek" to grow your own mushrooms (this part is illegal).
- michaelwww 4y agoThanks for the tip! I've been thinking about growing my own.
- tstrimple 4y agoMold is the most difficult part. Even being what I thought was very careful lead to nothing but fuzzy mold covering everything. Uncle Bens Tek helps a lot with the colonization phase, but the spawn to bulk always turned nasty for me.
- twirlock 4y ago
- photochemsyn 4y agoIt's a bit odd that this article doesn't even mention the fact that psychedelic treatments for depression, if widely successful, would likely destroy a major fraction of anti-depressant sales across the United States. That's an obvious reason the pharmaceutical industry would be pushing back against this.
- mousetree 4y agoIf they were widely successful, why wouldn't the pharmaceutical industry offer psychedelic treatments?
- LouisSayers 4y agoThe problem is barriers to entry. If made legal there'd be very little barrier to entry for people (or companies) to grow mushrooms. There's a lot stopping people from producing patented drug concoctions.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- akomtu 4y agoBecause it would be wildly efficient and cheap. All your permanently depressed clintee would be gone and with them your profits.
- jscipione 4y agoThe SNRI therapy bubble has already burst, now druggists are looking for alternatives. The tragic part is that psychologists have been prescribing mind-altering drugs for years that didn't treat depression. What makes psychedelics any different?
- darawk 4y ago> The findings were somewhat lackluster: it found that the psychedelic was only marginally better than traditional treatments at relieving depression. Err, what? What could possibly be lackluster about that? A one time (or few times) treatment does marginally better than a daily pill? Even if taken at face value, that's a spectacular result.
- nostromo 4y agoThe actual paper states things more clearly. > In this trial the primary outcome did not differ significantly between the trial groups. > Secondary outcomes generally favored psilocybin over escitalopram; however, the confidence intervals for the between-group differences were not adjusted for multiple comparisons, and no conclusions can be drawn from these data.
- p_j_w 4y agoIt's also just one single study. Maybe there's more out there, but this article doesn't even remotely make the case that its headline implies.
- mtalantikite 4y agoAnother thing that stood out to me is that all participants actually received psilocybin, it’s just that one group took 25mg vs the ssri group that took 1mg. It’s certainly a very small dose, but it’s a powerful chemical that seems to have effects even at these microdose levels. It would have been nice to see a group that had no psilocybin at all.
- mw888 4y agoIt seems like the bubble that’s been bursting for the last couple of years obvious to anyone paying attention is that microdosing is not equal to the sum of its doses. The studies which show inspiring results on hard problems like PTSD and depression involve high dose, singular experiences, and because of the nature of that high dose, a lot of preparation takes place, weeks or months sometimes and a lot of care planned out via therapist. I believe it was a Roland Griffiths study that showed that if the subjective and measured (brain scan) experience was not consistent with a deeply spiritual experience, the positive long term effects did not come.
- akomtu 4y agoWhat psychodelics seem to do, based on all the accounts of "feeling of connectedness" and "higher vision", is it does something to epiphysis cerebri in the brain to mute the lower triad of the human - body, emotions and mind - so the quiet voice of the true human, aka its soul, can be heard. There, above, connectedness of everything, as well as the clear vision of purpose and practical invincibility, are self evident realities. It gives you a glimpse into what the normal state of consciousness of a saint looks like. Meditation is a slow and safe way to get to the same state eventually, with an important difference - that state won't depend on a whim of some chemicals.
- adultSwim 4y agoI don't think psychedelics need to be a miracle cure-all to have value in our society. Prohibition should end immediately.
- lawrenceyan 4y agoI think you need some kind of framework in order to utilize psychedelics properly. Buddhist or other meditation oriented practices are very popular, but not the only path. The important thing is to have something you can cultivate because otherwise what might happen is that you accidentally heighten your existing feedback loops, which are likely negative, leading to a bad trip and in the worst case possibly psychosis. Having strong foundational positive feedback loops that you can use as a anchor or bedrock are useful not only during chemically altered brain states, but in general life as well in protecting your mind (a Patronus for your “defense against the dark arts” you might say).
- chiefalchemist 4y ago> The findings were somewhat lackluster: it found that the psychedelic was only marginally better than traditional treatments at relieving depression. This is said early on. But then the article continues and the gist is that it's still early days for psychedelics. That is, they compared well tested therapies with a new one (i.e., it's possible the dosage isn't optimized yet). Given that psychedelics have been around much longer, then it's actually the newer (propriety Big Pharma) therapies that are coming up short.
- xor99 4y agoJust decriminalise possession.
- dunemaster 4y agoI don’t think that anecdotal evidence benefits the evidence behind psychedelic therapies. I lost a lot of weight by eating gummy bears around the same time I started to exercise and eat less. Is that a convincing argument for gummy bears as a weight loss tool? They weren’t keto either.