13 ms·
30TB Portable SSD Hits Walmart for $39 but Stay Away from It
- Macha 4y agoPrevious discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32611021 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32611021
- ec109685 4y agoAmazon let’s the same thing happen in their store: https://www.amazon.com/s?k=1+tb+flash+drive&crid=1XK7KPUOQ4XJ7&sprefix=%2Caps%2C119&ref=nb_sb_ss_recent_1_0_recent https://www.amazon.com/s?k=1+tb+flash+drive&crid=1XK7KPUOQ4X... It’s horrible and they won’t do anything about it despite contacting them via help requests and Twitter. 3 of the top 5 listings are total scams. And Amazon’s choice for 1TB flash drive is a scam: USB Flash Drive 1TB, Flash Memory Stick for PC/Laptop, Ultra Large Storage USB Drive, Portable Thumb Drives (Black) https://a.co/d/cTi7XqZ https://a.co/d/cTi7XqZ
- bsharitt 4y agoI've had Amazon take down reviews that point out that a drive is a scam.
- Alex3917 4y agoAmazon doesn't even take down products that give kids lead poisoning. If a foreign nation had imposed Amazon upon us, we'd consider it an act of war.
- badpun 4y agoSounds like it's a semi-legit area for blockchain applicability- a website/app which stores all reviews on blockchain so that people are 100% certain no one has tampered with them.
- NortySpock 4y agoStep 2: Spam the blockchain with marketing, false stories, and smears against your competitors products. If the blockchain requires a fee to write to (most do), you win because you have a marketing budget and the average consumer does not.
- antiterra 4y agoI don’t think Amazon’s choice is the same for every one. I would guess it adjusts for shipping time and result relevance weighted by previous usage. For me, the choice 1TB flash drive is a PNY thumb drive. At the very least, it seems brave to assign your company’s endorsement automatically based on an algorithm.
- tedmiston 4y ago> I don’t think Amazon’s choice is the same for every one. I believe it is the same for all users for a given keyword search, but it is also dynamically changing. From [1], the algorithm itself is a black box though: > One innovation the company devised is “Amazon’s Choice,” a distinctive black badge typically bestowed on a single product per search term. The company says the award is given to “highly rated, well-priced products available to ship immediately.” But for many categories, dozens of options fit that description. How does Amazon choose its choices? Do humans have a hand in the decisions, or are they governed by an algorithm? > The company won’t say. “Amazon’s Choice is just our recommendation, and customers can always ask for specific brands or products if they choose,” an Amazon spokesperson said in a statement. [1]: https://www.wired.com/story/what-does-amazons-choice-mean/ https://www.wired.com/story/what-does-amazons-choice-mean/
- antiterra 4y agoIt definitely was different logged-in vs not, and I suspect shipping time to a known address to be the most likely reason.
- Liquix 4y agoThe "Amazon's Choice" label seems to be almost as gameable as reviews - sellers somehow have a way of creating categories it would take very little work to be #1 in, such as "Amazon's Choice for <company name> flash drive"
- numpad0 4y agoAmazon’s Choice seems like a dynamic labeling to me. The impression of it that there must be a list of Choice products is likely just a deliberate impression.
- gardenfelder 4y agoVisit amazon in your usual browser, then visit it in a different one with a private window (no cookies). They give different messages.
- cmeacham98 4y agoFor what it's worth, the "Amazon's Choice" for me is a legitimately 1TB USB Drive (from PNY).
- tyingq 4y agoClick the "shop by price" tab in that Amazon's Choice area. There will probably be a fake product there.
- NelsonMinar 4y agoWhy would they do anything? They're still making their buck on every sale.
- kelp 4y agoBecause if the problem is bad enough, people will start looking for alternative places to buy things. It's like how people will avoid the bad neighborhoods in a city.
- NelsonMinar 4y agoOh right; if Amazon doesn't have what I want I'll get it on Walmart, the trustworthy online store!
- kelp 4y agoOr BestBuy that doesn't have the marketplace problem.
- 0134340 4y agoBut the once good, now bad neighborhoods can't buy the now good neighborhoods in monopolistic fashion; the analogy doesn't hold up with economics.
- rolph 4y agoi think it needs to talk to FTC ?
- kennend3 4y agoAmazon is on a gradual decline and what is shocking is that people dont see it. I stopped using amazon around 2 years ago. If i want to buy "Chinesium" i use aliexpress and save a lot of middlemen in return for a long shipping time. I've been burned by fake products a few times and learned my lesson long ago. Sure, amazon does make it easy to return them, but going to a real store avoids it all-together. If you shop around for prices, it is rare that amazon's prices are even competitive vs an actual physical store these days. this makes little sense, the store has employees and high rents, what are amazon's reasons?
- MangoCoffee 4y agoAmazon seem to pivot into a cloud giant with e-commerce as side biz.
- Kye 4y agoAWS is their biggest profit center, so it makes sense.
- fragmede 4y agoThat just excuses their poor behavior on their own marketplace. Where they're making untold amounts of money. No, just like Comcast's customer support isn't worth spending more of Comcast's money on, so, too Amazon doesn't have the incentives to improve on the status quo. and why shouldn't they? they're making money hand over fist
- jsjohnst 4y ago> Sure, amazon does make it easy to return them, but going to a real store avoids it all-together. Genuine question, what store is this that: 1) has inventory in store of items like this 2) doesn’t also ever have fake merchandise on their shelves The problem isn’t just Amazon, Walmart, or other large online retailers, it’s issues throughout the supply chain because of the lack of enforcement by all actors (retailers, distributors, shippers, manufacturers, customs agents, government agencies, etc).
- 4y ago
- chmod600 4y agoAre you saying the SanDisk listings are scams, or are those the two non-scam listings?
- mattm 4y agoPretty sure the SanDisk one would be legit. Look at the price difference between that one and the other ones to tell.
- ec109685 4y agoYeah, SanDisk seem fine. It's the $19.99 for 1TB or $39.99 for 2TB ones that aren't. I originally got alerted to this when I was boasting about how cheap flash disks had gotten and some person here pointed out I was linking to something totally scammy, which I had no idea about.
- hot_gril 4y agoWow, they're even Prime.
- eCa 4y ago> If something sounds too good to be true, then it isn't. That doesn’t sound right.
- geocrasher 4y agoIt's incorrect. The correct phrase would be "If something seems too good to be true, it usually is." which can be extrapolated to "If something seems too good to be true, it usually is too good to be true."
- rgoulter 4y agoThe reading of that phrase is "if something seems to good to be true, then it isn't [true]". It seems unhelpful that both "it is" and "it isn't" can be used to convey "it's not as good as it appears", though.
- wongarsu 4y agoThat is the intended reading, but it just seems wrong. The sentence parses to me to the components "[if] [something] [seems] [too good to be true], [it] [isn't]", so [isn't] has to apply to [too good to be true].
- CalRobert 4y agoThe writing is strange in general - "The drive is far from being one of the best SSDs, but it deserves a spot on everyone's blocklist." is an odd one to parse too.
- greggh 4y agoThis has been going on for awhile. But my question for the crowd here: I actually need a bunch more storage soon, and can't afford to spend much. So while this is an obvious scam, what isn't? Got any links to the best price for the most space?
- mathgeek 4y agoStick with the name brands, look at SlickDeals or r/pcdeals for daily deals, and assume any off-brand hardware is a scam.
- boppo1 4y agoI think newegg is still honest.
- robbs 4y agoNewegg has the same problem as all the other big online retailers, third party sellers.
- lazide 4y agoNewegg is a shitshow. Same problem. I won’t buy from them anymore. It’s just worse Amazon.
- Dwedit 4y agoNewegg has actual product categorization, Amazon doesn't.
- Karunamon 4y agoSadly no, they have the "marketplace" problem that Amazon does where you never know who actually provided the widget you are buying, and they have a an even worse problem where they scam people out of returns. https://www.gamespot.com/articles/after-allegations-of-knowingly-selling-faulty-products-newegg-updates-its-return-policy/1100-6500795/ https://www.gamespot.com/articles/after-allegations-of-knowi...
- LegitShady 4y ago
- bergenty 4y agoThis article is missing the only piece of useful information I was looking for. What is the true capacity of the drive?
- axiolite 4y ago"two 512MB Flash drives" https://nitter.net/RayRedacted/status/1563021492157579264?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw https://nitter.net/RayRedacted/status/1563021492157579264?re...
- mathgeek 4y agoThe Ars article that Tom’s referenced from has that info: > Scammer gets two 512MB Flash drives. Or 1 gigabyte, or whatever. They then add hacked firmware that makes it misreport its size.
- ryanschneider 4y agoI’m curious why they bothered to add two microSD cards, but I wonder if that somehow actually makes the hack easier? Like maybe the firmware only needs to be patched in one spot to report a fake size when running in “RAID” mode?
- prmoustache 4y agoBecause they count on the fact that transfer rate is so slow people will really realize this too late. I guess this kind of business create an account on amazon, aliexpress and others, scam thousands of users for a month or two, close their accounts, create a new one before they get annoyed by disputes and everything.
- brundolf 4y agoWow, I have to be impressed though with the lengths they go to to keep up the charade. Hacking the firmware and creating fake files if you go over the real limit. Many people might never find out it's a fake (how many people who don't immediately know this is a scam are actually going to fill up that much space and find out?)
- netsharc 4y agoThe firmware hacking to fake the size isn't new in the whole fake USB drive scene, the new part of it is that it's being sold on Walmart.com . Some commenters have said it's a marketplace product, but I visited the page and I can't even spot an indicator to say so.
- bombcar 4y agoApparently the indicator only appears when it is in stock. Which kind of makes sense but is still annoying. It’s getting harder and harder to find non marketplace sellers at both Amazon and Walmart. Starting to default to target and Home Depot and Best Buy for now.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mindslight 4y agoThat's the standard way of making fake memory cards. The "innovation" of this scam is the nice enclosure. The firmware is actually not much of a hack, but quite in line with how flash memory operates. Flash memory can't be modified, but rather needs to be bulk erased and then written. Thus an address doesn't indicate a physical place but rather goes through some indirection data structure. The hacked firmware just reports a larger capacity, and silently discards older blocks it's supposed to be hanging onto.
- rep_lodsb 4y agoPresumably it'll fail quickly if you use full disk encryption. Or any filesystem other than NTFS, if it somehow interprets that in order to not overwrite directory blocks.
- Sakos 4y agoThis has always been a thing, but I think it's insane that a retailer is carrying a scam product like this. Amazon has the excuse that third-party sellers are usually the ones selling them (which is of course still bullshit). What's Walmart's excuse?
- mdasen 4y agoWalmart isn't carrying it. It's being sold by a third party on Walmart.com. Walmart allows third parties to sell on Walmart.com just as Amazon allows third parties to sell on their website.
- Sakos 4y agoWhere do you see that it's a third-party seller? I'm not seeing it. edit: Reading through the text and looking at the pictures, it's obvious that it's a third-party, but nothing on the site explicitly says "this is a seller not associated with Walmart". Comparison: Amazon: https://i.imgur.com/rGdTkM4.png https://i.imgur.com/rGdTkM4.png Walmart: https://i.imgur.com/JRwhzBy.png https://i.imgur.com/JRwhzBy.png Edit: Ahhh, of course. You're right, thanks guys.
- anamexis 4y agoI think it's not obvious because it is out of stock, so no one is selling it. If you find an in-stock item from a third party, it's pretty straightforward. https://imgur.com/a/tqjlPui https://imgur.com/a/tqjlPui
- MereInterest 4y agoIt's pretty straightforward once you know what to look for, but I don't think I'd call it straightforward overall. It's halfway down the page, sandwiched between shipping and return policy, and doesn't show up at all on the search results.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- herf 4y agoYou can check spot prices for NAND chips (Gigabits not GB) which explains the margins for end-user products. (This one is <2% of the TLC chip cost, obviously fake.) https://www.trendforce.com/price/flash https://www.trendforce.com/price/flash
- Havoc 4y agoPretty wild that walmart rolled with this. Implies they've got literally nobody even vaguely competent & qualified involved their purchase decisions >limited to USB 2.0 speeds Nice.
- lazide 4y agoWell, near as I can tell Newegg isn’t much better. It’s the ‘trying to be the curated next gen shopping experience’ but really being a digital flea market. Which, don’t ever buy furniture at those, they got the name for a reason.
- cyral 4y ago> digital flea market A great way of describing it. You can't trust any large online retailer these days. Every top result on Amazon is from a brand with random letters that has no accountability. Even Etsy is filled with tons of "Verified handmade" items that are obviously mass produced products from Alibaba/AliExpress (they don't even bother to use different pictures than the original listing). I ordered something off Wayfair this week and what I got was totally lower quality than the pictures.
- kortilla 4y agoIt’s a third party listing. Walmart didn’t purchase it.
- noasaservice 4y agoWrong. If I buy something from walmart.com and it happens to be a 3rd party seller, MY MONEY STILL GOES THROUGH WALMART. Or at least that's what my credit card statement says. No matter how much contortions Walmart/Scamazon/Newegg want to distance away from 3rd party sellers, they are endorsing the 3rd parties when they allow them on the site.
- kortilla 4y agoCalm down. I’m not endorsing the third party listings. I’m pointing out that’s what this was to explain how Walmart made no purchasing decision at all here.
- baobabKoodaa 4y ago> The hacked firmware writes new data on top of the old data and keeps the directory. It appears to be working, but when you try to access your files, there's nothing there. I don't understand why someone would release fake products like this. If you're going to sell a fake product, wouldn't you be better off sending like a functioning 0.5TB HDD, or sending a literal brick? Why would you send a fake product that causes data loss?
- charcircuit 4y agoThe goal is to increase the amount of time before the customer notices what they got is not what you claimed. If the drive's capacity immediately shows something different they will start whatever refund process within the window where that is allowed.
- Karunamon 4y agoBecause it increases the length of time between your fake product being sold and the return claims/consumers calling shenanigans get you kicked off of the platform. If they opened the box and see a brick, or plug it in and only see half a terabyte of capacity, they will immediately start a return. Unless you are the rare type who thoroughly tests all storage you buy before you use it, it is likely you would be backing up data to this and be blissfully unaware of what it is doing until much later, and even then it's likely you'll think of the drive as defective, rather than intentionally sold as fraudulent.
- baobabKoodaa 4y agoThis is a good explanation. Thank you.
- pwg 4y agoBecause as the scammer once you have the payment from the purchaser, you don't care. And a 0.5TB disk would cut into your 'margins' on something like this.
- dymk 4y ago
- sneak 4y agoThere are hundreds of these on Amazon. Amazon could have some person spend a few hours a day nuking the clearly fraudulent products, but they dgaf and do not.
- vidarh 4y agoThey won't care unless there are regulations making it possible to cost them money if they don't act. E.g. if they were required to pay a reasonably small statutory fee on top of the refund when refunding a fraudulent product they'd need to start addressing it, or lists of products would quickly spread online and cause them massive losses.
- Tempest1981 4y agoAlthough a lot of people want smaller government and less regulation. Enforcement would require more bureaucracy in spending. Feels like an uphill battle.
- vidarh 4y agoAll it requires is the court system.
- yalogin 4y agoThis is almost impossible to control. The amount of staffing and expertise needed to do this at scale across all product styles and segments is just impossible to maintain. There are no laws or any repercussions at all to allowing fake items on their stores, so Amazon and Walmart will not do anything about them. Problem is if someone does the right thing and weeds out all the scams from their site they will not have enough products and because of economies of scale they can’t offer the price Amazon or Walmart can offer. So essentially these scam items are giving them market pricing power. It’s almost impossible to beat, and I am sure that is why Walmart jumped into the game themselves.
- ec109685 4y agoJudging from the fact that the scams persist, you seem to be right. But anyone with sense can immediately spot the patterns that show these to be scams (e.g. prices that are too good to be true and recent reviews that say these are scams). Therefore, it seems like automated scanning could eventually be tuned to catch and ban these sellers. I think they also get away with this (and receive some good reviews) because the drives are too slow to ever fill up.
- slivanes 4y agoThe old adage is "The only way to win is to not play the game". I wish these large retailers didn't allow these 3rd party sellers to pollute their listings.
- amelius 4y ago> This is almost impossible to control. I bet some Apple fans are giggling now.
- kemayo 4y agoEven Apple's walled garden does a so-so job of stopping scams. Given their app review process, they've got rather less of an excuse -- you'd really think they'd give close scrutiny to any app charging above-the-norm subscription prices, but apparently not... E.g. from this week: https://9to5mac.com/2022/08/22/app-store-review-process-authenticator-app-copycats/ https://9to5mac.com/2022/08/22/app-store-review-process-auth...
- rvr_ 4y agoThis should be a crime, like selling spoiled food.
- jasongill 4y agoother than baby food/formula, it's not a crime to sell spoiled food (at least not in the USA)
- amelius 4y agoEven in restaurants?
- noasaservice 4y agoIf they're knowingly selling fraudulent merchandise, that's interstate commerce fraud.
- flipbrad 4y agoIt's fraud, of course it's a crime
- zekrioca 4y agoThe tactic is always the same: hack the firmware. I remember 15 years ago when I got one of these “Portable MP4 Players” (exactly like an iPod, but for 10% of the price), and it would say “8 GB” on it. When trying to upload my music into it, at some point it’d return an random storage error. I didn’t understand, so I decided to format it. What was my surprise when the 8 GB disk turned into 1 GB? I researched like crazy, and then found out in some forum that they would tweak the firmware to tell the OS about its fake size, though I’m not sure how formatting it would ‘fix’ this. After formatting it, it worked normally and for many years. In the end, it is the same stupid technique, 15 years later. I’m not sure why wouldn’t they just sell it with proper specifications and profit over the okay quality of the device..
- giancarlostoro 4y agoSounds like a bytes vs bits hack.
- stjo 4y agoThey probably changed the partition table to say that the partition is 8GB. No complex firmware shenanigans needed. See https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Master_boot_record https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Master_boot_record. Tools like fdisk will allow you to “hack” it in 10 seconds. When you reparationed your OS probably read the true disk size (correctly reported by firmware) and made a brand new partition table, partition and file system on top of it.
- neilv 4y agoFlash drives with hacked firmware to pretend to be bigger capacity than they were (along with other evildoing, like counterfeits targeting people paying a premium to get Sandisk quality) were already rampant on eBay IIRC 15+ years ago. I was still seething over some of the storage ones when, a few years ago, I joined an anti-counterfeiting startup. (Sadly, our successful MVP launch integrated into a high-end factory production line happened just as Covid was breaking out, which spooked our flagship customer, and impacted followthrough we needed, then we ran out of runway while pivoting.) As a consumer, I can imagine a lot of things that the marketplaces like Amazon.com and Walmart.com could do to improve trustworthiness. I don't know whether those make business sense. I'd love to see consumers reward a marketplace that conspicuously kept out the scammers. Ideally, the solution would protect integrity of all brands, not only house brands.
- 14 4y agoIn order to sell on those platforms companies should have to place $5 million in escrow and Amazon promises to test at random a certain percentage of your products and if failed you lose your money. I laughed at a client when he told me he bought a 1TB hard drive off of Wish. I told him well good luck with that hope you didn't just get scammed. Saw him a week later and he told me the drive wouldn't work on his new PS5. I told him I would bet him the cost of the drive it was a fake and probably couldn't hold even half of what it is reporting and told him to use the tools to see it's actual size. He didn't take the bet so I will never be sure but no way in hell I would be a $25 storage from Wish.
- silvestrov 4y ago> $5 million in escrow Nestle have no problem putting up $5M, but most good small companies just can't. So the end effect is that you enable big monopolies. You need to invent some kind of reputation system. Small towns (and communities) have this builtin as everybody knows almost everybody. Amazon is missing the ability to say "this is a new seller without solid reputation". But I'm guessing this would be bad for short-term thinking, the wish for "the everything store". You can't be quality store and "everything store". Everything is mostly junk (Sturgeon's law).
- sfvegandude 4y ago
- rolph 4y agothis doesnt just scam you for capacity, it will overwrite files to maintain the illusion of large capacity so you will lose data until you catch on that they are going into a bit bucket.
- computerfriend 4y agoI bought a 512 GB SanDisk SD card in Shenzhen several years ago that was similarly fake. I think what happened here is they just incorporated these off-the-shelf fake SD cards into their product, rather than hacking the firmware of the SD cards themselves.
- j-bos 4y agoThis is why I buy all my electronics from B&H, they have a more personal narrowly-scoped, and good reputation at stake. So I trust them, atm.
- tomxor 4y ago> If something sounds too good to be true, then it isn't. Is this an American version of the idiom? I've always heard it as "then it is", referring to the predicate... which I think sounds natural but now I'm wondering if that was just cultural.
- miloignis 4y agoI don't think so, your version is correct to my American ears!
- tomxor 4y ago> The hacked firmware writes new data on top of the old data and keeps the directory. It appears to be working, but when you try to access your files, there's nothing there. Jeez, this last detail elevates it from scam to plain malicious... Overwriting files isn't likely to conceal the scam much longer for a drive that already missreports it's size and is limited to 60MB/s - but it is likely to lose data for someone who actually manages to reach that capacity. [edit] Not speculation, reality... following the link to similar drives on amazon by a sibling comment, first 1 start review shows story of data loss [0]: > They have figured out a way for it to tell the computer that it's a hard drive with 1 or 2TB, where it really is 128GB, according to the engineers who looked at it [...] I spent several hundred dollars to retrieve a few documents that were critical to me [...] These drives are costing non technical people data loss, not just money. [0] https://www.amazon.com/product-reviews/B08SBHV3VT/ref=acr_dp_hist_1?ie=UTF8&filterByStar=one_star&reviewerType=all_reviews#reviews-filter-bar https://www.amazon.com/product-reviews/B08SBHV3VT/ref=acr_dp...
- jedberg 4y agoA lot of people use these kinds of drives for backup, so they might write a bunch of data and not go back to get it for years.
- rufusroflpunch 4y ago> If something sounds too good to be true, then it isn't. This one threw me for a loop, at first. Wouldn’t one normally say “then it is” instead of “then it isn’t”?
- compressedgas 4y ago"then it is 'too good to be true'" vs "then it isn't 'true'"
- numpad0 4y agoWhat I always wonder about fake SD cards and USB drives is, if they could “run DOOM” - can a microSD card be used as an extremely cost effective, low endurance general purpose computers with single level storage? Bottom of the barrel microSD is about $2.50, I don’t smoke but a pack of cigarette is over twice as that. So microSD-based devices should be able to be distributed in a similar affordability and scale, with computing resource of perhaps late 80s PC. What could it do, for the good or for fun?
- jstanley 4y ago> can a microSD card be used as an extremely cost effective, low endurance general purpose computers with single level storage? This is exactly what Raspberry Pi's use, so the answer is yes.
- frostburg 4y agoI think that the parent post means to use the onboard controller as a CPU and the flash memory as virtual memory (with no ram) and mass storage. I don't think this is actually viable with sd cards but it might work with different memory formats.
- hot_gril 4y agoDespite being solid state, SD cards have horrible random read and write speeds, worse even than HDDs. They're made for storing media from cameras, so it doesn't matter. Maybe RPis do OK cause they just load the system once, maybe even sequentially. I also keep a card in my MBP. It takes forever to write directories, but it's good enough to store Xcode etc only cause the RAM caches things. Torrenting Ubuntu onto it was unusably slow. I expect it'd be unusable as single-level storage.
- 0134340 4y agoAfter a quick search, looking at one such controller [0], it has a 24mhz CPU w/ 16KB RAM and another I came across that has 32mhz CPU and per doom minimum requirements @ 66mhz CPU and 8MB RAM[1], good luck on that. It's been ported to some pretty weak embedded systems before but maybe someone will eventually prove me wrong. 0: https://www.globalspec.com/Industrial-Directory/nand_flash_controller https://www.globalspec.com/Industrial-Directory/nand_flash_c... 1: https://www.sysrequirements.com/game/doom https://www.sysrequirements.com/game/doom
- mmh0000 4y agoAnytime I buy a "new" storage device, it gets runs through F3[0] first. Several storage devices I've got off Amazon have been fake, even when buying from known name brands. [0] https://fight-flash-fraud.readthedocs.io/en/latest/introduction.html https://fight-flash-fraud.readthedocs.io/en/latest/introduct...
- zxcvbn4038 4y agoBuyer beware - my wife hates Amazon and goes out of her way to not purchase from them. She has encountered several vendors on Walmart marketplace that simply place orders with Amazon at 100% markup - the packages arrive in Amazon boxes w/ a receipt showing the actual cost paid at Amazon. Total rip-off. When ordering electronics from Walmart Marketplace, particularly TVs, I’ve found that the marketplace sellers freely substitute makes and models. Maybe nobody notices if you are shipping a gift to someone else, but since I need specific models from specific manufacturers for development it gets noticed when I order LG model XYZ and get a no-name tv instead. I stopped ordering from Walmart altogether after the second time (out of two, consecutive) that happened. So my advice is anything you buy online at Walmart, make sure it is not a marketplace seller, just save yourself the trouble. In all cases Wal-Mart refunded my money after waiting for a week for the vendor to respond, though I had to lug the stuff to the UPS store to return it. Amazon usually suggests I donate stuff rather then return it. I’ve not had any issues with the items sold by Wal-mart actual, those you can buy with confidence.
- TMWNN 4y ago>Buyer beware - my wife hates Amazon and goes out of her way to not purchase from them. She has encountered several vendors on Walmart marketplace that simply place orders with Amazon at 100% markup - the packages arrive in Amazon boxes w/ a receipt showing the actual cost paid at Amazon. Total rip-off. I sell on both Walmart and Amazon. As somethingwitty1 said, this works in multiple directions; people dropshipping ittems from Amazon directly to Walmart customers, from Walmart to Amazon customers, and from both to eBay customers. It's also forbidden. Both Walmart and Amazon explicitly warn against shipping items to customers in competitors' boxes; Walmart even explicitly bans tracking numbers starting with "TBA". If your wife reports that this is happening to Walmart buyer support, the sellers won't be there for long; recent anecdotes say that both companies are really cracking down on dropshipping. >When ordering electronics from Walmart Marketplace, particularly TVs, I’ve found that the marketplace sellers freely substitute makes and models. Ugh. All I can say that I've also had less-than-positive experiences when buying from other sellers on both platforms. Amazon is notorious for allowing anyone to open a seller account. Walmart is in theory supposed to be much stricter in examining applicants' qualifications, with many waiting for weeks or months. While this is great from my perspective (both in terms of improving the overall quality of third-party sellers, and minimizing my competition), the incompetent and crooked are still getting through; Walmart recently allowing non US-domiciled sellers (i.e., Chinese) doesn't help. >I’ve not had any issues with the items sold by Wal-mart actual, those you can buy with confidence. Agreed. Amazon commingles its own inventory and that of third-party sellers that Amazon handles storage and shipping for (FBA); as a result, my own confidence in the genuineness of, say, household staples from Amazon has plummeted. I think Walmart does not do so with WFS, its FBA equivalent. In any case WFS much less used than FBA, because there is little advantage for sellers to do so over fulfilling items themselves.
- dbingham 4y agoSo if NewEgg has gone the way of garbage as well, where do people go for trustworthy parts these days? I haven't built my own machine in about a decade, but thinking about building a new one soon...
- zubiaur 4y agoMicrocenter, BestBuy, BH
- avip3d 4y agoIf it is too good to be true... it definitely is... I stay away from buying storage devices from aliexpress for the same reason.
- libpcap 4y agohttps://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/quality-fade-chinas-great-business-challenge/ https://knowledge.wharton.upenn.edu/article/quality-fade-chi...
- no_wizard 4y agois NewEgg / TigerDirect still the place to buy from if you want to get some level of authenticity in your shopping for electronics? I find I only trust things from the Apple store anymore myself. Markup and all.
- spaetzleesser 4y agoI used to buy a lot of stuff from Newegg. Unfortunately some years ago they decided to follow the Amazon model and went to hell.
- dam_broke_it 4y agoI'll get downvoted to oblivion, but one should use ebay....
- frozenport 4y agoWatching Walmart destroy its competitive advantage.
- LiberationUnion 4y ago