12 ms·
Why thinking hard makes us feel tired
- sizzle 4y agoWhen I’m thinking through a hard problem something I’ve learned to feel/notice is an oncoming massive migraine unless I supplement some magnesium, multivitamin, nootropics or easy to digest amino acids to give my brain the essential elements it needs to perform. I recall our bodies do not produce magnesium. This advice is on top of being properly hydrated, otherwise I will have impaired cognition and brain fog until proper hydration + supplementation is achieved. Can anyone relate?
- amai 4y agoI use books on theoretical physics as sleeping aid. It makes me feel tired quickly and I can sleep very well on it.
- IceMetalPunk 4y agoI'm now wondering what, if any, connection there is between glutamate regulation and depression, since listlessness and fatigue are common and characteristic symptoms. To scientists: More research, please!
- Phileosopher 4y agoI'm not scientific about it (n=1, after all), but I've realized from my own diagnosis and coming out of it that depression is a complex abstraction: 1. Reactionary primary emotion (e.g., shock, surprise, confusion) 2. Add the perception of injustice to create the secondary emotion of anger 3. Have anger directed toward meeting an unmet need 4. Give hopelessness about attaining that unmet need 5. END IF nothing gives that hope to meet that need that the anger was directed toward edit: fayled at phormatting
- IceMetalPunk 4y agoIn my own struggles with depression, I can't really pinpoint any anger/injustice most of the time. It's more just "anxiety leads to inaction leads to ruined or missed opportunities leads to insecurity and low self esteem leads to hopelessness leads to 'why bother-ism'." Then again, my depression is comorbid with an anxiety disorder, so perhaps it's different from someone who has only the depression shrug
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoBeautifully put. I think this is very interesting to contrast with the also-well-put GP commenter. Different flavors of sadness.
- georgeburdell 4y agoI didn’t know this was a phenomenon. I have been thinking of hard problems to fall asleep at night for years
- CoastalCoder 4y agoThanks for sharing that idea! I look forward to trying it out tonight.
- wizofaus 4y agoSadly the more likely consequence is that you might fall asleep quickly then wake up a few hours later and find yourself still thinking about it, and that second time your brain refuses to shut down until it solves it. Or maybe that's just me.
- dimal 4y agoSame thing happens to me. I’m actually jealous of people that can code at night. I have such great ideas from 9-11pm, but if I actually write any code, I’m guaranteed to be up from 2-4am.
- odysseus 4y agoI have the opposite problem - if I'm thinking too hard near bedtime about financial math or boolean algebra for example, I won't be able to sleep. My brain is too active going through all the calculations in my head. If I want to fall asleep within 5 minutes, what works for me is varied physical and mental exercise throughout the day, and an easygoing book or movie near bedtime. If there's something stressful going on the next day, a tech-nerd podcast like ATP helps me forget about it and get to sleep. But I try not to let late night podcasts become a habit - sometimes they get too interesting and I stay up for over an hour to keep listening.
- partiallypro 4y agoI'm the same way, I may become exhausted, I can feel myself being exhausted by my mind won't let me sleep.
- eminence32 4y agoIt seems like the headline overstates the findings (as headlines are wont to do), but it's interesting nonetheless > participants who spent more than six hours working on a tedious and mentally taxing assignment had higher levels of glutamate > too much glutamate can disrupt brain function, and a rest period could allow the brain to restore proper regulation of the molecule It sounds like the next step is for some studies on the effects of glutamate
- 1MachineElf 4y agoGlutamate can act as an excitotoxin. Excitotoxicity is believed to be associated with neurodegenerative diseases. https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnins.2015.00469/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fnins.2015.0046... https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fncel.2020.00051/full https://www.frontiersin.org/articles/10.3389/fncel.2020.0005... Related- conflicting research findings and anecdotes on glutamate toxicity from MSG consumption might indicate certain people are more susceptible to the negative effect than others. Raising this question often invites comments on: whether or not cautioning against MSG is actually racist; misdirection about the sodium being the prime issue with MSG; and comments from those with vested interest in MSG (MSG producers, any food producer with MSG, Yeast Extract, or "Natural Flavorings" in their ingredients list, etc.)
- bryceacc 4y agofrom the first link: >L-glu along with glutamine is the most abundant free amino acid in the central nervous system this would suggest that L-glu is highly regulated in the body. Abundance usually means there should be storage of it if level swings can bring "inbalance" to it's usage. on top of that, from this study: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3698427/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3698427/ >In the brain, Glu, which is locally produced completely de novo from glucose, acts as a major excitatory neurotransmitter, and its activity regulates synaptic plasticity, learning, memory, motor activity, and neural development. But dietary Glu is almost impermeable into the circulating blood. Also there is the blood–brain barrier against Glu in between blood and brain so as to not to incorporate into it the brain. if high MSG(or just G from other sources) consumption did cause neurodegenerative diseases, shouldn't we see that data clearly in places that consume more in culture?
- Phileosopher 4y agoI've noticed this phenomenon anecdotally. It seems like my impulse to NOT eat junk food goes down significantly on the days I drive home after working on a hard mental problem. On easy days, I'm craving celery.
- skinnyarms 4y agoThere was an old (but popular) study that showed people were less likely to make healthy snack choices when they were asked to memorize more digits. https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/209563#metadata_info_tab_contents https://www.jstor.org/stable/10.1086/209563#metadata_info_ta...
- Silverback_VII 4y ago
- havblue 4y agoThis has always been an embarrassing issue for me: Lose track of the lecture. Try really hard to concentrate and catch up. Nod off.
- throwaway81523 4y agoI suspect that nodding off in meetings or lectures, a lot of time, is caused by too much CO2 in the air, caused by poor ventilation and a room full of exhaling people.
- swayvil 4y agoThinking is a bottomless pit for attention. Put X attention into digging a hole and you get that much hole dug. Put X attention into sandwich-making and you get that many sandwiches made. But with thinking there's no real connection like that. You can put a whole decade of attention into a bunch of thinking and achieve zip. It's an amazing attention sink. Whole mountains of attention can disappear. Easily. Casually. And then when you consider that many of us basically think all the time. Habitually. Chewing over... memories and dreams and plans and stuff. Woah! And that attention is our energy budget. Flushed down the thinkhole.
- rzzzt 4y agoCan you go without thinking for an extended period of time? I have split seconds here and there when I get the feeling I haven't thought about anything for a while, only to interrupt the streak with the very act of noticing.
- swayvil 4y agoYes I can. That's sorta what we do in this one meditation technique called vipassana. I've been doing it for a few years. When you get out of the habit of doing stuff with your attention all the time (thinking etc) then your attention moves in a new way. It sorta grows. It's pretty great.
- jackconsidine 4y agoGrandmasters apparently lose 6000 calories during classical chess games [0]. That's a few marathons worth of calories. [0] https://www.espn.com/espn/story/_/id/27593253/why-grandmasters-magnus-carlsen-fabiano-caruana-lose-weight-playing-chess https://www.espn.com/espn/story/_/id/27593253/why-grandmaste...
- Tenoke 4y agoThis myth is complete nonsense, I'm not sure how people still share it. The author provides no evidence and simply made some sensationalists estimates based on heart rate and blood pressure during games.
- partiallypro 4y agoI'm sure they are burning more calories, but I doubt it's 6000.
- lemonlime 4y agoNo one who understands how much 6,000 calories is could make this claim. That would mean they need to eat 8,000 calories a day for a normal 2000 calorie diet. That's like Michael Phelps level. That's like: leave the tournament, go back to your hotel and eat 7-8 medium dominos entire pizzas in a sitting. I hope I don't need to explain that this is not what chess masters are doing.
- jackconsidine 4y agoAfter reading Behave, I hold Sapolsky in high regard. Even if he provides weak evidence for the claim, the grandmaster in the article loses 15 pounds- or a whopping 11% of his body weight- on average during a 10 day tournament which is striking.
- heavyset_go 4y agoThis can simply happen because of a change in eating and drinking habits during a 10 day tournament.
- jyounker 4y agoBeing poor takes a huge amount of mental effort. This would explain in physiological terms why it's hard to make good decisions when you're poor.
- challenger-derp 4y agoI think this line of research is necessary in helping us (society) understand ourselves better. Although I've not been poor myself, the ongoing mental stress/strain when met with challenges in which I feel I stand a high chance of failure (e.g. job interviews when I was a new graduate, finding a PhD advisor, submitting first paper for publication) has led me to making poor diet, exercise, and sleep decisions. I would imagine that the poor are faced with an even greater amount of stress in terms of food security, relationship strain, and being cast in a negative light by people around them; making it, as you put it, physiologically harder to make good decisions.
- dalmo3 4y agoThey should study people who spend 6 hours in meetings next.
- vorpalhex 4y agoMeetings are taxing. You're trying to ingest the presented information, social cues/emotional states and often times keeping an eye on slack or what have you.
- joe_the_user 4y ago"...a challenging task: for example, watching letters appear on a computer screen every 1.6 seconds and documenting when one matched a letter that had appeared three letters ago." It seems like they're conflating "stressful" and "thinking hard". IE, Is this "thinking hard" or is it "maintaining constant alertness"? I think things like staring at screen tax more than the brain as such. I spend most mornings working on math, programming and philosophy. This doesn't make me feel tired. Neither does playing the game of Go without a time limit. I assume all those tax the brain itself. But Zoom call will absolutely make me feel tired regardless of the subject. And "stress" could cause a build-up of glutamate or whatever in the brain also.
- glial 4y agoThey used the N-back task, a standard task used for inducing mental effort (e.g. [1]). So in this case they have N=1 for the easy group and N=3 for the hard group. Then they compared glutamate concentration across groups. I'm don't disagree that "thinking hard" is poorly defined. But they did control for staring at a screen. [1] https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0068210 https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal...
- a_c 4y agoI don't know which is more tiresome, 3-4 hours of focused programming and thinking, or 8 hours attending two children below 5. They are both tiring, but differently. Intensive programming is like working hard at the gym. Tiring, but content. Attending children is low intensity in attention, but constantly vigilant. And you are expected to pay that kind of attention for another maybe 4 years. Very different kind of tiring indeed, both makes you unable to focus afterwards. So while thinking hard makes us tired, not thinking hard can also makes us tired.
- fartcannon 4y agoIt really is the vigilance. It's hard to explain to people who haven't experienced it. I certainly tried to understand my colleagues who had kids, but it turns out it's quite a bit harder than the hardest I imagined. Nowadays I'm a part time developer, and the rest of the time, I'm the primary care for a toddler. Programming at work is my time off. You have to be react so quickly to certain things that it keeps you totally wound up. You see them pick something up off the ground and wonder, 'what is that, are they going to eat it' and instinctively you sprint half way across the room to grab what turned out to be a cheerio from their mouth. It's almost always a cheerio. But your brain won't let you rest if there's even an impossibly small chance it's a battery or I dunno, glass or whatever, it doesn't matter how many times you check, you can always imagine something. It's exhausting. I'm rambling because I'm tired. :)
- a_c 4y agoI feel you completely. The children brought me joy that no way I can express how grateful I am. They made me realized experience can only be, well, experienced. No amount of describing can imprint the experience onto anyone. Now I empathize much more with co-workers when they seem oblivious to some solutions. Right now the children are asleep. I tried to catch up some articles or to prototype some something. But hey, no more focus juice left at all :)
- fartcannon 4y agoYou'd think nap times would help, but due to a combination of being zonked from the morning shift, and the mild anxiety that you need to take advantage of this nap time to relax, you end up just staring at a figurative wall for 2 hours. I agree about the joy. This child woke me up.
- ravi-delia 4y agoSee this is why I get annoyed at a body evolved for caloric scarcity. We shouldn't get tired, we should get hungry! Oh, pollutants build up in the brain? Burn more energy to get rid of them! I should be able to strap an icepack to my head, fill a bottle with olive oil, and overclock my brain to 10x speed.
- sebastianconcpt 4y agoHahaha that would be nice. But it likely demands a stock of varied nutrients, not just "energy". Also the cells changing need to take a break to consolidate what they have adapted to (brain plasticity).
- ravi-delia 4y ago> Also the cells changing need to take a break to consolidate what they have adapted to (brain plasticity). I feel like this has got to be a problem solvable by throwing money at it. Not as is, most likely, but if we had evolved without caloric restriction there would be some kind of more complicated support structure which handles all that.
- SketchySeaBeast 4y agoThis feels like it may fall into the realm of "I think if we just throw money at it we could solve it" problems that you can't actually solve by throwing money at.
- ravi-delia 4y agoMetaphorical money thrown at evolution several million years ago, namely calories. You were built on a budget, just because it's still better than anything we could make doesn't mean it's the best evolution can do under lesser constraints
- mywacaday 4y agoIf we had no calorie restriction why would we have evolved.
- sebastianconcpt 4y agoAfter some intense code challenges I did felt exhausted. I learn a lot too because they were out of my comfort zone. I felt like kind of needing to recover resting more the next two days.
- foxbee 4y agoI lost 2kg trying to center a div once. Jokes aside. Interesting article. I think the title assumes an answer but in reality the article is a gateway to further studies. Worthwhile read nonetheless.
- quickthrower2 4y agoIt used to be so easy when <table> was socially acceptable.
- girishso 4y agoCouldn't agree more.
- elcritch 4y agoStraight up raw CSS Grid is my new favorite. It let's you do what we used to do with tables. It even improves it with fr units. Though not sure what to do with the extra brain cycles that don't goto div soup layouts.
- girishso 4y agoMe too. I can't get my head around all the properties for Flexbox, but CSS Grid makes everything so simple. My latest trick is to swap around the "cells", without changing the HTML markup (generated by simple_form Ruby gem).
- bearmode 4y agoIt's way easier with flexbox now, though?
- randomsearch 4y agoCentring divs is now an out of date joke, grandad, get with it. Flex box ruined it. Seriously, I wonder what the modern equivalent is? Using dev tools to find the source of an unwanted space? What do you mean property X is inherited but only from the last positioned ancestor with a flex size of pi and a negative z index?
- NotTameAntelope 4y agoBrilliant work, and the researcher involved seems quite humble, despite her impressive discovery. Where in the world is Carmen Sandi’s ego?
- SmileyJames 4y agoLooks like an interesting article, too tired to read it though. XD
- wawjgreen 4y agothe article merely said the obvious: thinking makes you tired--without providing any workable solutions. typical of the pedants and grant-whores.
- ElijahLynn 4y agoVery fascinating discovery! I wonder if this may be linked to Type II Narcolepsy, which currently doesn't have a known cause. Type II narcolepsy requires very short naps that come on suddenly, like a computer reboot, then the brain is back in action!
- tastysandwich 4y agoMaybe it's just me, but I find meetings to be way more mentally fatiguing than, say, coding. Even if I'm just listening in. A 1.5hr meeting cooks me. After a showcase, which can go for 2 hours, I'm done for the day. However what works for me isn't having a rest, or flicking through YT for some quick mental rewards. A good walk, or doing some gardening, mowing the lawns - basically anything physical - helps me regenerate. Especially being outside. That's been a big benefit of working from home. Yesterday at lunchtime I just went out back with a skillsaw and cut a whole bunch of wood for an hour (not random cutting, I need it for a project haha). Came back in feeling great!
- the_only_law 4y agoGod yes. If I’m properly ”in the flow” as they say (although it’s rare), then I feel more energetic. Meetings, especially ones I’m barely relevant to but forced to attend, could probably be an effective sleep aid.
- shard 4y agoListening in on meetings is one level of fatigue, but hosting/leading meetings is a whole other level for me. Having to multi-process in order to: 1. Keep discussions on track 2. Give everyone a chance to participate 3. Watch the time and make sure that all topics are covered 4. Take notes 5. Think about what is being discussed and participate is incredibly exhausting. After leading 2-3 meetings, I feel like I've used up all my mental energy for the day. And as I a writing this, I realized that after leading a meeting, I typically hop out to the kitchen and grab a bite to eat. Maybe that's an instinctual need to refill the calories I expended thinking? Or maybe it's just a reward am seeking after the tiring task...
- mancerayder 4y agoFor me the above is part of it. And our company culture isn't big on sending out minutes (which is bad and good). The bigger thing that tires me out is the wild context switching of one meeting after the next, on very disparate topics. I'm often left still thinking about something from before, and have to jump to a wildly new topic with my full attention. It's exhausting.
- jrjarrett 4y ago
- jameslk 4y ago> At the end of their work day, these study participants were also more likely than those who had performed easier tasks to opt for short-term, easily won financial rewards of lesser value than larger rewards that come after a longer wait or involve more effort. I wonder if this has any implications on the "ego depletion" model, which has had a checkered history in reproducibility: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ego_depletion https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ego_depletion
- coderenegade 4y agoNot a doctor, so I might be stating the obvious to anyone who is, but couldn't this explain why exercise seems to make people feel more energetic? If a buildup of pollutants in the brain can make you feel fatigued, then better cardiovascular fitness and healthy kidneys would help clear these pollutants out more effectively, right? It isn't that you have more energy, it's just that being healthier is helping clear the things that make you mentally fatigued. I guess you could also turn this on its head for people with chronic fatigue by looking at their cardiovascular and kidney function.
- randomsearch 4y agoCan definitely confirm that exercise reduces my stress levels and improved my intellectual capacity. It is almost universal advice to startup founders to exercise frequently, and I think there’s a lot of personal experiences behind that.
- tapatio 4y agoSolution: stop thinking. Sign me up!
- djmips 4y agoYeah, take some breaks. Also don't refuse to take vacations.
- occasionalcoder 4y agoI always wondered how we feel being tired - whatever the underlying reason is. Where in the brain does it happen, what system does the perception of beeing tired - reporting it to consciousness? Also, it must exist to stop something harmful to happen to the brain or other parts of the body. Something else: Abnormal fatigue happens after brain injuries but also in depression. In brain injury some basic mechanism - like transmitter metabolism my be damaged, and cause the fatigue, but may fatigue also protect the psyche in some way, or may it sometimes give "false readouts"? I'm amazed how little we understand, but even more that nobody seem to ask the question about or investigate the question of the "tiredness-perception-brain-curcuit".
- AccountAccount1 4y agoNo, it's definitely in study and a lot of computational models of how these mechanisms may work were put forward. Most definitely it has to do with "to stop something harmful to happen to the brain" but since the brain is such a huge interconnected mess, it's difficult to make a grand statement. An analogy with weight-lifting (or long-distance running) is easier: when you are lifting weights sometimes you reach failure and you think you can go no further, but usually this is a message having to do with the body parts you are exercising just being to hot... some weight-lifters quickly cool down the palms of their hands (under the arms, under the feets, etc...) and can continue lifting. Is very simple, you don't want to cook yourself, but the message that we consciously feel is akin to, "I can't go no more" when instead by lowering body temperature, you can come back. So one factor, definitely, is temperature (you don't want your brain to get too hot) but also is the rate at which you can recreate new neuronal connections (when learning for example. And what are the constituents of these new neuronal pathways? Do you also delete?) These are only two factors and there has to be a whole panoply of them (electrolytes, vitamins, glucose, dopamine, etc...)
- kaumrebahan 4y agoReading this article makes me feel tired.
- fargle 4y agoThen why does spending all day in stupid endless meetings make you feel even more tired?
- MuffinFlavored 4y agoDoes thinking hard burn calories/contribute to weight loss?
- falseprofit 4y agoMore discussion on the article in Science here: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32435019 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32435019 Top commenter there seems to find the reporting problematic. I’d love to see more discussion in that thread from anyone who is knowledgable.
- zwischenzug 4y agoI do 4 hour long OReilly trainings. These are to about 100 people online you can't see or hear. The first time I did it, it was so stressful that I couldn't stand up afterwards - my legs were so tired. I also needed to switch my brain off afterwards, so drank quite a lot of alcohol. Let nobody tell you that desk work is not physically demanding work!