10 ms·
A proper carbon tax would only increase flight costs by about 8%, since there's lots of other costs than fuel. People don't seem to believe that though. Becaus
by ZeroGravitas 4y ago
A proper carbon tax would only increase flight costs by about 8%, since there's lots of other costs than fuel.
People don't seem to believe that though. Because a carbon tax high enough to make your flight cast 8% more, would totally destroy the fossil fuel industry, as everyone would suddenly have a financial incentive to burn less of it, and there's alternatives for almost all uses. And so, a measure that would kill the fossil fuel industry, and not really bother any other industry, is portrayed as an impossible dream because the fossil fuel industry has a lot of money and power.
- indymike 4y ago> a measure that would kill the fossil fuel industry Increasing the cost of flights by 8%, and by doing so, killing the source of fuel for those flights sounds like economic Armageddon.
- aoeusnth1 4y agoI guess we have to choose between two Armageddons then, one real and one inconvenient.
- indymike 4y ago> I guess we have to choose between two Armageddons then, one real and one inconvenient. We can chose something that is less perfect, but does not result in Armageddon. Solutions that are as bad or worse than the problem are a very hard sell.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoclimate change will result in famine and war, maybe nuclear war. Madagaskar has a drought xaused famine right now. Uf that hapens in Pakistan thats a powderkeg situation. Which 'solution' is as bad?
- quickthrower2 4y agoImagine what it would do if we put heavy restrictions on borders and travel and there was a massive drop in demand from, something like a terrorist attack, or maybe a virus. It would snuff out all industry. Impossible to cope.
- npc54321 4y agoMy whole family went from just plain d poverty to extreme poverty thanks to the lockdowns....
- nslzk 4y ago
- salawat 4y agoNot everyone here is ignorant or unwilling to think of second order effects. You can't really do programming/networks/tech as a career and not get it after a certain point. These problems are hard as hell, and yeah, being paid well insulates one from a lot of problems if that's what you set out to do. Not everyone sets out to do that though.
- yonaguska 4y agoIt's hard to understand being poor unless you've been there though. You can acknowledge it, yes, but that's usually as far as most people will go.
- quickthrower2 4y agoSorry that your family had to go through that, and all the people in affected industries, but the lockdowns also saved a lot of lives. Probably millions. Thousands of 9/11s. Worldwide. A lockdown "here" prevents covid spreading both here .... and there. The main topic of this thread is saving humanity from adverse man-made climate change. We are also talking about saving millions here.
- wmf 4y agoWe shouldn't say that the oil industry will be killed; it would be more like a ramp down over 30-40 years.
- dheera 4y agoNo, we would /reduce/ the source of fuel for those flights to the amount actually needed while people who don't have a good reason to fly stop flying. It will also incentivize people to find better sources of fuel, and invent better aircraft.
- LorenPechtel 4y agoWhich is why we should never implement such a tax all at once. You implement such things slowly to let the market adjust.
- jasonlaramburu 4y ago>a carbon tax high enough to make your flight cast 8% more, would totally destroy the fossil fuel industry, as everyone would suddenly have a financial incentive to burn less of it. This is not necessarily true. Oil has a traditionally low elasticity of demand, meaning that demand for it does not change significantly even when its price changes. This is particularly true in the US, where there are few public transportation options in most cities.
- Dylan16807 4y agoIn the short term, yes. Long term there are so many things we can switch to electricity or to alternate sources.
- seunosewa 4y agoPlease explain how you obtained the 8% figure.
- Terr_ 4y agoNot the parent poster, but if we assume fuel costs are 20% of total expenses [1] then a 40% tax on the fuel, if completely passed on to the customer, would make each flight 8% more expensive. Whether 40% correctly offsets pollution externalities is a tougher question. [1] https://www.transportation.gov/administrations/assistant-secretary-research-and-technology/what-cost-airline-fuel-means-you https://www.transportation.gov/administrations/assistant-sec...
- nopzor 4y agojet-a is a /lot/ more expensive since that article was written ;-)
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoNote though it's not fuel cost we're taxing, but carbon, so more efficiently made fossil fuels would be cheaper and have less carbon tax, even if they are chemically indistinguishable from other fuels and contain the exact same number of fossil carbon atoms. Things like, does the delivery truck have an efficient engine. Does the refinery use green or gray hydrogen to desulpherise the inputs, do they buy their fossil fuels from Norway vs Russia and so on. It might only be a small difference but small differences across the whole economy is how the carbon tax is supposed to work.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoThe EU calculate that as the price rise that would result in 2050 from their net zero plans. Here's an aviation industry take on the plans, which seek to reduce the carbon by 55% by 2030 https://www.eurocontrol.int/article/eus-fit-55-package-what-does-it-mean-aviation https://www.eurocontrol.int/article/eus-fit-55-package-what-... But it's easy enough to find CO2 calculators and estimated costs of carbon and compare with current flight costs to get your own number for flights that matter to you. When people do this though, they think "This seems suspiciously cheap? I thought this was going to take us back to the stone age, not just make long transatlantic flights a bit more expensive by not subsidizing them as much" then they come up with conspiracy theories about how it's all greenwashing to make sense of it all.
- atwood22 4y agoI’m of a different opinion. There actually aren’t alternatives to fossil fuel and that’s why there isn’t broad support for the tax. A tax on fossil fuel would make everything more expensive with little recourse for alternatives. I bought an electric power washer and weed wacker recently. The performance is just laughable compared to the petrol powered version. Electric cars have given people hope that a fossil fuel free future is possible. However, electric cars seem to occupy a niche where carrying around 30x the amount of “fuel” is possible. Most fossil fuel uses don’t share this luxury. Climate change will likely force a fossil fuel free future. But it probably won’t look much like the society we have today. There certainly won’t be high PSI pressure washers.
- ClumsyPilot 4y ago> A tax on fossil fuel would make everything more expensive with little recourse for alternatives. that money doesn't dissapear, it could be used to reduce other taxes, say income tax or VAT. it's purpose is to rebalance relative cost of things
- collegeburner 4y agono its purpose is to fix an externality. it should be exactly equal to the cost of carbon offset for the amount emitted. or better yet license anybody to do carbon capture and require presenting a certificate of equal carbon removed. start at like 1/8 emissions removal and go up over time. if you care about stopping carbon emissions i think this is the most realistic and efficient way. otherwise we get caught up in discussions of how this changes redistribution and "economic/environmental justice" or whatever and it will never happen. but unfortunately there are many people who care more about adding more free stuff or using the funds for more dumb congress policies then actually passing a carbon policy.
- Clubber 4y ago>>A proper carbon tax would only increase flight costs by about 8% >no its purpose is to fix an externality. it should be exactly equal to the cost of carbon offset for the amount emitted. So it would only cost 8% of the cost of a flight to completely remove all the carbon emitted from that flight? That seems pretty reasonable. How is this done?
- VoodooJuJu 4y ago>a carbon tax high enough to make your flight cast 8% more Where would this money go? Who would allocate it? Would it be allocated effectively, efficiently? As effective as road tax dollars, or as effective as lottery tax dollars? Would it just go to make more factories for Tesla? More eco-warehouses for Amazon? For the bureaucrat-in-charge's cousins? Where does it go and how does it get there?
- ItsMonkk 4y agoThe Canadian system mostly simply gives it back out evenly to all. That choice is a just one. > Alberta, Ontario, Manitoba, Saskatchewan, Yukon and Nunavat use the federal carbon tax system, the Federal Fuel Charge, which started in 2019. Of these, all but Nunavat have a carbon fee and dividend scheme in place that redistributes tax revenue to the public. [0] Since carbon use is skewed heavily to those that use the most, this means that the median user of carbon is actually given a tax credit each year. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_fee_and_dividend#Implementation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_fee_and_dividend#Implem...
- vasco 4y agoIt also means the current generation of normal people have no incentive to put pressure on the large industries of their country, the more they use the more money they get and the more messed up they leave it for the next generation.
- gruez 4y agoOkay but at an individual level you're still incentivized to reduce your own emissions. Every $1 of carbon tax you pay is $1 out of your wallet, but you're only getting $1/(39 million) back through the carbon rebate.
- theptip 4y ago“Normal people” don’t have to put pressure for this to work. Every point along the supply chain absorbs the price signal and will find cheaper (ie less CO2-producing) options where possible, raising the price a little. Where not possible the price goes up by the full CO2 tax amount. (In other words if it’s still the cheapest option to just pay the extra tax, like jet fuel, then the price just goes up.) The consumer might hypothetically not get any different choices, but still see a CO2 tax cause all deliveries to use electric trucks, for example. Consumers “putting pressure on companies” is a terrible way to fix this problem because few consumers have a clear picture of the current landscape of CO2 intensity and possible best fixes across the whole economy. But if you just price the externality in, then the market constraint-solves the problem for you. (To be clear I don’t think markets are perfect, they are just much better than human coordinators at solving this class of problem.)
- uluyol 4y agoIf oil costs rise, it will impact more than just jet fuel prices for planes. Wages and part prices are sure to rise as well.
- ncmncm 4y agoThat is the point. Carbon-intensive industry prices would rise more than others, and people would shift spending to alternatives, where presented. People would have more to spend, and would re-allocate according to price signals.
- devwastaken 4y ago8% carbon tax is 8% higher power bill. Natural gas is still king in power generation.
- aembleton 4y ago8% higher power bill will increase the yield for alternatives and incentives investment in them.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Eavolution 4y agoThis don't seem fair on people who dont have much of a choice, like if you live in the country (no public transport) and frequently have to make trips longer than an EV would typically allow. All a carbon tax there would do is make life more expensive.
- evandijk70 4y agoDo you really believe that there are people that can't make their life work without making frequent 100+ mile long trips?
- krageon 4y agoEven if there are, they are a vanishing minority - they're worth taking into account but not to the extent of not taking measures necessary to save everyone.
- yellowapple 4y agoThere indeed are here in the US, including quite a few of my family members. That said, the people who live in such places (including the aforementioned family members) tend to be the hardy and adaptable sort, and would readily figure something out should carbon-emitting transportation become cost-prohibitive.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoMany actual carbon taxes/fees that exist in the real world give rural people slightly more money for this reason. I believe this is the case in parts of Canada and Austria for example. They're often also phased per sector, so you might have a carbon fee for transport but not industry or vice versa, or have different levels of fees. It's fairly flexible as a policy tool.
- parkingrift 4y agoWhat you’re describing here is economic suicide. One party could vote this into law, but it would be repealed in absolutely no more than four years. Fossil fuel lobbyists aren’t the problem. No one individual nation is willing to commit economic suicide while the rest of the world advances. There is no appetite at present for a global economic suicide pact. Your 8% comment is fundamentally wrong, too. You don’t think the “lots of other costs” would be impacted by a 40% fuel tax?!? Back to reality, please. Edit: you’re -> your
- plaguepilled 4y agoI was about to ask OP for a source, but since you're confident that they're incorrect, can you cite your claims too?
- ZeroGravitas 4y agohttps://www.euractiv.com/section/biofuels/news/greening-measures-will-add-around-8-to-airline-costs-eu-estimates/ https://www.euractiv.com/section/biofuels/news/greening-meas... News story with a summary but there's plenty of source documents out there if you feel like a deep dive.
- parkingrift 4y agoYou want a source that immediately increasing fuel costs by 40%, as suggested by OP, would be economic suicide? Fortunately, I don’t need a study. Fuel costs rose in the US 40% over the last year before falling. If you want to know what happened in the US, pick up a newspaper and read about record high inflation.
- ZeroGravitas 4y agoWhy did you introduce the idea of it happening immediately, overnight? Did it seem too reasonable a suggestion to phase it in over decades with plenty of advance notice? Too achievable, too simple, too sensible? Not to mention, the "extra cost" would be getting paid to the government in your own country, not to Vladimir Putin or similar in another. And then new business opportunities would be created, again in your own country, to meet this new demand. Luckily, we've actually started doing this already. It seems important that the people who complain about it being impossible seem to have not noticed that it's already started and been quite successful so far, giving confidence to people who are paying attention. If that's the case, how bad can it actually be?