14 ms·
That whole line of thinking just blows me away. It's possible to accurately sample and reproduce any vinyl recording in the digital realm. It's absolutely not p
by kstrauser 4y ago
That whole line of thinking just blows me away. It's possible to accurately sample and reproduce any vinyl recording in the digital realm. It's absolutely not possible to accurately record every digital recording onto vinyl. For instance, it's not hard at all to make bass so loud that it causes the needle to leap out of the track, or treble so high that the needle can't accurately track the high frequency vibrations.
In fact, part of the record player spec is the "RIAA equalization"[0] that attempts to account for the fact that vinyl isn't good at recording a wide range of frequencies well. On recording, you cut the bass and jack up the treble. On playback, you boost the bass and reduce the treble. Without that, vinyl would be even worse than it is today.
It's absolutely, 100% fine for someone to say that they subjectively prefer the sound quality of a record player to a CD. I don't, but that's fine: it's purely a preference thing. But to claim that vinyl is objectively better in some way is just ludicrous.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RIAA_equalization https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/RIAA_equalization
- jrajav 4y agoMost of the time people will argue that vinyl has "warmth" and this makes it subjectively better. This is true, but it's actually because of the pleasing distortion record players add to the music. Being distortion, even if it improves your listening experience (and this depends on genre, though it generally does), it is certainly objectively worse in terms of accurate reproduction.
- kstrauser 4y agoExactly. If you like that warmth, awesome. There's not a thing wrong with that. It's when people confuse "warm" for "better" that the problems start.
- mod 4y agoCan't the warmth just be reproduced in a digital player anyway?
- kstrauser 4y agoYup. Boost the mids on your EQ and you're halfway there.
- djbusby 4y agoWhat's the other half? Magic in the amp-circuit?
- cool_dude85 4y agoThousand dollar rocks and crystals to place around your room.
- iamacyborg 4y agoCrystals? I only use wooden resonators, personally. https://www.analogueseduction.net/record-clamps/SHUNMOOKprod4.html https://www.analogueseduction.net/record-clamps/SHUNMOOKprod...
- masklinn 4y agoWell yes but that's not actually what the intent was. Though I would expect it'd be more of an eq profile thing.
- com2kid 4y agoYes, the "warmth" generated by from literally any possible analog circuit can be reproduced digitally. Physics doesn't care about people's beliefs, but sadly many people also don't care about physics.
- 323 4y agoIn theory. In practice, if I give you a random analog box, transforming it into an accurate DSP algorithm it's an extremely difficult problem. Which is why people instead of doing that, they recreate the "idea" (reverb, delay, ...) digitally, but it's not a copy.
- taylorportman 4y agoAn instrument amplified by vacuum tubes does have a distinct sound, "vinyl" also has its own signature.. magnetic tape is pretty analog too. All of these signature sounds can be digitized/discretized at sampling rates that preserve the vinyl crackle or tube warmth or combinations. To me it seems like marketing and the consumers justification of their susceptibility.
- bigiain 4y ago> An instrument amplified by vacuum tubes does have a distinct sound Only if it’s pushed into distortion. Guitar players (generally) like tube Amos because of the way they distort compared to transistor amps. If you are not pushing the amps into distortion, they will only sound different if they’re badly designed.
- bobbylarrybobby 4y agoNot necessarily (well I guess it depends what you mean by "pushed"), but I think tube amps naturally boost the even-numbered harmonics at all volume levels. This sounds good but is distortion.
- bigiain 4y agoThat’d show up in the Total Harmonic Distortion figure for the amp, and for any halfway hifi quality oriented amp it’ll be well below 0.1%. Perhaps “golden ears” can hear that? I’m not convinced. Most hifi audio amps typically run at well down into the single digit percentage of their rated output at ordinary listening levels in most systems, so they’re an order of magnitude or two away from clipping. If the feedback circuit and the output devices (transistors or tubes) can’t keep the response perfectly linear the thd down under 0.1% across the entire audio frequency band in that power range, it’s just badly designed.
- bambax 4y agoYES! The article says this: > But a few specialty houses (...) have long advocated for the warmth of analog. “Not that you can’t make good records with digital, but it just isn’t as natural as when you use the original tape,” says Bernie Grundman which is absurd. "Warmth" is a kind of distortion, and if a signal is distorted then it's less accurate or "natural"! They can't claim "fidelity" and "warmth" at the same time. It's one or the other.
- AnimalMuppet 4y agoBut if analog is what you knew, that wasn't "distortion". That was "natural", because it was what you grew up with. That was the way things were supposed to be. So "fidelity" means "fidelity to the way I remember" (and like).
- yencabulator 4y agoNot "natural", "familiar". Just like people buying yellow lightbulbs because that's how incandescent bulbs used to always be -- actual natural sunlight isn't that yellow. Good LEDs are more "natural", but less "familiar" to people.
- tomc1985 4y agoOn a high quality record with a high quality setup, you can have both. It's because the distortion is really subtle, and hits all the right harmonics. On bass-heavy music it makes the bass sound really nice. The other parts of "warmth" aren't really in my wheelhouse, but it makes the bass in bass music better
- pessimizer 4y agoI still think that "warmth" is a way to describe not actually hearing the separate digital samples subconsciously, and just hearing the sounds gliss into each other. I also think it's an anachronism that comes from way back when the digital sample rate was often a lot lower (and people would insist that their live digital effects sounded as good as analog, when you could sometimes even consciously hear the samples jumping into each other.) Other than that, it seems like something that people project onto music with bassy reverb.
- Wolfenstein98k 4y agoYou cannot hear samples, or the "steps" between them. This is a silly idea that comes from people seeing pictures of the waveform as it is digitally captured and imagining they can hear it. You cannot, it is impossible. Even with an unrealistically low sample rate (say 500Hz instead of 44.1kH), this will not sound like 500 beats per second as the "steps" occur, but rather will just sound extraordinarily dull, as the Nyquist frequency has dropped to 1kHz, a fairly low tone, and all info above that has been lowpassed away. When the signal is changed to analog by the DAC in order to come out of a speaker, the "steps" become smooth curves like any analog waveform. You cannot hear "digital steps" because they cannot be audible - sound is vibration, and it cannot be made into steps in the analog realm.
- palimpsests 4y agoas the other poster noted, it’s not possible to hear each sample individually. what is bassy reverb?
- christkv 4y agoReminds me of the tube vs transistor amplifiers discussions where tube amplifiers are supposed to have a warmer sound.
- wrycoder 4y agoThe thing I miss with the Apple audio chain is a user-controlled equalizer. With my hearing issues, I really need to boost treble, and I prefer to boost bass. I haven't yet discovered a way to do that. Apple thinks that flat is best, and so should you, apparently.
- bitcurious 4y agoOn iOS, settings>music>EQ has some presets you could try. Not quite the same as custom eq but might be better than flat.
- ultrarunner 4y agoAnd it's insane that this hasn't changed for at least a decade! Apple's own PowerBeats Pro sound like garbage without bumping up the low frequencies, but with an equalizer they sound great. Or maybe this is just subjective and you can file it under "accessibility". I was jailbroken on iOS 14 for the longest time solely for a system-wide equalizer for Apple Music. With a new phone it's a major step back, and I've switched to Spotify for their (worse) equalizer and somewhat worse overall experience (Spotify doesn't even have an equalizer on desktop!) It's really unfortunate that such a straightforward feature is so limited on Apple platforms, and for no discernible reason.
- egypturnash 4y agoOn OSX Music, window>equalizer. You can also grab Rogue Amoeba’s “SoundSource” to have volume controls for every noise-generating app on the computer, and apply effects chains to them, including EQ.
- kstrauser 4y agoI love SoundSource so much. I bought it so I could use the volume keys on my keyboard to adjust the system volume on my HDMI monitor. I was blown away when I found out I could plug my collection of VSTs into the output pipeline.
- 4y ago
- kazinator 4y ago> 100% fine for someone to say that they subjectively prefer the sound quality of a record player to a CD It's not intellectually fine, only fine in the sense that it's well within the bounds of free speech.
- NovemberWhiskey 4y agoNo; it's really fine - same with tube amps etc. It's OK to have a subjective preference for some kinds of distortion. It's not OK to say it's "truer to the original sound", which is where this usually comes off the rails.
- kazinator 4y agoSure, if the artifact you prefer actually exists and you can confirm it in a double blind test.
- cwillu 4y ago“I prefer bit of oregano on my pasta.” “Not without a double-blind test you don't!”
- pessimizer 4y ago"The pasta you just said was the best pasta you ever had didn't have any oregano on it."
- cwillu 4y agoThere was no cilantro in the dish you just said was delicious: we substituted dove-brand soap shavings.
- wolrah 4y agoYou're not wrong in the general "audiophile" world where fools and their money are parted over snake oil magical cables claiming benefits only those with the most golden of ears can enjoy. Where you're getting pushback is that this thread is talking about vinyl records and tube amps, things where the noise and distortions introduced by their operation are well known, well documented, audible to anyone with normally functional ears, and regularly utilized artistically. These are not the inventions of grifters with a product to sell, it's just an older technology that is less precise in a certain predictable way which some people find pleasant.
- iforgotpassword 4y agoThat's the main reason I really like vinyl. Physics prevents the mastering engineers from going overly crazy. Vinyl often sounds more carefully mastered, even though nothing would technically prevent you from releasing the same thing in digital form. The other thing I like is that it really takes more effort to put on a record than start a track on Spotify. I really only do it when I can take the time to do so. Pick a record from the shelf, carefully take it out of the sleeve, carefully put it down on the turntable, and then really listen to a full record while sitting or lying on the couch doing nothing else. Again nothing you couldn't do with Spotify or YouTube music, but somehow you (well, at least I) never do.
- kstrauser 4y agoI listened to "Disintegration" last week exactly like that, but with Apple Music. It was the first time I'd listened to an album start-to-finish in years, and I highly recommend it. I like not having to flip the record halfway through, or being able to listen to "The Wall" without 3 flips.
- wk_end 4y agoThe structure that side/disc limitations impose is part of the listening experience, to me - I like having to take a moment to consider the sub-narrative of the side as a whole before moving on. Even when streaming I’ll often look up the vinyl track listings to get a sense of the artist’s intended schema.
- kstrauser 4y agoI get it. I still like having the option to skip it if I'm being lazy.
- hbn 4y ago> I like having to take a moment to consider the sub-narrative of the side as a whole before moving on. That's a great way of putting it! And something I hadn't considered before I bought a record player and started listening to it. There's that point in time where you realize the A-side is done, you get up to go and flip it, and you have a half-minute or so of reflection on the first half. Then the B-side starts and it's like the second act of a play is starting after intermission.
- cammikebrown 4y agoWhat’s really funny about this is that although CDs objectively can present a greater dynamic range, the loudness wars have created a lot of highly compressed CDs that do sound worse than a lot of vinyl, where it often seems that more cars is taken with mastering because of the limitations of the medium. Additionally, a lot of early 80s albums sound better on vinyl because digital mastering wasn’t as good then. It is an absolutely night and day difference between my vinyl copy of Unknown Pleasures and my CD.
- Nav_Panel 4y agoYep. This is why I like buying original 80s CDs where they just chucked the master tape onto a digital disk, rather than post-2000 reissues where they slap a limiter on the master and jack it up +8 dB.
- btown 4y ago> it often seems that more cars is taken with mastering I know this was a typo, but tools like https://shop.audified.com/products/mixchecker https://shop.audified.com/products/mixchecker (with a literal "sedan" button) and articles like https://ask.audio/articles/the-final-mix-using-your-car https://ask.audio/articles/the-final-mix-using-your-car are sadly indicative of the emphasis in modern mastering on sounding good on car speakers - which is the entire problem in a nutshell.
- palimpsests 4y agomodern mastering does not optimize fidelity in a car at the expense of other modes of listening, and these articles do not indicate as such. modern mastering does take into account a highly popular listening environment, to ensure that the mix sounds good there as well. the second article you posted is talking about using a car as one of several environments in which to test a mix. because it’s a “known” reference in a real-world environment (your ears are used to listening to mastered music on a car stereo).
- amelius 4y ago> On recording, you cut the bass and jack up the treble. On playback, you boost the bass and reduce the treble. Sounds like if you combine the two steps you end up with the identity operator :)
- Jaxan 4y agoThat’s the point!
- amelius 4y agoParent was trying to show that > It's absolutely not possible to accurately record every digital recording onto vinyl. Outlining an idempotent process of recording and playback does not help there.
- kstrauser 4y agoIf they were idempotent, yes. But they're not. Analog processing can't be perfect, and amplification is an inherently noisy process. The RIAA curve first cuts the signal on the bass end of the spectrum, throwing away information in the process (because vinyl doesn't have infinite resolution). Then it amplifies that degraded signal. You can simulate this pretty well with computer speakers. Turn down your audio outputs so that it's barely audible, then turn up the speakers as load as they'll go. Noisy, isn't it? In theory that should be the same as turning the outputs to their maximum clean level and turning your speakers way down, but in practice it's absolutely not. Well, every vinyl record made does exactly that to the bass.
- colejohnson66 4y agoThat’s the idea, in theory. But because analog components such as the resistors, capacitors, and transistors will not be identical[0] between the master and player, it’s not perfect. [0]: you can get very low tolerance resistors and capacitors, but they’ll cost you
- kstrauser 4y agoTo a point, but remember that you're dealing with low-bit floating point math. That boosting stage creates information that wasn't originally there. That's not so bad in the treble case where original * boost / filter is pretty close to the original. But in the bass case, original / filter * boost might be significantly different than the original. That's usually not a huge problem because the low bass frequencies are pretty forgiving, but it's something to consider.
- cratermoon 4y ago> it's not hard at all to make bass so loud that it causes the needle to leap out of the track Reminds me of the LP my band teacher in high school had. It was the 1812 overture, and the groves for the cannon shots at the end were easily distinguishable with just a casual examination. Based on what you're saying, I suspect that recording was pushing the limits of vinyl.
- cwillu 4y agoI'm imagining a recording of a nuclear blast with sufficiently deep grooves to accurately reproduce the shock wave. With the satisfying full warm tone vinyl is known for.
- wrycoder 4y agoFermi just dropped small pieces of paper :)
- cwillu 4y agoWas going more for: “Rabbit hands Duck a phonograph of a nuclear detonation. Duck carefully places the needle on the record. Duck sits quietly in front of the phonograph's horn. Blastwave from nuclear detonation is emitted from the horn while Rabbit looks at the viewer smugly.”
- kstrauser 4y agoYes! That exact song is perhaps the canonical demonstration of the limitations of vinyl! Here are some pics of the grooves on that LP: https://imgur.com/a/veVB0 https://imgur.com/a/veVB0
- cratermoon 4y agoOh, very nice. That's exactly I as I remember it.
- ryukoposting 4y agoI absolutely despise most of the vinyl community. Don't get me wrong, I love my records. I have hundreds of them and I play them regularly. For some reason, almost everyone I come by has this delusion that vinyl is objectively better than a good digital recording. Anyone who dissents from that narrative gets gaslit: "oh what kind of turntable do you have? oh that's not good enough, there's your problem right there." "what speakers do you have? what about your phono + power amps? oh that's not good enough, there's your problem right there." "how did you place your speakers? oh, you should have them at 45 degrees, not 60." "is it a re-pressing? from whom? oh, there's your problem right there." The end result is a bunch of nerds ruining their credit scores because someone told them they need gold-plated hydraulic bearings in their tonearm to properly listen to their mom's copy of Led Zeppelin IV. Does it sound different? Yes. Does it sound better? If you're really trying to get the most out of the music itself, no. Warm ⊄ good. Vinyl is great because you aren't just listening to music. The medium demands something from you. It's tactile. The album artwork is a complete ensemble, rather than a little icon on your phone. In my case, I had to put in effort to restore the equipment I play my records on, so there's a bit of pride in it. It's a more intimate experience.
- xbar 4y agoIs this not the experience in every human community? For the record, I like your approach to music enjoyment.
- dekhn 4y agoThere definitely was a short period in college where I needed to spend money I barely had to upgrade my system. This was when CDs first came out. I could tell, when listening through my stereo (as compared to plugging my headphones into the CD player) that there was a ton of extra noise/distortion and most importantly, a very high noise level (audible hiss). Ended up having to go to Salvation Army to buy a $25 used receiver and the speaker store to buy a pair of $200 speakers before I got decent results. Even after that, I had no end of problems with the analog cable. it took a long time to switch to digital. Nowadays I can get excellent audio quality watching good Youtube videos or streaming from my preferred music site (I only listen through headphones now). I'm super glad I was able to get to the quality level I liked for fairly cheap.
- analog31 4y agoThere's no a priori reason why any recording medium needs to have a flat response curve, so long as the curve is known so it can be reversed. The reason for the RIAA curve is that most sound has an inverse relationship between amplitude and frequency. The RIAA recording curve limits the overall amplitude of the groove, allowing for better management of dynamic range and distortion in the cutting and playback processes. The slight lumps in the curve are a concession to practical filter technology of the 1950s. Other analog broadcast and recording media have similar curves, called pre- and de-emphasis. Digital doesn't need it because it has effectively zero distortion, and dynamic range to spare. An advantage of vinyl is that there's a physical deliverable, making it possible to monetize it. I think that's why a lot of indie bands use vinyl.
- kstrauser 4y agoMore people own CD players than record players. Indie bands would be better off selling CDs if that were really the main intention.
- analog31 4y agoIndeed, that's true. The vinyl thing is probably more about the vinyl trend. I go to a lot of "indie" performances, and have the musicians directly: How do I buy your stuff, so you make the most money? The answer is always the same: Buy the CD right here.
- bigbillheck 4y ago> It's absolutely, 100% fine for someone to say that they subjectively prefer the sound quality of a record player to a CD. There's a lot of weirdos out there, but these ones aren't hurting anybody.
- FullyFunctional 4y agoFlat earth, Scientology, dowsing rods, ... willful ignorance is hard to fight. Anyone with basic understanding of A/D conversion and sampling theory will understand that you can always exceed analog with digital, given enough bits (and 2*16 @ 44.1 kHz is already pretty darn good). In the early days of MPEG Audio, Level 2 (not mp3) I spent a lot of time listening to samples and I was taken aback when I finally traced flaws back to the CD itself (Cranberries, Zombie, 1994). Many of the early CDs really weren't that great, but that wasn't due to being "digital", just a sloppy production.
- mrandish 4y agoAgreed. So much of the early negativity around "digital" and "compression" was due to avoidable mistakes made when mastering some particular pieces of media back in the early days.
- staticautomatic 4y agoI’ve heard stories about things like the cannon sounds in the Telarc vinyl of the 1812 Overture blowing out unfiltered speakers. Are they myths?
- bigiain 4y ago> It's absolutely, 100% fine for someone to say that they subjectively prefer the sound quality of a record player to a CD. I love listening to vinyl. But I’m not gonna lie to myself and say “it sounds better”. The engineer/scientist in me knows it doesn’t, and the pragmatist/experimentalist in me knows that even if I can reliably detect differences between a good digital recording and a good vinyl copy of a song (which I’m not convinced I really can) there is nit nearly enough difference ever to say one is better than the other. I like the ceremony of playing vinyl. It adds to my enjoyment, but in the kind of way that a Japanese tea ceremony “improves the taste” of tea. Also, a long time back I realised that listening to hifi _gear_ leads only to criticism and unhappiness, while listening to great music leads to joy. So I mostly have given up critically listening to “gear”. A great song or album can be a thing of joy coming out of your laptop speakers. Coltrane or Ellen Allien or Polyphia are no less amazingly talented in shitty phone earbuds compared to my thousands of dollars of living room hifi. I’m too old to want to argue about “clarity of soundstage” or “time alignment in the tweeter crossover”, I just want to rock out or dance or groove along to great tunes. I can do that with a 100% analog signal path in my lounge room, or in cheap Bluetooth earbuds inside my motorcycle helmet with a 97db noise floor…
- brigandish 4y ago> For instance, it's not hard at all to make bass so loud that it causes the needle to leap out of the track I was a drum and bass dj when it was all still vinyl. Even in a club with huge speakers, I've never seen the needle jump due to the bass (although some places used to tape a penny to the top of the headshelf). The weighting on the tone arms can be adjusted so if you've got a needle dancing around it's due to your set up, not the bass, or Jungle music wouldn't have lasted too long.
- kstrauser 4y agoSee my other comment here about the 1812 Overture.
- iamacyborg 4y agoSame deal with dubstep records.
- crtasm 4y agoThey're not referring to amplified sound. If you press a record with too much bass on it the 'wobble' of the groove itself can end up so extreme it'll make the needle jump out - no speakers required.
- brigandish 4y agoThere's an awful lot of bass on drum and bass records and yet I've never seen a needle jumping because of it.