17 ms·
What is the cost of a cashless society?
- AinderS 4y agoAccording to the article, the main problem of a financial police state where you cannot so much as buy a loaf of bread without permission and surveillance from the payment system, is that not everyone is included.
- seibelj 4y agoShoplift? No big deal. Have the theoretical potential to avoid even 1 penny in taxes? The only option is a financial panopticon that tracks the flow of all money!
- mistrial9 4y agodefend and expand the taxation, fines and supervision -- bingo
- Nursie 4y agoIt does seem to be a more clear and present danger to health and wellbeing for a chunk of society than the usual HN paranoia about loss of some imagined supreme personal autonomy and the government stopping you from buying what you want.
- kevincox 4y agoIf you give me the choice between being able to buy a loaf of bread and having my payments private I'm feeding myself ten times out of ten. I'm not saying that privacy isn't important but I don't think it is the main problem compared to people being unable to use currency.
- StanislavPetrov 4y agoIf you give me the choice between a government that tries to force me to cede my autonomy and my privacy in order to buy a loaf of bread or go hungry, I'm sharpening my pitchfork and lighting my torch ten times out of ten.
- JetAlone 4y agoGovernments don't even have to get involved, we are heading in the direction fo functional cashlessness by the influence of corporations and the market alone. Hope you like incinerating fat cats to doom music, my friend.
- mistrial9 4y agobut you missed a crucial part -- the post says "pitchforks" but is made by a ninety-nine percent civilized person with manners and education, who is unlikely to actually do the physical act mentioned -- but in the modern day, will Very Likely remember this topic at voting time. Take-no-prisoners politics means that the losing candidate, really actually loses and is therefore out of a job right now. So these are high stakes for political types and they do know it. Sadly most American politicians on both sides of the aisle would probably vote for cashless right now, but, not all of them... and things do change.
- JetAlone 4y agoOut of autonomy, out of food. Out of a job, out of blood. Rising flood raises all ships. The stakes will get higher for all of us. Edit: Besides, the GP's got a slav sounding username. One would be wise not to assume civilization rates in excess of 75%. Strong slavs make bad times. Bad times make strong slavs.
- time0ut 4y agoMaybe more Russian sounding https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Petrov https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stanislav_Petrov
- JetAlone 4y agoRussians are a slavic people. There are ethnic subgroups of other backgrounds that live largely within the borders of Russian and have Russian nationality like the Tatars, the Chechens, the Kalmyks etc.
- tboyd47 4y agoI'd feed myself nine times and eat leftovers on the tenth. Privacy isn't the most important thing in the world but it's shortsighted to just throw it out the window. You don't need it 'til you need it. It's okay to be friends with people who can't keep a secret but you need to have at least one friend who can.
- thisgoesnowhere 4y agoThis comment is identical to the one you responded to.
- tboyd47 4y ago10/10 != 9/10
- happyopossum 4y agoWhen giving up privacy, once is roughly equivalent to ‘every time’.
- bryanrasmussen 4y agogiven the technical capabilities to make it so, which we have.
- tboyd47 4y agoIf what you said was true, then no one would have any privacy at all. But yet certain people have seemingly perfect privacy, like Satoshi Nakamoto and Jeffrey Epstein's employers. How? I now realize a lot of people on HN are hard liners when it comes to privacy and think there's only absolute privacy and no privacy. I think you all forget that not all information is the same. You can keep private channels open "just in case" while using public ones. You can also enhance your privacy to a degree better than most people with simple, easy-to-do steps. Anyway, the "all or nothing" mindset is detrimental to your cause and makes the average person feel like it's not worth it.
- 4y ago
- leereeves 4y agoThat's not a real choice because governments will abuse it. If you don't have private, permissionless payments, you face the risk that the government will stop you from buying bread. Don't believe it? Here are some other programs governments have abused: The US put people on the no fly list for refusing to become FBI informants [1]. Canada froze bank accounts of protestors. China abused their COVID tracking app to stop protests. [2] It's important to remember past government abuses so we don't give them more tools for future abuses. 1: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/24/us/supreme-court-case-no-fly-list.html https://www.nytimes.com/2020/02/24/us/supreme-court-case-no-... 2: https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/16/business/china-code-protesters.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/06/16/business/china-code-prote...
- thisgoesnowhere 4y agoThis is such a childish nonsense response to a nuanced well articulated argument.
- happyopossum 4y agoIt’s insane to make it a choice though. Allow/require cash as an option, and all of these problems go away.
- AinderS 4y agoThat is precisely my point. The ability to prevent you from buying a loaf of bread will be used for control.
- imtringued 4y agoYou must be really naive if you think that isn't the case already. Imagine a bitcoin standard where the rich own all the Bitcoin and governments force you to use Bitcoin. The rich have no reason to lend you Bitcoin for free, you don't need the Bitcoin, you need the loaf of bread and you are willing to trade your time for that loaf of bread but since the middleman Bitcoin was inserted, you are forced to borrow in the hope that you can pay the money back. Nobody lends out money for free, you are going to have to pay interest. The best part is that you are going to default as the interest payments end up in the wallet of the rich guy you just borrowed money from, due to the magic of compound interest he is going to lend his money out again. This means your debt is unpayable because interest payments must recirculate in the economy and somehow end up with you again but in this case they are just being lent out again. The only thing you can do is outcompete some other guy and take the money he borrowed into the economy to pay your own debt. Since someone is going to lose this competition there are going to be destitute and poor people in your society. The only known way out of this mess that is commonly practiced is to force the economy to grow faster which degrades the environment and results in ever inequality. The obvious solution and actually working solution is to make liquidity have a cost so that withholding money from the economy is impossible over the long term. Money is power and control for those who have it and their power extends beyond what they can buy with it, it also extends to those who don't have it.
- notpushkin 4y agoThis is exactly why we shouldn't let governments force us to use any currency. We don't have a currency problem, we have a government problem.
- mcv 4y agoBut that's the point: people will not be able to buy a loaf of bread if they don't meet with the system's approval. Look, I switched to completely contactless payment through my phone since Covid, and it's so convenient I'm not going back. And it's hard for me to imagine people who don't have access to a bank account or smartphone, but those people do exist, and they may eventually become unable to buy a loaf of bread, and that's a problem.
- cmroanirgo 4y agoDue to government tactics, a lot of australians are now deliberately using cash a) for the privacy b) as a statement against orwellian mechanisms. I find it really sad when people are blaise about something that once gone, can't be put back. A social credit system, & everyone talking about it as an inevitable thing, have already bought into the propaganda. I find it inevitable that with sentiments like that, that i'll be forced to live in a car & eventually the gutter & arrested regularly because of my nuisance factor. All because of the convenience.
- imtringued 4y agoThere are anonymous payment services. Just mandate the use of those in the laws.
- perf1 4y agoIs this meant as a joke? Because almost the whole world is working on outlawing or "regulating" these and they aren't even anonymous most of the time. Not being controlled and centralized is threatening enough.
- mdp2021 4y ago> anonymous payment services Could you please expand? In this area, the only ones available I found have a surcharge of ~5..10% (you buy a 100€ card through 105€..110€). Note: I am not certain of the amount, it has been a while since I used one. And in Europe electronic payments cannot by law be anonymous over 150€.
- 4y ago
- john_the_writer 4y agoWhat if you get arrested because you buy a pride flag? Or if you get killed because you use a service? What if you get arrested because you sold a train ticket to someone who doesn't have enough "social credit" to buy said train ticket?
- desas 4y agoThen your society has bigger problems than how purchases are carried out.
- mdp2021 4y ago> your society has bigger problems It does not. A psychically deficient society expresses its "illness"¹ in many different ways, all with the same root. (¹Both "evil", original sense, and "malfunction", translated sense. 'Illness' is a good term for this context.)
- rapnie 4y agoAnd a cashless society helps aggravate these problems.
- ajsnigrutin 4y agoIf you want total financial control over people, you sure want it over the whole population, and not just those who already have too much to lose to actually protest or do something against the government. Since the "two missed meals" that are between today and a revolution are most probable for the poor, skipping them would be bad for the overlords.
- EdwardDiego 4y agoHow is an electronic record of a transaction any worse then being filmed by multiple cameras as you walked in to buy that bread? In my country, a warrant is required to access both sources of data.
- dcposch 4y agoIt's an exceptionally flexible and convenient method of control. Earlier this year, donors to the truck convey protest in Canada had their bank accounts frozen. This wasn't a targeted list of "these 37 people have broken a law"--rather, it was a broad mandate to freeze accounts assocated with the protests, operationalized a bit differently by each bank. In a society where most businesses don't take cash anymore, this turnkey coercive capability becomes more airtight. The frog will boil slowly. A few years ago, all US payment processors blocked donations to Wikileaks, after they reported on war crimes in Iraq. Today, most people still think of digital money in the same way as physical cash; in reality, every transaction is a request for permission, with fraud heuristics and blocklists that might say yes or no. Soon, a guy gets DUI, loses the ability to buy alcohol for six months--who would oppose that? Over time, the scope and frequency of financial deplatforminig will expand. Twitter does one-week suspensions for violating their terms of service. Why not your credit card?
- EdwardDiego 4y agoAnd that is something that I hope Canada has a moral reckoning with, that's absolutely astounding to me. Cash doesn't prevent this entirely though, unless you have all your cash under a mattress.
- mdp2021 4y ago> Cash doesn't prevent this entirely though Yes, but it's "not being able to buy a car" vs "not being able to buy bread".
- woofyman 4y agoThat is a myth. https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-rcmp-banks-and-ottawa-say-convoy-protest-donors-wont-have-accounts/ https://www.theglobeandmail.com/canada/article-rcmp-banks-an...
- imtringued 4y agoThere are anonynous digital payment services. It is very difficult to surveil your loaf of bread transaction history if it isn't recorded and the customer is unknown.
- brippalcharrid 4y agoOne of the key selling-points of Central Bank Digital Currencies for governments is that they will be able to provide extensive insights into citizens' behavior (how demand and consumption patterns change according to various factors) as well as a variety of levers that they will be able to use adjust that behavior in subtle and opaque ways. I'm not sure how much parallel privacy-focused systems will be tolerated under such future regimes.
- JetAlone 4y agoThis morning, I had a very new looking 10,000 yen bill at the conbini auto-register that wouldn't go into the register. Looked at it, didn't seem to be folded or missing a corner, which often causes bill insertion into machines to fail. Tried again, wouldn't go in. Had to use another bill. <Commercial> If only we went cashless and installed the app, I wouldn't have to deal with bill and coin recognition failing anymore! What a wonderful, convenient world! </Commercial> Just kidding. There'd be all the familiar glitches, errors, holdups and overreaches of excessive bureaucracy + automation and the malice and incompetence behind it. Edit: decided to look up "Malice and Incompetence" to see if anyone else has struck on the idea that Hanlon's razor is a heuristic which overfits us towards thinking malice and incompetence are mutually exclusive. Giving credit to this blogger for coining this word "malcompetence: incompetence magnified by malevolent intent." https://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2014/07/malice_incompetence_or_malcompetence.html https://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2014/07/malice_incompet...
- judge2020 4y agoAnecdotally Apple Pay on vending machines in the U.S. is amazing and I've only encountered one within the past few years that was erroring whenever you tried to tap, and any debit/credit transaction on that machine didn't work.
- JetAlone 4y agoReliability good. I think it's useful to have cash as a fallback. I don't know if the conbini has a manual override where the machine opens like a register at the cashier's behest. I hope it does. And I hope it always will.
- thescriptkiddie 4y agoAnother thing to consider in that credit and debit card processing fees, which in the US are substantial, especially for small merchants that can't use large volume to negotiate a discount. This amounts to a ~3% hidden "tax" on all transactions, the bulk of which goes to one of four enormous corporations.
- asciident 4y ago3% is actually not bad for what it gets you: fraud detection, not having to lug cash to the bank every day, reduction of theft and employee mistakes, better recordkeeping for taxes, a way to handle refunds, and cleanliness. Small merchants often use Venmo where I am, and they save 3% in exchange for that awkward dance of sending payments.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoVendors can choose to accept only debit cards and not have to pay 3%. Accepting debit cards is basically free in comparison.
- Teever 4y agoBut why do we need a 3rd party middle man fornwhat used to be a private transaction between two individuals? If the government is going to replace cash with technology, why can't it do it itself and not involve some trabsbational bohemoth like Visa or Mastercard?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoSupposedly, that is in development: https://www.federalreserve.gov/paymentsystems/fednow_about.htm https://www.federalreserve.gov/paymentsystems/fednow_about.h...
- Nursie 4y agoThe US needs to get on top of this. Most other places I know of don't have the cashback cards because they limit the fees that can be charged. The flip side of this, of course, is that in places with limited fees it is now cheaper for the merchant to use a card than to deal in cash, as cash has to be counted, reconciled and banked, has security requirements for transport etc. In places like the UK and Australia, lots of small merchants now operate in a cashless way because it costs less.
- teddyh 4y agoEverybody who talks about how they never use cash and love the convenience of never having to use cash, they all sound just like all the people who loved Google just before their account was terminated for undisclosed reasons.
- halfmatthalfcat 4y agoBanks can freeze your account for undisclosed reasons too so I'm not sure I see the point.
- workshirt 4y agoThat is their point
- toomuchtodo 4y agoCash is the illusion of autonomy and control of one’s financial destiny to those who don’t believe in regulation as a recourse mechanism for financial inclusion. The solution is not cash, it is regulators who will kick the door in when you’ve suffered injury in the course of using financial infrastructure or services.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoI would like both, can we please have that?
- BurningFrog 4y agoThe solution of "let's just have smart and benevolent rulers" to the old "Who will guard the guards?" question doesn't have the greatest track record.
- toomuchtodo 4y agoDoes the need for constant vigilance suck? Yes. Is it necessary because humans will be humans? Also yes. If change is inevitable, as is turnover in governance and those who participate in it, than naturally systems and underlying mechanisms must be maintained to ensure stability. People problems demand people solutions. I know, it’s a bummer. No tech saved Kansas abortion rights earlier this week. Overwhelming constituent turnout to vote did (voter registration is up 1000% in Kansas). (Used only as an example for my thesis)
- Rackedup 4y ago
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoBecause privatization of essential services has gone just so well in other areas of life, why not extend it to 100% of financial transactions.
- bediger4000 4y agoI think this is a good thing. It will prevent Terrorism, and keep us all from buying Porn, so no more onanism or Luciferian child abuse and cannibalism. Also will eliminate drugs.
- turdit 4y agowhat’s terrorism?
- Kamq 4y agoAny sort of violence that the people in power don't like
- imtringued 4y agoYou mean any form of political activity that the people on power don't like. Violence is too high of a bar.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- john_the_writer 4y agoWhere the term "violence" is a sliding scale, without admitting it's a scale at all. Even silence is violence.
- willnonya 4y agoThis is probably the most naive comment in this thread. At that bar is set pretty high. Where there's a will there's a way...
- AnotherGoodName 4y agoAustralia's been cashless for a long time now and has no laws requiring acceptance of cash so a lot of places are cashless only. Even the old lady who has a tea and snack cart at the train station is cashless here. I'll state some benefits: Public transport becomes much better. You tap your card or phone and never bother with the hassle of a ticket ever again. You probably never realized just how much of a barrier the ticketing fuss was to public transport but all of a sudden you start using it a lot more. Small conveniences based on cashless payment start appearing everywhere. I've noticed cashless vending machines for really rare use cases have started to appear where i suspect they'd be too low value/high maintainance if they required cash. I'd put electric scooters/bikes here too. Some things wouldn't work or be as successful without cashless systems. Lot's of these examples but i don't need to list them all out. Taxation. You may argue this is a negative. I think it's a positive that it's harder to cheat the system. I like fairness. You can argue that there should be lower tax but i won't support any argument that it's OK for some to skip tax while others pay. Safety. The tea lady at the station is now 100% cashless so simply can't be robbed (well kids might steal snacks off the cart but that's minor). No more wallets. Australia has phone based drivers licenses and with no cash It's normal to carry a phone and nothing else. One less thing to carry and worry about. I get that a cashless society would be worse under a totalitarian dictatorship than a cash based society under a totalitarian dictatorship. I'd rather work to avoid the totalitarian dictatorship part than the cashless part though.
- dannyw 4y agoAustralia is not cashless, it's just that cash is infrequently used. You can easily get cash out at ATMs, to buy some weed from a dealer or for buying second hand goods from other people on Facebook Marketplace. You can pay your groceries with cash, or any bill at a post office.
- phist_mcgee 4y agoYou'd be surprised at the number of people buying drugs using PayID.
- wslh 4y ago
- imwillofficial 4y agoAbout 3-5%
- DavidKarlas 4y agoWorking with cash is not free either, you need security truck and drivers that come pick up cash at end of day... Afaik in EU debit cards are capped much lower than 3%.
- imwillofficial 4y agoIf they weren’t turning a profit, they wouldn’t be pushing this.
- Denvercoder9 4y agoIt's not mutually exclusive. For example, if the operating costs of a cashless system are 1%, the operators charge 3% and cash costs business 5%, the operators turn a profit while it's advantageous for businesses as well. If businesses lower prices with the 2% they saved, it's advantageous for consumers too.
- imwillofficial 4y agoI disagree with those figures. In my experience handling cash is not nearly as expensive as transaction fees.
- ammo1662 4y agoIn China, even though the gov said that it is illegal to refuse using the cash. Most of the small shops stop receiving that. They do not have enough cash to give change. As for me, the only problem is that when your phone is dead, you can barely purchase anything. So I always carry a credit card. I do have some cash at home for emergencies. But it was already locked there for several years. The only reason when you need cash would be that you want to "hide" the trade. The police has already cought a lot of drug dealers by tracing the payment records of their customers. However, as most of pepole will not use cash. So it will be much more easier for police to trace the serial number of the cash. It is getting more difficult to "hide" payment these days. Not only for drug dealers, also for the husbands who wnat to have some small private money. Especially when you want to buy some games or some new useless gadgets. You will miss the good old days with cash.
- fenesiistvan 4y ago...hard to be a gamer husband in China :)
- Arch485 4y agoI am certainly not pro-cashless, but the points this article makes are lackluster at best. In an entirely cashless society, the problem isn't that "not everyone is included", the problem is surveillance. You can solve inclusion easily enough... Replace cash with prepaid cards (an idea posed in the article), or issue small, purpose-built digital wallets (equivalent to a low-power smartphone, except only for managing your digital bank account), or any number of other solutions. An even better idea is to just legally require businesses to accept cash (although this goes directly against the concept of cashless). Digital (non-"crypto") currencies could do a lot of good when applied properly. I just don't think any government or institution would apply it properly.
- Findecanor 4y agoYou're overlooking a couple of things: person-to-person transactions, and the disabled/impaired. Among those who protest the most against a cashless society are interest groups for the elderly and the handicapped. The blind need their money amounts to be tactile, well ... because they need almost everything they interact with to be. You can't use prepaid cards for person-to-person transactions, but there are various types of smartphone apps. But then you are back to the original problem in the article. And you need to have good eye sight to use those too, so you can't be too old. And a good signal to the nearest tower, which rules out rural areas. .. and no service disruptions.
- lightedman 4y agoMy contactless payment (GPay with my debit card on it) on my phone works without a cellular connection. It literally just physically acts as a card. This phone has had the SIM removed, airplane mode on with wifi shut off, and only the NFC functionality active. It exists solely as my contactless payment method. The only real issue - you have to keep it powered.
- rufus_foreman 4y ago>> Replace cash with prepaid cards Prepaid with what?
- motohagiography 4y agoThis is an issue I have experience and strong opinions about, and please take the following as one sample of the sentiment that is brewing in this country over policies that impact cashlessness, privacy, autonomy, freedom of movement and association, and lately, of speech. I just happen to be close to these issues from a tech and policy perspective, and am an expert at articulating these things, but regretably, this will be a bit political. Framing the issue in terms of the "most vulnerable," ignores the effects of economic centralization on the majority. The current government is tremendously unpopular in a large segment of the population, and just this year it used our partial cashlessness to make the banks freeze the accounts of citizens who donated to an opposition activist cause that had constitutionally legitimate concerns. So much so that the government only avoided collapse from a loss of confidence by withdrawing its emergency powers legislation before it was about to be put down by our senate. It's polarized and getting bad fast. Policies like cashlessness just consolidate economic division and the inevitable effect is a permanent underclass that starts in the grey markets using alternative means of exchange, and spreads to creating poverty traps and a parallel and inescapable underground economy that is more violent and exploitative as a result of its official isolation than anything we have today. Just look at any country with official exchange rates for their debased or controlled currencies, and consider what their economic upsides are. Cashlessness is a policy of economic polarization, not inclusion. It has become hard to believe that creating an underclass isn't the explicit agenda of the policy influencers behind it, because the middle class prosperity that characterizes Canadian society means that the status conferred on technocrats is too little to mollify their status anxiety. I know these people. I have worked with them in government, media, and tech for decades. I grew up with them and know their alumni. I have sat at their brunch tables. The thing they seethe most over is independent business owners whose way of life comes from providing value and the actual approval of the people who buy their products, and patronize their businesses. It is the inconsolable envy toward those whose contributions are actually desired by the people they live with - and not imposed in some social engineering scheme for fabricated constituencies of "the most vulnerable" that always seem to put the same people at the centre managing them. What this class hates is the basic natural dignity of people that comes from humble, competent achievement, and not the affectations of prestige. As though their impostor syndrome were our fault, because nobody recognizes them as elite outside their own circles. We owe them no deference, and this is unforgivable. I would say what has changed in Canada over the last decade is that I see that people really openly hate each other, but that's not the whole picture. It's that the people actuated by their own hatred have graduated into our institutions and do not see themselves as accountable to the values of the society they grew up identifying as a victim of. We didn't care about what the Laurentian Consensus and the media class thought because we believed with distance, diversity, and different communities, we could co-exist peacefully. What is clear now is that this was naive. The argument about locking activists bank accounts was, "but they were extremists," but when you compare them to the actual arsonists, looters, rioters, shooters, and knife criminals motivated by more fashionably acceptable causes like creating religious and racial conflict, it's like our government and chattering classes just humiliate themselves by parroting absurdities and lies, and then take out their shame on Canadians with even more self righteousness. It's a cycle of abuse that is winding up with ever more momentum. When you see the government ministers speaking television, it's something darker than smug. There's a relish for the impunity these actors have that people recognize as fundamentally anti-Canadian. Advocates of cashlessness problematize the freedom of others instead of producing things anyone wants, because it's just easier. My prediction is we have less than 5 years before this country descends into a constitutional crisis more serious than the referendum on Quebec's separation in the early 90s. This isn't about the tech. I feel like we have a narrowing opportunity to stop antagonizing citizens with policies and utterly disconnected articles like these.
- EdwardDiego 4y agoNew Zealand has gone largely cashless (and entirely chequeless). Everyone is paid by direct credit to their account. You pay your bills via direct credit / debit. I don't think any bank is charging fees (for customers) for electronic transactions via card, or direct credits/debits. They don't even charge a fee for using another bank's ATM anymore. I am always amazed at how often people in the US mention cheques. NZ retailers moved away from cheques in the 90s due to their massive fraudulent use case (back when cheques were common, so was chequebook theft). The last banks that would accept cheques stopped doing so in 2020, IIRC. You can use cash, but few people do. Parking machines have tap n pay. I really only need cash when the kids are having a bake sale or disco at school. But as part of that shift, the Government owned bank ensures that anyone can have a bank account with no fees, no matter how spotty your previous track record. Works for us. But I don't think we'll ever go cashless, there's no real desire to do so from anyone other than the people who have to pay to make the cash.
- alx__ 4y ago> anyone can have a bank account with no fees, no matter how spotty your previous track record. We're still working on that idea :(
- EdwardDiego 4y agoYeah, it was realised that a bank of last resort was needed.
- 16amxn16 4y ago
- rjbwork 4y agoNot an appropriate comment for HN. You should read the guidelines. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- 4y ago
- jillesvangurp 4y agoI think this article just really highlights how badly the Canadian banking system needs to be modernized. Is it really that bad? I think I saw my parents use cheques a few times. That was in the nineteen eighties. Banks stopped accepting them in much of Europe decades ago. The cost of processing those became just prohibitively expensive and they offered no benefit whatsoever. There's no logical reason to be doing anything with cheques in 2022. That's just bureaucratic inertia and stupidity. You could turn this question around as well. What's the cost of cash? It's not zero. Cash logistics are expensive. Companies that hold cash need security, the cash needs transport, it needs to be printed and distributed, insured, etc. And there's the black economy which means losses in tax revenue. A lot of shops in e.g. the Netherlands went cashless so they make less of a target for armed robberies. Bank accounts are really cheap these days. Some banks charge for them but that's just greed. The nominal cost of tracking a few million integers in a computer is pretty low. That's why there are so many online banks these days. Creating a few billion bank accounts is not a technical problem. Same with transaction cost. There's no logical reason to charge multiple percents on every transaction. That kind of scam only works if banks have a monopoly on their markets, which of course in some markets is very much a thing. In market with competition, that cost goes away pretty quickly.
- nlitened 4y agoA bit of a rant. By January 2022 I hadn't used anything but Apple Pay for three years. But then my home country starts a war (which is terrible), and since the war was not approved by countries controlling the cashless technologies, immediately all my cards stop working, I am not allowed to get a new one anywhere in the world, my foreign currency bank accounts and retirement savings on brokerage accounts get frozen indefinitely. Make sure you keep enough cash and cryptos for a rainy day.
- jeroenhd 4y agoThis is the problem I have with Apple Pay, Google Pay, and any other international service taking over transaction responsibilities. Especially if they're based on puritan countries like the United States where opinions on products like adult entertainment and certain medical procedures can influence a company's ability to receive payment. Almost any modern smartphone has an NFC chip to do contactless payments. Banks should have the capability of leveraging that through their own services instead of depending on Apple's/Google's pinky promise to always make payment available. Banks can do contactless payments quite easily on Android so in my opinion they should have their own apps. I'm fine with them also offering GPay for customer convenience, but there should be a national fallback. If you buy Apple, you're locking yourself in. My opinion is that this is a fault with Apple's ecosystem, though an argument can be made that this is what Apple users chose when they bought their iPhone. Regardless, the end result is the same and your capacity to send or receive payment can now go down the moment your government gets sanctioned. Sure, the invasion of Ukraine is reason enough for sanctions in my book, but the American government has a reputation of manipulating the world to suit them best. No other country should rely on American companies to do basic things like payment, just like the USA shouldn't rely on foreign services to accomplish the same.
- lrvick 4y agoI use only cash IRL so my purchasing history and locations I frequent are not logged and sold. I detest that industry. A secondary reason is because some of those of us that do not -have- to use cash must do it anyway to justify stores continuing to accept it. You get used to it. People actually give me discounts for cash frequently, particularly small businesses or individuals. Saves them up to 5% fees on stripe/square. It has major benefits when dealing with service workers. You tip well in cash on the first drink and they prioritize your table all night even when places are slammed because you are not a tip gamble like everyone else, and they likely get away with not reporting most of it to management. I do carry visa gift cards purchased with cash for the rare vendors that refuse cash directly in captive venues where no other choice exists like concerts.
- PhantomBKB 4y agoUPI (Unified Payments Interface) transactions using VPA (Virtual Payment Address) are free for now. Around 6 billion transactions are processed every month. But apparently the Indian govt is planning on adding a 50 paise (₹0.5; $1 ≈ ₹80) transaction fee in the future.
- jeroenhd 4y agoI think a cashless society can work perfectly well. There's a single place that I still use cash with because they don't take card (probably avoiding tax) so every time I go there, I come back with change to tip to delivery people when I order food. Everything from my rent to my grocery shopping is done digitally and I honestly think it's great. However, that's probably because I live in a debit-based country. Debit cards without overdraft capabilities should be readily available even to people with no financial skills because you can't use them to spend more than you earn, making the risk to the banks themselves minimal. The small fee paid for banking services is the only thing at risk and even that won't have much of an impact on the bank in general. Some countries, most importantly probably the USA, almost exclusively operate on credit cards for digital money, which are practically quick instant loans that you don't want to think about. There's very little in there to limit your credit card spending to your actual income and some people are foolish or desperate enough to borrow money to pay off loans, with credit cards being one of the easiest options. People with poor or no financial skills will run up a debt and quickly stop qualifying for credit, and the end result is that they're dependent on cash or even something as archaic as cheques to transfer money in stores. The extreme impact credit scores can have in the States is mind boggling but it almost looks like people accept some shady third party evaluating their entire life for fraud risk as a normal thing. If your standard modus operandi is spending money that you'll have to pay back later, I don't think your society can be cashless. Normalise debit cards as standard payment systems and almost everyone can qualify. Frauds will find themselves struggling to get an affordable bank account, but in a modern banking system there are plenty of alternatives available. Based on this article, Canada clearly needs a banking overhaul for any cashless ambitions to stick without dire consequences.
- perf1 4y agoIt's a receipt for disaster. Especially if they centralize it even more by replacing banks with a Central Bank that fully controls the Digital Currency. Which they are already planning and testing. This will be misused. And people can be controlled with this in a really bad way. If your Social Credit Score is low you could be taxed higher or even forbidden to drive your car or travel, for example. Your food choices could be restricted at any moment too if you don't behave.
- LatteLazy 4y agoIf you actually want to only do business in cash, you're already going to have a very bad time. 95% of jobs (99.9% of decent paying or professional or large company jobs) won't pay you in cash. The same for any sort of loan or finance (who can you borrow money from without leaving an electronic trail?). What sort of landlord or mortgage company will accept actual cash? Can you pay the tax man with it (probably but good luck). The truth is, you're already in a cashless society for the vast majority of your income and expenses.
- TheFattestNinja 4y agoThis twitter thread might be a bit extreme, but it raises interesting points ( https://twitter.com/punk6529/status/1494444624630403083?lang=en https://twitter.com/punk6529/status/1494444624630403083?lang... ). Basically, if you are not allowed to spend money (transact) then you are really not able to exercise your other rights. And if everything was cashless there is an actual risk of Gov or BigBank having the power to stop you transacting completely. It has happened in 1st world countries like Canada already, and without a trial or anything as per thread. Granted, it was kind of an emergency situation, but while I'd love to go cashless (I really really want to), this kind of thing makes me steer back into supporting the opposite side of the argument.
- anovikov 4y agoI'd raise the opposite point: for every reaction there is counterreaction. Going cashless will inevitably become a major boost for crypto and will greatly help detach crypto from fiat, becoming a major facilitator of illicit transactions of all kinds, to the point that people will stop seeing breaking the law as anything objectionable, destroying the very notion of law and order. People should be permitted to do lesser evil (go to the corner and buy a joint for cash) lest they will build a workaround so good there will be no reason to stop in expanding it's use until it consumes the very fabric of society.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> Going cashless will inevitably become a major boost for crypto These are unlinked. Demographics using crypto loosely correlate with those going cashless. Cashless countries even more loosely correlate with crypto adoption. > people will stop seeing breaking the law as anything objectionable We have a long tradition of this with our 21-year drinking age. People can differentiate between the laws they can break and the ones they shouldn’t. In any case, arguing crypto will undermine state power ignores the millennia of commodity money.
- noasaservice 4y ago> We have a long tradition of this with our 21-year drinking age. People can differentiate between the laws they can break and the ones they shouldn’t. Well, not really. It was originally 18 to drink. Thanks to the federal government linking interstate funds to a requirement states support 21 drinking age is how they did that. In some states, even 16 could drink beer prior to the feds fucking things up.
- hypertele-Xii 4y agoMy biggest fear is not cashless society, it's humanless payment processing. If you think losing access to your Google account for unspecified terms violations is bad, what about a payment processing computer malfunctioning? A few years ago my debit card refused checkout at a supermarket. After the cashier rebooted the card reader machine, it ate a hundred bucks from my account without confirming the purchase. When I called my bank they said it's all automated, couldn't do anything about it, and would fix itself in two weeks. If that hundred bucks would've been my last food money, I'd gone hungry for half a month while the entirely humanless, supportless, automated, blackbox financial system "sorts itself out". Cashless over my dead body.
- perryfsg 4y agoThis is the real reason of crypto currencies. When cash is eventually being removed we lose all our rights, and the process has already started now with the introduction of the green pass. It just takes a while before the masses realize what's actually happening. With a crypto currency I can transfer value straight into your wallet without anyone in between, instantly, from anywhere in the world. Don't be blinded by the crypto scams and so, scams are everywhere around us, it's not bound to crypto. Do you realize how many scams there are with banking and cash?
- Xylakant 4y agoA while ago, a larger German bank double processed all withdrawals occurring around the end of the month - rent and associated costs for many people. I know a few folks that ended up stranded with no access to funds due to that.
- LeeroyWasHere 4y agoLiving in Asia I've seen: - People's account getting skimmed without much recourse - Bank/Wallet service being unavailable/down for hours - Money being debited into a black whole when transferring or paying, taking days or weeks to be refunded. Resulted in people being stranded, not being able to go home, not able to go to work, not being able to afford groceries, meal, medecine, rent... Absolute nightmare, removing cash will impact the poorest the most, it already does.
- cribugv 4y ago[dead]
- arcade79 4y agoNorway has been mostly cashless for the better part of 2 decades. I've noticed one particular thing that gets much more difficult. I have trouble teaching my kid about money, and quick addition/substraction. When money is much more abstract, it's difficult to explain how bank accounts aren't limitless, that it's not enough to put a piece of plastic close to a card reader. The other part is that I get shocked at how slow kids seem to be at knowing how to do various "money changing calculations".
- Kiro 4y agoWhy is this framed like a hypothetical scenario when there's an abundance of countries that are already cashless and have been so for a long time? I haven't even seen a physical bill in many years. No idea how the coins look nowadays.
- ciconia 4y ago> There’s no question printed or minted currency is grubby and kind of gross (paper banknotes, studies demonstrate, can be covered in everything from E. coli to fecal matter). What's with this compulsive obsession with hygiene? Our own bodies contain about 3 times more microbes than human cells [1]. The air we breath is full of microbes, pollen and spores (not to mention the chemical pollutants nobody seems to care about). Any surface we touch - door handles, pieces of paper, keyboard keys, sofas, etc. - is full of microbes. Just saying... [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_microbiome https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Human_microbiome
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoThe article is very superficial about cost. It's not just about money, it's about freedom and democracy. A cashless society, like everything with computer, information control or centralize power, is fine when you are riding the happy path. As soon as you are not inline with society, or that slthe system itself become no more adapted to it's context, it's a nightmare.
- paskozdilar 4y agoThis rigidity of computers is exactly why we must not let them control society. Society is responsible for each and every member of it. Having 0.001% of population's lives ruined because of an error is not acceptable. Humans may be slower and less efficient than machines (and require living wages), but humans are flexible and understand context. Replacing them with machines will only remove the useful human capabilities that we need so much in this society where most of the rules are still ad-hoc and implicit. Imagine being assaulted by a robot policeman whose crime detection facility has malfunctioned, while you can't even complain to his robot colleague because it hasn't been programmed for malfunction of other robot policemen.
- SturgeonsLaw 4y ago> Imagine being assaulted by a robot policeman whose crime detection facility has malfunctioned, while you can't even complain to his robot colleague because it hasn't been programmed for malfunction of other robot policemen. To be fair, that's pretty much how it works with human cops
- BiteCode_dev 4y agoYou can experience that every time you fill a form online. If it works, it's a joy. Saved time and energy. So much more efficient. If something goes wrong however, there is no flexible human to fix it, give you an alternative solution, or perform a workaround. You are now in for a long and painful trip.
- starkd 4y agoIndeed. This is why a digital currency is only viable if you have the ability to make anonymous third party transactions. Until then, I remain a hard no. But even bitcoin doesn't truly offer that.
- SapporoChris 4y agoWhen there are major power outages that take down networks how will cashless payments be made? I've seen stores stay open in a power outage with clever uses of extension cords running out to vehicles, enough to power the cash register and a few led lights. These stores were able to easily sell groceries (before they perished) and non-perishable items via cash.
- 1ark 4y agoStores will be closed. It's not far to imagine a Kaseya-like incident, or just a power outage like you mention. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaseya_VSA_ransomware_attack https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaseya_VSA_ransomware_attack
- preisschild 4y agoCash is going away someday, thats for sure. Digital payments are just more comfortable to use and it allows to send money over vast distances in a few seconds, which is useful for buying stuff on the internet. I'd just wish open source, decentralized, not-crypto-bro currencies like Monero (https://www.getmonero.org/ https://www.getmonero.org/), that are unlike Bitcoin actually anonymous, would be more commonly accepted outside of darknet markets.
- 1ark 4y agoIn a way Monero has been good money last couple of years. Not fluctuating too much up or down compared to others. So using it as fungible money could be ok. Monero has trade-offs though, how many are mined and have there been exploits/bugs in the supply?
- jeroenhd 4y agoIt's good for a cryptocurrency, but looking at the exchange rates, that's still fluctuating way too much to make me feel comfortable in using it as a real currency. I love the concept of the blockchain, but the cryptobros turned any kind of decentralized money into a gambling game, even the ones designed to be reasonably stable. This type of greed is why we can't have nice things.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoCash works during a power outage, or as was recently experienced in Canada because Rogers f'ed up their network, service disruptions.
- 1ark 4y agoTo continue on Canada. Or if you have you credit card/bank account frozen from being targeted by the government for protesting.
- Kye 4y agoThere's no guarantee a cashier can actually handle processing sales without the computer to add things up. I can't remember the last time I saw a calculator or battery-backed adding machine for backup at a checkout. Assuming prices are even printed/stickered on the products.
- Eddy_Viscosity2 4y agoCalculators on phones would still work.
- Inhibit 4y agoThe article's first paragraph proposes that "we" didn't understand that respiratory illness spreads through water droplets in the air. I honestly doubt that was ever the case; it certainly makes everything else posited seem a bit orwellian.
- LinkLink 4y agoThe cost is that you cannot easily break the law. Despite the current state of the world and the continued apathy of lawmakers to anything but corporate pockets, people insist on furthering policy which only gives more trust and control to the government. America came to be out of a bloody rebellion against tyranny, and 200 years later people seem determined to recreate the British authoritatian system that our founders once destroyed.
- rdtwo 4y ago3% per transaction
- togs 4y agoIt doesn't matter what the cost is. Cashless is more efficient, so it's going to happen. Nobody has a say.