10 ms·
Japan, U.S. to launch R&D for 2-nm chip mass production
- karmicthreat 4y agoI’m guessing this will build off the existing EUV light sources and just scale up multi-patterning?
- mrtweetyhack 4y ago
- NonNefarious 4y agoCan't wait for the launch of 0-nm production.
- running101 4y agoFinally, I hope this the start of things to come.
- Jabbles 4y agoStandard reminder: The term "2 nanometer" or alternatively "20 angstrom" (a term used by Intel) has no relation to any actual physical feature (such as gate length, metal pitch or gate pitch) of the transistors. It is a commercial or marketing term used by the semiconductor chip fabrication industry to refer to a new, improved generation of silicon semiconductor chips in terms of increased transistor density (i.e. a higher degree of miniaturization), increased speed and reduced power consumption. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2_nm_process https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2_nm_process
- joemi 4y agoIs there a meaningful metric that changes between generations, that could alternatively be used, perhaps by consumers in spite of marketing's desires?
- nabla9 4y agoYes. The correct figure of merit is transistor density MTr/mm² (millions of transistors per squared millimeter). In reality transistor count is not actually transistor count. Transistor count/area = 0.6 × NAND2/area + 0.4×[Scan Flip Flops]/area
- bpodgursky 4y agoThat's disappointing I always liked to believe that when two fourth-generation fighters fell in love, they produced an F-35.
- umvi 4y agoI hate that that's legal. Imagine if the food industry could get away with this in their marketing: "10g Fiber Bars" (fiber bars actually contain only 1g of fiber, "10g fiber" just refers to the fact that it's the 10th generation of fiber bar they've created)
- jjoonathan 4y agoOh yeah? But my fiber bars are Asbestos Free! (thanks XKCD, I hate whoever figured this out too)
- mortenjorck 4y agoLike household products marketed as "not tested on animals" when all the compounds in the product were already tested on animals a century ago and the overhead for using any novel compounds would mean a vastly higher price (and probably animal testing).
- wahern 4y ago
- deelowe 4y agoIs the talent here/there?
- ParksNet 4y agoWhy not just import 10 million Taiwanese into America?
- bigcat12345678 4y agoThat would be great, suddenly everyone is happy: China got the island because no one lives there US got talents Taiwan can have freedom
- trasz 4y agoUS would lose a strategic bridgehead, so it’s not going to ever happen.
- bigcat12345678 4y agoHah? Bridge head to what? Contain China?
- trasz 4y agoAny kind of military action. To US, Taiwan is a “stone aircraft carrier group”.
- pvarangot 4y agoWhere would they live? isn't any place with remotely similar climate and geography to what you see in Taiwan is already overpopulated in the US?
- inciampati 4y agoWhere in the US, outside of less than a handful of large urban centers, is overpopulated? It's not a very densely populated country, with density of 33.6/km². Compare that to Taiwan at 650/km². New York City is 778.2/km².
- nwiswell 4y agoJust so everyone is aware, terms like "2 nm" are industry jargon used primarily for marketing and roadmap comparisons of process nodes. It doesn't really have any physical bearing on the sizes of the devices involved anymore.
- truncate 4y agoI think its quite known now that its industry jargon, but when did they start doing that as I presume it wasn't always the case.
- km3r 4y agoI don't think it was any one time, just a slow drift away from Moore's law physically while the marketing department followed it strictly (as well as defined the nodes before the processes were actually developed, so they were going off best guess).
- nsxwolf 4y agoI still read about claims that Moore's law is ending due to quantum tunneling because the transistors are getting too tiny.
- jrockway 4y agoWhat is Moore's law up to these days? I feel like that, as a user, nothing got faster for about a decade between 2010 and 2020 (not quite right, more like 2012-2018). Instead everyone was like "oh it requires less air conditioners in a data center!" or "uh we're out of ideas, have 32 cores". OK, but I need more FPS from my game. I have a great air conditioner. That seems to have changed in the last couple years, though. AMD and Apple seem to have gotten serious. (I know, Moore's law is about transistor count, and I guess adding more cores technically increases the transistor count. But as a software engineer, I need my chips to get 2x faster every 18 months, or I'll have to start using a profiler or something!)
- Symmetry 4y ago
- guardiangod 4y agoFrom my experience, no offense, when you pool together a bunch of also-ran teams together to catch up to the industry leader, you'd just get a larger also-ran team. I also have reservations on whether the academia can surpass the speed of commercial R&D teams on semiconductor tech. I will believe it when I see it.
- DubiousPusher 4y agoAlso rans? Are you implying that thr U.S. and Japan are "behind" Taiwan? If so, I don't think that is very accurate. The machines that allow Taiwanese companies to create computer circuits come from a Dutch company ASML (with the second most advanced machines coming from Nikon Japan). ASML's machines have over 4,000 parts in their own supply chains. Many of these are high technology which even ASML does not know how to produce. Many of them come from the U.S. and Europe. The EUV process ASML uses in its most advanced machines was only possible due to investments made by the U.S. government and U.S. companies. What is happening here is not an attempt by the U.S. and Japanese governments to compete with Taiwan. It's an investment to ensure the next generation of lithographic technology plays out much like the current generation. Meaning the U.S. it's allied governments and many of their respective companies invest enough to acquire leverage over the technology and thus are able to locked China and other countries out of it. Fabrication is far easier to catch up than bootstrapping. If a country started today, they could subsidize fabrication and within eighteen months they could be making strides to deliver more chips from within. It might literally take a decade or two for a new company to build ASMLs supply chains and replicate one of their machines and that would be 10-20 with no production growth, they would just at that point be getting started.
- terrorOf 4y ago
- freemint 4y agoWhile ASMLs machines are a critical element in the production chain of sub 7nm chips at scale however it is far from the only critical component. Reducing all of Taiwan's leadership to be about access to these machines is beyond ignorant. It is TSMC who integrates the ASML machine into a node. A node being made of dozens of machines performing hundreds of discrete steps with right parameters in the right order. It is TSMC who build fabs with enormously short lead times.
- artemonster 4y agoI hate everything about this. The automotive morons forced semi's to shit their pants during pandemic, we have lots of supply chain issues for the whole production chain (packaging, testing, not only wafer manufacturing!) and here we push for marketing "2nm", where pushing the envelope doesnt make any sense in reality. Scale older processes, make them cheaper, goddamnit! Analog power transistors give zero shits about your nanometers, we need more 90nm and 160nm capacity.
- throw8383833jj 4y agoyeah. Personally, I don't want more microchips in everything. I just want a cheap fridge, a cheap washing machine, or cheap whatever, F** the chips. Even in a car, I want the aboslute minimum amount of chips and other nonsense.
- phpisthebest 4y agoYes but car companies see Google Revenue and say "Look how much money there is on Spying on people" and......
- artemonster 4y agono, here you are wrong, mate. Having mechanical (or any other) control for your dishwasher or washing machine is a VERY bad idea. also for your engine timing and sensor evaluation in your car, also planes, also, basically, everything. I understand the notion where you wonder "WTF there is a WiFi in my freackn OVEN?!" and "WHY THE HELL WE HAVE LCD SCREENS HERE?!", but in general microcontroller is a FAR superior and __safer__ controlling contraption than everything else humanity have ever devised.
- throw8383833jj 4y agoWe went to buy a new washing machine (even though the old wasn't even broken yet). Even the salesman had to admit that they don't make washing machines like they used to and told us that it would last an average of 8 years, as opposed to much longer from the older ones.
- hrgiger 4y agoThis is fascinating considering dna is 2.5 atom between 1-0.5 nanometer
- ricardobeat 4y agoNot quite. A strand of DNA is roughly 2.5nm wide, and it would take ~47 hydrogen atoms to span that distance. Still fascinating!
- 2bitencryption 4y agoplanning/development for progressively lower N-nm chips seems to happen extremely far in advance - here we are talking about 2-nm when 3-nm is still around the corner. My question is, does the development of 2-nm happen totally independently of 3-nm? Are they happening concurrently, and 3-nm just got a head start? Do the advances made during development of 3-nm factor in to the design of 2-nm? Or is each "N-nm" a somewhat clean slate that brings an entirely new process? Does each fab invent its own process for N-nm? Or does the "N-nm process" for TSMC look the same as another fabs? (replies need not say "ackshually, 2-nm is not really 2-nm". we all know this. 90% of the comments so far are about this haha)
- jbverschoor 4y agoThe whole world is running on ASMI/ASML machines and tech.. Not TSMC's
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nwiswell 4y agoThis is a gross misrepresentation analogous to saying the whole world runs on Rolls-Royce's tech, not Boeing's.
- jbverschoor 4y agoMore like all the airlines fly Boeing.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- terrorOf 4y ago
- nwiswell 4y ago
- 11thEarlOfMar 4y agoIn order for this to work, we need to understand why the US and Japan are behind Taiwan in this technology in the first place. For TSMC, as a foundry, their value is maximized by their ability to fabricate devices that semiconductor design companies cannot fabricate themselves. Intel and Toshiba apparently don't see cutting edge device scale as a differentiator and so far haven't invested (enough) in matching TSMC in that arena. There is very little chance, IMHO, that establishing and funding an independent organization to pursue 2nm will yield the desired results. Providing funding tranched on a results basis to existing firms stands a much better chance, provided that they are permitted to pursue 2 nm fabrication without sharing what they've learned, so they gain the benefit of the effort. If that were the approach, I don't see why the US and Japan need to collaborate at all. Seems more like narrative-supporting publicity than anything else. Ugh.
- R0b0t1 4y agoThose companies sold American manufacturing overseas and are now demanding money to bring it back. I like the idea of an independent organization, though I'm not sure it will succeed.
- mytailorisrich 4y agoTSMC is strategic for Taiwan. This is a big part of what makes them 'useful' and worth protecting. On the other hand the US (and Japan, and others) seem to have decided that it is time to hedge their bets. A lot of the action in semiconductors right now is geostrategic.
- ideamotor 4y agoHow much their being worth protecting is causally protecting them? I suspect we have the same concern - that Taiwan is more likely to be subsumed if their products can be sourced elsewhere - but I don’t know if this is valid.
- crumpled 4y agoI think "One China" is about a lot of things beyond commerce. States do have an interest in protecting their trading partners, insofar as it's still a good deal. And the poorer the country, the lower the fruit for a hungry invader.
- wdb 4y agoWould ASML be involved in this?
- ChrisRR 4y agoPhysicists: We're pushing the limits of physics in order to produce ever faster computers Devs: I'm going to write this in javascript
- aitchnyu 4y agoDennis Ritchie anecdote. He promoted writing functions instead of inlining the contents each time. His employees were hooked, and kept going even when the profiler reported the computer was spending most of its time processing CALLs.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoMay still have been worth it if it increased reliability and maintenance.
- AnonMO 4y agoHonestly to me all these comments are wrong and focusing too much on the 2nm aspect and not the possible r&d outcomes. EUV come to fruition because of r&d research between the US and other countries/companies. TSMC might be the largest foundry but a majority if not all of their tooling is from the west and japan; from ASML, AMAT, Lam Research and others. Best believe some acquisitions will happen especially on from the US side and new tech will be coming out probably some sort of EUV replacement.
- raxxorraxor 4y agoPlus people get trained and knowhow gets retained. Discussion is just a step ahead to outsourcing key tech by the previous generation. Not that I want to advertise blind protectionism either.