19 ms·
When cities treated cars as dangerous intruders
- lettergram 4y agoI’m surprised this doesn’t mention that part of the reason cities supported the adoption of cars was the fact city streets were covered in horse poop… you also had to feed, house, and care for the horses. Frankly, this article feels like a puff piece.
- politelemon 4y agoOuch, so US towns and cities didn't always be hostile towards walking. My assumption that it's always been this way, was wrong. But in a way that's worse because it means they used to have this privilege and it has been taken away, and cars-first has become the norm. But the roads would have been used for something, at a guess, was it trams and horse carriages, and that these didn't pose much of a problem? I've been to towns with trams in the middle of roads and it's normal for people to just walk around it or near the tracks without problem. But I am a stupid tourist so I kept my distance.
- aqme28 4y ago> My assumption that it's always been this way, was wrong. On the other side, it's interesting to note that beautiful walkable bikeable Amsterdam was a traffic and cars hellhole up until the 70s. Nothing has to be permanent.
- rzwitserloot 4y agoAnd to add to this: I can imagine an urban engineer walking through Amsterdam (or any other dutch city, really) to just despair. The sheer amount of infra Amsterdam has built to be this bike friendly is of an epic scale: The dutch have been doing their infra projects with 'bikes and walking comes first' in mind for about 50 years now; no wonder it seems undoable to reproduce that kind of thing in less than a decade. For those who haven't been there: Entire, completely separated two-way wide bike paths with their own bridges and tunnels, nowhere near car roads. Huge swaths of the city that are _solely_ for bikes and walking, with only a few roads dedicated for cars. (i.e. to travel between 2 places in inner Amsterdam by car, generally you drive _away_ from your destination towards the ring, hop on a ring road, drive _past_ your target, and then drive back into the inner city. And yet this is faster than the US style because it avoids incessant waiting in queues and traffic lights, and there's far less traffic as bike/walk is a workable alternative). The bikes, where they even have to cross a car road, get preferential traffic lights and all the bike paths have double detector loops - your bike traffic light tends to switch to green just as you approach the intersection, and if you're the last in a peloton of bicycles you might notice the light switching to orange juuust as you pass the light. That's not a coincidence. Yeah, you can build that up. But it takes quite a while, and requires a financial outlay that seems daunting unless you smear it out over 50 years. However, perhaps, go to Copenhagen. It's often listed as just as bike friendly, if not _more_ bike friendly than cities in The Netherlands. This is hogwash (SOURCE: I've been in, and biked in, both places, recently). Copenhagen is great, Amsterdam is far better. However, Copenhagen looks much more doable. Where Amsterdam has completely separated bike infra and no major car roads running through the center, Copenhagen has giant 3-lane-each car highways right through the busy city center, and almost no separated bike infra. What Copenhagen does have, is one entire lane of car traffic dedicated to bikes, with not a painted line, but an actual physical divider (just a curb thing. You can drive over them but if you do it at speed that might cause some damage, that's all. Cheap as heck, but an order of magnitude better than just a painted line of course). They are wider than 'the minimum necessary for the width of one bike' that you often see elsewhere. A select few tricky intersections have dedicated bike infra. Maybe one bridge is bike-dedicated. And that is all. That should fill you with hope: __That is enough__ to get the kind of bike-friendly name that Copenhagen enjoys. You can get that done in any major city on an acceptable budget within the span of a decade, assuming non-deadlocked political chaos (unfortunately, US and UK, you may have to return to that feeling of despair). From _there_, by all means, look at The Netherlands as bike walhalla. Here's a simple formula to 'fix' the stroads of the USA. They tend to be 4 to 5 lanes each side, so there's plenty of room for this: 1. Turn the stroad into a road - few exits (no way to turn right onto a store's parking lot). But only 2 lanes. Reducing 5 lanes to 2 sounds like a disaster but it won't be: Road congestion primarily depends on the exit: If a popular destination cannot deal with the number of cars that want to exit off of it, even if you have 100 lanes, you _will_ end up with a traffic jam eventually. 2 lanes still allows dynamic traffic (faster traffic capable of passing slower traffic). That's 90% of the win right there, any further lanes barely make a dent. 2. Make strips of 'access road' - these are small, 1-lane roads with a low maximum speed, where every few meters an 'exit' to a store's car park or a home driveway. Between the access road and the main car road there's a real divider: A ditch, a small creek, or an actual metal divider if you have to (Especially in the US with all the trucks, I fear folks will just drive across the dirt or grass otherwise). If you wanna throw money at it and really work on making the place look nice: Line of trees does wonders. Only way to switch from the main road to the access road is to exit onto one from the major intersections which are now miles apart. Between 2 intersections there __are no exits at all__ on the main car road. To go to a store you drive to the intersection that precedes it, exit onto the access road, and drive to it from there. 3. We have 1 lane left (2 lanes to the car road, 1 for the divider, 1 for the access road). The remaining road can now be used to become a bike path. It should optimally be between the access road and the main car road, _between_ the trees : You don't want the bikes to have to deal with the exit/entries onto driveways and car park every few meters. You have plenty of space: in this setup, assuming you started with a 5-lane stroad, it's 2 lanes worth of space you get to play with. It's not exactly cheap but the US is spending literally multiple billions on widening literally 26-lane-wide highways (Katy Highway for example) with some more lanes to 'fight traffic', which seems idiotic and indeed does not work - if you want to fight traffic, reduce traffic. One way to do that: Entice some car traffic to turn itself into bike traffic by making that a viable option. You won't, and can't, replace all the traffic. But if you can eliminate even 5% of the cars, traffic jams are reduced by 50%+. Building these bike strips and turning massive stroads into roads+streets is an order of magnitude cheaper. Note that the primary problem is that the popular target exits lead into city blocks that simply cannot handle the traffic, hence, 'widen the highway' is a net negative, even: It makes people _think_ the car is now a better option (induced demand), but it didn't do anything at all to address the problem. So you really just need to add some bike infra to these overly busy destination city blocks to replace 5% of the traffic within them with bikes - just the 'local traffic' will easily do that. So, this WILL work. And yet, it isn't done. What the fuck, USA?
- jacquesm 4y agoOther cities have done it quite a bit quicker, Amsterdam had a head start to begin with because the old city always was hostile to vehicles simply by the way it was laid out.
- msrenee 4y agoIf you funnel all the traffic that needs to turn in the next 2 miles into a one-lane access road, you're just going to have them backed up past the exit on the main road. The reason no one has implemented this system is that it wouldn't work.
- ska 4y ago>Yeah, you can build that up. But it takes quite a while, "The best time to plant a tree was 30 years ago, the second best time in today" Things could move a lot faster than Amsterdam did, honestly. If a decision was made to stop centering cars in city & infrastructure planning, you would see changes quickly. This isn't the same as being anti-car, it's just prioritizing differently. The real kicker is that there is basically no way to do this without making car use less convenient, because for many decades the majority of planning and builds have been dedicated to making car use more convenient (or at least, not less) and externalizing most of the costs of it.
- matthewfcarlson 4y agoI love this optimism. I’ve long held that I would move to a bike only city if it was in my current country (USA). Starting a bike friendly city seems complicated and expensive but renovating a city seems significantly less expensive but much more political. I’m not sure which is harder of the two.
- danielvaughn 4y agoI think the political hurdles would be far worse than any expense, especially here in America where the car-centric attitude is so deeply embedded.
- pessimizer 4y agoI think it's more that any threat to auto sales would cause marketing and lobbying spend to go up accordingly. Those two things determine what information Americans get exposed to, and what gets subsidized and what gets regulated. The US car-centric attitude is about half t-shirt slogans, half the necessity to have a car in a place built for cars with hourlong commutes, so why not love them? Regulations on marketing, campaign finance, and quid-pro-quo would go a long way in demolishing political hurdles between us and a lot of better things.
- bluejekyll 4y agoStart local. Your local city counselors are generally receptive to feedback from their community (in my experience). Compared to national politics, they tend not to get as much feedback about local issues that people care about. Write a letter, even email, and you’ll be surprised. Then talk to your neighbors, and get them to do the same. You then can live in a bike friendly city.
- jcpst 4y agoI second this. And here’s proof it’s possible. It took a while, but we now have a part of the city that is designed around pedestrians: https://www.lenexa.com/government/departments___divisions/community_development/neighborhoods/lenexa_city_center https://www.lenexa.com/government/departments___divisions/co...
- abirch 4y agoI'm hoping self-driving cars will take people from the burbs to the cities, but then people can use public transportation and bikes in the cities.
- thrown_22 4y agoSelf driving cars should at most drive people to the train stations that take them to the city.
- trothamel 4y agoWhy? Public transit takes about twice as long as driving a car. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-61077-0 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41598-020-61077-0 https://www.governing.com/archive/gov-transit-driving-times.html https://www.governing.com/archive/gov-transit-driving-times....
- pessimizer 4y agoBecause it fills the street with cars that are trying to go twice as fast as public transportation. That's the point of the entire thread, I think.
- abirch 4y agoWith more self driving cars there should be fewer accidents which translates to even faster driving times.
- jeremyjacob 4y agoThat's the problem, and why people choose cars over public transportation. It's a solvable problem however, and countries like Japan and Switzerland have done just that.
- thrown_22 4y agoIn São Paulo, Stockholm, Sydney and Amsterdam. None of which are top tier cities when it comes to public transport. Why not talk about Singapore, London, Hong Kong, Paris and Tokyo? The paper also ignores the last part of a car trip: finding a parking spot. In cities that takes often as long as the trip.
- spamizbad 4y agoJust out of curiosity, do the elderly there pine for the more automobile-centric days of the 1970s?
- wiseowise 4y agoGiven how many elderly I see on bikes - not really.
- xg15 4y agoTrue in principle. But I think in this case, it's more interesting to observe which forces managed to change laws and culture in the US so radically that we got from the pedestrian-friendly state to today's situation. Know your enemy and know what they are capable of, in a sense.
- nerdponx 4y agoOn the other hand, cyclists in the Netherlands are totally disrespectful of pedestrians, making it almost less walkable than New York City, where for the most part you don't have to worry about getting hit by a bike at every corner.
- woile 4y agoAmsterdam is perfectly walkable. I'm still more worried by every combustion powered vehicle, specially those who think they are above the rules. Motorbikes are becoming a problem, while a bike is not gonna kill you.
- nerdponx 4y agoIt's possible that the cyclists are only hazardous in the touristy and busy old city. I had no trouble walking in the less-dense areas.
- mancerayder 4y agoI disagree - see my other comment here. It might be part of a bigger Zeitgeist in NY, but pedestrians are bullied and disrespected at every level by cyclists. Danger increases further when bringing e bikes into the picture.
- wiseowise 4y agoWhere do you get your data from?
- nerdponx 4y agoAnecdotal but firsthand.
- ska 4y agoI've walked a fair bit in both cities, and that just doesn't match my experience at all. Additionally, when people talk about how walkabout NYC is, I suspect they only really mean a relatively small part of the metro area.
- throwawaycuriou 4y agoAnything we can read or watch on the transformation Amsterdam made?
- erwincoumans 4y agoHere is one link:https://inkspire.org/post/amsterdam-was-a-car-loving-city-in-the-1970s-what-changed/ https://inkspire.org/post/amsterdam-was-a-car-loving-city-in... There are other cities in the Netherlands, such as Utrecht as well: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-07-05/how-the-dutch-made-utrecht-a-bicycle-first-city https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2019-07-05/how-the-d...
- roeles 4y agoNot Amsterdam, but Utrecht.. But still. I think Utrecht might be more bike friendly than Amsterdam, with a clear network of central bike ways and free secure bike parking throughout the city. https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fePpwYCs_JM https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fePpwYCs_JM
- scrollaway 4y agoIndeed it wasn’t always this way. And this mindset plagued more countries. The Netherlands narrowly avoided it: https://youtu.be/vI5pbDFDZyI https://youtu.be/vI5pbDFDZyI
- masklinn 4y ago> Ouch, so US towns and cities didn't always be hostile towards walking. My assumption that it's always been this way, was wrong. Couldn't have been since US cities (at least on the east coast) predate the very existence of cars. > But in a way that's worse because it means they used to have this privilege and it has been taken away, and cars-first has become the norm. Yep, the entire concept of jaywalking was invented for the convenience of car owners and the car industry, and pedestrians were alienated from the street surface. > But the roads would have been used for something, at a guess, was it trams and horse carriages, and that these didn't pose much of a problem? Much less so, horses would not trample people unless spooked (and they don't have anywhere near the acceleration or speed of a car, especially as mass increases). And streetcars generally keep to pretty low speed (bike range) in pedestrian areas. You can see what it looks like in low-speed / pedestrian streets of europe, where streetcars are pretty common e.g. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oXrGbZ6LKzs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oXrGbZ6LKzs
- rootusrootus 4y ago> Yep, the entire concept of jaywalking was invented for the convenience of car owners and the car industry, and pedestrians were alienated from the street surface. In a venn diagram "pedestrians" and "car owners" would be nearly a perfect circle. Singling them out as opposing groups with conflicting interests isn't helpful. America got to be car-centric not because of nefarious car companies or other special interests, it got to be car-centric because cars work very well for our use case. Consumers and voters (another near perfect Venn circle) have expressed their preference continuously for nearly a century.
- masklinn 4y ago> In a venn diagram "pedestrians" and "car owners" would be nearly a perfect circle. Nonsense. The ability to walk doesn't a pedestrian make" in the context of the discussion, and having to walk from the parking lot to the store and back isn't a pedestrian activity. > Singling them out as opposing groups with conflicting interests isn't helpful. I didn't decide of the historical events of a hundred years ago mate. > America got to be car-centric not because of nefarious car companies or other special interests, it got to be car-centric because cars work very well for our use case. Consumers and voters (another near perfect Venn circle) have expressed their preference continuously for nearly a century. Even worse, completely ahistorical, nonsense. Long-term infrastructural decisions are rarely decided directly by voters (as Robert Moses knew and leveraged), and furthermore can often be swayed by short terms concerns.
- Sharlin 4y agoSurely it would have been difficult to be hostile towards walking at a time when walking was the only mode of transport readily available to most people?
- iso1631 4y agoI was in Birmingham for a couple of weeks, the squares and streets with trams (not busses, taxis, and other nonsense like oxford street in London) are great -- the tram is only every few minutes, you can easily hear it, you know exactly where it's going and where it stops, and through the pedestrian area it travels slowly.
- jt2190 4y ago> … trams and horse carriages, and that these didn't pose much of a problem? Horse manure was a huge problem on city streets. (Trams we’re originally horse-drawn.) > According to the 89th Annual Report of the Board of Health, nearly 500 tones of horse manure were collected from the streets of New York every day, produced by 62,208 horses living in 1,307 stables. https://www.nyhistory.org/community/horse-manure https://www.nyhistory.org/community/horse-manure Edit: A more in-depth article https://www.newyorkalmanack.com/2021/02/the-unpleasant-side-of-life-with-horses-in-cities/ https://www.newyorkalmanack.com/2021/02/the-unpleasant-side-...
- soneil 4y agoI've never had a problem walking around trams, they're incredibly predictable. And horses (as vehicles) are the level of intelligence we're hoping to get self-driving vehicles back to - they don't actually want to run you over.
- Voline 4y agoTake a look: Rare film of Market Street in San Francisco in 1906. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aG9XXbKuYfA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=aG9XXbKuYfA
- heavyset_go 4y agoPhiladelphia used to have extensive electric trolley systems that went down pretty much every street[1]. [1] https://i.redd.it/zidqa2mbmav31.png https://i.redd.it/zidqa2mbmav31.png
- joe_the_user 4y agoOuch, so US towns and cities didn't always be hostile towards walking. Well, the article is more saying the average person in cities was car hostile but it notes that authorities starting trying to force people to adapt to cars quite early by enforcing "jay-walking" ordinances and similar things.
- asdff 4y agoIt was trams and horses and people and early cars. It was pure chaos, almost like images you see from countries without strong traffic laws. Here was downtown LA: https://www.discoverlosangeles.com/sites/default/files/images/2019-01/Downtown%20Los%20Angeles%20April%201910.jpg https://www.discoverlosangeles.com/sites/default/files/image... As you can imagine, average speeds for every vehicle in this situation was very low. Downtown LA was notoriously congested, and the city for a long time had a height limit imposed where no structure could be taller than city hall, to ensure congestion didn't get even worse and to encourage more sprawl. This eventually put pressure on the city to replace these streetcar routes with bus routes, since its much easier to navigate a bus in this environment than a streetcar that cannot easily detour and has tracking that is damaged constantly by other traffic. The highways were planned (and still do with bus and some rail in LA county) to carry transit as well as car traffic, and to disperse the population from concentrating so much in these early congested regions. They were also used to permit infilling of the gaps between these population centers (e.g. hollywood and downtown la were once separate municipalities with some distance of rural space in between).
- gnufied 4y agoWhat I wouldn't give to have a planned neighborhood where cars are banned. It would be kids wonderland. In US at least even inside gated communities u can't leave kids (3-6) by themselves because cars. Imagine all those kids having fun without parent supervision.
- rootusrootus 4y agoIt isn't cars that kept me from leaving my 3 year old unsupervised. It's not like there aren't other (in many cases more significant) dangers to a young child.
- concordDance 4y agoMost notably: other children
- scrollaway 4y agoStranger Danger, eh? I hope your kids will find a better life for theirs. https://youtu.be/oHlpmxLTxpw https://youtu.be/oHlpmxLTxpw
- iso1631 4y agoI wouldn't trust a 3 year old to not jump off a wall, stick their head down a drain, eat some random berries, etc.
- esarbe 4y ago> "A developed nation is not a place where the poor own cars, but where the rich use public transportation." - Gustavo Petro, Mayor of Bogotá We have gone so awfully off the bend with our cities; not places to live but places to drive through. I'm hoping that with the trend to more homeoffice, we can maybe scale back the commuting a bit and go back a step towards cities for living, with community neighborhoods, parks and public spaces everywhere. Just imagine turning the streets of your local city into green lanes, with lots of excellent public transport. That would be amazing.
- supertrope 4y agoBogota has a mass transit system with BRT stations and double/triple length buses. This was done to avoid the upfront capital cost of a metro while still providing most of the benefits of frequent high capacity service. Now it is extremely crowded and an upgrade to an actual metro is needed but has not happened.
- esarbe 4y agoI think that was more of an aspirational statement.
- KingOfCoders 4y agoToday they treat pedestrians as dangerous obstacles.
- car_hacker 4y ago
- kory 4y agoIt’s good thing we moved from these old urban walkable designs to a car centric lifestyle, which the vast majority of Americans enjoy. The tradeoff of owning a single family home with a good plot of land is well worth the loss in walkability. This isn’t sarcasm. Edit: I understand HN really doesn’t like pro car and pro sprawl viewpoints, but downvotes don’t feel well placed.
- scrollaway 4y agoYour comment history is fascinating. You posted yourself about the ridiculous subsidies that US suburbia gets so you clearly understand that the way Americans live in the suburbs is completely out of touch with how much it really costs, and very few people if any would actually choose suburbia if they had to bear those costs. Yet here and elsewhere you also say it’s all a “good thing”, and that Americans are “choosing this”. They really aren’t. Zoning laws are preventing better alternatives from being created, and the subsidies basically force an unnatural amount of people to go that route even if they hate it. And honestly, most of y’all don’t know any better. Whenever I have Americans over visiting Brussels, it ends in “holy shit I want to move here”. Last guy I had over was from Alabama. I walked with him from one end of the city to the other in less than a couple hours, stopping everywhere interesting. His mind was blown: it’s the same distance he would have to take his car to go to the nearest pub to his house.
- kory 4y ago> Your comment history is fascinating. Can we refrain from the reddit-esque creepy "gotcha" of digging through post history of another user instead of addressing the argument at hand? > You posted yourself about the ridiculous subsidies that US suburbia gets so you clearly understand that the way Americans live in the suburbs is completely out of touch with how much it really costs Yep. > and very few people if any would actually choose suburbia if they had to bear those costs. I don't agree. It's arguable we do already bear much of these costs, as a lot of infrastructure is paid for through development fees (higher housing prices) or through federal & state grants (which we all pay for). I understand cities subsidize suburban areas to some extent, but that's largely from business tax that, again, we all pay for in higher prices. > Americans are “choosing this” Look at the pandemic trends, that haven't really reversed since. People left cities and suburban / rural property values shot up compared to big city real estate. > oning laws are preventing better alternatives from being created No, they're keeping nice neighborhoods nice low density neighborhoods. Like the inhabitants of those neighborhoods want them to be. > Whenever I have Americans over visiting Brussels Something tells me "Americans who want to visit Brussels" has a strong pro-density sampling bias. You're also seeing the initial reaction and not the long term reaction. > His mind was blown But would he really live there, or was he just surprised by the different infrastructure? For clarity, I live right in the middle in one of the most walkable places in the US. In the past, I’ve lived in suburban and rural areas. I understand the pro's of walkability, but I also understand suburbanites and rural folks don't want those pros because of the cons that come with them.
- MomoXenosaga 4y agoIn the 70s and 80s urban planners looked to the US for inspiration. Let's turn this medieval square into a giant parking lot! Pave over the canals and turn them into roads! Giant 10 lane highways cutting straight through the city! They've now spent billions undoing the future of the past.
- Tijdreiziger 4y agoNot Just Bikes made an interesting video on the thankfully-avoided plan to build a US-style highway system in Amsterdam: https://youtu.be/vI5pbDFDZyI https://youtu.be/vI5pbDFDZyI
- codefreeordie 4y ago
- _dain_ 4y agothat "freedom of movement" was exclusively for people in cars, and came at the expense of the freedom of movement of everyone else (not to mention safety). besides, it's not like you can't still drive in the netherlands.
- codefreeordie 4y ago
- _dain_ 4y agowhat are you basing this on? the netherlands has a system of high speed motorways, along with rapid inter-city rail and a dense network of cycle routes. cars, trains, bikes, buses, are all viable ways of getting around, both within cities and between them. why do you think the only worthwhile part of the transport network is the road network? and why do you think the only worthwhile road users are motorists? it seems like you think nobody should have any choice except to travel by motor car. lack of choice doesn't seem like freedom to me.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaway0x7E6 4y agoif it means we get back the all the other features and attitudes from that era, sure, I'd love to go back to that.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- duchenne 4y agoIt is worth noting that streets were dangerous even before cars. For instance, Pierre Curie (Nobel prize and husband of Marie Curie) was killed by a horse-powered truck in the streets of Paris in 1906. He was 46. But pedestrians at that time had the freedom to walk in the middle of the street at any time. You can clearly see it in this fascinating video of Paris in late 1890s: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fo_eZuOTBNc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fo_eZuOTBNc
- bertil 4y agoIn those cases, it was easy to blame either the horse or the professional rider. Cars were driven by wealthy people who could not face that kind of responsibilities — see _The Great Gatsby_.
- throwawaygal7 4y agoAdjacent to this, the USA used to have great light rail / trolleys in even small and rural towns. If we just brought back rail, we would be able to improve walkability without rebuilding!
- Zigurd 4y agoI can fly to Schiphol airport, get on a train without even stepping outdoors, ride to a suburb on the far side of Amsterdam in time for a morning meeting, walk to my hotel, all without even a taxi ride. On this side of the ocean, I have to call for a limo to the airport because the commuter rail schedule is too sparse, the trains are too crowded for being under-provisioned. The diesel locomotives are as polluting as if everyone on the train drove their cars instead. There is no long term parking at the train stations. The subway stop at the airport is far from the terminals. Bad transportation is a drag on the US economy. How much productivity sits on our highways for hours each day?
- Clubber 4y ago>With their traditional mission of defending custom and seeking equity, police were unwilling to abridge pedestrians’ rights to the free use of city streets. How times have changed. In regards to police/government respecting citizen's rights. I've always wondered what a person from the past, say pre-WWI era would think if they were to time travel to the present. They would probably think we live in an authoritarian police state. They'd probably be right.
- woweoe 4y agoI usually say that walking is the most simple/easy form of transportation. Why is walking to another room of your house simple, but walking anyway in the outside world hard? Driving is basically a second level of complexity that means your focusing on driving rather than sleeping, working or playing. You walk in a mall and a park for example. I grew up and prefer a lifestyle where the car exists but you have multiple options of public transport. It's easier to be able to take a metro train under traffic jams and buildings to where you need to go, or a bus after a night out drinking. Driving is just a lot of stress and work.
- Spivak 4y agoI mean people don’t put up with those costs and complexity for no reason. Carrying stuff and long distances are the big ones for me day to day. My nearest grocery store is 1.5 miles away, my friends 19 miles away, the nearest Costco is 5 miles away, IKEA is 11 miles away. Just last weekend I rented a small venue for a birthday party and had to transport about 100 lbs of food, drinks, serveware, decorations, and alcohol 18 miles of highway. The weekend before I was camping at a festival and again the car was packed with coolers, tents, and clothes. That was a 56 mile trip. Getting to my airport is 2.5 hours by public transport or 20 minutes by car.
- woweoe 4y agoI currently live in Japan but I have lived in major cities of the West as well. For big items the locals will usually do home delivery, and for groceries the norm in most of Europe and Asia is to buy them every few days in smaller amounts when you need them (since centuries ago) and therefore you do not need the car. For the camping you would rent a car. I said that the car was still something I expected to be able to use. Switzerland for example is famous for its car journey holidays but most people use public transport.
- rainsford 4y agoI don't think most people are arguing that you as an individual should switch to walking or public transit without anything else changing. The situations you describe are the way they are because we've spent decades heavily investing in making cars the most convenient or often only option. The suggestion is that we should consider making different choices going forward so people have other options. Everything doesn't have to be so far away and things like public transit don't have to suck. I also think there's a misinterpretation that alternatives to cars means nobody should drive anywhere. For something like going camping, it's hard to argue that a car doesn't make the most sense. But the point is to make it so you don't have to drive everywhere for everything and can save the driving for when it really is the best option.
- matsemann 4y agoA similar book about history of cars in Norway is "Et land på fire hjul": https://respublica.no/produkter/et-land-pa-fire-hjul/ https://respublica.no/produkter/et-land-pa-fire-hjul/ It's very interesting to read how a few rich people getting cars changed the whole capitol. Tens of thousands of pedestrians had to move out of the way for these few, and everything changed permanently. Or how most traffic safety organizations were really pro-car organizations, and in the media always shifted the blame over to pedestrians being uncultivated and walking where they shouldn't be etc.
- nextstep 4y agoIt’s hard to monetize walking, so unfortunately pedestrians have undersized representation in the political process.
- supertrope 4y agoMore pedestrian friendly Main Streets are an opportunity for more local stores to open and thrive. Towns that want to collect sales tax, income tax, and property tax will do road diets, widen sidewalks, enhance trash pickup, and move parking to the periphery of the commercial zone to cultivate growth. While citizens pick their local government leaders, governments also pick their residents by setting zoning laws that effectively determine who can move in or open up shop. Local governments are incentivized to pick what use yields the most votes or tax dollars. People driving through in their car are only contributing a danger to pedestrians, parking demand, air pollution, and noise. People driving to downtown can be accommodated with parking off to the side (but not taking up prime real estate). Pedestrians are much more likely to stop and participate in the economy.
- beowulfey 4y agoReading this infuriates me. I can’t believe so much effort was put into giving cars higher priority than pedestrians. What a tremendous detriment. And it’s so hard to undo! People always stick to the status quo; we need even more work to undo all of it. What a waste.
- lamontcg 4y agoIt is funny how it is the "conservative" supposedly "old ways are the best ways" people who would absolutely riot if you restored the order that we had before 1920 with pedestrians taking precedence over cars. The radical experiment of constructing our society entirely around single occupancy internal combustion engine vehicles has failed. Lets go back to the old ways.
- ycombinete 4y ago“I've come up with a set of rules that describe our reactions to technologies: 1. Anything that is in the world when you’re born is normal and ordinary and is just a natural part of the way the world works. 2. Anything that's invented between when you’re fifteen and thirty-five is new and exciting and revolutionary and you can probably get a career in it. 3. Anything invented after you're thirty-five is against the natural order of things.” ― Douglas Adams, The Salmon of Doubt
- actionablefiber 4y agoI'm not sure this applies here. Urbanism seems to be taking strong root in the popular imagination today, especially among young people, who are increasingly saying "screw cars, give us trains and buses and bikes and let us walk around town." And in this matter, the "old fuddy-duddies" are the ones who want to keep the new, aberrant patterns of development and transportation that became dominant during their lives, possibly arguing to hot-swap the ICEs with EVs while keeping all the new highways and sprawling developments, and young people want to revert to the patterns of development from over a century ago with car-free infrastructure.
- rayiner 4y ago> And in this matter, the "old fuddy-duddies" are the ones who want to keep the new, aberrant patterns of development and transportation that became dominant during their lives Even in 1960 80% of households had a car: https://transportgeography.org/contents/chapter8/urban-transport-challenges/household-vehicles-united-states https://transportgeography.org/contents/chapter8/urban-trans.... Even in 1925 it was over half. There isn't a generation in American history where most people lived in a city and took public transit. In the 1920s and 1930s when that was common for people living in cities, half the country lived in rural places.
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI remember in Sixth Grade (in Maryland), our teacher telling us that there was still a law on the state books, that said (I can’t remember what he said, precisely, but this is the gist): If a car is going in one direction on a road, and there is a horse (I don’t think he specified whether or not it was harnessed, but I’ll bet it needed to be in harness) coming the opposite direction, the car needed to pull over, and yield to the horse. If the horse refused to pass the car, then it was incumbent upon the car owner to (in escalating order): 1) Turn off the engine. 2) Cover the car in a blanket. 3) Dismantle the car, piece by piece, until the horse passes. I could see a cranky old farmer having fun with that law.
- mancerayder 4y agoNYC has become extremely more hostile to pedestrians in only the last 4-5 years. Now, not only are you on the lookout for cars when crossing, but you have to add e-bikers and cyclists. Both of those often don't honor one way streets, so now you have to look both ways. They don't stop at red lights, so you have to look both ways when you have right of way. They ride on the sidewalk, so you have to be careful when turning a corner. Society loves these vehicles as eco-friendly, and carves out a part of the road for them. No one carves anything for pedestrians. It's time to leave the city, which now seems left for people in their 20s and people who generally don't care about any order whatsoever.
- throw__away7391 4y agoAh yes, bicycles, enemy #1 of walkable cities.
- actionablefiber 4y agoIt is a real problem that NYC street design gives so much space to cars while people walking, cycling and scootering are left to fight over the scraps. GP is correct that things are getting harder although I think they are wrong to blame individual behaviors instead of faulty infrastructure.
- mancerayder 4y agoBut there are bike lanes available. And markings that say yield to pedestrians. And lights for bikes in some cases. These things are generally completely ignored, leaving the pedestrian with the burden of watching everyone else. It's fine to have a preference for a bike-friendly city over a car-centric one, but one has to consider that almost any vehicle is going to be dangerous to a pedestrian, not just cars. Would you feel comfortable with an older member of your family taking a walk on a Sunday while trusting e bikers not to bowl them over turning around a corner on the sidewalk, going the opposite way on a one-way street, or running a red light?
- 4y ago
- JKCalhoun 4y agoA lot of literature from that time (perhaps most well known, "The Great Gatsby") have cars and their drivers as the antagonist.
- mgraczyk 4y agoI don't have a car and absolutely hate the car-centric culture of American cities (I live in SF). That being said, this article is completely wrong and draws the wrong conclusions. People were anti-car early on because most people didn't have cars. Later, people stopped being anti-car because most people had cars. The article would have you believe that at no point in time did the majority of people want car-centric city streets and that it was forced on them by a small minority of people interested in selling cars. That simply isn't the case. Vocal opposition to cars faded away as more people owned them. It's important to understand the status quo correctly if we ever want to change things. The sad reality is that most people want cars, even in dense cities. As I look out my apartment window on a Sunday morning, with pleasant weather and a walkable green neighborhood, I still count far more cars going by than people on foot or bicycle. Hopefully that would change if we made it easier and safer for people to walk, but it's not productive to pretend most people secretly hate cars.
- hnhg 4y agoYou're looking at on car usage after all the rules were changed, and all those drivers know no better, or worse, have no choice. But imagine a city designed for no car usage! How would all those car driver vote then? SF has terrible public transport by international standards. You have to rebalance your baseline, I'm afraid.
- mgraczyk 4y agoRight, I would strongly prefer a city designed for less/no car usage. My complaint is that this article misrepresents history and misrepresents the current situation. Public transit 100 years ago was worse for everyone than car ownership today. Living in a car centric city with a car is an overwhelmingly better lifestyle than riding public transit in the 1910s. At the time that cars became popular, they were a huge improvement in quality of life for the vast majority of people. Today we have technology to build better transit that is an improvement on car ownership for most people, but we're not building it. I'd like the narrative to be "we can do better", not "we used to do better but secret evil forces hurt us".
- dionidium 4y ago
- foreigner 4y agoI love this amazing illustration showing streets in our society from a pedestrian's perspective: https://i.insider.com/59036a187dea725c008b50b2?width=1400&format=jpeg&auto=webp https://i.insider.com/59036a187dea725c008b50b2?width=1400&fo...
- DoneWithAllThat 4y agoOh look it’s Sunday so we need another escapee from /r/fuckcars on HN.
- kodah 4y agoI like being able to walk my city (I live in San Jose) but I can't imagine not having a car. Being able to take road trips to things like festivals where I don't have to pay incredible baggage fees or sit on a train without wifi for days at a time is fairly nice. I would like a world that balances being able to walk with being able to own a car, especially as I get older and move out of the city. I do think it's a little odd that so many HNers hate cars (an example: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32297081 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32297081). I'm not quite sure what to make of those attitudes, even after reading some of their text.
- opportune 4y agoHow much of that is because you live in one of the sprawliest cities in the US? Of course living in San Jose would be terrible without a car. But that's because the city was designed around cars. In places like Hong Kong it's the exact opposite, you would not even want a car because the city was not designed around them - you can easily get to places without one, and things like parking/dealing with pedestrians/the cost would make it an overall terrible UX. Also, you are not exactly not paying baggage fees or saving money on wifi. The car itself still has a lot of costs (the upfront cost or payments, insurance, gas, various bureaucratic costs, parking, potentially tolls) - it may very well be that in your situation you're still effectively saving money with the car, but it's not exactly clear-cut.
- kodah 4y agoYou actually didn't address why I said I liked cars, which is for road trips. My independence is really another. My point here, is rather than arguing for no cars, I argue for a society that balances both equally. I don't really like the idea of people making somewhere totally unwalkable or totally undrivable. Ironically, as much as you tried to disqualify what I said, I have no problem walking or biking around San Jose. Whether it was "designed for cars" is pretty arbitrary to me. I can ride my bike to the grocery store or deli and I can walk to a c-store and anywhere else I need to go. Maybe stop trying to dismiss me and really read what I said.
- stevenjgarner 4y ago> “The pedestrian,” explained a Brooklyn man, “as an American citizen, naturally resents any intrusion upon his prior constitutional rights.” Custom and the Anglo-American legal tradition confirmed pedestrians’ inalienable right to the street. > In 1913 the New York Court of Appeals observed that it was “common knowledge” that the “great size and weight” of automobiles could make them “a most serious danger,” and so the responsibility for preserving the safety of the streets lay overwhelmingly with motorists. Any legal researchers or history buffs out there know of any other precedents at appeal (or higher) siding with the rights of pedestrians over motorists? Did the issue ever make the US Supreme Court? Its always intrigued me that arbitrary rules (like driving on the right) have such enforceable weight of law behind them (thank goodness), while other rules are more lax. For example, is the customary tradition for the US (along with Liberia and Myanmar) to use imperial (rather than metric) measurements set in legal stone somewhere? I know that NASA and their contractors all use metric [0]. What requires a custom or tradition to be legally defined? [0] https://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2007/08jan_metricmoon https://science.nasa.gov/science-news/science-at-nasa/2007/0...
- ilaksh 4y agoCities should be redesigned from the ground up. We have good technology for much better design collaboration. There should be very small self driving vehicles and generally there is no reason for roadways to intersect directly with pedestrian paths. The roadways should be multilevel in areas of high density.
- BuyMyBitcoins 4y agoWe can redesign them easily but reconstructing them would be monumentally expensive.
- trhway 4y agoThe same story these days with drones and VTOLs. We know how it will end (and the drones and VTOLs will liberate our streets from cars (except for some small golf-cart likes) and our Earth surface from asphalt), yet it is still a long way to go for the population mentality which right now has even hardly reached the stage of the Red Flag laws https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Locomotive_Acts https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Locomotive_Acts (or in grief stages - somewhere between Denial and Anger)
- twobitshifter 4y agoTo take another slant on the article, you can see how the laws and systems were adapted to support the automobile from where they were before. There were no stop signs, speed limits, license requirements, or traffic lights in the 1920s. Fast forward to today and we see E-Bikes and E-Scooters being banned from different areas, having speed caps put on, not being allowed on sidewalks, into bike paths, trails, etc. There is no adaptation in most locations. People are finally moving away from automobiles, but officials are choosing to make it much more difficult for people to use new forms of transportation. E-Scooters have been called a scourge just about everywhere they show up. They're vilified in city after city, due to the lack of supporting infrastructure and incompatibility with roads. In some places, officials want scooters to ride in 50 mph traffic - which all cyclists know is a death wish, but not on the unused sidewalks. Many cyclists blame e-bikes and scooters for the problems caused by cars, and want to hoard the infrastructure to themselves. Pedestrian safety is an easy scare tactic, but in reality, e-scooters and e-bikes make being a pedestrian much more feasible and increase the use of bike paths and sidewalks. I'd like to see a comparison of pedestrians killed by e-scooters on a sidewalk vs. pedestrians on sidewalks vs. cars or even cars vs. e-scooters. If a place ends up with scooters on the sidewalks, the city should build a mobility lane, not kick them out into the street. I'm interested to see how planners and cities adjust to using a bike to get to work no longer requiring lycra and a shower. If you do the math, being able to travel at 10-15 MPH for 30 minutes under electric power, can get you just about anywhere in most cities in the USA. It's really a question of having safe infrastructure to get you there.
- 8bitsrule 4y agoInteresting problem that will soon become a historical curiousity, because there is clearly no alternative. Even if* we immediately ban the sale of gaoline-powered vehicles to be driven in cities, that'd be too little. For five years I've lived near a suburban arterial street that's busy from 6 a.m. to midnight most days. I've seen no diminution of traffic in that time. This is madness. We either create a workable rational solution or consign ourselves to our individual fates.
- tomohawk 4y agoCities in California can't keep up with the volume of human manure deposited on sidewalks, so why not add to the problem and bring back horses instead of cars!