18 ms·
Oldest and Fatherless: The Terrible Secret of Tom Bombadil (2011)
- xenophonf 4y agoPreviously: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9982237 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=9982237 And previously-er: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6923547 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6923547
- tevon 4y agoTo me, Tom Bombadil is the introduction of natural magic. He is nature, indicating to the reader that there is a source of magic beyond the elves, Wizards, and Sauron. There are many magical creatures in Middle-Earth without a described source, which to me makes the whole story feel more magic. The Ents probably being the chief example. Another important role of Tom’s is his introduction of magic and power outside of the “good vs evil” struggle.
- stevekemp 4y ago> The Ents probably being the chief example. The Ents were made by Yavanna, in the same way that Aulë made the Dwarves, according to my memories of the Silmarillion. They awoke at the coming of others, and they were taught speech by the Elves.
- Aeolun 4y agoI pity the poor elf that taught the Ents speech... even for an elf that sounds like the work of a lifetime.
- bowsamic 4y agoYeah I agree, and I don't think it needs to be complicated beyond that point. Him and the other stuff that happens very close to that point (Old Man Willow and the barrow-wight) are just showing that this is a naturally magical world without being tied to just elves and wizards and rings. Unfortunately the movies did away with almost all of that part of the books, making it more like a Harry Potter style of magic: simply that there are indeed magic beings and wizards but generally the world itself is un-magical.
- xxs 4y agoSome researchers consider Tom to be the 'reader'
- reptation 4y agoPlease expand on this.
- ThaDood 4y agoReally? Thats actually a super interesting theory that I had never considered before. Any more info, I'd love to look into this.
- xxs 4y agoI guess: https://lotr.fandom.com/wiki/Theories_about_Tom_Bombadil https://lotr.fandom.com/wiki/Theories_about_Tom_Bombadil
- peteradio 4y agoPerhaps the author?
- xxs 4y agoHe declined that... Tolkien said Tom Bombadil had been 'invented'. He considered his wife Edith: to have been Lúthien, so that would make Tolkien - Beren. "I never called Edith Lúthien – but she was the source of the story that in time became the chief part of The Silmarillion." Tom Bombadil predates the story of the ring. It's placed there as a very powerful creature - still would lose to Sauron if all the world fell apart according to Glorfindel [and Gandalf doesn't object either]. That creature has no direct influence on the story, being more of a bystander... similar to the reader.
- WJW 4y agoI suppose it would come down to if you think the Ring could influence the reader of the story, if it were possible for the reader to actually acquire the Ring. Tbh, it seems obvious to me that any ordinary human would probably fall to its pernicious influence. I certainly would, and its powers are such that I just can't imagine any human could resist its charms. Yet, Bombadil is completely untouched by it. Tom Bombadil is like the Middle Earth equivalent of a Buddhist sage, just existing without wishing to be more or less than he already is.
- jiggywiggy 4y agoSounds indeed more in line with what Tolkien said, although everyone can create their own version of the story of course. Tolkien: "But Tom Bombadil is just as he is. Just an odd ‘fact’ of that world. He won’t be explained, because as long as you are (as in this tale you are meant to be) concentrated on the Ring, he is inexplicable. But he’s there – a reminder of the truth (as I see it) that the world is so large and manifold that if you take one facet and fix your mind and heart on it, there is always something that does not come in to that story/argument/approach, and seems to belong to a larger story. But of course in another way, not that of pure story-making, Bombadil is a deliberate contrast to the Elves who are artists. But B. does not want to make, alter, devise, or control anything: just to observe and take joy in the contemplating the things that are not himself. The spirit of the [deleted: world > this earth] made aware of itself. He is more like science (utterly free from technological blemish) and history than art. He represents the complete fearlessness of that spirit when we can catch a little of it. But I do suggest that it is possible to fear (as I do) that the making artistic sub-creative spirit (of Men and Elves) is actually more potent, and can ‘fall’, and that it could in the eventual triumph of its own evil destroy the whole earth, and Bombadil and all." http://www.hammondandscull.com/addenda/bombadil.html http://www.hammondandscull.com/addenda/bombadil.html
- permo-w 4y agoI really like this. In many many many works of fiction, if you are presented with an odd detail that seems extraneous to the plot or the aesthetic, there’s a huge chance that this will turn out to be some kind of pivotal point later in the story. I love that Tolkien was introducing them simply to create depth - and to a great extent - to provoke the feelings that bring about posts and discussion like this https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impression_of_depth_in_The_Lord_of_the_Rings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Impression_of_depth_in_The_Lor...
- Trasmatta 4y agoThanks for the link to that Wikipedia page, I'd never seen it before. Really amazing stuff. There have been many authors since that have done a good job at replicating that "impression of depth", but I still feel like none of them has ever done it at Tolkien's level.
- carapace 4y agoHe's the Green Man, older than gods, and more real.
- NeverFade 4y ago> There are many magical creatures in Middle-Earth without a described source, which to me makes the whole story feel more magic. As far as I know, this isn't true. Virtually all creatures and major characters in LotR have a clear source in the lore Tolkien developed. Of course, only a fraction of this lore is in LotR itself, and the rest was in notes published after his death, e.g. in The Silmarillion. That's precisely what makes Tom Bombadil such an eye-catching exception.
- pozdnyshev 4y agoI disagree. Tolkien leaves plenty to the imagination and often alludes to histories or events which he doesn't bother explaining elsewhere. >'We cannot go further tonight,' said Boromir. `Let those call it the wind who will; there are fell voices on the air; and these stones are aimed at us.' `I do call it the wind,' said Aragorn. `But that does not make what you say untrue. There are many evil and unfriendly things in the world that have little love for those that go on two legs, and yet are not in league with Sauron, but have purposes of their own. Some have been in this world longer than he.' 'Caradhras was called the Cruel, and had an ill name, said Gimli, `long years ago, when rumour of Sauron had not been heard in these lands.' Aragorn explains that there are evils older than Sauron and we get the sense that the mountain itself may hold a prejudice against the company but this is never explained or developed elsewhere. Caradhras the Cruel doesn't appear elsewhere either. I'll add that the film unfortunately dispels this uncertainty from the original novel.
- NeverFade 4y ago> Aragorn explains that there are evils older than Sauron Caradhras contained Durin's Bane, a Balrog, which sufficiently explains this comment. There are certainly many evils predating Sauron, notably Morgoth.
- JohnJamesRambo 4y agoInteresting ideas but having listened to a mountain of Tolkien Professor podcasts, I don’t think this is a canonical view of Bombadil. My impression is that he is not evil, he is just so old and powerful that he doesn’t care about power anymore.
- ramesh31 4y agoWho the hell is Tom Bombadil?
- jyriand 4y agoFuck livejournal for hijacking my back button on mobile. Edit: obviously, I replied under wrong comment.
- michaericalribo 4y agoPress and hold back on iOS to choose the page to return to
- Insanity 4y agoCool, TIL
- everyone 4y agoFucking seconded. Does it for me on firefox/windows also.
- fsflover 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Bombadil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tom_Bombadil
- wongarsu 4y agoA character from Lord of the Rings. He's a hermit living in nature, and one of the more notable things omitted in the movies. Probably because apart from saving the Hobbits from some dangers early in their journey he doesn't play much of a role.
- ramesh31 4y agoSorry, lame joke. Peter Jackson cut Tom Bombadil from the movies, and it was a meme 20 years ago.
- nathell 4y agoI know it’s disproved, but I always liked to think about Tom Bombadil as Eru Ilúvatar.
- boringg 4y agoIs this popping up because of Elden Ring coming out in the fall?
- theknocker 4y ago
- 1234letshaveatw 4y agoWhy does it seem like everyone wants it to fail? It is almost like everyone has deemed it to be a disaster without watching one episode. I hope that is not the case and critics go in with an open mind, why sap all the fun out of it right out of the starting gate
- boringg 4y agoI didn't say anything about it or alluding to it failing - I mentioned that there is LOTR content popping up at the same time as Elden Ring is getting traction. Your bias really shines through here.
- saiya-jin 4y agoWell not sure why you keep repeating name 'Elden ring' - thats a computer game completely unrelated to LOTR or incoming TV show from Amazon (The rings of power). It may sound like a jab on the TV show from you, probably hence the reactions
- ysavir 4y agoLotR stuff pops on here pretty regularly, though not in big swarms. There's the Battle of Helms Deep analysis series (or something like that) that usually gets posted, for example. I'm sure The Rings of Power (which I assume is what you meant) will give the subject a bump, but this is more likely something someone came across and shared unrelated.
- samrocksc 4y agothis is the best thing ever posted on HN..... going to restart the lord of the rings podcast now.
- shaftoe444 4y agoWhat podcast is that? I'm just reading the books for the first time.
- whicks 4y agoNot sure which one the OP had in mind but if you're into more theatrical audiobooks / podcasts check out "An Unexpected Journey" by "Samwise Gamgee" on Spotify. Absolutely top-tier audiobook of both The Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings.
- olvy0 4y agoWow, just listened to the beginning of chpater 1. This is really, seriously good. Thanks you. I was just thinking what's next for my morning commute...
- klohto 4y agoThank you so much! I started listening yesterday and cannot put it down. I am not certain how long will it stay up, but it is gold.
- digdugdirk 4y agoJust seconding this request. Any and all podcast recommendations on the LoTR would be welcome.
- danparsonson 4y agoTangentially related, the BBC published a pretty solid radio adaptation of LOTR in the 80's: https://archive.org/details/the-lord-of-the-rings-bbc-radio-drama https://archive.org/details/the-lord-of-the-rings-bbc-radio-... (no sign of Tom Bombadil here either though, IIRC)
- wly_cdgr 4y agoI find the classic take that Tom Bombadil was intended by Tolkien to be god persuasive. But he is definitely creepy
- boringg 4y agoThis take almost makes him sound like nature inherent. Quiet in the background of all the activity of humans, elves, orcs etc but always ready to take over the world again as soon as those creatures depart or diminish.
- gaoshan 4y agoThis is roughly how I always viewed him.
- boringg 4y agoA random thought just occurred - and I welcome speculation. Do you/we think Lord of the Rings will have staying power in human history 1000 years from now or only last one century or so? Inherent assumptions: humans will survive 1000 years and so will books.
- IlliOnato 4y agoHomer's works have survived for far longer than that...
- simonh 4y agoI think it will be studied and valued indefinitely, if not for anything else, due to it's massive impact on literature and popular culture in this era, which shows no sign of waning. If anything in my lifetime it's influence has increase dramatically. Nobody in the future interested in the culture of the 20th and 21st century, and quite possibly well beyond, could ignore it. Having said that, will non-academics in that far future still read it for entertainment? That's harder to say because in large part it depends how much language evolves. We still read Shakespear, go to see the plays, and even go and see film productions of it in cinemas but it's language is only diverged from our by 400 years. A thousand years can allow for a lot more linguistic divergence. Chaucer from 900 years ago is hardly recognisable as English, but that's mainly due to a shift that occurred in only a few hundred years. If such a shift occurs again then today's fiction might become inaccessible, but we can't know that in advance.
- KineticLensman 4y ago> That's harder to say because in large part it depends how much language evolves. LoTR is interesting here because it explicitly contains examples of language change. In fact language change was one of Tolkien's original motivations for developing the history of Middle Earth - to provide a historical context for the evolution of Elvish. E.g. Elves being sundered during the First Age and then developing independent languages. Even Frodo is aware of 'high' Elvish. The language of the Rohirrim, to the hobbits, sounds something like Old English does to us. Tolkien himself uses archaic modes of English to describe some of the events near the end of the story, some of which might already be difficult to understand for modern readers. One example is when he states that some characters were 'in the van' meaning 'vanguard' rather than a road vehicle.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Trasmatta 4y ago> Possibly the least liked character in The Lord of the Rings. A childish figure so disliked by fans of the book that few object to his absence from all adaptations of the story. I've been a fan of Tolkien for decades, and this doesn't match up with my experience at all...Tolkien fans seem to generally love Tom, and many were deeply disappointed that he wasn't in the movies (even though his exclusion makes perfect sense). Did I just run in different Tolkien circles than the author?
- ycombinete 4y agoI’m really surprised by this as well. Every fan I’ve spoken to also believes that he was sorely missed as a point of perspective to the story. His contentment with his place, and his power. That he was here before this war, and will be here afterward.
- simplicio 4y agoI like him in the books, but he also seems like a really good example of why making movies their own thing instead of slavishly following the source material is a good idea. There's no way having the hobbits break the tense flight from the Shire->Rivendale for a weird musical number with an unexplained character who's never referenced again in the story would've been anything but confusing for the film audience.
- ycombinete 4y agoI agree, the story would have had to go: Shire -> Buckland -> Old Forest (Tom) -> Bree -> Rivendell Instead of: Shire -> Bree -> Rivendell Part of me still wished he featured; or at least the spirit of Bombadil's relationship to the ring was embodied by something/someone in the story.
- lordfoom 4y agoThere is even an active sub-reddit of fans: https://old.reddit.com/r/GloriousTomBombadil/ https://old.reddit.com/r/GloriousTomBombadil/ And his absence from the films was remarked upon, negatively in my circles.
- tmcneal 4y agoThis reminds me of the fan theory that Tom Bombadil is secretly the Witch-King of Angmar: http://www.flyingmoose.org/tolksarc/theories/bombadil.htm http://www.flyingmoose.org/tolksarc/theories/bombadil.htm
- orthoxerox 4y agoBut did Aragorn wear pants?
- ncmncm 4y agoAnd, did ents have knees?
- permo-w 4y agothe first two points really don’t help the credibility of this theory. it does actually get better after that
- outworlder 4y agoThe Witch King would immediately seize the One Ring for himself. Although the notion of a ringwraith singing and dancing is amusing.
- hajile 4y agoAnd is about as faulty. The Witch-king would definitely have been affected after putting on the ring of power (and would have immediately killed them before returning it to Sauron). It is also worth noting that Frodo didn't have his normal nervousness about handing the ring to Bombadil.
- fritztastic 4y agoOk, 2 points: 1. I'm surprised LiveJournal still exists. Genuinely. I used to have one, a loooong time ago. 2. I was always fascinated by Bombadil, he seemed to me like the embodiment of nature itself, or forests. At least, that's the concept he seemed to represent to me. I admit I skipped reading the lyrics though. This is a fascinating theory although it is quite different than what I would conclude from the same evidence.
- HeckFeck 4y agoI recently looked into LJ, it looks to be a better take on social media than many things that came after. Many ancient blogs are still live, documenting daily struggles and ramblings from 2003. It could be written into social history.
- rst 4y agoLJ was bought by some company in Russia years ago -- at which point, there was a very large exodus among Anglophone users (particularly of the LGBTQA community, and their friends). A lot of them went to Dreamwidth, which started with a fork of the LJ codebase, but not enough to make it nearly as vital as LJ used to be.
- nonameiguess 4y agoGeorge Martin was still publishing his blog there until pretty recently, so that forced it to stay in somewhat of the public eye as the only place to get any official updates on when Winds of Winter might finally be published.
- throwaway290 4y agoTLDR + rebuttal combo that also isn't chock full of ads and doesn't break your back button: https://www.reddit.com/r/Fantasy/comments/p3mh4m/comment/h8t09w3 https://www.reddit.com/r/Fantasy/comments/p3mh4m/comment/h8t...
- AndrewDucker 4y agoIf you enjoyed this, you might also enjoy the same writer's take on R2D2 being the central character of Star Wara: https://km-515.livejournal.com/746.html https://km-515.livejournal.com/746.html
- bell-cot 4y agoWOW. Yeah, pretty clear that the article's author likes doing "interesting" / dark / fringe / conspiratorial takes on popular stories. Next up: Little Red Riding Hood was actually a time-traveling deep cover Mossad agent gone rogue.
- sbf501 4y ago> Next up: Little Red Riding Hood was actually a time-traveling deep cover Mossad agent gone rogue. Tell me you wouldn't pay to see this.
- bell-cot 4y agoDepends on how well it was written. I've really enjoyed some of David Brin's crazy-premise stories. ("Thor Meets Captain America", "The River of Time", etc.)
- mealkh 4y agoMissed opportunity for deliberate typo, 'gone rouge'.
- bell-cot 4y ago+1...but actually she acquired her taste for red outfits in the 9th century, while impersonating a Cardinal representing Antipope Anastasius Bibliothecarius ( https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anastasius_Bibliothecarius https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Anastasius_Bibliothecarius ) in Constantinople.
- CRConrad 4y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoodwinked https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hoodwinked! [EDIT:] Highly recommended! [/EDIT]
- DontchaKnowit 4y agoI've always felt that Tom Bombadil was the Jar Jar banks of lord of the rings. Completely pointless character that I love for that exact reason.
- ur-whale 4y agoExcept no one loves jar jar
- yesbabyyes 4y agoBut Jar-Jar was highly consequential, and not pointless at all. He was a delegate to the Senate, and he wanted to make a difference. As such, he took it upon himself to speak to the Senate, to grant Chancellor Palpatine emergency powers. You may argue that anyone else could have done that, but I'm not so sure; it seems like one of those things that many may support, more or less in quiet, but nobody wants to take the initiative, as they are too careful and political to do so. As such, he is the reason for the fall of the Republic and rise of the Empire.
- ncmncm 4y agoJJ is the secret puppetmaster of the whole epic.
- unethical_ban 4y agoI remember reading this several years ago, and I find it to be a plausible theory and pretty terrifying. I know it likely isn't canon and that TB is just a happy entity.
- sudden_dystopia 4y agoThis sets up what could have been a great continuation of the story. A whole new way to look at lotr.
- thekiptxt 4y agoAbout a week ago, I (mid 20s) began reading LoTR for the first time, despite having seen the movies long ago. I knew books are always richer in content than movies, but Tom Bombadil was the first radical departure from the movies that I encountered, and the weird encounter was an exciting switch that made me perceive the story I’m reading as new and different from the story I’ve seen. The group has not yet arrived to Rivendell (so no spoilers please :))
- jdbdisnshsh 4y ago
- hajile 4y agoGiven that you have seen the movies, you may wish to contemplate the prophecy about the death of the Witch-king of Angmar and it's relation to the Barrow Downs. A "chance" meeting of the Wight and a rescue by Bombadil where they (not of the race of men) happen to get magic knives woven with the exact ancient spells capable of undoing the Witch-king. The fate of Gondor relied on this piece of the books that is missing in the movies. Without it, the Witch-king isn't killed and they fall to Sauron's minions.
- em500 4y agoI think the most crucial (and often overlooked) difference between the films and the books is the narrator's perspective. The films are largely shown from a neutral / omniscient narrator's perspective. The books OTOH are mostly written from the perspective of the Hobbits. (The conceit is that the books are adapted from written hobbit lore collected mostly by Bilbo and Frodo[1].) The implication is that there's much more emphasis in the books on what's important and interesting to the Hobbits, as opposed to Men or Elves. In the film, Frodo and Sam are only arguably the main characters, and only because they are the Ringbearer and those that destroy the Ring in the end. But the boook is really Frodo's Own Story. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Book_of_Westmarch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Red_Book_of_Westmarch
- Villodre 4y agoI always loved Bombadil. A discordant note among wizards of great power and elves of slender form and perhaps a metaphor for Nature itself, but I also have enjoyed a lot this take on the character.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- chaostheory 4y agoTom is the oldest in that he’s Tolkien’s oldest fictional creation. Tolkien made him up one day for his children’s bed time story. In this context, it explains why Tom feels so off from Middle Earth. Personally, I like the character and I’m surprised to hear that a lot of people didn’t like him.
- MobiusHorizons 4y ago> And yet no hobbit has ever heard of him. This is just not true. At a minimum farmer maggot is supposed to have known about Tom Bombadil.
- cvoss 4y agoAnd the article even admits as much a few paragraphs later. Just one of many pieces of evidence that this article is not of much value, even as a work of speculative fan fiction.
- jeabo 4y agoIn the Silmarillion, the universe was created by the music of the Ainur. At first it was in line with the mind of Iluvatar (God) but Melkor sang louder and then in discord. Some fans theorize that this discord created Tom Bombadil, along with barrow wrights, Shelob, the watcher of the water, and the ancient creatures that Gandalf saw while chasing the Balrog under Moria.
- vintermann 4y agoThe barrow-wights are undead, things that were once living humans and were buried in the mounds they haunt. They're not primeval beings. Shelob has a canonical origin story, as I recall, as daughter of the primeval spider-shadow thing Ungoliant. The watcher in the water doesn't seem quite spectacular enough to be truly primeval if you ask me, but then again, Bombadil isn't especially flashy either, and we know he is primeval. Maybe it's more relevant that the watcher in the water wasn't always there, it only appeared around the same time as the balrog was dug up. Which sounds pretty un-primeval to me.
- wchar_t 4y agoShelob is not a primordial being. She is one of the children of Ungoliant, who is herself a fallen Ainur.
- eric_cc 4y agoTolkien on Tom in Letter 144: I might put it this way. The story is cast in terms of a good side, and a bad side, beauty against ruthless ugliness, tyranny against kingship, moderated freedom with consent against compulsion that has long lost any object save mere power, and so on; but both sides in some degree, conservative or destructive, want a measure of control. but if you have, as it were taken 'a vow of poverty', renounced control, and take your delight in things for themselves without reference to yourself, watching, observing, and to some extent knowing, then the question of the rights and wrongs of power and control might become utterly meaningless to you, and the means of power quite valueless. It is a natural pacifist view, which always arises in the mind when there is a war. The Letters of J.R.R. Tolkien 144: To Naomi Mitchison. April 1954
- bo1024 4y agoWow!
- hacknat 4y agoThis has always been my understanding of Bombadil as well. The most popular/accepted view of who he is among Tolkien-dom that I've heard is that he represents the lands of the West themselves (or perhaps all of Middle-Earth?). In the Tolkien legendarium power comes from knowing the right names for things and the right words to say to them. Tom Bombadil is the most powerful being in Middle-Earth because he is so old that he knows the proper name for everything and how to address them (he chastises Old Man Willow to release the Hobbits like he is a child). I do want to credit the author of this post with the observation that the rulers of lands in Tolkien's legendarium have influence over how those lands express themselves, but I think this letter is the answer to that. Tom is the exception; he eschews power. One of Gandalf's reasons for saying that they wouldn't want to give the ring to Tom is that he would probably lose the ring, not thinking it very important. Tom only cares of eating and drinking and making merry. In that regard he is a Dionysian figure. If you read the Adventures of Tom Bombadil (which this author surprisingly doesn't reference) he is clearly modeled on the Dionysus cycle of myths.
- mrex 4y ago
- ineedasername 4y agoI always thought of Tom Bombidil as Eru, the creator, or at the very least was taking cues from Eru. Two pieces of evidence: 1) The song he gives, which seemed a positive one, and is not remarked upon as discordant or unpleasant. Eru created through song, and in that choir it was the introduction of disharmony that signified evil. 2) The passage where it's asked "who is he?" The answer is "He is." And then "he is as you have seen him". Tolkien was a religious person, and this passage has always seemed to echo that of the bible where a similar question gets the godly response "I am that I am". This echo always seemed to much to be a coincidence.
- SkyMarshal 4y agoEncyclopedia of Arda has an analysis of that, and concludes he’s not Eru: https://www.glyphweb.com/arda/t/tombombadil.html https://www.glyphweb.com/arda/t/tombombadil.html
- ineedasername 4y agoVery interesting! But I wonder if it might be a bit of misdirection by Tolkein to say "there is no embodiment of the One.." After all he is good Catholic who believed in the Trinity. Still it is strong evidence against == Eru unless Tolkein was playing semantic games.
- ineedasername 4y agoAnd to elaborate: Rather than his surroundings being a symbol of the true Tom, I take this to be Tolkien's allegory of divine intervention, God himself reaching in and tilting the balance slightly, a little nudge while otherwise letting things play out. An extremely rare occurrence both in Tolkien's creation and his own religion, which is why Tom is not more widely known, except by Gandalf who rubs elbows with the Valar when not running around Middle Earth.
- zmgsabst 4y ago> Eru created through song, and in that choir it was the introduction of disharmony that signified evil. I take a different view: Eru knew who Melkor was from the start, and his “disharmony” was part of a broader and richer song — as shown by the duet that led to man and the ultimate downfall of evil lords. The only time Eru spoke to Melkor, he chided him for thinking that a being of his own essence was acting outside his intent or marring the music. If you take the Valar as aspects of Eru, then Melkor is the internal critic that drives genius to greater heights.
- Sporktacular 4y agoI understood Ciridan the Shipwright to be the oldest character but may be wrong.
- valarauko 4y agoCirdan is certainly the oldest elf in Middle Earth during the period of the LotR. Treebeard and the other ents are probably older.
- fmajid 4y agoGandalf, as a Maia, has got to be older than all left in Middle Earth.
- valarauko 4y agoProbably true, though as Gandalf himself refers to Treebeard as old. In Chapter 5 of The Two Towers, Gandalf calls Treebeard "...the oldest living thing that still walks beneath the Sun upon this Middle-earth." In The Return of the King, Chapter 6, "Many Partings", Celeborn addresses Treebeard as "Eldest." If Maia are included, then Sauron and Radagast (if still alive) would be just as old.
- wchar_t 4y agoBarrow-wights are Bombadil's servants? Ridiculous. Tolkien made it clear that they were the spawn of the Witch King, sent out to ensure that no men could settle in that particular area. This is reinforced by the fact that Bombadil himself destroys one of the wights while rescuing the hobbits.
- MattConfluence 4y agoIt's a fun read in a fan-fiction sense, but when you look at the out-of-universe story of the events of Tolkien's life and his writing process it becomes clear that Tom is not meant to be any kind of evil. Tolkien wrote a silly whimsical poem about one of his children's toys that they had named Tom Bombadil. In this tale he lives in a dangerous environment, but he is able to overcome the dangers and get his happy ending. When Tolkien later was writing LotR, he drew upon his former work and put in the silly whimsical Tom as an early encounter for the Hobbits just as they are leaving the Shire and starting their adventure. This story arc delivers some early exposition about the world in his dialogue, it shows that the Hobbits are hopelessly unprepared to stand up against any foe such as Old Man Willow or the Barrow-Wight and need rescue (this way they can have character growth and become Heroes by the time they return to the Shire) and it gets the Hobbits armed for their quest towards Rivendell (and most importantly to put the right kind of blade into Pippin's hands for later). In a more thematic sense he is just part of nature, not evil but also not actively looking to do good, just existing. He is master of his domain in the same sense a big moose might be the "master" of his local forest, he's the biggest around and isn't threatened by anything else, but he has no human desire for expansion and doesn't push back when civilization comes around to turn the land nearby into farmland either, just keeps to himself. He doesn't try to tame the angry trees because it's just protecting it's territory, as is natural, nor does he try to "exorcise" the barrows because nature doesn't actively go about trying to undo the evils created by man.
- TheRealPomax 4y agoIt's interesting that this description is apparently "evil", even if in this framing Tom predates all, and everyone lives on his unceded land. You'd become "particular" about your role after living through several ages of that, too. Rather than evil, it's more "biding their time until that injustice can finally be rectified". In this post's framing, literally every humanoid race is by definition an (unwitting) invader.
- joe_the_user 4y agoThe thing about Tolkien (and I think good story telling in general), is he gives a feeling of consistency, depth and complex choices. But that's completely different from needing fine-grained consistency between chapters of a long book. I'm not a Tolkien expert but I think are a whole variety of "plot holes" one can point to but these don't particularly matter for the development of the story, where the main thing is the suffering and redemption of the main characters which only has to feel real and as well as feeling dramatic. I think Elrond hadn't heard of Tom just because that made the council scene more dramatic, for instance.
- helloworld11 4y agoThe author of this delightful post is very wrong or at least from a very unusual bubble in thinking that Bombadil is disliked by most readers of the Hobbit, but other than that, the narrative of secret evil he constructs is wonderfully compelling, enough to create a whole fascinating story line of its own. I loved it.
- aszantu 4y agotom dongelong geht den pfad hinauf dongelong hebt schöne blume auf steht am straßenrand eine komische baum mit füße drin "eh... stamm!" from german fanfiction, tom bombadil rap, sadly the site went offline a while ago https://www.last.fm/music/www.das-schwarze-ohr.de https://www.last.fm/music/www.das-schwarze-ohr.de looks like someone saved it!
- thriftwy 4y agoMaybe Tom Bombadil is just JRRT himself. Why won't he just live there and know everything without being noticed, other than occassional Deus Ex Machina action?
- martythemaniak 4y agoI like this analysis much better: https://twitter.com/BeijingPalmer/status/1552467596817174529?t=m2XB52yvMOc4jyWtpv7nSg&s=19 https://twitter.com/BeijingPalmer/status/1552467596817174529... Tldr: "So that's what I think Tom is. He's Tolkien's version of what a pagan survival would have looked like in Middle Earth. He doesn't quite fit because he's from the bit of Middle Earth that is England, or a version of England, and from a different set of stories. "
- nu11ptr 4y agoI'm kind of neutral to Tom, while my brother always hated his character. I kind of disliked him on the first read, but became neutral on the 2nd. I think this was because I knew the 2nd time that most people hated him and was waiting for it to hit, but it never really did for me.
- jakzurr 4y agoI enjoyed this quite a bit, thanks for the post. Clever, fun, even if not necessarily accurate analysis and speculation. But, that's just my two cents to add to all the other bikeshedding.
- bambax 4y agoI would not be commenting about how little interest I have in this story, if the website didn't break the back button. The people who do this, what are they thinking? That we will never leave, and keep watching their webpage until we die? Tolkien is overrated, but this... this is useless and annoying.
- percentcer 4y agoOld Tom Bombadil is a merry fellow.
- stakkur 4y agoIt's always odd when someone picks apart a work of fiction with the tools of realism. It tells me they either have too much time on their hands, or they have missed the entire point of stories.
- ngvrnd 4y agoThis is a wonderful spin; the author says that they don't believe Tolkien intended this. But it's a fun thing to think about.
- TheMagicHorsey 4y agoThis is a strange, and Lovecraftian take on Bombadil. I always thought he really was just a jolly fat guy out in the woods. Kind of like a Middle Earth version of one of those potbellied rednecks you see laughing on a small fishing boat, surrounded by a pile of empty beer cans, who waves at you and asks you if you want a cold one, before turning back to the Skynnard blaring from the ancient boombox on their ice cooler.
- Jenz 4y agoThe author of this has clearly not read much of Tolkien's legendarium beoynd the LoTR... This is a whole lot of speculation that does not at all fit into Eä, the World that is. Though indeed one might say the same of Bombadil, it is far from clear what role he has to play in Arda, and Tolkien took his cosmology very seriously, so there is every reason to think this mystery of who the hell is Tom Bombadil? is intentional. But the reasonings of this article is exactly those of conspiracy theorists, not those of any serious Tolkien scholar. Seemingly relying on “No hobbit has ever heard of him,” “Elrond, the greatest lore-master of the Third Age, has never heard of Tom Bombadil” as implicitly implying “therefore there must be some great dark secret,” Gandalf's explanations he simply dismisses as not “the true one.” Tolkien was a philologist, familiar with and directly inspired by many different mythologies, for example Väinämöinen, a hero and demigod of songs and poetry from finnish folklore has been pointed out as a possible inspiration for Bombadil. Though from his close connection to nature one would rather expect him to be a sort of demiurge than a hero, neither evil nor good, and indeed as opposed to Väinämöinen whose adventuring is due to his seeking a wife, Tom has a wife and makes a big point out of this, he is content, and has no desire for evil. If I may continue my rant I'll add that the very creation of Arda is by music, taught by Eru Ilúvatar, the One, to the Ainur. There is little doubt that Bombadil is among the Ainur, one of the Maia on par with Gandalf and Sauron. It seems entirely plausible to me, that Bombadil indeed is as he says, the oldest, of special significance to Ilúvatar, prior to Arda and whatever may be happening in it. I'll also add that I have never heard of any Tolkien enthusiast not liking Bombadil before this. I suspect the author of this article is among the minority who thinks that abruptly breaking into song is lame, mistakenly of course, hehe.
- justin66 4y ago> There is little doubt that Bombadil is among the Ainur, one of the Maia on par with Gandalf and Sauron. Tom Bombadil is the slacker version of Melian the Maia. Instead of marrying Elvish royalty and running an enchanted kingdom, he shacked up with an orphan and runs a nature park full of angry, semi-sentient trees. He could do a lot more if he really applied himself.
- katla 4y agoIn before the trilogy of Bombadils Bombastic Bamboozle drops.
- tablespoon 4y agoThis particular article may be old, but by now I'm kind of tired of the "forced reinterpretation of X as sinister and evil" trope.
- kbelder 4y agoAnd its cousin, the "forced reinterpretation of villain Y as misunderstood and justified".
- bitwize 4y agoObligatory: https://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/unused-audio-commentary-by-howard-zinn-and-noam-chomsky-recorded-summer-2002-for-the-fellowship-of-the-ring-platinum-series-extended-edition-dvd-part-one https://www.mcsweeneys.net/articles/unused-audio-commentary-...
- qrush 4y agoIf you haven't discovered it yet: Andy Serkis narrated audiobooks for the Hobbit and the entire LoTR trilogy, and it's a joy. His voice and singing for Tom Bombadil is stuck in my head forever now!
- jonnycomputer 4y agoWhat a load of crap. >And yet no hobbit has ever heard of him. Farmer Maggot knows him. > Possibly the least liked character in The Lord of the Rings. A childish figure so disliked by fans of the book that few object to his absence from all adaptations of the story. Nonsense. On all counts. I won't even go on from here. Ugh.
- kpgraham 4y agoI always felt that Tom Bombadil was filler in order to bridge events between Crick Hollow and the Prancing Pony. Tolkien had already written The Adventures of Tom Bombadil as a separate piece with Goldberry and Old Man Willow. He just dropped that into the Fellowship and used it to fill the space. I used to skip the Tom section and move right up to Bree. Now I read the books much slower, and I savor every section, even Tom.
- UberFly 4y agoThat was a fantastically written speculation, and showcases the fertile ground that Tolkien created.
- rendall 4y ago> A childish figure so disliked by fans of the book that few object to his absence from all adaptations of the story. No way! I love the character, and would love to see him adapted. In a way, that he is so low priority kind of underscores what is so great about him.
- netmonk 4y agoTom is the most important character of this masterpiece. Only a few knows. All other dissing Tom are just posing and not real fan.