5 ms·
A much better article on Anandtech [1]. Dual Stack 116 Layers. And as noted inside the article 100+ layer per stack isn't exactly new. Personally I am interest
by ksec 4y ago
A much better article on Anandtech [1]. Dual Stack 116 Layers. And as noted inside the article 100+ layer per stack isn't exactly new.
Personally I am interested in Cost per Bit reduction. Hopefully there will be news in Flash Memory Summit new week. I wouldn't mind to have a slow 100 write cycle NAND that cost a third of today's price. Think 2TB USB Stick for $49.
[1] https://www.anandtech.com/show/17509/microns-232-layer-nand-now-shipping https://www.anandtech.com/show/17509/microns-232-layer-nand-...
- dtgriscom 4y agoI suspect it would be difficult to properly balance writing across blocks with only 100 cycles before wearout.
- Zandikar 4y agoDepends. If you're trying to use it as a drop in replacement for a Scratch/Boot/Database drive, sure. That'd probably not be a good plan. But if you consider HDD's are primarily deployed in WORM or WFRM (Write Few, Read Many) work loads these days, a 100 P/E cycle NAND flash that has comparable $/TB value to spinning disk could definitely have a viable market. It'd be kinda like Flashes version of Shingled HDD's. Got be a bit more careful with their usecase, can't just drop them in whereever and expect it all to work fine, but as long as you use them in WORM/WFRM, they'd be excellent for greater physical data density and far superior power efficiency.
- TapamN 4y agoFor some kind of write once archival storage, it would probably still have a use. But with flash that fragile, I'd be worried about how sensitive to read disturb it would be.
- tlamponi 4y ago> And as noted inside the article 100+ layer per stack isn't exactly new. Per deck, not stack. The current prevalent 176 (total) Layer consists also of two 88 Layer decks, as the same article mentions (check the table) so 116 layers per deck is new!
- Zandikar 4y agoThat would be a death knell for hard drives if they could actually get it that cheap (~$25/TB). In addition to obvious benefits for consumers, More and more in the enterprise space (which is the dominant buyer of HDD unit purchase volume) HDD's are being regulated to write few, read lots if not outright WORM, and focused on Sequential speeds. You can knock an order of magnitude of speed off modern NAND Flash and still compete with spinning disks on sequential speed and have a few more orders of magnitude to shave off of Random I/O. It wouldn't kill HDD's overnight, but it would definitely give them a definitive terminal diagnosis. I would love that. I doubt that's what they're doing, but I would love that.
- Dylan16807 4y agoThat depends on how much those supposed 50TB hard drives cost in four years. Though even if hard drive prices stay completely stagnant at $14/TB during sales, I'd still get a hard drive for videos and backups rather than pay $25.
- Zandikar 4y ago> I'd still get a hard drive for videos and backups rather than pay $25. So would everyone who's only motivation for buying storage is $/TB and nothing else. The vast majority of those people think 8 or even 80TB is alot and are pefectly happy with subpar drives being packaged in external usb enclosures. And there's nothing wrong with that, but that demographic of consumers is not the driving economic force in what gets developed, invested in, and brought to market. HDD's ~$15/TB bargain values wont be sustainable if Enterprise drops HDD's for WORM/WFRM workloads because their TCO is too high (and many are). Disk shelves chew through Kilowatts like candy while capacious focused flash hosts seem comparatively allergic to electricity, and repairing/rebulding arrays on spinning rust compared to flash arrays alone is impetus enough for a lot of shops to dump rust and embrace solid state. > That depends on how much those supposed 50TB hard drives cost in four years. For sure. I'm highly skeptical they can pull that off in that time frame though. the pace of innovation in the HDD space is woefully lacking. They need a win like that, with competitive pricing, or the industries days are numbered. If they can pull it off though that's great. I'm all for cheaper/better storage options, even if it's mechanical (or optical or whatever).
- Dylan16807 4y agoWhat manufacturing changes do you imagine would make that possible? Making cells smaller gets unusable pretty quickly, and adding more bits to TLC/QLC is a mild price improvement at best. Prices will go down over time as manufacturing improves, but if you're waiting for that then you don't need to sacrifice speed and durability.
- ksec 4y ago>Prices will go down over time as manufacturing improves That is not always true though. If we look at DRAM. There is a reason why we are still stuck with 8GB DRAM as entry level while 99.99999% of tech community including HN has been stating DRAM is cheap and it is only going to be cheaper for more than a decade. The cost to produce DRAM has only dropped 10-20% over the past decade, while pricing fluctuate a lot as with any commodity. Microsoft knew this way back in 2006 ( or even earlier ) when they were designing Xbox. >What manufacturing changes do you imagine would make that possible? AFAIK, Not any time soon. You could probably read up on all the issues on thememoryguy [1] or SemiEngineering [2]. But even PLC wouldn't bring that much cost savings, if there are any. There is nothing on the roadmap for the next 5 years. Not even in R&D Labs which suggest it may not even happen in 2030. That is why I am hopping for some news, some progress like [3]. [1] https://thememoryguy.com/how-3d-nand-makes-qlc-and-plc-feasible/ https://thememoryguy.com/how-3d-nand-makes-qlc-and-plc-feasi... [2] https://semiengineering.com https://semiengineering.com [3] https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9830513 https://ieeexplore.ieee.org/document/9830513
- Klinky 4y agoDRAM markets have been notoriously price fixed in the past[1], and it would not be surprising if there's still a lot of winking, nudging, and backdoor handshakes going on. The chip shortage makes it even more excusable now. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DRAM_price_fixing_scandal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DRAM_price_fixing_scandal
- jeffbee 4y agoThe main reason the price of DRAM is not plunging is because DRAM faces stark physics problems. I don’t think it’s market failure.
- Melatonic 4y agoI am really interested long term in longevity. I am sure they will keep increasing speeds and decreasing prices but what about this stuff wearing out? NAND that can last for as long as a well cooled and unstressed CPU would be epic!
- kmeisthax 4y agoNAND wear is a function of write cycles, which itself is a function of both how much data you write and how much the controller's wear-levelling and garbage collection amplifies those writes. If your benchmark is "lasting as long as well-cooled electronics" then flash already beats hard drives; since hard drives have bearings that will lose lubrication and fail until you open the drive up in a clean room and replace them.
- mgerdts 4y agoAnd NAND has an electrical charge that will dissipate, eventually leading to data loss. This time period is on the order of 90 days (I think I’ve seen some data sheets saying 30 days) up to one year. https://www.jedec.org/sites/default/files/Alvin_Cox%20%5BCompatibility%20Mode%5D_0.pdf https://www.jedec.org/sites/default/files/Alvin_Cox%20%5BCom... https://www.ibm.com/support/pages/potential-ssd-data-loss-after-extended-shutdown https://www.ibm.com/support/pages/potential-ssd-data-loss-af... The OCP NVMe Cloud SSD Specification states that drives must not have data loss when powered off for up to 30 days and that when powered on data must me rewritten to refresh data that may have started to lose charge while powered off. Search for retention in: https://www.opencompute.org/documents/nvme-cloud-ssd-specification-v1-0-3-pdf https://www.opencompute.org/documents/nvme-cloud-ssd-specifi...
- xyzzy123 4y agoYour overall point is valid (there are lifetime constraints that mean you shouldn't rely on unpowered SSDs for long term archiving) but IMHO your post is overly pessimistic. The spec is 1 year minimum for client and 3mo for server, but most drives exceed that. This thread includes a response from a Micron rep: https://community.spiceworks.com/topic/944779-enterprise-ssds-powered-off-potentially-lose-data-in-a-week https://community.spiceworks.com/topic/944779-enterprise-ssd... "The very most important thing to realize when looking at these charts is that the data retention number stated are for SSDs which have reached the end of their useful life. They're worn out. If you have an enterprise-class SSD which is rated for 5 petabytes of writes over its lifetime (just to pick a typical number) , then you will not see this 3 month data retention number until you've actually written 5 petabytes to the drive. When NAND Flash is brand new out of the box, the data retention is actually several years (although we typically don't rate data retention when new). Honestly, Flash-based storage probably isn't optimal for unpowered archiving. That three-month, EOL spec reflects this. In enterprise computing, when the NAND lifetime is used up, the intent should be to move any important data to a new device (or wipe the old device for security reasons). In client computing (notebooks and desktops), we rarely see the typical user getting to the point where NAND wearout is a concern, so we rarely see data retention as an issue, either. So, you needn't be concerned about data retention until your SSD gets really, really old."