28 ms·
DALL·E now available in beta
- AndrianV 4y agoEvery day for the past week or so, I've spent an hour or so using DALL-E, making up new combos and making my pals laugh. In the same way that you can't get bored of art or visual stimulation, you can't get bored of this either.
- bulbosaur123 4y ago
- hhmc 4y agoSo you actually _wanted_ images that perpetuate the biases of the world?
- illwrks 4y agoI thought the same thing but I think the commenter is making a joke, but I could be wrong. I think they are suggesting that things like this (neural nets etc) work using bias, and by removing "bias" the developers are making the product worse. It's a very sh!t comment if it's not a joke.
- Geonode 4y agoReducing bias means affecting the data, instead of letting the end user just choose an appropriate image generated by a clean data set.
- minimaxir 4y agoUnfortunately, the method OpenAI may be using to reduce bias (by adding words to the prompt unknown to the user) is a naive approach that can affect images unexpectedly and outside of the domain OpenAI intended: https://twitter.com/rzhang88/status/1549472829304741888 https://twitter.com/rzhang88/status/1549472829304741888 I have also seeing some cases where the bias correction may not be working at all, so who knows. And it's why transparancy is important.
- kmeisthax 4y agoThis sounds like something that could backfire very badly on certain prompts. "person eating a watermelon" for example.
- CobrastanJorji 4y agoWhat a fascinating hack. I mean, yeah, naive and simplistic and doesn't really do anything interesting with the model itself, but props to the person who was given the "make this more diverse" instruction and said "okay, what's the simplest thing that could possibly work? What if I just append some races and genders onto the end of the query string, would that mostly work?" and then it did! Was it a GOOD idea? Maybe not. But I appreciate the optimization.
- scifibestfi 4y agoHow do you remove bias as long as humans are in the loop? Aren't they just swapping one bias for their own?
- bulbosaur123 4y agoYes, I did. I want it to show world as it is not as people want it to be.
- hhmc 4y agoSo you want the world to be the way it is?
- bulbosaur123 4y agoReread what I said: I WANT THE DALLE GENERATOR TO SHOW THE WORLD AS IT IS NOT AS PEOPLE WISH IT WAS.
- hhmc 4y agoReread what I said, try engaging more of your brain this time.
- brycethornton 4y agoI'm blown away by this: "Starting today, users get full usage rights to commercialize the images they create with DALL·E, including the right to reprint, sell, and merchandise. This includes images they generated during the research preview." I assumed this was going to be the sticking point for wider usage for a long time. They're now saying that you have full rights to sell Dall-E 2 creations?
- minimaxir 4y agoPreviously, OpenAI asserted they owned the generated images, so the new licensing is a shift in that aspect. GPT-3 also has a "you own the content" clause as well. Of course, that clause won't deter a third party from filing a lawsuit against you if you commercialize a generated image too close to something realistic, as the copyrights of AI generated content still hasn't been legally tested.
- pornel 4y agoAFAIK only people can own copyright (the monkey selfie case tested this), and machine-generated outputs don't count as creative work (you can't write an algorithm that generates every permutation of notes and claim you own every song[1]), so DALL-E-generated images are most likely copyright-free. I presume OpenAI only relies on terms of service to dictate what users are allowed to do, but they can't own the images, and neither can their users. [1]: https://felixreda.eu/2021/07/github-copilot-is-not-infringing-your-copyright/ https://felixreda.eu/2021/07/github-copilot-is-not-infringin...
- TaylorAlexander 4y agoThe monkey selfie was not derived from millions of existing works, and that is the difference. If an artist has a well-known art style, and this algorithm was trained on it and can copy that style, would the artist have grounds to sue? I don't know.
- ZetaZero 4y ago
- ccmcarey 4y agoThat's about 10x as expensive as it should be
- karencarits 4y ago$15 for 115 iterations/460 images?
- ccmcarey 4y agoYep. During the alpha it was (50*6) 300 images per day, by their pricing model that would be $300 a month now
- WalterSear 4y ago$15 for 115 attempts to get usable images.
- gverri 4y ago$0.13/prompt can only be useful for artists/end users. Anyone thinking about using this at scale would need a 20/30x reduction in price. But there's still no API available so I think that will change with time. Maybe they will add different tiers based on volume.
- jeanlucas 4y agoThing is, as a current user: you rarely get it right in the first prompt, you can iterate 10 times until you get what you want. I spent several tries yesterday to get this angle "from the ground up": https://labs.openai.com/s/mz8LiyvkI8KwD2luJ6MrS23m https://labs.openai.com/s/mz8LiyvkI8KwD2luJ6MrS23m
- dntrkv 4y agoSo $1.30 for getting a result that would have cost how much to pay someone to make? Not to mention the 59 other variations you would have.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- skilled 4y agoI can’t check right now but this mean the watermark is also gone and images will have a higher resolution?
- gverri 4y agoWatermarks are still there and resolution still 1024x1024.
- skilled 4y agoI wonder if they have plans to allow SVG exports in the future. I mean, the file size would probably be ridiculous in a lot of the cases, but for my use case I wouldn't mind it. And sucks about the watermark, maybe they will introduce an option to pay for removing it.
- rahimnathwani 4y agoSVG exports would only be meaningful if the model is generating vector images, which are then converted to bitmaps. I highly doubt that's the case, but perhaps someone who has actually looked at the model structure can confirm?
- tiagod 4y agoIt's just pixels. You can pass them into a tracer
- moyix 4y agoSVG isn't really possible with the model architecture they're using. The diffusion+upscaling step basically outputs 1024x1024 pixels; at no point does the model have a vector representation. I suppose it's possible that at some point they'll try to make an image -> svg translation model?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- jawns 4y agoOne of the commercial use cases this post mentions is authors who want to add illustrations to children's stories. I wonder if there is a way for DALL-E to generate a character, then persist that character over subsequent runs. Otherwise, it would be pretty difficult to generate illustrations that depict a coherent story. Example ... Image 1 prompt: A character named Boop, a green alien with three arms, climbs out of its spaceship. Image 2 prompt: Boop meets a group of three children and shakes hands with each one.
- minimaxir 4y agoYou can cheat this to a limited extent using inpainting.
- rahimnathwani 4y agoYou mean just generate a single large image with all the stuff you want for the whole story, and then use cropping and inpainting to get only the piece you want for each page?
- TaupeRanger 4y agoYou can't do that. I can't see this working well for children's book illustrations unless the story was specifically tailored in a way that makes continuity of style and characters irrelevant.
- WalterSear 4y agoI would expect continuuity to be a relatively simple feature to retrain for and implement.
- CobrastanJorji 4y agoAs an aside, Ursula Vernon did pretty well under the constraint you described. She set a comic in a dreamscape and used AI to generate most of the background imagery: https://twitter.com/UrsulaV/status/1467652391059214337 https://twitter.com/UrsulaV/status/1467652391059214337 It's not the "specify the character positions in text" proposed, but still a neat take on using this sort of AI for art.
- pawelduda 4y agoThat's disappointing given up until this point you could have 50 free uses per 24h. I expected it to get monetized eventually, but not so fast and drastically. Well, still had my fun and have to say the creations are so good it's often mind blowing there's an AI behind it.
- dougmwne 4y agoHonestly, it is probably just that expensive to run. You can’t expect someone to hand you free compute of significant value and directly charging for it is a lot better than other things they could do.
- mysore 4y agothey're a non-profit so the price is probably still dirt cheap
- ajafari1 4y agoNot correct. They have a for-profit entity now. That's why there is a huge incentive to monetize. Any for-profit investment gain is capped at 100x, with the rest required to go to their nonprofit. This commercialization is just as I predicted in my substack post 2 days ago that hit the front page of Hacker News: https://aifuture.substack.com/p/the-ai-battle-rages-on https://aifuture.substack.com/p/the-ai-battle-rages-on
- rvz 4y ago> Starting today, users get full usage rights to commercialize the images they create with DALL·E, including the right to reprint, sell, and merchandise. This includes images they generated during the research preview. So DALL·E 2 is going to restart, revive and cause another renaissance of fully automated and mass generated NFTs, full of derivatives and remixing etc to pump up the crypto NFT hype squad? Either way, OpenAI wins again as these crypto companies are going to pour tens of thousands of generated images to pump their NFT griftopia off of life support, reconfirming that it isn't going to die that easily. Regardless of this possible revival attempt, 90% of these JPEG NFTs will eventually still die.
- Bud 4y agoI don't see why there's any credible reason to expect that DALL-E will do anything at all to help those promoting the NFT silliness. Two separate issues.
- mdanger007 4y agoIf OpenAI could make a profit selling Dall-E images as NFT, I'd assume they'd do it, yeah?
- Melting_Harps 4y agoAltman tried his hand at that by launching Worldcoin, and it didn't go well at all. So I think it's prudent that OpenAI keep the 'sell shovels' business model instead with DALLE and GPT, at least for the time being.
- randomperson_24 4y agoI have tried playing around with the beta access to make it generate NFT art with different prompts, but in vail. I think it has not been trained on NFT art (crypto punks and so on).
- Melting_Harps 4y ago> I think it has not been trained on NFT art (crypto punks and so on). How exactly are you defining NFT art? I mean, it can literately be anything: Dorsey sold a screencap of his 1st tweet, Nadya from Pussy Riot did some creative stuff, and the Ape crap was the bulk of this stuff that got passed around. I think what can be gleaned from that short-lived non-sense is that value is subjective and that the quality of a valuabe piece of 'art' is equally as hard to define. Much the same with its predecessor: cryptokitties.
- TekMol 4y agoI wonder how fast they will invite the 1 million users? I have been on the waitlist for a while and did not get access yet. Did anybody get access already today?
- deviner 4y agonope, I've been for quite some time too
- nharada 4y agoSomething I haven’t seen anyone talking about with these huge models: how do future models get trained when more content online is model generated to start with? Presumably you don’t wanna train a model on autogenerated images or text, but you can’t necessarily know which is which.
- cpach 4y agoMakes me think of Ouroboros https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouroboros https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ouroboros
- nharada 4y agoReminds me of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-background_steel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Low-background_steel
- espadrine 4y agoIn this situation, the low-background steel is the MS-COCO dataset, associated with the Fréchet inception distance computed by comparing the statistical divergence between the high-level vector outputs of passing MS-COCO images through Google’s InceptionV3 classifier, and passing DALL-E images (or its competitors) through it. For now at least, there is a detectable difference in variety.
- zitterbewegung 4y agoThis should be a step in cleaning your data to begin with. If you don't know the providence of your data then you shouldn't be even training with it. Getting humans to refine your data is the best solution right now and many companies and researches go with this approach.
- nharada 4y agoBut how would you know? A random string of text or an image with the watermark removed is going to be very hard to distinguish generated from human written.
- dharbin 4y agoI find it amusing that they suggest DALL-E, which typically generates lovecraftian nightmare images, for making children's story illustrations.
- driverdan 4y agoHow so? If you give it prompts for children story illustrations with a detailed description it will not give you "lovecraftian nightmare images".
- throwaway0x7E6 4y agoyeah. dalle is "so bad it's good". it's great for post-post-ironic memes, but I don't see it being useful for anything else
- arkitaip 4y agoNo wireless. Less space than a nomad. Lame.
- andybak 4y agoHave you tried any of the "human or Dall-E" tests? How did you score? I only scored as well as I did because I knew the kind of stylistic choices to look out for. In terms of "quality" I really don't understand how you've reached this conclusion.
- throwaway0x7E6 4y agoI've only seen this thing https://huggingface.co/spaces/dalle-mini/dalle-mini https://huggingface.co/spaces/dalle-mini/dalle-mini is it not dall-e?
- andybak 4y agoIt's a reimplementation. It's a long way off in terms of quality (at the moment anyway)
- cypress66 4y ago> Reducing bias: We implemented a new technique so that DALL·E generates images of people that more accurately reflect the diversity of the world’s population. This technique is applied at the system level when DALL·E is given a prompt about an individual that does not specify race or gender, like “CEO.” Will it do it "more accurately" as they claim? As in, if 90% of CEOs are male, then the odds of a CEO being male in a picture is 90%? Or less "accurately reflect the diversity of the world’s population" and show what they would like the real world to be like?
- scifibestfi 4y agoThe latter. Here's what we, a small number of people, think the world should look like according to our own biases and information bubble in the current moment. We will impose our biases upon you, the unenlightened masses who must be manipulated for your own good. And for god sakes, don't look for photos of the US Math team or NBA Basketball or compare soccer teams across different countries and cultures.
- bequanna 4y ago> Here's what we, a small number of people, think the world should look like according to our own biases and information bubble in the current moment. You're being quite charitable. It is much more likely that optics and virtue signaling is behind this addition.
- erikpukinskis 4y agoIf I search for “food” I don’t want to see a slice of pizza every time, even if that’s the #1 food. I want to see some variety. I think you’re jumping to quickly to bad intentions. Injecting diversity of results is a sane thing to do, totally irrespective of politics.
- jlawson 4y agoYou are correct but that's not what anyone's discussing. If I search for "food", the reasonable result would be to get images that represent food according to its actual proportions of real life. E.g. if Pizza is the most common food at 10% prevalence, 10% of the images should be pizza. That's not what OpenAI are doing. They are introducing crafted biases to create images that deliberately misrepresent what the world looks like, and instead represent what they believe the world ought to look like. -- You also need some reason why diversity "of this" is important but not diversity "of that". Why is diversity of race and sex so critical, but not diversity of age, height, disability? Should a search for "basketball player" yield 1/2 able-bodied people and 1/2 wheelchair basketball players? Why? Then try to answer where you came up with the categories you do want depicted. Why are the races what they are? Should "basketball player" include half whites and half black people? Or maybe split in 3, white/black/Asian? Why not Australian Aborigines, native Americans, or Persians - so we can divide into 6? If you don't add Indian people to your list then, is that racist against them? How did you decide what must be represented, in what proportions, and what's okay to leave out?
- NaughtyShiba 4y agoSlightly offtopic, but how one would report false-positive check in content policy check?
- modeless 4y agoIt's laughably primitive. Tried to upload "The Creation of Adam", policy violation. Tried to make an image in "yarn bombing" style, policy violation. The Scunthorpe problem is too hard for cutting edge AI to tackle, I guess.
- c0decracker 4y agoInteresting. I got access couple weeks ago (was on waitlist since the initial announcement) and frankly as much as really want to be excited and like it, DALL-E ended up being a bit underwhelming. IMHO - often results that produced are of low quality (distorted images, or quite wacky representation of the query). Some styles of imagery are certainly a better fit for being generated by DALL-E, but as far as commercial usage I think it needs a few iterations and probably even larger underlying model.
- andybak 4y agoI also got access a couple of weeks ago and I can't fathom how anyone could be underwhelmed by it. What were you expecting?
- harpersealtako 4y agoDalle seems to only have a few "styles" of drawing that it is actually "good" at. It is particularly strong at these styles but disappointingly underwhelming at anything else, and will actively fight you and morph your prompt into one of these styles even when given an inpainting example of exactly what you want. It's great at photorealistic images like this: https://labs.openai.com/s/0MFuSC1AsZcwaafD3r0nuJTT https://labs.openai.com/s/0MFuSC1AsZcwaafD3r0nuJTT, but it's intentionally lobotomized to be bad at faces, and often has an uncanny valley feel in general, like this: https://labs.openai.com/s/t1iBu9G6vRqkx5KLBGnIQDrp https://labs.openai.com/s/t1iBu9G6vRqkx5KLBGnIQDrp (never mind that it's also lobotomized to be unable to recognize characters in general). It's basically as close to perfect as an AI can be at generating dogs and cats though, but anything else will be "off" in some meaningful ways. It has a particular sort of blurry, amateur oil painting digital art style it often tries to use for any colorful drawings, like this: https://labs.openai.com/s/EYsKUFR5GvooTSP5VjDuvii2 https://labs.openai.com/s/EYsKUFR5GvooTSP5VjDuvii2 or this: https://labs.openai.com/s/xBAJm1J8hjidvnhjEosesMZL https://labs.openai.com/s/xBAJm1J8hjidvnhjEosesMZL . You can see the exact problem in the second one with inpainting: it utterly fails at the "clean" digital art style, or drawing anything with any level of fine detail, or matching any sort of vector art or line art (e.g. anime/manga style) without loads of ugly, distracting visual artifacts. Even Craiyon and DALLE-mini outperform it on this. I've tried over 100 prompts to get stuff like that to generate and have not had a single prompt that is able to generate anything even remotely good in that style yet. It seems almost like it has a "resolution" of detail for non-photographic images, and any detail below a certain resolution just becomes a blobby, grainy brush stroke, e.g. this one: https://labs.openai.com/s/jtvRjiIZRsAU1ukofUvHiFhX https://labs.openai.com/s/jtvRjiIZRsAU1ukofUvHiFhX , the "fairies" become vague colored blobs here. It can generate some pretty ok art in very specific styles, e.g. classical landscape paintings: https://labs.openai.com/s/6rY7AF7fWPb5wWiSH0rAG0Rm https://labs.openai.com/s/6rY7AF7fWPb5wWiSH0rAG0Rm , but for anything other than this generic style it disappoints hard. The other style it is ok at is garish corporate clip art, which is unremarkable and there's already more than enough clip art out there for the next 1000 years of our collective needs -- it is nevertheless somewhat annoying when it occasionally wastes a prompt generating that crap because you weren't specific that you wanted "good" images of the thing you were asking for. The more I use DALLE-2 the more I just get depressed at how much wasted potential it has. It's incredibly obvious they trimmed a huge amount of quality data and sources from their databases for "safety" reasons, and this had huge effects on the actual quality of the outputs in all but the most mundane of prompts. I've got a bunch more examples of trying to get it to generate the kind of art I want (cute anime art, is that too much to ask for?) and watching it fail utterly every single time. The saddest part is when you can see it's got some incredible glimpse of inspiration or creative genius, but just doesn't have the ability to actually follow through with it.
- bemmu 4y agoI was supposed to be making a video game, but got a bit sidetracked when DALL·E came out and made this website on the side: http://dailywrong.com/ http://dailywrong.com/ (yes I should get SSL). It's like The Onion, but all the articles are made with GPT-3 and DALL·E. I start with an interesting DALL·E image, then describe it to GPT-3 and ask it for an Onion-like article on the topic. The results are surprisingly good.
- jelliclesfarm 4y agoLove it! Better than other news I get to read these days. Some of it rings..like the bluebird suing the cat. Thank you! Bookmarked!
- aantix 4y agoParenting > "Gillette Releases a New Razor for Babies"
- bemmu 4y agoI loved how it just consistently decided that if babies have facial hair, it's always white fluff.
- lancesells 4y agoI think it's because it's using images of babies with soap on their face to learn. Still funny though!
- busyant 4y agoThis is clever. Does GPT-3 come up with the title of the article, too? That's the funniest part.
- bemmu 4y agoAt first I came up with them myself, but found that it often comes up with better ones, so I ask it for variations. I think I got it to even fill the title given a picture, something like “Article picture caption: Man holding an apple. Article title: ...”. Might experiment more with that in the future.
- lagrange77 4y agoHas anyone else had problems with the 'Generate Variations' functions lately? Tried it out first 3 days ago, and it says 'Something went wrong. Please try again later, or contact support@openai.com if this is an ongoing problem.' everytime since then.
- jeanlucas 4y agoHmmm DALL·E was a struggling sometimes, you can always keep check on Discord, they keep us informed there.
- tourist_on_road 4y agoSuper impressive to see how OpenAI managed to bring the project from research to production (something usable for creatives). This is non trivial since the usecase involves filtering NSFW content, reducing bias in generated images. Kudos to the entire team.
- aledalgrande 4y agoI wonder at this price point which kind of business can use DALL E at scale?
- xnx 4y agoI fully expect stock image sites to be swamped by DALL-E generated images that match popular terms (e.g. "business person shaking hands"). Generate the image for $0.15. Sell it for $1.00.
- dymk 4y agoThey'll likely immediately go out of business, because I can just pay OpenAI 15 cents directly for the exact same product.
- dylanlacom 4y agoEh, I’d bet the arbitrage window is pretty brief, and that prices will fall closer to $0.15 pretty quickly.
- redox99 4y agoDALL-E 2 isn't good enough for such photorealistic pictures with humans as of yet however.
- bpicolo 4y agohttps://twitter.com/TobiasCornille/status/1549729060397453312/photo/1 https://twitter.com/TobiasCornille/status/154972906039745331... Unless I'm missing something, these seem pretty darn good
- zerocrates 4y agoWoof, that bias "solution" that that thread is actually about though...!
- arecurrence 4y agoThere has been trouble with generating life-like eyes but a second pass with a model tuned around making realistic faces has been very successful at fixing that.
- thorum 4y agoDALLE images are still only 1024 px wide. Which has its uses, but I don’t think the stock photo industry is in real danger until someone figures out a better AI superresolution system that can produce larger and more detailed images.
- anewpersonality 4y agoFeel sorry for the full time artists.
- danielvf 4y agoI am thrilled about DALL-E, and the new terms of service. However, how they implemented the improved "diversity" is hilarious. Turns out that they randomly, silently modify your prompt text to append words like "black male" or "female". See https://twitter.com/jd_pressman/status/1549523790060605440 https://twitter.com/jd_pressman/status/1549523790060605440 I don't know which emotion I feel more - applause at how glorious this hack is or tears at how ugly it is. Good luck to them!
- mysore 4y agoit's a hard problem. at least they tried.
- protonbob 4y agoHonestly I would rather that they not try. I don't understand why a computer tool has to be held to a political standard.
- daemoens 4y agoIt's not a political standard though. There is actual diversity in this world. Why wouldn't you want that in your product?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mensetmanusman 4y agoFix the data input side, not the data output side. The data input side is slowly being fixed in real time as the rest of the world gets online and learns these methods.
- astrange 4y agoThat wouldn't necessarily fix the issue or do anything. A model isn't a perfect average of all the data you throw into its training set. You have to actually try these things and see if they work.
- DecayingOrganic 4y agoSince many people will start generating their first images soon, be sure to check out this amazing DALL-E prompt engineering book [0]. It will help you get the most out of DALL-E. [0]: https://dallery.gallery/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/The-DALL%C2%B7E-2-prompt-book-v1.01.pdf https://dallery.gallery/wp-content/uploads/2022/07/The-DALL%... (PDF)
- uplifter 4y agoThanks for this! A bit of prompt engineering know-how will help me get the most bang for the buck out of this beta. I also just want to say that dallery.gallery is delightfully clever naming.
- ZeWaka 4y agoThis is absolutely amazing. Thanks!
- ru552 4y agonice write up, thanks
- samstave 4y agoAMAZING, Thank you. I hope that every science teacher that can - provide this to every student. This is the future they live in now. They should know these as well as they know how to install an app on a device. Wait until we have a DALL-E -- Enabled Custom EMOJI stream - whereby, every text you send out has it corresponding DALL-E resultant image for every txt -- Then we can compare images from different people at different times but the prompt was identical... and see what the resultant library of emoji<-->PROMPT looks like? What about using Dall-e as a watermark for 'nft' signature 'notary' of an email. If DALL-E provided a unique PID# for every image - and that PID was a key that only the OP runner of the image has - it can be used to authenticate an image to a text source... ??? (Assuming that no two prompts have the same result ever, but assigning a unique id that CAN be used to replay the image to verify it was generated when an original email/SMS was actually sent - it could be a unique way to timestamp authenticity/provenance of a thing...
- alexalx666 4y ago
- draw_down 4y ago
- totetsu 4y agoI was really enjoying using Dalle2 to take surrealist walks around the latent image space of human cultural production. I was using it as one might use Wikipedia researching the links between objects and their representation. Also just to generate suggestion for what to have for lunch. None of this was for anything of commercial value to me. What am I to do now, start to find ways to sell the images I'm outputting? Do I displace the freelance artists in the market who actually have real talent and ability to create images and compositions and who studied how use the tools of the trade. Does the income artists can make now get displaced by people using dalle? Then do people stop learning how to actually make art and we come to the end of new cultural production and just start remixing everything made untill now?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- totetsu 4y agoWith real artist left only making images of sex and violence and other TOS violations
- O__________O 4y agoTwo questions: (1) Any opinions on if removing the watermark is possible? Is doing so against the terms of service? (2) Appears the output is still at 1024x1024 - what are options to upscale the resolution, for example would OpenCV super resolution work?
- jeanlucas 4y agoIt is possible, they confirmed on discord you can remove the watermark. Yep... The output is an issue, I'd like to pay if that was an upgrade.
- O__________O 4y agoAnnoying that if removing the watermark is allowed that it is even inserted. Imagine if Adobe did that. Here’s more information on super resolution options beyond what Adobe already offers: (1) List of options current options for super resolutions: https://upscale.wiki/wiki/Different_Neural_Networks https://upscale.wiki/wiki/Different_Neural_Networks (2) Older example of one way to benchmark: https://docs.opencv.org/4.x/dc/d69/tutorial_dnn_superres_benchmark.html https://docs.opencv.org/4.x/dc/d69/tutorial_dnn_superres_ben...
- jeanlucas 4y agoBetween us... The watermark is just on the frontend... It's not into the image...
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- choppaface 4y agoA free alternative: https://huggingface.co/spaces/dalle-mini/dalle-mini https://huggingface.co/spaces/dalle-mini/dalle-mini Reminder that the OpenAI team claimed safety issues about releasing the weights. Now they’re charging, when the above link GPU time is being paid for by investor dollars. I guess sama must be hurting if he can only afford OpenAI credit packs for celebrities and his friends.
- ajafari1 4y agoI wrote about this happening two days ago on my sub stack post, "OpenAI will start charging businesses for images based on how many images they request. Just like Amazon Web Services charges businesses for usage across storage, computing, etc. Imagine a simple webpage where OpenAI will list out their AI-job suite, including “jobs” such as software developer, graphics designer, customer support rep, and accountant. You can select which service offerings you’d like to purchase ad-hoc or opt into the full AI-job suite." In case you are interested in reading the whole take: https://aifuture.substack.com/p/the-ai-battle-rages-on https://aifuture.substack.com/p/the-ai-battle-rages-on
- arrow7000 4y ago"Business monetises their offering" can't say I'm entirely blown away by the prediction
- naillo 4y agoThis news is funny since it doesn't actually change anything. It's still a waitlist that they're pushing out slowly (not an open beta). Nice way to stay in the news though.
- naillo 4y agoI wonder if they'll even make back what they spent on training the models before competitors of equal quality and lower cost eats up their margins.
- seshagiric 4y agoFor those who want to try DALL.E but do not have access yet, this is good play site: https://www.craiyon.com/ https://www.craiyon.com/
- Sohcahtoa82 4y agoThe name "OpenAI" to me implies being open-source. I have an RTX 3080 and will likely be buying a 4090 when it comes out. Will I ever be able to generate these images locally, rather than having to use a paid service? I've done it with DALL-E Mini, but the images from that don't hold a candle to what DALL-E 2 produces.
- ronsor 4y agoI'm not sure if any current or next-generation GPU even has enough power to run DALL-E 2 locally. Anyway, OpenAI is unlikely to release the model. The situation will like it is with GPT-3; however, it's also likely another team will attempt to duplicate OpenAI's work.
- MrBra 4y agoThanks to the amazing @lucidrains there's already an open-source implementation of DALL-E 2: https://github.com/lucidrains/DALLE2-pytorch https://github.com/lucidrains/DALLE2-pytorch and a pretrained model for it should be released within this year. The same person is also at work on an open-source implementation of Google's Imagen which should be even better (and faster) than DALLE-2: https://github.com/lucidrains/imagen-pytorch https://github.com/lucidrains/imagen-pytorch. This is possible because the original research papers behind DALLE-2 and Imagen were both publicly released.
- whywhywhywhy 4y agoTheir choice of name gets funnier every month.
- kisero 4y ago> Since its research is free from financial obligations, OpenAI can better focus on a positive human impact. Haha description of the company from Google
- jazzyjackson 4y agoFrom what i've seen it's all about the VRAM if you've got 60GB available to your GPU then maybe you can get close I'm really curious if Apple's unified memory architecture is of benefit here, especially a few years from now if we can start getting 128/256GB of shared RAM on the SoC
- neya 4y agoI'm curious to know - does the community have any open source alternatives to DALL.E? For an initiative named OpenAI, keeping their source code and models closed behind a license is bullshit in my opinion.
- minimaxir 4y agoThe best open-source-but-actually-can-be-run-on-simple-infra analogous to DALL-E 2 is min-dalle: https://github.com/kuprel/min-dalle https://github.com/kuprel/min-dalle
- MrBra 4y agoHow is minDALL-E better than DALL-E mini? I can run DALL-E mini with the MEGA model with 12 GB of VRAM. What are the requirements for minDALL-E in terms of VRAM?
- arecurrence 4y agoLAION is working on open source alternatives. There's a lot of activity in their discord and they have amassed the necessary training data but I am uncertain as to whether they have obtained the funding needed to deliver fully trained models. Phil Wang created initial implementations of several papers including imagen and parti in his GitHub account. EG: https://github.com/lucidrains/DALLE2-pytorch https://github.com/lucidrains/DALLE2-pytorch
- gwern 4y agoEAI/Emad/et al's 'Stable Diffusion' model will be coming out in the next month or so. I don't know if it will hit DALL-E 2 level but a lot of people will be using it based on the during-training samples they've been releasing on Twitter.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zone411 4y agoI have some first-hand experience about how the copyright office views these works from creating an AI assistant to help me write these melodies: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLoCzMRqh5SkFwkumE578YO4qa1NTkmMi4 https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLoCzMRqh5SkFwkumE578Y.... Here is a quote from the response from the Copyright Office email before I provided additional information about how they were created: "To be copyrightable, a work must be fixed in a tangible form, must be of human origin, and must contain a minimal degree of creative expression" So some employees there are aware of the impact that AI can have. Getting these DALL-E images copyrighted won't be trivial. I think it will be many years before the law is clarified.
- nbzso 4y agoAnything to end Corporate Memphis. Even, if we as illustrators will not have jobs or commissions. Let's hope that every creative human endeavour, painting, music, poetry will be replaced and removed from the commercial realm. Then maybe we will see artistic humanism instead of synthetic trans-humanistic "pop art". Happily for me I stopped painting digitally long time ago. I even stopped calling myself "an artist". Nowadays I paint and draw only with real medium and call all of that "Archivist craftsmanship with analogue medium". :)
- justinzollars 4y agoI would love access to this in order to design Silver Rounds. If you work at open API please reach out!
- can16358p 4y agoSo can we now legally remove the "color blocks" watermark or not? What about generating NFTs? It was explicitly prohibited during the previous period, now there is no notion of it. Without notion and rights for commercial use I think it's allowed but because it was an explicitly forbidden use case before, I want to be sure whether it can be used or not. Regardless, excited to see what possibilities it opens.
- gwern 4y agoAnother user saying that OA has said it's OK to remove the watermark: https://www.reddit.com/r/dalle2/comments/w3qsxd/dalle_now_available_in_beta/igxss1o/ https://www.reddit.com/r/dalle2/comments/w3qsxd/dalle_now_av... The commercial use language appears pretty clear to me to allow NFTs. (But note the absence of any discussion of derivative works...)
- peteforde 4y agoI have been having a blast with DALL-E, spending about an hour a day trying out wild combinations and cracking my friends up. I cannot imagine getting bored of it; it's like getting bored with visual stimulus, or art in general. In fact, I've been glad to have a 50/day limit, because it helps me contain my hyperfocus instincts. The information about new pricing is, to me as someone just enjoying making crazy imagines, a huge drag. It means that to do the same 50/day I'd be spending $300/month. OpenAI: introduce a $20/month non-commercial plan for 50/day, and I'll be at the front of the line.
- bfgoodrich 4y ago
- nsxwolf 4y agoI'm already bored of it. When you have everything, you have nothing.
- danielvaughn 4y agoI'm sure the novelty wears off. But I'm already coming up with several applications for it. On the personal side, I've been getting into game development, but the biggest roadblock is creating concept art. I'm an artist but it takes a huge amount of time to get the ideas on paper. Using DALLE will be a massive benefit and will let me expedite that process. It's important to note that this is not replacing my entire creative process. But it solves the issue I have, where I'm lying in bed imagining a scene in my mind, but don't have the time or energy to sketch it out myself.
- nsxwolf 4y agoI did notice it is very good at making small pixel art icons/sprites.
- KaoruAoiShiho 4y agoDo you have any tips or some prompt examples?
- ukzuck 4y agoCan anyone invite me for DALL E!
- password321 4y agoThe worlds most expensive meme generator.
- moron4hire 4y agoHow do you interface with DALL-E? For MidJourney I was painfully surprised to find that everything is done through chat messages on a Discord server. I'm not a paid member, so I have to enter my prompts in public channels. It's extremely easy to lose your own prompts in the rapidly flowing stream of prompts going on. I can kind of see why they did it that way--maybe, if I squint really hard--to try to promote visibility and community interaction, but it's just not happening. It's hard enough to find my own images, say nothing about follow what someone else is doing. This is literally the worst user experience I have ever had with a piece of software. There are dozens of channels. It's so spammy, doing it through Discord. It's constantly pinging new notifications and I have to go through and manually mute each and every one of the channels. Then they open a few dozen more. Rinse. Repeat. I understand paid users can have their own channels to generate images, but I really don't see the point in paying for it when, even subtracting the firehose of prompts and images, it's still an objectively shitty interface to have to do everything through Discord chat messages.
- pjgalbraith 4y agoYou use a web app to interface with it. Agree going from DALL-E 2 to Midjourney is pretty painful. Hopefully Midjourney create a web UI for it like OpenAI/Craiyon.
- throwaway675309 4y agoYeah that's definitely one of the worst aspects of using midjourney, supposedly a API is coming but it doesn't look like it's going to be happening anytime soon. I don't know who thought that discord would make a good GUI front end...
- jowday 4y agoSad to say I've been dissapointed in DALLE's performance since I got access to it a couple of weeks ago - I think mainly because it was hyped up as the holy grail of text2image ever since it was first announced. For a long while whenever Midjourney or DALLE-mini or the other models underperformed or failed to match a prompt the common refrain seemed to be "ah, but these are just the smaller version of the real impressive text2image models - surely they'd perform better on this prompt". Honestly, I don't think it performs dramatically better than DALLE-mini or Midjourney - in some cases I even think DALLE-mini outperforms it for whatever reason. Maybe because of filtering applied by OpenAI? What difference there is seems to be a difference in quality on queries that work well, not a capability to tackle more complex queries. If you try a sentence involving lots of relationships between objects in the scene, DALLE will still generate a mishmash of those objects - it'll just look like a slightly higher quality mishmash than from DALLE-mini. And on queries that it does seem to handle well, there's almost always something off with the scene if you spend more than a moment inspecting it. I think this is why there's such a plethora of stylized and abstract imagery in the examples of DALLE's capabilities - humans are much more forgiving of flaws in those images. I don't think artists should be afraid of being replaced by text2image models anytime soon. That said, I have gotten access to other large text2image models that claim to outperform DALLE on several metrics, and my experience matched with that claim - images were more detailed and handled relationships in the scene better than DALLE does. So there's clearly a lot of room for improvement left in the space.
- MWil 4y agoI've been on the waitlist since April 16th. Would have loved to have played around with the alpha but now clearly my ability to experiment and learn to use the system to cut down on expenses is extremely limited.
- isoprophlex 4y agoWait until someone trains a model like this, for porn. There seems to be a post-DALLE obscenity detector on openAI's tool, as so far I've found it to be entirely robust against deliberate typos designed to avoid simple 'bad word lists'. Ask it for a "pruple violon" and you get purple violins... you get the deal. "Metastable" prompts that may or may not generate obscene (content with nudity, guns, violence as I've found) results sometimes shown non-obscene generations, and sometimes trigger a warning.
- jowday 4y agoIf I had to guess, I'd bet they have a supervised classifier trained to recognize bad content (violence, porn, etc) that they use to filter the generated images before passing them to the user, on top of the bad word lists.
- isoprophlex 4y agoExactly!
- cmarschner 4y agoMost likely they just take the one from bing. Or, if they trained a better one, it goes vice versa sooner or later
- spread_love 4y agoThis is mentioned, "content filters" are "blocking images that violate our content policy — which does not allow users to generate violent, adult, or political content, among other categories" and they "limited DALL·E’s exposure to these concepts by removing the most explicit content from its training data."
- jug 4y agoI’ve thought about this and in fact porn generation sounds like a good thing?? It ensures that it’s victimless. Of course, there is a problem with generation of illegal (underage) porn but other than this, I think it could be helpful for this world.
- Al-Khwarizmi 4y agoIn beta, maybe, but I don't think "available" means what they think it means. I have been on the waitlist from the very beginning. Still waiting.
- Nevin1901 4y agoI don't like how they're charging money for Dalle, yet they don't have an API available.
- cm2012 4y agoI really want access, wish there was a way to pay to get in.
- hit8run 4y agoIt’s so dirty what Microsoft is doing here. They ripped the tech out of developers hands just to sell us drips of it. Drips that are not enough to build a product for more than a few people. They require to check on the use before launching etc. I truly hate this company, their shitty operating system and their monopoly business game. Everything they buy turns to shit. And don’t tell me about VSCode. It’s just a trap to fool developers.
- blintz 4y agoThe content policy is strikingly puritanical: > "Do not attempt to create, upload, or share images that are not G-rated" https://labs.openai.com/policies/content-policy https://labs.openai.com/policies/content-policy
- avidphantasm 4y agoI like how everyone’s face is rendered by DALL-E to look either like a still from a David Lynch film, or have teeth and hair coming out of weird places.
- Plough_Jogger 4y agoIs this referring to the first version of the model, or DALL-E 2?
- mark_l_watson 4y agoI tried DALLE once and liked the generated images. Not really my thing, but so cool. What I do use is OpenAI’s GPT-3 APIs, I am a paying customer. Great tool!
- softwaredoug 4y agoSurprised by the lack of comments on the ethics of DALL-E being trained on artists content whereas copilot threads are chock full of devs up in arms over models trained on open source code. Isn’t it the same thing?
- anhncommenter25 4y agoI recently talked with a concept artist about DALL-E and first thing they mentioned was "you know that's all stolen art, right?" Immediately made me think of GitHub Copilot. However the artists being featured in DALL-E's newsletters can't stop gushing about 'the new instrument they are learning how to play' and other such metaphors that are meant to launder what's going on. My theory is that the professions most at-risk for automation are acting on their anxieties. Must not be a lot of freelance artists on HN, and a whole lot of programmers. I think the artists have an even clearer case. I don't think GitHub Copilot is ready to steal anyone's job yet. But DALL-E is poised to replace all formerly commissioned filler art for magazines, marketing sites, and blogs. Now the only point to hiring a human is to say you hired a human. Our filler art is farm-to-table.
- scifibestfi 4y agoWhere did they get the art from anyway? Do they have a list of sources anywhere?
- trop 4y agoQuite true. Best case, we're seeing DJ Spooky style culture jamming/remixing. But more likely it is as you write. On the other hand, the market for stock photography was already decimated by the internet. Where previously skilled photographers would create libraries of images to exemplify various terms and sell these as stock, in the last decade or so, an art director with the aid of a search engine could rapidly produce similar results.
- anhner 4y agoI first read the artist's reply as "you know all art is stolen, right" which made more sense to me. If you look at the history of art, you'd also know that it's true.
- outsider7 4y agoAmazing stuff (really fun)... can it solve climate change ?
- samstave 4y agoWonderful! Also, I love how, while signing up for access to this amazing AI, I am asked to, indeed, affirm I am _not_ a robot.
- treelovinhippie 4y ago
- unixbane 4y ago
- williamcotton 4y agoI would like to point out that there is not as much of an uproar on this forum over DALL-E utilizing other people’s photographs, illustrations, et al, as there is around Copilot utilizing other people’s code. Why do you think that is?
- orange8 4y ago- This is not a photography/illustration focused forum. - Unlike software photography/illustration are not used to run essential systems like banking, manufacturing, medical equipment etc
- williamcotton 4y agoWhile I have definitely seen discussions of safety from what I can gather the main point of contention is with copyright.
- yunwal 4y agoOne reason is that copilot could be easily prompted to "create" line for line reproductions of people's code. AFAICT, you can't do this with DALLE (even if you, for example, try to input the caption of an image directly).
- xzghfat 4y agoi like it
- seydor 4y agoWhat is the copyright situation of generated images?
- pyuser583 4y agoI know it’s a dumb question, but what am I supposed to do with this thing?
- spaceman_2020 4y agoThis is going to completely obliterate the low end of the illustrator/graphic designer market. Anyone on Fiverr should be looking for new work.
- Traubenfuchs 4y agoIs there a comprehensive list of all the disgraceful censorship and model-neutering restrictions they put on DALL-E? It's sad to see that openai is so absolutely terrified of their models producing upsetting content and the bad press that would ensue, when they could just show everyone the finger and say: "It's just pretty pictures. Made up pictures. They aren't real and can't hurt you, so stop crying." e.g. One is unable to create faces of real people in the public eye.
- irthomasthomas 4y agoDALLe was fun for a few days, but I'm already tired of it. Now the web is going to be flooded with it; I'm glad I don't use social media.
- bepero 4y agoSome DALL·E Demos: https://www.aidemos.info/category/dall%c2%b7e-demos/ https://www.aidemos.info/category/dall%c2%b7e-demos/
- NicoleJO 4y agoDALL-E 2 was trained on approximately 650 million COPYRIGHTED image-text pairs SCRAPED FROM THE INTERNET, according to the paper that OpenAI posted to ArXiv. https://cdn.openai.com/papers/dall-e-2.pdf https://cdn.openai.com/papers/dall-e-2.pdf That includes YOURS. Have you been paid for it?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- srelbo 4y agoAI art generation, completely free, no limits — https://art.elbo.ai https://art.elbo.ai