7 ms·
NYC releases PSA for what to do in case of nuclear attack
- King-Aaron 4y agoTo be honest it's something that everyone should have at least a cursory education on.
- thrillgore 4y agoI looked at the information about surviving a nuclear attack and determined the lack of access to food, water, and healthcare afterwards aren't guaranteed. It's easier for me to just wait for the bombs to do me in.
- dqpb 4y ago> “get inside” and “stay tuned.” Ok, but is it like that time when Chris Christie shut down the beach, and then took his family there for a private vacation? Like, is this just to get all the people out of the way so the elites can get to where they need to go?
- Rapzid 4y agoAll those empty roads you gotta ask yourself who benefits.
- C50VGicCxmHC 4y agoFrom https://www.ready.gov/nuclear-explosion https://www.ready.gov/nuclear-explosion > Continue to practice social distancing by wearing a mask and by keeping a distance of at least six feet between yourself and people who not part of your household. Somehow I think that if you are in the immediate area of a nuclear explosion, COVID-19 precautions aren't going to be on the top of the list of stuff to worry about.
- tablespoon 4y agoBoy, that "ready.gov" page is garbage. Right before the section you quoted they state: > Go to the basement or middle of the building. Stay away from the outer walls and roof. Try to maintain a distance of at least six feet between yourself and people who are not part of your household. They should have used all that space about COVID-19 to better explain where to hide. I'm no expert, but I'm under the impression that if you're in a basement, it would be better to shelter against an outside wall, since all that dirt on the other side will effectively shield you from radiation coming from that direction (and you've got the rest of the mass of the building in the other direction). Also... > Stay inside for 24 hours unless local authorities provide other instructions. Isn't that totally backwards? If you're dealing with fallout, don't you want to stay inside for at least 1-2 weeks unless explicitly told it's safe?
- TameAntelope 4y agoI’m assuming the “24 hours” thing is a math thing where staying inside additional time will be more harmful than getting outside and finding out what to do next. If you can do both, yeah do that, but if you could never leave your home, and your home is a clean room, also definitely do that.
- tablespoon 4y ago> I’m assuming the “24 hours” thing is a math thing where staying inside additional time will be more harmful than getting outside and finding out what to do next. I don't think that's case at all. If you're dealing with fallout, the radiation decreases with time. Waiting 24 hours is better than not waiting at all, but I've seen charts and I'm under the impression that's only enough time for the radiation to decrease by ~50%, which could still be very lethal.
- TameAntelope 4y agoWhat's more lethal; dying in a week because you didn't organize with the people who are left, or dying in a decade because of radiation poisoning?
- srvmshr 4y agoThey are making sure you don't die of COVID, if you somehow survive a megaton blast and then make through the intense radiation /s Sounds absurd. Priorities have gone for a toss.
- PhasmaFelis 4y agoHm. Y'know what, infectious disease tends to be a big killer after any large-scale disaster. Water and sanitation services are offline, hospitals are critically overloaded, immune systems are reduced by stress and injury and malnutrition, people congregate around whatever aid is available... A simple seasonal flu can tear through a city like a wildfire, under those circumstances. In 2022, everyone already knows how to do social distancing, and it works just fine against many diseases besides COVID. Why take the chance?
- KoftaBob 4y agoThat line indicated to me that this was probably written during the height of the pandemic, not more recently.
- srvmshr 4y agoThis Kurzgesagt video is a much better explainer: https://youtu.be/5iPH-br_eJQ https://youtu.be/5iPH-br_eJQ These directives are mostly common sense knowledge which anyone in modern world will know. No mention of iodine tablets for fallouts. Besides if modern nuclear devices are detonated will they be a Hiroshima type? (Hint hint: No. Emphatic No). The MIRVs of US are typically rated at 275KT going up to several megatons. Similar scale for Russia & China. Unless you're in reinforced bunkers with heavy steel doors, you are most likely toast. Incineration by the thermal blast is most likely outcome.
- King-Aaron 4y ago> The MIRVs of US are typically rated at 275KT going up to several megatons. Yep, that last line in the OP video really gets me... "All right? You've got this!" No, you don't got this
- jnwatson 4y agoObviously, the message doesn’t matter for those incinerated. It applies to the folks in the outer boroughs and suburbs outside the blast radius.
- srvmshr 4y agoThe article doesn't specifically tell these are instructions for people outside the kill zone. And severely lacking survival information. Either the script should have added more details (instead of a commonsensical fluff piece) or added more practical information such as shelter inside well built closets, underground subway or enclosed spaces (and pay attention to emergency alarms/ alerts of a nuclear strike)
- ohiovr 4y agoMIRVs cover a vast area. The blast area basically surrounds the target and it burns out from the outside to the inside.
- idontwantthis 4y agoA bigger fireball also means more people affected, but not incinerated because the area of less destruction surrounding it will also be bigger. This advice is always going to be relevant, no matter how big the bomb. > Unless you're in reinforced bunkers with heavy steel doors, you are most likely toast. No building in the world, not even Cheyenne mountain can survive being in a nuclear fireball or even close to one. The steel doors are also for people nearby, but not directly hit.
- ilaksh 4y agoSo is this just NYC or is there a general concern? I feel like the lack of progress on nuclear disarmament is a total failure of global management. Maybe I should stock up on fresh water reserves or something.
- Caligatio 4y ago100% disarmament will simply never happen because the country that hides a few nukes while claiming to have none will win if push comes to shove. Best case in that scenario is every country is hiding nukes which is arguably not a lot better than the status quo. With Russia explicitly nuclear war if other countries interfere in Ukraine, I also don't see any nuclear arms control talks occuring in the near future.
- ilaksh 4y agoI would argue every country hiding a few nukes is better than the current situation with over 13,000 nukes.
- tablespoon 4y ago> I would argue every country hiding a few nukes is better than the current situation with over 13,000 nukes. Not necessarily. Having "a few nukes" means they will almost certainty used against civilian population centers (coutervalue), because that results in more destruction per nuke. If you have more nukes, it may be sufficiently deterring to only attack military targets (couterforce) and kill fewer civilians. https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.2968/057004008 https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/pdf/10.2968/057004008: > The first scenario that NRDC ran involved a counterforce attack against Russian nuclear forces. They believed this scenario to be close to the one fabricated by Stratcom. Using the most comprehensive levels of targeting for Russian aviation and naval sites, the total number of warheads required by the first NRDC plan was 1,289... The result of the “attack” as detailed in the report... Then the fallout would descend, creating lethal conditions over an area larger than 775,000 square kilometers... casualties would be between 11 and 17 million, of which eight to 12 million would be fatalities. > But what would happen if the United States drastically reduced the number of weapons in its arsenal and abandoned the pretense that one kind of nuclear targeting is more morally acceptable than another? How many nuclear weapons is enough to deter a nuclear attack on the United States, which, according to the NRDC report, is arguably the only reason for continuing to possess nuclear weapons at all? > To illustrate this, NRDC ran nuclear attack scenarios on Russian cities using either 150 single-warhead, silo-based ICBMs or 192 single-warhead, submarine-launched ballistic missiles (SLBM's), essentially the load aboard a single fully loaded Trident submarine. The results from either scenario, each using less than 3 percent of current U.S. nuclear forces, resulted in more than 50 million casualties [computed casualties totaled 52 million people, including 49 million deaths].
- haunter 4y agoMeanwhile in Japan https://www.bousai.metro.tokyo.lg.jp/book/pdf/en/02_Lets_Get_Prepared.pdf https://www.bousai.metro.tokyo.lg.jp/book/pdf/en/02_Lets_Get... https://www.bousai.metro.tokyo.lg.jp/book/pdf/en/03_Other_Disasters_and_Countermeasures.pdf https://www.bousai.metro.tokyo.lg.jp/book/pdf/en/03_Other_Di... https://www.bousai.metro.tokyo.lg.jp/book/pdf/en/04_Survival_Tips.pdf https://www.bousai.metro.tokyo.lg.jp/book/pdf/en/04_Survival... https://www.metro.tokyo.lg.jp/english/guide/bosai/index.html https://www.metro.tokyo.lg.jp/english/guide/bosai/index.html
- srvmshr 4y agoTokyo Metropolitan government is one of the best I have seen in matters of everyday functioning. They are pretty well prepared most of the time. I think this has more to do with the ever present threat of major earthquakes. You can pick up printed copies of this guidebook for free from any local government office. (Even new apartment rentals provide this nowadays) (Disclaimer: Lived in Charlotte, Boston, SF and now in Tokyo)
- eatonphil 4y agoWhile standard disaster practice in there looks solid, the only thing I can find among the links you shared that sort of has to do with nuclear attacks is: > Missile attack > It would be extremely difficult to identify the target of the attack, and it is estimated that the time to impact will be short. And that's... not very specific. :)
- theIV 4y agoThere is _a little_ more, although, not much more specific :x > Evacuation from a nuclear explosion or radioactive > contamination > > If there is a nuclear explosion, hide behind cover and > evacuate to an underground facility or strong building. > An explosive called a “dirty bomb” will cause radioactive > contamination of the area. Follow the instructions of the > authorities and consult a physician.
- Axien 4y agoI wish we had better missile defense. It is 2022, we should not be living like it is the 1960’s.
- AinderS 4y agoThe last thing you want is for a nuclear armed country to think "we can launch a few nukes - our missile defense will shield us from retaliation".
- selfhoster11 4y agoThey would be less likely to launch them. Nukes are expensive, so what's the point of launching them if they'll be reliably shot down by the enemy?
- AinderS 4y agoThe implication was that they would be launched at an enemy without reliable missile defense.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- nradov 4y agoThe Missile Defense Agency annual budget is about $10B. How much more should we spend on it?
- namlem 4y agoIf we did have better missile defense, it would be a secret. The last thing we want is for our enemies to know about it.
- Crosseye_Jack 4y agoWait, you telling me that you don’t sign post where your secret things are kept? https://i.imgur.com/Pm0AkqR.jpg https://i.imgur.com/Pm0AkqR.jpg
- Proven 4y ago
- weatherlight 4y agohttps://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/ https://nuclearsecrecy.com/nukemap/ Select NYC, and then select 800kt, (best case scenario) you are looking at 1.5 million dead instantaneously, and then probably another 3.5 million over the next week. The only parts that "wouldn't be affected" are parts of Staten Island and the Rockaways. It's horrifying
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- mzs 4y agomight be dirty bomb or not delivered by missile
- joezydeco 4y agoStay tuned Just out of curiosity, how many of you have an operable AM or AM/FM radio and batteries to use it? This idea of "watch the media" is going to be really hard if you're going to rely on wireless carriers. If you have a TV, does it have an OTA antenna?
- thrillgore 4y agoI believe Switzerland still requires every new home to have a shelter, even if they have tabled any new public shelters.
- ohiovr 4y agoImagine 20 of the largest oil tankers in the world in New York Harbor filled with TNT and it exploding. I don't think people are going to be logging into Youtube to see the gossip about it. Or posting selfies or hiding in the subway. NYC would evaporate.