12 ms·
Only 6.8% of adults have optimal cardiometabolic health
- dubswithus 4y agoI'm one of the 6.8%. Very low LDL. Taking questions. Bet let's get this out of the way first: I eat a lot of carbohydrates.
- mise_en_place 4y agoI have very low LDL but I’d trade it for higher testosterone levels. Last test check was 200 ng/dl. I’m not a hardgainer body type either, but due to aromatase converting my T into E my body ends up storing more fat.
- TimedToasts 4y agoDon't accept low t - see your doctor and if your doctor won't there are T-specific clinic in your area that will be happy to help.
- moosedev 4y agoDo you have any sources or additional info on the latter? How did you determine that aromatase is the culprit? Thanks.
- dubswithus 4y agoDecrease in testosterone as you grow older may be cardio protective. It seems like it's currently unknown. Do you have your T levels tested every year?
- PainfullyNormal 4y agoHow about seed oils?
- MattGaiser 4y agoAre seed oils some new health trend? I keep seeing people mention them in health discussions.
- PainfullyNormal 4y agoThe opposite. https://fireinabottle.net/ https://fireinabottle.net/
- hirundo 4y agoThere's a lot of evidence that PUFAs are obesogenic and diabetogenic. Their consumption increase broadly tracks the epidemics of both. E.g. https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Soybean-Oil-Is-More-Obesogenic-and-Diabetogenic-Oil-Deol-Evans/6794028d3bbf6c2d8bb7f6a6b5d9e671dbf8b247 https://www.semanticscholar.org/paper/Soybean-Oil-Is-More-Ob... If the effect is real it takes place over decades, gradually damaging mitochondria, making it difficult to cover with RCTs.
- Entinel 4y ago"A lot" is a stretch. There is some evidence in mice and a few hypothesis but I certaintly wouldn't say "a lot." The exception to this I would say is soybean oil. There is a decent amount of research pointing in direction that soybean oil isn't great.
- rafaelero 4y agoAdded oil should be kept at minimum. It doesn't matter the source. But of course this is not the main reason for the obesity epidemic; people just like to find easy culprits instead of looking at the culture around food in the US.
- SamPatt 4y agoI believe the case against seed oils isn't about them causing obesity, but heart disease.
- xwdv 4y agoDo NOT consume seed oils. Go in your pantry and throw away anything that lists some kind of seed oil as an ingredient.
- austinjp 4y agoWhy? * * By which I mean with references. And yes, big farma, etc etc, but really, decent studies please.
- PainfullyNormal 4y agoBuckle up, because Brad Marshall over at fireinabottle.net has a six part series on this complete with footnotes. https://fireinabottle.net/how-seed-oils-cause-reductive-stress-part-i/ https://fireinabottle.net/how-seed-oils-cause-reductive-stre... https://fireinabottle.net/the-mitochondrial-bottleneck-as-the-carburetor-screw-how-seed-oils-cause-reductive-stress-part-ii/ https://fireinabottle.net/the-mitochondrial-bottleneck-as-th... https://fireinabottle.net/acetylation-turns-on-lipogenic-genes-how-seed-oils-cause-reductive-stress-part-iii/ https://fireinabottle.net/acetylation-turns-on-lipogenic-gen... https://fireinabottle.net/what-happens-to-seed-oils-when-you-eat-them-how-seed-oils-cause-reductive-stress-part-iv/ https://fireinabottle.net/what-happens-to-seed-oils-when-you... https://fireinabottle.net/seed-oils-make-lean-people-behave-like-fat-people-metabolically-speaking-how-seed-oils-cause-reductive-stress-part-v/ https://fireinabottle.net/seed-oils-make-lean-people-behave-... https://fireinabottle.net/pufa-as-an-obesogen-how-seed-oils-cause-reductive-stress-part-vi/ https://fireinabottle.net/pufa-as-an-obesogen-how-seed-oils-...
- lr4444lr 4y agoWhat about whole nuts and seeds from which they're derived? Do they cause the same effect? I find this all a little hard to believe given that obese people tend to consume animal fats at a higher rate than non-obese people, nationwide changes notwithstanding.
- PainfullyNormal 4y ago
- dubswithus 4y agoI don't consume any oils. Of course if I'm eating out or at someone's house it can be outside my control.
- cableshaft 4y agoWhat's your exercise regimen look like?
- dubswithus 4y agoRight now I'm doing 30-40+ miles of running a week. It's on concrete and asphalt with extremely high humidity and I'm still attempting to adapt. Will be starting a strength training program soon because I'm kind of destroying my body. In the past I've done a mix of treadmill and outdoors. I would like to get back to using a treadmill but don't have access to one right now.
- asdfqwertzxcv 4y agoWhole Food Plant Based and regular exercise, right?
- dubswithus 4y agoMostly whole food plant-based. I do eat a lot of candy and I will eat meat sometimes. Usually if I'm at dinner or at someone's house. I avoid all oils. My exercise is more extreme on the cardio side and has been since high school.
- TimedToasts 4y agoDo you know your FFMI?
- dubswithus 4y agoNope, but I'm not lean right now unfortunately.
- stubybubs 4y agoI'm like this. Got some labs from when I was 36: HDL: 1.96 normal range 0.90-1.60 ("good" cholesterol, above high normal) LDL: 2.19 normal range 2.00-3.40 Triglycerides: 0.54 normal range 0.60-2.30 (below low normal, lower is better) HbA1c: 4.9% normal range 4.5-6.5% (measure of average blood sugar over about 3 months) I had these results while I was in med school (late bloomer) and having seen a lot of lipids/HbA1c I have to say I have never seen results this good in anybody else. Yes, I am pretty proud of myself! At one point I ran a half marathon, but that was 4-5 years previous to this. By this point I was on 20 minutes intense cardio 3x week, and heavy weights. By heavy I mean heavy for me, as in I didn't show up at the gym expect to do 3 set of 10 no matter what. If I could do 3x10 of a certain weight, it was time to up the weight for constant improvement. I ate balanced protein and carbs with some fat, a habit I picked up from Body for Life a long time ago. I ate a lot of chicken, plenty of beef, also fish. I also love candy, and will eat a lot of it while coding or studying. Never skimped on things like popcorn, triple butter please. Love eggs. Love eating out, rich meals and dessert. I have never been vegan or vegetarian. When I really wanted to build muscle, I ate lots of meat. For a genetic background, I have a sibling who ended up with NAFLD in their early 30s. Aunt and grandfather with T2DM. Mother is on statins now in her late 60s. Generally my family is average build, maybe a big chubbier. I would say my health is 90% effort. I think the key is, you have to use absolutely everything you put in your body. If you are not building a stronger body with it, it's going to waste.
- danachow 4y ago> Yes, I am pretty proud of myself! Congratulate your parents as well for the good genes. > I also love candy, and will eat a lot of it while coding or studying. Never skimped on things like popcorn, triple butter please. > I think the key is, you have to use absolutely everything you put in your body. If you are not building a stronger body with it, it's going to waste. I mean I’m totally in the indulge in moderation crowd if only to enjoy life, but I am still at a loss how your two statements above are connected. How are you building a stronger body with the triple butter?
- stubybubs 4y agoI added some genetic background. That definitely isn't it. Nobody else in my family has put in the effort that I have. > How are you building a stronger body with the triple butter? The point is that I used it all. I burned all of the calories I put into my body. Even if the calories were "crap" I burned them instead of consuming the quality protein I ingested for basic metabolic needs. My weight crept slowly upward from 155 to 165 over the course of 10 years and it was muscle, not fat.
- sacrosancty 4y agoNot having seen the full paper, surely the range of values that belong to "optimal" is arbitrary and if measurement error or understanding were improved, the optimal range would shrink, excluding even more people. So doesn't that make the percentage meaningless?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- lisper 4y agoExactly right. The claim is absurd on its face because of its very form.
- loeg 4y agoYes. But the actual title is "Trends and Disparities in Cardiometabolic Health Among U.S. Adults, 1999-2018" and the major conclusion was "Between 1999 and 2000 and 2017 and 2018, U.S. cardiometabolic health has been poor and worsening." The HN title is editorialized to focus on a relatively insignificant and easy-to-quibble-with detail.
- throwthere 4y agoWould you have to assume the researchers and journal editors were wantonly naive to make that kind mistake?
- Dylan16807 4y agoNot "surely". For something like body fat, we have a pretty good understanding and very precise measurements but the optimal range is much much bigger than that precision.
- dpeck 4y agoWhat’s the metric to define that? This is just the abstract to anyone who doesn’t have access to the journal.
- PeterWhittaker 4y agoFrom the Method section, just a few paras in (I just clicked on the link provided, I do not subscribe to any journals): We assessed proportions of adults with optimal cardiometabolic health, based on adiposity, blood glucose, blood lipids, blood pressure, and clinical CVD; and optimal, intermediate, and poor levels of each component among 55,081 U.S. adults in the National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey.
- mdorazio 4y agoThat doesn't actually explain anything, though. What is "optimal" in each of those categories and why is that level optimal as opposed to any other one?
- AtlasBarfed 4y agoI would guess what is desired is low LDL in order to not build up plaques and avoid congestive heart failure.
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y agoI always wonder if one can take solace in the fact that one has a problem that everybody else also is dealing with/will be dealing with and so there is a huge financial (and quite frankly medically selfish) incentive to solve. The opposite of that is that having such thoughts immediately makes me feel a shitty person because financial resources are not infinite and if they are thrown at solving the problem that everybody is dealing with it means that people with rare diseases are getting the short hand of the stick.
- Hnrobert42 4y agoThere isn’t a financial incentive to solve it. There is one to treat it. Insulin, blood pressure meds, statins for cholesterol, cardiac stints are all big business.
- Bubble_Pop_22 4y agoSo was the ice business, not to mention the salt business, the ice cartel and the salt cartel were dominating but the person who invented the refrigerator put them both out of business in one swoop and managed to subtract all their wealth/ status from them. In this case there is also the incentive to solve it if anything out of selfishness given that everybody at some point develops cardiometabolic problems
- steve_adams_86 4y agoIt seems to me that the vast bulk of their business is made possible by the fact that our alternative is to dramatically improve our diets, sleep, and exercise regimens. Studies seem to show that each of these often have meaningful effects on preventing, stopping and even reversing common diseases. This is all really hard for people to do, though. There’s a lot working against us. It’s hard to see why we should do it at the individual level — it’s hard to believe these changes will make a meaningful difference. But you’re right that there’s no financial incentive there. Not at all. There is for each of us, and here in Canada there is an incentive to reduce medical spending, but pharmaceutical companies stand to gain nothing and lose so much. It’s hard to imagine this changing much, but what a difference it would make. Life could be so much different for so many of us.
- makeitdouble 4y agohttps://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9027860/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9027860/ ↑ This paper seems to be studying the same data and has it’s own take on the results. Conclusions go in the same direction, but at least we have more info on how they look at it and their comments on the methodology and findings.
- loeg 4y agoActual title is "Trends and Disparities in Cardiometabolic Health Among U.S. Adults, 1999-2018" if you want to de-editorialize it, @dang.
- cletus 4y agoCount me in that 6.8%. In my 40s, resting heart rate ~50 (no it's not bradycardiac), relatively healthy weight, low LDL, low HDL, 115/70 BP. I ride 25 miles 3/week on average and probably walk another 3 miles 3/week. Pretty much intermittent fasting (1 meal/day) plus some protein shakes. Probably the most depressing thing to me about the US is how car-dependent almost everything else. In most places in the country you can't even have a walkable lifestyle (without driving somewhere to "hike") even if you wanted to. IMHO it's a lot harder to become unhealthy and morbidly obese if you routinely walk places.
- itsmefaz 4y agoI have bradycardia and my resting heart is around ~50. Is this something I must about concerned about?
- chillwaves 4y agoAsk your doctor.
- Godel_unicode 4y agoThis is the only sensible idea expressed in this entire thread. Most of you have good tech company health insurance, use it. Stop asking for health advice from engineers who read that one paper that agrees with their prejudices.
- halfmatthalfcat 4y agoDefinitely talk to your doctor but if you're highly endurant and do high-cardio exercise, it's not abnormal to have resting heart rates between 40 - 50 or even lower.
- steve_adams_86 4y agoAbsolutely. Walking and sleeping especially — time spent burning energy in which it isn’t possible or convenient to eat. I recently read about how exercise kind of dampens appetite as well, including walking (though to a lesser degree than more intense exercise). We should all try to walk and sleep more, it seems.
- alexfromapex 4y agoI was in bad health, i.e. raised adiposity (which is a beautiful euphemism, I might add), for a while and it's because I spent so much time working to pay my bills. I had almost no time to exercise. That is especially true when I spent my free time with friends or working on hobbies. The additional stress of work and lack of time drove me to drinking which messed up my liver (was diagnosed fatty liver) and added to my bad fat metabolism. Recently, I've been taking a break from working and have had time every day to go running and go to the gym twice a week and I've dropped 7 pounds in 2 months and feel way healthier.
- civilized 4y agoFor me it was kids. Love them, but they're sleep deprivation and stress 24/7. Better now that they're older but the weight has been hard to lose. If only there was a magical food that gave you energy, satiated hunger, tasted like pepperoni pizza, and had no calories. Life's a bitch.
- alexpetralia 4y agoI imagine this affects many parents. I would love to know how many parents successfully manage this (or, perhaps, success is simply defined as raising your kids well)?
- civilized 4y agoPeople seem to have all sorts of problems from having kids. Some have no problem with weight gain but their marriage falls apart. I guess I'm glad I got what I got instead of that.
- pfisherman 4y agoYou absolutely need to prioritize getting 30-60 mins of exercise at least 5 times per week. Block out time on your work calendar if you have to. The cognitive / health / mood benefits will make up for the lost time. A home gym setup will save you the 30-40 mins to and from the gym. Barring space for any equipment / weights some exercise bands and a yoga mat will do. App based fitness classes such as AppleFitness+ also make it much much easier to program your workouts.
- d--b 4y agoReally there is only 1 guy who has the best cardiometabolic health of all humans. Probably not me.
- strken 4y agoLooks like it only declined from 7.5% or thereabouts. Is there a more specific figure in the full paper?
- nycbenf 4y agoI also have a resting heart rate in the mid 50s and LDL of 46, but in my case it is because of beta blockers and 80 mg of statins daily. 3 years ago I found out I had 3 total occlusions and needed an immediate coronary artery bypass graft. 3 years later and my heart is still only half as efficient as a normal man my age because of extensive scarring! Take care of yourselves people, there is more to life than shipping software!
- ampham 4y agoA majority of infrastructure in the US makes it extremely hard to be healthy. Activity and healthy foods isn’t integrated into daily life. For example, you can’t just walk to the grocery store or other things in most places. And if you live in a bad neighborhood, you can’t feel safe going walking or running. Living in a walkable, safe, and nice area is out of reach for a lot of people. This makes it hard for people when activity isn’t the default.
- dorkwood 4y agoThere's also seems to be a cultural stigma against walking, although I don't know how widespread it is. When I lived in California, people would actually laugh at me for walking places. "Only homeless people walk", I was told.
- izzydata 4y agoIs it even possible to walk places in California? It seems like everything would take hours to get to or would take hiking over hills and highways.
- CharlesW 4y ago> Is it even possible to walk places in California? California is vast, so there are many areas that are almost comically walk-proof, but there are also cities with a high average "walk score". https://www.walkscore.com/CA/ https://www.walkscore.com/CA/ I live in a SoCal coastal city of 60K which has a fairly low "walk score" of 43. The services I'd need on a regular basis are in the neighborhood of a 20-45m walk (one way).
- SllX 4y agoEasily within most of San Francisco. It boils down to the neighborhood you live in, but a bus or streetcar can augment the trip. The downside of doing it that way is that then you also have to endure MUNI and depending on the time of the day it can feel taxing, so it’s better if you live in one of the neighborhoods that already has a good market street (e.g. Clement & Geary in the Inner Richmond).
- drewg123 4y agoI'm early 50s. In my mid 40s, I had terrible cholesterol and was obese. I have a family history of heart disease, and I got scared. So I started exercising (running, then switched to alternating rowing and lifting) and lost 70lbs and reached my ideal body weight, but I didn't change my diet. My cholesterol improved, but was still not good. My doctor was talking about putting me on a statin. Two years ago, I started dating a vegan and slowly became vegan myself and I now eat a plant based diet. Between the exercise and the diet, my cholesterol numbers have totally turned around. My doctor commented last month at my physical that she's never seen anybody turn their cholesterol around like that without drugs.
- halfmatthalfcat 4y agoGood on you and cringe on your doctor's part, how can doctors be so clueless?
- drewg123 4y agoShe wasn't clueless. She just said that in her experience, nobody actually takes her advice to exercise and change their diet seriously and they wind up on statins.
- olyjohn 4y agoI've met people who do this exact thing. They were clearly overweight, and we're complaining that the doctors were "offending" them my telling them they were overweight. They kept seeing different doctors, and told the same thing. They just could not find a doctor who could tell them what they wanted to hear.
- spicymaki 4y agoExactly! A friend of mine said there is nothing you can do about type 2 diabetes and I told him many people are just unwilling to come to grips with obesity and poor diet. A well planned vegan diet can prevent and manage type II diabetes by controlling your weight and sugar levels.
- mihaic 4y agoPersonally, I think a lot more blame should be dumped on the gym industry. Sure, the unhealthy food industry is primarily to blame, but keeping physically fit was something that people did everywhere: sports in the park, exercise at home. Now we've ended up with a significant number of ultra-toned individuals (I think higher than ever in terms of percentage actually) that spend a significant amount of time making everyone else look bad. This raising of the bar coupled with the fact that working out need to be done now in special locations that involve a lot more effort than doing 20 push-ups at home, many people have given up entire on exercise as it seems futile to them.
- vgatherps 4y agoThis is a super strange take. Is that claim that since there's a higher proportion of people that are extremely strong, people who aren't fit feel bad when going to the gym since they don't compare? The gym industry takes some blame for people not being fit because .... by making serious strength training widely available it's produced too many too fit people? > but keeping physically fit was something that people did everywhere: sports in the park, exercise at home. Nobody took away sports in the park or exercise at home > This raising of the bar coupled with the fact that working out need to be done now in special locations that involve a lot more effort than doing 20 push-ups at home Nobody took away 20 pushups at home, or is forcing you to do exercise at a gym. If anything, the ease of access to high quality information on bodyweight exercises (/yoga/dance class/...) is miles beyond what it used to be - just go to youtube! They're SUPER effective as well!
- mihaic 4y agoI know it's a hard argument to make, but what I mean is that if there were fewer gyms that would be a more developed culture of 5-minute exercises at home. Sure, people can go to youtube and learn. Nobody is stopping them but at the same time nobody in their circle of friends is encouraging this. Many people need to be convinced by example, and I actually see a lot of friends that would be in better shape if there were advice floating around in casual conversations on how to keep fit within a full schedule. Gym culture has taken up the bulk of the public discourse space on keeping fit, and it's led to a polarized population.
- mancerayder 4y agoI've found most benefits that make me seem years younger are likely linked to: - Some form of resistance training (in my case oly and general strength training) - Walking a lot (a benefit of a walkable city) as part of routine, rather than a scheduled exercise - Not snacking, sticking to scheduled meal times - For me personally, intermittent fasting in the form of skipping breakfast. Not only is breakfast unnecessary for most of us, you'd be surprised by how much you can achieve fasted, you might even find an enhanced energy. I'm sure resistance training can be substituted for other 'training' by which we mean a stimulus strong enough to lead to an adaptation. With the adaptation to the exercise comes some of the benefits - like optimal cardiometabolic health.
- rusteh1 4y agoI feel folks overcomplicate this. At least for the the HN crowd, it is totally possible to eat mostly non-processed, fresh food, don't drink too much booze, and get an average of 30 minutes of incidental exercise a day. Those three things and you are head of 90% of people.
- eixiepia 4y agoHappy to be in the 6.8% group. Started on the carnivore diet about 7 years ago. I had been a vegan for years before that, but my health deteriorated badly because of this. I also exercise and fast regularly. I have never been in better health, and this is confirmed with blood work every 6 months.
- wincy 4y agoI’m amazed at how well carnivore works for me. I started a few days ago. Before that I’d been throwing up 5+ times a day, every day, for months. My doctor shrugged and had no idea what to do. Even Zofran didn’t help.
- eixiepia 4y agoWell that indeed sounds amazing. Great that you are already feeling better. Because of my past, I'm often contacted by recovering ex-vegans in my area. I immediately get them started on the carnivore diet and within a week or two, most will come back, often with tears in their eyes, to tell me that they finally begin to feel normal again, really a joy to experience.
- merry_flame 4y agoHow do you know? Did you see the metrics that were used and compare them with your bloodwork? This reads as low-effort anecdata.
- Madmallard 4y agoWhat is their definition of optimal cardiometabolic health? I don’t see a mention of VO2 max. Yeah it’s normal weight and I would think it is an average or better VO2 max for your age group.
- sdze 4y agoSedentary lifestyle. Especially we IT workers are at risk.
- ranguna 4y agoAnd once again, a HN title that says the US is the only country in the world.