9 ms·
Archaeological analysis suggests warfare helped societies become more complex
- imtringued 4y agoMarx thought that communism followed the end of capitalism, the moment capitalism completed its mission of growth and there is enough for everyone, that it should switch to communism. My pet theory is that markets strive towards market freedom as opposed to a free market which is purely defined by a lack of regulation and then followed by processes that fill the power vacuum. No, market freedom is about giving everyone the ability to participate in the division of labor to the extend that they want, the ability to refuse to be trapped by debt against their will, the freedom from being forced to grow the economy against their will, the freedom from rent seeking and the freedom from being deprived of basic humans needs like land and food via the division of labor. As you can see, these freedoms aren't granted by default, a free market does not grant them. We introduced states with their monopoly on violence to protect people from violence. The right to life has to be enforced by competent officials as otherwise a small portion of the population will inevitably use murder for their own benefit. Because of this constant striving toward market freedom, people resist authoritarianism and this necessitates guard labor which forcibly distorts the market away from market freedom. At some point half the population engages in guard labor at which point the ruler will be overthrown by the guard labor leading to a military dictatorship which will be overthrown again. If this doesn't happen, then the ruler will be overthrown by the rebellion instead leading to an economy that is closer to market freedom. "Smart" rulers notice that they should avoid becoming a villain, instead they blame someone else, a foreign country and their leaders. During market saturation, money fails to circulate, leading to mass unemployment as the productivity of a handful of people is enough to produce most products and the jobs are unfairly allocated to people who do not need their additional income. This encourages governments to invest the surplus labor force in the military and for building and stockpiling weapons to fight the villain country. Because the choice to only work for their rent and food has been taken away from them through the unfair concentration of work, people are forced to engage in wartime production, they simply have no choice. What warfare represents is just a way to keep capital gains and interest rates high in an economy that has no need for further growth. People quite literally destroy capital because they haven't learned how to allocate it properly. Market saturation is as if capitalism was a video game that can be beat, but when you finish it, you and everyone realizes that beating capitalism doesn't solve poverty whatsoever and people get become aware and angry that the problem wasn't a lack of growth to begin with and eliminating poverty is purely about wealth and income distribution for which capitalists have no answer. Hence the endless need to grow and if you can't, to go to war, to keep people busy and sweep the inequality under the rug.
- juve1996 4y agoFTA: “The majority of archaeologists are against the warfare theory,” says Peter Turchin, an evolutionary anthropologist at the University of Connecticut, Storrs, and the new study’s lead author. “Nobody likes this ugly idea because obviously warfare is a horrible thing, and we don’t like to think it can have any positive effects.” I find it really concerning if this is actually true. How can you be an archaeologist and not think war has been a major part of human history?
- tomjakubowski 4y agoThese beliefs—that (1) war has been a major part of human history and (2) war doesn't have _positive_ effects—seem compatible to me, what do you mean?
- juve1996 4y agoIt seems dubious to claim something that has impacted history as significantly as war has not had any positive effects on civilization.
- lupire 4y agoOn the winner's civilization, mostly.
- juve1996 4y agoEven the losers - we borrow many ideas from plenty of failed civilizations.
- Ensorceled 4y agoAnd many ideas are also simply lost, history is full of the ebb and flow of advancement as civilizations are destroyed and plundered.
- 4y ago
- jokoon 4y agoSometimes I wonder about a worldwide, UN-controlled authority to dismantle any organization and factories that build firearms or other weapons that use powder. Maybe there will be a day in the future where firearms will be banned worldwide. Of course firearms will still exist but will be rare, making armed conflict almost impossible, and they would only be produced in very small quantities, to defend against people who make them illegally. One thing that should be definitely be banned, are long distance rockets mounted on trucks. Those are very inaccurate and should not exist.
- vanattab 4y agoThey are not all very inaccurate. Some of them have GPS guided rockets
- philangist 4y ago> a worldwide, UN-controlled authority How would it enforce it’s authority with non-compliant actors?
- formerly_proven 4y agoEasier to just kill all humans. Also, have you considered what the term "authority" means? But then again, a bunch of people still also think communism or socialism are great ideas, so...
- gadflyinyoureye 4y agoThe UN would have to keep guns and other weapons because they have to enforce the no-weapons edict. Sure a realistic side effect is that the UN assumes an ever increasing level of power. But that is just the side effect of utopia.
- throwaway4aday 4y ago> making armed conflict almost impossible As China and India have demonstrated recently, this is not the case. Firearms are not the source of conflict. I also question whether you truly mean all firearms would be banned as it would not be possible to enforce this ban without your UN-controlled authority possessing firearms. So this is yet another proposal for only the government to have a monopoly on weapons.
- upupandup 4y agoChimpanzees engage in warfare, it is one of the few species other than humans to engage in mass combat. Is it complex? I would say to a certain degree.
- VictorPath 4y agoChimpanzees certainly don't engage in warfare, unless you want to anthropomorphic chimpanzees and change the nomenclature of warfare. While chimpanzees certainly hit each other, they have not been observed much to kill one another, unless humans artificially modify their feeding environments and territories.
- ceejayoz 4y agoWars between groups of chimps are well documented. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gombe_Chimpanzee_War https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gombe_Chimpanzee_War
- missedthecue 4y agoIs that the only one ever documented, because it's the only one I ever see sourced.
- whoomp12342 4y agohttps://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/22/science/22chimp.html https://www.nytimes.com/2010/06/22/science/22chimp.html
- missedthecue 4y agovery, very interesting
- carapace 4y agoCould the chimps have learned these behaviors from us? Maybe chimpanzees are bonobos that live too close to humans?
- mediocregopher 4y agoWar is a symptom of various causes, like over-population, changing geographical conditions, and just plain old greed. It is not a root cause. If humans had no bloodthirst we would still wage war, so long as we had a will to survive (something which would be difficult to take out of a lifeform). The actual article only asserts that military innovation is a predictor for social complexity, which is pretty different from saying that "war makes society complex". > “Nobody likes this ugly idea because obviously warfare is a horrible thing, and we don’t like to think it can have any positive effects.” The implicit assumption being that a more complex society _is_ a good thing, which is not clear to me.
- ramraj07 4y agoIt may not be universally clear but to most people it clearly is a good thing to be in a more complex society. im definitely happy to not be sitting in a hut in a jungle with no other option.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pbhjpbhj 4y agoIt's possible to cooperate to survive, it seems much harder (more complex!), but I don't agree that it's impossible. Much easier, I'm sure. We'd need to forgo some autonomy to achieve it IMO, for example: we'd need to get a handle on population rises; we'd need to limit resource usage using some mechanism other than financial affordability; and lots else.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- glitchc 4y agoWarfare requires belief in an idea (or a collection of ideas). Animals capable of holding beliefs and ideas are likely to have complex societies and engage in war with other complex societies espousing a different set of ideas. Both are symptoms of higher cognitive function.
- the_lonely_road 4y agoI like watching ant colonies wage war against one another. I’m not sure what you are saying is true.
- EthanHeilman 4y agoThis really comes down to how narrowly you define warfare and I'm pretty unclear on a good definition. Ant colonies fight battles with other ant colonies but do they fight wars? Does war require that the participants have some sort of shared goal? It is not an infrequent occurrence that in human wars the planners and decision makers are not unified around the aims of the war.
- User23 4y agoSomehow some mint started growing in my landscape. It's definitely waging a war on all the other weeds, and except for a few patches of monkey grass, it's winning decisively. It reminds me of the scene in Anathem where two of the monks wage a garden battle.
- pessimizer 4y agoIdeas are a pretense in war, not a cause.
- trashtester 4y agoAny social anmial that claim a territory can have warfare. From ants and up.
- boredumb 4y agoReminds me of https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/in-the-long-run-wars-make-us-safer-and-richer/2014/04/25/a4207660-c965-11e3-a75e-463587891b57_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/in-the-long-run-wars... from 2014.
- eevilspock 4y agoVery many human endeavors and technology were accelerated/funded by war (including cold wars). Some very recent examples: - satellites and space travel - the internet - GPS I'm sure we can add many more things to this list. (Please do in reply.) I don't think it's a contradiction to acknowledge this and at the same time be anti-war, just as it isn't a contradiction to acknowledge greed and selfishness as a strongly motivating factor in human nature (such acknowledgment is the very basis of capitalism) and at the same time advocate for human society to find a way to transcend our base natures and evolve a society and economic system not built on them. Transcending our base nature is the whole point of culture.
- hammock 4y agoThomas Jefferson to John Adams, 1787: What country before ever existed a century and half without a rebellion? And what country can preserve its liberties if their rulers are not warned from time to time that their people preserve the spirit of resistance? Let them take arms. The remedy is to set them right as to facts, pardon and pacify them. What signify a few lives lost in a century or two? The tree of liberty must be refreshed from time to time with the blood of patriots and tyrants. It is its natural manure. He seemed to believe in warfare theory
- Gys 4y agoI wonder if he still would be with the current state of arms and options for mass destruction.
- googlryas 4y agoMaybe? Flintlock muskets were fairly new technology around the US revolution - less than 100 years before that, people would have been using match locks and arquebuses - relatively the difference is probably similar to the difference between a smith and wesson revolver and an AR-15.
- eric-hu 4y agoDid “right to bear arms” ever include larger weapons like cannons? I’ve kind of wondered why the second amendment doesn’t cover larger and more destructive things.
- simonh 4y agoYou could own canons. Civilian ships sometimes carried them.
- pokey00 4y agoTough question to answer. Historically, privately owned artillery has been OK and was crucial during the Revolutionary War and all sorts of little skirmishes throughout the 19th century. It still is OK with the right tax stamps, but that doesn't say much about the natural right side of things... just because you can own them doesn't make ownership constitutionally protected. My pet theory that I've espoused on here before is that the 2A, in part, protects at minimum "bearable arms"- essentially a soldier's personal weapon. There's a very big gray area outside of that though, especially in regards to anything that explodes.
- bell-cot 4y agoGrumpy Geezer reaction to the title: "None of the kids behind that Controversial Study knew squat about the history of Rome, did they? Nor game theory. Nor..."
- tut-urut-utut 4y agoWar is an evolution on a societal organization level. Survival of the fittest. Through wars, we get to find out which system better and organizational structure fits better in the current world. Is it a fake democracy, anarchy, or an autocracy? Who will survive in the end? What kind of balance between military, science and economy works the best? What is more important, human rights of all in and out groups, or cohesion of the main societal group? Should the decision makers be people we elect, or "objectively" most capable and smartest individuals. We all played Civilization, and we know that different societies have different trade-offs and balances. The principle is the same in the real world, just more nuanced and complex. And it takes decades to show the results. Back to the question if the warfare make societies more complex? Maybe, but only in cases where more complex societies win the war, which is not always. We may consider current Afghanistan under Taliban one of the simplest societal structure, and they won hands-down against a complex alliance of complex organized societies.
- eterevsky 4y agoSince the study concerns itself mostly with ancient civilizations, a better title would be "_Did_ warfare make societies more complex". We can't extrapolate the findings about the ancient societies to the post-industrial age.
- behnamoh 4y agoAll these comments and no mention of World War I and II. Despite their unacceptable destruction and loss of life, one can't deny their effect of the world's geopolitics (e.g., the start of the cold war, splitting countries—such as the Ottoman empire—into smaller countries, the famine in Iran due to Russian and British forces, etc.). Moreover, technology as we know it got a tremendous boost during the big wars. Think about V2 (which made NASA and the moon landings a possibility), Enigma, Turing's computer, lots of advances in biology (for warfare purposes at first), advances in aviary, etc. It's as if the humanity needed a _boost_. Too sad that it was war that did the trick.
- majormajor 4y agoThe book Metropolis by Ben Wilson - focusing on cities more than the empires that may or may not have been around them - provides an alternate view where societal complexity and trade and cultural development are much more linked through cities - a mostly-virtuous cycle of proximity and trade enabling specialization and unlocking additional development. This bit from the linked article makes me wary of their correlation/causation jump: "But she thinks the time between advances in agriculture and military technology and the development of social complexity is too long to be confident about their impact. She says a lag time of 300 to 400 years between the arrival of ironworking and horses and the rise of an empire suggests “military technology must be viewed as a very remote predictor of the outcome.”" Part of Metropolis, though, can also be read as a cautionary tale about neglecting weapons development. The problem is that someone else can always be a bigger asshole: a thriving trade network across many different civilizations in the Indian Ocean was wrecked, conquered, and colonized by religious-driven aggression by the Portuguese when European civilization finally caught back up and was much more armed since Europeans had spent the time just before that in years of fighting amongst themselves.
- namuol 4y agoOn the other hand, war is actually very bad and avoidable.
- antihipocrat 4y agoHow is it avoidable? If it can't be 100% avoided we still have to be prepared, just in case.
- proc0 4y agoIsn't the idea that war is completely bad relatively new? Ancient people had gods of war, although how exactly they were regarded I'm not sure, but it seems to me there was a more balanced view of life and death, and the cycle of a society. So war was viewed as inevitable, especially since the world was so unknown and mysterious. > competition is what drives societies to become more complex, building more hierarchical armies to fight ever-more-complex wars and organizing increasingly bureaucratic governments to manage diverse resources and growing populations. This reminds me how the competition between the different species of humans millions of years ago engaged in a cognitive race, making more complex tools and language. The bigger brain homo-sapiens won the war it seems, but we then had to deal with our internal competition. Maybe war is some kind of continuation of the cognitive race.