16 ms·
‘Blade Runner’ at 40
- modeless 4y agoI had a professor in college who was obsessed with Blade Runner and had us watch it in class. I just didn't get it. I mean I love sci-fi, but Blade Runner was just OK. Maybe in the context of its time it was great, pioneering, all that stuff. But in the context of now, or even back when I was in college (closer to the release of Blade Runner than present day, yikes), it didn't seem that special to me. I guess now that I have kids I'll soon be on the other side trying to convince them that the old stuff I like is cool and special, and they'll prefer the new stuff.
- adam_arthur 4y agoAgreed. Great movie, but many movies from the past fail to hold up simply due to lower production values... which also feeds into the storytelling element
- x3iv130f 4y agoDon't tell the diehard fans but I prefer the theatrical edition as the story works better in a shorter punchier presentation.
- antishatter 4y agoWith the hilariously bad harrison ford voice over? my god man.
- tingol 4y agoYeah, I'm not opening any movie topics on HN based on replies to this one :D
- georgeecollins 4y agoThere are pros and cons to the theatrical version, so I think your opinion has merit. The original script had vo, and that fits with the noir movie style they were trying to achieve. Unfortunately Harrison Ford was not into doing vo. But it is a more concise version.
- bigDinosaur 4y agoThe version with the VO? If so, that literally treats the audience like they're incapable of understanding blatant metaphor. Contrast the theatrical cut: https://youtu.be/AJzIT6fQ3OU https://youtu.be/AJzIT6fQ3OU (VO at 4:13) with the director's cut: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NoAzpa1x7jU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NoAzpa1x7jU The theatrical version is punchier because it's beating you over the head. For a film that's so heavily into metaphor (I mean, Rutger Hauer's character releases a dove at the end, maybe he just likes birds, we will never know since the VO doesn't explain it) it's quite boring to just be outright told what you're supposed to think. And even if you like your scenes explained in the most anodyne manner possible, it's well known that Harrison Ford was phoning it in for the overall performance but particularly the VO, so it's not even a well-done VO in terms of literal recording. Hardly a 'diehard fan', I like the aesthetic but it's an incredibly slow film, but I hate that VO with a passion.
- georgeecollins 4y agoI think if you saw it in the context of movies of its time you would understand the appeal, if not appreciate it. So many things imitate it that the most original parts seem like cliches. The other thing is that it holds up for most people, so that it is better when you go back to it because you see thing you missed the first time.
- golergka 4y agoThis is literally what “Seinfeld is unfunny” trope is about. The original, groundbreaking work gets quoted and used so much that a modern viewer doesn't see anything original in it anymore.
- modeless 4y agoSome things survive this process, though, and some don't. For example, I didn't see Alien until after I saw Blade Runner. I see Alien as more influential and copied than Blade Runner, yet I still think it's great.
- browningstreet 4y agoTo wit: I just watched Close Encounters on a plane. Surprised at how much Spielberg himself quoted from it. It feels like a mashup of ET, Indiana Jones and even Schindlers List.
- JeanMarcS 4y agoMy ex wife is 16 years younger than me (from 1987). So I made her watch many movies from the 80's and 90's that I think are classics. Well,most of the time she didn't apreciate them because she watched a lot of TV movies in her teens, and knew most of the plots and twists.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoI think it still holds up. Very few films are as bold and original today. Everything is CGI focus group contrived garbage now. What good recent scifi comes close? Dune? Bladerunner 2049?
- Apocryphon 4y agoEverything Everywhere All At Once
- AdamJacobMuller 4y agoMaybe Dune, but, Dune is an unfinished sentence.
- ur-whale 4y ago> Maybe Dune I don't think Dune, the 2022 version will make it to the heights Blade Runner is at. There are some scenes that give you Blade Runner level shivers (e.g. the Sardaukar assembly on Salusa Secundus), but they're few and far between. And if you meant the original Dune ... nah, it certainly hasn't aged as well as BR.
- AdamJacobMuller 4y agoI mean the 2022 one. The 1984 one has not aged well. I'm quite the fan of the 2000 tv mini-series one though. Maybe it will rise to the levels of great sci-fi, maybe it will not, I won't judge it till I can see the complete picture. It has the correct aesthetic and the truly shiver-worthy moments are yet to come.
- einpoklum 4y agoI'd say the exact opposite. The 2022 version - it's nice; I could fault it here or there, but it has a lot of going for it. But... it only goes so far. It doesn't reach the dramatic heights of Lynch's creation, and the mystique of the design. (Of course one should try and watch one of the longer cuts with more of the dialog and establishing scenes.)
- zepearl 4y ago> I guess now that I have kids I'll soon be on the other side trying to convince them that the old stuff I like is cool and special, and they'll prefer the new stuff. Absolutely, hehe. (I love the old Blade Runner, not at all the new one) > I had a professor in college who was obsessed with Blade Runner and had us watch it in class. To balance that out, our religion teacher showed us The Exorcist ( https://www.themoviedb.org/movie/9552-the-exorcist https://www.themoviedb.org/movie/9552-the-exorcist ) - sounds hard but to be fair anybody who did not want to watch it was allowed to leave the room & come back later.
- phkahler 4y ago>> now that I have kids I'll soon be on the other side trying to convince them that the old stuff I like is cool and special Nope. Kids today have access to everything under the sun. The classics still resonate with them. My kid loves Queen and Zepplin. Enjoyed the hell out of "They Live", the Matrix and many other classic movies. Not so much John Carpenters "the Thing" which even I found a bit slow these days. A lot of this was discovered without my introduction too. Music in particular. Share the movies without explanation. Classics are universal.
- hedora 4y agoOh crap; they cancelled Raised by Wolves: https://www.cheatsheet.com/entertainment/raised-by-wolves-cast-fans-team-try-save-series.html/ https://www.cheatsheet.com/entertainment/raised-by-wolves-ca... Unbelievable! (Ridley Scott was involved with it.)
- micromacrofoot 4y agoit wasn’t particularly good, I really really wanted to like it and persevered through the whole thing… and it’s just a mess
- AdamJacobMuller 4y agoI really enjoyed the aesthetic of it, I enjoyed the tone and even many of the major story elements but I found it so hard to track the story. It's unfortunate because the show had the great thematic elements (Mithraic vs atheist war -- mother as a godlike angel etc) and had amazing small details but lost itself somewhere in-between. Why was there a giant worm and why did everyone forget about the giant worm in Season 2 ? This might be a Ridley Scott problem, because, everything I said can also apply to Prometheus.
- jghn 4y agoIt's a Ridley Scott problem. Everything I've seen in the last several years that he's had a hand in (another example is Taboo) is visually amazing but confusing.
- micromacrofoot 4y ago> I really enjoyed the aesthetic of it, I enjoyed the tone and even many of the major story elements but I found it so hard to track the story. Yeah this is exactly what Ridley Scott has done for the past couple decades. It always feels like his stuff is supposed to be twice as long, and we're only getting half the story.
- browningstreet 4y agoIt was better than Foundation…
- JKCalhoun 4y agoMind-blowing art-direction/set-decorating/costumes when it came out. I have to make an excuse to get up though when Harrison Ford tries to play a nerdy fan in the Zhora character's dressing room. So bad.
- mhh__ 4y agoIsn't that the express purpose of the scene?
- anigbrowl 4y agoThat's because Deckard is lying to her (poorly). Remember, he's not that good of a detective. They use him because he's willing to do dirty work and is expendable.
- JKCalhoun 4y agoIt feels like he's not that good of an actor, frankly.
- xsmasher 4y agoI love it when an actor has to play at being a bad actor. It really highlights their craft. Harrison Ford is a great actor, Deckard is not. It's Deckard that is failing to be convincing in that scene, not Ford.
- schmeckleberg 4y agoIf you are a true connoisseur of cringe, see if you can find "The Eiger Sanction" with Clint Eastwood and George Kennedy. There's a part in that flick where Clint Eastwood's character pretends to be a gay-coded deliveryman with a package of dental floss. "What am I gonna do with this boxth of floth?" Unforgettably bad but mostly unforgettable :)
- jmyeet 4y agoI am one of the 11 people on Earth that hates coffee. "Hate" isn't strong enough. Even "despises" I'm not sure goes far enough. It tastes disgusting to me. I can't even stand the smell. This has led me at times to wonder if I'm crazy or if everyone else is. I do notice a ton of people consume a ton of sugar in their coffee so it seems like many don't really like coffee. They like sugar. But I digresss. I have the same "am I crazy?" thoughts with Blade Runner. Unlike coffee it's not bad (subjectively). I just don't get the hype. It's a product of its time too. I'd put it in the 80s Cyberpunk bucket where the noir surroundings and mega corporations are a product of xenophobia, basically. There were genuine fears the Japanese were "taking over". And Blade Runner reflects this zeitgeist. In Blade Runner it's the Tyrell Corporation. In Aliens it was the Weyland-Yutani Corporation. Rutger Hauer did give a good performance and there were some good lines [1] but I'd never put it in my list of top films. Not even my list of top sci-fi films. It is better than Interstellar though, which is trash, so there's that. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wRxHYHPzs7s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wRxHYHPzs7s
- aglavine 4y agoBlade Runner was truly original.And it was truly copied all over the place.
- HorizonXP 4y agoI have to ask then, what films do you like better than Interstellar?
- fb03 4y agoI was also baffled by the "interstellar is trash" line. Maybe I watched it wrong.
- AdamJacobMuller 4y agoI didn't love Interstellar the first time I saw it. When I watched Inception for the first time I walked out of the theatre in love with that movie (and I still am), but, leaving Interstellar I felt confused and underwhelmed. Perversely I think I was actually very overwhelmed by Interstellar because after seeing it many times in the almost a decade since it came out (oh my god how has it been 10 years) it's become one of my favorite films, but, there is just so much going on that it was difficult to connect with it on the first viewing.
- SoftTalker 4y agoThis is one movie that has put me to sleep every time I tried to watch it. I have never seen it beginning to end.
- davesque 4y agoCalling it the "greatest of all time" seems like a total exaggeration. That being said, I've found it interesting that a film that in many ways seems so dated manages to have such a hypnotic effect on me every time I watch it. I think it's just one of Ridley Scott's directorial gifts that he manages to conjure up such an infectious mood in so many of his films. Of course, the other example is Alien. I definitely love a good viewing of Blade Runner when I'm content to chew on some slow paced sci-fi.
- AdamJacobMuller 4y ago> Calling it the "greatest of all time" seems like a total exaggeration I was thinking this at first but I've struggled with a suggestion of a better, and critically more impactful/influential, movie in the genere.
- willhinsa 4y ago2001: A Space Odyssey
- muro 4y agoThe "ages" jumping weirdness just ruined it, IMHO. Beautiful middle part, though.
- AdamJacobMuller 4y agoBeautiful opening, great story in the middle, utterly incomprehensible ending. Kubrick was no doubt a genius and mystery is a part of storytelling, the entirety of Eyes Wide Shut leaves so much room for mystique and interpretation that we can debate and discuss it forever but I did not find similar in the ending of 2001, it seemed like confusion for confusions sake with little deeper meaning.
- colordrops 4y agoArthur C Clarke is one of the greatest sci fi authors of all time and wrote the book in conjunction with the movie with Stanley Kubrick. They are meant to be consumed together. Read the book and the movie makes a lot more sense. There is virtually zero ambiguity if you read the book.
- duxup 4y agoI hated that movie the first to I saw it. I was bored with it. Now I love it. I really enjoy how much time they spend establishing the atmosphere and characters. It all feels very real and has depth. I loath the speedy sci fi that tries to touch on atmosphere and then hurries along with their paper characters and so on. So much sci fi I encounter now feels little more than a long trailer with no idea how to end.
- melling 4y agoYeah, I don’t recalling loving it either. Perhaps as a kid, it wasn’t upbeat enough for me. In 1982, 2019 sure looked exciting though. Androids, flying cars, … I hope kids today have a much more interesting future 40 years from now.
- nick__m 4y agoI hope kids today have a much more interesting future 40 years from now. I am sure that they will live in interesting time but I doubt that it is a blessing.
- Agentlien 4y agoI'm the other way around. I loved the atmosphere and the slow pace when I first saw it. But ever since I read the book I can't enjoy it the same way. I feel it just doesn't do it justice.
- JeanMarcS 4y agoI'm another way around: I read the book then watch the movie not long after. I slept. And everytime I try to watch it I get bored quick. I think I would have much more apreciate it, the atmosphere et all, if I hadn't read the book before. And I realy regret it because I know it's a good movie.
- robertbarbe 4y agoThe book has a level emotional depth of that is not matched in the film. The first dialogue between Deckhart and his wife (yes he is married in the book) is really clever and meta. I was extremely disappointed by the film (I first saw it 2 years ago) and it feels very dated and has that 80s men-women cringe-portrayal. I agree, read the book it is awesome!
- kebman 4y agoThinking about what was possible to make in 1982, it's pretty amazing. It's an absolute classic, up there with the best of the noirs (the actual film noirs), such as The Maltese Falcon, Double Indemnity and The Third Man; the logical answer to the Neo Noir Body Heat the year before. It's like a legacy moving onto such things as Ghost in the Shell and even The Matrix.
- bsder 4y agoAnd I think that's why it flopped initially but has such staying power. Balde Runner is fundamentally film noir and the sci-fi is just the setting. The essential conflicts are human conflicts--not technological ones. You can replace the setting and you still have mostly the same story.
- deltaonefour 4y agoBut if you replaced the setting with a mundane one the movie would be a generic film noir. It only works because of the combination of the setting and the story.
- hodgesrm 4y agoI disagree. I'm a big fan of Chandler and his monumental creation, Philip Marlowe. Deckard is quite a different character. Just comparing the two, Deckard's role is to be a witness to Batty's dawning humanity (as well as Rachel's I suppose). I think that's one of the things that gives the movie the feeling of extraordinary redemption at the end. There's no such sense of redemption in Chandler--the Marlowe storylines revolve around the struggle to keep a moral compass in the midst of societal corruption, in line with the common definition of the Noir genre. [0] (I'm thinking particularly of The Long Goodbye but it's common to all the Marlowe stories.) Just my $0.02. It's definitely fun to think about. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noir_fiction https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Noir_fiction
- aglavine 4y agoNot even a word there in the note devoted to goddess Daryl Hannah.
- aresant 4y agoThe visual language Bladerunner invented has virtually defined SciFi for the past 40 years. If you enjoy it's worth digging into the work Syd Mead - the film's concept artist - created: https://www.flickr.com/photos/x-ray_delta_one/5642443624/in/album-72157622906191929/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/x-ray_delta_one/5642443624/in/... https://www.flickr.com/photos/x-ray_delta_one/5642443252/in/album-72157622906191929/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/x-ray_delta_one/5642443252/in/... https://www.flickr.com/photos/x-ray_delta_one/5641873923/in/album-72157622906191929/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/x-ray_delta_one/5641873923/in/... https://www.flickr.com/photos/x-ray_delta_one/5642441904/in/album-72157622906191929/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/x-ray_delta_one/5642441904/in/... Syd's work in general is worth a deeper investigation if interested -> https://sydmead.com/ https://sydmead.com/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/40143737@N02/albums/72157622906191929/ https://www.flickr.com/photos/40143737@N02/albums/7215762290... https://www.iamag.co/the-art-of-syd-mead/ https://www.iamag.co/the-art-of-syd-mead/
- shaftoe444 4y agoThese links are excellent and I hadn't heard of Syd Mead despite being a long time fan of this film. Thank you for posting.
- nico 4y agoThere is also the failed attempt of Jodorowsky to make a Dune movie: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jodorowsky's_Dune https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jodorowsky's_Dune https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dune_(novel)#Early_stalled_attempts https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dune_(novel)#Early_stalled_a... The documentary is pretty fascinating. Jodorowsky managed to put together a stellar team, among them H.R. Giger, Dalí and the script writer who would later write Alien.
- CyanBird 4y agoYeah, it is thanks to these two movies that modern scifi and its visual development side of things exists basically
- 4y ago
- easeout 4y agoJust an incredible film. Even the slow parts, and there are a lot of them, have so much rich setting to marvel at. The love scene comes across as nonconsensual and it makes me uncomfortable every time. Whether that's intended discomfort or an artistic regret, I don't know. Other than that, it's one of my all time favorites for the reasons others are mentioning. I recommend the 2007 Final Cut.
- norin 4y agoI've pretty much owned every copy of the first movie. I still hear Roy's haunting message as a razor blade going through my skull.
- jansan 4y ago“I've seen things you people wouldn't believe. Attack ships on fire off the shoulder of Orion. I watched C-beams glitter in the dark near the Tannhäuser Gate. All those moments will be lost in time, like tears in rain. Time to die.” For me probably the best monologue in movie history.
- nabla9 4y agoBlade Runner suffers from the same problem as every other important classic. Younger generations who see it today have already seen 100s's of movies and TV-series, anime etc. that are based on aesthetics and narrative of Blade Runner. The original has little originality left for new viewers because it has been endlessly copied and they have already been immersed in it. Another great example is Friz Lang's M (1931). It has influenced everyone from Hitchcock to everything in Film Noir. If you watch it now it's almost comical. It has every trope of serial killer movie. Except everyone else is copying M. Even if you have not watched the movie, you have already seen the movie thousands of times.
- gravelc 4y agoIt’s long been my favourite film, so I guess that makes it the GOAT. That soundtrack never fails to resonate. The moral ambiguity of everyone is so well balanced. The set design and props. Everything, really.
- deltaonefour 4y agoBlade runner isn't even that good, thematically. But I get why it's considered the best. It's because in most sci-fi movies a lot of effort is spent on the setting and thus the story while many times is good, often lacks the depth of their non-fiction counter-parts. Bladerunner is one of the few movies that has blockbuster level visuals while maintaining a very serious story with a lot of depth. Gattaca is another sci-fi movie that achieves this as well, though the visuals in Gattaca aren't blockbuster level.
- jogjayr 4y agoMost of Gattaca is shot indoors and the sets have a very minimalist aesthetic. It looks futuristic, but since their budget was quite low* it was also a way to keep costs down. The visuals bear no comparison at all to Blade Runner. It's an incredible movie nevertheless. * I quite enjoyed how astronauts wear a suit and tie even on spaceship launches. Out-of-universe that was probably because they didn't have the budget for spacesuit costumes. But in-universe it is still legitimately a "space suit" and might be a nod to how formal the Gattacca workplace setting is (I've read too much r/moviedetails).
- justin66 4y agoNothing against Andrew Niccol, who wrote and directed Gattaca, but the same film with the same actors, directed by Ridley Scott, is really something to contemplate.
- deltaonezero 4y agoRidley Scott isn't a director that just does contemplative movies all the time. A lot of his stuff flat out just average (Prometheus for example) and he even does raw action blockbusters like gladiator that are very far away from being as thematically engaging as BR. If ridley scott did Gattaca, there'd definitely be more of a budget on the sci-fi setting. It'd be more grounded and gritty with less of an 80s aesthetic. As for whether it'd be as good as Andrew Niccols' version well... that's hard to say given Scotts hit or miss track record.
- dm8 4y agoBlade Runner is one of those movies that gets better every time you watch. First time I watched it, I was thoroughly bored. But over the years I seem to appreciate the deeper meaning under it. It tries to present some fundamental questions - "what separates humans from robot/AI?, Is it the act of humans giving birth to other humans or feelings or deeds?, Is robot/AI superior to human or vice a versa?" For those who find this movie boring, I'd recommend reading the book - "Do Androids dream of electric sheep" and maybe then watch the movie. I was born after it was released yet I find it's imagery unique even now. Every frame feels like an elaborate painting/artwork. I can imagine how innovative might've been when it was first released in early eighties.
- forgetfulness 4y agoThe strongest point of the movie was really the question of what makes us human. Given that it's stated that Rachael was a replicant, there's the contrast of her character with that of Deckard, who we are led to believe is human. Rachael, being a human creation, is made to embody what we think makes us unique and precious, the best version of ourselves we could think of. A worthy successor even. The tension with Deckard is that you have to question if his, say, minimalist expression of those qualities disqualify him as human, even though we know well enough that he's perfectly within the range of human expression in reality, and you would only doubt his humanity in light of the existence of artificial humans who visibly display a greater, more intense range of the human experience than him. Not that they have a choice, either. Of course then comes the filmmaker to state his intention with it, which takes away the mystique, but eh the artist having a more boring opinion on a work than the people who enjoy it is something that has been quipped about since antiquity.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- moltude 4y agoThe soundtrack/score by Vangelis is entirely underrated.
- globular-toast 4y agoIt's very well rated in the electronic music community. In the 90s it was common to hear it mixed into trance sets by Paul Oakenfold.
- mhh__ 4y agoI'd say it's underrated by people today who've only ever experienced Hans Zimmer but those who've heard it love it, surely.
- dekhn 4y agoI bought the soundtrack :) Good background for programming.
- Barrin92 4y agoI like Blade Runner but I don't think it has aged particularly well, it was very much a product of its time even though ironically enough at the time it was very much unique. What made this really clear to me was the sequel which I think was way too literal about the aesthetics. Flying cars and CEOs living in ziggurats and CCCP banners made the new movie almost seem like a caricature. It's retrofuturism, like Back to the Future almost rather than science fiction. And that has somehow impacted my experience of the original now too which seems more dated to me now. What does stand the test of time though is Rutger Hauer's performance and the humanism that he has given his character, something that was absent in the sequel.
- fartcannon 4y agoAs a slight aside, isn't it amazing that art exists? I like to just stand back and appreciate that humans both make and love art. And it's not one thing, it's so. many. things. I especially like that some people like some art and not other art. It means there's complexity to it. And we can harness it to make beauty.
- tus666 4y agoStar Wars was better.
- mhh__ 4y agoWhat is star wars actually about though. There's probably no blade runner without star wars but it's just childish/shallow if you don't buy into George Lucas. The originals are good movies but only empire is truly great and even then it's just a good flick. It asks almost no questions of the audience.
- corrral 4y ago> The originals are good movies but only empire is truly great and even then it's just a good flick. It asks almost no questions of the audience. Star Wars (as in, "Episode IV: A New Hope") gets a lot of points on the greatness scale for basically inventing the multi-genre pastiche film, and for being a pretty good example of the practice. Empire's a better movie in a lot of ways, but less ground-breaking as far as the storytelling goes. But yeah, no Star Wars films are high art. The first two, especially, though, get a lot of basic stuff right and have fairly straightforward plots, so they make for excellent examples for illustrating many of aspects of film story-telling: mood, plotting, characterization, foreshadowing, setup/payoff in general, et c.
- mhh__ 4y agoThat's a fair assessment. I like them, I don't like the mythology of star wars movies. And not even the originals, people actually think the prequels are some misunderstood masterpieces...
- kennywinker 4y agoStar Wars isn't science fiction, it's fantasy
- deltaonefour 4y agoNo it's not. You're just getting too technical. Star wars is science fiction. Because in the same vein you could call LOTR science fiction too because the fantasy elements are just natural properties of the created world. The "magic" can technically be technology as well.
- bowsamic 4y agoNo one has captured cyberpunk so perfectly since. It is the ultimate visual and auditory expression of it. The sequel is also excellent
- Krasnol 4y agoThe sequel gave me more of a post-cyberpunk vibe and I feel like it was intended. They killed Capitalist-Tokyo-Dystopia and replaced it with Soviet Russia.
- mhh__ 4y ago2049 choosing to include Joi elevates it a little beyond the original in that regard for me. Replicants are more of a question about dehumanization whereas a true AI (with the projection to help the audience along) is much trickier. There's no flesh to hold and yet it seems to feel
- hujun 4y agoblade runner is good, however my personal best sci-fi film is matrix, specially the 1st one
- colordrops 4y agoI would disagree and posit that 2001 is the GOAT. Most scifi is heavily influenced by it. The artistry is unsurpassed. The scope and depth of the story is mind blowing. I was at lunch talking with coworkers about scifi movies. None of them even heard about 2001. It was quite shocking to me. I was the oldest at the table, but I'm not that old.
- mhh__ 4y ago2001 is a very different type of film though. Blade runner is a film I could get my marvel-loving friends to watch, they would not watch 25 of chimp on chimp action
- mhh__ 4y ago2049 is probably a better film in almost every way and yet the original is better just by virtue of the clarity of vision it had.
- meken 4y agoI think the first half was perfect. But then once the second half starts, it really feels like whole scenes are just omitted from the movie, it’s kind of all over the place (indeed, Ridley Scott says the whole film is over 4 hours).
- tingol 4y ago2049 did so many things well (great visuals, great acting, waaaay better love story, better detecting!), but the main story sucked so much. The messianic human/replicant hybrid and the foreshadowed uprising seemed so cheap. The original asked hard questions that's why it's still talked about, the sequel took it away and answered it itself and quite poorly IMO.
- mhh__ 4y agoI thought the story was fine. Blade Runner's story honestly isn't all that good, the concept of the memories and K's self-discovery is arguably better than the original if you imagine that the original barely has a story as per se (but does have a better defined set of plot-beats). 2049 feels like it asks less questions, but wait until we have better AI in 10 years and watch how prescient including Joi rather than a new replicant character is.
- kirevmaco 4y agoI saw 2049 when it came out. I didn't like the original film much but of course was still curious about the sequel since I liked the original novel. One problem I have with both these movies is that the whole "memories" thing doesn't have anything to do with the point the original novel was making. The main point of the original novel is that the replicants are fake human beings which are not only deplorable due to their lack of empathy but are also rather dangerous, and that real human beings will likely become dehumanized ourselves in our eventual efforts to eradicate them. I'm paraphrasing Dick in that last sentence but you can hear the more full version in this interview: https://invidious.snopyta.org/watch?v=3d7XMnmPgUk https://invidious.snopyta.org/watch?v=3d7XMnmPgUk Anyway, I agree that 2049 has more of a plot than the original, but I lost most of my interest in the movie as soon as I realized that the main character was a replicant (which unfortunately happened pretty early on). Great cinematography though.
- rr808 4y agoBladerunner 2049 is better.
- sanj 4y agoSo, is Deckard a replicant?
- gallerdude 4y agoWhy don’t you ask him?
- jq-r 4y agoOf course he is.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoOf course, he isn't. Later attempts to shoehorn him into being one in subsequent editions cheapen Batty's act of forgiving him. Thus, it is wrong.
- forgetfulness 4y agoDeckard being a replicant makes for a good sci-fi twist, heavier on the technological aspect of sci-fi rather than the reflection of our worries that it commonly poses, and an interesting solution to The Question as a puzzle. And also cheapens the plot and the questions it poses by a lot, a lot. The movie leaves you with more after watching it if he isn't, or if it's just ambiguous.
- forgetfulness 4y agoIt's ambiguous in the film and far more interesting if he's not, as it becomes an interrogation of what makes us human, and forces us to accept our imperfection and that of our fellow man. Well, besides that you know, the obvious implications for the rights of intelligent beings, natural or not, but since we won't have strong AI for a while and it wasn't about animal rights no matter how much you stretch it, we're left with questions about our own nature and how we relate to other humans.
- Sporktacular 4y agoRidley Scott is a middling, hit and miss director who has said that if something does well he'll follow up with sequels. It's a kind of throw it at the wall and see what sticks approach as opposed to committing to a vision and knowing when to let it end. Blade Runner was an ambitious, pretty, ambient but also boring film. To refer to it as the GOAT is hyperbolic. To call Scott a genius etc. because of Blade Runner is also unjustified because all its strengths trace directly to PKD, Syd Mead, Jordan Cronenweth etc. It's one seriously overhyped film. All subjective of course, but then so are such articles and they arguably add to the hype.
- cm2187 4y agoI agree, and Blade Runner is very dated (80s fashion and music). Alien on the other hand hasn’t aged a bit, and along 2001 and Star Wars really defined scifi movies. The same guy reinvented peplums with Gladiator, and war movies with Black Hawk Down. I think it’s enough to justify all the misses. You can download IMDB’s database as flat files. It is interesting to see the evolution of imdb ratings over a director’s career. Some are remarkably stable like Woody Allen or Martin Scorsese. Some others falter like Brian de Palma. Ridley Scott has some ups and down but is fairly stable over a long career.
- hrocha1 4y agoFrom my experience all atmospheric films are like this. Some people love them, some people find them boring because they are more about visuals/sounds/music/feelings rather than plot lines or action scenes.
- als0 4y agoI'd also add that the soundtrack by Vangelis was just as critical as the film's visual elements.
- tim333 4y agoMeh - it's quite good. On IMDB rankings the best three are Inception, The Empire Strikes Back and The Matrix.
- rainworld 4y agoAs for The Question, I believe there is a fairly unambiguous answer... http://www.gavinrothery.com/my-blog/2011/10/1/a-matter-of-electric-sheep.html http://www.gavinrothery.com/my-blog/2011/10/1/a-matter-of-el...
- mhh__ 4y agoHampton Fancher I think once said the question is more interesting than the answer, I'm inclined to agree, although once you notice the nudging in the sequel it's more funny than anything else.
- fullshark 4y agoThey were stuck in the sequel, needed Harrison Ford (who has aged dramatically) to be in the film for financial reasons, and also needed to pay lip service to the supposed answer. So I think there's one scene that outlines how it could be possible that made no sense but was clearly shoehorned in there.
- mhh__ 4y agoI think that was more of a nod to the writer's and I assume director's respect for but disagreement with Ridley Scott's thesis. They don't actually think Deckard is a replicant, but they're more than happy to channel the idea of him being a replicant, but it's through Gaff where it can either come across as subtle misdirection, a hint to a wayward soul (K), or just playing tricks on someone that presumably took over his job - "something in his eyes".
- fullshark 4y agoWhen I first got really into Blade Runner, having first seen the original director's cut, I enjoyed the question as a puzzle to be solved. Really got into fan theories online and the unicorn dream was the smoking gun, and wasn't that so clever! So cool. Then I read a compelling essay online (that I can no longer find) that pointed out the entire film's thematic weight only exists if the opposite holds. I also saw the original theatrical cut and read interviews with the screenwriter and Harrison Ford and it became clear that the unicorn dream was basically a retcon by Ridley Scott and it really makes no sense for it to be there. So my version of Blade Runner is basically the final cut without the unicorn dream, that is a perfect film, ambiguous without that "smoking gun." (don't worry I read your essay...and now THAT is a fan theory)
- gambiting 4y agoI was bored with it when I first saw it, I'm still bored with it having seen it again recently. It's just so....full of itself. Like oh my god, you think you're trying to say something deep and meaningful, but you really aren't. The cinematography is still incredible and the film deserves all the praise in that department. But the whole philosophical argument being made there has the depth of a teaspoon. I just laugh when the villain makes his monologue at the end, you can almost feel the writer behind those lines straining with all their might to write something, anything that would be interesting in any way, and just failing completely.
- Andrew_nenakhov 4y agoI have a personal opinion about voice-overs that were removed in later editions. Typically, people hate them, and truly, they are somewhat out of place when you hear them. However, they get much better on subsequent viewings of more modern cuts, when you don't hear them, but you remember them.
- mhh__ 4y agoThe idea of a gruff but charismatic Harrison Ford ticking the story along isn't a bad one I suppose. It just ended like https://youtu.be/m__PBksZ0zA https://youtu.be/m__PBksZ0zA
- Simplicitas 4y agoArguably one of the best reproduction of an artist's https://bleedingcool.com/movies/philip-k-dick-blade-runner/ https://bleedingcool.com/movies/philip-k-dick-blade-runner/
- imwillofficial 4y ago“Less gym-bro than The Terminator” That’s a stupid way to sum up a classic like The Terminator
- mhh__ 4y ago"He gets a gun put to his head and then he fucks a dishwasher." - Rutger Hauer in mark kermodes excellent documentary On the edge of blade runner https://youtu.be/g3mq-1jcFzk https://youtu.be/g3mq-1jcFzk
- FpUser 4y agoIn my "the greatest" collection. Keep watching it every 3-4 years.
- gerdesj 4y agoThat's Sir Ridley Scott to you 8) Quite a bright boy but a phenomenal director and producer.
- shaggie76 4y agoAbout 20 years ago I ripped the DVD audio to MP3 so I could immerse myself in the amazing soundscapes from this film on the go. The soundtrack is great, don't get me wrong, but I think the sound is magnificent.
- auggierose 4y agoCouldn't freaking agree more. My favourite movie, undisputedly. I couldn't believe my eyes when I saw it the first time, it is all so perfect, the actors, the atmosphere, the soundtrack, the story, the ideas. "Memories. You're talking about memories!". And although I am also a big fan of P.K. Dick, it is good that the movie does its own thing and that there are no electric sheep in it.
- trentnix 4y agoBlade Runner is best viewed on the biggest screen you can get. First time I watched it was on VHS on a small CRT and I didn’t get it. Now, on the living room big screen, it’s immersive and sublime. A theatrical environment makes all the difference. Same thing happened to me with Ghost in the Shell. I didn’t appreciate it until I saw it on a big screen.
- willis936 4y agoI share a lot of thoughts with the RLM re:View of Blade Runner. It seems that Ridley Scott misunderstood his creation, much like George Lucas with Star Wars. It's one of those strange times where the vision of one is much weaker than the sum of many visions amalgamated. https://youtu.be/adjfTktpIzg https://youtu.be/adjfTktpIzg
- kirevmaco 4y agoThanks for posting that, it was hilarious. I'll definitely re-watch the part where they're quoting him directly again when I need a good laugh. I wouldn't say he misunderstood his creation, I would rather say that he didn't care about the source material and made something different, with themes that weren't really thought through too well. I agree that the sum of the visions amalgamated is better than the vision of the director in this case.
- butterisgood 4y agoYeah.. no. It’s a watchable film. It’s entertaining. But it’s also kinda rapey.
- kirevmaco 4y ago"The main difference between what Ridley views this all in terms of and what I view it all in terms of is as follows. To me, the replicants (or androids, if you will) are deplorable because [inaudible] they are cold, they are selfish, they are heartless, they are completely self-centered, they have no empathy, they don't care about what happens to other creatures, and to me this is essentially a less-than-human entity for that reason. Now, Ridley said that he regarded them as supermen who couldn't fly. He said they are smarter than humans, they are stronger than humans, and they have faster reflexes than humans. Well, then I said 'well, gee Ridley, I mean, holy smokes, uh, golly,' and that was about all I could think of to say, you know. That's rather a great divergence, you see: we've gone from somebody who is a simulation of the authentic human to somebody who is literally superior to the authentic human. So we've now flipped all the cards on the table, you see, when we do that: in other words, all the cards that were up are now down and all the ones that were down are now up. And I was at a loss at that point, you know, to respond, I mean. I said, 'okay, now the theme of the book is that Rick Deckard is dehumanized in his job of tracking down the replicants and killing them, that in other words he winds up essentially like they are.' And Ridley said that he regarded that as an intellectual idea and he was not interested in making an esoteric film." -- Philip K. Dick, interview with Paul M. Sammon (https://invidious.snopyta.org/watch?v=3d7XMnmPgUk https://invidious.snopyta.org/watch?v=3d7XMnmPgUk starting at 19:10)
- JohnJamesRambo 4y ago>they are cold, they are selfish, they are heartless, they are completely self-centered, they have no empathy, they don't care about what happens to other creatures Are we sure that there aren’t a lot of replicants walking around already?
- 8bitsrule 4y agoIf you can find a copy 'out there', [2] the 1980 film version [1] of LeGuin's novel 'The Lathe of Heaven' has something of the BR 'feel' to it. (Made by WNET it was aired on many PBS stations at the time.) [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lathe_of_Heaven_(film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Lathe_of_Heaven_(film) Interesting trivia: that Dick and LeGuin both graduated from the same Berkeley High School in 1947. [2]Edit: of course [480p largest] ... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M8VRbaVNvSA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M8VRbaVNvSA
- TedDoesntTalk 4y agoI just spent some time reading about this film amd trying to buy the dvd. Its on ebay for about $60. It's also on the thepiratebay.org with 6 seeders. Thanks for the recommendation.
- what-imright 4y agoBladerunner was great and the sequel was also enjoyable. but you know, these 80 sequels that have their characters stop and watch clips of the original movie are in the worst possible taste. it’s an admission that the current generation of directors are unable to compete w the former. this generation appears to be very much living in the shadows and riding the coattails of the last. it’s sad. I was expecting some off the wall novelty. for the most part, it’s CGI vomit with a regurgitated plot on the side
- Jaruzel 4y agoDon't forget the 3 'prequel' shorts, plus the Black Lotus anime series.
- russellbeattie 4y agoJust want to say for the record that I prefer the versions where Harrison Ford is narrating in his Sam Spade style voice over. It was the first version I saw in the 80s and I just like the nostalgia of it. Plus, when I first saw it, I was too young to realize how cliche it was, so it had the intended effect of "being inside the mind of a hard nosed investigator", and explaining the bewildering plot of course. But for me it was the feel of the narration that I liked.
- hoseja 4y ago>And, decades before Elon Musk looked set to take over the world, Blade Runner’s Tyrell Corporation (and indeed, Alien’s Weyland-Yutani) was inspiring evil empires (...) These journos just can't help themselves, can they. Why are you so willfully blind to all the other much worse ways the world is already "taken over" and focus so much on mean twitter man.
- mihaic 4y agoRon Cobb is my absolute favorite "hidden influence" on how 70s-80s sci-fi/fantasy turned out. He was a designer on Dark Star, Alien, Star Wars, Conan the Barbarian and even the unproduced Dune helmed by Jodorowsky that has become a shibboleth with some nerds. Nothing he did felt dogmatic, referential or with ego, it was just the most appropriate thing for those productions. Even though he didn't work on Blade Runner, I'm sure a lot of the esthetic comes indirectly from him.
- Kosirich 4y agoI highly recommend watching a short film inspired by Blade Runner, made by a small Croatian studio: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uyn0cLCMKsM https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uyn0cLCMKsM
- rendall 4y agoMy favoritest movie of all time. Blade Runner 2049 was a really good movie, but I don't consider it canon, Scott's endorsement notwithstanding. They were both awesome science fiction. The original was transformative, brilliant, hopeful and had a sense of humor; by contrast the sequel was dour, gloomy, pessimistic and despairing. Still, I am glad it was made, and I think Villeneuve is a phenomenal director. Arrival was amazing. Dune has been brilliant.