23 ms·
Sick and struggling to pay, 100M people in the U.S. live with medical debt
- Bostonian 4y agoDefining the problem so broadly makes it less likely that it will be solved. We already have high inflation in part because of high government transfers during the pandemic, and handing out money to 100M people with medical debt or student loan debt would aggravate this.
- suture 4y agoI find it odd that when talking about inflation or moral hazard people bring up money spent given to individuals but not about the trillions spent given to businesses. I think it is immoral for a country as wealthy as the United States to have so many people with medical debt. There should be universal, almost free healthcare. The moral imperative is far more important to me than considerations about inflation.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoI dislike adding morals into this discussion. However, there is a real question of whether society in its current state can, in fact, function well. I personally would argue that right now society is very dysfunctional and that dysfunction is primarily benefiting those at the top. And the usual issue with dysfunctional societies is that they tend to fall apart. Now, reasonable person would argue that would not be a good thing even for those on the top of the pile, but clearly no one is scared enough yet. All I want is balance. That societal balance does not exist now. Hence the tension that seems to be increasing.
- suture 4y agoI very much agree overall with your observations and points. I do think though that one should always consider moral aspects to policies and decision making since peoples’ lives are affected. Making policy based on economic theory without considering moral aspects seems like a bad idea in general.
- pjc50 4y agoReminds me of my joke policy that meets many people's stated goals yet would be universally unpopular: the government should fight inflation by confiscating money from billionaires and then destroying it.
- suture 4y agoVery nice. That would abrogate the concern that taxing the wealthy is socialist redistribution. Can’t have that accusation if you just burn it!
- dktokyo 4y agoTwo wildly different issues. Medical debt is still generally owed to payers, student loan debt (as considered in debt relief) is largely federal. The impacts of forgiveness of either would seem radically different.
- HarryHirsch 4y agohigh government transfers during the pandemic The government would like you to believe that, but a good chunk of the problem is supply-side, not demand-side.
- baremetal 4y agoMilton Friedman famously said: “Inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon, in the sense that it is and can be produced only by a more rapid increase in the quantity of money than in output.”
- HarryHirsch 4y agoWe have a housing crisis and an energy crisis. There's absolutely no need to drag monetary theory in when the outcome is due to failed industrial policy.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoWhy can't it be all three? I understand that it is easier to sell it as a specific political problem, but I am genuinely tired of arguing partial inflation problem, because discussing it as a whole undermines some political angle.
- pjc50 4y agoWell, he's wrong, given that output has been knocked about by a large number of non-monetary factors such as COVID, supply chain issues, the war with Russia, and (yet again) oil and gas.
- tdehnel 4y agoThe way I see it, even if there’s a war or Covid or whatever, if people don’t have more money to spend, they can’t pay higher prices. Then you get a recession. If they do have the money (because you printed more) they pay the higher prices. Then you get inflation.
- 1111567893 4y agoAnd letting people starve or die would have been better than inflation? I don't understand that point of view. It seems pretty cold to me.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- maxwell 4y ago
- lotsofpulp 4y agoDemocrats do not control the Senate.
- docdeek 4y agoThere are 48 Democrat Sentors and 2 Independents who caucus with the Democrats, one of whom has sought the Democratic nomination for President. That’s 50 votes, plus the Democratic VP to break any tie. While it might be correct to say the Democrats do not have a majority in the Senate, its not incorrect to say they do control the Senate.
- wilde 4y agoThe Democrats control the one spending bill a year subject to the Byrd rule. All other bills require 60 senators.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIn the context of voting for taxpayer funded healthcare, or any other broad population wide benefit program / tax increase, it would be inaccurate to label Manchin and Sinema as Democrats. Same as when Affordable Care Act was being molded, a couple of “Democrat” senators like Leiberman sank any chance a taxpayer funded option. Just like Manchin and Sinema sank Biden’s universal preschool/daycare and paid parental leave proposal last year.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 4y agoEh, both Manchin and Sinema self-identify as democracts, which some argue is all you really need these days. More importantly to me, however, if we rely on actions and not words, they consciously elect to remain members of Democractic party ( as opposed to say.. being Republican, Independent, Green or whatever ). For all practical reporting purposes, they are Democracts. The moment you apply 'but they voted for X', you can cast McConnel as a democract, because he greenlighted new gun deal.
- nottorp 4y agoI would read it but i can only agree to tracking.
- blendergeek 4y agoTry this link. https://text.npr.org/1104679219 https://text.npr.org/1104679219
- nottorp 4y agoBut NPR tried their damnedest to hide it from me. A while ago you could reject tracking and get the text only version of the article. Today I only saw "agree" and "see how we use cookies". No official pointer to the text site. So no, they can keep their article.
- abledon 4y agoso 30% of the country's population has medical debt.. what the hell
- thablackbull 4y agoAnd 70m of the population is 18 and under. So apparently the percentage of people with medical debt who are over 18 is quite substantial. Didn't realize it was so significant myself.
- treis 4y agoIt's an entire industry based on fraud and deception. My wife recently had surgery and we got hit with a $1500 surprise facility fee. It likely won't be covered by insurance due to some fuckery around not reimbursing the fee if the in plan physician owns the facility. We knew enough to ask about the anesthesiologist and any surgery assistants. But they came up with some new bullshit and got us. When the world gets wise to this nonsense they'll come up with something else. It's a business deeply rooted and based on scamming their customers.
- geoduck14 4y agoI don't see why this is a bad number. It is easy to get on a 0% payment plan for medical procedures, or to contest a medical bill that is "a debt" that will get paid eventually.
- refurb 4y ago
- rxhernandez 4y agoIn TFA: "A quarter of adults with health care debt owe more than $5,000."
- orangepurple 4y agoWould that mean 25 million adults with health care debt owe more than $5,000?
- formerkrogemp 4y agoYes.
- osrec 4y agoYes, assuming the 100m comprises of adults only, which is probably how they would have reported it.
- refurb 4y agoAgain, I “owed” that when my kid was born. Deductible plus co-insurance added up to about that. Not saying some people don’t have “bad” medical debt (they can’t repay) but to lump in all debt as “bad” is silly. Edit: Oh, it's a poll. Similar to the poll that said "Households earnings more than $250,000 are stuggling financially". I mean, it's a poll? Did you expect people to say "nah, I have medical debt but I can handle it no problem".
- NickC25 4y agoAnyone interested in this topic who wishes to explore it in depth should read Marty Markary's 2019 book "The Price We Pay". While slightly out-of-date due to legislation that has passed since then, the book does an excellent job of explaining a lot of the perverse incentives at all levels throughout the medical industry that contribute to the outrageously high cost of healthcare in the US. Worth a read.
- crisdux 4y agoI have issues with how they did their analysis. They count anyone who paid for medical services on a credit card and then is carrying that on their credit card balance month to month. Folks… that’s how many Americans pay for all goods and services and run their finances. The last time I checked, 60% of Americans carry a credit card balance from month to month. The findings in their report seem aligned to that. I think people are reading too much into a poor analysis, created and reported on by institutions with an obvious agenda.
- swarnie 4y agoAnyone fancy giving universal healthcare another stab? Either to save lives: https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/universal-health-care-could-have-saved-more-than-330-000-u-s-lives-during-covid/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/universal-health-... Or to save money: https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.2200536119 https://www.pnas.org/doi/full/10.1073/pnas.2200536119 The aversion to it honestly baffles me.
- jioujoijoijoi 4y ago
- thomasjudge 4y agoUnfortunately a majority of voters in this country reject single-payer coverage on the grounds that it is "socialist"
- jioujoijoijoi 4y agoNothing is outlawing liberal states from doing it.
- ishjoh 4y agoDrs and other high earners in the states that introduce socialized health care will leave immediately as the state institutes price controls. There is a reason so many Drs trained in Canada immigrate to the US.
- 1111567893 4y agoWithout every state agreeing to it, you end up with a race to the bottom.
- egberts1 4y agoAnyone who owes $5 or more in outstanding medical bill is counted as part of 1/3rd of country. Really? How about year-long debt or 30-60-90 day breakout chart by amount?
- lotsofpulp 4y agoIt is always the same poor journalism tactic of obscuring the distribution of data to make a “plausible” controversial claim. Similar to the oft quoted “Americans cannot afford a $500 emergency”.
- jioujoijoijoi 4y ago
- EricE 4y agoStill better than dealing with rationing. The rest of the world better hope the US never goes socialist with health care - kiss innovation goodbye.
- EricE 4y agoFor all the downvoters - this was also on the front page: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31767347 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31767347 Downvote away though :p
- jasongill 4y agoGo ask any law enforcement officer, fire fighter, or EMT how many times a week they hear "please don't call an ambulance, I can't afford it" and the answer will be so depressing that you may change your tone about this.
- wahnfrieden 4y agoNo point arguing with people about this, they believe those who can’t afford it are in that situation because of personal moral failings
- mikeyouse 4y agoFun fact about the US's system too - even when ambulances are called for things like heart attacks -- they take much longer to show up in poor areas compared to wealthier ones; https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle/2716993 https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jamanetworkopen/fullarticle... There are some common agreed upon thresholds that strongly correlate with positive outcomes, e.g. 15 minute response time after a heart attack. In wealthy areas, this outcome was achieved 97% of the time vs. only 93% of the time in poorer ones. That doesn't sound too bad, but that means you were something like 230% more likely to miss that cutoff if you were in a poor neighborhood. But at least it's not "socialist".
- jasonlotito 4y agoYes, I will always vote down comments talking about down votes, and the comments they reference, regardless of what they are talking about. Comments talking about voting (including this one) are worthless, and deserve every down vote they get.
- bombcar 4y agoInteresting: > For many Americans, debt from medical or dental care may be relatively low. About a third owe less than $1,000, the KFF poll found. I wonder how they'd count me, who puts all expenses on a credit card and pays it off each month, technically I'm going into debt ...
- kube-system 4y agoI also intentionally go in to debt for any of my expenses subject to deductible, because my hospital offers zero-interest payment plans. I then pay their payment plan with a credit card, get 2% back, and pay it off at the end of the month.
- secabeen 4y agoThis also ties into that commonly statistic that 60+% of bankruptcies are caused by medical bills. The study is more complicated than that, and it's not the best summary: https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2009/jun/11/chris-dodd/medical-bankruptcy-study-not-clear-cut/ https://www.politifact.com/factchecks/2009/jun/11/chris-dodd...
- bombcar 4y agoThis is exactly the kind of thing I'm getting at - absolutely 100% of bankruptcies are caused by debt; perhaps 60% of them also have medical debt somewhere in there, but that may be a distraction (after all, once you're on the path to bankruptcy why bother trying to make medical payments, they're not going to repossess your lung but they very well may repossess your house). The US has a major debt problem and the solution at some point is going to be curtailing just how much debt you can accumulate with just a signature.
- kube-system 4y agoA lot of people read that statistic as "medical debt is crippling" but there are also correlations with lot of other life circumstances going on in that figure too. Most of the people who file something like chapter 7 have little to no income, don't have big bank accounts, luxury cars, second homes, etc. This often correlates with people who have medical issues and rack up big bills, and can't work a job. These people can file "no-asset" chapter 7 cases, in which case, they lose absolutely nothing. This is what happens in the majority of chapter 7 cases filed. So, for a lot of the people who do choose to file, this is because it is a good option, not because it is a life crippling choice forced upon them.
- draw_down 4y ago
- sirtimbly 4y agoI hate the way the health-care system works and how it's affected me and those close to me. I spent much of my adult life paying off medical debt exactly like they describe. Defrayed by parents somewhat, but still a significant burden for many years. On one hand, we have debt and bankruptcy as a tool to help individuals deal with costs that would be impossible to save up for. On the other hand, this quote from the article rings true: > “We have a health care system almost perfectly designed to create debt.” This was true before the ACA – and is still true.
- bombcar 4y agoThe entirety of the US economy is tuned to create debt; healthcare is just one example of it.
- jjoonathan 4y agoWell, yeah -- once you've squeeezed all the money out of poor people, how else are you supposed to squeeze even harder?
- bombcar 4y agoAs implied in another comment, the real solution is one people don't want to consider - forbid people from taking debt on in certain circumstances. But this immediately appears as "unfair" even if predatory lending is a huge problem. Meanwhile those who already have some money wouldn't be affected by it much, for example, a law requiring all credit cards that charge interest on balances to be secured ones (where if you have a $1k credit line you must have $1k cash/cash equivalent in the bank).
- sirtimbly 4y agoYes. Debt is the entire story of the American economy, from top to bottom, it's not inherently evil. It's useful for creating new wealth. But of course it gets misused also.
- 4y ago
- notch656a 4y agoAlso known as 100M people who may have died without medical care, but were provided it despite their inability to pay for it. If you remove the ability for medical workers to seek payment for their services, most medical workers are just gonna say fuck it and not work for free. Medical care providers have families they have to feed too.
- jasongill 4y agoDo all of the medical providers in other nations with universal healthcare have starving families?
- notch656a 4y agoThe US doesn't have universal healthcare, so there's not a great mechanism for health care workers to earn a living without charging client for it. Some charities excepted.
- Joeri 4y agoThe money going into medicare is enough to extend coverage to all americans provided the system is run with the cost efficiency of the typical EU healthcare system.
- notch656a 4y agoBut then people go into debt to pay the tax to pay the other guy's medical debt.
- monkey_monkey 4y agoI'm not entirely sure you understand how taxes work.
- notch656a 4y agoYes because no one is in debt as a result of making insufficient income after tax deductions, and no one owes tax debt.
- rattyc 4y agoThey have 330million people, that's terrifying.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoYour comment insulting 330 million people in the USA is unwelcome on HN.
- 1111567892 4y ago
- david_l_lin 4y agoJust watched John Q (2002) last night, and can't believe that despite all the attention it gets, nothing has changed at all. Can't say I'm surprised though.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y agoBasically the way things work in the US is that even if you can get an overwhelming majority of people to agree that something is a problem, you will never get them to agree on a solution. In this instance, the two proposed solutions are: make healthcare the government's responsibility like many countries that don't have this problem, or do nothing because that solution isn't perfect.
- heretogetout 4y agoFurther, neither side (seems to) accept incremental change and loves making the perfect the enemy of the good -- especially, imo, the left -- so they get nothing and complain about it.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 4y agoYou're going to have to elaborate on that one, considering that the ACA came from the Obama administration and was about the smallest incremental change possible. Not that republicans didn't try to repeal it several times anyway.
- heretogetout 4y agoSometimes incremental change happens, like the ACA, sometimes people go all accelerationist[0]/Bernie-or-bust on us and then someone vastly worse[1] gets elected. Seems like it's more the latter than the former these days considering how divided we are, politically. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerationism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accelerationism 1: edited to add: imo. And probably in their o as well.
- hedora 4y ago
- nimbius 4y agonot that it honestly matters. the whole cabal of private healthcare has become such a teetering house of cards post covid that credit reporting agencies no longer count medical debt in your score. https://www.forbes.com/advisor/personal-finance/medical-debt-removed-from-consumer-credit-reports/ https://www.forbes.com/advisor/personal-finance/medical-debt...
- sirtimbly 4y agoThat sounds like a solid improvement. It really is a different class of market interaction.
- dathmar 4y agoMy wife had a decent chunk of medical debt when we got married which was long before COVID. Even at that time medical debt didn't count terribly against her. Maybe a 10 pt drop in her score. And eventually the debt fell off her credit.
- SoftTalker 4y agoSo did she/the two of you pay it eventually? If not, were there any collection efforts/judgments/garnishments or anything like that? Simply walking away from medical debt if there is only a minor impact on credit score seems like a decent option if not.
- noelsusman 4y agoThis is one of many reasons why hospitals charge so much. Medical debt is extremely difficult to actually collect because refusing to pay has basically no consequences. Hospitals have to eat those costs and make up for it by squeezing patients who do pay for as much as possible. I did the same thing with an ER bill I couldn't afford a while back. I just never paid it and suffered virtually no consequences.
- a9h74j 4y agoI have heard of hospital insiders giving precisely such advice: Don't even start to pay or they will hound you as if you can.
- kube-system 4y agoThis is the expected result of median deductibles being larger than median savings accounts. Small amounts of debt <$1000 are not necessarily problematic amounts of debt, especially considering that they can typically be paid off over time with no interest.
- marcusverus 4y agoThe article also studiously ignores the fact that the median net worth is more than 100X the median medical debt.
- newaccount2021 4y ago
- willcipriano 4y ago> Elizabeth Woodruff drained her retirement account and took on three jobs after she and her husband were sued for nearly $10,000 by the New York hospital where his infected leg was amputated. I'm not sure what sort of retirement they had planned to have on less than 10k, but it looks like in this case the hospital knew they could afford to pay but preferred not to. When people use number of jobs rather than hours worked per week it's typically beacuse number of jobs is greater than one and hours is less than forty. > Ariane Buck, a young father in Arizona who sells health insurance, couldn’t make an appointment with his doctor for a dangerous intestinal infection because the office said he had outstanding bills. The emergency room was available to him. What was the total he was asked to pay? Why didn't he pay it? > Allyson Ward and her husband loaded up credit cards, borrowed from relatives, and delayed repaying student loans after the premature birth of their twins left them with $80,000 in debt. Ward, a nurse practitioner, took on extra nursing shifts, working days and nights. Average nurse practitioner salary 115k. Why are they putting medical debt on credit cards? The emergency room wasn't going to stop care to those kids if they didn't pay immediately. If they were poor the kids would get CHIP, so I think they probably had too high income and maybe decided to forgo health insurance and work as contractors for additional pay. What was the plan for the birth? Was the problem that they were early and they didn't have a chance to get insurance at the last second?
- alephnan 4y ago> number of jobs is greater than one and hours is less than forty. It could also be the companies aren't willing to have someone on full-time, because then they'd have to pay for medical and other benefits.
- GiorgioG 4y agoYou don't know their whole story, stop judging people from your high horse.
- willcipriano 4y ago> You don't know their whole story I'm pretty sure that's on purpose.
- pastor_bob 4y agoUrgent care had my girlfriend go to ER when she went in for Epinephrine shot. Because, apparently, they call an ambulance for anybody who shows up with something potentially dangerous (including EKG readings they can't read, according the the ambulance driver who took us). We just sat on a chair for a couple hours for 'monitoring', and sure enough we got a $1700 bill from them, since she hadn't met her deductible yet. Of course people are in debt if they get hit with bills like that.
- justinzollars 4y agoI see any suggestion to the contrary of Socialized medicine being downvoted. Honest question. How do you propose to expand healthcare with 130% Debt to GDP and 8.9% inflation? It seems we are broke and there is a demand from the HN community to spend more? Feels like hitting the accelerator as one drives off a cliff and invokes memories of Thelma & Louise
- jjoonathan 4y agoWe pay nearly double for our privatized monstrosity, compared to the most expensive socialized systems. Such savings! So cheap! Very efficient! Can the treasury possibly bear the expense of spending less than double? ------ Yeah, a transition is going to be an expensive shitshow and now is not a good time, but just about any other time in the last decade was a good time and in a year or two it will be a decent time again. We'd better rip this bandaid before it soaks all our blood out.
- justinzollars 4y agoPolitics aside, money puts a cap on everything: wars, social services, etc. The issue at hand is to take something the public spends nothing on, that the government gets for "free" and to put that on the public balance sheet - a huge cost. I guess we could balance that out with a tax, but who would like that? And even if we were to raise taxes - it wouldn't help our balance sheet since we already spend 30% more than we take in. Looking at the balance sheet as it stands today, we can't even afford what we currently spend. And inflation is on the rise. I just don't see it ever happening. Save a collapse and total reset of the current monetary system.
- jjoonathan 4y ago> Politics aside, money puts a cap What part of "we pay nearly double" didn't make it through? We can't afford the enormous premium we are paying for privatized care. > I guess we could balance that out with a tax Payroll tax. In the vacancy left by private insurance. Scribble off one memo line, write in another. Come on, this is a 101 level objection.
- asdffdsa 4y agoI always figured that the reason why I make as much money as possible is so that I can pay for medical expenses when things go wrong.
- killjoywashere 4y agoUnless you make millions, it's unlikely your finances could survive an ICU admission.
- corrral 4y agoIf you're not incredibly rich, you're just temporarily holding all your savings & retirement accounts for the hospitals and nursing homes that'll eventually take all of it. And then some.
- avgDev 4y agoYou can file bankruptcy which will protect your retirement accounts. There are other way to protect your assets and money as you get older and risk gets higher. It should not be this way though because mostly the wealthy take advantage of protecting their assets as it requires some money.
- SoftTalker 4y agoYep the entire end-of-life industry is incentivized to drain all the wealth from the old and terminally ill before they die. That is why my plan is to opt out. DNR, living will, I will not enter a care facility or hospital I'd rather die on my own terms and have my children inherit whatever I have managed to accumulate.
- avgDev 4y agoUncle was in ICU for 2 week before his death with multiple organ failure. His stay was more than $350k. Basically the hospital took the house he worked his whole life for.
- dekhn 4y ago
- yalogin 4y agoTangential to health care debt, Some times I wonder if the only true innovation happens in facilitating debt and making huge debt seem like easily tackleable. 30yr mortgage, 15 and 10yr arm, car payments sold as “only $199 a month!”. Buy now pay later is the latest in a long line of these encouraging people to pile on debt.
- coffeefirst 4y agoBy the way, if you'd actually like to do something about this that benefits real people right now, RIP Medical Debt (mentioned in the article and has good ratings) buys debt at 1% of its face value and immediately forgives it. https://ripmedicaldebt.org https://ripmedicaldebt.org
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- boppo1 4y agoThanks, this is awesome I'll keep it in mind!
- antisthenes 4y agoHow can I submit my debt? Or is it kind of a site that buys debt that the hospital has 0% chance of collecting anyway?
- kube-system 4y ago"Buying debt" is analogous to "debt sent to collections" So yes, the latter. Basically, that site helps people to not get phone calls about bills they were never going to pay.
- antisthenes 4y agoRight, which is nice, I guess, but it's more of a feel-good project for those who run it, rather than actual help. 99% of hospitals have financial assistance programs that will either completely eliminate your debt or reduce it by a substantial amount if you fall under a certain bracket of income (usually some multiple 3x or 4x poverty level), which essentially does the same thing. It doesn't address the fact that hospitals prices ballooned out of control due to perverse incentives with insurance companies and dumb regulation that limits profits to a percentage (incentivizing absolute increases in prices, rather than price controls like NHS does)
- willcipriano 4y ago
- 71a54xd 4y agoThis is not intended to be political - all politicians are corrupt. That said, if only we could've saved a few of the billions we sent to Ukraine or Iraq and use that to pay for healthcare for common Americans. Fortunately as an engineer, shelling out $4k a year on top of my basically "free" health insurance through my employer is more of a nuisance than something I lose sleep over. That said, people in this country need better healthcare. Doing this will unsaddle startups and businesses from having to provide it directly. Healthcare is something I would pay more taxes for, but above all I command the government to spend in ways that BENEFIT the American people not just corporate donors.
- yalogin 4y agoNone of these metrics will change the political stance our one majority party took. They have shut their eyes and ears and are hell bent on preserving the interests of the lobbying companies and fetishizing “free market competition”. I can bet a sizeable amount of money that nothing will change in the next 50yrs even. Today there is still a rule that a hospital cannot say no to a patient, I strongly believe that is one rule that will fall down next. It makes too much profit for the health care providers to not attack that. In fact after Roe fell I can see that as the next one.
- colpabar 4y agoI make this comment in a lot of threads, but if democrats wanted to fix this problem, they would write legislation for it and try to get it passed. Instead, all we get (from both parties) are massive 1000+ page bills that include a bunch of completely unrelated stuff. Why haven't democrats produce a 10 page bill with a tl;dr of "medical debt is hereby abolished"? Stop pretending the clowns pretending to be politicians are doing anything to help us. This is about the rich not wanting to give up their money, and both sides are just protecting them.
- notacoward 4y agoLast time I proposed this same thing in a blog comment section (Lawyers, Guns, and Money) a couple of people said "but filibuster" and the rest went straight to an absolute firehose of middle-school-level verbal abuse. I've had similar reactions from other self-proclaimed progressives. Nonetheless I stand by the idea. These big omnibus bills give every single opponent (and some "mavericks" a.k.a. turncoats in one's own party) their very own personal reason to vote against it without political consequence. A more focused bill at least has a slight chance of prying loose a few around the edges, if only because they know that their "no" vote will be used effectively against them in the next election cycle with no room for excuses. When your legislative success rate (not counting bills to name post offices) is close to zero already, might as well try something different.
- colpabar 4y ago
- drcongo 4y agoThe American healthcare system is barbaric.
- jmyeet 4y agoWhat depresses me the most about this situation is the callous, unempathetic disregard a significant portion of the population has for everyone not like them. "Just get a good paying job with health insurance" is not and should not be the basis for a health care policy. Americans are profoundly selfish and that's getting harder and harder to ignore. Many will defend such practices in the name of "freedom". "Freedom" will often be an integral part of their identity. The sad truth is that these people seem so desperate for someone telling them what to do. Supporters of universal access to health care simply want people not to be denied life-saving or life-changing medical care and not to be bankrupted by that. That's literally it. Yet such people are so often demonized as "socialists" or "communists". The Bezoses and Buffetts of the world has so successfully propagandized and manipulated these people, choosing billionaires having a little bit more money over people literally dying in the streets. I really do worry this country will be lost to white Christian fascism in the not too distant future.
- oceanplexian 4y ago> What depresses me the most about this situation is the callous, unempathetic disregard a significant portion of the population has for everyone not like them. "Just get a good paying job with health insurance" is not and should not be the basis for a health care policy. The problem is this is a straw-man argument. We can agree that healthcare costs are too high, and have empathy for people who are being screwed over, but not agree that massive government intervention is a reasonable solution to the problem. In fact, there is an argument to be made that the only reason healthcare is expensive in the US is because of lawmakers failure to account for the second-order effects of their decisions (e.g. EMTALA). In the early 90s you could buy decent health insurance for less than the cost of Cable TV. Unfortunately, the oft-repeated "solution" to the current crisis always involves forcibly taking tax dollars, and then directly funneling them into one of the most dysfunctional and corrupt institutions of all time (Healthcare), then lying to voters and telling them that doing so would magically turn the USA into Sweden or something. The people who don't support a public option are so exhausted making these arguments that they will tell you "It's socialism" and walk away from the conversation.
- 4y ago
- otikik 4y agoI like that the article shows how this affects regular people pretty much randomly. One thing I missed on the article was a section about "how did we get here" (including things like Hospitals not disclosing prices for their treatments and forcing people to sign papers under duress). And a section about "who benefits from all this suffering" would complete it.
- josephd79 4y agomaking it insanely difficult to track services on invoices they send you. I had a 3 night stay a 2 years ago and received bills from 5 different 'companies'. I even paid one that I was incorrectly billed for and had to jump through hoops to get the money back.
- sparklingmango 4y agoSome standout stats for me: - Hospitals recorded their most profitable year on record in 2019, notching an aggregate profit margin of 7.6% - From 2012 to 2016, prices for medical care surged 16%, almost four times the rate of overall inflation - Last year the average annual deductible for a single worker with job-based coverage topped $1,400, almost four times what it was in 2006... Family deductibles can top $10,000 Facilities charge exorbitant prices for procedures and insurance companies pass more and more of these costs on to patients via higher deductibles and premiums. It will continue to get worse unless there is colossal change.
- pocketero-dan 4y agoProposed colossal change: a common practice of paying for healthcare out of pocket, instead of through healthcare insurance. Yes, this sounds unreasonable right now because prices are so high. But bear with me for a second. Most healthcare in the US is paid through insurance. Insurance creates moral hazard. Insured patients generally don't even need to know the prices of what they're buying, much less negotiate those prices. And here's a dirty secret: insurers don't care much either. They simply add a margin on top of their actuarially-forecasted cost. So healthcare prices rise dramatically over time, because relatively few people are directly exposed to them and push back on them. From this perspective, healthcare insurance is a problem, not a solution. Don't get me wrong, there are admittedly some obstacles to patients paying out of pocket right now. My point is that we know properly functioning markets set fair prices, and we know our healthcare market is dysfunctional. Healthcare insurance plays a part in that dysfunction. Patients negotiating directly for better prices eliminates moral hazard and restores market function. Strategically, that would finally restore pressure on healthcare providers, who have become accustomed to raising prices with very little push-back. Without some kind of push-back, providers will continue raising prices - because they can.
- dragonwriter 4y ago> My point is that we know properly functioning markets set fair prices For frequently-repeated purchases of goods with robust competition for close alternatives where the approximate total infinite-horizon costs and utilities resulting from the decision are both entirely experienced by the participants to the exchange and very clear before or quickly after it occurs so that behavior can rapidly adjust to more optimal alternatives when suboptimal choices are made, in other words where the perfect knowledge assumption underlying rational choice theory is, while it is never actually accurate, at least closely approximated in the relevant market, and there are no externalities making inefficient in the global sense actions efficient from the perspective of participants. Medical care very much does not fit this pattern.
- josephd79 4y agoIt's ridiculous in the year 2022 we still have people making a decision to not seek medical treatment of any kind because they are afraid it will bankrupt their family, they won't be able to pay their rent or mortgage on time, they might have to go without food, take out loans or borrow money that puts them in even more debt causing more health issues. I'm not sure what the solution is but I feel like there's got to be a better way.
- spacechild1 4y ago> I'm not sure what the solution is but I feel like there's got to be a better way. Universal healthcare? Like any other Western country?
- paxys 4y agoAmerica has socialized healthcare with a hundred extra steps and implemented in the most inefficient way possible so that everyone comes out worse. Hospitals aren't allowed to deny care (obviously). They will bill people outrageous amounts and know that they will only ever see a fraction of it. So prices for people who do pay are raised considerably to make up for it. People don't get early preventive care due to costs or because they are uninsured. Supply of doctors is artificially limited by the ABMS so that demand stays high. The government doesn't negotiate or mandate prices, so drug manufacturers, equipment manufacturers, researchers, hospitals and everyone else in the ecosystem squeezes out as much profit as they can to make up for all the countries where they are not allowed to. The end result is that the average American knowingly or unknowingly pays a lot more for healthcare than any other country in the world while receiving sub-par care.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoI never understood why if they have a cap to at least increase it as population increases. Also we need to give more medical decisions over to advance level (but not doctors) levels of people like Physicians Assistants and Nurse Practitioners.
- maxerickson 4y agoEmergency rooms at hospitals that accept Medicare are not allowed to deny care under EMTALA. Hospitals that do not accept Medicare can run a 24 hour, high level of service department and deny care all they want. There's no requirement to provide non-stabilizing care.
- noelsusman 4y agoWhich hospitals don't accept Medicare?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- hedora 4y agoAlso, something like 20-33% of health care dollars go to claim submission/processing at the doctor/hospital and the insurance company. Those people do nothing but argue with each other There's a highly rated HMO around here. Their costs are significantly lower than regular insurance, and they seem to pass some of that on to customers in the form of health care.
- zikduruqe 4y agoNot my family. We filed for bankruptcy, so screw the whole medical industry. Honestly, it wasn't bad and within 18 months bought a new car, new house and started life over again.
- starik36 4y agoDoesn't the bankruptcy stick around on the credit report for 7 years?
- egberts1 4y agoYep but if you add a note for the reason of bankruptcy into your credit application, the credit provider would still take that into consideration and STILL charge you a higher interest rate. Depending on the absolved medical debt (being discharged by your bankruptcy), and its would-be crushing monthly payments, the higher interest rate of your new (mortgage/credit) credit lines and its monthly payments are often less than the impact by (then dissolved) medical payments therefore your living standard would still improve after such medical-related bankruptcy.
- agubelu 4y agoAs someone from the other side of the Atlantic, I've always been surprised at how much people in the US rely on debt and credit lines for their daily lives (besides very infrequent, very expensive purchases such as a house). I'm personally extremely wary of spending money I don't have.
- zikduruqe 4y ago> STILL charge you a higher interest rate. My mortgage is 2.25% and the car we financed was 0%. The saddest part was with each creditor that asked about the bankruptcy and we explained it was due to medical debt, they would just say something like "oh no problem, get those all the time" or "bad things happened to good people", like it was no issue. It was like, having crushing medical debt is normal, for people.
- silicon2401 4y agoIf you have insurance with an out of pocket max, how is it possible to end up paying for more than that?
- DavidPeiffer 4y agoSometimes services are rendered which insurance does not deem required, and then refuses to pay for, and some items are simply not covered at all. For example, insulin may be covered by insurance, but needles and syringes are not. On top of that, it's basically impossible to anticipate the cost ahead of time for many procedures. One person I know was quoted $2,000 to $30,000 for a portion of a surgery that is not covered by insurance, depending on exactly what needed to be done. How do you even plan for that? At one end, it's like buying ~2 new refrigerators of pain, and the other end is a brand new, top of the line Chevy Bolt. For many people, hitting max out of pocket is simply not possible without debt. It's common to see 3-5k MOOP, but taking a modest standard of living on an average salary, it's an incredible amount of time to make up for it. E.g. $5,000 household income (60k annual) * $800 rent * $1,000 childcare * $250 gas * $200 utilities * $500 groceries * $500 income taxes * $250 student loan payments * $100 car insurance $1,400 leftover, but there have been no incidental expenses, $800 is probably lower than you could find a 2 bedroom apartment in Iowa, and I'm assuming they own their car outright. Once you hit January 1, your deductible and max out of pocket reset, so you could be like a friend of mine and get MRI's on December 31 and January 1 while staying in the hospital for a couple days on either end. They had to pay their full max out twice because of the timing in the year when they got sick.
- silicon2401 4y agoThat's terrifying. The healthcare issue with the US is what seriously makes me want to live in Europe, at least to try it. The thought of your whole life falling apart just because you need medical care is horrible. I'm living the double-software-engineer-income, no kids life with my partner, and even then I think a major medical issue would be life changing. As a risk-averse person, the US feels like a place to get high rewards as a SWE, but there are massively high risks that don't get talked about often enough.
- charlie0 4y agoI like ACA, but... Hot take: The only reason ACA passed is because the government did not want to foot the entire healthcare bill for our aging boomer generation. So ACA became a way to partially distribute those costs to the rest of the US population by forcing them into a healthcare plan. Sure, in theory those forced into the ACA are protected from financial disaster in case they get sick, but in practice, the younger generation won't need healthcare for quite a long time, thereby once again kicking this can of worms down the road.
- rufus_foreman 4y ago100M people in the US are not sick and struggling to pay.
- colechristensen 4y agoI have a bunch of medical debt but not really, just waiting for treatment to be “finished” and someone else’s car insurance to foot the bill. I have debt collectors calling me which i ignore now because me describing the situation and them “putting a note in my file” has zero effect on how often they contact me. In the end I’ll owe $0 it will just take time to settle. But there is something coming close to $10k of “debt” out there with my name on it.
- Austin654 4y ago