19 ms·
This sort of thing has been MS's playbook since I was a kid, or earlier. It surprises me that people are still surprised when things like this happen. I espec
by kelnos 4y ago
This sort of thing has been MS's playbook since I was a kid, or earlier. It surprises me that people are still surprised when things like this happen. I especially think someone with Miguel de Icaza's experience should know better[0].
It's interesting to see the generational difference here. Many of my somewhat-younger (even only by 7-10 years) programmer/techie friends just don't remember the Microsoft of the 80s and 90s, and see all the "good" they've been doing with the open source community in more recent times, and think MS is a pretty good corporate citizen in the tech world.
But in reality, MS has just done a great job whitewashing their image[1] in the past 15 years, especially in the past 8 years since Ballmer stepped down and Nadella took the reins. I do believe they're a better, less anti-competitive company than they used to be. But they're still the same company in many ways. I think a big part of their "play nice" strategy was born out of necessity, since they heavily dropped the ball in the late 90s/early 00s when the internet/WWW was really coming into its own, and then again in the early/mid 10s when Windows Phone failed miserably. They just lost the clout to do the anti-competitive bullshit they used to pull. But the desire to do all this stuff is still there.
[0] It was clear to me that MS intended .NET to be a wholly-proprietary, Windows-only technology until de Icaza and co. built Mono, when MS grudgingly embraced it. This proprietary extension feels like their standard follow-on of "extend and extinguish", though it's coming a bit later than we'd expect.
[1] Bill Gates has also done an amazing job rehabilitating his image through philanthropy. A lot of people forget how his actions at MS probably held back progress in the computing industry for at least a decade (or two?), through forced lock-in and anti-competitive behavior.
- bayindirh 4y agoYes, a lot of younger developers and "tech citizens" think MS is a saint now. They need to love Open Source / Linux because their platform has lost to the openness, composability and lightness of Linux. They lost the server space, but they're retrying to seize desktop from Linux with WSL and invading the developer tools space and trying to isolate Desktop Linux as an "irrelevant layer which runs MS software and technologies, which is not visible and accessible as the laymen", and Linux server as a layer "which you don't need to think about" (i.e. make Linux irrelevant as a whole OS for developers at scale). Canonical is helping them with this endeavor, because Ubuntu desktop doesn't make money. If they can piggyback the userspace to Windows and earn money from servers, they're kosher. It's really ugly. However, De Icasa is not a saint either by pushing Mono on GNOME and Linux and allowing some borders to dissolve to allow Microsoft in, regardless of it's intended or not.
- kelnos 4y agoYup, agreed. Didn't realize how much Canonical was helping with WSL, though it of course makes sense that they're doing so, unfortunately. > De Icasa is not a saint either by pushing Mono on GNOME and Linux Eh, I think interoperability is good, and reverse-engineering Windows frameworks/technology has a long history in the open-source world (WINE & Samba being two prominent examples). I was disappointed when they sold Xamarin to MS, though. That felt like selling out, even though I'm sure it made sense at the time.
- bayindirh 4y ago> Didn't realize how much Canonical was helping with WSL, though it of course makes sense that they're doing so, unfortunately. Eh, they have a dedicated team for enabling WSL/Ubuntu desktop in Canonical. They're fueling the effort. > Eh, I think interoperability is good, and reverse-engineering Windows frameworks/technology has a long history in the open-source world (WINE & Samba being two prominent examples). IIRC, De Icaza left GNOME, joined Microsoft, developed Mono on open specs, founded Xamarin and sold it back to Microsoft. His joint venture with MS what turned everything sour for many people, incl. me. However, we all love Wine, esp. when they implement things bug-by-bug without knowing it (and without help from Microsoft). The cursor (or Icon or WMF) exploit was a great laugh. We all love SMB too, because it's done despite Microsoft. The language on this page is loaded (in a way I don't like), but it keeps a good roster of the events: http://techrights.org/wiki/Miguel_de_Icaza http://techrights.org/wiki/Miguel_de_Icaza
- littlecranky67 4y ago> His joint venture with MS what turned everything sour for many people, incl. me. Why did it turn things sour for you? I mean, ever since the Xamarin acquisition, MS .NET has become open + cross plattform and Xamarin which was a commercial/paid-for product is open too. VSCode is a first class citizen for free C#/.NET development on macOS and Linux. Not saying all of this is related to de Icaza getting bought by MS, but just saying ever since the ecosystem has become completely open.
- headmelted 4y agoI think what's more likely in this case is that MS under Satya really does want to be a good corporate citizen, but are finding themselves in a bind that threatens the whole organisation. They're spending up the wazoo on Xbox, still, to battle PlayStation. They were supposed to have conquered that market over 15 years ago and are still throwing money at it. Windows is hurting as a retail business. License costs have been driven down by Chromebooks and resurgent Macs, and with all the free upgrades they get very little revenue from gaming PCs anymore (which is one of their biggest markets) while also battling Proton and Vulkan to keep users on the platform. That leaves Azure and Office as the big cash cows. Azure is struggling to compete with AWS, and the big draw of Azure is the deep integration between it and Visual Studio (which, to be fair, is unrivalled anywhere else). That's the bind. Microsoft needs the open-source community to embrace Visual Studio Code, and they have, but they also need to protect Azure's hegemony with .NET developers. Can you build and deploy .NET on other clouds currently? Of course. Do you lose a lot of features by doing that? yes. Ones you may miss, or (if you've never been on Azure to become familiar with them), ones that may draw you to migrate later.
- kelnos 4y agoThis reads to me as: > MS under Satya really does want to be a good corporate citizen ... followed by... > [a bunch of reasons why MS won't be a good corporate citizen] Wanting is great, but actions speak louder. Maybe instead of doing sketchy things to try to lock people into your cloud platform (and make using your framework on other platforms more difficult), they could, I dunno, maybe focus on Azure itself, and making it better than AWS? The world would be a better place if companies were incentivized to compete on product features, and not through shady practices and backroom dealing.
- short_sells_poo 4y agoI wonder how much inertia an organization like MS has. I never worked there, but the anecdotes I read/hear indicate that MS is really 4-5 semi-independent competing power structures. E.g. there's sometimes (often?) adversarial relationship between them even, which then projects into baffling end user experiences. The windows shut down menu or the highly schizophrenic situation between the new and old control panels comes to mind. Steering something like that is not even analogous to captaining a single large ship, it's more like trying to steer a flotilla where each captain hates the other bunch and they are all continuously pulling in different directions. Satya may be doing his very best to improve the culture, but management has to change or be replaced on multiple levels below him to make things stick. He has to do this in a way that doesn't unite the leaders of the sub-groups against him in mutiny. Again, I'm not trying to excuse MS's behavior in any measure, just highlight that even with the best of intentions it may take decades to change firm like MS to give up it's old ways.
- someotherperson 4y agoOpinions like this have always been weird to me. Not wrong, but weird. Any contribution that M$ (remember when people would sub the S for a dollar sign?) makes to open source or open standards is to support their own bottom line and we shouldn't expect anything else. The directors have a legal responsibility to the company and to boost the share price, not for the betterment of humanity. To this effect, companies will contribute to open standards when it's better for the share price, and will seek to screw open standards when it's better for the share price. Public companies are inherently evil by default -- this is because the only goal of a public company is to strengthen the share price. I've said it before and I'll say it again: always assume bad faith when you're dealing with a company. From this, it doesn't matter what people thought of Microsoft before, or what they think of them now. Microsoft like all companies has a single goal. If we can pressure these companies to coast in a certain direction then great. But we shouldn't ever believe that companies can 'turn over a new leaf' when they legally cannot. FAANG is the same. Ford is the same. Starbucks is the same. Every company is exactly the same, but the larger they grow, the more visible and impactful these actions become. Microsoft has been in the spotlight for decades because it has been a juggernaut for decades. But it's hardly unique in what it does. Our real concerns should be why regulators were quick to put the smack down on Microsoft but have since turned into paper tigers and are allowing unhinged monopolization from FAANG in 2022.
- oblio 4y agoPeople forget that before about 2000 or so, Microsoft was bigger than the next 10 or so software companies, <<combined>>. And had much higher profit margins that the other tech companies. IBM created the playbook, Microsoft perfected it, FAANG copied it.
- ethbr0 4y agoOne distinction between Microsoft and early FAANG (except for Apple): FAANG cut out the distributor and kept those profits themselves. Microsoft always had distributors as a key component of their platform sales.
- 4y ago
- SideburnsOfDoom 4y ago> It was clear to me that MS intended .NET to be a wholly-proprietary, Windows-only technology until de Icaza and co. built Mono, when MS grudgingly embraced it. I kinda disagree with that, based on things that MS people straight-up say out loud. MS changed that "wholly-proprietary, Windows-only technology" thinking for other reasons. VS and .NET are not the profit centres any more. Azure is. Even #2 spot in cloud computing is vastly profitable (1) and strategic. Is Azure "struggling" eh, it depends. Sure they want to have more users than AWS, and they're struggling to do that. Struggling to be successful, big, profitable etc, no not at all, Azure is all of those things. MS wants you to run it on Azure. For just about any "it". They'll even prioritize enticing you to Azure over enticing you to Windows servers. Therefor, there should be a good "it runs on Linux on Azure" story for any popular dev tool. Doubly so for the MS developer base. 1) https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-cloud-revenue-at-23-4-billion-in-q3-up-32-percent/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/microsoft-cloud-revenue-at-23-...
- dustinmoris 4y agoYup: https://github.com/omnisharp/omnisharp-vscode/issues/5276#issuecomment-1157074523 https://github.com/omnisharp/omnisharp-vscode/issues/5276#is...
- codeulike 4y agoIt's not that a new generation of coders don't know about the past. It's more that what Microsoft did in the 90s was a preview of how all giant tech corporations behave, and now they all do the same: build empires and ecosystems wherever possible. Pretty much everything ms did in the 90s is now standard practice. E.g defacto Browser lock in? (iOS, android...). Facebook wanting to be the whole internet, Amp, App Stores, launching os features that compete with popular third parties. Champion privacy if it gives you a market differentiator, otherwise harvest whatever info you can from everywhere etc etc One trick MS never thought of was "use mountain of cash to buy up all the manufacturing capacity"
- blagie 4y agoCompanies aren't people. The set of people in Microsoft is completely different in 2022 than it was in 1995. A quarter-century has passed. It's not the same organization as it was back then. It has very little relationship to it. I've been consistently surprised by Microsoft doing non-evil things over the past decade, until I accepted that I no longer had reason to hate it. Conversely, for a while, I was surprised by Google doing evil things, until I realized that the Google of 15 years ago no longer existed. The company has over 10x the employees of the old Google of "don't be evil" days. Even if no one had left, it's over 90% of people who don't know how to not be evil, and don't know they're not supposed to be evil. In practice, most non-evil people I knew at the old Google have long since left (although far from everyone, but enough that it's probably <1% pre-evil). Microsoft was evil in the nineties. In 2022, it's not a saint, but it's pretty good. Google was genuinely good in the early '00s. Today, it's pretty evil. The same has happened to many of my non-profits. Open source was started to strip ethics out of free software, and many genuinely nasty organizations from back then now behave like the FSF of the nineties. Conversely, some of my favorite non-profits went woke, and stopped doing what they were created to do. A few of my favorite academic institutions turned into Enron, while others moved up. Etc. Organizations are abstractions. Swap out the people and incentives, and it's a new thing under an old name.
- croes 4y agoAccording to the Supreme Court companies are people https://www.npr.org/2014/07/28/335288388/when-did-companies-become-people-excavating-the-legal-evolution https://www.npr.org/2014/07/28/335288388/when-did-companies-...
- elviejo 4y agoSecond the people selected for a company are selected based on their conformance to that companies culture. So even if not a single human in Microsoft is the same, the company culture is the there. This reminds me of an old story, might be fiction, that conveys the idea. five chimpanzees were put in a cage, bananas in the center everytime one tried to get a banana they would get cold water untill they simply stoped trying. Then one by one they replaced the chimpanzees do one one of the new ones, tried to take one of the bananas the old ones would stop him. Slowly they replaced all of them and none of the new chimpanzees, who had never received a cold shower, took the bananas. The same with corporations.
- Beltiras 4y agoI've worked with MS solutions and I've worked with *nix solutions for 2 decades. I can't for the life of me understand how people choose to inflict the pain of MS on themselves in anything except "office productivity". I must admit, that's an area they have got pretty good at. .NET is horrible to work with. C# is a decent language mind you, I like the language features. It just needs a better "standard library".
- rmeby 4y agoWhat sorts of things are wrong with .NET in your view? As someone who recently started working with it after using Java for years, it has been refreshing and largely enjoyable for me.
- Beltiras 4y agoYou must have not had to work with SOAP then.
- svick 4y agoNobody does anymore, so I don't see how that counts as a valid criticism of current .Net.
- pianoben 4y agoIf you deal with (some parts of) the public sector, you certainly will encounter SOAP. For example - those online drivers-ed courses you buy in California to get rid of a ticket? They all talk to a SOAP backend maintained by the State. Certainly SOAP isn't everywhere the way it used to be (thankfully), but it's out there and isn't going away any time soon.
- lovich 4y agoSOAP and the related libraries in .NET are pretty unfun to work with. However they are so old and unused compared to modern development that it’s not really a good comparison. Like I have a Java app I am struggling with currently and not a fan of, but its on Java 8 so I don’t consider it representative of whatever I might find in modern Java despite the fact that I am working with it in modern times
- spamizbad 4y agoI wish I could dig it up in the way back machine, but there was a period in the early aughts where Microsoft employees blogged religiously (on orders from corporate). Anyway, a group of them discussed lobbying the US government to charge Linus Torvalds and Eric Raymond for securities fraud, alleging that people promoting open source software were actually engaged in a pump-and-dump scheme for companies like VA Linux (a dot com company that crashed and burned) To me this perfectly encapsulates Microsoft’s attitude of that era. It’s all there right in a bunch of early aughts blogs.
- enriquto 4y ago> someone with Miguel de Icaza's experience should know better Surely RMS told him this exact thing would happen when he left gnome for ms.
- scarface74 4y agoYou act as if any public company doesn’t use open source more as marketing than anything else. Famously Google bragged about Android being “open” and then they slowly started moving anything that made Android “Android” to most people closed source. As far as .Net being Windows only. MS doesn’t care about Windows anymore. It cares more about Azure, services, Office etc. There are more Linux instances on Azure than Windows instances.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- yonaguska 4y ago> Bill Gates has also done an amazing job rehabilitating his image through philanthropy. I think this is no longer true following the pandemic and his vaccine work. And his Epstein connections. In retrospect to this, it's hard for me personally to take his philanthropy into account. I went from childhood, disliking Bill Gates for his anticompetitive Microsoft stuff, to college age, admiring him for his philanthropy, and now back to harboring a strong distrust of the man.
- lovich 4y agoThe Epstein connection is obviously bad to me but what did he do wrong with vaccines? The only complaints I’ve heard have been conspiracy theories along the lines of 5G microchips in the vaccines