8 ms·
Apple and Google’s mobile browser ‘stranglehold’ may face UK investigation
- tjpnz 4y agoDirect link: https://www.theguardian.com/business/2022/jun/10/apple-and-google-mobile-browser-stranglehold-may-face-uk-investigation https://www.theguardian.com/business/2022/jun/10/apple-and-g...
- capableweb 4y agoThere is some irony with this submission URL being redirected through Google, with who knows what amount of tracking. Probably because they ended up copy-pasting something that looks like a URL at first, but when you click on it, changes to be a redirect through Google (looking at you, Google search results).
- beardyw 4y agoEmbarrassed! Though in mitigation I use the Guardian app so I wanted a clean link. Failed.
- underdeserver 4y agoCan you edit it? If not, @dang, can you please edit it?
- beardyw 4y agoNo, just the title.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- beardyw 4y agoI am struggling to get my arms round this I mean, it's not actually about the browser, but let's ignore that. Companies that sell phones choose to install a particular OS. Apple's choice is obvious, for others (99.9%) it's a version of Android. The vast majority of those choose to use Google's ecosystem with its Playstore. Much as I can understand the sentiment, I can't see how it equates to a stranglehold. If others want to create a new OS and get manufacturers to install it they can. Whether the UK has any clout compared to the EU is a different question.
- Apocryphon 4y agoAt this point, the EU regulatory bodies are probably inclined to agree with their former brethren. There seem to be very few national or supranational governments left that are going to bat for these companies.
- capableweb 4y agoOn iOS, it is about the browser, as Apple is acting anti-competitive by not allowing any other browser engines but their own. Browser makers can't compete with Safari by making a faster browser for example, because they won't be able to deploy it on iOS device. All applications go through the App Store, and the App Store forbids any browser engines not made by Apple. Regarding the app stores, it seems like lawmakers are catching up with the idea of "If I buy it, I should be able to own it and make my own decisions", which includes being able to install applications from 3rd party developers. It seems like a fine idea that Apple has a default application index where you can install applications from, but what is not fine is Apple deciding which application indexes should be allowed to exists in the first place. Kind of like how lawmakers wouldn't look the other way if suddenly all macOS computers only allowed installation of software from the App Store. Purchasing a device shouldn't mean "The company decides what I'm allowed to install on this thing".
- scarface74 4y agoDoes that include consoles and smart TVs?
- underdeserver 4y agoHonestly I'm surprised it's as low as 90%. What's the rest? The Samsung browser? From my experience using Firefox on Android, very few websites care about compatibility with it.
- tgv 4y agoThe Samsung browser is a Chromium wrapper. Some people dismiss wrappers around Safari on iOS, although I think there are more important things to worry about than exactly which rendering engine gets used.
- Gigachad 4y agoThe rendering engine is less important than the JS apis. Safari is missing half of them and some of them are flat out broken.
- tgv 4y agoSafari is not missing anything of value: it's mainly access to USB, Bluetooth and such which have no place in a browser. And Firefox doesn't support many of them either. It's just Google trying to get more data about you.
- throwaway4good 4y agoWhat are you going to do about it? A symbolic fine? There are no alternatives.
- agust 4y agoRequiring them to stop banning competing browser engines? That's the number one remedy considered by the CMA. You should read the study, it's very insightful.
- seaman1921 4y agofill their pockets and then shut up for a few years
- fulafel 4y agoProgressively larger fines?
- native_samples 4y agoThe obvious one would be to fine Apple until they implement Android-style mechanisms for openness. As pointed out above, although they're being lumped together, Android is leagues more open than iOS. Does it even make sense to talk about an Android "stranglehold" when the OS is forkable and many vendors have their own spins on it, with new features often appearing there first before Google even have it themselves? In reality they are going to be treated together, because governments tend to reason in terms of countries and people not technical details. Apple/Android are both rich US tech firms who aren't going to leave the market regardless of how big the fines get, and in Android's case literally can't (because someone else could simply license it or use it and step in to replace Google). So it'll be like all other attempts at tech regulation, it'll just turn into cranking the handle on the cash cow to try and fill a part of the lockdown-created budget holes.
- ccouzens 4y ago> Does it even make sense to talk about an Android "stranglehold" when the OS is forkable and many vendors have their own spins on it, There are improvements to be had here. > The agreement (to pre-install Google play) places a company-wide ban on Android forks, saying OEMs are forbidden from taking "any actions that may cause or result in the fragmentation of Android" https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2014/02/new-android-oem-licensing-terms-leak-open-comes-with-restrictions/ https://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2014/02/new-android-oem-lice... For better or for worse this restriction limits the ability for an Android fork to get off the ground.
- Aardwolf 4y agoOn Android I can install Firefox, Edge, other versions of these browsers from f-droid, and many other browsers, all with their own engines. On iPhones, afaik, you can only get Safari, or other browsers that are just a thin wrapper around Safari. That is a huge difference and I hope they know that.
- boudin 4y agoIt's a bit like IE in the 2000s, it was possible to install an alternative browser on Windows but the fact that IE was pre-installed and set as default meant that it was very hard for competitors to get in the market. This is a similar situation on Android.
- nvrspyx 4y agoOk, but IE continued to be pre-installed and set as default. Now, it's Edge. It was that IE was set as default AND Microsoft restricted the API for third-party browsers.
- boudin 4y agoNot everywhere, in the EU a ruling forbid Microsoft to do that and when installing Windows, the user was prompted to choose a browser. It was there for quite a while: https://www.cnet.com/tech/services-and-software/windows-8-gets-browser-ballot-amid-eu-antitrust-probe/ https://www.cnet.com/tech/services-and-software/windows-8-ge...
- tgv 4y agoWhat's wrong with a wrapper around Safari? It's a capable and efficient browser. Firefox can wrap its bookmark sharing and whatever around it (I actually use Firefox on iOS, though I don't bother with the profile sharing). We don't need Safari to be 100% Chrome compatible, right? That's just for lazy programmers and greedy marketeers.
- nixass 4y agoIt's literally crap and lacks features. See Firefox on Android, compare it to iOS and update your post
- Terry_Roll 4y agoWill this set a precedent for car infotainment systems or even TV extra's? When is a device with a general purpose cpu something that can be upgraded or modified with other software and when isnt it?
- throwaway4good 4y agoAt least with cars things are different for now; the browser/platform business model is a "surveillance capitalism" one. Where we (Google or Google via a deal with Apple) give away a product, that has been extremely costly to build, for free, in return for you giving us a (de-facto) exclusive on profiling and data mining your online behaviour, so we can get an effective monopoly on brokering advertisement.
- numpad0 4y agoCompulsory headunit/car separation? That...would be ideal...
- gernb 4y ago2 companies control the actions of 4-10 billion devices and through them the access of billions of people no car company has that reach. no video game platform has that reach. hence they're not held to the same standard
- Terry_Roll 4y agoWell if you want to look at it like that, then the 2 dominant search engines should also be considered because they control the actions of many billions of people, but then every legal system that refers to God is criminal because it perpetuates superstition. Its a case of choose your criminal protectorate.
- mtomweb 4y agoWe were considering asking for this, but we’re just unsure how important it was and whether it would place an undue burden on manufacturers for more simple devices. Mobile devices are an obvious target for competition because they are just so ubiquitous and two companies basically control the market.
- throwaway4good 4y agoFor the foreseeable future the only companies that may foster alternatives to the Apple / Google duopoly are Chinese ones. And there is absolutely no way they will be allowed to gain foldhold in the west.
- Barrin92 4y agoI've been using Xiaomi phones since forever, they're very popular in Europe.
- throwaway4good 4y agoA Xiaomi phone is a Google phone with full GMS (outside of China).
- ajvs 4y agoNot really. Firefox and Brave are two great alternatives that suffer due to not being the default browser on most systems, unlike the current duopoly.
- daviddever23box 4y agoBrave’s value-add isn’t the underlying engine (NOT Gecko).
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThe Chinese phones telling their masters if you were searching for banned information outside of China wasn’t a great start…
- lmrs 4y agoWaste of tax payers money
- neximo64 4y agoIt's interesting to hear Apple always talk about the level playing field they've tried to create. From within the company i think they really believe they've got a level playing field. But then Apple has apps that can do much more than everyone else has access to, in ways that have nothing to do with security or privacy. - Apps access to NFC (e.g Apple Pay vs you being able to make your own nfc card) - Inability to have non WKWebView type browsers. Safari can do the one it wants, which is Apples choice. - Health app has access to nicer push notifications than standard - Federated Identity type login only works with Apple. So login with Apple is built tightly into the OS, where you can't make an app that does that. - Wallet app can access 2FA SMS code without having to type it The list is much longer but it is not a level playing field with regards to the access to apis. If Apple has an app like Messages, other apps should be able to access the same things too. I pretty much couldn't care less about the app store and review process, but the asymmetric access to APIs really helps Apple cement their moat (e.g with iMessage, Wallet), basically any app where they do it has serious market power.
- AndersSandvik 4y agoIf you delete an Apple app and redownload it it will put itself on the homebar or first app page pushing your other apps away. Comman, they dont let other apps do that!
- Tagbert 4y agoIt was Apple Music and they have fixed that in the most recent update.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoThanks for being a voice of reason rather than assuming Apple Is Evil at every turn lol.
- mgsk 4y agoDoesn’t invalidate your larger point, but 2FA code completion is available to all apps: https://developer.apple.com/news/?id=z0i801mg https://developer.apple.com/news/?id=z0i801mg
- TekMol 4y agoIs there a mobile browser for iOS that supports uBlock Origin? On my Laptop, I get no YouTube ads. It seems uBlock Origin removes them. On my iPad, I get YouTube ads in an unbearable frequency. It seems there is no solution for this? How is the situation on Android?
- chupchap 4y ago> It seems there is no solution for this? Get YouTube Premium?
- TekMol 4y agoI would pay for many things on the internet if there was something like digital cash. But the way it is, every time I pay for something, the mega corporations can tie my identity to everything I do. I am not ok with that. So the barrier to pay for something is very high.
- tzs 4y agoDepending on your level of paranoia, one of these might work. 1. Buy a prepaid reloadable credit/debit card. In the US you can do this at major supermarkets, Walmart, and I think many convenience stores. You can load this by transferring funds from your normal bank account. Your bank can tie your identity to that, but they don't know what you are using the prepaid card for. The prepaid card company knows what you are using it for but doesn't know who you are. Same with whoever you buy things from with it. 2. Buy a prepaid credit/debit card using cash. 3. Buy a prepaid reloadable credit/debit card using cash. Use this for your internet purchases. To reload it, buy prepaid non-reloadable debit cards using cash and use them to reload the reloadable card. (I'm not sure you can use one card to load another, though. Using credit cards to load prepaid cards is usually forbidden I believe, but I couldn't find anything on using debit cards to do so).
- TekMol 4y agoI'm in Europe. You cannot buy+use credit/debit cards without going through an identification process here.
- skc 4y agoAn investigation that will lead nowhere seeing as there is no alternative. This is what happens when the tech press is cheered on for laughing off anyone that dares to compete with iOS and Android. Yes, I'm still very bitter about the demise of WindowsPhone and PalmOS. Had they been championed a little more the mobile OS landscape would have been much more vibrant and exciting.
- giantrobot 4y agoYou can't regulate capable competition into existence. PalmOS and Windows Phone/Mobile/10 both died because their parent companies screwed up. PalmOS was a painfully out of date design by the time it got stuck on phones. No amount of regulation was going to solve the clusterfuck of Palm and PalmSource. Nor was regulation going to make Cobalt actually ship and work as advertised. Regulation also wasn't going to stop Microsoft from screwing up Windows Mobile. After the iPhone's release the WinMo 6.x development was an obvious dead end for licensees. Android was just a better response to iOS than WinMo. Microsoft then knifed the platform moving to 7 giving licensees even less reason to use it. Regulation wasn't going to make companies license a dead end platform. An OS landscape isn't vibrant or exciting when established players just stop meaningful development or just have a shit vision. Apple showed the multitouch and a soft keyboard could be practical on a mobile device. Palm and Microsoft were stuck iterating a design from 1995. No regulation was going to fix their lack of imagination.
- skc 4y agoNobody's talking about regulation. And I think you're confusing WindowsPhone for WindowsMobile by the way. My main issue was that these two OS's Palm and WP had a mountain to climb facing off against iOS and Android and it wasn't helped by the tech press poo-pooing their efforts at every turn, often gleefully so. I think it's a shame that we will never see a third player in this space.
- giantrobot 4y ago> My main issue was that these two OS's Palm and WP had a mountain to climb facing off against iOS and Android and it wasn't helped by the tech press poo-pooing their efforts at every turn, often gleefully so. My point is these platforms were not able competition to even early iOS and Android. The tech press were excited about Android and iOS because they were good and showed how bad those previous systems were. The tech press was also excited that someone (Apple, later Google) actually made a smartphone for consumers. Consumers were stuck with feature phones with little to no Internet connectivity and smart phones were aimed primarily at business users. At the end of the day the tech press did not control PalmSource or Microsoft. It was up to those companies to make their platforms better and actually compete against iOS and Android. While both might have had the technical talent capable of doing so neither had the vision or leadership and so both failed. The mountain both platforms had to climb was built mostly through mismanagement and hubris. Don't be disappointed in the tech press or consumers wanting iPhones and Android phones. Be disappointed in Palm/PalmSource, Microsoft, and RIM for not having any vision and throwing away their lead in the space. They were all trying to make bigger and better Exchange clients when a vast majority of people wanted real web access and media functionality.
- mtomweb 4y agoThis article gives a much better summary. https://www.macrumors.com/2022/06/10/uk-to-target-apple-gaming-and-browser-restrictions/ https://www.macrumors.com/2022/06/10/uk-to-target-apple-gami... It’s not “may face investigation”, it’s the start of the process to force Apple to support third party browsers and web apps.
- ccouzens 4y agoAnd this is the press release itself. https://www.gov.uk/government/news/cma-plans-market-investigation-into-mobile-browsers-and-cloud-gaming https://www.gov.uk/government/news/cma-plans-market-investig... The pdf from the original article doesn't work. https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/mobile-ecosystems-market-study-final-report https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/mobile-ecosystems...
- ccouzens 4y agohttps://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/62a22d5bd3bf7f036750b0d8/Appendix_D__002_.pdf https://assets.publishing.service.gov.uk/media/62a22d5bd3bf7... This is a comparison about the difficulties (real and perceived) about switching between platforms. It gives me the impression that Apple goes out of their way to lock users in.
- hank_z 4y agoI always want to set Startpage as the default search engine in Safari. But it is impossible unless Apple adds it. Hopefully regulators somehow will make Apple more open in the near future.
- ColinHayhurst 4y agoYes, but it is not being ble to add custom options that makes this a total barrier. It's not just Startpage, of course. I have written at length about this [0]. Ironically, Apple is a bigger block on search competition than Google and Microsoft; at least you can add custom options in Chrome and Edge. Still you can certainly argue it is the Apple-Google deal that is a root cause. We don't now what the deal is between Apple-Microsoft (Bing and Bing syndicates) but this may have a big influence too. [0] https://blog.mojeek.com/2022/05/gatekeepers-of-the-western-web.html https://blog.mojeek.com/2022/05/gatekeepers-of-the-western-w...
- agust 4y agoTo clarify what this is about regarding Apple: After a year long market study, the CMA has concluded that Apple's browser engine ban on iOS in anti-competitive and distort the browser market, as well as limit the capabilities of web apps on iOS and on the entire mobile eco-system. They note that it is obviously to their own benefit, as a weaker web on iOS results in a stronger exclusive and captive native app eco-system, which they can tax at will. The CMA is now set to start a market investigation reference (MIR) which will give them the power to impose changes to Apple. The number one remedy considered is requiring Apple to stop banning competing engines on iOS. Announcement for the MIR: https://www.gov.uk/cma-cases/mobile-browsers-and-cloud-gaming https://www.gov.uk/cma-cases/mobile-browsers-and-cloud-gamin... Final market study report: https://www.gov.uk/cma-cases/mobile-ecosystems-market-study https://www.gov.uk/cma-cases/mobile-ecosystems-market-study
- MCArth 4y agoMusic to my ears - from my own experience, safari is a pain to deal with. I've run into many bugs that haven't been fixed for years, and they've lagged behind in implementing standards like WebGL 2. Hopefully this will force them to invest more resources into safari and webkit
- agust 4y agoIt's actually already happening. Since the CMA started investigating around October last year, Apple has issued more than 70 job listings for WebKit, at least half of which have already been filled. They also have significantly increased their release cycles, and released a number of bug fixes and new features. They still have a long way to go to fix the huge number of bugs WebKit's been rigged with for years, and to catch up with other engines in terms of functionality, but it's encouraging. It seems like Apple acknowledged regulation is coming and they can't stop it.
- MCArth 4y agoAmazing!
- 4y ago
- tomschwiha 4y agoFor me it looked like the article is hosted on google.com, but it's actually just a redirect. Updating the URL of the submission would be great as currently it can be misleading.
- tambourine_man 4y agoUsing google’s domain for this subscription is particularly funny
- talideon 4y agoCould somebody update URL on this so it points at The Guardian directly rather than bouncing through Google?
- ubermonkey 4y agoAh, the never-ending quest to define platform features as anti-competitive in order to make Apple worse.
- timmg 4y agoIt's not that Apple ships a browser engine that is the problem. It's that they don't allow you to publish apps that use a different browser engine. Big difference.
- ubermonkey 4y agoI still don't see the problem. Apple is a minority player in this market. Android presumably allows whatever you want, right? If you want the customized experience, use that.
- timmg 4y ago> Apple is a minority player in this market. In the phone market? Maybe by units. Certainly not by revenue. Either way, they have a monopoly on "iPhone apps" and their distribution. You can argue whether that's a market in itself. But lawyers and regulators can make an argument too.
- ubermonkey 4y agoRevenue does not determine market control. Market share does. They are DEFINITELY a minority player vs. Android in terms of handsets in use. It’s not close. Closed platforms have always been a thing. Mostly, they’ve been game consoles. It is hard to understand how Apple should be forced to do anything on antitrust or monopoly grounds, though, based how we have traditionally understood anticompetitive practices.
- codefeenix 4y agoNetscape navigator and IE, or the EU decisions on Microsoft bundling Windows media player? is anything different with this?
- sys_64738 4y agoIt sounds like there might be a backhander in play here that this country suddenly decides there’s no competing in a market which has had the same rules for fifth teen years. Given the ongoing scandals of the current British government then that makes sense that their elected officials area easily bribed and corrupt.
- mrcartmeneses 4y agoAs a user I have no desire to even try any browser other than Safari in my iPhone. As a developer I have a strong desire to not have to deal with multiple browsers on iOS. Forgive my ignorance but I’ve got no idea what tangible benefit a new browser engine would give. Perhaps I’m just lazy and part of the problem.
- stjohnswarts 4y agoHow does google have a stanglehold on android browser? You can download several other browsers.